A&A 440, 1105-1118 (2005)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20052901
K. G. Strassmeier1 -
J. B. Rice2 - A. Ritter1 - M. Küker1 - G. A. J.
Hussain3, - S. Hubrig4 - R. Shobbrook5
1 - Astrophysical Institute Potsdam, An der Sternwarte 16,
14482 Potsdam, Germany
2 - Department of Physics,
Brandon University, Brandon, Manitoba R7A 6A9, Canada
3 - Harvard
Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, Cambridge, USA
4 - European Southern
Observatory, 19001 Santiago, Chile
5 - Research School of
Astronomy and Astrophysics, Australian National University, Cotter
Road, Weston, ACT 2611 Australia
Received 18 February 2005 / Accepted 9 June 2005
Abstract
We obtained high-resolution, high-quality VLT/UVES
spectra to reconstruct the two-dimensional surface structure of
the rapidly-rotating classical T-Tauri star MN Lupi on two
separate nights. Both surface maps show a structured warm
(5000 K) band centered around the pole at a latitude of 65
.
Located within the band are two hot spots with
temperatures of approximately or possibly even in excess of 5800 K, i.e. 2000 K above the effective photospheric
temperature. Both maps appear with an adjacent equatorial band of
temperature 3400 K, some 400-500 K below the effective
photospheric temperature. While we interpret the two hot spots and
the warm high-latitude band to be the heating points from two
accretion impacts at the time of our observations and their
redistributed energy trailed due to the fast stellar rotation,
respectively, the cool equatorial band may not be cool after all
but due to obscuration of the stellar surface by the innermost
region of the disk. The fact that the hot spots appear at high
stellar latitude is in agreement with the magnetospheric accretion
model that proposes material funnelling onto the star along a
predominantly dipolar magnetic field at roughly 50
latitude.
The evidence of ongoing disk accretion, together with the very
fast rotation of MN Lupi of just 3-4 times below its break-up
velocity, suggests that the accretion mechanism is the cause of
its rapid surface rotation. We present a model of magnetic
star-disk coupling for MN Lupi that predicts a polar surface
magnetic field of
3 kG.
Key words: stars: activity - starspots - stars: imaging - stars: individual: MN Lup - stars: individual: T Tauri - stars: pre-main sequence
MN Lupi = RX J1523.5-3821 (RA 15 23 30.2, Dec -38 21 26 (2000.0,
FK5),
,
M 0) is a very young star in the Lupus
star-forming region and was discovered on the basis of its ROSAT
X-ray emission (Krautter et al. 1997). It was listed as
a weak-lined T Tauri star (WTTS) in subsequent studies of the
Lupus region. Wichmann et al. (1998a) discovered its
photometric variability due to starspots with a rotation period of 0.44 days and obtained first estimates of its age
(
2 Myr) and mass (0.30
).
At a distance of just 150 pc, the Lupus region is one of the nearest star-forming regions. The bulk of (known) stellar components are in the age range between a few 106 yr and 108 yr, i.e., the age between the oldest T Tauris and the youngest ZAMS dwarfs (Wichmann et al. 1998a). Again based on the Krautter et al. sample, Wichmann et al. (1997) found that the mean age of weak-line T Tauri stars seen in projection against dark clouds is lower than the mean age of WTTSs far away from them, but still higher than the mean age of the cluster's classical T Tauri stars (CTTS). This makes the Lupus region an interesting laboratory for studies of infant evolutionary processes and their interrelations.
One of the questions to be answered for CTTSs in general is the relation between accretion disk parameters, especially the accretion rate, and the evolution of the central star, and how does it all tie into the basic magnetospheric model and its numerous variants. CTTSs are believed to have an accretion disk with a number of complex physical processes that cause, among other effects, an excess of radiation in the IR and the UV due to reradiation off the disk and the appearance of accretion shocks in the stellar atmosphere, respectively (e.g. Hartmann et al. 1994). CTTSs are not necessarily always younger than WTTSs because a disk's size is largely determined by the initial conditions of star formation rather than subsequent evolution (Bertout 1989). CTTS optical spectra are dominated by very strong emission lines, usually hydrogen and forbidden oxygen lines but also resonance lines such as Ca II H and K. The WTTSs, on the other hand, are thought to be without a disk, i.e. "naked'' (cf. Walter 1987), and thus without the large IR and UV excess. Particularly the photospheric lithium abundance may be a good WTTS indicator. Many of them still show signs of circumstellar material but largely without accretion. However, some of our previous Doppler images of WTTSs showed occasionally hot spots (e.g. Strassmeier & Rice 2000; Rice & Strassmeier 1996) while others did not (Strassmeier & Rice 1998). Also, no veiling of the photospheric spectrum was apparent in these stars. Finally, most of the ZAMS dwarfs show a solar-like optical/UV spectrum without the aforementioned irregularities and with almost all the surface lithium depleted. A good overview of previous results from high-resolution spectroscopy of CTTSs was given in the discussion by Stempels & Piskunov (2002), and we refer the reader to this paper for further references.
