A&A 471, 247-254 (2007)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20077607
M. Reyniers1,
-
G. C. Van de Steene2 -
P. A. M. van Hoof2 -
H. Van Winckel1
1 - Instituut voor Sterrenkunde, Departement Natuurkunde en
Sterrenkunde, K.U.Leuven, Celestijnenlaan 200D, 3001 Leuven,
Belgium
2 - Koninklijke Sterrenwacht van België, Ringlaan 3, 1180 Brussel, Belgium
Received 4 April 2007 / Accepted 6 June 2007
Abstract
Aims. One of the puzzling findings in the study of the chemical evolution of (post-)AGB stars is why very similar stars (in terms of metallicity, spectral type, infrared properties, etc.) show a very different photospheric composition. We aim at extending the still limited sample of s-process enriched post-AGB stars, in order to obtain a statistically large enough sample that allows us to formulate conclusions concerning the 3rd dredge-up occurrence.
Methods. We selected two post-AGB stars on the basis of IR colours indicative of a past history of heavy mass loss: IRAS 08281-4850 and IRAS 14325-6428. They are cool sources in the locus of the Planetary Nebulae (PNe) in the IRAS colour-colour diagram. Abundances of both objects were derived for the first time on the basis of high-quality UVES and EMMI spectra, using a critically compiled line list with accurate log(gf) values, together with the latest Kurucz model atmospheres.
Results. Both objects have very similar spectroscopically defined effective temperatures of 7750 - 8000 K. They are strongly carbon and s-process enriched, with a C/O ratio of 1.9 and 1.6, and an [ls/Fe] of +1.7 and +1.2, for IRAS 08281-4850 and IRAS 14325-6428 respectively. Moreover, the spectral energy distributions (SEDs) point to heavy mass-loss during the preceding AGB phase.
Conclusions. IRAS 08281-4850 and IRAS 14325-6428 are prototypical post-AGB objects in the sense that they show strong post 3rd dredge-up chemical enrichments. The neutron irradiation has been extremely efficient, despite the only mild sub-solar metallicity. This is not conform with the recent chemical models. The existence of very similar post-AGB stars without any enrichment emphasizes our poor knowledge of the details of the AGB nucleosynthesis and dredge-up phenomena. We call for a very systematic chemical study of all cool sources in the PN region of the IRAS colour-colour diagram.
Key words: stars: AGB and post-AGB - stars: abundances - stars: carbon - stars: individual: IRAS 14325-6428 - stars: individual: IRAS 08281-4850
Post-AGB stars are key objects in the study of the dramatic chemical and morphological changes of objects on their ascent on the Asymptotic Giant Branch (AGB) and subsequent evolution. In this paper we report on our ongoing research to study the AGB chemical evolution by a systematic study of post-AGB photospheres. Spectra of post-AGB stars are much easier to study than their AGB precursors for several reasons. First, their atmospheres do not show the large amplitude pulsations and the large mass loss rates that characterise AGB atmospheres. Second, their photospheres are hotter, so atomic transitions prevail in post-AGB spectra, while molecular transitions prevail in AGB star spectra. This allows us to quantify the chemical content of a very wide range of trace elements. Unfortunately, post-AGB stars evolve on a very fast track and whether the current Galactic sample is representative is one of the most difficult issues when interpreting the results of single post-AGB stars in the broader context of stellar evolution. Therefore, extending the still limited sample of post-AGB stars is indispensable in order to attain a statistically large enough sample that allows us to formulate conclusions concerning the (post-)AGB evolution in general.
During the past decennia, it has been realised that post-AGB stars are
chemically much more diverse than previously thought. Binary objects tend to have a totally different photospheric composition than single objects, showing some degree of depletion of refractory elements in their photosphere (see e.g. Maas et al. 2005). The single objects, on their side, are also far from chemically homogeneous. Some objects are the most s-process enriched objects known to date (e.g. Reyniers et al. 2004, and references therein), while others are not enriched at all. This dichotomy is very strict, in the sense that mildly enhanced objects do not exist, except for a few rather atypical objects.
