M. Matsuura1 - A. A. Zijlstra1 - J. Th. van Loon2 - I. Yamamura3 - A. J. Markwick4 - P. A. Whitelock5 - P. M. Woods1 - J. R. Marshall2 - M. W. Feast6 - L. B. F. M. Waters7,8
1 - School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Manchester,
Sackville Street, PO Box 88, Manchester M60 1QD, UK
2 -
Astrophysics Group,
School of Chemistry and Physics, Keele University, Staffordshire ST5 5BG,
UK
3 -
The Institute of Space and Astronautical Science,
Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency,
Yoshino-dai 3-1-1, Sagamihara, Kanagawa 229-8510, Japan
4 -
Space Science Division, NASA Ames Research Centre, MS 245-3,
Moffett Field, CA 94035, USA
5 -
South African Astronomical Observatory, PO Box 9, 7935
Observatory, South Africa
6 -
Astronomy Department, University of Cape Town, 7701
Rondebosch, South Africa
7 -
Astronomical Institute "Anton Pannekoek'', University of Amsterdam,
Kruislaan 403, 1098 SJ, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
8 -
Instituut voor Sterrenkunde, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven,
Celestijnenlaan 200B, 3001 Heverlee, Belgium
Received 3 November 2004 / Accepted 21 December 2004
Abstract
The dependence of stellar molecular bands
on the metallicity is studied using infrared L-band spectra of
AGB stars (both carbon-rich and oxygen-rich) and M-type
supergiants in the Large and Small Magellanic Clouds (LMC and
SMC) and in the Sagittarius Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy. The
spectra cover SiO bands for
oxygen-rich stars, and acetylene (C2H2), CH and HCN bands for
carbon-rich AGB stars.
The equivalent width of acetylene is found to be high even at low
metallicity. The high C2H2 abundance can be explained with
a high carbon-to-oxygen (C/O) ratio for lower metallicity carbon
stars. In contrast, the HCN equivalent width is low: fewer than half
of the extra-galactic carbon stars show the 3.5 m HCN band,
and only a few LMC stars show high HCN equivalent width. HCN
abundances are limited by both nitrogen and carbon elemental
abundances. The amount of synthesized nitrogen depends on the
initial mass, and stars with high luminosity (i.e. high initial
mass) could have a high HCN abundance. CH bands are found in both
the extra-galactic and Galactic carbon stars.
One SMC post-AGB star, SMC-S2, shows the 3.3
m PAH band.
This first detection of a PAH band from an SMC post-AGB
star confirms PAHs can form in these low-metallicity stars.
None of the oxygen-rich LMC stars show SiO bands, except one
possible detection in a low quality spectrum. The limits on the
equivalent widths of the SiO bands are below the
expectation of up to 30 Å for LMC metallicity. Several
possible explanations are discussed, mostly based on the effect of
pulsation and circumstellar dust.
The observations imply that LMC and
SMC carbon stars could reach mass-loss rates as high as their
Galactic counterparts, because there are more carbon atoms available
and more carbonaceous dust can be formed. On the other hand,
the lack of SiO suggests less dust and lower mass-loss rates in
low-metallicity oxygen-rich stars. The effect on the
ISM dust enrichment is discussed.
Key words: stars: AGB and post-AGB - infrared: stars - galaxies: stellar content - stars: atmospheres
Asymptotic Giant
Branch (AGB) and Red Supergiant (RSG) stars are
important sources of dust
and gas in galaxies. Within the final
104-105 years of the AGB
phase, stars lose up to 80% of
their mass via a slow wind with mass-loss
rates up to
.
Red supergiants can
experience a similar mass-loss
phase. AGB stars have initial masses of
1-8
,
but their large
population compensates for the lower
mass.
The other main source of dust and gas, supernovae,
produce higher elements per event
but occur at a much lower rate. The balance
between dust production by
supernovae and by AGB/RSG stars is not well
known. If the mass-loss rate
of AGB/RSG stars is much lower at
low-metallicity (Zijlstra 2004),
the relative contributions may be
strongly dependent on metallicity
(Edmunds 2001).
How mass-loss rates are affected by metallicity is not well understood. In general, the elemental abundances of extra-galactic stars are assumed to scale with the metallicity, but this ignores the elements which are synthesized in the AGB stars or supergiants themselves. The wind is dust-driven, and dust forms out of simple molecules that are stable at the photospheric temperatures of the cool giants. An indication of the metallicity effect on mass loss can therefore be obtained by studying the molecules in AGB and RSG stars at low metallicity.
AGB stars are classified into two major spectral types: carbon-rich stars and oxygen-rich stars. In photospheric chemistry, CO molecules are formed first as their bonding energy is highest. In a carbon-rich environment, carbon atoms remaining after CO formation are incorporated into carbon-bearing molecules, such as C2, C2H2, CN, and HCN. Oxygen-bearing molecules such as H2O, SiO, CO2 are formed in oxygen-rich stars. There is additionally a minor group of stars, S-type stars, which have carbon-to-oxygen ratio (C/O ratio) close to unity, and where CO molecules are prominent in the infrared spectra.
