A&A 425, 151-162 (2004)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20040542
R. Gredel
Max-Planck Institut für Astronomie (MPIA), Königstuhl 17, 69117 Heidelberg, Germany
Received 29 March 2004 / Accepted 10 June 2004
Abstract
An analysis of optical echelle spectra towards nine stars in the
Cep OB4 association is presented. Interstellar absorption lines
which arise in the (1, 0) and (2, 0) bands of the CN A
- X
red
system towards BD+66
1661, BD+66
1674, and BD+66
1675
are used to infer accurate CN column densities N(CN). A comparison
with earlier measurements in the CN violet system allows to infer
a CN Doppler b parameter of b(CN
) = 1.2-2.4 km s-1.
Molecular carbon absorption lines which
arise in the (1, 0), (2, 0) and (3, 0) bands of the C2Ã
- X
Phillips
system is used to infer gaskinetic temperatures of
K and
densities of
cm-3 towards
BD+66
1661 and BD+66
1675, and a temperature of
K and a density of
cm-3 towards BD+66
1674.
The R(1) line of the (0, 0) band of the CH A
system is detected towards 6 stars. A tight
correlation exists between N(C2) and N(CH). N(CN)
increases with N(CH) and with N(C2).
Interstellar CH+ is marginally detected towards
four stars. Inferred CH+ column densities are significantly
lower than towards other lines of sight with similar reddening.
The velocity structure towards Cep OB4 and the chemical abundances
suggest that CN, C2, CH, and CH+ are formed
in quiescent material. A previous suggestion that the molecules
form in a photon-dominated region close to the stars is not supported
by the observations.
Key words: ISM: abundances - ISM: clouds - ISM: molecules - ISM: lines and bands
The previous observations suggest that a HII-H2 interaction region is located towards Cep OB4 and that it may be studied by traditional optical absorption line techniques. We have thus decided to perform a more comprehensive search of interstellar molecular absorption lines towards the Cep OB4 association. High signal-to-noise spectra towards nine stars in Cep OB4 were obtained using the echelle spectrograph at the Calar Alto 2.2 m telescope. The main aim here was to search for interstellar absorption lines of CN, C2, CH, and CH+ in the spectra of the background stars. In general, observations of these molecules allow to infer physical parameters such as gaskinetic temperatures, densities, Doppler-b values, and accurate molecular column densities. The observations are described in Sect. 2. An analysis of the results is given in Sect. 3, with an emphasis of the rotational excitation of CN and of C2given in Sects. 3.2 and 3.3, respectively. The velocity structure of the region is discussed in Sect. 4.1. The inferred molecular abundances are compared with the expectations from models of photon-dominated regions (PDRs) and of quiescent translucent clouds in Sect. 4.3. A summary of the findings is given in Sect. 5.
Optical spectra of stars in the Cep OB4 association
were obtained with the Calar Alto 2.2 m telescope using the fibre-fed echelle spectrograph FOCES.
The instrument is described by Pfeiffer et al. (1998). FOCES was
used with a 180 m entrance slit and a 15
m
pixel LORAL detector. This setup provided an actual 2 pixel resolution
of
as judged from the
width of the thorium lines. The large format detector allows
to record the full optical spectrum from 3500-11 000
in a single exposure.
The observations were carried out during
September 1999, September 2001, and January 2002. Observations in September 2001 and
January 2002 were affected by poor weather. In Table 1, the observed stars,
their spectral type, the visual magnitude V, the reddening EB-V,
the dates of the observations, and the total integration times
are listed. With the exception of BD+66
1973, the stars listed in
Table 1 all have similar Hipparcos parallaxes and proper motions
(de Zeeuw et al. 1999). The corresponding distances of 800-1000 pc
are consistent with the earlier determined distance of 850 pc derived by
MacConnell (1968). The star BD+66
1973 has been discarded as a member
of the Cep OB4 association on the basis of its Hipparcos proper motion
and parallax (de Zeeuw et al. 1999).
Table 1: Observed stars and properties.
The data were reduced within the MIDAS echelle context.
From the raw data frames, the background, which includes
the bias and the scattered light
level, was determined from a two-dimensional fit to the
inter-order regions. Flat-field
corrections were achieved using integrations on an internal
halogen lamp. The design of FOCES is such that the optical
path of the light from the halogen lamp coincides very
well with that of the stars, so very accurate
flat-field corrections can be obtained using
internal lamps (Grupp 2003).