Our approach in the present and forthcoming paper is to analyze phase-resolved, high-resolution and high signal-to-noise optical spectra of selected targets that may be in an evolutionary transition phase, either from CTTS to WTTS or from WTTS to ZAMS. Our direct goal is to disentangle the spectral signatures of the accretion flow from the chromospheric and photospheric magnetic activity by spatially resolving the stellar surface with the technique of Doppler imaging. From these maps we hope to be able to, among other objectives, constrain the accretion rates and whether or not these are consistent with the general magnetospheric model of disk accretion at the evolutionary state of the central star under investigation. Mapping a series of suitable stars of various ages may then lead to quantitative values to be compared to model predictions of the magnetospheric star-disk interaction, in particular those of Küker et al. (2003).
Section 2 describes our observations and data reductions. Astrophysical parameters of MN Lupi are determined in Sect. 3, the results from the Doppler-imaging analysis are described in Sect. 4. Section 5 is an attempt to model the observed surface structure with a magnetospheric star-disk model. Section 6 summarizes our conclusions.
The H
emission and the strong lithium absorption were
already discovered from a
spectrum obtained by
Krautter et al. (1997) in 1992/93. We are aware of only
one further,
ESO-CASPEC spectrum in the range
580-850 nm obtained by Wichmann et al. (1999) in 1995.
According to this spectrum, MN Lupi would be a double-lined
spectroscopic binary with radial velocities of -12.6 and +23.8 km s-1 and projected rotational velocities of 50-55 km s-1 and 27 km s-1 for the two components, respectively (Table 1 in
Wichmann et al. 1999). H
was already interpreted
to be multiple based on the older
spectrum that
showed a profile asymmetry in the red wing (Fig. 5 in Krautter et al. 1997). In the present paper, we can not verify the
spectroscopic binary nature of MN Lupi nor do we see a persistent
H
-line asymmetry. We attribute this to the low resolution
and the comparably low quality of the previous data.
High-resolution spectroscopic observations were obtained with the
Ultraviolet Visual Echelle Spectrograph (UVES, Dekker et al.
2000) at the 8.2-m Kuyen telescope of the VLT in Chile
during two consecutive nights on May 26/27 and 27/28, 2000. UVES's
blue and red arm were used simultaneously and gave a nearly
continuous wavelength coverage from 340 nm to 680 nm with a
spectral resolution of
(there is a small gap from 450-478 nm due to the dichroid). The three-slice Bowen-Walraven
image slicer #1 was used, which projects the
entrance aperture to a
slit. The CCD system of UVES
consists of a blue-sensitive EEV 44-82 2 k
4 k device with a
measured QE of 55% at 350 nm and a mosaic of a red-optimized EEV 2 k
4 k version and a red-sensitive MIT CCID-20 2 k
4 k
device with a measured QE of 80% at 800 nm. A gap between the two
chips of width 0.96 mm, or 64 15-
m pixels, causes an
additional gap in the spectral coverage of
10 nm from 574 nm to 584 nm.
Seeing was always between 0.6-1.0
and all red
integrations were set to an exposure time of 2100 s. This
allowed for a total of 17 spectra of MN Lupi in the first night
and 16 spectra in the second night. The series also included 8 uv/blue integrations per night (with twice the integration time).
A few of these spectra suffered from large amounts of cosmic-ray
hits due to their low signal-to-noise (S/N) ratio. The
red-wavelength spectra have S/N ratios of typically 100:1 per single exposure per pixel while the uv/blue spectra range from a
minimum of
3:1 between 320-340 nm (not shown in
Fig. 1) to a maximum of 30:1 at 420 nm.
![]() |
Figure 1: Optical and UV spectrum of MN Lupi (top spectrum) in comparison with the inactive M0-star HD 209290 (bottom spectrum, shifted by 0.5 in intensity). All hydrogen Balmer lines up to the Balmer jump appear in emission. Strong Ca II H and K, Na D, and He I emission are evident as well as numerous weak telluric features. The very strong forbidden oxygen O I lines are geocoronal in origin. Also notice the lithium absorption line at 670.8 nm. |
Open with DEXTER |
Figure 1 displays a UVES spectrum of MN Lupi from 360 nm to 680 nm along with the inactive M 0 comparison star HD 209920.
Table 1:
VLT/UVES observing log. Listed is the wavelength range
,
number of spectra N, their exposure time t in
seconds, and the averaged heliocentric radial velocity
.
Values for MN Lupi are from this paper (errors are
rms).
Calibration frames included Th-Ar comparison-lamp spectra, several series of flat-field spectra from a quartz lamp, and numerous CCD biases.
