A&A 479, 603-624 (2008)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20078652
S. S. Kaisin - I. D. Karachentsev
Special Astrophysical Observatory, Russian Academy of Sciences, N. Arkhyz, KChR, 369167, Russia
Received 11 September 2007 / Accepted 25 September 2007
Abstract
We present results of H
imaging for 42 galaxies in the nearby
low-density cloud Canes Venatici I, populated mainly by late-type objects.
Estimates of the H
flux and integrated star formation rate (
)
are now available for all 78 known members of this scattered system,
spanning a large range in luminosity, surface brightness, HI content and
.
Distributions of the CVnI galaxies versus their
,
blue absolute
magnitude and total hydrogen mass, are given in comparison with those
for a population of the nearby virialized group around M 81. We found
no essential correlation between star formation activity in a galaxy and
its density environment. The bulk of CVnI galaxies had enough time to
generate their baryon mass with the observed
.
Most of them also
possess a supply of gas that is sufficient to maintain their observed
s
during the next Hubble time.
Key words: galaxies: evolution - galaxies: ISM - galaxies: dwarf
Being a scattered system with rare interactions between galaxies, the nearby
CVnI cloud is a unique opportunity for studying star formation processes in
galaxies running independently, without a noticeable external influence.
Kennicutt et al. (1989), Hoopes et al. (1999), van Zee (2000), Gil de Paz et al. (2003), James et al. (2004) and Hunter & Elmegreen (2004)
conducted observations in the H line of three dozen galaxies
of this complex, which made it possible to determine the star formation
rate (
)
in them. However, more than half of the other members of the cloud
proved to be out of vision of these authors. Our task consisted in the
completion of the H
-survey of the population of the CVnI cloud.
The results of our observations and their primary analysis are presented
in this paper.
Our data reduction followed standard practice and was performed within
the MIDAS package. For all the data, bias was subtracted and the
images were flat-fielded by twilight flats. Cosmic particles were
removed and the sky background was subtracted.
The next operation was to bring all the images of a given
object into coincidence. The images in the continuum were then
normalized to H images using 5-15 field stars, and subtracted.
H
fluxes were obtained for the continuum-subtracted images,
using spectrophotometric standard stars from Oke (1990)
observed on the same nights as the objects.
The investigation of measurement errors contributed by the
continuum subtraction, flat-fielding and scatter in the zeropoints,
has shown that they have typical values within 10%. We did not
correct H
fluxes for the contribution of the [NII] lines,
because it is likely to be small for the majority of low-luminosity galaxies
in our sample.
Table 1: The observational log. (1) - the galaxy name; (2) - the date of observation; (3) - the total exposure time in seconds; a colon means that the sky was not photometric.
Some basic properties of 78 galaxies located in the CVnI cloud are listed
in Table 2. Table 2 also includes the data on the galaxies that have been
observed by other authors. The columns of Table 2 contain the following
characteristics of the cloud members, taken mainly from the Catalog of
Neighboring Galaxies (CNG; Karachensev et al. 2004): (1) the galaxy name;
(2) and (3) the equatorial coordinates for the epoch J2000.0;
(4) morphological type in numerical code according to
de Vaucouleurs et al. (1991). Column (5) represents the tidal index (TI)
following from the CNG; i.e. for every galaxy ``i'' we have found its
``main disturber''(=MD), producing the highest tidal action
,
where Mk is the total mass of any neighboring potential MD galaxy
(proportional to its luminosity with
)
separated from the considered galaxy by a space distance Dik;
the value of the constant C is chosen so that TI = 0, when the
Keplerian cyclic period of the galaxy with respect to its MD equals
the cosmic Hubble time, T0. Therefore, positive values correspond
to galaxies in groups, while negative values correspond to field
galaxies. Column (6) gives the galaxy radial velocity (in km s-1)
with respect to
the Local Group centroid, with the apex parameters adopted in the
NASA/IPAC Extragalactic Database (NED). Column (7) gives the distance
to a galaxy in megaparsecs, with allowance made for new measurements
(Karachentsev et al. 2006; Tully et al. 2007). Column (8) presents the blue
absolute magnitude of a galaxy with the given distance, after correction
for the Galactic extinction Ab from Schlegel et al. (1998) and the
internal absorption in the galaxy, determined as
if
Vm > 42.7 km s-1, otherwise,
.
