A&A 422, 907-913 (2004)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20035937
K. Jäger1 - B. L. Ziegler1 - A. Böhm1 - J. Heidt2 - C. Möllenhoff2 - U. Hopp3 - R. H. Mendez4 - S. Wagner2
1 - Universitätssternwarte Göttingen, Geismarlandstr. 11, 37083
Göttingen, Germany
2 -
Landessternwarte Heidelberg, Königstuhl, 69117 Heidelberg,
Germany
3 -
Universitätssternwarte München, Scheinerstr. 1, 81679
München, Germany
4 -
Institute for Astronomy, 2680 Woodlawn Drive, Honolulu, Hawaii 96822, USA
Received 23 December 2003 / Accepted 21 April 2004
Abstract
We have conducted an observing campaign with the FORS instruments
at the ESO-Very Large Telescope
to explore the kinematical properties of spiral galaxies in distant
galaxy clusters. Our
main goal is to analyse transformation - and interaction processes of disk
galaxies within the special environment of clusters as compared to the
hierarchical evolution of galaxies in the field.
Spatially resolved multi object spectra
have been obtained for seven galaxy clusters at 0.3<z<0.6
to measure rotation velocities of cluster members.
For three of the clusters, Cl 0303+17, Cl 0413-65, and MS 1008-12,
for which we presented results including a Tully-Fisher-diagram
in Ziegler et al. (2003),
we describe here in detail the sample selection, observations, data
reduction, and data analysis.
Each of them was observed with two setups of the standard MOS-unit of FORS. With typical exposure times of >2 h we reach an
in the emission lines appropriate for the deduction of the galaxies'
internal rotation velocities
from [OII],
,
or [OIII] emission line profiles.
Preselection of targets was done on the basis of available
redshifts as well as from photometric and morphological information gathered
from own observations, archive data, and from the literature. Emphasis was
laid on the definition of suitable setups to avoid the typical
restrictions of the standard MOS unit for this kind of observations.
In total we assembled spectra of 116 objects of which 50 turned out to be
cluster members.
Position velocity diagrams, finding charts for each setup as well as tables
with photometric, spectral, and structural parameters of individual galaxies
are presented.
Key words: galaxies: evolution - galaxies: kinematics and dynamics - galaxies: spiral - galaxies: clusters: individual: MS 1008.1-1224 - galaxies: clusters: individual: Cl 0303+1706 - galaxies: clusters: individual: Cl 0413-6559
With the advent of 10 m-class telescopes we are now able to analyse the
internal kinematics of disk galaxies as a function of density environment
over a wide range of cosmic epochs.
Spatially resolved galaxy spectra up to redshifts
are needed to
compare, for example, the Tully-Fisher-Relation (TFR, Tully & Fisher
1977) of local galaxies in clusters and the field with the TFR of their
more distant and therefore much younger counterparts.
Table 1: Observation log of our MOS- and imaging data.
Following models of hierarchically growing structure, clusters of galaxies are still in the process of forming at z=1 in the concordance cosmology. High resolution Hubble Space Telecope (HST) and ground-based images indicate that the morphological structure of cluster galaxies is affected by different phenomena related to their dense environment. This implies a higher galaxy infall rate, star formation rate and frequency of interactions of the cluster members at intermediate redshifts (e.g., Kodama & Bower 2001). However, any specific evolution of cluster galaxies is superposed on the hierarchical evolution of galaxies which is characterized by the growth of objects, by mergers, and declining star formation rates. Furthermore, cluster members should interact with the intracluster medium which fills the gravitational potential of clusters. Finally, it is possible that the the dark matter halo of cluster galaxies (and therefore their total mass) is undergoing distinct changes by particular interaction processes.
