A&A 436, 999-1008 (2005)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20041796
V. Rezania1,2 - J. C. Samson1
1 - Theoretical Physics Institute,
Department of Physics,
University of Alberta,
Edmonton, AB, T6G 2J1
, Canada
2 -
Institute for Advanced Studies in Basic Sciences,
Zanjan 45195, Iran
Received 5 August 2004 / Accepted 19 February 2005
Abstract
We propose a new model for quasi-periodic oscillations
(QPOs) based on oscillating magnetohydrodynamic modes in neutron
star magnetospheres. We argue that
the interaction of the accretion disk with the magnetosphere can
excite resonant shear Alfvén waves in a region of enhanced
density gradients, the region where accretion material flows along the
magnetic field lines in the magnetosphere (see Fig. 1).
We demonstrate that depending on the distance
of this region from the star and the magnetic
field strength, the frequency of the field line resonance can
range from several Hz (a weaker field, farther from the star), to
approximately kHz frequencies (a stronger field,
2-10 stellar
radii from the star). We show that such oscillations are able to
significantly modulate inflow of matter from the high density
region toward the star's surface and possibly produce the observed
X-ray spectrum. In addition, we show that the observed 2:3 frequency ratio of QPOs is a natural result of our model.
Key words: stars: neutron - stars: magnetic fields - X-rays: binaries
The discovery of quasi-periodic oscillations (QPOs) in low-mass
X-ray binaries (LMXBs) has been reported and discussed in recent
studies in theoretical and observational astrophysics. The Rossi X-Ray Timing Explorer has observed oscillations in the
X-ray flux of about 20 accreting neutron stars. These oscillations
are very strong and remarkably coherent with frequencies ranging
from
10 Hz to
1200 Hz. The kHz frequencies
correspond to dynamical
time scales at radii of a few tens of kilometers, and are possibly
closely related to the Keplerian orbital frequency of matter in
the inner disk. Almost all sources have also shown twin spectral
peak QPOs in the 500 Hz to 1200 Hz part of the X-ray spectrum,
and both peaks move up and down in frequency simultaneously.
Although there are some detailed differences between different types of X-ray sources, the observed QPOs are remarkably similar, both in frequency and peak separation. (Six of the 20 known sources were originally identified as "Z'' sources and the rest are known as "atoll'' sources (see Table 1). For more information about the atoll and Z sources, see van der Klis 2000). Such a similarity shows that QPOs should depend on the general characteristics of the X-ray sources which are common to all systems. In other words, the QPO can be regarded as a generic feature of the accreting neutron star.
Table 1: Observed frequencies of kilohertz QPOs in Z and atoll sources.
Remarkably, the characteristic
dynamical time scale for material orbiting near the compact object
is comparable to the observed millisecond X-ray variability, i.e.
because
where r is the distance of
the orbiting material from the center of the compact object with mass M (circular orbit),
dyn cm2/g2, and
g.
Such a natural time scale is
the foundation of most models for the observed QPOs.
Alpar & Shaham (1985) first proposed a beat-frequency model to explain the
low-frequency
horizontal branch oscillation (HBO) seen in Z sources (see also Lamb et al. 1985). They used the Alfvén radius,
where the magnetic pressure balances the ram pressure of
the infalling material in spherical accretion,
,
as the preferred
radius. For this Alfvén radius, the assumptions are: the
magnetic field is stellar dipole, the velocity and mass density are for the
free-fall case.
Here
is the mass accretion rate (this corresponds to
yr-1 and is typical of low-mass accreting neutron
stars)
in units of 1017 g s-1 and
is the magnetic
dipole moment at the stellar surface in units of 1026 G cm3.
Note that we assumed that
is constant in time and position.
Miller et al. (1996,1998) proposed a beat-frequency model to study
kHz QPOs, the so-called
sonic-point beat-frequency model, based on a new preferred
radius, the sonic radius. In this model, they assumed that near
the neutron star there is a very narrow region of the disk in
which the radial inflow velocity increases rapidly as the radius
decreases. Such a sharp transition in the radial velocity of
plasma flow from subsonic to supersonic happens at the "sonic
point'' radius,
.