The location of the orders in the raw data files were
determined using a Hough transformation. Individual orders
were extracted using a 4-pixel slit.
The spectra were rebinned to a linear,
heliocentric wavelength scale using Th-Ar reference frames.
Barycentric corrections were calculated within MIDAS.
In the limit of unsaturated lines (Doppler parameters
), the measured equivalent widths
are converted into column densities
using
,
where
and wavelengths
are in units of
and
is in units of cm-2, and where fJ'J'' are the line oscillator strengths.
Generally, optical absorption line studies of interstellar
CN focus the (0, 0) band of the CN B
- X
violet system, around 3875
.
This is because the absorption lines in the violet system
are strong and the corresponding spectral region
is not contaminated by telluric absorption lines.
For the heavily reddened stars observed here, the
signal-to-noise ratio below 4000
is too
low to infer reliable equivalent widths.
We thus proceed to analyse absorption lines which arise in the (1, 0) and (2, 0) bands of the CN A
- X
red system, at wavelengths
around 9150
and 7900
,
respectively.
CN lines in the (3, 0) band of the red system, around 6950
,
are not detected in our spectra. The band oscillator strengths
of the CN red system are almost an order of magnitude lower than those of
the CN violet system, which allows in general a more accurate determination
of column densities as saturation effects are less pronounced
(e.g. Gredel et al. 1991). This
advantage is somewhat impaired, however, by the fact that the absorption lines
appear in spectral regions which are heavily contaminated by telluric
absorption lines.
![]() |
Figure 1:
Normalised spectra of interstellar CN lines of the (1, 0) and (2, 0) bands
of the A ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
Table 2: Measured CN lines.
Figure 1 contains the spectra of three stars where absorption
lines in the CN red system are detected. For each of the three
stars BD+66 1675, BD+66
1674, and BD+66
1661, the spectral regions
around 7875
,
7906
,
and 9185
,
are shown. Detected
CN lines are marked by filled triangles. The detected lines all
arise from the J''=0 level. Open triangles indicate the
expected position of absorption lines which arise from the J''=1 level. CN absorption lines which arise from J''+1are not detected in any of the spectra obtained here.
All spectra are rebinned to heliocentric wavelength scales
which causes shifts in the position of the telluric features
from one star to the other. Figure 1 also contains, at the top,
spectra towards 16 Tau, which do not contain CN absorption lines.
The comparison spectra of 16 Tau may serve to better illustrate the presence
of CN absorption lines in the spectra of the other three stars.
A comprehensive discussion of the analysis of CN absorption lines
which arise in the red system is given in Gredel et al. (1991).
We use their listed wavelengths and band oscillator strengths to
infer heliocentric velocities and column densities N(0) in
rotational level J''=0. We assume that saturation effects are
negligible for the absorption lines detected in the CN red system.
A summary of the measurements is given in Table 2,
which contains, in Cols. 1-5, the line identifications, the
heliocentric wavelengths
,
the measured equivalent widths
,
the inferred heliocentric
velocities
,
and the column densities N(0) in units of 1012 cm-2. Measurement uncertainties in
and corresponding uncertainties in N(0) are given in
parentheses.
Towards BD+66 1661, the
(2, 0) R1(0) line near 7906
is rather broad and may be
decomposed into two velocity components near
= -22 km s-1 and -29 km s-1, but the Gaussian fit is not unique. Toward BD+66
1675, both the (2, 0) R1(0) and (2, 0) RQ21(0) lines, near 7906
and 7874
,
respectively, are decomposed into
three absorption components near -22.5 km s-1, -16.5 km s-1, and -9.3 km s-1, but again, the fit is not unique.
The (1, 0) R1(0) towards BD+66
1675 is blended
with a telluric absorption line, and the listed velocity of -0.4 km s-1 may not be accurate. Towards BD+66
1673, the (1, 0) R1(0) line
is blended with a telluric absorption line and the listed equivalent
width is highly uncertain. The latter two measurements are ignored in the
discussion of Sect. 4.
![]() |
Figure 2:
Normalised spectra of the
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
Towards most of the stars of the present sample,
strong interstellar absorption lines of CH which arise from the
-doublet of the (0, 0) band of the
A
system are detected. The corresponding spectra are
reproduced in Fig. 2. The star BD+66
1669 is a visual double
star and the spectra towards both components are shown.
The CH absorption lines towards the stars are all unresolved, but the spectra
indicate the presence of multiple velocity components.
