The impact of convective criteria on the properties of massive stars

Observatoire de Genève, Chemin Pegasi 51, 1290 Versoix, Switzerland
e-mail: yves.sibony@unige.ch

Received: 12 April 2023
Accepted: 17 October 2023

Abstract

Context. Libraries of stellar models computed with either the Ledoux or the Schwarzschild criterion to determine the sizes of convective regions are available in the literature. It is still not clear, however, which of these two criteria should be used, although many works have been devoted to that question in the past.

Aims. In the framework of the evolution of single rotating stars, we study the differences between models computed with Ledoux and Schwarzschild criteria on the internal structure, evolutionary track in the Hertzsprung–Russell diagram (HRD), lifetimes, evolution of the surface abundances and velocities, and masses of the He and CO cores. We investigate the consequences on the nature of the supernova (SN) progenitors and the type of SN events, as well as on the stellar yields of light elements. We also study the impact on the outputs of population synthesis models.

Methods. Models with initial masses between 7 and 120 M_⊙ at solar metallicity (Z = 0.014) and with an initial rotation equal to 0 or 0.4 times the critical velocity at the zero-age main sequence were computed with either the Schwarzschild or the Ledoux criterion until the end of the C-burning phase.

Results. Models with initial masses between 15 and 32 M_⊙ computed with the Schwarzschild criterion show larger intermediate convective zones attached to the H-burning shell than models computed with the Ledoux criterion. Their CO cores and outer convective zones in the red supergiant (RSG) phase are also smaller. This impacts many outputs of stars during the core He-burning phase. Schwarzschild models have smaller CO cores and outer convective zones in the RSG phase, and their blue-to-red supergiant ratio is much higher than for Ledoux models. They also produce longer crossings of the Hertzsprung gap and favour blue loops. The upper luminosity of RSGs is little affected by the change in the convective criterion. The maximum luminosity of RSG progenitors for type II-P SN events is lowered from 5.2 to 4.95 when the Ledoux criterion is used instead of the Schwarzschild criterion in non-rotating models. The Schwarzschild criterion predicts longer-lasting, less nitrogen-enriched, and faster-rotating Cepheids. Rotational mixing tends to decrease the differences between Schwarzschild and Ledoux models.

Conclusions. The results of this paper can be used as first guidelines to set up observational programs that may help to distinguish between these two model families.