The echelle spectra were reduced and extracted using the Image Reduction and Analysis Facility (IRAF). The bad-pixel correction, bias subtraction, flat fielding and cosmic-rays detection was done using the ccdred package. Bias levels were removed by subtracting the median overscan from each image, followed by the subtraction of a median (already overscan subtracted) bias frame. The images were flattened by dividing by a median, normalized flat. After the removal of cosmic rays the one-dimensional spectra were extracted, wavelength calibrated and normalized using the echelle package. The extraction of the one-dimensional spectra was done from summed apertures of between 42-46 pixels width centered on the spectra. No profile weighting was presumed. The target spectra were then wavelength calibrated using the consecutively recorded Th-Ar arc spectra. No background sky-subtraction could be performed due to the use of an image slicer. Therefore, telluric emission features were not removed during the reduction process (neither were absorption features). Finally, the extracted spectra were continuum normalized. Notice in Fig. 1 that the continuum around the Balmer jump at 370 nm was set such that the spectrum appears flat on both sides of the jump. No absolute flux calibration was attempted.
Follow-up photometry of MN Lupi was obtained at Siding Spring
Observatory using the Australian National University's 61-cm
reflector on 8 nights between June 4-12, 2002. The telescope was
equipped with a thermoelectrically cooled RCA 31034A
photomultiplier photometer and filters that match the Johnson
system. The filters are as listed by Bessell
(1979, 1990). A 30
aperture was
used. The B band measurements are the noisiest as they had the
smallest integration times (16 s; 1300 counts) but they were
obtained just to get an independent average B-V value. The other
bandpasses all had 80 s integration time and count rates of
approximately 30 k, 70 k and 100 k for V, R, and I,
respectively. All magnitudes are relative to the comparison star
HD 136736 (K2III). Its parameters are found to be:
,
,
,
and
.
Errors of the colors are approximately
0
03.
The constancy of the comparison star was checked against a third
star, HD 136647, and proofed to be constant to within 0
02 over
the course of the eight nights. Its parameters are found to be:
,
,
,
and
.
These values were determined from one night on which
four standards were observed. Being much brighter than MN Lupi,
both comparison stars were given only one-half of the total
integration time of the variable and were measured to a higher
internal precision of between 0
005 and 0
010.
![]() |
Figure 2: Differential BVRI-photometry of MN Lupi phased with P=0.439 days (only V is shown). Different symbols refer to different nights, i.e. JD 2 452 400+(night number) as following: plusses = +30, asterisks = +31, diamonds = +33, triangles = +34, squares = +35, dots = +36, crosses = +37. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 3: Periodogram of MN Lupi from the CLEAN algorithm. The peak at 0.439 days is interpreted to be the rotational period. |
Open with DEXTER |
Wichmann et al. (1998a) had already found a period of 0.44 days but deemed it very uncertain given their sparse data and the
small amplitude. We applied two different period-search algorithms
to our new data, a modified Lomb-Scargle method and the CLEAN
approach - the latter deconvolves the spectral window from the
Fourier power spectrum. The periodogram from the CLEAN algorithm
is shown in Fig. 3 and shows a single well-defined peak
at
days, in excellent agreement with Wichmann's
0.44-day value. The Lomb-Scargle periodogram also shows the
0.44-day period as the strongest peak but additionally a
comparable but formally weaker peak at 0.31 days, and an even
weaker one at 0.78 days.
We interpret the 0.44-day period to be the rotation period of
MN Lupi and phase all data in this paper according to the following
ephemeris
![]() |
(1) |
![]() |
Figure 4: Heliocentric radial velocities of MN Lupi for both nights. Only absorption lines were used for the cross correlation in order to best represent the photospheric velocities. Note that the error bars are rms values from individual measures of many different wavelength regions relative to the first spectrum and represent best estimates of the true external errors. |
Open with DEXTER |
Figure 4 shows our photospheric velocity measurements
during the two consecutive nights of observation. Despite having
error bars that are relatively large due to the broad and variable
spectral lines of MN Lupi, we detect a peak-to-peak velocity
variations of 9 km s-1 during the second night and
3 km s-1 during the first night. Velocities were
determined by cross correlating all combined echelle orders from
one CCD with our comparison stars (listed in Table 1).
Regions with emission lines were excluded. Firstly, we cross
correlated the reference stars within each other to verify their
adopted values. As primary standard, the Sun (a twilight sky
spectrum) and HD 209290 (+18.363 km s-1, Nidever et al.
2002) were adopted. Secondly, all echelle orders for
MN Lupi were cross correlated with HD 209290 as the zero point.
This gave comparably large error bars because of the large width
of the Gaussian fit function and the variations of the line
profiles. Therefore, we preferred to cross correlate all single
wavelength regions without emission lines one by one with the
appropriate wavelength region of the first MN Lupi image as a
reference. Then the mean and rms of these results are built,
followed by a comparison of the resulting mean value to the mean
of the heliocentric velocities from the cross correlation with
HD 209290. The rms of an individual measure in Fig. 4 is
0.7 km s-1.
The two-night average heliocentric velocity of MN Lupi is
(rms) km s-1, with a peak-to-peak range from 0.5-9.5 km s-1. This compares to the 0 km s-1 of the core clouds of
Lupus from CO-band observations (Dame 1987) and with the
km s-1 of the combined CTTS sample of Dubath et al.
(1996) and Wichmann et al. (1999), and the
1.3-3.2 km s-1 from the ROSAT WTTSs in Lupus (Wichmann et al.
1999). MN Lupi clearly belongs to the Lupus star-forming
region but its position and velocity suggests it lies away from
the central CO clouds.