Previous surveys of AGB stars in the local group galaxies have shown
that the ratio of carbon-rich stars to oxygen-rich ones depends on the
metallicity of the galaxies (e.g. Groenewegen 1999). In the
solar neighbourhood, about 90% of the late AGB stars are oxygen-rich,
while in the SMC, which has lower metallicity, about 80% are carbon-rich. This is because a
fixed amount of carbon injected into the envelope has a larger effect
for a low metallicity, leading to a higher C/O ratio
(Lattanzio & Wood 2003), but also because dredge-up of newly synthesized
carbon atoms is more efficient in AGB stars of lower metallicity
(Vassiliadis & Wood 1993). Marigo (2002) concludes that the
carbon-to-oxygen (C/O) ratio should be systematically higher in
carbon-rich stars at lower metallicity. Spectroscopic evidence of high
C/O ratio could be found in data of extra-galactic AGB stars.
van Loon et al. (1999a) presented the first L-band spectra of LMC carbon
stars, and found that the equivalent widths of the 3.1 m HCN and
C2H2 bands appear to be similar in LMC stars and in Galactic
stars. Matsuura et al. (2002b, hereafter Paper I) found that the
equivalent widths of the 3.1
m band and the 3.8
m C2H2
band are larger in LMC stars than in Galactic stars. This shows that
abundances of carbon-bearing molecules do not scale simply with the
metallicity of the host galaxies; instead, carbon synthesized inside AGB
stars should result in the higher C/O ratio in the LMC stars. The
high C/O ratio compensates for the low elemental abundances: carbon-bearing
molecules are abundant in carbon stars at
lower metallicity.
Here we present an observational study of infrared molecular bands in
AGB/RSG stars in nearby galaxies. The target galaxies are the Large
Magellanic Cloud (LMC) and the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC), with
metallicities of about half and one-quarter of the solar value,
respectively, and the Sagittarius Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy (SgrD), where
the two planetary nebulae and the AGB stars have
(Dudziak et al. 2000); colour-magnitude diagrams show a range of
metallicities down to [Fe/H] = -1.15 (Marconi 1998). The
spectra target HCN and C2H2 bands from carbon-rich stars and SiO
bands from oxygen-rich stars. We choose these molecules because they are
parent molecules for dust grain formation (via PAH and silicate), and their
abundance could affect the dust formation efficiency and, therefore, the
mass-loss rates of the dust-driven winds of these stars.
We selected AGB stars and late-type supergiants in the LMC, the SMC and the SgrD from published catalogues: van Loon et al. (1999a); Trams et al. (1999b) for LMC stars, Groenewegen & Blommaert (1998) for SMC stars, and Whitelock et al. (1996,1999) for SgrD stars. The selections are based on L-band magnitudes and known classification (oxygen-rich or carbon-rich). The observed targets are listed in Table 1. The LMC and the SMC contain luminous and high mass-loss stars that are likely to be young (intermediate-mass) stars. The SgrD stars are older, with a likely age around 5 Gyr, and are optical carbon stars without evidence for high mass loss.
L-band spectra were observed with ISAAC on the Very Large Telescope (VLT) at ESO Paranal, Chile on 12th-14th of December 2001 (LMC targets) and 24th of July 2002 (SMC and SgrD targets). The sky conditions were clear on December 13th, and thin cloudy on the 12th and 14th of December and on the 24th July. On cloudy nights, especially on July 24th, the sky conditions were variable, and cancellation of atmospheric telluric lines was not ideal. We used chop-and-nod to subtract the sky background. Jitter is used along the slit to minimize the influence of hot pixels.
We used two ISAAC instrument modes: low spectral resolution (LR) and
medium resolution (MR). The LR mode covers the entire L-band, so this
mode was used mainly for carbon-rich stars. The MR mode has a spectral
coverage of 0.255 m, and was used to resolve the SiO band heads
against the continuum in oxygen-rich stars. The wavelength resolutions (
)
are 360 (1-arcsec slit) and 600 (0.6-arcsec
slit) in LR mode, and 2000 (1-arcsec slit) and 3300 (0.6-arcsec slit) in MR
mode.
Telluric standards, which were B dwarfs and giants from the Hipparcos catalog, were observed after each target observation.
The spectrum of the telluric standard is assumed to be a blackbody with
an effective temperature based on the spectral type from the
Hipparcos catalog. Br
and, in some cases, other hydrogen
recombination lines and the He I line are detected in the telluric
standards.
We assume a Gaussian profile for these lines.
Although Starck broadening will affect the profile,
we ignore this effect because its precise calculation requires a hydrostatic model.
The cancellation of
the atmospheric lines is not good at the Br
and He I wavelength in some cases. The 3.308-3.320
m region of the
spectra is not used in the discussion, because several telluric
methane bands are saturated and cannot be removed.
The absolute flux is scaled to L-band magnitude,
which is either taken from Trams et al. (1999b),
or estimated from the spectral type, V-band magnitude,
and colour of the telluric standard;
it is uncertain to within a factor of two.
The data are
reduced using the eclipse package and IDL. An exposure of
thermal emission from the twilight sky is used for flat-fielding.
The wavelength calibration is
based on exposures of an Ar+Xe arc lamp with the same wavelength setting
as the target observations. The flux error is estimated from ten nearby sky
pixels in the ISAAC CCD image.
We re-analysed the data for the LMC carbon stars whose equivalent widths were published in Matsuura et al. (2002b). Only the positive images of chop-and-nod were used in Paper I, while in this paper both the positive and negative images are used.