One important scenario presently discussed came from the finding that local clusters are dominated by elliptical and lenticular galaxies while the distant ones show a high fraction of spiral and irregular galaxies (Dressler et al. 1997). Spirals from the field might fall into clusters and experience a morphological transformation into S0 galaxies. Some conceivable interactions, like merging, should cause substantial distortions of the internal kinematics of disk galaxies with velocity profiles no longer following the universal form (Persic et al. 1996). Galaxies with "regular'' rotation curves can be used to investigate their luminosity evolution via the TFR which connects their internal kinematics to their stellar population. First studies of distant clusters have been done by Milvang-Jensen et al. (2003) (7 TF spiral galaxies within MS 1054.4-0321 at z=0.83) and Metevier et al. (2003) (10 TF spirals within CL0024+1654 at z=0.40) using the VLT and the Keck telescope, respectively. In Ziegler et al. (2003, hereafter Paper I) we recently presented first results of our FORS-VLT MOS observations of three clusters at intermediate redshift. Both position velocity diagrams of late-type galaxies as well as a TF-diagram for 13 cluster members were shown supplemented by a comparison of our results with those from the publications mentioned above. In this paper we focus on a more detailed description of our observations and measurements and present the data in tabular form.
Our overall project comprises
observations of galaxies in the fields of seven rich clusters
within the redshift range 0.3<z<0.6.
From spatially resolved spectra we investigate internal kinematics.
Photometric measurements complete the data set.
All observations have been carried out with the two
FORS instruments (FOcal Reducer and Spectrograph)
mounted at the Very Large Telescope (VLT) of the European Southern
Observatory (ESO) (see
Appenzeller et al. (2000) for a comprehensive list of technical
papers on FORS).
While FORS2 now supports exchangable masks (Mask Exchange
Unit - MXU),
all observations of Cl 0413-65, MS 1008-12 and
Cl 0303+17 were still restricted to the
standard Multi Object Spectroscopy Unit (MOS) with 19 moveable
slitlets. Only these observations (Table 1) are discussed
within this paper. The other four clusters will be
discussed in a future publication since different reduction techniques are
necessary.
The paper is organized as follows: Sect. 2 describes our imaging observations and the determination of photometric values and absolute magnitudes which are important for the construction of a TF-diagram. Section 3 gives an overview about the target selection for our MOS observations and how we deal with some restrictions of the standard MOS unit of FORS. Section 4 describes the observations and reduction of the MOS data, while Sect. 5 explains our measurements of internal galaxy kinematics. In Sect. 6 finding charts, position velocity diagrams and data tables are presented.
Direct imaging of the cluster fields was needed to prepare the MOS setups and to obtain photometric and structural information of the galaxies for the TF-diagram.
For Cl 0303+17 three R band FORS1 images with 300 s exposure time each were taken in October 1999. Photometric information for Cl 0413-65 was gathered from two FORS1 images in R and I with 600 s exposure time, respectively, taken in December 1998. For MS 1008-12 we could use the FORS Cluster Deep Field images (see Lombardi et al. 2000). Additionally, we took an acquisition image of 300 s in I in February 2000 with FORS2.
Except for the Cluster Deep Field images which were available from the
ESO archive
already reduced and calibrated,
all own FORS images were reduced with standard procedures of
ESO-MIDAS
.
Each science and flatfield image was firstly
bias substracted by using a master bias which was created
from a stack of single bias frames and which was scaled to the overscan level
of the individual image. Skyflats were taken to
correct for the pixel to pixel variations whereas the
large scale gradients were removed by a normalized superflat
created from a medianed and smoothed stack of further
science frames taken during the same nights.
Finally, tracks of cosmic rays have been removed
with a standard MIDAS procedure (see Sect. 4 for some details).
Photometric zeropoints were calculated from observations of Landolt
standard fields (Landolt 1992) during the same nights.
The photometry of the galaxies was performed with the Source Extractor package
(SExtractor) by Bertin & Arnouts (1996).
As total apparent magnitudes we adopted the MAG_BEST values which are
measured within the elliptical Kron radius (Kron 1980) determined
automatically by SExtractor.
To verify our calibration, we also conducted aperture photometry and compared
our aperture magnitudes to published values. We found good agreement
within our photometric errors (see below).
For the TF diagram presented in Paper I, we determined the absolute restframe
B magnitudes.