![]() |
Figure 5:
Evolution of the observed Balmer line profiles. Each
panel shows the original spectra in the top, the residuals after
subtraction of an average spectrum in the middle, and a grey scale
plot of the residuals in the bottom. Time runs from top to bottom
with individual spectra offset by an arbitrary constant C. n1refers to the first night, n2 to the second night. Note the dark
and bright features that consistently appear throughout the
emission profiles. The average equivalent widths are -4.7 Å (![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The observed optical spectrum is dominated by hydrogen and forbidden oxygen lines but also by the resonance lines of Ca II H and K and Na I D1,2, and a bulk of comparably weak telluric features, the so-called airglow emission lines (Fig. 1). Hanuschik (2003) presented a high-resolution atlas of optical sky emission lines as measured with UVES, which includes the strong forbidden oxygen lines. Obviously, a number of different formation regions and mechanisms cause the emission-line spectrum of MN Lupi.
Balmer emission is present all the way down to the Balmer jump.
Visual inspection indicates emission up to at least H13, with the
H8 emission being the strongest of all Balmer lines. S/N ratio for
the UV part of our blue-wavelength spectra is between 10-15:1.
Figure 5 compares time series of the line profiles of H
through H
and indicates their consistent
changes. The average width of the H
core-emission
component is
270 km s-1 with a total equivalent width of
(rms) Å. There is a similar value for the other
lines, indicating that these lines form far above the stellar
photosphere, likely in the freely falling gas channelled along
magnetic field lines outside of the accretion shock (see
Sect. 5). The H
origin is clearly more complex, as
indicated by its non-Gaussian shape and large equivalent width of
(rms) Å. The high-excitation H lines (H8-H13)
seem to originate closer to or even within the accretion shock(s)
near the stellar surface that should also give rise to a hot
continuum excess. We will use these lines for a more direct
mapping of the accretion shocks in a forthcoming paper because it
involves three-dimensional structure that currently can not be
handled by our inversion code TempMap.
![]() |
Figure 6:
Evolution of a) He I and b) Ca
II H and H![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The line width of the He I-D3 emission at 587.6 nm
(Fig. 6a) is km s-1, comparable with the
Balmer emission lines except H
,
which appears more
broadened. The persistently strong He I emission suggests
continuous high temperatures well above 10 000 K at its location
of origin. If we assume this region to be the accretion shock(s),
its profile variations suggest permanent and spatially
inhomogeneous impacts on the stellar surface. Its line-profile
variability pattern is similar to the H-lines or the Ca II H and K lines (Fig. 6). As with the Balmer lines, an
additional chromospheric contribution is likely present but can
not be separated from the data without explicit modelling.
Numerous weak and narrow emission lines appear with a
double-peaked profile. The average width at continuum level of
these lines is just 24 km s-1 (a fifth of the expected rotational broadening of MN Lupi). Its
blue-to-red peak separation is even smaller, between 7-12 km s-1, close to the resolution limit of our observations of 5 km s-1. Their line intensities and equivalent widths
vary consistently with air mass while their radial velocity
remains constant. These lines are obviously of telluric origin as
marked in Fig. 1 and are due to the airglow layer.
By far the strongest emission lines are the forbidden oxygen lines
from [O I] at 557.7, 630.0, and 636.4 nm with line
intensities relative to the continuum of up to 50, 20, and 8,
respectively (for comparison, H reaches at most 3; see
also the T-Tauri star spectral atlas by Appenzeller et al.
1986). The width at continuum level is even smaller than for
the weak and narrow telluric emission lines, on average just 13 km s-1 (a tenth of the expected photospheric rotational broadening). None
of the three O I lines appear asymmetric or even double
peaked as for most CTTSs (Edwards et al. 1987). The line
intensities vary by almost 100% over the course of a night,
without any variation of the radial velocity. While these changes
are consistent for the 630.0-nm and 636.4-nm lines, the 557.7-nm
line intensity seems to change inversely to the two other oxygen
lines.
The two strong and very narrow Na D emission lines - that we
interpret to be geocoronal in origin - behave the same way as
[O I] 557.7 nm, suggesting that almost all of the [O
I] emission is also geocoronal in origin, in agreement with the
findings of Hanuschik (2003). That interpretation agrees
with the fact that we do not see any signs of the low-density
sensitive [S II] or [N II] emissions at 671.6 nm,
673.1 nm and 654.8 nm, 658.4 nm, respectively, which suggests that MN Lupi does not have the typical loosely-collimated bipolar outflow.
A partial background contamination due to diffuse [O I] emission from the Lupus cloud, or a H II region, can not be
completely excluded.
The analysis of photospheric CTTS spectra is hampered by the fact that the spectrum is diluted due to a pseudo continuum from a hot accretion shock. This decreases the depth of photospheric absorption lines by a factor that is called the "veiling'' (e.g. Calvet & Gullbring 1998).
Stempels & Piskunov (2002) applied two different
techniques to determine the veiling for the CTTS RU Lupi. We are
following their approach and use our M 0 standard HD 209290 as a
template star and solve for the veiling factor in a few wavelength
ranges that are interesting for photospheric Doppler imaging.