Table 1:
Targets and log of the ISAAC observations.
C/O classification shows the basis of classification into oxygen-rich or
carbon-rich (cand: candidate) in publications.
Opt sp: optical spectra, IR sp: infrared spectra (mainly molecule
features), dust: 9.8 m silicate band.
is the total exposure time in minutes.
Observing mode shows either LR or MR
and the slit width in arcsec.
Observing dates are 12th and 14th December,
2001 for LMC stars, and 24th
July 2002 for the SMC and SgrD.
Ref: reference
for the
coordinates.
![]() |
Figure 1:
The
3.85-4.10 ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The 3.95-4.10 m spectra of four oxygen-rich stars in the LMC
are shown in Fig. 1, where a model spectrum
of the SiO bands
and a spectrum of a Galactic M giant star (g Her)
are plotted as references. The data of
g Her were taken with ISO/SWS AOT S6
(resolution of about 1600-2000), and the
spectrum of g Her clearly shows
SiO bands. Parameters for the model
spectra of SiO are taken
from Langhoff & Bauschlicher (1993) and Sauval & Tatum (1984).
The oxygen-rich stars in the LMC show no clear features in their spectra. Although the observations targeted the SiO bands, no SiO bands are detected in any of these stars.
The quality of the IRAS 04407-7000 spectrum is poor. A
bump at
4.05 m is caused by insufficient cancellation of
atmospheric
lines due to Br
absorption in the telluric standard
star,
and does not imply a Br
emission
line.
![]() |
Figure 2:
The spectrum of one of the oxygen-rich stars,
IRAS 05148-6730, which
covers the entire L-band. For comparison, a
spectra of g Her, and OH and
SiO models are also plotted.
10![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 3:
The
spectrum of IRAS 05128-6455, compared
the spectrum of the
galactic oxygen-rich Mira, Z Cyg
(![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
A spectrum covering the full L-band of the oxygen-rich star
IRAS 05148-6730 is shown in Fig. 2. A spectrum of
g Her and model spectra of OH and SiO lines are also plotted.
Parameters for the model spectra of OH lines are taken from HITRAN
(Rothman et al. 1998). The ISO/SWS spectrum of g Her shows OH, SiO and
possibly weak H2O bands shortwards 3.2 m.
In the spectrum of
IRAS 05148-6730 the decline of the flux shortward of
3.0
m could be due to high-temperature H2O bands;
other than this, no particular molecular bands are detected. Most of the
features are residual atmospheric lines and noise, rather than OH or SiO
bands. The H2O continuous
absorption changes its shape depending on the excitation temperature
and column density. The H2O feature in IRAS 05148-6730 will
not necessarily resemble the one in g Her.
Figure 3 shows the spectra of
IRAS 05128-6455 and a
comparison galactic oxygen-rich star
Z Cyg. Z Cyg shows continuous
H2O absorption up to
3.8 m, which is also seen in IRAS 05128-6455.
SiO bands are found in
IRAS 05128-6455 spectra, although the intensity is
almost at noise
level, due to insufficient cancellation of atmospheric lines.
A small dip at 3.20
m found both in Z Cyg and
in IRAS 05128-6455 is part of the H2O feature with OH blending
(also found in g Her and the OH model spectrum in Fig. 2).
IRAS 05128-6455 was misclassified as a carbon star in
Trams et al. (1999b),
based on the infrared colours and on the ISO/PHOT
spectrum. The latter
suggests some absorption-like structure at
3 m, which could be the HCN
and C2H2 bands. However, we
could not find such an absorption feature
in the ISAAC/VLT spectra.
The structure in the ISO/PHOT spectrum appears to
be the result of an
inaccuracy in the ISO/PHOT detector response curve at
the time of
reduction. Such an anomaly is also found in the ISO/PHOT spectrum of
the oxygen-rich star WOH G64 (Trams et al. 1999b).
IRAS 05128-6455 is clearly an oxygen-rich star,
as shown by its optical spectrum
(van Loon et al. in preparation).
The spectral type is M9 (van Loon et al.)
The equivalent width (EW) of the SiO bands (
)
are measured for
LMC oxygen-rich stars and compared with the galactic
sample
(Fig. 4, Table 3). The definition
of
is similar to the one in Aringer et al. (1997,1999), who
studied
SiO bands in Galactic AGB stars. The
is the sum of
equivalent widths
of three strong 28SiO bands. The wavelengths
used for the continuum and
the SiO bands are the same as
Aringer et al. (1997,1999). In
Aringer et al. (1997), the continuum is
estimated by a polynomial fit. Here we use a linear fit, because
third-order polynomials were
inappropriate and because
we occasionally have insufficient data to attempt higher order fits.
This
difference of fitting has little influence on the measured EW, as
tested on
SWS spectra: less than 5 Å. The exception is KK Per, for
which we found a difference of about 10 Å. The precise wavelength
regions used for the
continuum are summarized in Table 2.
The one-
error
in the EW is propagated from the noise in the
spectrum, and is less than
1 Å. However, in practice, the error of
the local continuum estimate has
a larger uncertainty, as mentioned
above. Aringer et al. (1999) found a
similar uncertainty up to
5 Å.
To allow comparison with the LMC sample, we used the SiO EWs of
Galactic AGB stars given in
Aringer et al. (1999). In addition, we reduced
ISO/SWS spectra that were
observed in AOT 6 (wavelength resolution of
about
R=1600-2000), and AOT 1 speed 4
(
R=1000-1400) which was used for Ori.