This is for instance seen towards BD+66
1598 and BD+66
1661,
where red wings appear in the CH line profile. A robust decomposition into
individual Gaussians is not possible. A decomposition of the
CH line profile toward BD+66
1675 into the three velocity components
seen in CN (cf. Sect. 2.1) is possible, but it is not unique.
In the major part of the discussion below, we use integrated equivalent widths
and centroid wavelengths only.
Table 3: Measured CH and CH+ lines.
![]() |
Figure 3:
Normalised spectra of the CH+ R(0) line of the (0, 0) band of the A![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The measured equivalent widths are rather large, which makes the derived
column densities uncertain because of possible saturation
effects. The level of saturation can be determined
from a comparison with absorption lines which arise
in the CH B
system, which have oscillator strengths
about a factor of two lower. Absorption lines of the B-X system are, however,
not detected in our spectra. We proceed and adopt a value of b(CH) = 1 km s-1 to
estimate the magnitude of saturation effects. Very high spectral resolution
observations of Andersson et al. (2002) and Crawford (1995), among others,
show that Doppler values around
km s-1 are very typical indeed for
individual velocity components of CH.
The curve of growth analysis used to infer column densities
is described in Gredel et al. (1993). In the
analysis, the
-doubling of the absorption line is
treated explicitly, adopting wavelengths of 4300.3030
and 4300.3235
for the two components. A band oscillator strength of
f00 = 0.00506 is used to infer column densities.
Columns 2-5 of Table 3 list
the heliocentric wavelengths, the equivalent widths, the inferred
heliocentric velocities, and the CH column densities
.
Measurement uncertainties in
and corresponding uncertainties in
are given in parentheses. Column 6 of Table 3 gives column
densities for CH inferred in the limit of b = 1 km s-1.
The uncertainties in Nb=1
correspond to the measurement uncertainties of
.
Towards BD+66
1669a, BD+66
1674, and BD+66
1675, inferred
column densities for b = 1 km s-1 are very large indeed. For the
latter three stars, the tabulated column densities
given in brackets correspond to equivalent widths of 60-65 m
.
Upper limits in N(CH) which are allowed by the
measurement uncertainties are well above 1015 cm-2.
Table 3 also lists, in Col. 7, CH column densities
Nb=2.4 inferred for a Doppler parameter of b = 2.4 km s-1.
The particular value of b = 2.4 km s-1 is justified in Sect. 3.1.
The large range in column densities obtained for
,
b = 2.4 km s-1, and b = 1 km s-1 demonstrate that the largest uncertainties
in the CH column densities arise from the uncertainties in b, and not from the
measurement uncertainties in
.
In the discussion of Sect. 4,
we use Nb=2.4 as final CH column densities, and assign uncertainties
which reflect the range in column densities from
to Nb=1.
CH+ absorption lines which arise in the R(0) line of
the (0, 0) band of the A
system,
near 4232
,
are marginally detected towards four stars.
The corresponding spectra are shown in Fig. 3.
In the calculation of column densities and heliocentric velocities,
rest wavelengths of 4232.548
and band oscillator
strength of
f00 = 0.00545 are used (Gredel et al. 1993).
CH+ column densities are calculated
in the limit of
and for b=1 km s-1.
The CH+ data are included in Table 3. The detected
CH+ absorption lines are rather faint and the CH+ column densities
are not sensitive to Doppler parameters b > 1 km s-1.
The R(1) and Q(1) lines near 4229
and 4237
,
respectively,
are not detected.
The spectra towards BD+66 1661, BD+66
1674, and BD+66
1675 show prominent C2ãbsorption lines which arise in the (2, 0) band of the A
- X
Phillips system,
at wavelengths around 8765
.
The corresponding spectra are shown
in Fig. 4. Towards BD+66
1661, the detected C2lines
are explicity identified. Towards all three stars, additional
C2ãbsorption lines which arise in the (1, 0) and (3, 0) bands,
around wavelengths of 10 150
and 7720
,
respectively,
are detected as well.
A few C2ãbsorption lines in the (2, 0) band are present towards the
star BD+66
1673. A summary of the C2measurements is given
in Table 4, with heliocentric wavelengths, measured equivalent
widths, heliocentric velocities, and column densities N(J'') listed
in Cols. 2-5, respectively. Column 6 of Table 4 lists the
average column densities
in J''
in cases where multiple measurements are available.
