A&A 453, 295-299 (2006)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20065025
N. Masetti1 - M. Orlandini1 - E. Palazzi1 - L. Amati1 - F. Frontera1,2
1 - INAF - Istituto di Astrofisica Spaziale e Fisica Cosmica di Bologna,
via Gobetti 101, 40129 Bologna, Italy (formerly IASF/CNR, Bologna)
2 -
Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Ferrara, via Saragat 1, 44100
Ferrara, Italy
Received 15 February 2006 / Accepted 9 March 2005
Abstract
We observed with Chandra two peculiar galactic X-ray
sources, 4U 1700+24 and 4U 1954+319, which are suspected to have a
M-type giant star as optical counterpart, in order to get a
high-precision astrometric position for both of them. The peculiarity of
these sources lies in the fact that these are the only two cases among
low-mass X-ray binaries (LMXBs), besides the confirmed case of GX 1+4,
for which the companion can possibly be a M-type giant.
We found that in both cases the field M-type giant star
is indeed the counterpart of these X-ray sources. We also determined
the distance to 4U 1954+319 to be 1.7 kpc. This result suggests
that a number of faint (
erg s-1) Galactic X-ray sources are "symbiotic X-ray binaries'',
that is, wide-orbit LMXBs composed of a compact object, most likely a
neutron star, accreting from the wind of a M-type giant.
Key words: astrometry - stars: binaries: general - X-rays: binaries - stars: neutron - stars: individuals: 4U 1700+24 - stars: individual: 4U 1954+319
Low-mass X-ray Binaries (LMXBs) are interacting systems composed of an
accreting compact object and a low-mass (1
or less)
main-sequence or slightly evolved late-type star. However, among the
more than 150 LMXBs known (Liu et al. 2001) in only one case
(GX 1+4; Chakrabarty & Roche 1997) the secondary is a M-type
giant. Thus, in principle, LMXBs of this kind are extremely rare.
There are
however two more LMXBs which might have a M-type giant as optical
companion, but the X-ray position is not known with sufficiently high
precision to securely confirm (or reject) the association; moreover,
their optical spectra do not conclusively show the characteristic
features of accreting binaries (e.g. Balmer and He II emission
lines and/or a non-stellar continuum blueward of
5500 Å). These
X-ray sources are 4U 1700+24 and 4U 1954+319.
4U 1700+24 has an X-ray flux which is variable up to a factor of 50
in the 2-10 keV band, and X-ray spectrum which shows
a hardening trend with increasing X-ray flux (Dal Fiume et al. 1990;
Masetti et al. 2002). The source
exhibits huge X-ray aperiodic time variability: the average fractional
variation in the flux during an EXOSAT observation was 50%
on timescales from tens to thousands of seconds (Dal Fiume et al. 1990).
Masetti et al. (2002) presented an X-ray monitoring (performed by using data from 4 different satellites and spanning about 15 years) of this source, showing substantial long-term variability. Its X-ray spectrum is also variable in the long term. A high-resolution X-ray spectroscopy analysis of 4U 1700+24 during a phase of enhanced activity was performed with XMM-Newton by Tiengo et al. (2005).
Garcia et al. (1983), using the X-ray position afforded by the HEAO-1 satellite, identified this source in the optical with a "normal''
M-type giant star, HD 154791, located at 800 pc from Earth. Masetti
et al. (2002) gave a more accurate
spectral classification (M2-3 III) to this putative optical
companion and, in turn, a new distance estimate (d = 420 pc).
The latter authors moreover explained the absence of the
features typical of accreting systems in the optical spectrum
of HD 154791 as due to the fact that the luminosity of the giant star is
200 times larger that any possible optical emission from the
accreting stream, and so the latter is overwhelmed by the former.
All of the X-ray characteristics described above are interpreted as produced by a neutron star (NS) accreting from the wind of the M-type giant.
The 1.5-12 keV RXTE/ASM light curve of 4U 1700+24 suggests the possibility of
a periodicity of around 400 days, which would be compatible with the
pulsation period of a M-type giant star or with a wide orbit for the
system (Masetti et al. 2002). Indeed, Galloway et al. (2002) found an
optical spectroscopic period of 404 days, fully consistent with the
above X-ray finding.
However, Morgan & Garcia (2001), using a ROSAT/HRI pointing, gave the
most precise position for 4U 1700+24 available up to now, with a
90%-confidence level error radius of 2
1.
This localization is inconsistent, at a 3.6-
level, with the
extremely accurate position (with 90% error of 14 mas, considering
also the proper motion uncertainties) of the M giant provided by Hipparcos (Perryman et al. 1997).