Here, Vm is the
rotation velocity of the galaxy, corrected for the inclination, and a/bis the galaxy axial ratio. Therefore, we assume the internal absorption
to be dependent not only on the inclination, but also on the galaxy
luminosity (Verheijen 2001).
Column (9) gives the logarithm of the hydrogen mass of a galaxy,
,
defined from its flux
in the 21 cm line; in some dwarf
spheroidal galaxies the upper limit of the flux was estimated from the
observations by Huchtmeier et al. (2000). Column (10) gives
the logarithm of the observed
integral flux of a galaxy in the H
+ [NII] lines, expressed in
terms of erg cm-2 s-1. Notes indicate data sources of
s
according to other authors.
Column (11) gives the star
formation rate in the galaxy on a logarithmic scale,
/year) =
(Gallagher et al. 1984), where the integral flux in the H
line is corrected for the Galactic and internal
extinction as
,
while the galaxy distance is expressed in Mpc.
Columns (12) and (13) give the dimensionless parameters
and
,
which characterize the past and the future of the process of star formation;
here LB denotes the total blue luminosity of the galaxy in units of solar
luminosity, while T0 is the age of the universe assumed to equal to 13.7 billion years (Spergel et al. 2003).
![]() |
Figure 1:
The H![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 1: continued. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 1: continued. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 1: continued. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 1: continued. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 1: continued. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 1: continued. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 1: continued. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 1: continued. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 1: continued. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 1: continued. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 1: continued. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 1: continued. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 1: continued. |
Open with DEXTER |
Table 2: Basic parameters of galaxies in the Canes Venatici I cloud.
Here we note some properties of the galaxies that we observed, in particular, their HII pattern.UGC 5427. This dwarf galaxy with asymmetric HII filaments is situated at the fartherst western outskirts of the CVnI cloud. Its distance, 7.1 Mpc, was estimated from the luminosity of the brightest stars.
NGC 3344. This is one of the rare galaxies in the cloud with a quite regular spiral pattern. Its distance of 6.9 Mpc, determined from the radial velocity at a Hubble constant H0=72 km s-1 Mpc-1, may be considerably underestimated since the galaxy is located in the Local Velocity Anomaly zone (Tully et al. 1992).
KK 109. This dwarf system of low surface brightness belongs to an
intermediate type between irregular and spheroidal galaxies, like the known
member of the Local Group, LGS-3. Its distance, 4.51 Mpc, was determined
from the tip of the red giant branch, TRGB (Karachentsev et al. 2003).
There are no massive neighbors (TI=-0.6) in the vicinities of
KK 109, which could cause pushing of gas from this galaxy by the ram pressure.
The H-flux shown in Table 2 for the galaxy corresponds only to
the upper limit.
BTS 76 and MGC 6-27-17. These are two relatively compact bluish galaxies, the shape of which is not notable for great irregularity. They have not been resolved into stars yet, and the distances to them are estimated from their radial velocities. Compact emission knots are seen in the central parts of both galaxies.
DDO 113 = KDG 90. This is a dwarf system of regular shape and low
surface brightness. It has been resolved into stars with the Hubble Space
Telescope (HST). Judging by
its CM-diagram, DDO 113 contains an old stellar population and can be
classified as dSph. We have not found in it either HII regions or diffuse
H emission. The measurement of its HI-flux is hampered by close
proximity (
with the bright Im-galaxy NGC 4214,
of which DDO 113 is evidently a close companion.