Rest wavelengths and band oscillator
strengths are adopted from Bakker et al. (1997).
![]() |
Figure 4:
Absorption lines which arise from the (2, 0) band
of the C2Ã
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The reported equivalent width of
= 80 m
for the (
R1(0) +RQ21(0)) absorption line blend of the (0, 0) band of the
CN violet system by Münch (1964) can be used to infer the
CN Doppler parameter b(CN). If saturation is
negligible, the column density in J''=0 inferred
from the measurement of Münch (1964) is
cm-2.
Our measurements yield an average value of
cm-2. We thus
perform a curve of growth analysis in order to determine
an effective Doppler b parameter for CN which brings the
two results for N(0) into agreement. If the CN absorption arises
in a single velocity component, a value of b(CN)=2.4 km s-1
increases the column density inferred from the CN violet
system to our value of
cm-2.
If we assume that the CN absorption arises in three velocity
components with velocity separations of some 5 km s-1 and 7 km s-1
from the central line at its average velocity of
= -16.5 km s-1
(cf. Table 2), a CN Doppler parameter
of
b = 1.2-1.3 km s-1 for each velocity component is obtained.
We note that the photographic measurements of Münch (1964)
seem to underestimate the equivalent widths of the absorption
lines (see Sect. 4.2). If so, the CN Doppler parameters
inferred from the present analysis would increase.
As discussed in detail by Black & van Dishoeck (1991), the rotational
excitation of CN is dominated by radiative interactions with the
cosmic background radiation, neutral collisions, and electron impact
excitations. Thus, the determination of accurate column densities in
the rotational levels J''>1 allows to gain insight into
physical parameters such as total hydrogen and electron densities.
Münch (1964) did report the presence
of CN absorption lines from rotational levels up to J''=3 towards
BD+66 1675. In the spectra shown obtained here, CN absorption lines
which arise from rotational levels
are absent.
The expected position of the R2(1
) + RQ21(1) blend,
the R1(1) line, the QR12(1) + Q1(1) blend
in the (2, 0) band, at heliocentric wavelengths around 7873.4
,
7903.3
and 7908.3
,
respectively,
and the (1, 0) R1(1) line near 9183
,
are indicated in Fig. 1 by open triangles.
Column densities in N(1) inferred from upper limits of
m
of the corresponding lines
can be used to infer upper
limits of the CN rotational excitation temperature T10.
We use
and obtain
T10 < 3 K. We proceed to calculate total CN column
densities
using average
values of N(0) from the measurements and theoretical column densities N(1) and N(2) derived from an excitation temperature of
T10
= 2.8 K. Total CN column densities obtained this way
are given in Table 5.
Table 4: Measured C2 lines.
The analysis of interstellar absorption lines of
C2ãllow to infer physical parameters in the clouds where the molecules form.
The method developed by van Dishoeck & Black (1982)
is routinely adopted to infer gaskinetic temperatures
and densities in homogeneous translucent
molecular clouds (e.g. Gredel et al. 2001, and
references therein). The method benefits from the fact
that in translucent clouds, in general, the population density in
the lowest rotational levels is dominated by collisions,
and thus thermalised, while the population density
in the higher rotational levels may deviate from a
thermal distribution because of radiative pumping.
The deviations from a thermal population distribution
among the higher rotational levels allow to determine
the ratio
,
where
is the density of
the collision partners (
H) + n(H2)) and I is the scaling factor of the interstellar radiation field.
![]() |
Figure 5:
C2excitation diagrams towards BD+66![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
Figure 5 contains the C2 excitation diagrams
constructed for the three stars BD+66 1661, BD+66
1674, and BD+66
1675,
with values of
plotted versus excitation energies E(J'') of rotational levels J''. In the three diagrams, data points inferred from (2, 0) band observations are represented by open triangles, while
open squares and open pentagons refer to data obtained from (3, 0) and (1, 0) band measurements, respectively. In cases
where various determinations of N(J'') are available for
a given J'', arithmetic means are plotted and are
represented by filled squares.
In the excitation diagram of BD+66 1661,
the theoretical C2 population distributions
obtained for
= 35 K and parameters
cm-3
and 450 cm-3 are represented by full lines. The dashed line
corresponds to a thermal population distribution at
= 35 K. The parameter range of
cm-3 does provide a good fit to the observations. From the theoretical
models, total C2population densities
are obtained, where the summation is carried
out over rotational levels in the vibrational state v''=0.