Furthermore, we use the Kurucz (1993) ATLAS-9 model
atmospheres within our Doppler-imaging code to compute an optimal
template line profile that best fits the line profile shape
and the equivalent width of a number of relatively
unblended spectral lines. For the Li I 670.8, the Ca
I 643.9 and the Fe I 610.2 region, this yields slightly
negative veiling factors
of a few per cent
(d' is the observed relative line depth, and d the unveiled
relative line depth). Therefore, we conclude that no veiling is
present at these wavelengths and attribute the slightly negative
veiling factors to a combination of relatively poor S/N and the
high degree of blending.
We have also measured the lithium equivalent width from the
670.8-nm line in all 33 spectra by integrating between two
continuum points. Its average value is (rms) mÅ. No
lithium is detectable in our M 0 reference star HD 209290.
![]() |
Figure 7: Two examples for the evolution of photospheric absorption line profiles. a) Li I 670.8 nm, b) Fe I 610.2 nm. Nomenclature as in Fig. 5. Note that the Li line appears flat bottomed while the Fe line has a more triangular shape. |
Open with DEXTER |
However, in MN Lupi we observe a number of triangular-shaped
absorption lines that appear neither in the atomic line lists,
like VALD, nor in common molecular line lists.
Figure 7 compares our time series of the neutral
lithium line at 670.8 nm and the blend of a neutral iron line at 610.2 nm with the excited lithium line at 610.4 nm. While the
670.8-nm lithium resonance line shows a flat bottomed profile
typical for spotted stars with polar or high-latitude spots, the
iron line shows a triangular-shaped profile (with the excited
lithium blend in the red wing). Further examples of such lines are
638.16 nm with only a very weak V I line match,
638.85 nm also with only a very weak Sr I line
match, and
644.98 nm which should be a Ca line but it is
much stronger than predicted by TempMap or by R. Gray's synthesis
program (for
to 4250). On the other hand, our
standard imaging line Fe I 643.085 nm seems much weaker than
it should be. Generally there are many lines of Fe and Ca that
seem to have a more normal line shape but are severely blended.
Most likely, the spectrum of MN Lupi consists of many weak
molecular features that we can not readily identify at the given
line broadening. We conclude that the 670.8 nm lithium line appears
to be completely photospheric in origin and uncontaminated by
molecular blends.
Hughes et al. (1993) determined a distance to the Lupus
star-forming region of pc from the parallaxes of
foreground stars while Hipparcos observed five pms stars in
the Lupus region and its values suggest a distance of
pc (Wichmann et al. 1998b). However,
Wichmann et al. (1999) reevaluated the distance with the
assumption of known rotational periods, line broadenings, and
inclinations for the Li-rich stars in the Lupus region on a
statistical basis. They found the most likely distance to be 135-165 pc, only in moderate agreement with the Hipparcos parallax. We
adopt their average value of
pc in this paper.
The "least-spotted'' magnitude of MN Lupi, i.e. the magnitude at
the peak of the light curve, is
(see
Sect. 3.1) which converts, using a distance of
pc and
(see
Sect. 3.1), to
.
With a bolometric
correction of
and a bolometric magnitude for the Sun of +4
74 (Cox 2000) one gets a bolometric magnitude of 6
87
0
21 for MN Lupi which is equivalent to a luminosity
of
.
These results then imply a radius of
for MN Lupi. Note that Table 2
summarizes the parameters that are later also used in the
Doppler-imaging analysis.
Table 2: Astrophysical data for MN Lupi.
![]() |
Figure 8:
MN Lupi in the H-R diagram. The dot with error bars is
the position of MN Lupi. The full lines are the evolutionary tracks
from Baraffe et al. (1998) for masses between 0.4-0.8
solar masses. The dash-dotted lines are the isochrones for 2, 10,
50, and 100 Myr. The comparison suggests a mass for MN Lupi of 0.68
![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
Figure 8 shows the position of MN Lupi in the H-R diagram.
We adopted the effective temperature of
K from the
Doppler maps with rather conservative error estimates. The
pre-main-sequence tracks are from Baraffe et al. (1998)
for solar abundances. This comparison suggests a mass for MN Lupi
of 0.68
and an age of 10-30 Myr
(
of 7.30). Hartmann et al. (1998) list
only one other T Tauri star with a disk at that age (HN Tau,
). We note though that the various pre-main-sequence
tracks found in the literature can give quite different estimates.
Granzer (2005) compared various
theoretical tracks based on different convection treatment,
boundary conditions, and equations of state and found differences
for a 0.6
model of up to 10% in
and 25% in
.
For example, when using the Siess et al.
(2000) tracks, MN Lupi has a mass of
but still about the same age (note that a
normal main-sequence M 0 star is expected to have a mass of 0.51
).
A new value for
of
km s-1 is derived from
the Doppler imaging analysis (Sect. 4.5) and, together with
the rotation period of
days, suggests a minimum
radius of
.