This fact, if confirmed, would suggest that the actual counterpart of 4U 1700+24 is a background object, and that HD 154791 is probably an interloper
along the line of sight.
Table 1: Log of the Chandra and XMM-Newton observation used in this paper.
The X-ray source 4U 1954+319 was first detected by the Ariel
satellite at a flux of 10 mCrab
in the 2-10 keV range (Warwick et al. 1981), but the first
pointed observation was that by EXOSAT (Cook et al. 1984).
These authors showed that the source has a dramatic flaring behaviour on
timescales of several minutes, with variations in intensity up to a factor
of 10. This variability is still present, as demonstrated by the
1.5-12 keV RXTE/ASM light curve of this source.
4U 1954+319 has been subsequently observed by Ginga (Tweedy et al.
1989), confirming the previous EXOSAT results.
The spectrum observed by both EXOSAT and Ginga, albeit complex
below 4 keV,
is adequately described above this energy by the typical X-ray pulsar
spectrum, namely a power law modified at high energy by an exponential
cutoff (White et al. 1983).
An in-depth X-ray spectroscopic monitoring of 4U 1954+319 will be
presented in Rigon et al. (in preparation).
Both the spectral shape and the large amplitude flaring activity seen in
4U 1954+319 are typical of X-ray binary systems with a NS
and a high mass companion (e.g., White et al. 1995). Anyway, a
univocal identification of the optical counterpart of this source is still
lacking. The two best X-ray positions (J2000) for 4U 1954+319 were provided
by ROSAT and are:
,
(Voges et al. 1999) and
6,
(ROSAT Team 2000) with 3
error boxes of radius 9'' and 11'', respectively. These positions are however inconsistent with each
other; also, in the middle of the two error boxes, and positionally
inconsitent with both, a V-band 12th magnitude M-type
giant star is present (Tweedy et al. 1989).
Two more possible fainter candidates (Tweedy et al. 1989) do not show any
significant H
activity. Therefore the classification of the
companion of 4U 1954+319 as a close M-type giant (Cook et al. 1984)
or as a distant and reddened Be star (Tweedy et al. 1989) is still not
clarified.
In order to conclusively answer, for both X-ray objects, the problem of the identification of their true optical counterpart, we performed two short ("snapshot'') observations of their fields in X-rays with Chandra. Thanks to the superb astrometric accuracy afforded by this spacecraft, we will restrict the error box regions of 4U 1700+24 and 4U 1954+319 by a factor greater than 10 and 200 in size, respectively. Moreover, for the latter source the uncertainty between the two available X-ray positions will be solved. For 4U 1700+24 we also analyzed XMM-Newton archival data to further support the Chandra results.
As we will show in the following, this comparison will allow us to definitely confirm beyond any reasonable doubt that HD 154791 is the true optical counterpart of 4U 1700+24, and to determine that the real counterpart of 4U 1954+319 is the bright M-type giant mentioned above. The study of this latter object will be complemented by optical spectroscopy afforded in order to determine the spectral type and distance to this source.
We observed 4U 1700+24 (obs. ID: 5455) and 4U 1954+319 (obs. ID: 5456) with
the HRC-I instrument (Murray et al. 2000) onboard Chandra (Weisskopf
et al. 2002) for 1 ks each.
The log of these observations is reported in Table 1.
CIAO
v3.2.2 and CALDB
v3.1.0 were used for the data reduction. The aspect-solution 90% confidence level error radius of 0
6 was assumed for the positions
of the X-ray sources determined from these observations.
The position of the X-ray sources in the Chandra images was obtained
using the celldetect command. In the 4U 1700+24 data set, only a
single bright source is detected at the center of the
HRC field of view. For the case of 4U 1954+319, besides the target object,
a faint (
)
source was detected close to the edge of the
detector. The Chandra PSF degradation at large offset
angles
,
together with the faintness of this object, does not allow one to use it
to further refine the astrometry of this pointing.
Thus, in both cases, we cannot tie the internal Chandra astrometry to that of optical and/or near-infrared catalogues in order to improve the positional uncertainty afforded by the HRC-I X-ray data.
For the sake of completeness, we also retrived four archival XMM-Newton (Jansen et al. 2001) pointings (Obs. IDs: 0155960601,
0151240201, 0151240301 and 0151240401) performed on 4U 1700+24 with the
EPIC instrument (Strüder et al. 2001) in "small window'' mode between
August 2002 and August 2003 (see Table 1).