This radius tends to be close to
the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO)
,
,
however, radiative stresses may
change its location, as required by the observation that the kHz QPO frequencies vary with time. Comparing the HBO and kHz QPO frequencies,
clearly
,
so part of the accreting
matter must remain in near-Keplerian orbits well within
.
An important prediction of the sonic-point model is that
is constant at the spin
frequency of the neutron star
,
which is
contrary to observations (Lamb & Miller 2001). Accurate observations from
the millisecond pulsar SAX J1808.4-3658 show that the frequency separation
Hz,
while the pulsar spin frequency is
Hz (Wijnands et al. 2003; Chakrabarty et al. 2003).
Nonetheless, further observations reveal that the frequency
separation
decreases when
increases.
Stella & Vietri (1998,1999) proposed a relativistic
precession model in which the high kHz QPO frequency
is
identified with the Keplerian frequency of an orbit in the disk
(similar to the beat-frequency model) and the low kHz QPO frequency
with the periastron precession of that orbit.
Furthermore, in the relativistic model
and
are not expected to be
equal as in a beat-frequency interpretation. An interesting
result of the relativistic precession model is that
should decrease not only when
increases (as observed) but
also when it decreases sufficiently.
However, in this model it is not clear how the X-ray flux is modulated
at these frequencies.
Recently Zhang (2004) proposed a model for kHz QPOs based on
magnetohydrodynamic (MHD)
Alfvén oscillations in the disk. He introduced a new preferred radius, the
quasi-sonic point radius, where the Alfvén velocity matches
the orbital Keplerian velocity. The author suggested that the upper and lower kHz frequencies are the MHD Alfvén wave frequencies
at the quasi-sonic point radius with low and high
accreted material mass densities, respectively.
In this model,
the frequency separation will decrease when
increases
and/or sufficiently decreases.
Although his results show good agreement
with observations, several issues are left unresolved.
For example, no mechanism is suggested to explain the
excitation of Alfvén wave oscillations within the star's magnetosphere.
More importantly, it is not clear how these Alfvén wave frequencies modulate
the X-ray flux coming from the surface of the star.
In this paper, we propose a new model to explain QPOs in LMXBs
based on interaction of accreting
plasma with the neutron star magnetosphere. This interaction is a
common feature in all accreting binary systems. Matter transfers
from the companion star to the compact
object. This matter is accelerated by the gravitational pull of
the compact object and hits the magnetosphere of the star with a
sonic/supersonic speed. The MHD interaction of the infalling
plasma with the neutron star magnetosphere will alter not only
the plasma flow toward the surface of the star, as assumed by
current QPO models, but also the structure of the star's
magnetosphere. The magnetic field of the neutron star is
distorted inward by the infalling plasma of the Keplerian
accretion flow. Since the gravity of the star confines the inward
flow to a small solid angle
10-2 ster, the magnetic
field of the star will be more compressed in the disk plane than
in other areas (see Fig. 1). Furthermore, in a more
realistic picture, one would expect that the highly accelerated
plasma due to the infall process would be able to penetrate
the magnetic field lines. Such material will be trapped
by the magnetic field lines and produce enhanced density
gradient regions
within the magnetosphere
.
However, due to the material's initial
velocity, the penetrating material moves along the field lines,
finally hitting the star's
surface at the magnetic poles and producing the observed X-ray
fluxes (Fig. 1). See Ghosh et al. (1977) for more details.
| |
Figure 1:
A schematic and idealized side view of an accreting
neutron star-disk system. The neutron star's strong gravity
causes a very high velocity flow toward the magnetosphere. As a
result, the magnetosphere is pushed inward in the disk plane but
balloons outward in a direction away from the disk plane. Some of
the plasma may leave the disk and flow along the field lines. The
magnetic star-disk connection by a dipolar magnetosphere as well
as the polar accretion flow along the field lines are part of a
reasonable but simplified picture of magnetized star-disk systems
in general. The dashed box represents the model that we
considered in this paper.