We also use reduced ISO/SWS AOT 6 spectra from
Sloan et al. (2003).
The measured EW of SiO bands are summarized in Table 3. No evidence for absorption bands is found, consistent with a non-detection of SiO. Three LMC stars are affected by data problems and are listed separately; for IRAS 05128-6455 and IRAS 05148-6730 the wavelength resolution is not high enough to separate the continuum and the absorption, while IRAS 04407-7000 has a poor quality spectrum.
Figure 4 shows the
of LMC and Galactic oxygen-rich
stars, as a function of H-K colour.
Here we plot the
of three
LMC stars only, avoiding any with poor quality data.
The H-K colour is the
measure of the effective temperature for blue
stars, but not for red
stars where the colour is strongly affected by dust. For both LMC
and Galactic stars, large
stars (larger than 20
Å) are absent
among red stars (H-K>0.7). Within our sample of blue
Galactic
stars, there is no difference in
between supergiants and
giants
(Mira and semi-regular variables) as is consistent with
previous
observations (Heras et al. 2002; Wallace & Hinkle 2002).
![]() |
Figure 4: The equivalent width of the SiO bands. For Galactic stars, supergiants and Mira variables sources are shown by different symbols. Semi-regular variables and unknown variable types are plotted as "others''. |
Open with DEXTER |
Table 2:
The
definition of equivalent width (EW) for the molecular absorption
bands.
The continuum level is linearly interpolated from the
wavelength
region in the last column.
SiO molecules show three strong bands
from 4.0-4.1 m,
and
is the total of these three
bands.
Table 3:
The
equivalent width of SiO bands (unit is Å).
The date is that of either ISAAC or ISO/SWS observations in ddmmyyformat, which is different from the observing date of the magnitudes.
Column four
(
)
lists
the pulsation phase during the SiO observations,
which is estimated from infrared K-band light curve
(Whitelock et al. 2003), where 0.0 and 1.0
are the maxima. Uncertainty
should be about 0.1.
The optical phase (
)
is estimated for the ISO sample,
based on the AAVSO light curve.
The optical phase is usually about 0.1-0.2 of a cycle ahead of the infrared phase.
Photometric magnitudes are taken from Trams et al. (1999b)
for the LMC sample,
and 2MASS for the Galactic sample.
Luminosity class and
spectral types for Galactic
stars are taken from
Simbad.
Figure 5
shows the ISAAC spectra of carbon-rich stars in the LMC, while spectra of
carbon-rich AGB stars in the SMC and SgrD are shown in
Fig. 6. Bands of different molecules are found in the
L-band: the 3.1 m HCN+C2H2 band, 3.4 and 3.7
m CH,
3.5
m HCN, and 3.8
m C2H2. The last identification is
probable rather than certain.
The 3.1 m HCN+C2H2 is commonly seen in carbon-rich stars,
but is more pronounced in bluer stars, such as IRAS 04496-6958.
The sharp absorption at 3.57
m is due to HCN Q-branch lines.
The obvious features are blend of lines from (0000) to (0111)
and some other transitions (Harris et al. 2003). Lines with other
transitions of the HCN Q-branch, around 3.5
m, are not obvious in
our spectra. The 3.5
m feature is found in only a few of the
extra-galactic stars: IRAS 04496-6958, IRAS 06025-6712, SMC S30, and
probably IRAS 04557-6753 and IRAS 05112-6755.
A non-detection of the 3.5 m HCN band does not immediately mean
no contribution by HCN to the 3.1
m band. The absorbance ratio
of the 3.1
m /3.5
m HCN bands is approximately 100
(Harris et al. 2002), and the 3.1
m feature is easily formed even
at lower HCN column density.
The identification of the C2H2 feature is still tentative.
Goebel et al. (1981) noted the 3.8 m feature on a KAO spectrum of
the carbon star V CrB. Hron et al. (1998)'s model calculation
shows a C2H2 band at 3.8
m, and they identify this with a
feature in the ISO/SWS spectra of the Galactic carbon star R Scl.
However, the absorption in the R Scl spectrum starts
only at 3.9
m, which could indicate CS (Aoki et al. 1998). The
identification of the 3.8
m band, which stretches from 3.6 to
4.0
m, as a C2H2 feature is still not fully fixed.
There are several other weak lines visible in the
spectra around
3.4 m and at 3.7
m, where weak lines are seen
superposed on the broad C2H2 band. These lines are due to CH
(Fig. 7), whose bands are found in the Galactic carbon star
TX Psc (Aoki et al. 1998; Ridgway et al. 1984): its ISO/SWS spectrum
(Aoki et al. 1998) is added in Fig. 7 for comparison.
The resolution of the TX Psc spectrum is
,
higher than
the ISAAC LR spectra (R=600), and the CH bands appear more clearly. In the
ISAAC spectra, the CH v=1-0, and v=3-2 bands are easy to find
while v=2-1 at 3.5
m is not obvious. This could be
because of the blend with the 3.5
m HCN bands. Note that
C2H2, which contains C-H bonds, may also contribute narrow
features at 3.8
m, but these are not definitely detected.