For
= 35 K and
cm-3,
,
and for
cm-3,
.
The full lines in the excitation diagram
of BD+66 1674 correspond to nonthermal population distributions
characterised by
= 60 K and values of
,
300, 400, and 600 cm-3. The dashed lines corresponds to a thermal distribution
at
= 60 K. The measurements are consistent with densities
in the range of
cm-3. Corresponding total C2densities are
for
cm-3 and
for
cm-3.
A more rigorous constraint of the densities
requires the measurement of population densities in rotational
levels J''> 10 which is not available.
Note that the inferred population density in J''=0 towards
BD+66
1674 is too low if compared to N(2) or N(4).
The cause for the weakness of the R(0) line remains unclear
after a re-analysis of the data,
but it does not have a physical origin.
The full lines in the excitation diagram towards BD+66 1675
characterise nonthermal population distributions
obtained for
cm-3 and 450 cm-3 and
= 35 K. The corresponding
thermal distribution at
= 35 K is indicated by the dashed line.
The observed population distribution is well delimited by
this parameter range.
Towards the three stars, the C2 data indicate relatively
low gaskinetic temperatures in the 35-60 K range, and
parameters of
cm-3. Uncertainties in the derived
gaskinetic temperatures are of the order of 10 K. It is argued in
Sect. 4 that the molecular gas seen in absorption
towards Cep OB4 is probably not located in the vicinity of the stars.
We thus adopt a scaling factor of the interstellar radiation
field not larger than I=1. In
the presence of pure molecular gas, the C2ãnalysis indicates
total hydrogen densities n = n(H) + 2n(H2)
of
cm-3 toward BD+66
1661,
cm-3 toward BD+66
1674, and
cm-3 toward
BD+66
1675. The corresponding total C2
densities are
cm-2
toward BD+66
1661,
cm-2
toward BD+66
1674, and
cm-2
toward BD+66
1675.
The uncertainties correspond to the range in
which is derived from the excitation diagrams of Fig. 5.
The few C2towards BD+66 1673 do not allow to
construct a useful C2diagram.
The scatter in the inferred rotational population distributions
is too large to infer a robust temperature or density estimate.
In their analysis of C2 observations towards Cyg OB2 No. 12,
Cecchi-Pestellini & Dalgarno (2002) showed that the average excitation temperatures which
are obtained from the assumption of a homogeneous cloud
can also be obtained from a two-component cloud model where
dense clumps are embedded into a lower-density gas with filling
factors of 0.1-0.2. In particular, they showed that C2 is not sensitive to small-scale density fluctuations. In their
model, Cecchi-Pestellini & Dalgarno (2002) showed that the observed C2distribution towards Cyg OB2 No. 12 is well fitted
by a two-phase model where dense cores of
cm-3
are embedded into a low-density medium.
The standard analysis in terms of a single, homogeneous cloud
results in
= 35 K and
cm-3
(Gredel et al. 2001). The concept of single translucent clouds
towards heavily reddened lines of sight has been questioned
altogether by Rachford et al. (2002). In their analysis of FUSE data towards stars with visual reddening up to
mag, the authors found little evidence for
the presence of individual translucent clouds towards the
sightlines studied, and concluded that their data is better described
in terms of the presence of several diffuse clouds along the line of sight.
The physical parameters inferred from the present C2
should thus be used with care.
Table 5: Summary of observations.
The results of the analysis described in the previous section are
summarised in Table 5. For C2, Cols. 2-5 list the inferred gaskinetic temperatures
,
gas densities n,
total observed column densities
,
and total theoretical column densities
obtained from the best fit non-thermal models.
Columns 6 and 7 list average CN observed column densities N(0)
and total column densities assuming
an excitation temperature of 2.8 K. Columns 8 and 9 list CH and CH+ column densities. Average radial velocities
of C2, CN, CH, and CH+ are given in Cols. 10-13,
respectively. The CH measurements towards
BD+67
1585 and BD+66
1669a,b are given in Table 3
and are not repeated in Table 5.
In general, the radial velocities of CH, CH+, C2, and CN agree
very well with each other. Velocity uncertainties
for individual velocity determinations are of the order of 1-1.5 km s-1.
A mean radial LSR velocity of
= -14.5 km s-1 has been
obtained by Liu et al. (1989) for Berkeley 59, the central star cluster of Cep OB4.