MGC 9-20-131 = CGCG 269-049. In the central part of this dIrr galaxy, a bright HII region is seen. Together with UGC 7298, it is likely to constitute a physical pair of dwarf galaxies investigated in the HI line with the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (GMRT) (Begum et al. 2006).
UGC 7298 and UGC 7356. These are irregular galaxies with a low content
of HI. Their distances, 4.21 Mpc (UGC 7298) and 7.19 Mpc (UGC 7356),
have recently been measured by Karachentsev et al. (2003) and
Tully et al. (2007). Some faint emission regions are seen in both galaxies.
It is possible that, the high HI-flux from UGC 7356 is due to contamination from the
bright neighboring spiral NGC 4258, since the anomalously high ratio
looks inconsistent with the
morphology of this galaxy.
IC 3308 = UGC 7505. From the Tully-Fisher relation with the HI line width W50 = 128 km s-1, we derived the galaxy distance to be 12.8 Mpc.
KK 144. The measurement of H-flux is impeded because
of a bright star projected near the galaxy center.
NGC 4395. This is a Seyfert 1 type galaxy having a star-like nucleus,
which is lost among bright emission regions scattered over the disk. The integrated
H-flux in NGC 4395, as well as in the galaxies NGC 4449 and
NGC 4631, was corrected for the incomplete field of view under the
assumption that the H
-emission in these galaxies is distributed
in the same way as the blue luminosity.
UGCA 281 = Mkn 209. On the western side of this blue compact dwarf
galaxy (BCD), there is a very bright emission knot with a short arc.
Judging by the distance, 5.43 Mpc, measured by Tully et al. (2007) with
HST, this compact starburst galaxy has no close neighbors
and is quite appropriate to be called ``intergalactic HII region'', a name
given by Sargent & Searle (1970). We note some inconsistency in
the integrated blue magnitudes for this galaxy, i.e. Papaderos et al. (1996)
obtained
BT = 14.84, while Makarova et al. (1997) and
Gil de Paz et al. (2003) obtained 15.14 and 14.15 mag, respectively.
We observed UGCA 281 with the 6-m telescope in the B, V, R bands and obtained
.
This magnitude measured by Sharina is
presented in Table 2.
DDO 125 = UGC 7577. The diffuse emission regions in this dIrr galaxy form a knotty filament extending as far as the northern side of the galaxy.
UGC 7584. Together with diffuse emission regions, zones of noticeable internal absorption are seen in the galaxy, which is not typical of dwarf galaxies.
KKH 80. This is a galaxy of low surface brightness and of quite
regular shape. In Table 2, only the upper limit of its H-flux
is presented. Most likely, KKH 80 belongs to the transition dIrr/dSph
type.
NGC 4449. The bright galaxy of Magellanic type reveals numerous powerful starburst sites scattered over the whole disk. Its emission filament structure has been described in more detail by Hunter & Gallagher (1992).
NGC 4460. This is a lenticular galaxy without signs of spiral structure. Surprisingly, we find a compact emission disk in its core, from which diffuse emission protuberances originated, along the minor axis. Using the surface brighness fluctuations, Tonry et al. (2001) derived its distance to be 9.59 Mpc.
NGC 4627 and NGC 4631. This is a close-in-projection pair of dE and Sd
galaxies with distances of 9.38 Mpc and 7.66 Mpc, respectively. The elliptical
component shows weak peripheral distortion, which is likely to give
grounds to include this pair into the catalog of peculiar systems (Arp 1966).
However, with errors in the estimation of the distances to the galaxies of
15%, they may constitute a physical pair of the M32+M31 type, in which
the dE component lost its gas because of the
influence of a close massive neighbor.
Table 3:
Comparison of SFR estimates for the CVnI galaxies.
The index ``6 m'' at log[]
corresponds to our measurements, while the
index ``oth'' corresponds to other sources indicated in the last column.
KK 160. This is a galaxy of the transition dIrr/dSph type with weak
emission in HI, but without visible emission in the H line.