Chemical evolutionary AGB models do predict that there is a minimum initial mass for the 3rd dredge-up to occur, at around 1.4 (e.g. Straniero et al. 2003). Hence post-AGB stars without any helium burning products in their photosphere are theoretically expected.
However a strict dichotomy is not expected, since a more gradual
transition between non-enriched and enriched objects is predicted if
the transition from an O-rich AGB to a C-rich AGB star occurs over
many thermal pulses.
Furthermore, the s-process enriched sub-class of post-AGB
objects imposes another unsolved problem. These stars exhibit a large
spread in s-process efficiency, as they do not obey the expected
anti-correlation between metallicity and s-process efficiency
(see Fig. 4 of Van Winckel 2003). In other words, examples exist
of very similar post-AGB stars (in metallicity, spectral type, infrared
excess, etc.), but with a totally different photospheric abundance pattern (see for example Fig. 1 in Van Winckel & Reyniers 2001). This result dramatically illustrates that the 3rd dredge-up phenomenon is not yet fully understood.
![]() |
Figure 1: The spectral energy distribution of IRAS 08281-4850. |
Open with DEXTER |
Table 1: Basic parameters of the two objects discussed in this study.
In this paper, we selected two objects with far infrared colours typical of PNe from the IRAS point source catalogue. Apart from PNe, only post-AGB stars are typically found in this part of the colour-colour diagram (van Hoof et al. 1997). Furthermore, the selected objects were not detected in the radio continuum above a detection limit of 3 mJy (Van de Steene & Pottasch 1993,1995). Hence they do not seem to have evolved to the PN stage as yet and are very likely post-AGB stars. We obtained JHKL images of the candidates with CASPIR on the 2.3-m telescope at Siding Spring Observatory in Australia in order to assure the correct identification of the IRAS counterparts and obtain accurate positions (Van de Steene et al. 2000). Two of these infrared selected post-AGB stars which are presented here (see Table 1) have counterparts in the USNO catalogue so that their visual magnitudes are also known. They were sufficiently bright to be observed in the optical at high resolution.
The paper is organised as follows: in the next section, we discuss the spectral energy distribution of the two objects, and quantify the total reddening towards the two sources. In Sect. 3 we briefly discuss the observation and reduction of the high-resolution spectra, while in Sect. 4 we deal with the abundance analysis. Section 5 is a section devoted to the diffuse interstellar bands in the spectrum of IRAS 14325-6428. In the discussion (Sect. 6), we mainly focus on the s-process abundances. We end the paper with conclusions.
Images were obtained for both objects with the Swiss Euler telescope at La Silla (ESO) in 2005. The observing log is presented in Table 2. The objects were unresolved in all images. The images were bias subtracted and flatfielded in IRAF. The photometry package was used to do the aperture photometry. In case of crowded fields DAOPHOT was used to subtract the neighbours. One to three standard stars per band per star were available for the photometric calibration. The resulting magnitudes are presented in Table 3.
Table 2: Observational log for the images obtained at the Euler telescope at ESO, La Silla.
We collected additional photometry from various surveys: the Tycho-2 Catalogue
(Høg et al. 2000), the 3rd data release of DENIS (Epchtein et al. 1994), 2MASS
(Skrutskie et al. 1997), MSX (Egan et al. 2003), and the IRAS point source catalogue
(Beichmann 1985). We also obtained literature data from
Garcia-Lario et al. (1997, hereafter GL97) and Van de Steene et al. (2000, hereafter VdS00).
The data are presented in Table 3. Near-IR data
of IRAS 08281-4850 were present in the 2nd release of the
DENIS data set, but was deleted in the 3rd release. The data from the
2nd release have not been retained in the analysis. In order to
construct the spectral energy distribution (SED), we first converted the
Tycho-2 magnitudes to the Johnson system using the formulas:
Table 3: Broadband photometry for IRAS 08281-4850 and IRAS 14325-6428. IRAS 14325-6428 is contained twice in the DENIS catalogue. The data sets do not agree within the error margins, which may point to variability of the source. Both data sets have been retained in the analysis.
