Observational results supporting the accretion theory are the high [C/Si]
and [O/Si] abundance ratios found in some Bootis stars which can be used as
indicators of gas-dust separation (Paunzen et al. 1999a): carbon
and oxygen
have low
condensation temperatures and tends to
remain in the gas phase of the interstellar medium. Silicon, on the other
side, has a high condensation temperature representing
the elements locked up in the grains. Any preferential accretion of gas will
lead to a [C/Si] or [O/Si] larger than solar. The
correlation with Si of other elements of high condensation temperature also
fits nicely with the accretion scenario (Stürenburg 1993).
Charbonneau (1991) combined the accretion hypothesis with the
diffusion
theory concluding that, with an accretion rate of
the order of 10
yr-1, many peculiar
characteristics
of
the
Bootis stars (including their restriction to the above-mentioned spectral types)
are
reproduced quite naturally. Turcotte & Charbonneau (1993)
investigated the
effect of mixing through meridional
circulation, concluding that the abundance anomalies would disappear in
106 years, so all of the
Bootis stars should be
essentially young objects on or just arriving to the ZAMS. The scarcity of
Bootis will be also explained by the
strict requirements for the accretion rate. The fact that all
Bootis stars are
young objects is further strengthened by the lack of
Bootis stars in open
clusters older than 107 years (Gray & Corbally 1988) and the
discovery of
Bootis
stars in the young Orion OB1 association and NGC 2264 (Paunzen & Gray
1997).
A critical point in the accretion scenario is the necessary existence
of gas and dust
shells around Bootis stars. Some
Bootis stars show clear indications
of both gas (circumstellar lines) and
dust (IR excess) shells (Holweger & Rentzsch-Holm 1995;
Holweger et al. 1999).
However, the fact that some
Bootis stars do not show
evidence of shells does not necessary rule out this hypothesis. King
(1994) concluded that the amount of depleted gas required
to cause underabundances in
Bootis stars is small enough that any circumstellar
dust associated with this gas is not necessarily
detectable in the IR or submillimetre regions.
Michaud & Charland (1986) investigated the effect on abundances
in stellar atmospheres of the diffusion mechanism operating in the
presence of mass
loss. They found that, after about 108-109 years,
mass-loss
rates of only 10
yr-1 can reduce the extreme
overabundances predicted by diffusion theory for the Am
stars to underabundances of many elements, the degree
of underabundance of an element being a function of both gravity and time.
According to this,
Bootis stars would be rather old and
at the end of their Main Sequence.
There are, however, some points that cannot be explained with theory. One is
the moderate underabundances predicted (only a factor of
five less solar), very far from the strong underabundances found by
Venn & Lambert (1990) in the
three classical Bootis stars (
Boo,
Ori and 29 Cyg). Also it is
difficult to understand how
diffusion could operate in the presence of the meridional circulation which
would likely be generated by rapid rotation. Turcotte & Charbonneau
(1993) showed that
even an equatorial
rotational velocity of
50 kms-1 suppresses the appearance, at any epoch of Main
Sequence evolution, of the characteristic
Bootis abundance pattern.
Faraggiana & Bonifacio (1999) proposed this
alternative to explain the underabundances of, at least,
some Bootis stars. The composite spectra of a binary system with disentangled
components not very dissimilar produces a veiling
effect with apparent underabundances. The authors pointed out that the lack
of a uniform pattern in the chemical composition of the
Bootis stars can be
easily reconciled with the binary hypothesis. Moreover, they
claimed that the hypothesis of all
Bootis stars being very young objects in the
late phase of their PMS evolution is highly improbable on the basis of the
rapid evolution and the number of bright
Bootis candidates which would imply
that the
star formation process is
still very active in the solar neighborhood, leading to an unexpected large
number of Main Sequence B stars in a similar volume.
Andrievsky (1997) proposed a complementary scenario in which Bootis stars would be the result of the coalescence of contact binaries of W UMa type.
The system would be formed by two main-sequence components of approximately
equal spectral types. This scenario would lead to an age for
Bootis stars of
1 Gyr explaining the rather evolved nature of some
Bootis stars and the origin
of the material around them.
A class definition of the Bootis group is essential
on one hand to distinguish these stars from other groups of stars
populating the same region of the HR diagram and, on the other hand, to shed
light into the nature of the
Bootis phenomenon. Ideally, a stellar class should be
formed by a homogeneous sample of stars showing common properties originated
by the same astrophysical processes. Historically, this has not been the case
for the
Bootis group since the use in the past of classification criteria not
unique to the group (weakness of the Mg II 4481 Å line,
presence of spectral features at 1600 Å and 3040 Å, IR excess, ...)
has led to the inclusion of spurious members (horizontal branch stars,
Ap stars, shell stars, He-weak stars, ...). Although the problem of the class
definition can be efficiently alleviated making use of
unambiguous criteria defined in the ultraviolet range
(Solano & Paunzen 1998,
1999), the chemical composition-based definition of the class
makes it necessary to perform an accurate determination of the stellar
parameters for the final decision on the membership of a potential candidate
to the
Bootis group. The
observed sample was selected from the list of suspected
Bootis stars given in
Paunzen (2000). HD 68758 and HD 184190 were also included as
possible members
of the class.
Copyright ESO 2001