To minimize k-corrections, we chose different observed bands as starting point
depending on the redshift of the cluster.
In the case of Cl 0303+17, the three R band images were coadded to create a
single frame with a total exposure time of 900 s.
While we used the I band image for Cl 0413-65, we took the 1350 s V band exposure from the Cluster Deep Field Survey for
MS 1008-12.The latter is the sum of 3 images with the best seeing (
).
The total apparent magnitudes were corrected for intrinsic extinction
following the prescription by Tully and Fouque (1985) with a value of
for a galaxy seen face-on.
For the conversion from the B band to the other filters we adopted the
factors:
AI/AB=0.45,
AR/AB=0.56,
AV/AB=0.72.
Depending on the redshift of the cluster, AB was used for the V image
of MS 1008-12, AV for the I image of Cl 0413-65, and AB for the R image
of Cl 0303+17.
Galactic extinction was corrected for assuming the values calculated from the
dust maps of Schlegel et al. (1998).
With
E(B-V) = 0.135 for Cl 0303+17, we used
ARg=0.36.
With
E(B-V) = 0.041 for Cl 0413-65, we used
AIg=0.08.
With
E(B-V) = 0.069 for MS 1008-12, we used
AVg=0.23.
k-corrections for the transformation between observed filter and restframe B were calculated according to the SED type
of the respective galaxy using synthetic model spectra as described in
Böhm et al. (2004).
Finally, the distance modulus for each galaxy was calculated using the
"concordance'' cosmological values (H0 = 70 km s-1 Mpc-1,
,
).
Errors due to photon noise were estimated to be very low by SExtractor since the targeted galaxies are rather bright. Further errors arise from uncertainties in the calculation of the k-correction (determination of the T type, see Böhm et al. 2004), of the internal absorption which depends on the inclination, and of the Galactic extinction. We estimate total errors in the magnitudes to be typically 0.10 mag for galaxies in the field of MS 1008-12, and 0.15 mag in the case of Cl 0303+17 and Cl 0413-65.
The selection and observation of cluster spiral candidates was mainly determined by two boundary conditions resulting in a heterogeneous sample. First of all, we utilized previous publications which had different levels of information on the cluster galaxy population.
For Cl 0303+17, we used the spectroscopic catalog of
Dressler & Gunn (1992) and the morphological data from
HST observations (Smail et al. 1997).
In addition, an unpublished list of Belloni (priv. com.) was
used. In total, 82 galaxies which were i) cluster members, ii) of
late type and iii) brighter than R= 23 mag were selected of which we
determined the position angle (PA) from the
SExtractor photometry on the ground based images.
These values show a good
agreement with SExtractor measurements of some of the same galaxies
applied to the HST images which cover only the central cluster parts.
Then, in the end, 22 appropriate galaxies with
mean position angles close to the FORS-rotation angles of 45
and
were selected
for filling up two different MOS setups. The remaining slitlets
were filled with 16 other cluster member candidates independent from our
constraints on Hubble type and PA.
For Cl 0413-65, we used the MORPHS data
(Poggianti et al. 1999 and Smail et al. 1997)
and ground-based optical-infrared colors of Stanford
et al. (2002).
Since the HST/WFPC2 field covered only a small part of the FORS field and
since there were only 10 spectroscopically verified MORPHS cluster members,
the primarily selection was done by color.
By comparing stellar population models
of Bruzual & Charlot (1993, in the 1995 version) with the red
sequence of ellipticals
determined by Stanford et al. (1998),
we applied the following color criteria to select targets with the highest
probability to be cluster members:
spiral candidates had to obey
and
(the 10 spectroscopically verified cluster members lie within these color ranges).
This resulted in 39 possible
targets, which had to be distributed among two setups. Since the distribution
of the position angles as measured on a 10-min I-band FORS1 pre-image
were rather smooth, the orientation of the two setups were set to differ by 90 degrees (
and
).
To increase the number of possible targets, we
produced also a list of galaxies with somewhat redder colors than cited above
as candidates for cluster ellipticals.