The authors assign the rather large velocity uncertainty of 8 km s-1 because two out of the three stars of their sample, BD+66
1674
and BD+66
1675, are spectroscopic binaries, and the third star,
BD+66
9487, has but one measurement.
From their observations of the large-scale structure of the
neutral gas, Rossano et al. (1983) found three individual velocity components
of H2CO at LSR velocities of -13.2, -7.1, and -1 km s-1.
The -13 km s-1 cloud spreads in velocity from -11.8 to -15.1 km s-1.
Emission in H110
appears near velocities of
= -14.3,
-9.0, and +1.2 km s-1. Millimeter emission of 13CO was observed by Liu et al. (1988), who found a strong emission component at
= -14.4 km s-1
and two weaker components near
= -7.0 km s-1 and -0.4 km s-1.
The two "clouds'' which correspond to the velocity components
at -14.4 km s-1 and -7.0 km s-1, respectively,
are diametrically opposed to Berkeley 59, which
led Liu et al. (1988) to speculate that they
are the fossil remnants of a bi-polar outflow (cf. their
Fig. 6). The physical connection of the two velocity components
was however questioned by Yang & Fukui (1992),
who assigned the component near -7 km s-1
to foreground molecular gas. CO emission around -7 km s-1
is seen over some 100 square degrees and shows a good coincidence
with weak extinction features on the POSS plates.
The gas seen at -14.4 km s-1 arises
from two dense molecular clumps denoted C1 and C2, and Yang & Fukui (1992)
concluded that both clumps are in physical contact with the
HII region formed by Berkeley 59.
Towards BD+66 1674 and BD+66
1675, which are both members of Berkeley 59,
the molecular absorption
lines observed here appear at a mean heliocentric velocity of
= -18.35 km s-1, which corresponds to
= -9 km s-1.
The LSR velocities of the foreground gas seen in emission ranges from -7 km s-1 to -10 km s-1 (cf. Fig. 3 of Yang & Fukui 1992). The
agreement in radial velocities suggests that the gas seen in absorption
is spatially coexistent with this gas component. Based on its kinematics,
it is thus unlikely that the bulk of the CN, C2, CH, and CH+ absorption arises in the PDR which is located at LSR velocities of -14 km s-1.
The possibility exists, however, than a minor fraction of the CN absorption
arises in the HII-H2 interaction region near Berkeley 59.
In Sect. 2.1 a very uncertain decomposition
of the CN absorption line towards BD+66
1675 into three velocity components
has been described. The corresponding LSR velocities are
= -13.2, -7, and 0 km s-1. The component near -13.2 km s-1 holds
about 25% of the total equivalent width.
It can thus not be ruled out that a minor
fraction of the gas seen in absorption towards BD+66
1675
arises in molecular material close to the star, although the evidence
is rather poor.
The measurements reported here agree in general with the earlier
data towards Cep OB4.
The heliocentric velocity
= -18.8 km s-1 for CN towards
BD+66
1675 inferred by Münch (1964) is consistent with our
value of
= -16.1 km s-1. Towards BD+66$^$1674, both
Münch (1964) and the present study report a mean CN heliocentric
velocity of
= -16.8 km s-1.
Somewhat discrepant are the CN velocities towards BD+66
1661, where
our value of -23.3 km s-1 contrasts the value of -17.7 km s-1
of Münch (1964).
The detection of diatomic carbon towards BD+66
1675 has been
reported by Lutz & Crutcher (1983). While the assignation of
C2 absorption features in their spectrum requires some
courage, their measurements indicate a C2 column density
of
cm-2 when
scaled to the f1, 0 oscillator strength used here,
while we find
cm-3.
The reported equivalent width
of
m
for the (1, 0) Q(2) line is close to
our value of
m
.
The inferred temperature of
K for the C2 rotational
excitation of Lutz & Crutcher (1983) is consistent with our value of
=
K.
Towards BD+66
1675, the medium-resolution MMT observations of van Dishoeck & Black (1989)
indicate the presence of a double-component CH absorption profile with
a total CH column density of N(CH
cm-2. Their measured equivalent with of
=
m
is in good agreement with our value of
m
.
In his work, Münch (1964) cites a value of about
= 40 m
for
the CH absorption line towards BD+66
1675, which is significantly lower than the
equivalent widths inferred
with electronic detectors. The discrepancy may indicate that the use of photographic
plates led to an underestimation of the equivalent widths of the absorption
lines towards Cep OB4.