![]() |
Figure 2: The spectral energy distribution of IRAS 14325-6428. |
Open with DEXTER |
The SEDs of the post-AGB stars suffer from interstellar as well as
circumstellar extinction. We assumed that this total extinction can be
described by an RV=3.1 galactic extinction curve as defined by
Fitzpatrick (1999). We furthermore assumed that the intrinsic spectrum of
the stars can be described by an Atlas stellar atmosphere model
(Castelli & Kurucz 2004) with the parameters given in Table 8.
We then used an iterative procedure to determine the amount of total
extinction AV and the bolometric flux
by minimizing the
quadratic residuals of all observations between 0.4 and 4
m. The results
are given in Table 6. Plots of the Kurucz stellar
atmosphere models combined with the dereddened observed fluxes are shown in
Figs. 1 and 2.
Table 6: The total extinction AV and the bolometric luminosity Lof the program stars.
High-resolution, high signal-to-noise optical spectra of the two program
stars were taken in the framework of our ongoing program to study the
photospheric chemical composition of stars in their last stages of evolution
(e.g. Reyniers et al. 2004; Reyniers & Van Winckel 2003; Van de Steene & van Hoof 2003). IRAS 14325-6428
is observed with UVES on the VLT UT2 telescope (Kueyen), as a member of a
larger sample of seven post-AGB objects that were observed in service mode
during ESO period #73. IRAS 08281-4850 was observed in visitor mode
with the EMMI echelle grating #9 with cross disperser #3 at the
NTT during period #70. The resolving power of the UVES spectra varies between
55 000 and
60 000. The resolving power of our EMMI spectra is
significantly lower (
8400). The spectral interval covered and some other
details about the observations are given in Table 7.
Table 7: Log of the high-resolution observations. For IRAS 08281-4850, a spectral gap occurs between 493 nm and 500 nm. For IRAS 14325-6428, spectral gaps occur between 577 nm and 583 nm and between 854.4 nm and 864.5 nm due to the spatial gap between the two UVES CCDs.
The reduction of our UVES spectra was performed in the dedicated "UVES context'' of the MIDAS environment and included bias correction, cosmic hit correction, flat-fielding, background correction and sky correction. We used average extraction to convert frames from pixel-pixel to pixel-order space. The reduction of our EMMI spectrum was done within the echelle package in IRAF following the user's guide by Willmarth & Barnes (1994). The spectra were normalised by dividing the individual orders by a smoothed spline function defined through interactively identified continuum points. For a detailed description of the reduction procedure, we refer to Reyniers (2002). In Table 7, we also list some indicative signal-to-noise values of the final data product.
Sample spectra of our programme stars can be found in Figs. 3
and 6. In Fig. 3, the spectra of
IRAS 08281-4850 and IRAS 14325-6428 are compared
with the spectra of the A7Iab standard HD 81471 and the
non-enriched post-AGB star HD 133656. The spectrum of
HD 81471 is retrieved from UVESPOP, the library of
high-resolution UVES spectra of stars across the Hertzsprung-Russell
diagram (Bagnulo et al. 2003). HD 133656 is discussed in
Van Winckel et al. (1996). The spectrum of HD 133656 is an
ESO1.5-m+FEROS spectrum taken on June 27, 2001. This object has
atmospheric parameters comparable with the program stars (
,
,
)
= (8000 K, 1.0, 3.0 km s-1) but is
slightly more metal deficient ([Fe/H] = -0.9). The s-process
enhancement of the two IRAS stars is clear from the Ba II line.
IRAS 08281-4850 is the strongest s-enriched one, but the stronger
lines are also due to a slightly lower temperature of this object.