The error mostly reflects the
error of the
-measurement. Our Doppler images achieve
good agreement within a range of inclinations of
40-50
and formally give
as the
most consistent value based on
minimization. This
suggests a radius of
as the most likely
radius of MN Lupi, in agreement with the radius from the adopted
distance. The luminosity of MN Lupi is then
.
Note that a main-sequence M 0 star has a nominal radius
of 0.60
,
already smaller than the above minimum radius,
while a K7V-star has 0.65
,
according to the tables of
Gray (1992) and Cox (2000).
![]() |
Figure 9: Doppler image of MN Lupi for May 27, 2000 (image n1). Maps are plotted in a spherical projection at eight equidistant rotational phases. The temperature scale is indicated and is the same for all projections. The photospheric temperature is 3800 K. A ring of higher temperature around the visible rotational pole suggests remnant heating of the photosphere from accretion shocks. Several hot spots are identified and document the inhomogeneity of the accretion process. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 10: Doppler image of MN Lupi for May 28, 2000 (image n2), separated from image n1 by 14 h or 1.3 stellar rotations. Although the overall surface morphology remained as in image n1, some structures seem to have changed. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 11: Observations (crosses) and fits (lines) from the inversion of the Li I 670.8-nm profiles for a) night n1 and b) night n2. Note that the pixels with the cosmic-ray hit in profile n1/313 were given zero weight in the inversion. |
Open with DEXTER |
TempMap follows the standard mathematical process of Doppler
imaging which is essentially a matter of creating an error
function that represents the degree to which the predicted
spectrum from a current trial image of a star (the forward
calculation) differs from the observed spectrum and then altering
the parameters of the image to iteratively reduce the error
function to a minimum consistent with the error of the
observations. Typically the error function is represented as
In TempMap, the local line profiles are calculated from Kurucz (1993) model atmospheres that are appropriate to the local conditions for each surface element of the image, conditions such as the effective temperature. A file of temperatures covering 3500 K to over 6500 K is provided for the purpose of recovering the local effective temperatures. Calculating the line profiles for every element of the surface for each iteration of the conjugate gradient minimization routine would demand an inordinate amount of computing time, so the profile calculations are tabled for an array of limb angles and temperatures as outlined in Piskunov & Rice (1993).
With the expansion of computing power, TempMap now fits not just the time dependent variations of a single line but instead recovers images from multiple lines in the observed spectrum. In the present paper, the images are derived from single observed lines but the forward calculation of the local line profiles includes the blended effect of all reasonably strong lines that are found in the VALD listing (Piskunov et al. 1995; Kupka et al. 1999) at wavelengths near the principle line.
With a resolving power of UVES of
(
of 0.0108 nm at 642.5 nm, or
5 km s-1)
and a full width of the photospheric absorption lines at continuum
level of
nm, we have
30 resolution elements across the stellar disk. This is
equivalent to a spatial surface resolution along the equator at
the stellar meridian of approximately 7
.
However, the total
time-on-target of 35 min causes phase smearing due to stellar
rotation of up to a maximum of 0
055 or
20
along
the stellar equator and in the direction of the rotational motion,
which is three times the spectroscopic resolution limit. Our
inversion code produces a solution that best agrees with the data,
and thus implicitly always reconstructs a time-averaged image that
is still consistent with the data. This must be taken into account
when interpreting our images.
Because the rotational period of the star is a pre-determined and
fixed value for the line-profile inversion, if the period is wrong
in the first place then the resulting images will also be wrong.
We first computed trial images from Li I 670.8 nm for night n1 for all periods that were evident in the photometry. In spite
of the fact that the CLEAN periodogram suggested only the
0.439-day period to be correct, the Lomb-Scargle periodogram
(Sect. 3.2) had two further frequency peaks at periods of 0.31 days (f0+1) and 0.78 days (f0-1). None of the maps with 0.31 and 0.78 days arranged the line profiles such that their
changes made sense if they were due to rotation, i.e., sometimes
profile bumps were followed by dips and again by bumps. The maps
appeared correspondingly messy having an overall
never
better than a factor of two of the ones with 0.439 days. We
conclude that the 0.439-day period is indeed the correct one.
Because the star rotates at 27% of its break-up velocity it will
be rotationally distorted. However, the ratio of the polar radius
to the equatorial radius,
,
is just 0.965. This value is obtained from the assumption of equal Roche
potentials at the equator and the pole, following the prescription
in Slettebak (1949), together with a mass of 0.68
and an equatorial radius of 0.89
(the
latter is a weighted average of the two methods in
Sect. 3.6). The gravity ratio equator-to-pole is 0.931 and converts to a equator-to-pole temperature gradient of 22 K from von Zeipel's
law (Zeipel
1946; with a gravity-darkening exponent of 0.08 for stars
with a convective envelope and with
K). This is several times below the resolution
capability of our data. Nevertheless, we carried out numerical
simulations with a modified version of TempMap which accounts for
a rotationally distorted stellar surface (see Kovári et al.