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
Besides modifying the geometry of the magnetosphere, the compressing
action of the accretion flow can excite some plasma perturbations in the
region of enhanced density gradients. This can be understood as
the inward motion of the accretion flow being halted
by the outward magnetic pressure at a certain distance from the
star, the Alfvén radius (Ghosh et al. 1977). The
accretion flow pushes the stellar magnetic field toward the star
until the pressure of the infalling plasma
balances the magnetic pressure
.
Here
and
are the density and radial velocity of the
infalling matter and
is the poloidal magnetic field at the
disk plane. Therefore, any instability in the disk at the Alfvén
radius would disturb such quasi-equilibrium configurations as well
as the structure of the magnetosphere,
possibly through the Rayleigh-Taylor and/or ballooning
instability.
As an example, the interaction
of the solar wind with the Earth's magnetosphere excites resonant shear
Alfvén waves, or field line resonances (FLRs), along the
magnetic field lines (Samson 1991). As a result,
such Alfvén waves may be excited by the compressive
accreting plasma in the magnetosphere of an accreting neutron star
with the accretion flow playing the role of the solar wind.
The plan of this paper is as follows. We outline the occurrence of resonant coupling in a magnetized plasma in Sect. 2. We review the excitation of shear Alfvén waves by studying linear perturbations in MHD. Next, the occurrence of FLRs, as a result of a resonant coupling between the compressional and shear Alfvén waves, is discussed. To illustrate the basic features of FLRs, the excitation of these resonances in a rectilinear magnetic field is considered. In Sect. 3, in order to consider a more realistic model for an accreting neutron star, we study the influence of the ambient flow along the field line on the excitation of FLRs. We demonstrate that in this case the eigenfrequency of the Alfvén modes is modulated by the velocity of the field-aligned plasma flow. Depending on the field line where the resonance occurs, the eigenfrequency of the FLR is in the range of several hundred Hz to kHz. Furthermore, in the presence of this flow, the plasma displacement parallel to the magnetic field lines is non-zero. This is very important because these displacements, which are missing in the case of zero ambient flow, might be responsible for modulating the motion of infalling material toward the magnetic poles and producing the observed X-ray fluxes. Existence of this non-zero parallel component distinguishes our study from other related investigations in which the modulation of X-ray flux in observed QPOs is fairly unclear or ambiguous. A possible occurrence of more than one peak in the power spectrum is also discussed. In addition, we show that the observed 2:3 frequency ratio of QPOs is a natural result of our model. Section 4 is devoted to summarizing our results and further discussion.
In general, the dynamics of an ideal magnetized plasma is
described by plasma density
,
plasma pressure p,
gravitational potential
,
velocity vector
and magnetic
field
:
In a steady state (i.e.
), Eqs. (1)
have been studied in detail in connection with the problem of stellar
winds from rotating magnetic stars (Mestel 1968a,b) and in
connection with diffusing/flowing plasma into magnetospheres in
accreting neutron stars (Elsner & Lamb 1977,1984; Ghosh et al. 1977). Obviously, in
the case of accreting neutron stars,
represents the inflow
velocity of matter accreted to stars, while in stars with a
stellar wind it represents the plasma outflow velocity.
Consider an axisymmetric system consisting of
a rotating star with a constant angular velocity
along the z-axis and a magnetic field
whose symmetry axis is aligned with
the rotation axis of the star.
By decomposing the velocity and magnetic field vectors into poloidal
and toroidal components:
![]() |
(5) |
![]() |
(8) |
In MHD, waves can propagate in three different modes including
shear Alfvén waves, and the fast and slow compressional modes
(Landau & Lifshitz 1992). In a homogeneous plasma, one can easily show that
these three modes are linearly independent. However, in an
inhomogeneous medium these three modes can be coupled, yielding
either a resonant coupling (Southwood 1974; Hasegawa 1976), or an unstable
ballooning mode (Liu 1997; Ohtani & Tamao 1993). FLRs result from the coupling
of the fast compressional and the shear Alfvén modes
whereas the ballooning instability results from the coupling
of the slow compressional and the shear Alfvén modes. However,
in the cold-plasma approximation (which is appropriate for
neutron star magnetospheres), the slow compressional wave does not exist.