Sgr-C1 shows a flat spectrum without any feature in the L-band: no bands
are visible. The flat spectrum (in Jy) at L implies a red colour which shows
that this is a late-type star, but we were unable to confirm that it is actually a
carbon star. Sgr-C1 is one of the first stars found in SgrD (Ibata et al. 1995),
and it is an optically classified carbon star. It is unlikely that we took
the spectrum of the wrong object, because
the VLT pointing is in general accurate enough and the acquisition
image of ISAAC is consistent with the finding chart in
Whitelock et al. (1996). Whitelock et al. (1999) show
that the K-band magnitude of Sgr-C1 is 11.2 mag, fainter than the
three other Sgr-D carbon-rich stars (9.4, 9.8 and 9.7 mag). The luminosity of
Sgr-C1 is
mag, which is not near the tip of the AGB
sequence (Whitelock et al. 1996). All these suggest that Sgr-C1 could be
an extrinsic carbon star.
![]() |
Figure 5:
ISAAC
spectra of carbon-rich AGB stars in LMC.
Molecule bands, in particular the
3.1 ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 6: Same as Fig. 5, but for carbon-rich stars in SMC and SgrD. |
Open with DEXTER |
In the spectrum of SMC-S2, the 3.3 m PAH
band is detected (Fig. 8). Although this confirms
its carbon-rich
nature, it also shows that this object is unlikely to be an AGB star,
as PAH emission is never seen in AGB stars. The temperatures of AGB
stars are too low to excite PAHs: this requires UV or optical photons.
PAH emission is usually seen once the stars reach a temperature of
5000 K. The presence of PAH emission indicates that SMC-S2 is a
post-AGB star, which was already suspected from
its infrared colours and the optical spectra (Groenewegen & Blommaert 1998; Whitelock et al. 1989). This is probably the first detection of a PAH band in
an SMC post-AGB star.
The optical spectrum suggests a K-type star. This is rather cool for PAH excitation but the detected feature is weak. It is possible that the underlying star is hotter than implied by the spectral type and that the spectrum is masked by the stellar envelope. Whitelock et al. (1989) discuss whether the object may be an interacting binary. This cannot be excluded, but the weak variability and high luminosity are consistent with a post-AGB nature, and there is no evidence for ionization in the spectrum.
PAH emission is widespread in the interstellar medium (ISM) of the SMC, as shown by ISOCAM observations (Bot et al. 2004), but at a low abundance relative to the gas as expected from its metallicity. The extinction curve in the bar of the SMC rises very steeply to the UV (Gordon et al. 2003), which can be attributed to PAHs. It is not known whether the PAHs form in the ISM or derive from the same sources as the dust. PAH detection in SMC-S2 shows that PAHs can form in the metal-poor stars, leaving evolved stars as a potential source.
![]() |
Figure 7:
The flattened spectra of the carbon-rich stars, compared
with the CH model
spectrum and with the ISO/SWS spectrum of TX Psc.
The CH line list is taken
from Jørgensen et al. (1996). The relative
intensities of the CH lines in the
model are not always comparable to
the observed ones, especially around 3.5
and 3.8 ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 8:
The spectrum of SMC-S2, and smoothed spectrum to 1/10th of the
original wavelength resolution.
The 3.3 ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 9: The HCN equivalent widths of EW3.5. The symbols show the host galaxies of the samples. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 10: The C2H2 equivalent widths of EW3.8. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 11: The HCN and C2H2 equivalent widths of EW3.1. |
Open with DEXTER |
We measured the EWs of the three main molecular bands of carbon-rich stars. The parameters used to measure the EW are summarized in Table 2. The EWs are plotted against infrared colour in Figs. 9-11, where the infrared colour H-K is used as a measure for the effective temperature. The circumstellar excess also affects this colour for redder carbon-rich stars.
For comparison with Galactic stars, we reduced ISO/SWS spectra of carbon stars in the solar neighbourhood, and also used the reduced ISO/SWS spectra of Sloan et al. (2003). The infrared colours for the Galactic stars were taken from the literature (Table 4).
As seen in the spectra, the 3.5 m EW is almost negligible in
extra-galactic AGB stars, in contrast to the nearby AGB stars which
have EWs up to 12 Å. Only a few LMC stars show EW3.5 larger than
5 Å, but in those LMC stars that show the band,
this molecular band is as strong as in the
Galactic stars. There is a clear tendency for the EW to decrease with
increasing H-K, but there is also a group of
stars at blue H-K
colour with very weak HCN bands.
T Dra, V CrB and V460 Cyg were observed with ISO/SWS at several phases. We find evidence for a large time variation in the HCN EW3.5; e.g., V CrB shows variation from 2-10 Å.
The 3.8 m
EW, which probably measures the C2H2 abundance, is high
in red carbon
stars (H-K>1.2), as shown in Fig. 10. This
holds true for
both the LMC stars and the single SMC star. The SgrD stars do
not show the
band but this is consistent with their blue colour.
Among the Galactic
stars, only a few objects show a 3.8
m
C2H2 band.
The
3.1 m band is a mix of HCN and C2H2 bands. EW3.1 is
large in
the spectra of the extra-galactic, red carbon stars. The
weakness of the
3.5
m band in extra-galactic AGB stars suggests
a lower contribution
from HCN in extra-galactic stars than in galactic
stars: the 3.1
m
band of the extra-galactic stars may have a
larger contribution of
C2H2 than Galactic stars.