DDO 147 = UGC 7946. This dIrr galaxy has several emission regions of different degrees of compactness. Its distance, 9.9 Mpc, is estimated from the brightest stars and needs refinement.
KK 166. This is a dSph galaxy of very low surface brightness, for
which only upper limits of the fluxes in HI and H
are available.
This is one of the faintest (
MB=-10.82) known members of the CVnI cloud.
UGC 7990. The distance to this galaxy (20.9 Mpc), derived from the Tully-Fisher relation, is greatly different from the estimate made from its radial velocity (6.9 Mpc). The galaxy has not been resolved into stars yet.
UGC 8215. To the east of this dIrr galaxy there is a nearly star-like emission knot.
NGC 5023. This isolated late-type spiral galaxy, seen almost edge-on,
was observed with ACS at HST by Seth et al. (2005), who estimated its
distance to be 6.61 Mpc, based on the TRGB luminosity. All visible H emission from NGC 5023 is concentrated in its disk, without signs of
extra-planar gas motions.
NGC 5195. This is an elliptical component of the famous interacting
pair M51. Its diffuse H emission is distributed over
the galaxy body non-uniformly. A considerable part of the
H
-flux is concentrated in the circumnuclear region.
Some uncertainty in the evaluation of the integrated flux from NGC 5195
is introduced by the HII regions of the spiral arm of NGC 5194 crossing the
elliptical component of the pair.
NGC 5229. This is a late-type spiral galaxy seen almost edge-on. The edges of its disk are slightly curved to the opposite sides, giving the galaxy an ``integral-like'' shape.
UGC 8638. This is a compact galaxy whose main H-emission
comes from several compact HII regions near its center.
DDO 181 = UGC 8651. The galaxy has a curved bow-like shape similar to
DDO 165. The basic H-flux in DDO 181 is emitted from a very bright
HII region at the eastern edge.
Holmberg IV = UGC 8837. This is an irregular galaxy whose
H-emission is concentrated in compact HII regions without signs
of a diffuse component. Judging by the distance of 6.83 Mpc measured
by Tully et al. (2007), it is a satellite of the bright spiral galaxy M101.
UGC 8882. According to Rekola et al. (2005), this is a dE galaxy at a distance of 8.3 Mpc, with a compact nucleus and without
visible emission in the lines HI and H.
KK 230. This is an isolated dIrr galaxy of low surface brightness
situated between the CVnI cloud and the Local Group at a distance of
1.92 Mpc. No signs of H-emission are seen.
The distribution of neutral hydrogen in it, with high angular resolution,
has been investigated by Begum et al. (2006).
KKH 87. This dIrr galaxy is a likely companion to M101. Almost all
H-flux of KKH 87 comes from compact HII regions without signs of
a diffuse component.
DDO 190 = UGC 9240. The periphery of the galaxy has quite a regular shape. Compact and diffuse emission knots occupy the central and southern areas of the galaxy. Being an isolated dwarf system, DDO 190 is an expressive example of a star formation burst not triggered by external tides.
KKR 25. This is an isolated dSph galaxy of very low surface
brightness, near which a bright star is projected. KKR 25 is located between
the CVnI cloud and the Local Group at a distance of 1.86 Mpc. Its radial
velocity of +68 km c-1, measured by Huchtmeier et al. (2003), has not
been corroborated by deeper observations with GMRT (Begum & Chengalur 2005),
who estimated only the upper limit of the HI flux. On the northern side
of KKR 25 one can see a faint knot in H,
the nature of which
can be established by spectral observations.
![]() |
Figure 2:
Star formation rate versus blue absolute magnitude for 78 galaxies in the Canes Venatici I cloud (circles) and 41 members of the M 81
group (squares). The open symbols indicate the galaxies with only an upper
limit of their ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The distribution of
for all 78 galaxies in the CVnI cloud, as a function
of their blue absolute magnitude, is presented in Fig. 2 by filled circles.