FLRs are standing waves that are stimulated
in a pulsar with gradients in the Alfvén speed transverse
to the ambient B-field, particularly within density boundary
layers (a parallel gradient in the Alfvén speed is also included).
Efficient coupling between the shear Alfvén wave and
the fast compressional
wave can produce a relatively narrow FLR spectrum,
even when the driver is broadband.
The linear theory of FLRs was developed by Chen & Hasegawa (1974) and
Southwood (1974) and applied to auroral phenomena by Hasegawa (1976).
Samson et al. (2003) developed a nonlinear model with a nonlocal
electron conductivity to explain the evolution of field-aligned
potential drops and electron acceleration to form auroral arcs. They
studied the possible coupling between the fast compressional mode
and the shear Alfvén mode in an inhomogeneous plasma with a radial
gradient in the Alfvén velocity
.
For further discussion of mode conversion for shear Alfvén waves see for
instance Stix (1992), and for an example of computational models
see Rickard & Wright (1994). Analytic solutions for toroidal FLRs in dipole magnetic fields
can be found in Taylor & Walker (1984).
To illustrate the resonant coupling between the fast compressional mode and the shear Alfvén mode we study the excitation of FLRs in an inhomogeneous plasma in a rectilinear magnetic field model.
Plasma dynamics can often be described by the adiabatic ideal MHD equations:
| (10a) | |||
| (10b) | |||
| (10c) | |||
| (10d) |
![]() |
(14) |
In the case of a strong magnetic field, or for a cold plasma (i.e.
), one can put
.
Then G(x) and F(x), Eqs. (12) and (13), reduce
to
Briefly, the FLR mechanism can be outlined as follows: the incoming compressional wave hits the stellar magnetosphere and reaches a field line (or a magnetospheric shell) at which the frequency of the incoming wave matches the eigenfrequency of the standing shear Alfvén wave along that particular filed line. The resulting forced-oscillating system causes the amplitude of the shear Alfvén wave to grow in time, forming FLRs.
The FLR mechanism is generic and likely to occur in many astrophysical magnetospheres. As a result, one would expect that FLRs likely occur not only in the Earth's magnetosphere but also in the magnetospheres of accreting neutron stars. In the case of the Earth's magnetosphere, the source of energy for the FLRs is the interaction of the solar wind with the magnetosphere (Harrold & Samson 1992). In accreting neutron stars, the accreted plasma interacts with the stars' magnetosphere, allowing the compressional mode to propagate into the magnetosphere and flow along the field lines toward the magnetic poles. Such a compressional action of the accretion flow can excite resonant shear Alfvén waves in the enhanced density regions filled by plasma flowing along the field lines. In Sect. 3 we consider this mechanism more carefully to address its possible relation to the QPOs observed in accreting neutron stars in LMXBs.
As discussed above, FLRs have been used to model electron acceleration and auroral arcs in the Earth's magnetosphere. Although FLRs are likely to be excited in any magnetospheric system with an input of compressional energy, one must carefully evaluate the differences between the Earth's and neutron star magnetospheres. In neutron star magnetospheres, for example, the strong magnetic field of the neutron star, the rapid stellar rotation and the intense radiation pressure from the stellar surface should be considered.
In the case of the Earth's magnetosphere, due to the small gravitational attraction of the Earth and also its large distance from the Sun, the solar wind impacts the whole Sunward side of the geomagnetosphere. This supersonic solar wind produces the so-called bow shock structure at the outer boundary of the geomagnetosphere. On the contrary, the strong gravity of the neutron star creates a converging flow that is supersonic long before the flow hits the star's magnetosphere. Such a localized flow is able to change the structure of the magnetosphere in local areas, particularly in the equatorial plane. In addition, the highly variable nature of the exterior flow can change the magnetosphere's structure dramatically in time. The large flux of plasma stresses the star's outer magnetosphere and creates a relatively high plasma density in this region. The plasma then flows along the field lines, an interior flow, until it hits the star's surface near the magnetic poles (see Fig. 1). In this section we study the excitation of FLRs by considering such plasma flows in the neutron star magnetosphere. In the context of the Earth's magnetosphere, however, Harrold & Samson (1992) studied the resonant excitation of Alfvén waves by surface waves excited by the solar wind and plasma flows in the Earth's magnetosheath.