Both EW3.5 and EW3.8 decrease towards redder infrared colours; EW3.1 increases until H-K=1.2, and then EW3.1begins to decreases. This colour corresponds roughly to the tip of the AGB colour sequence: redder stars are affected by circumstellar extinction and/or dust emission. The decline towards red colours suggests that circumstellar emission fills in the absorption features.
Table 4: Equivalent widths of molecules found in carbon-rich stars. Date ( ddmmyy) shows the observing date of ISAAC or ISO/SWS, which is different from that of photometric observations.
The SiO bonding energy is one of the highest (after CO) amongst the major photospheric molecules. It is therefore not surprising that SiO bands are commonly detected in late-type stars in our Galaxy, including post-AGB stars (Käufl & Stangellini 1992) and S-type stars (Wallace & Hinkle 2002). However, we only found one possible detection of SiO bands among 6 LMC oxygen-rich stars (three of them are M-type supergiants). This difference needs to be explained.
The LMC oxygen-rich stars are very luminous (van Loon 2000), and three of our targets are supergiants. Possibly they are more luminous than the Galactic comparison stars. However, the luminosity class does not affect the EW of the SiO bands, as shown by Wallace & Hinkle (2002) and Heras et al. (2002).
The abundance of SiO is determined by the least abundant
component which will generally be silicon.
As an -element silicon is not synthesised in AGB stars
and its abundance is determined by the composition of the
progenitor star at its formation.
The major
effect on SiO abundance should be the Si elemental
abundance. The SiO
abundance is limited by the least abundant
component, Si. Silicon is an
-element, not
synthesized in AGB stars; the Si abundance
reflects the one at the
time the progenitor star was formed. In
supergiants, Si is
formed but only in the last stage of their evolution.
The current Si
abundance in the LMC can be measured from H II regions
or from
hot stars. The solar abundance is
(Anders & Grevesse 1989).
LMC H II regions show
(Russell & Dopita 1992), and
main sequence B-type stars have 6.7
(Garnett 1999). For
planetary nebulae Dopita et al. (1997) found
:
the
large difference may reflect the range in
progenitor ages. Here, we
use
for the LMC late-type
stars, taken from an
average over the planetary nebulae
(PNe).
Aringer et al. (1997) calculated the EW of SiO bands in M-type
giants
using a hydrostatic model.
is sensitive to both the
effective
temperature and silicon abundance. Aringer et al. (1999) measured the
SiO
EW of Galactic stars, finding values ranging from 0-50
Å.
Extrapolating this linearly to the LMC metallicity yields
of
0-30 Å (Fig. 12). The low Si elemental
abundance
could be the major cause of the lower
observed in the
LMC.
![]() |
Figure 12: The equivalent width of SiO bands as a function of metallicity. The model is from Aringer et al. (1997), and Galactic data are from Aringer et al. (1999). |
Open with DEXTER |
Our
measured
limits for three stars are at the lower range of
the
extrapolation from Aringer et al. (1997,1999). Galactic stars
show a
spread in
;
for the LMC stars we can also expect a few
very low values.
The low upper limits can be interpreted as
evidence that the Si abundance
among LMC oxygen-rich stars is lower
than the assumed value of 7.0.
However, two other possible reasons
should be considered.
First, for
Galactic stars Aringer et al. (1999) reported that observed
are lower than
their model predictions, with Mira variables
showing weaker bands than
semi-regular variables. Tsuji et al. (1994),
who observed M-giants and
supergiants, suggest that the strong
pulsations extend the atmosphere above
the photosphere. Molecular
bands in this extended atmosphere may fill in
their photospheric
counterparts. In extreme cases, the SiO bands could be
in emission
during the maximum phase of the variability (Yamamura et al. 1999),
when
the radius of the extended atmosphere is largest
(Matsuura et al. 2002a).
At least two of the LMC targets
are Mira variables (Whitelock et al. 2003). We may have observed the
stars
during the phase of the pulsation cycle when the SiO bands are
weak.
For two stars, for instance, we know the approximate phase at the time of
observation:
they were observed near maximum phase, when SiO bands could
be weak.
The
second possible explanation is that dust emission suppresses the
SiO
equivalent width. Among our Galactic sample, red stars (VY Sgr
and
VY CMa) with
H-K > 0.7 mag do not show any trace of SiO
bands. In
our LMC sample, two stars have comparably high values in H-Kand could be affected by dust emission.
Therefore, we suggest that the dust
filling could decrease
the
.
We also investigated the effect of higher C/O abundance for LMC
stars, as dredge-up of newly produced carbon (3 dredge-up)
has a larger effect for low metallicity stars (see next section) and
would reduce the free oxygen after the initial formation of
CO. However,
less oxygen has little or no effect on the SiO abundance
because the Si
abundance still limits the SiO formation. Only for C/O
very near to unity
(i.e. for S or SC stars) some effect may be expected
(Zijlstra et al. 2004).
In
conclusion, within our limited sample, we did not detect SiO bands at
all.
The model predicts that low Si abundance results in the low SiO
abundance,
and our observations do not conflict with this trend. The
measured
in
the LMC is even lower than the expected range of
.
Although several
explanations, such as pulsations and dust filling,
can be given for the
lower
than expected in the LMC, the
issue is not settled. The solution
awaits observation of a larger number of stars
with complete coverage in
colour both in our Galaxy and in the
LMC.