![]() |
Figure 3: The spectra of IRAS 14325-6428 and IRAS 08281-4850 compared with the A7Iab standard HD 81471 and the non-enriched post-AGB star HD 133656. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 4:
The relatively high microturbulent velocity
(
![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
Since the spectral resolution of the UVES spectra is much higher than that of the EMMI spectrum, we started the analysis with IRAS 14325-6428. In order to avoid undetected blends that are caused by the lower spectral resolution of the EMMI spectrum, we took the line list of IRAS 14325-6428 as our starting point for the analysis of IRAS 08281-4850. As a consequence, all lines that we used for IRAS 08281-4850 are also present in the line list of IRAS 14325-6428. This choice ensures the consistency of the analyses, implying that a comparison between the abundance results is highly reliable. Due to the stronger s-process enrichment of IRAS 08281-4850 compared to IRAS 14325-6428, the spectrum of IRAS 08281-4850 shows significantly more lines of s-process elements. Therefore, we performed an extra search for s-process lines in the spectrum of IRAS 08281-4850. This explains why we have used 12 La II lines and 1 Nd II in the analysis of IRAS 08281-4850, against only 5 La II lines and no Nd II lines for IRAS 14325-6428.
Table 8: Abundance results for IRAS 08281-4850 and IRAS14325-6428. For the explanation of the columns: see Sect. 4.2.
![]() |
Figure 5:
[el/Fe] values for IRAS 14325-6428 ( upper panel) and
IRAS 08281-4850 ( lower panel). The uncertainty on the [el/Fe]
values is the total uncertainty
![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The final results of our stellar atmosphere parameter determination and our
abundance analysis are listed in Table 8. The first column
of this table gives the actual ion. Then, for each star, the following columns
are listed: the number of lines used; the mean equivalent width in mÅ; the
absolute abundances by number
=
(N(el)/N(H))+12; the
line-to-line scatter
;
the abundance relative to iron
[el/Fe], and an estimate of the total uncertainty on the abundance
(see Sect. 4.3). For the references of
the solar abundances (the middle column) needed to calculate the [el/Fe]
values: see Reyniers et al. (2007).
The abundances are also graphically presented in Fig. 5. On this figure, the different groups of elements are marked with different symbols. We will summarize the main results for each of these groups.
Diffuse Interstellar Bands (DIBs) are broad absorption lines of interstellar origin that are seen in the spectra of reddened objects. The carriers of these DIBs are still not known, but polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) are amongst the most probable candidate carriers. Due to the severe mass loss in the preceding AGB phase, post-AGB stars are often enshrouded by carbon-rich circumstellar dust, causing severe reddening. Therefore, post-AGB stars are ideal testlabs to search for possible circumstellar DIBs. If, on the other hand, the DIBs are detected to be interstellar, a rough division can be made between the interstellar and circumstellar component of the total reddening towards the post-AGB star, since some DIBs correlate quite well with the interstellar reddening.
![]() |
Figure 6: Four clear diffuse interstellar bands in the spectrum of IRAS 14325-6428. A spectral synthesis is overplotted in red, to facilitate the DIB-detection. |
Open with DEXTER |
The heliocentric radial velocities of the DIBs show some scatter, but they are definitely different from the heliocentric velocity of the star (-87 km s-1) and show velocities very different from any expected outflow of the circumstellar material. Therefore, the DIBs seen in the spectrum of IRAS 14325-6428 are the imprint of an interstellar cloud between the object and the observer. A rough estimate for the distance towards the DIB producing cloud is obtained through the formula of Lang (1980), which describes the rotation of the Galactic Plane, yielding 1.6 kpc. Obviously, this distance is also a lower limit for the distance towards IRAS 14325-6428. The scatter in the DIB velocities could be caused by different DIB producing clouds in the line of sight towards IRAS 14325-6428, but also the rest wavelengths of the DIBs are difficult to quantify due to their complex fine structure (e.g. Galazutdinov et al. 2003).
For most DIBs, there is a correlation between its strength and the
reddening that is caused by the DIB producing cloud. The DIB standard that is often used to quantify this relation, is HD 183143
(
E(B-V)=1.28). In Table 9, the DIB strengths of this
standard, normalized to E(B-V)=1, are given in Col. 5, together with
the inferred reddening for the DIB producing cloud towards
IRAS 14325-6428 (Col. 6). A mean interstellar reddening of
E(B-V)=0.6 is obtained. If we combine this with the total reddening
towards IRAS 14325-6428 of
(Table 6), we can conclude that a significant fraction
(around 50%) of the total reddening towards IRAS 14325-6428 is of
interstellar origin.
Table 9: Studied DIBs in the spectrum of IRAS 14325-6428.