![]() |
Figure 6: a)-d): Molecular column densities of CH+ CH, C2, and CN, in units of 1013 cm-2, plotted versus reddening EB-V (in magnitudes). e)-f) Molecular column densities of CH+, CN, and C2 plotted versus molecular column density of CH, in units of 1013 cm-2. h) Column density of CN plotted versus column density of C2, both in units of 1013 cm-2. |
Open with DEXTER |
Figures 6a-d contain plots of the observed column densities of CH+, CH, C2, and CN versus the reddening EB-V of the background star. None of the column densities are correlated with the reddening. In quiescent, translucent clouds, the CH column density is in general tightly correlated with EB-V (cf. Liszt & Lucas 2002, and references therein), and there are indications that in general, the column densities of CN, C2, and CH+ increase with with EB-V as well (e.g. Federman et al. 1994; Gredel 1997). The absence of correlations of molecular column densities with the reddening of the background stars may indicate that the lines of sight towards Cep OB4 trace large amounts of dust associated with low density, atomic material. It may also indicate that the molecular abundances peak in a thin layer of the cloud, in which case the total molecular column densities are unrelated with the total optical depth of the cloud. For diatomic molecules such as CH, CH+ and CN, this behaviour is expected in photon dominated regions. Photon-dominated regions or PDRs form when molecular material is illuminated by a strong radiation field from nearby stars. The chemistry and physical characteristics of dense PDRs have been reviewed by Hollenbach & Tielens (1997). The chemistry of dense PDRs differs from that of dense molecular clouds in various ways. At the surface of PDRs, large abundances of molecules which have main formation routes via photoreactions are expected because of the strong ultraviolet radiation field which is present up to optical depths of a few. The UV photons maintain a large fraction of atomic hydrogen in the HII-H2 transition layer, thus reactions which involve atomic hydrogen are important as well.
The millimeter emission line observations of Yang & Fukui (1992)
have resulted in the detection of two dense molecular clumps with a total mass
of 600
near Berkeley 59, and the authors suggested that the star cluster
generates an ionisation front on the surface of the clumps.
If the dense clumps are located in the foreground of the star cluster, the
interstellar molecular absorption lines studied here may very well arise in
in the outer layers of a PDR.
In their comprehensive chemical model of a dense PDR, Sternberg & Dalgarno (1995) showed
that the CN abundances peak at the relatively low optical depths of about
= 2 mag.
Their model is characterised by a density of n=106 cm-3 and an intensity
of the incident FUV radiation field a factors of
stronger
than the ambient interstellar radiation field.
The largest abundance of CN occurs in the
H/H2 transition layer and falls off rapidly at higher depths into
the PDR, where the temperature decreases rapidly
(cf. Fig. 7 of Sternberg & Dalgarno 1995). For background stars
with sightlines passing through the outer layers of a dense PDR,
the CN column densities would thus be constant towards
stars with
> 2 mag. The abundance variation of CH and CH+
shows a similar behaviour. The PDRs produce very large CH and CH+ abundances
in a thin outer layer, which peak at the relatively
low optical depths of
0.5 mag. At larger depths, fractional abundances fall
off rapidly, and integrated column densities are constant for visual
extinctions of
> 2 mag, or
mag.
The qualitative agreement between the present observations and
the theoretical predictions of the PDR model is not matched,
however, by the quantitative predictions of the model.
Maximal integrated CN column densities of the model of
Sternberg & Dalgarno (1995) are N(CN
cm-2,
which is about an order of magnitude lower than what is observed
here. In addition, PDRs produce very large
amounts of CH and CH+, compared to quiescent translucent clouds.
Total integrated column
densities are N(CH
cm-2 and
N(CH
cm-2, or about an order of
magnitude larger than observed CH and CH+ column densities.
It is thus unlikely that the molecules observed here arise in
the outer layer of a dense PDR. This result is in agreement
with the analysis of the velocity structure of Sect. 4.1,
which on kinematic grounds indicates that the foreground molecular material
is not in physical contact with the HII region produced by Berkeley 59.
Mid- to far-infrared emission line observations of atomic fine structure lines
using ISO have been reported by Okada et al. (2003). The authors
collected one dimensional raster scans starting at the position of
Berkeley 59 out to some 5 pc away from the cluster. From the emission line observations,
which also trace material in the background of the stars of Berkeley 59,
the molecular part of the PDR formed by the star cluster was detected.