The galaxies with only the upper limit of the H
-flux
are given by open circles. For comparison, we include similar data on
the complete set of 41 galaxies situated
in the nearby virialized group around M 81 (Karachentsev
& Kaisin 2007).
![]() |
Figure 3:
Star formation rate versus neutral hydrogen mass for galaxies
in the CVnI cloud (circles) and the M 81 group (squares). The galaxies
with upper limit of ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
They are shown in this diagram by filled and open
squares. As can be seen, the bright members of the cloud and the group
follow a common linear relationship
,
displayed by the line.
The differences between the samples are not large, from either the integrated
range or from the scatter of specific
per unit luminosity.
Faint dwarfs in the two samples with
MB > -13m demonstrate a systematic
offset from the main sequence. However, their displacement in
can
be essentially reduced in a new scenario of stellar evolution proposed
by Weidner & Kroupa (2005).
Another important diagram (Fig. 3) illustrates a relationship between and total hydrogen mass
of galaxies. The members of the CVnI cloud,
and those of the M 81 group, are shown here by the same symbols as in Fig. 2.
As noted by many authors: (Kennicutt 1989, 1998;
Taylor & Webster 2005;
Tutukov 2006), spiral and irregular galaxies
show a steeper dependence of
on
than on luminosity LB,
namely
.
This confirms that dIrr galaxies
preserve a larger amount of gas than spirals to maintain
star formation with the recently observed rates. This diagram also
shows that the members of the CVnI cloud and M 81 group are mutually
well mixed, as in the previous plot.
To estimate the evolutionary status of normal and dwarf galaxies in the CVnI
cloud, we used the data on dimensionless parameters in the last two columns
of Table 2:
and
,
which characterize the past and future of the star formation process
in a galaxy, on the assumption of permanent star formation rate. The
evolutional ``past-future'' diagram for the observed galaxies is presented
in Fig. 4. The members of the CVnI cloud are shown by circles, and
the members of the group M 81 are marked by squares. The open symbols
correspond to the cases where observations give only the upper limit
of the flux in H
or HI.
![]() |
Figure 4:
The CVnI cloud galaxies and the M 81 group members on
the evolutional plane ``past-future'': p* = log
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The distribution of galaxies in the diagnostic {p*,f*} diagram
shows some interesting properties. The members of the CVnI cloud, on
the whole, are located quite symmetrically with respect to the origin of
coordinates, having median values p*=+0.02 and
f*=-0.03. This
means that the observed star formation rates in the CVnI galaxies proved
to be quite sufficient to reproduce their observed luminosity (baryon
mass). Moreover, the cloud galaxies possess sufficient gas reserves
to maintain the observed star formation rates during one more Hubble
time T0, since they are just in the middle of their evolutionary path.
For comparison, the median values p* and f* for the M 81 group members
are -0.30 and +0.12, respectively, i.e. their typical value of per unit luminosity is half of that seen in the galaxies of CVnI.
However, this difference is easily explicable by the presence of
a lot of dSphs around M 81, in which the current star formation can be suppressed
by tidal stripping. The CVnI cloud contains only 3 or 4 such ``extinct''
dwarfs: KK 109, DDO 113, KK 166 and, probably, UGC 8882.
In contrast to spiral galaxies, dIrr galaxies of low luminosity exhibit
multiple episodes of global star formation (Dohm-Palmer et al. 2002;
Dolphin et al. 2003; Skillman 2005; McConnachie et al. 2005; Young
et al. 2007). Stinson et al. (2007) simulated the collapse of isolated
dwarf galaxies with the effects of supernova feedback, and showed that
star formation in these galaxies occurs in the form of bursts rather than
of a sluggish process. The observed H
flux in galaxies
represents its current
only over the past
10 Myr (Bell &
Kennicutt 2001; Annibali et al. 2007). The difference between the observed
``momentary'' and the secular value of
averaged over T0 will lead
to scatter of flashing and dimming dIrr galaxies in the diagram
{p*,f*} along the diagonal line p*=-f*.