2006). We pre-fix the oblateness, defined as
,
invert the data and then go through
a number of trial oblatenesses and search for the lowest
and for systematic surface morphology differences. We applied this
procedure to both data sets of MN Lup by assuming two different
values of the radius ratio, 0.965 and an arbitrary 0.92. From
these tests it became obvious that even the relatively large ratio
of 0.92 had no significant impact on our line-profile
reconstruction. The achievable
,
at the S/N of the data
given, is also practically indistinguishable from the spherical
case. Therefore, we conclude that gravity darkening and rotational
deformation of MN Lupi can be neglected for our Doppler imaging.
Figures 9 and 10 show the final images from
Li I 670.8 nm for the two consecutive nights, respectively.
The observed spectral profiles and their respective fits are shown
in Fig. 11. The lithium line was inverted as is, i.e.,
without applying any veiling and with a fixed lithium abundance of
(on the usual
scale). This lithium abundance was obtained from the best
compromise in the parameter space abundance,
,
micro- and
macroturbulence, transition probabilities (a.o.), and is typical
for pre-main-sequence stars.
Both maps show a structured, warm (5000 K), ring-like band around
the visible rotational pole. The band's locus is possibly off
centered by 10
towards longitude 90
in image n1, but towards 270
in image n2. A central opening in
image n2 appears 400 K cooler than the effective temperature of 3800 K, but could be partially artificial due to the limited
velocity information near the pole. During both nights two hot
regions are seen within the warm band; a large monolithic one
centered at longitude 0
and latitude 65
in both images
and a close double spot centered at
160
in image n1 at a latitude of +65
,
and 200
and on the stellar
equator in image n2 (all of them with an average temperature of 5800 K). The former region appears very similar in both images,
even in shape. The latter seems to have either shifted in
longitude and significantly decreased in size (the latter by a
factor of four; compare the images at longitude
180
in Figs. 9 and 10, respectively) and/or was
wrongly reconstructed and partly mirrored to the equator. Note
that image n2 recovered a weak mirror image of the double
equatorial hot spot at the latitude within the warm band where it
was seen the night before in image n1. While the two hot regions
are associated with the sharp profile valleys seen in the data at
longitudes 189
and 185
for n1 and n2, respectively
(cf. Figs. 11a and 11b), we can not visually
identify the double structure of the latter in the line profiles.
The profile at longitude 226
in Fig. 11b may
indicate two close "valleys'' between two "peaks'', indicative
of a double structure. However, the current data do not allow a
clean decision regarding the true location of this particular
feature during the second night and we do not further discuss it.
The lower rim of the warm band is immediately followed by a
structured cool (3400-3500 K) band stretching to below the
stellar equator and all around the star. It is of varying width
and has its smallest part of just 10
crossing the
central meridian roughly at phase 90
and its thickest part
of
40
roughly at phase 200
.
No truly reliable
information can be retrieved below the stellar equator due to the
phase smearing of our data. Also note that the latitudinal
blurring at and below the equator is likely not real and due to
the still imperfect phase coverage. Although such imperfect phase
coverage is treated implicitly some residual uncertainty whether a
flux element belongs to a certain latitude or not remains.
A cross correlation of the two images (see Kovári et al.
2004 for a description of the method) reveals a high
degree of correlation for the features within the high-latitude
warm band between 50-70
latitude but almost none for the
low-latitude/equatorial cool band. This may be evidence that the
low-latitude spots are mostly artificial and that the accretion
disk actually blocks the photospheric light from parts of the
lower hemisphere.
Only two more CTTSs have been Doppler imaged to date. DF Tau
(Unruh et al. 1998) and SU Aur (Unruh et al. 2004;
Petrov et al. 1996). SU Aur is a much more massive,
hotter and larger system (2-2.5 ,
5700 K, 10
)
at an age of
3 Myr. Therefore, its Doppler maps can not
be directly compared with our MN Lupi maps. We also note that the
Doppler-imaging code applied by Unruh et al. could reconstruct
either hot or cool spots and that three very large
hot (6000 K) spots were reconstructed when only hot spots were
allowed but a large cool polar cap was reconstructed when only
cool spots were allowed. DF Tau, on the other hand, is a M2 CTTS
binary but with a significantly longer rotation period of 8.5 days
and also much more massive than MN Lupi. Again, using the same
Doppler imaging code as for SU Aur the authors reconstructed at
least two very large and hot (5500 K) spots, one on the equator
and one at mid latitudes. Generally, DF Tau is a highly variable
star and its luminosity determinations range from 1.7
to 6.3
from various authors, implying a stellar radius of 3
to 6
,
thus also quite different than MN Lupi.
The spin down of an accreting star by its surrounding accretion disk was first proposed by Ghosh & Lamb (1979a,b) for the spin-down of neutron stars. The model was later adopted to explain the moderate rotation rates of T Tauri stars (Camenzind 1990; Königl 1991; Shu et al. 1994; Armitage & Clarke 1996). In a recent paper, Matt & Pudritz (2005) argue that the disk-braking mechanism becomes less efficient if the finite extent of the region of the disk that is connected to the star is taken into account. As a result the spin-down time scale increases by about an order of magnitude, depending on the field geometry.