The 3.8 m C2H2 band is found in only a few ISO/SWS
spectra
of Galactic carbon-rich stars: V Cyg and HD 192443
(Matsuura et al. 2002b; Vandenbussche et al. 2002). On the other hand, almost
all
red LMC or SMC carbon stars show this band in their spectra.
The
measured EW3.8 is clearly larger among red carbon stars in the
LMC,
compared to the galactic stars. One SMC star measured in this work
also
follows this trend.
The likely explanation for the stronger 3.8 m band is that the
LMC and SMC stars have a higher C/O ratio (Paper I). If all the
elemental abundances simply scale with the metallicity, the C2H2abundance should be less because fewer carbon atoms are available. The
C/O ratio of the star, initially less than unity, increases during the
third dredge-up on the thermal-pulsing AGB. A fixed amount of carbon
injected into the envelope has a larger effect for a low metallicity,
leading to a higher C/O ratio (Mouhcine & Lançon 2003; Lattanzio & Wood 2003).
Additionally, the third dredge-up operates more efficiently at lower
metallicity (Vassiliadis & Wood 1993), adding larger quantities of carbon.
Both effects predict a systematically higher C/O ratio in the LMC and the SMC.
In stars with
almost all the oxygen
is tied up in CO, and the excess carbon will be available for forming
carbon-bearing molecules.
A higher C/O ratio at low metallicity is
supported by the fact that
the ratio of numbers of carbon-rich stars over
oxygen-rich stars
(
)
increases with decreasing
metallicity of the
host galaxy (Groenewegen 1999). Further confirmation
comes from
LMC and SMC planetary nebulae, which show a higher C/O
ratio
compared to Galactic PNe (Leisy & Dennefeld 1996). PNe show the final
AGB
abundances after the last dredge-up event.
Cohen et al. (1981) found that the J-K colour is redder in LMC carbon stars than in Galactic carbon stars. They suggested that the J-band magnitude in LMC stars is suppressed by deeper C2 absorption, and also mention a higher C/O as the likely cause. The stronger C2H2 absorption is consistent with this.
A
chemical equilibrium model (Fig. 13) shows
increase of
the C2H2 fractional abundance as function of the C/O
ratio. Details of the model are given in Markwick (2000).
Chemical equilibrium is a reasonable assumption
for the stellar photosphere but could be questioned
for the lower density atmosphere. We assume a typical C/O ratio for
Galactic carbon stars of 1.2 (Lambert et al. 1986; Ohnaka et al. 2000).
To obtain a higher
C2H2 fractional abundance for the LMC stars
requires
,
while
the SMC carbon-rich stars should have an even
higher value.
The mean C/O
ratio found in carbon-rich PNe in the LMC is 3.2 (Leisy & Dennefeld 1996, 8
samples)
or 2.8 (Dopita et al. 1997, 4 samples). AGB stars may
experience several more
third dredge-up events, giving a higher C/O
ratio in PNe than in AGB stars.
However, we cannot exclude such a
high C/O ratio in the LMC AGB stars. The
C2H2 abundance
increases only slowly for
(Fig. 13); the
relative increase in the number of free
carbon atoms (after CO
formation) is fastest for C/O close to unity.
In
Fig. 10, the EW of C2H2 increases sharply
at
,
and declines above 1.2. The initial increase is
caused
by a temperature effect. C2H2 is favoured at lower
temperatures: at
higher temperatures more of the carbon is in
diatomic molecules. The
temperature dependence of the various species
is shown in
Fig. 14. The decay at redder H-Kcolour is explained by
additional circumstellar emission.
We also detect CH bands in the
infrared spectra, for carbon-rich stars
in the LMC, the SMC, and SgrD. The
CH abundance depends on the C/O ratio: Aoki et al. (1998) found that SC-type
stars, which have C/O ratio
close to one, show only weak CH lines, while
N-type stars show clear CH
bands. Figure 13 shows that
CH increases
more slowly with C/O ratio than does C2H2, as expected
for its single
carbon atom. For a Galactic ratio of
,
the CH abundances in the
LMC and the Galaxy may become comparable but one would not
expect much
stronger bands in the LMC. The same argument holds for the SMC.
We
have not made a comparison in line strengths of the CH bands because
they
are blended with other molecular bands. However,
the fact that these bands
are seen in all stars including the Galactic
ones qualitatively supports the
suggestion that the CH band strength
is relatively independent of
metallicity.
In conclusion, a high C/O ratio affects the spectra of extra-galactic carbon-rich stars. The C/O ratio should be treated as an important parameter for spectral classification.
![]() |
Figure 13:
Abundance of molecules calculated with the chemical
model. The abundance
is normalized by H+H2 pressure. The left side is for
![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 14: Same as Fig.13, but as a function of temperature. The C/O ratio is 1.1 for both panels. |
Open with DEXTER |
In contrast to the C2H2 and possibly CH, the HCN lines are generally very weak in the extra-galactic stars. Lloyd Evans (1980) finds that optical carbon stars in the LMC show weak (optical) CN bands compared to C2. This argues against temperature as a factor, since C2 and CN show very similar temperature dependence (Fig. 14), as do (to a lesser extent) C2H2 and HCN. This leaves the nitrogen abundance as the most likely explanation.