Herewith we supplemented our data set of early type cluster galaxies
of another ongoing project.
For the first (second) setup 7 (5) slits had to be filled with
objects with no color information available, of which only 1 turned out to be
a cluster spiral.
The most comprehensive source for creating a candidate list of
galaxies (80 targets) was available for MS 1008-12.
In this case we used the catalogue
of Yee et al. (1998) which contains cluster members and
their spectral types from the CNOC survey
(Canadian Network for Observational Cosmology).
Thus, galaxies with emission lines (CNOC classes 4 and 5) were preferentially
assigned to the MOS slitlets of two different setups taking also into account
their respective position angles which we measured on a 5-min I-band
FORS2 pre-image. Together, 14 different spiral candidates, of which 7 were
taken for both setups, were chosen as targets. The remaining slitlets of
the two MOS setups
were
filled with 3 E+A and 8 elliptical cluster candidates and
serendipetously selected objects from the pre-image.
The main problem for observing an appropriate sample of cluster spiral
galaxy candidates arises from our restriction to the standard MOS unit of FORS at the time of the observations. Within one setup this mode provides 19 slitlets covering the area of the CCD in y-direction.
All of them are individually moveable along the x-axis but have
a fixed orientation and therefore a fixed slit angle.
Ideally, slits should be placed along the major
axis of a galaxy to measure its rotation curve.
Since this was impossible for the major fraction of our candidates,
we rotated the FORS instrument as to minimize the
deviation
between slit angle and position angle within one setup.
Unavoidably, the
deviation
was rather large in some cases leading to
geometric distortions of the observed velocity profile that could not be
fully corrected for.
Observations were carried out in November 1999 (Cl 0413-65), March 2000
(MS 1008-12) and October 2000 (Cl 0303+17).
Both FORS instruments were mounted at the Cassegrain focus
of one of the ESO-VLT unit telescopes, respectively.
Each instrument had a 2K Tektronix CCD
with 24 pixels and was used in the standard mode. This provides
a resolution of 0
2/pixel with a total FOV of
in imaging mode and a
usable FOV of
for MOS.
In total we gained 125 spectra of 116 objects in the range
18.0 < R < 23.0 (some objects were observed within two setups).
For each setup a total exposure time in the order of 8000 s
(splitted into 3-5 individual exposures)
was chosen to achieve an
in the emission lines even for the
faintest galaxies.
Due to the faintness and the apparent small spatial size of the distant galaxies
(in the order of 1
only) particular care has to be taken for
placing an object onto a slit.
The first order positioning of the slitlets was done on the basis of
FORS images and the FIMS-software
. After taking a through-slit aquisition
frame the final positioning of the slitlets on the targets was
within an accuracy of 0
1.
We used a slitwidth of 1
and grism GRIS 600R
.
This provides a resolution of
and a dispersion of 45 Å/mm corresponding to a sampling of 1.08 Å/pixel.
Each individual spectrum covers typically 2000 Å within a wavelength
range between 4400-8200 Å depending on the slit position within the FOV.
All data reduction steps were done with MIDAS
or with own procedures which were implemented into MIDAS.
Since the ESO-Paranal staff provides calibration frames
(as bias, flatfields or standards)
of VLT observations in general by following a standard calibration plan
we have checked at first all calibration frames for compatibility
with their corresponding science frames (e.g. same read-out-mode,
sampling, gain etc.).
Furthermore, properties of sets of calibration frames
contemporary gained with the science frames during one night have been
principally compared with other sets e.g. before averaging.
In some cases science frames of one setup were collected during
several nights. Such sub-setups and their corresponding
calibration frames were always treated separately at first to check at
which state of the data reduction they could be combined.
Firstly, all science and flatfield frames were bias corrected.
We created master bias frames for each observing
night by the median of typically 20 single bias frames which have been
set to the same level before. This was possible since in all cases
the mean bias level
changed only in the order of 1% even between different nights and all
frames showed little but equal two dimensional patterns.