This tendency is actually seen in Fig. 4 both for the CVnI cloud and for
the M 81 group members. These data permit us to estimate that the global
star formation rate in the dIrrs can vary with time by about
an order of magnitude. The most expressive representatives of a dwarf
galaxy at a burst stage are UGCA 281 = Mkn 209 and UGC 6541 = Mkn 178,
in which the specific
per unit luminosity is 16 times and 7 times
higher than the average value, respectively. The known ``exploding''
galaxy M 82 in the M 81 group has a bit lower specific
.
![]() |
Figure 5:
The specific star formation rate ( left) and the time of
exhaustion of the available reserves of gas ( right) versus the tidal
index for the CVnI cloud (circles) and the M 81 group galaxies (squares). The
open symbols indicate the galaxies with upper limits of ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
Among 500 galaxies of the Local volume there are only 6 galaxies with
a hydrogen mass-to-luminosity ratio greater 5
.
Surprisingly, half of these semi-gaseous galaxies (DDO 154, NGC 3741
and UGCA 292) reside in the CVnI cloud; all three of them are located
in the upper right quadrant of Fig. 4. In contrast Karachentsev
& Kaisin (2007) have found only one peculiar object in the same quadrant
of the M 81 group, the dark HI cloud HIJASS with a rather
uncertain estimate of
.
Galaxies probably galaxies start their evolution
just from this quadrant, [
p*>0,f*>0],
converting their initial gaseous mass into stars.
There is a widespread point of view that close galaxy encounters trigger
enhanced star formation in the galaxies. However, Hunter & Elmegreen (2004)
and Noeske et al. (2001) find no correlation between star formation
activity in a galaxy and its proximity to other neighboring galaxies.
Telles & Maddox (2000) and James et al. (2004) found that bursting
dwarf galaxies inhabit slightly lower density environments than those of
denser field. Our data are in agreement with such a conclusion. The
left-hand diagram of Fig. 5 presents the distribution of members of the CVnI
cloud (circles) and of the M 81 group (squares) versus their specific
and
tidal index. Here the solid regression line has a slope of
corresponding to the galaxies detected in the H
line, while the dashed
regression line with a slope of
corresponds to the whole
sample of 78+41 galaxies, including those with upper limits of their
H
flux.
This diagram does not show a significant difference in
for
galaxies in groups (TI > 0) as compared to isolated ones.
In particular, the strongly disturbed system Garland, near NGC 3077, and
the isolated blue galaxy UGCA 281, have almost the same
extremely high values of p*.
The right diagram of Fig. 5 presents the time of exhaustion of the
available reserves of HI gas, f*, for the CVnI cloud and the M 81 group
galaxies versus their tidal index. The solid and dashed regression lines with
slopes
and
correspond to the galaxies
detected in the H
and HI lines, and to the whole sample of galaxies,
respectively.
Despite the considerable dispersion,
a trend of diminishing of the value of f* from isolated galaxies
towards interacting ones is seen, which reflects the known tendency
of HI-deficiency to rise with increasing density of its environment
(Giovanelli & Haynes 1991).
We regard the isolated (TI=-0.7) lenticular galaxy NGC 4460 to be the most intriguing object in the sample considered. A powerful star formation burst in its center exhausts all available reserve of gas in just 170 Myr. Possibly, we are observing a rare event of interaction of the S0 galaxy with an intergalactic HI cloud. Such dark, completely starless clouds have already been detected in the nearby groups M 81 (Boyce et al. 2001), Leo-I (Schneider 1985) and the nearby Virgo cluster (Minchin et al. 2005).
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank Margarita Sharina for her help with the photometry of UGCA 281. We are also grateful to B. Tully for useful discussions. Support associated with HST program 10905 was provided by NASA through a grant from the Space Telescope Science Institute, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under NASA contract NAS5-26555. This work was also supported by RFFI grant 07-02-00005 and grant DFG-RFBR 06-02-04017.