IRAS 08281-4850 and IRAS 14325-6428 were selected on the basis of their position in the IRAS colour-colour diagram (Pottasch et al. 1988) and the lack of free-free radio continuum emission (Van de Steene & Pottasch 1993,1995).
Both objects remained poorly studied until now. Our chemical analysis presented in this paper shows that both objects are among the hottest members of the s-process enhanced post-AGB stars known to date and illustrates that the rich IRAS legacy of objects in the transition between the AGB and the PN phase is far from being harvested. Although the distance to the objects is not well constrained, both objects do not show an extremely high luminosity (Table 6) and, given the sub-solar metallicity, both objects represent the final evolutionary phase of a star with a low initial
mass (
< 2
).
There is general agreement that the source of the neutrons for the s-process in low and intermediate AGB stars is the "13C source''. A long standing problem is the formation of the 13C pocket itself. Stellar models using a standard treatment of mixing cannot reproduce the 13C pocket at a level which is high enough for the s-process to take place (Herwig 2005). Until now, there is no satisfying description for this phenomenon, and the different modeling groups use different descriptions. Many models use some kind of overshoot mechanism (e.g. Herwig et al. 1997). Also differential rotation has recently been studied as a possible mixing mechanism driving the proton engulfment, but this rotationally induced mixing alone cannot account for the formation of a large enough 13C pocket (Herwig et al. 2003). Other groups avoid this formation problem by assuming an ad-hoc 13C pocket in the He intershell (models by e.g. Gallino et al. 1998) or an ad-hoc proton density profile (models by e.g. Goriely & Mowlavi 2000). The observed spread in s-process efficiency (see Sect. 1) is then reproduced by a variable 13C pocket strength. Since the 13C pocket is build upon primary synthesised 12C, the formation is thought to be largely independent of the initial metallicity and a richer s-process nucleosynthesis is expected for lower metallicity stars, because more neutrons become available per iron-seed. In practise, such a trend has not been found for post-AGB stars.
The very recent results of the population synthesis models by Bonacic Marinovic et al. (2006) and Bonacic Marinovic et al. (2007) are very interesting in this context. Their approach is to combine stellar population synthesis with a rapid stellar evolution code including AGB nucleosynthesis and evolution. Interestingly, their models do reproduce both the observed dichotomy (see Fig. 1d in Bonacic Marinovic et al. 2006), and the observed spread. Contrary to previous models, only a limited spread in the strength of the 13C pocket is needed to reproduce the observed efficiency spread. With the new results presented in this paper, we are able to add two important datapoints to constrain this promising new generation of models. Indeed, the two stars discussed here show a strong s-process enrichment, although they are only mildly metal deficient. Particularly the results of IRAS 08281-4850 are on the predicted boundaries of both the [hs/ls] index (Fig. 3 of Bonacic Marinovic et al. 2007) and the Zr overabundance (Fig. 8 of Bonacic Marinovic et al. 2007).
With the comprehensive abundance analysis presented in this paper, the objects IRAS 08281-4850 and IRAS 14325-6428 join the group of post-AGB stars with a clear post third dredge-up signature, since they do not only show a clear carbon enhancement, but also a strong enrichment in s-process elements. This enrichment is surprisingly strong with a high ratio of heavy versus light s-process elements, despite the only mild metal deficiency of both objects. This provides additional evidence of the intrinsic s-process efficiency spread in (post-)AGB stars. A systematic analysis of post-AGB stars in the PNe locus of the IRAS colour-colour diagram would be a very rewarding program to study the relation between the AGB nucleosynthesis, the dredge-up efficiency and the overall stellar evolution of the central star.
Acknowledgements
MR is grateful to Sara Regibo for the preliminary analysis of IRAS 14325-6428 in an early stage of the paper. The Geneva staff is thanked for observation time on the Euler telescope. MR acknowledges financial support from the Fund for Scientific Research - Flanders (Belgium). PvH acknowledges support from the Belgian Science Policy Office through grant MO/33/017.
Table 4: Absolute flux calibration for the various photometric bands used in this paper.
Table 5:
The spectral energy distribution (sorted by wavelength) given as
in SI units.