In their model the equilibrium rotation frequency is
![]() |
(3) |
![]() |
(4) |
![]() |
(5) |
![]() |
(6) |
![]() |
(7) |
The conditions for the formation of a funnel flow turn out to be
harder to meet than those for disk locking. Miller & Stone
(1997) studied the interaction between a star-centered
dipole field and a circumstellar accretion disk for different
field geometries. They found that a funnel flow only occurs if the
magnetic pressure of the stellar dipole field is large enough to
balance the ram pressure of the gas in the disk. This finding was
confirmed by Romanova et al. (2003). Figure 12
shows a snapshot of MN Lupi computed from a modified version of the
model by Küker et al. (2003). The main difference lies
in the choice of the inner boundary, which is now the stellar
surface. The magnetic diffusion term was dropped, leaving only
numerical diffusion and viscosity. At the beginning of the
simulation the disk is truncated at the corotation radius. Viscous
and magnetic stress then brake the rotation of the gas, which thus
moves inwards and the inner radius of the disk moves towards the
star. The magnetic pressure rapidly increases with decreasing
distance from the star and a point is finally reached where the
gas can no longer move radially inwards. It then piles up at that
radius and eventually a gas flow evolves along the magnetic field,
which hits the stellar surface at high latitudes (50
). The position of the inner disk radius is thus determined by the
balance between magnetic pressure and mass accretion. For an
accretion rate of
yr-1 we find that a field
strength of 3 kG is necessary to enforce funnel flow. For smaller
strengths of the stellar dipole field the disk extends down to the
stellar surface. In this case the accretion torque is balanced by
the magnetic torque while the viscous torque becomes marginal.
Larger accretion rates require stronger magnetic fields. For an
accretion rate of
yr-1 we found a value of about 15 kG (polar field strength on the stellar surface) to be
necessary. These large values of the field strength lead to a
distortion and partial disruption of the inner part of the disk up
to about four corotation radii and the gas flow is strongly non
stationary.
![]() |
Figure 12:
Poloidal field lines and density contours for the inner
part of the MN Lupi system (units in stellar radii). The outer
boundary is located at r=20. The time unit is the stellar
breakup rotation period. The initial disk was computed from a
standard model with a viscosity parameter
![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The rotation rate of MN Lupi of 10.5 h is just 3.7 times below its break-up rotation rate of 2.8 h. It is therefore among the fastest rotators of non-degenerate stars. The simultaneous presence of high-excitation Balmer lines and periodically changing broadened photospheric absorption lines hint towards a complex evolution of the magnetic star-disk coupling and its associated angular-momentum exchange. MN Lupi seems to be an example of a CTTS that has been spun up recently, or is still being spun up, while accretion onto the stellar surface is ongoing at the same time. The commonly referred to "dipolar magnetospheric accretion model'' (cf. Ghosh & Lamb 1979a,b) predicts a toroidal field component from the rotational shear between the star and the disk that reverses its sign at the corotation radius, as does the torque exerted on the disk. Inside the corotation radius, angular momentum is transferred along these field lines from the disk to the star, and thus spins up the star. Outside the corotation radius the disk acts to brake the stellar rotation. The 2-D MHD models of Küker et al. (2003) for a solar-mass CTTS with a 1 kG surface field suggest that the accretion torque exceeds the magnetic torque by two orders of magnitude. Therefore, the total torque at the inner boundary of the disk would be always negative and consequently spin up the stellar surface long before the disk is depleted. At a field of as strong as 10 kG the disk will be disrupted out to radii beyond the corotation radius.
Indeed, classical T Tauri stars are observed to have strong
magnetic fields on their surface as well as within their
accretion shocks slightly above the surface, as inferred from
circularly polarized He I line emission. For a list of
existing magnetic field measures of CTTSs see Johns-Krull et al.
(2003). Their compilation of 13 CTTSs suggests surface
fields between 1.0-2.7 kG, and field strengths in the shock
regions of between 1.0-2.9 kG, with the bulk of stars having
field strengths of 2.5 kG. This led Johns-Krull &
Gafford (2002) to assume that all CTTSs have similar
field strengths, perhaps due to a dynamo operating at its limit.
We interpret the hot spots in our Doppler images as due to the
accretion shocks from material that is funnelled along magnetic
field lines. The model of Küker et al. then predicts a (dipole)
field strength for MN Lupi at the poles at the stellar surface of 3 kG.
A direct measurement of the magnetic field of MN Lupi is clearly
needed and would further constrain our magnetic star-disk model.
Stars with a visual magnitude of as faint as 14
3 are currently
not within reach for Zeeman Doppler imaging though, but will be
prime targets for PEPSI, the upcoming high-resolution
spectropolarimeter for the 11.8 m Large Binocular Telescope in
southern Arizona (Strassmeier et al. 2004) - just to make
an optimistic statement for the future.
Acknowledgements
K.G.S. is very grateful to the German Science Foundation (DFG) for support under grant STR645. We thank Scott Wolk and Bo Reipurth for discussions about CTTS accretion geometry and Thomas Granzer for computing the stellar models for us and an anonymous referee for helping to improve the paper.