Then, each master bias was scaled to the overscan level of
the science frame and subtracted.
Hereafter, a cosmic ray correction on the two dimensional
MOS frames has been applied by using the standard MIDAS tool FILTER/COSMIC.
Within this routine cosmic ray events are detected by the comparison of the raw
frame with a median filtered version of that image. Pixels with an intensity
greater than a defined threshold as compared to the local median are replaced
by this median value. To avoid misdetections, in particular within the emission
lines, we furthermore compared the individual exposures of
a given setup.
Now, two dimensional subframes corresponding to individual slit spectra were extracted from each MOS frame. Similarly, appropriate subframes (with same dimensions and CCD-pixel coordinates) were extracted from the corresponding two dimensional flatfield- and calibration images. Flatfields were gained with through-slit-exposures. For each setup two versions with different exposure times were taken to warrant for correct illumination of the upper and lower part of the CCD, respectively. This was necessary to avoid diffuse reflection from the gaps between the slitlets. To perform the correction of the science spectra for pixel-to-pixel variations and the CCD-response over the dispersion direction masterflats were created from typically 3-5 corresponding single flatfields by normalization and averaging.
One of the critical steps was the correction for an instrument based curvature of the frames in y-direction (see Fig. 1 for an illustration). This distortion changes gradually from a positive curvature at the top of the CCD to a negative curvature at the bottom of the CCD with a maximal misalignment in the order of five pixel (in y) at the edges of the uppermost and lowest spectrum. To correct for, each column of a certain slit image has to be shifted with subpixel accuracy. To get values with a resolution of 0.1 pixel we applied a fit to the curvature. We checked that the flux of the science frames was conserved within a few percent. The same procedure was applied to the calibration spectra. We point out that the rectification for corresponding science/calibration spectra has to be achieved with exactly the same parameters. Furthermore, this reduction step has to be done after the flatfield correction since there are small but non-commutative changes of pixel values which would affect the flatfield correction if doing it in the reverse order.
To subtract the night sky emission typically 30-40 rows
(6
-8
)
on both sides of
the galaxy emission were selected interactively
before each column of a certain spectrum was fitted.
Only few galaxy spectra were located very close to the edges of the
respective slitlets. In those cases the definition of the sky
region was restricted to
one side of the galaxy spectrum, only.
![]() |
Figure 1: Example for the correction of the curvature of the spectra in y-direction. Top: the raw but cosmic corrected two dimensional spectrum of the galaxy A18 (slit No. 18 of setup A) of MS 1008-12. Center: the same spectrum after applying the rectification. Bottom: the fully reduced and wavelength calibrated spectrum. A18 is an early-type galaxy and a member of MS 1008-12 (z=0.3111). Please note that the figures are expanded in y-direction for a better illustration of the curvature. |
Open with DEXTER |
Distortions in wavelength direction, i.e. the curvature of arc-lines
were corrected during the
standard wavelength calibration. Calibration spectra have been taken with Ne, He, and Ar lamps and a two-dimensional dispersion relation
(rms )
was calculated for each spectrum
by polynomial fits.
This dispersion relation was then applied to the corresponding
science spectrum.
For the summation of single exposures of the same slitlet, the center of the galaxy emission along the spatial axis was determined by a Gaussian fit for each exposure. Only for a very limited number we measured an offset in the order of 1-2 pixel making it necessary to shift along the spatial axis before summation. In the case of seeing variations larger than 25% between individual frames a weighted addition has been applied.
For the derivation of rotational velocities of the galaxies as a function of radius we followed exactly the same procedure as described in detail in Ziegler et al. (2002) and in Böhm et al. (2004). Both publications present the analysis of the internal kinematics of spiral galaxies at intermediate redshift taken from the FORS Deep Field Survey (e.g., Heidt et al. 2003). Since these objects were observed with the same instrumental setups as the ones presented here we only summarize the main properties of this part of the analysis.
Rotation velocities were determined by an analysis of the
[OII] 3727, H
or [OIII] 5007 emission lines (see Fig. 2 for
an illustration of our data).