With these data we determined the average X-ray position of the source
using the XMM-SAS
v6.5.0 software.
In this case also, due to the choice of readout mode which guaranteed a
field of view not larger than
,
the XMM-Newton
astrometry could not be tied to optical/near-infrared catalogues; thus,
the accuracy of the XMM-Newton position for 4U 1700+24 is limited
by the typical EPIC angular resolution, that is, 4'' (90% confidence
level).
Table 2: Coordinates (equinox: J2000) and 90% confidence level errors of the positions of the X-ray source 4U 1700+24 and of the optical star HD 154791.
One medium-resolution optical spectrum of the red star in the field
of 4U 1954+319 was acquired starting at 23:50 UT of 15 July 2004 in
Loiano (Italy) with the Bologna Astronomical Observatory 1.52 metre
"G.D. Cassini'' telescope plus BFOSC. The exposure time was 1 min.
The Cassini telescope is equipped with a
pixels EEV CCD. Grism #4 and a slit width of 2'' were used, providing a
3500-8700 Å nominal spectral coverage. The use of this setup
secured a final spectral dispersion of 4.0 Å/pix.
The spectrum, after correction for flat-field, bias and cosmic-ray
rejection, was background subtracted and optimally extracted (Horne
1986) using IRAF. Wavelength calibration
was performed using He-Ar lamps, while flux calibration was
accomplished by using the spectrophotometric standard
BD +25
3941 (Stone 1977). Wavelength calibration
uncertainty was
0.5 Å; this was checked by using the
positions of background night sky lines.
![]() |
Figure 1:
Chandra/HRC image of 4U 1700+24 in the 0.1-10 keV band.
Superimposed to the X-ray image, the following 90% confidence level
error circles are drawn: Chandra/HRC (light circle; radius: 0
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 2:
DSS-II-Red image of the field of 4U 1954+319 with
superimposed the 0.1-10 keV band Chandra/HRC X-ray position
(small circle). As one can see, the HRC position falls on the bright
M-type star in the 4U 1954+319 field. North is at top, East is to the
left. The field size is ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The Chandra/HRC and XMM-Newton/EPIC X-ray astrometric
results obtained for 4U 1700+24 are reported in Fig. 1 and in Table 2,
together with all of the most accurate localizations available in the
literature for this source and for the star HD 154791.
As one can see from Fig. 1, the HRC error box is perfectly consistent
with the position of optical star, and inconsistent at a 3.5- level with the ROSAT/HRI localization of Morgan & Garcia (2001).
Moreover, HD 154791 lies within one HRC detector pixel from the PSF peak
of the Chandra X-ray image.
![]() |
Figure 3:
3800-8500 Å optical spectum of the optical counterpart of
4U 1954+319 obtained with the Loiano 1.52-meter telescope plus BFOSC on 15 July 2004. The spectrum is typical of a star of type M4-5 III (see text).
The telluric absorption bands are marked with the symbol ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The XMM-Newton data confirm this result, as they also are completely consistent with the more accurate Chandra position, whereas the consistency with the ROSAT/HRI position is apparently marginal.
Rescaling the interloper chance probabilities computed in Morgan &
Garcia (2001) using the more precise Chandra error box, we find
that the numbers computed by these authors become smaller by a factor
of 40.
This confirms, beyond any reasonable doubt, that HD 154791 is indeed the actual optical counterpart of 4U 1700+24, and that this X-ray source is indeed a LMXB composed of a compact object (most likely a NS) orbiting a M-type giant and located at 420 pc from Earth (Masetti et al. 2002; Galloway et al. 2002).
The HRC-I data do not contain spectral information; however, for 4U 1700+24 we determine an HRC-I 0.1-10 keV count rate of
counts s-1. This corresponds to a 2-10 keV flux of
erg cm-2 s-1 assuming a
Comptonization spectrum as described in Masetti et al. (2002) for the
BeppoSAX data. This value converts into a 2-10 keV luminosity of
erg s-1 using the above distance estimate
from Masetti et al. (2002). The comparison of this value with the
long-term monitoring of this source reported in Masetti et al. (2002)
indicates that 4U 1700+24 was in an intermediate X-ray activity
state during the Chandra observation.
The position obtained with Chandra/HRC for 4U 1954+319, overlaid on
the relevant DSS-II-Red survey image, is shown in Fig. 2. Its
coordinates,
272,
82 (J2000) are consistent within the errors
with the position of the USNO-A2.0
bright
star U1200_13816030, that is, the bright red object mentioned in Tweedy
et al. (1989). This star lies at
33,
1 (with an
uncertainty of 0
25: Assafin et al. 2001; Deutsch 1999), that is, 0
79 from the X-ray position. The two positions are thus
consistent with each other at a 1.8
level, and we can
confidently state that this star is the optical counterpart of
4U 1954+319.