The presence of a flow
in the plasma adds more modes to the
plasma waves. In general, such flows are a combination of plasma
flow along the magnetic field lines,
,
and rotational motion
of the plasma around the star, with angular velocity
,
i.e.
(see Eq. (2)).
As we shall see in Eq. (22a), the existence of
alone induces a non-zero parallel (relative to
the direction of the magnetic field) component of displacement
that vanishes in a cold plasma
if
.
We note that this component can be responsible for
modulating the infalling plasma flow near the star's surface with
FLRs' frequencies and producing the observed X-ray fluxes, see Eq. (22a) below. We will return to this point later.
In a strong magnetic field, the usual definition of the Alfvén
velocity,
,
is not correct as with
this non-relativistic definition, velocities can be
larger than the speed of light, c. The correct definition,
the relativistic Alfvén velocity, uses energy density
relative to c2, which for an ideal gas reads
![]() |
Figure 2:
Radial profile of the relativistic Alfvén speed |
| Open with DEXTER | |
The linearized perturbed magnetohydrodynamic
equations in the presence of an ambient flow can be obtained from Eqs. (9) as
To treat the problem analytically, we again consider a
rectilinear magnetic field configuration. Although
this configuration may not be suitable for an accreting neutron
star, it may describe QPOs.
Separating Eqs. (20) into parallel and perpendicular
components relative to the ambient magnetic field and assuming
perturbed quantities in the form of
![]() |
(21) |
We set the magnetic field in the z-direction with
gradients in the ambient parameters in the x-direction (
)
only, i.e.
,
and further
![]() |
(23) |
Mathematically our result is similar to the one obtained by Harrold & Samson (1992),
however, they considered a different model in which
flow in the Earth's magnetosheath is perpendicular to the B-field and there
is no ambient flow in the region of FLRs.
For a constant flow along magnetic field lines, i.e.
,
Eq. (24) reduces to
![]() |
(28) |
As a result, we expect that
the two FLR peaks (Eq. (27)) occur where
and
are
more or less comparable (i.e. of the same order of magnitude). As we now show,
using the flow velocity and the Alfvén velocity definitions below,
one might expect that the FLRs likely occur at
.
![]() |
Figure 3:
Frequency of the regular Alfvén resonance
(
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
![]() |
Figure 4:
Frequency of the regular Alfvén resonance (
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
| |
|||
| (29) |
Setting
as the observed peak separation frequency
and
as the upper QPO
frequency
,
one can find
and
as
![]() |
Figure 5:
Variation of the spectral peak separation |
| Open with DEXTER | |
![]() |
Figure 6:
Variation of the spectral peak separation
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
The lower QPO frequency can also be rewritten as
.
As a result,
we obtain the frequency ratio
to ![]()
Such pairs of high frequencies with a 2:3 frequency ratio have
been observed in the X-ray flux of some neutron stars in
LMXBs
and black hole
systems (the 3:5 ratio has been in one source), and it would
appear that this feature is common to those systems.
However, recent statistical analyses by Belloni et al. (2004,2005) showed that
although the two high and low kHz QPO frequencies in LMXBs are well correlated,
the frequency-frequency correlation is significantly different from
a 2:3 relation. They analyzed all published values of kHz QPO frequencies
from neutron star systems and found that the strong linear correlation observed
between the lower and upper kHz QPO frequencies in both Atoll and Z sources
is not compatible with a single constant ratio.
Furthermore, by analysis of a much larger RXTE/PCA dataset for Sco X-1, they showed that
there is no sharp concentration around a 2:3 ratio, but that the ratios
are broadly distributed over the range
820-1150 Hz.
The explanation for such rational ratios is still a mystery. In black hole systems, it has been suggested that such frequencies correspond to a trapped g-mode or c-mode of disk oscillation in the Kerr metric, see for example Kato (2001) and references therein. In neutron star systems they are explained as the fundamental and the first harmonic of the non-axisymmetric (m=1) g-mode (Kato 2002,2003). Further, Rezzolla et al. (2003a,b) studied small perturbations of an accretion torus orbiting close to the black hole and modeled the observed high QPO frequencies with basic p-modes of relativistic tori. They showed that these modes behave as sound waves trapped in the torus with eigenfrequencies appearing in the sequence 2:3:4:... Abramowicz et al. (2003) also proposed that the observed rational ratios of frequencies may be due to the strong gravity of the compact object and a non-linear resonance between radial and vertical oscillations in accretion disks.