Any blue - and redshift in wavelength within an emission line
due to the internal kinematics of a galaxy has to be measured with
reference to the center of that line.
Therefore, we firstly fitted a Gaussian profile to the selected
emission line to define its center along the spatial axis within an accuracy
of 0
1. This was achieved by averaging 100 columns centered on that
emission line to construct a one-dimensional intensity profile along the
spatial axis.
To determine the wavelength shifts along the spatial axis the emission line
was fitted row by row
with Gaussian profiles after three neighbouring rows were averaged
before each fit to increase the S/N ratio.
Due to the resolution of 0
2 arcsec/pixel this "boxcar''-filter corresponds
to 0
6 (only in the few cases of very weak lines we used a boxcar of 1
). Wavelength shifts relative to the center of the line
were now transformed into velocity shifts under consideration of
a cosmological correction of
(1+z)-1 to gain an observed
rotation curve RC
.
Any velocity value measured on the basis of RC
will lead to an underestimation of the true intrinsic maximum galaxy
rotation velocity.
This is due to the fact that the visible disk size of spirals at
intermediate redshifts and the slit width of 1 arcsec
are of comparable sizes and, therefore, an integrated spectrum
covers a substantial fraction of
the two-dimensional intrinsic velocity field of a galaxy. At z=0.5 -
that is the distance of Cl 0413-65 for example - a typical
scalelength of 3 kpc corresponds to
0.5 arcsec.
Hence, this "blurring'' effect has to be taken into account in particular
for the determination of the maximum rotation velocity
.
The problem was solved by generating a synthetic rotation
curve RC
which was compared with RC
.
![]() |
Figure 2:
Illustration of our observed data by means of one galaxy from Setup B
of the cluster MS 1008-12 (ID = B5). Left:
the spatially resolved ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
To simulate a rotation curve we assumed an intrinsic rotation law.
A simple shape was used with a
linear rise of
at small radii turning over at a characteristic radius
r0 into a flat part of
as it can be expected
due to the influence of a Dark Matter Halo.
Based on RC
we generated the two-dimensional velocity
field for an individual galaxy as it would appear under consideration of
the observed position angle, inclination and disk scale length as determined
by a fit to the respective two-dimensional surface brightness profile
and the seeing (FWHM) during spectroscopy.
Simulating the slit spectroscopy we then integrate over the velocity field
within a stripe of 1
taking also into account the mismatch angle
to find
.
This fit was repeated varying the values of i,
and
within the errors. For a detailed
discussion of a
-fitting procedure based on the errors from the
RC extraction and a discussion of the influence of different RC
shapes on
see also Böhm et al. (2004).
In 8 cases more than one emission line was present within a spectrum.
Rotation curves have been measured from each line and compared.
They were consistent within the errors in 6 cases.
The other two had too low S/N.
The tabulated values for
have been derived
from the curve with the largest covered radius and the highest S/N
ratio.
Only galaxies showing a rotation curve that is
rising in the inner region and then turning into a flat part
are useful for the construction of a TF-diagram.
In such cases the maximum
rotation velocity can be used as an indicator for the total dynamical mass of a
galaxy and would therefore reflect the influence of a dark matter halo on the
internal galaxy kinematics.
In Paper I we presented a TF-diagram in which 13 cluster
spirals of Cl 0303+17, Cl 0413-65, and MS 1008-12 as well as seven
field spiral galaxies are shown in comparison to the distribution of the FORS Deep
Field galaxies from Böhm et al. (2004). We point out that we only used those
galaxies for the diagram where we were able to measure
in the sense
mentioned above. Galaxies with disturbed kinematics (either intrinsic or
geometric) do not enter the TF-diagram.
Within this section we present data tables (Tables 2-10) on individual galaxies, finding charts (Fig. 3) of the six MOS-setups, and position velocity diagrams of galaxies (Figs. 4-6) in the field of the clusters.
The finding charts show the full
FORS
- FOV
in standard imaging mode.