The inspection of the optical spectrum of this object (reported in
Fig. 3) clearly shows the typical features of a M-type star (Jaschek
& Jaschek 1987): it is dominated by TiO absorption bands and no
emission features typical of X-ray binaries are apparent.
The H line is also detected
in absorption. We also detect, among the main spectral features, the
Mg "b'' absorption around 5170 Å and two atomic line blends of metal
intersystemlines of Fe I, Ti I, Cr I, Ba I,
Ca I, Mn I, Co I and Ni I located at 6352 Å and 6497 Å (see e.g. Turnshek et al. 1985). Telluric absorption
features are moreover detected at 6870 and 7600 Å.
Using the Bruzual-Persson-Gunn-Stryker (Gunn & Stryker 1983) and
Jacoby-Hunter-Christian
(Jacoby et al. 1984)
spectroscopy atlases, we then compared the spectrum of star
U1200_13816030 with those of several late-type stars. The best
match is
obtained with stars HD 110964 (M4 III) and SAO 62808 (M5 III). Thus,
we classify U1200_13816030 as a star of spectral type M4-5 III.
Next, from the R-band magnitude information extracted from the USNO-B1.0 catalogue (Monet et al. 2003) and from the V-R color index of a M4 III star (1.58; Ducati et al. 2001), we determine a V magnitude of 10.7 for the counterpart of 4U 1954+319. Assuming that a star of this spectral type has an absolute magnitude MV = -0.5 (Lang 1992), we obtain a distance d = 1.7 kpc. We however stress that this should conservatively be considered as an upper limit to the distance to this object, as the effect of the (presently unknown) amount of the interstellar absorption along the line of sight was not accounted for.
The HRC-I 0.1-10 keV count rate for 4U 1954+319 is
counts s-1, indicating that the source was quite faint at the time
of the Chandra observation. This was also confirmed by the RXTE/ASM data for this object. This count rate corresponds to a 2-10 keV flux of
erg cm-2 s-1 assuming
a Comptonization spectrum as in Rigon et al. (in preparation). This
value implies a 2-10 keV luminosity of
erg s-1 using the distance estimate obtained above from the optical
spectroscopy.
All of the above makes 4U 1954+319 a more distant twin of the
X-ray binary 4U 1700+24, both in terms of spectral type of the companion and of X-ray
luminosity range. This system is therefore most likely hosting a compact
object accreting from the wind of a M-type giant star showing no spectral
signatures other than those of its spectral type. The latter
characteristic is due to the low X-ray luminosity when compared to the
bolometric luminosity of a M4 III star (
erg s-1; Lang 1992); so, reprocessing of variable X-ray emission is
completely lost into the glare of the M-type giant companion.
Thus, a scenario similar to that described by Masetti et al. (2002)
for 4U 1700+24 may also be applicable to the system 4U 1954+319.
The positional information obtained from the Chandra observations presented in this paper showed that the optical counterparts of X-ray sources 4U 1700+24 and 4U 1954+319 are both M-type giant stars to a high confidence level. Besides, spectroscopy of the optical counterpart of 4U 1954+319 allowed us to determine its spectral type and its distance.
The detection of two such systems within the 4th Uhuru catalogue (Forman et al. 1978) indicates that a number of wide systems composed of a compact object and a giant star may be present in the Galaxy, eventually evolving (as suggested by Gaudenzi & Polcaro 1999) to a tighter configuration similar to that observed in the X-ray binary GX 1+4 (Chakrabarty & Roche 1997).
Thus, in conclusion we suggest that many faint X-ray objects in the Galaxy may belong to this subclass of binary systems (which, by analogy with symbiotic stars in which a white dwarf accretes from the wind of a M-type giant companion, can be dubbed "symbiotic X-ray binaries'') and that this may be a non-negligible evolution channel for LMXBs.
Acknowledgements
We thank the referee, Hans Ritter, for his useful comments which helped us to improve the paper and for suggesting the "symbiotic X-ray binary'' definition for GX 1+4, 4U 1700+24 and 4U 1954+319. We also thank R. Gualandi for the assistance at the Loiano telescope. This work has made use of the NASA's Astrophysics Data System and HEASARC archive, and of the SIMBAD database operated at CDS, Strasbourg, France.