Although the majority of extra-galactic carbon stars do
not show the
3.5 m HCN feature, a few LMC stars have EW3.5 >5 Å as high
as Galactic stars. There may be two discrete extra-galactic
groups:
HCN-rich and non-HCN. The C/N ratio should be different for
these
two groups.
The C/N ratio varies strongly over the course of the
star's evolution, mainly because of C production and CN cycling which
transmutes C into N. First dredge-up decreases carbon and increases
nitrogen, and lowers the C/N ratio by a factor of 2 or more. The largest
changes affect stars more massive than 2-3 .
Second
dredge-up, which only occurs in stars with
,
has a
similar effect, and alters the C/N ratio by a factor of
1.5.
Third dredge-up increases the carbon abundance by large factors but leaves
N relatively unaffected. The most massive AGB stars may suffer burning at
the bottom of the convective envelope, a process called hot bottom
burning which again cycles C into N. The cumulative changes in
the C/N ratios
are shown in Boothroyd & Sackman (1999).
The effect of the third dredge-up scenario can explain two distinct groups: low-metallicity stars without hot bottom burning (HBB; Iben 1981) will show low N, while stars with HBB show enhanced N. An example of an LMC star believed to have experienced HBB is IRAS 04496-6958, which is a high-luminosity silicate carbon star (Trams et al. 1999a).
The fact that 3 of our 8 LMC stars are HCN-rich suggests that the
lower mass limit for HBB cannot be much higher than the canonical
4 ,
since otherwise very few AGB stars would pass through
this phase. In PNe, nitrogen and carbon elemental abundance ratios
vary greatly between individual objects (Dopita et al. 1997), showing
the effect of the initial parameters on the enrichment history.
Our observations suggest that at low metallicities, carbon and oxygen-rich stars behave differently. Carbon stars show higher C/O ratios and more abundant carbon-bearing molecules (excluding CO) than their Galactic counterparts. Oxygen-rich stars show primarily low SiO abundances, as expected from the low metallicity. This difference can be expected to affect their dust formation, since C2H2 and SiO are the respective starting points for build-up towards either carbonaceous or silicate dust grains.
For oxygen-rich stars, silicate grains require Si, O and iron and/or magnesium. The low SiO abundance caused by the low metallicity suggests a lower silicate dust abundance. Iron or magnesium may also limit the amount of silicate dust.
For carbon stars, Groenewegen (1995) shows that the mass of amorphous carbon dust is about 10 times more than that of silicon carbide (SiC). Large molecules can build up from C2H2 (Woods et al. 2002) and can form a major component of carbonaceous dust, as shown by the large mass of carbon dust. The enhanced C/O ratio, giving a high abundance of C2H2, can allow for carbonaceous dust to form at a rate at least comparable to those of Galactic stars. In addition, if PAHs may be formed in AGB stars (but not excited), then more C2H2 can also lead to enhanced PAH abundances.
The dust
formation rate directly affects the mass-loss rate of the
star. Above a
metallicity of
,
the mass-loss process is
driven via radiation
pressure on the dust - the accelerated dust drags
the gas with it (Bowen & Willson 1991).
At low metallicities the amount of dust formed will be very small and mass
loss will be very inefficient.
This all suggests that while oxygen-rich stars will show low mass-loss
rates due to the reduced SiO, carbon stars should be able to reach
mass-loss rates similar to Galactic stars, which is consistent
with our (limited) knowledge of LMC stars. Carbon stars in the LMC reach
mass-loss rates of a few times
(van Loon 2000), similar to what is found in the Galaxy.
Oxygen-rich stars in the LMC reach higher mass-loss rates than
Galactic stars (van Loon 2000), but do so at a luminosity several
times higher than the LMC carbon stars. Direct comparison with
Galactic stars is hampered by uncertain distances to Galactic
stars and by the fact that the LMC measurements were made for stars
known to be surrounded by dust, so that the sample is already
biased towards high mass-loss rates.
If oxygen-rich stars show reduced mass-loss but carbon stars do not, this will affect the composition of the dust which subsequently enters the ISM. Even if oxygen-rich stars can still reach the mass-loss rates, but do so later in their evolution, this would still imply a shift in composition since the delay will allow more stars to reach the carbon star phase. The main sources of dust in a galaxy are supernovae (and their progenitors) and AGB stars, but the relative contribution of each is uncertain and will differ for silicate and carbonaceous dust. Reduced mass-loss of oxygen-rich AGB stars will cause a relative shift towards carbonaceous grains. The ISO observations of H II regions and molecular clouds show that PAH bands are ubiquitous in the LMC and the SMC (Vermeij et al. 2002; Reach et al. 2000), with a similar fraction to total dust as found in our Galaxy; the detailed composition of the PAHs may vary with more open PAHs found in the SMC. The fractional dust abundance in the SMC is 30 times lower than that of our Galaxy, but although this holds for both small and large grains (Bot et al. 2004), it is not known whether the fractions of carbonaceous and silicate dust differ. Our detection of a PAH band from an SMC post-AGB star shows that PAHs can form in a low-metallicity AGB wind.
Our main conclusions are:
Acknowledgements
We would like to thanks Dr. Y. Jung for helping with our data reduction. The ISO data archive and the 2MASS data archive provide useful data for this study. Simbad data base is used for this research. M.M. is supported by a PPARC Rolling grant.