All observed primary MOS-targets are marked by circles and
labeled by their slit numbers. These numbers correspond to the identifier
(ID) given in the data tables. Tables 2-4 contain a complete list of
all observed objects (within all setups and all slitlets) with
positions, redshifts and magnitudes.
The positions were measured on our FORS images and are
not astrometric corrected.
In Table 5 specific information is given on only those spiral galaxies for
which we derived
.
The columns of that table have the following meaning, respectively:
Acknowledgements
We thank ESO and the Paranal staff for efficient support. We also thank the PI of the FORS project, Prof. I. Appenzeller (Heidelberg), and Prof. K. J. Fricke (Göttingen) for providing guaranteed time for our project. Furthermore we want to thank the anonymous referee for his helpful remarks. This work has been supported by the Volkswagen Foundation (I/76 520) and the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (Fr 325/46-1 and SFB 439).
![]() |
Figure 3:
Finding charts of all MOS setups. Top: MS 1008-12.
Center: Cl 0303+17. Bottom: Cl 0413-65.
In all cases we show the full FORS 6
![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
Table 2:
MOS targets in the field of MS 1008-12 observed with Setup A (
)
and
Setup B (
).
There are 7 objects which have been observed in both setups: A3 = B14, A4 = B15, A6 = B6, A8 = B19, A12 = B8,
A15 = B11 and A17 = B10. For identification of galaxies see finding chart in
Fig. 3.
Table 3:
MOS targets in the field of Cl 0303+17 observed with Setup A (
)
and
Setup B (
). A11 = B6.
Table 4:
MOS targets in the field of Cl 0413-65 observed with Setup A (
)
and
Setup B (
). A11 = B9.
Table 5:
All galaxies from which we obtained
.
In the case of MS 1008-12 A12 = B8.
For an identification see finding charts in Fig. 3.
In some cases there was no [OII] line within the spectra and we used other emission lines.
![]() |
Figure 4: Position velocity diagrams of galaxies in the field of MS 1008-12. Galaxies which entered the TF diagram presented in Paper I are labeled (TF). The solid line represents the projected best fitting model profile. See Tables 6-8 for comparison. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 5: Position velocity diagrams of galaxies in the field of Cl 0303+17. Galaxies which entered the TF diagram presented in Paper I are labeled (TF). The solid line represents the projected best fitting model profile. See Table 9 for comparison. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 6: Position velocity diagrams of galaxies in the field of Cl 0413-65. Galaxies which entered the TF diagram presented in Paper I are labeled (TF). The solid line represents the projected best fitting model profile. See Tables 10 and 11 for comparison. |
Open with DEXTER |
Table 6:
Measured rotation velocities
as function of projected distance (Pos) to
the galaxies' centers (Pos = 0) for MS 1008-12. Galaxies are indicated by their ID with the measured emission line, respectively.
See Fig. 4 for comparison.
Table 7:
Measured rotation velocities
as function of projected distance (Pos) to
the galaxies' centers (Pos = 0) for MS 1008-12. Galaxies are indicated by their ID with the measured emission line, respectively.
See Fig. 4 for comparison.
Table 8:
Measured rotation velocities
as function of projected distance (Pos) to
the galaxies' centers (Pos = 0) for MS 1008-12. Galaxies are indicated by their ID with the measured emission line, respectively.
See Fig. 4 for comparison.
Table 9:
Measured rotation velocities
as function of projected distance (Pos) to
the galaxies' centers (Pos = 0) for Cl 0303+17. Galaxies are indicated by their ID with the measured emission line, respectively.
See Fig. 5 for comparison.
Table 10:
Measured rotation velocities
as function of projected distance (Pos) to
the galaxies' centers (Pos = 0) for Cl 0413-65. Galaxies are indicated by their ID with the measured emission line, respectively.
See Fig. 6 for comparison.
Table 11:
Measured rotation velocities
as function of projected distance (Pos) to
the galaxies' centers (Pos = 0) for Cl 0413-65. Galaxies are indicated by their ID with the measured emission line, respectively.
See Fig. 6 for comparison.