As it is the case for other PDRs as well, it was found that the observed
[OI] 63 m/[OI] 146
m
ratio was too small if compared with the predictions of the
more recent PDR models of Kaufman et al. (1999). In order to explain the
small line ratio, the authors suggested that self-absorption of
the [OI] emission line by foreground gas along the line of sight occurs.
Self-absorption of the [OI] 63
m line has been used to
explain the low [OI] 63
m/[OI] 146
m line ratio in NGC 2024,
and is seen in high spectral
resolution KAO observations towards star forming regions (see Okada et al.
2003 for references). The proposition by Okada et al. (2003) provides
further support to the suggestion that cold molecular gas exists towards
Berkeley 59 which is detached from the PDR created by the star cluster.
The processes which lead to the formation of interstellar
CN in quiescent translucent clouds have been identified some 20 years
ago (see Federman et al. 1994, and references therein).
In translucent molecular clouds, CN probes the denser gas
in general, and
CN column densities are only poorly correlated with the reddening of
the background stars. On the other side, N(CN) is in general well correlated
with N(C2), as shown by van Dishoeck & Black (1989) and Federman et al. (1994).
The tight N(CN) -N(C2) correlation which has been inferred towards
other regions is also present in
our data, as seen in Fig. 6h. Since
the formation and destruction channels of both molecules
involve different dependencies on the optical depth
in the ultraviolet, the correlation of the column densities is
not expected on chemical grounds but reflects the fact that both molecules
are formed in similar parcels of gas, as suggested by Federman et al. (1994).
Our data are consistent with the relation logN(CN
(C2)
of Federman et al. (1994).
In Fig. 6f,
the column densities of CN are plotted versus the column density of CH.
Despite the large uncertainties which hamper the derivation of accurate column
densities, a few correlations are obvious from the figures.
The data are consistent with the relation N(CN
CH).
The formation of interstellar C2translucent clouds has been
discussed in Federman & Huntress (1989). The derived column densities N(CN) are tightly correlated with N(C2). The data are consistent with N(C2) = N(CH) (cf. Fig. 6g). The values given
in Table 5 follow the empirical relations
of van Dishoeck & Black (1989) and the theoretical relation of Federman et al. (1994).
In translucent molecular clouds, the CH column density appears to be
a good measure of the molecular hydrogen column density, and
Liszt & Lucas (2002) find a mean relation of
N(CH)/N(H
.
The CH column densities may thus be used to derive fractional
abundances
f(X) = N(X)/2N(H
) = N(X)/2N(H2) of species Xassuming that all hydrogen is in molecular form.
This procedure fixes the fractional abundance of
CH to f(CH
for all lines of
sight. Our measurements indicate fractional abundances of
f(CN
,
f(C2
,
and
f(CH
.
The derived fractional abundances of CN and CH are
very typical for translucent molecular clouds and are
well fit by the models of van Dishoeck & Black (1989).
The marginal data on CH+ obtained here are not useful to provide new contributions to the discussion related to the formation scenarios of interstellar CH+. The column densities of CH+ are not correlated with N(CH), as can be seen from Fig. 6e. The derived CH+ column densities are relatively small if compared to values of N(CH+) inferred towards other stars with similar reddenings. This may indicate that the dominant CH+ formation processes which are at work towards other OB associations are not efficient towards Cep OB4.
We have analysed interstellar absorption lines
of CN, C2, CH, and CH+ towards stars in the
Cep OB4 association and its central cluster Berkeley 59.
The present observations provide no evidence to support
an earlier suggestion that the large column densities of
interstellar CN towards BD+66 1661, BD+66
1674, and BD+66
1675,
originate in the HII-H2 interface region near Berkeley 59.
The analysis of the velocity structure of the molecular gas,
the molecular abundances of CH, CH+, and indirect evidence
from far-infrared atomic emission line observations, suggest that
the CN, C2, CH, and CH+ absorption lines arise in molecular
material well detached from the PDR formed by the central cluster
Berkeley 59. Our treatment of the C2results in gaskinetic
temperatures of 35-60 K and densities of 700-800 cm-3 in the foreground translucent cloud.
Total molecular column densities of CN and C2 are tightly
correlated with the column density of CH. The correlations, and
the column densities of CN, C2, and CH, are well understood in
terms of models of quiescent translucent clouds.
Acknowledgements
Part of the observations have been carried out in service mode by Calar Alto staff. It is a pleasure to thank the Calar Alto astronomy group for their support.