In the present work, we have studied the interaction of an accretion disk with a neutron star magnetosphere in the LMXBs. The recent extensive observations reveal the existence of quasi-periodic oscillations in the X-ray fluxes of such stars. These oscillations, with frequencies ranging from 10 Hz to 1200 Hz, have been the subject of several theoretical and observational investigations. Based on theoretical models for the observed aurora in the Earth's magnetosphere, we have introduced a generic magnetospheric model for accretion disk-neutron star systems to address the occurrence and the behavior of the observed QPOs in those systems. In order to explain those QPOs consistently, we consider the interaction of the accreting plasma with the neutron star magnetosphere. Due to the strong gravity of the star, a very steep and supersonic flow hits the magnetosphere boundary and deforms its structure drastically. Such a plasma flow can readily excite different MHD waves in the magnetosphere, including shear Alfvén waves.
In the Earth's magnetosphere, occurrence of aurorae is a result of
the resonant coupling between the shear Alfvén waves and the fast
compressional waves (produced by the solar wind). These resonances
are known as FLRs and are reviewed in detail in Sect. 2 of this paper. We argue that such resonant coupling
is likely to occur in neutron star magnetospheres due to the
interaction with accreting plasma. In the context
of QPOs in neutron star magnetospheres, we formulated an improved FLR
model by considering a plasma flow moving with velocity
along the
magnetic field lines. Such flows are likely to occur in a neutron star
magnetosphere (Ghosh et al. 1977). For a simple geometry, a
rectilinear magnetic field, and in the presence of a plasma flow
we found: (a) two resonant MHD modes with
frequencies
;
(b) the
resulting frequencies for
cm-1 and typical flow and/or Alfvén velocity
.1 cat the stellar surface will be in kHz range within a few stellar radii.
Our results match the kHz oscillations
observed in the X-ray fluxes in LMXBs. As shown in Figs. 3 and 4, the closer to the star
and/or the larger the Alfvén velocity the higher the frequency;
(c) the quasi-periodicity of the observed oscillations can be
understood by noting that due to several processes such as
magneto-turbulence at boundaries and the time varying accretion
rate, the FLR frequencies may vary with time; (d) a non-zero
plasma displacement along the magnetic field lines
.
Such a displacement, which oscillates with resulting frequencies
,
modulates the flow of the plasma toward the surface
of the neutron star. As a result, the X-ray flux from the star will
show these frequencies as well; (e) setting
and
,
one can explain the behavior of the
peak separation frequency
relative to the upper QPO frequency
.
As observed, the value of
decreases as the magnitude of
decreases and/or increases.
Figure 6 clearly shows such a behavior; (f) for
(obtained at
for
),
the frequency ratio
is comparable with the observed frequency ratio 2:3 in some neutron star systems. However, a broad range of
frequency ratios (Belloni et al. 2004,2005) is expected as values
of
and
change.
Interestingly, using the observed values of QPO frequencies, one
can determine the mass density and the magnetic dipole moment
of the star using
| (33a) | |||
| (33b) |
Furthermore, our model is able to explain the low frequency
(
10 Hz) quasi-periodic oscillations observed in rapid
bursters such as MXB 1730-335 and GRO J1744-28 (Masetti et al. 2000). Such
low frequencies can be extracted from the model by considering
smaller inflow/Alfvén velocities and/or further distances from the
star.
Nevertheless, in order to avoid a number of complexities in our calculations, we used approximations such as slow rotation and a cold plasma. These assumptions may place some restrictions on the validity of our model and results. Future studies will be devoted to overcoming these restrictions.
Acknowledgements
V.R. wishes to thank Mariano Mendez for kindly providing QPO data. The authors appreciate the referee's careful reading of the manuscript and valuable suggestions. This research was supported by the National Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada.