A&A 419, 469-484 (2004)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20035646
S. Pustilnik1,7 - A. Kniazev1,2,7 - A. Pramskij1,7 - Y. Izotov3 - C. Foltz4 - N. Brosch5 - J.-M. Martin6 - A. Ugryumov1,7
1 - Special Astrophysical Observatory RAS, Nizhnij Arkhyz,
Karachai-Circassia 369167, Russia
2 - Max Planck Institut für Astronomie, Königstuhl 17,
69117
Heidelberg, Germany
3 - Main Astronomical Observatory, 27 Zabolotnoho str., Kyiv 03680,
Ukraine
4 - National Science Foundation, 4201 Wilson Blvd., Arlington,
Virginia 22230, USA
5 - the Wise Observatory and the Raymond and Beverly Sackler Faculty
of
Exact Sciences, Tel-Aviv University, Tel Aviv 69978, Israel
6 - Observatoire de Paris, place J. Janssen, 92195 Meudon Cedex, France
7 - Isaac Newton Institute of Chile, SAO Branch
Received 7 November 2003 / Accepted 18 February 2004
Abstract
We present the results of high S/N long-slit spectroscopy with the
Multiple
Mirror and the SAO 6-m telescopes, optical imaging with the Wise 1-m
telescope
and H I observations with the Nançay Radio Telescope
of the very metal-deficient
( (O/H)=7.64) luminous (
)
blue compact
galaxy (BCG) HS 0837+4717. The
blue bump near
4650,
characteristic of WR stars
is detected in the central supergiant H II region, as well as
the barely seen red bump at
5808.
The derived number of WR stars in the region of the current starburst is
1000. Evidence for fast motions in this region is also seen as broad,
low-contrast components in the H
,
H
and strong
[O III]
lines
4959,5007. While the extinction of the narrow
emission
lines from the supergiant H II region is low, the very large
Balmer decrement of the broad
components suggests that the part of current starburst is highly
obscured by dust.
Abundance ratios X/O for
,
Ar, S, Fe and Cl in the supergiant H II region are in good agreement with the mean values of other very
metal-deficient BCGs.
Nitrogen, however, is
overabundant by a factor of
6.
This implies an unusually efficient N enrichment in HS 0837+4717, and
probably, a non-typical evolution scenario. The H
-line
position-velocity
(P-V) diagrams for directions approximately along the major and minor
axes reveal disturbed
motions of the ionized gas, mainly in peripheral regions.
The SW part of the major axis P-V diagram looks like a rotation curve,
with
the velocity amplitude
km s-1 at r
=4.3 kpc. Its
NE part displays, however, strong deviations, indicating either
counter-rotation, or a strong outflow/supershell.
If it is considered as indicating a
shell-like feature
its velocity amplitude of
70 km s-1 (relative to the extrapolated rotation curve), and the apparent
extent
of
4
(3.3 kpc) imply a dynamical age of
14 Myr and the
full energetic equivalent of
SNe. The latter
indicates continuing starbursts during at least this time interval.
The long-slit spectra reveal a complex morphology for this galaxy. It
consists of two compact regions at a distance of
2 kpc. Their
continuum flux
differs by a factor of four. The brightest one is related to the
current starburst with the age of
3.7 Myr.
The slightly redder
fainter component could be an older starburst (
25 Myr). The Wise 1-m telescope UBVR integrated photometry reveals
a high optical luminosity for this BCG, and the unusual (B-V)and (V-R) colours. The morphology of HS 0837+4717 is highly disturbed,
with two small tails emerging to NNW and SSE.
Such a disturbed overall morphology, a "double-nucleus" structure,
significantly disturbed velocities of ionized gas, together with the
very high
power of the starburst suggests a possible explanation of the object as
a recent merger.
We compare the properties of this BCG and of
similar objects
known in the
literature, and conclude that their high nitrogen excess is most
probably related to the short phase of a powerful starburst
when many WR stars contribute to the enrichment of ISM.
Key words: galaxies: starburst - galaxies: abundances - galaxies: interactions - galaxies: evolution - stars: Wolf-Rayet - galaxies: individual: HS 0837+4717
Most low-mass gas-rich galaxies have low metallicities, with the
typical range of Z/15 to Z
/3 (e.g., review of Kunth &
Östlin 2000).
Only for a very small fraction of galaxies in the Local Universe is the
metallicity extremely low, in the
range of Z
/50 to Z
/20. This range is more
characteristic of high-redshift damped Ly
absorption systems which could be young galaxies.
The study of the extremely metal-deficient (XMD) galaxies
allows one to test many
theoretical ideas on massive star formation and evolution, and models of
galaxy evolution in a very low metallicity environment.
Table 1: Journal of spectral observations of HS 0837+4717.
In particular,
the abundance patterns of -elements and iron, that is, the
ratios X/O (with
,
S, Ar, Fe), allow one to check models of stellar
nucleosynthesis. For metal-poor galaxies they were found to be remarkably
constant over a wide range of O/H (e.g., Izotov & Thuan 1999,
hereafter IT99).
This implies that all these elements are primary
and are produced in the same massive stars. The ratio N/O was also found to
be fairly constant for XMD BCGs (IT99), implying mainly primary production of nitrogen
in very low metallicity environment.
Wolf-Rayet (WR) stars - a specific very short phase of massive star
evolution, characterized by strong mass outflow, and enriched mainly in N and C, are often seen in high S/N spectra of starburst galaxies (e.g.,
Kunth & Joubert 1985; Izotov et al. 1996;
Guseva et al. 2000).
These stars are detected through the broad emission features of the so
called "blue bump'' near 4650 Å, and more rarely in the red,
near
5808 Å.
Models of stellar evolution predict that the number of WR stars in a young
star cluster is a sensitive function of metallicity, IMF and starburst
age (e.g., Schaerer & Vacca 1998, hereafter SV98).
WR star outflows could produce a significant N overabundance at the locations of young starbursts. However, the analysis of a large sample of H II galaxies by Kobulnicky & Skillman (1996) showed that galaxies, with and without strong WR features in their integrated spectra, show identical N/O ratios. This is probably explained by nitrogen outflow in the hot phase. Therefore, only significantly after its ejection could the nitrogen be cooled and mixed into the optically observed ionized gas.
Significant nitrogen overabundance is detected in
a few starburst galaxies. The most prominent one is Mkn 996
(Thuan et al. 1996), with (O/H)=8.0. It is
a non-typical BCG due to the large
number of WR stars and to a powerful outflow from the compact central
SF burst. Its N/O in the region with diameter of 0.6 kpc is 4 to 25 times
higher than the typical value for low-metallicity BCGs
of
1/40.
The morphology of Mkn 996 implies that likely it is a
remnant of a recent merger. The authors
argue that the observed large N/O ratio is directly related to the
powerful outflows of numerous WR stars.
Another well known case is a factor of three nitrogen overabundance,
found in two compact regions ( pc) near the central
starburst in the nearby (
Mpc) dwarf WR galaxy NGC 5253 (e.g.,
Kobulnicky et al. 1997, and the summary of previous results
therein).
Only three galaxies:
UM 420, Mkn 1089, and UM 448, all luminous and with detected WR lines
(Guseva et al. 2000), from the sample of 50 BCGs in IT99, show nitrogen
overabundance of a factor of 3 relative to the mean N/O value of 1/30 for their range of O/H). Finally, the galaxy Haro 11 from the sample
of luminous BCGs (Bergvall & Östlin 2002), also with strong
WR bump, shows an N/O ratio that is 6 times higher than for the main
BCG group.
In this paper we present the results of a comprehensive study of
HS 0837+4717, found in the Hamburg/SAO survey
(Pustilnik et al. 1999).
The very low metallicity of HS 0837+4717 (
/20) was
first
derived from the observations with the SAO RAS 6-m telescope (BTA) in 1996 (Kniazev et al. 2000a).
Classified as an XMD BCG, it is unusually luminous for
its metallicity. This galaxy shows WR bumps and broad
components of strong emission lines of hydrogen and oxygen.
This is the next most nitrogen overabundant galaxy known after Mkn 996. But, in contrast to the latter, its optical spectrum does not look
atypical for BCGs, and its very large nitrogen overabundance is seen on
an otherwise more or less typical BCG background.
In Sect. 2 we describe the observations and their reduction. In Sect. 3 all the results from the reduction and preliminary analysis are presented, including the heavy element abundances, the WR and broad components of strong lines, the ionized gas kinematics and the morphology and photometry. In Sect. 4 we discuss the obtained results and derived parameters of this galaxy, compare its properties with those of other luminous and XMD BCGs, and draw conclusions. The adopted distance to the galaxy is 170.5 Mpc; respective scale is 827 pc per arcsecond.
Spectrophotometric observations of HS 0837+4717 with high S/N ratio
were obtained with the MMT on May 1, 1997.
The observations were performed with the Blue Channel of the MMT Spectrograph using a highly-optimized Loral
CCD
detector.
A
slit was used along with a 500 grooves mm-1 grating used in the first order and with the L-38 second
order blocking filter.
This yields a spatial scale along the slit of 0
3 pixel-1, a
scale
perpendicular to the slit of 1.9 Å pixel-1, a spectral range 3600-8300 Å and a spectral resolution of
7 Å (FWHM). For
these observations the
CCD rows were binned by a factor of 2, yielding a final spatial
sampling of 0
6 pixel-1. The observations cover the full spectral range in
a single frame which contains all the lines of interest. Furthermore,
the
spectra have sufficient spectral resolution to separate [O III]
4363 from the nearby H
and to distinguish between the
narrow nebular and the broad WR emission lines. The total exposure time
was 40 min, split into 2 equal subexposures, to allow for more
effective cosmic ray removal.
Both exposures were taken at an airmass of
1.13.
The slit was
oriented in the direction with the position angle
,
along
the major axis of the brightest region of the galaxy (Fig. 1).
The spectrophotometric standard star HZ 44 (Massey et al.
1988) was observed for flux calibration.
Reference spectra of He-Ne-Ar were obtained before and after each
observation to provide wavelength calibration.
Observations with the BTA were conducted on February 19, 2002 with the Long-slit spectrograph (Afanasiev et al.
1995)
at the prime focus of telescope. A CCD detector Photometrics PM1024
with
m pixel was used
for data acquisition. For abundance study a grating with 651 grooves mm-1 was used in the first order, giving 2.38 Å pixel-1(
Å)
and allowing the simultaneous coverage of the range 3700-6100 Å. Two 30-min exposure spectra were averaged to yield the final spectrum.
was selected to be
close to the apparent major axis of the object's fainter isophotes.
To complement the study of emission lines in the blue, and to study the
ionized gas kinematics, we obtained two spectra in the red with a
grating with 1302 grooves mm-1, giving 1.2 Å pixel-1, and
Å. These
spectra covered the range 6000-7200 Å, and were obtained also with the slit direction along
,
and in the nearly perpendicular direction of
.
The long slit of 2
120
was used for
both observations.
![]() |
Figure 1:
Morphology of HS 0837+4717 as seen in the Wise V-band
image. North is up, East is to the left.
The positions of MMT (
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 2:
Upper panel: the MMT 2D spectrum of HS 0837+4717
with
![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The reduction of the spectral observations was carried out at SAO using
the
IRAF and the
MIDAS
software packages.
It included bias subtraction, cosmic ray removal, and flat-field
correction using exposures of a quartz incandescent lamp.
After wavelength mapping, night sky background subtraction, and
correcting
for atmospheric extinction, each frame was calibrated to absolute
fluxes. One-dimensional spectra were extracted by summing up, without
weighting,
different numbers of rows along the slit depending on exact region of
interest.
The MMT spectrum of the brightest region of HS 0837+4717 in the range
3600 Å
Å for the aperture
and the BTA spectra in the blue and red, extracted with the aperture
,
are shown in Fig. 2.
Photometric observation of HS 0837+4717 were performed with the Wise
observatory 1-m telescope on nights 27 and 28.05.1999 in U,B,V and bands. The images were exposed through the standard filters onto a
Tektronics
pixels CCD and
field-of-view (at 0.696 arcsec pixel-1).
During the first night, the observations were performed at airmasses of 1.69 till 2.3, beginning from the U-band, and ending with the
-band. The
exposure time was 30 min for U, and 15 min for the others filters.
For the
second night, the observations were collected at the airmasses from 1.54 to 2.20, with the same exposure times. Photometric standards from the
fields of
Landolt (1992) were observed at an airmass range close to
that of the studied galaxy. The seeing during both nights was
(2-2.5)
.
The reduction of photometry was performed in IRAF, following the
standard pipe-line, including the de-biasing, cosmic ray removal and
flat-fielding. Aperture
photometry was performed in circular apertures, and the asymptotic
values of
the growth curves were accepted as the final integrated magnitudes.
The nights were not perfect; some cirrus clouds presumably were
present. Therefore, the maximal
differences, obtained for the magnitudes in these 2 nights reach 0
3
(in the V-band).
We combined the results for both nights in the attempt to
obtain
more reliable magnitudes of this galaxy. We also used as an independent
control, the BVR magnitudes and colours derived from the convolution
of the MMT spectrum with the B,V and R passbands.
H I line observations were carried out in February 1998 with the
300 m Nançay
radio telescope (NRT). The NRT has a half-power beam width of 3
7 (EW)
22
(NS) at the declination
.
Since HS 0837+4717 had a known optical redshift,
we split the 1024-channel autocorrelator in two halves and used
a dual-polarization receiver to increase the S/N ratio.
Each correlator segment covered a 6.4 MHz bandwidth, corresponding to a 1350 km s-1 velocity coverage, and was centered at the frequency
corresponding to the optical redshift.
The channel spacing was 2.6 km s-1 before smoothing and the
effective resolution after averaging pairs of adjacent channels and Hanning
smoothing was 10.6 km s-1. The system temperature of the receiver
was 40 K in the horizontal and vertical linear polarizations.
For the target galaxy declination the telescope gain was 0.88 K/Jy.
The observations were made in the standard total
power (position switching) mode with 1-min on-source
and 1-min off-source integrations.
The data were reduced using the NRT standard packages,
written by the observatory's staff. The Horizontal and Vertical linear
polarization spectra
were calibrated and processed independently, and were averaged
together.
Table 2: Line intensities in the supergiant H II region.
To derive element abundances of species O, Ne, N, S, Ar and Cl we use
the standard method from Aller (1984), and follow the procedure
described in detail by Pagel et al. (1992) and
Izotov et al. (1994, hereafter ITL94).
The electron temperature
is known to be different in high-
and low-ionization H II regions (Stasinska 1990). In the
following we have chosen to determine
(O III) from the
[O III]
4363/(
4959+
5007)
ratio using the five-level atom model of O III, and N
(S II) from the
[S II]
6717/
6731 ratio. We then adopt
(O III) for derivation of O2+, Ne2+ and Ar3+.
To derive the electron temperature for O+ ion, we used the
relation between
(O II) and
(O III)
fitted by ITL94 for the photoionized H II models of Stasinska
(1990).
(O II) has been used to
derive the O+, N+ and Fe+ ionic abundances. For Ar2+and S2+ we have used an electronic temperature intermediate
between
(O II) and
(O III) following the
prescription of Garnett (1992).
Total element abundances have been derived after correction for unobserved
stages of ionization as described by ITL94. For the case applicable to HS 0837+4717, when the strong nebular He II 4686 emission
line is present, this implies that a non-negligible amount of O3+ ion should present. Its abundance is derived from the relation:
![]() |
(1) |
![]() |
(2) |
The derived values of (O III),
(O II),
(S III) and
(S II) for this
supergiant H II region are shown in Table 3.
The ionic and total abundances in the table are derived from the two
MMT spectra according to the methods described in ITL94 and in Izotov
et al. (1997a, hereafter ITL97). Since they showed a mutual
consistency, we averaged their derived parameters.
In the derivation of the O, N and Fe abundances, the broad low
intensity underlying components of the strongest emission lines H,
H
and [O III]
4959,5007, and WR broad lines were
taken into account (see Sect. 3.2).
For the abundance determination only
the fluxes of the narrow (instrumental width) components of these
strong lines
were used. In the derivation of the Cl abundance, we used
the respective formula from Aller (1984) with the ICF adopted
from Stasinska (1990). The abundances found here are well
consistent with the previous results from BTA those in Kniazev et al.
(2000a) and those based on the SDSS spectra (Kniazev
et al. 2003).
As evident from Table 3, the
object belongs to the group of the most metal-poor
H II-galaxies, which includes only 1-2 per cent of the known BCGs.
Notice the very high abundance of nitrogen. The N/O ratio
is 6 times higher than the typical value for all
known XMD BCGs. As shown in IT99,
BCGs with
have
with a very small scatter (Fig. 4).
The relative abundances of the other elements in HS 0837+4717 are close
to the mean values for the XMD BCGs (IT99).
Table 3: Abundances in the supergiant H II region.
![]() |
Figure 3:
Gaussian multicomponent fitting (solid lines) of the BTA spectra of
HS 0837+4717 (dotted lines).
Top panel: region of the blue bump;
middle panel: region of H![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 4:
Distribution of ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The Wolf-Rayet features of the blue bump (near 4650 Å) and broad
low-contrast components of the strong emission lines H
,
H
,
[O III]
4959,5007 are evident in both the MMT and BTA spectra of HS 0837+4717. This allows us
to check the accuracy of the derived parameters.
In Fig. 3 we show an expanded view of the BTA spectrum with
the Gaussian decomposition of the narrow lines and the broad component
of He II 4686 and the WR lines N III
4640, attributed to late WN stars,
and C IV
4658, attributed to WC stars (e.g., SV98).
The latter also could appear as the red bump centered at
5808.
This bump, however, is barely detected in our spectra.
Its flux as estimated (S/N ratio
2) from the
MMT spectrum, is
erg cm-2 s-1.
The parameters of fitted lines in different spectra are consistent
within their rather large uncertainties.
The parameters of narrow and broad lines are presented in Tables 2 and 4, respectively.
Table 4: Parameters of the WR lines and of the broad components.
The broad components of the strong emission lines of H,
H
and [O III]
4959,5007 originate in the ionized gas
moving
with velocities of
1-2 thousand km s-1. Such high velocities are
related either to supernovae shells or to stellar winds of massive
stars. Since the widths of the Balmer and the [O III] lines are
similar,
it is reasonable to suggest that both originate in the same regions.
While broad features centered at H
(the He II
4861 + H
blend) and H
(the He II
6562 + H
blend), characteristic of WR stars (e.g., SV98),
should
contribute to the broad components of the Balmer lines, their relative
strengths calculated from models are expected to be tens of times lower
than ones observed in HS 0837+4717. Therefore their origin in this galaxy, as well as in
other similar cases, can probably be attributed to rather young
remnants of multiple SN explosions. Having the line
intensity ratios for the broad components, we can address the physical
conditions in the regions of their formation.
The parameters of broad components of these four lines are presented in
Table 4.
It is evident that these components have systematically
higher line fluxes in the BTA spectra. This can be attributed to the
wider slit (2
at BTA vs. 1
5 at MMT) and to the different PA.
![]() |
Figure 5:
Left panel: intensity distribution along the slit of the
continuum between H![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The Balmer decrement of the broad line components, I(H)/I(H
) appears unusually large.
Accounting for the significant uncertainties,
we accept the average of the MMT and BTA ratios for the fluxes of the
broad and narrow
components of H
,
equal to (
)%. The same average
ratio for H
is (
)%. Adopting a flux
ratio of the narrow H
to H
lines, corrected for extinction,
of 2.76, a Balmer ratio for the broad components is
.
Such a large Balmer decrement is rather unusual. To ensure its reality
we checked two possible factors, which could in principle enhance the
Balmer ratio. The first one is underlying stellar absorption in the Balmer
lines,
which has an EW comparable to the EW(broad H), and hence could
affect it. However,
since the FWHM of stellar absorption lines (
200 km s-1) is
typically
7 times smaller than that of broad emission component, the effect of
stellar
H
absorption will decrease the flux of broad emission H
at most by 15%.
The second factor could be purely instrumental: light scattering in the
spectrograph of the strong lines could produce some artifacts with
arbitrary
ratio of intensities. This certainly can be excluded, since we
observed another object during the same night at the MMT and found even
stronger emission lines, but with no hints of the broad components.
Thus, this very large Balmer decrement is either related to substantial
internal extinction of the regions where the broad Balmer lines are formed,
or to the excitation of hydrogen levels by electron collisions,
or both. For the latter, H/H
ratio can reach the value of 5.8 for
K (Chamberlain 1953).
Thus, even for the case of
electron excitation, some significant extinction (accounting for the
additional factor of at least
in the Balmer line
ratio)
should be invoked for the regions of the broad Balmer lines formation.
Using
the Whitford extinction law, the latter possibility corresponds to
and an additional extinction in the B-band of
mag! The latter indicates that the
broad line emission forms in, or propagates through, a very dusty medium,
contrary to what is observed for the narrow line H II region type
emission.
If no alternative explanation of the large Balmer decrement is found,
this implies that the fluxes of broad features, and of the unknown optical
continuum related to them, should be corrected by a factor of 25-100,
depending on the wavelength.
Such correction will raise the total luminosity of the BCG by a factor
of several.
The highly obscured regions are
quite typical of starbursts observed in mergers.
Moreover, in the XMD BCG SBS 0335-052 E mid-IR observations reveal a highly obscured starburst
(Hunt et al. 2001).
We also point out the very large difference between the ratio
of I(4959)/I(H
)
for the narrow and the broad
components:
for the average of the MMT and BTA data they are 1.88 and 0.62,
respectively.
Is this due to the effect of significant collisional de-excitation of O++ ions, or to a significantly lower O/H ratio in the regions of
broad
line formation, or their lower
? It is possible that all
these factors combine to produce the observed effect.
To answer these questions, higher S/N ratio data will be helpful.
Below we exploit the advantage of long-slit spectra to
examine various morphological features of the object.
The seeing during the MMT observations (
)
and BTA observations in the red (
)
was
significantly less than the full extent of both line and continuum
emission (8
-10
), and allows the performance of a coarse analysis
of the
BCG substructure. Note that what we refer to as seeing is the width
of an unresolved object as measured perpendicular to the spectrograph's
dispersion
and so includes contributions from the atmosphere as well as the
telescope and spectrograph optics.
In Fig. 5 we show the intensity profiles of the
continuum
along the slit on the MMT spectrum averaged over the line-free spectral
ranges (in the rest frame system) of 4110-4310 Å and 5900-6400 Å.
For comparison, the intensity distribution in a narrow band, centered
on the H+[N II] lines is also presented.
The intensity distributions of the continuum in Fig. 5 and of the strong emission lines are different. The latter have well fitted PSF profiles, with the FWHM close to that of seeing. Some very faint wings/pedestal are present, which have just the appearance of the PSF at a few per cent level of the peak value.
Table 5: Main parameters of HS 0837+4717.
The spatial distribution of continuum in the BCG shows some additional
features. The main peak, related to the current starburst,
fully coincides in position (along the slit) with the
peak of the line emission. This starburst continuum component dominates the
other components. However, an additional
component (knot) on the MMT spectrum is seen at 2
2 (1.8 kpc) to the SSW, with the relative flux of
25%
in the blue
and of
28% in the red. This implies that the (B-R) of the faint
"knot'' is
0
13 redder than that of the
current starburst, which
dominates the BCG light and determines its integrated colours. Based on
the relation above we can approximately estimate the (B-R) colour of
the faint knot. From the data in Table 5, the integrated (B-R)0 is 0.15. This colour is affected by the strong emission lines
included in both filters. Accounting for the EWs of
these lines and for the effective widths of both filters, we estimate
that the (B-R) of the continuum component is redder due to the emission
lines by
0.12. This implies that the net continuum of HS 0837+4717
has a
.
The latter is very similar to the colour
(B-R)=-0.05 of the mixture
of a starburst with an age of 3.7 Myr and the continuum produced by gas at
K.
The former, according to the PEGASE.2 model (with a Salpeter IMF with
limits of 0.1 and 120 M
and Z=Z
/20), is
(B-R)=-0.24, while the latter, from the data in Aller
(1984),
has
(B-R)=+0.53. They are mixed in the proportion that results in the
observed narrow-line EW(H
Å.
We accept the bright component continuum colour of
(B-R)=-0.05, and
from the
latter we obtain for the faint knot
.
For an instantaneous star formation (SF) with the same IMF and
Z=Z
/20, this
(B-R) corresponds to an age of
25 Myr.
Apart from this fainter knot of continuum emission, there is also some
diffuse component, stretching further to the SW and NE, as seen
at the V-band image in Fig. 1.
We estimate the intrinsic size of the supergiant H II region from a
comparison of the FWHM of its strong emission lines with that of PSF.
Unfortunately, for the sharpest images (
,
BTA observations in
the red), the seeing fluctuated, therefore it is difficult to
accept the value of the FWHM for the PSF. For the MMT observations the
situation is better.
A nearby star appears on the slit and can be used to estimate the PSF
at various wavelengths. The weighted mean of the FWHM(PSF)
in red and green is 1
60.
The FWHM(intrinsic), derived as the weighted mean of the values in
red and green, is
.
FWHM(intrinsic)
were calculated by quadratic subtraction of the FWHM(PSF) from the measured
FWHM of strong lines.
The size of the faint knot is difficult to measure directly. However, from the
decomposition
of the light distribution along the slit, shown in Fig. 5, the FWHM of
this knot is
2
2. Adopting the same FWHM of the PSF,
we obtain a coarse estimate for the intrinsic size of the faint knot as
FWHM(knot)
1
5.
These sizes correspond to a FWHM linear diameters of the two components
of
0.58 kpc and
1.25 kpc, respectively.
Summarizing this analysis, we find that along the major axis at its
brightest
part, this BCG has a double-nucleus structure with characteristic sizes
of the components
of 0.6 and 1.25 kpc, respectively, and a projected distance of 2
2 (1.8 kpc) between the components. The total extent of the underlying
low-surface-brightness
(LSB) component is
10
(8 kpc). The nature of the
faint knot is not clear. But since it is also quite blue, one can
expect that this is also related to the recent SF event.
![]() |
Figure 6:
Left panel: intensity distribution of H![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The slit position at
is expected to be the optimal one to
see the overall rotation of this galaxy.
However, the respective P-V diagram does not look like a typical
rotation.
We discuss below two possible explanations for the unusual distribution
of the radial velocity.
The first one treats the P-V diagram as the consequence of
counter-rotation.
At positive coordinates along the slit we see the receding
branch of the rotation curve with a velocity
amplitude of 50-70 km s-1 (depending on how the real curve is drawn
between
the two last points) relative to the brightness peak velocity.
However, the symmetric (approaching) continuation of this branch at
negative
coordinates is not seen. Instead, the receding branch is present,
with an amplitude of 20-30 km s-1. This could probably indicate 2 dynamically decoupled gas systems.
A difference of 30 km s-1 between the radial velocities near the peak
of the H
emission for
and
can be attributed to small difference in the zero-points
of the dispersion curves for the two independent spectra.
Another explanation treats the part of P-V diagram at negative coordinates
as a significant velocity disturbance relative to the extrapolated
approaching
branch. This could be related to a strong outflow from the recent SF episode.
If one is to draw the approaching branch of the rotation curve as a
symmetric extrapolation of the receding one, the resulting difference
between
the observed data and drawn approaching branch shows us the form of the
disturbance. This resembles the common wave-like form of supershells,
as they are usually seen on P-V diagrams of starbursting galaxies.
The velocity of such supershell relative to the background rotation
velocity is 70-100 km s-1. Its visible extent is
2
.
The results could indicate that only a half of the shell is seen, which
is closer to the center.
Therefore, its full extent could be
4
,
or
3.3 kpc.
Such features in P-V diagrams are detected in many BCGs, and
the most
plausible explanation is related to the expansion of supershells formed
in the ionized gas
due to the recent star-forming activity in these objects.
Supershells are produced by hot bubbles, originating from the
energy injection of numerous massive star winds and supernovae (SNe)
explosions into the galactic ISM (e.g., Tenorio-Tagle & Bodenheimer
1988).
In particular, a similar, but scaled down according to the parameters
of the host galaxy, supershell in HS 0822+3542 was discussed
by Pustilnik et al. (2003a). The energy of that supershell
with a diameter of 0.48 kpc and a velocity amplitude of 30 km s-1 was
provided by 13 SNe. Assuming the same density of ambient gas of 0.1 cm-2,
with the supershell parameters as observed in HS 0837+4717 (adopting a
minimal
km s-1), we derive a total
energy larger by a factor of
1770. This corresponds to
23 000 SNe exploded during a period of the order of one dynamical age of the
supershell. The latter is
Myr
(Weaver et al. 1977). This would imply the existence of a
star cluster with an age of
17 Myr, provided the mean rate
1700 SNe per Myr during last
14 Myr (recall, that SNe begin to explode
in the cluster after
3 Myr). From this SN rate and a PEGASE.2 model with the same IMF as above, we derive the mass of such a cluster of
.
For a galaxy of this high luminosity and an apparent diameter of 10 kpc, the estimated rotation velocity is rather small.
The inclination correction, if applicable, is modest.
From the apparent axial ratio of this BCG (
p=b/a=0.67), it
follows, that in the case of a stable rotating disk, i is quite large.
Indeed, from the well known formula:
,
and the range of
intrinsic ratio for disk-like galaxies of
q=b/a=0.2-0.3, the iwould fall in the range of 49
-52
.
The respective correction of 1/
(
i)=1.27-1.32.
In this case the corrected
can reach the value of 65 to 90 km s-1, within the range characteristic of low-mass galaxies.
If this object is a merger, gas motions due
to dissipative collisions could be significantly decoupled from the
motion of stars.
Until the system relaxes, the gas motions are bad tracers of mass
distribution (e.g., Amram & Östlin 2001). Therefore the amplitude
of the rotation velocity observed in H
could be unrelated
to the overall gravitational potential.
In the light of the discussion on the possible merger nature of HS 0837+4717, it is important to inspect the 2D morphology of the galaxy. Its grey-scale V-band image with isophotes superimposed is shown in Fig. 1.
The overall structure is asymmetric and somewhat disturbed,
both near the center, and in the peripheral regions. In particular, the
fainter component at 2
to the South (which is seen in the
continuum on the long-slit spectrum) is apparent on this image, however
smeared due to the seeing effect. The outermost isophotes indicate
several appendages to the main body.
Disregarding the faintest isophote as being subject to noise,
we notice two small features,
at NNW and SSE of the center, the latter being much more prominent.
The BCG images
available from the Data Release 1 (DR1) database
of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) (York et al. 2000;
Abazajian et al. 2003) corroborate this disturbed morphology.
As described above, small transparency variations took place during
imaging with the Wise 1-m telescope.
In order to minimize their effect on the object's integrated magnitudes,
we selected from each of the nights the brightest value in each of the
bands, and compared them with the magnitudes, derived through the
convolution of the MMT spectrum. For U-band we could not use an MMT measurement due to the limited wavelength coverage. Therefore, even
though the U-band magnitudes for both nights are consistent within the
observational
uncertainties, they should be treated with caution. The brightest
values
for the Wise measurements in B and R are consistent with the MMT data within the uncertainties, therefore we accept
them with an rms error of 0
10. In the V-band, however, the
brightest magnitude on Wise data is still 0
27 fainter than the
respective
magnitude derived from the MMT spectrum. Therefore, for V we accept
the MMT derived value. The integrated photometry data are summarized
in Table 5.
The very red (B-V) (0.9) and blue (V-R) (
-0.7) colours of
this object are related to the very large EWs of the [O III]
4959 and
5007 Å emission lines, redshifted to the
center of V-band. This can be checked by the convolution of the
deredshifted BCG spectrum (see Table 5).
Effectively, we observed HS 0837+4717 in "on+off'' positions for 320 min and, after smoothing, obtained an rms noise of 1.3 mK. This
translates to an rms in flux density of 1.6 mJy. Since no signal
was detected, we put a 2 upper limit of 3.2 mJy on the peak
flux density from the galaxy.
The full amplitude of ionized gas velocity variations,
100-140 km s-1 is used to estimate the upper limit of the H I flux. Adopting
this
value as an estimate of
for the H I profile,
the
upper limit of the integrated H I flux is of (0.32-0.45) Jy km s-1.
The respective upper limit on the H I mass is M(H I,BCG
.
The integrated parameters of HS 0837+4717 are summarized in Table 5.
There are two unusual properties, which are probably related. The first
one is the high luminosity of this BCG for its very low metallicity (see,
e.g., plots of O/H versus
in Kunth & Östlin 2000;
Pustilnik et al. 2003b).
The second one is the very large nitrogen abundance excess: N/O is a
factor of
6 larger than for other BCGs with similar O/H.
The first property can be attributed to an exceptionally strong
starburst, which
causes an additional brightening by several magnitudes. Pustilnik
et al. (2001b) argued that the majority of starbursts in BCGs are
triggered by interactions of various strengths with other galaxies. The
range spreads from weak tidal interactions through strong tidals and
the sinking of satellites to
merging of low-mass galaxies. The latter case can be considered as a
down-scaled analog of ultraluminous IR galaxies, mergers of
massive gas-rich galaxies (e.g., Genzel et al. 2001).
Below we discuss the possibility that HS 0837+4717 as well could be
an advanced merger.
Telles & Terlevich (1997) found that the most luminous BCGs show disturbed external morphologies, while low luminosity BCGs show regular morphology. In their detailed studies of several luminous BCGs, Östlin et al. (1999,2001) found morphological and kinematic evidences for the merger nature of these galaxies. HS 0837+4717 is similar to their BCGs in several aspects.
As shown above, the overall disturbed morphology of this BCG, its "double-nucleus'' appearance, and the presence of appendages on the periphery, presumably imply some recent disturbance. However, no disturbing galaxies are visible in the environment of this BCG (see Sect. 4.5).
In addition, the distribution of the ionized gas velocity also appears
disturbed, mainly near the edges of the galaxy.
The gas motions along the
apparent major axis show large deviations from the expected regular
rotation.
These could be related either to a counter-rotating gaseous component,
or to a very energetic supershell.
The two knots, related to the current/recent starbursts
are very massive.
Indeed, from the photometry in Table 5 and numbers derived
in Sect. 3.3, from a PEGASE.2 model with Z=Z/20,
and a Salpeter IMF as above, we find the following.
For the brighter component with
and an age of 3.7 Myr
the mass of starburst is
.
As shown above, a significant part of this starburst could be highly
obscured by dust. Therefore, its unobscured blue luminosity could be
several times higher than that listed here. This would translate to a
total mass for this starburst region of
.
For the faint knot
.
Its colour (B-R) corresponds to an instantaneous SF burst with an age
of 25 Myr.
With the same IMF as above, PEGASE.2 predicts
a star
cluster mass of
.
Also, from the parameters
of the suggested supershell at the NE edge of the galaxy, we estimate
the mass of the embedded star cluster with an age of
17 Myr as
.
Such massive starbursts should
involve
molecular clouds with the masses of 108 M
or more. We will
return to this point in Sect. 4.4.
Finally, as shown, e.g., by Mihos & Hernquist (1996), very
energetic starbursts are characteristic of merging galaxies.
An alternative option for such a case is a strong interaction with an undetected massive object, such as very LSB galaxy or a hydrogen cloud devoid of stars, similar to the case of Dw 1225+0152 (Salzer et al. 1991).
Table 6: Starburst galaxies with significant nitrogen excess.
The WR stellar population is observed only in four of about 30 XMD BCGs known. They include I Zw 18 (Izotov et al. 1997c; Legrand et al. 1997), SBS 0335-052E (Izotov et al. 2001), Tol 1214-277 (Fricke et al. 2001) and UM 133 (Kniazev et al. 2001, 2004, in prep.). Thus, HS 0837+4717 is the fifth XMD BCG with a detected WR population. While the accuracy of the flux measurements of the broad WR features on the available spectra is far from sufficient for accurate prediction, it is useful to obtain an estimate of the WR-to-O star relative numbers.
To derive N(WR)/N(O+WR), we follow the approach
described in detail by Guseva et al. (2000).
The number of WR stars was derived from the luminosity of the WR lines.
Their fluxes were derived directly from the 1-D spectra,
as discussed in Sect. 3.2.1.
No aperture correction was applied to the WR-line fluxes, assuming that
this emission
is produced in a compact region with an angular size less than the
width of the slit.
The number of O stars was derived from the total H luminosity
for the brightest SF region (
),
corrected for the contribution of WR stars and for the
aperture effect. For the latter we adopt the circular symmetry of
the bright SF region as seen in the direct image.
To estimate the fraction of the undetected H
flux,
the radial distribution of the H
line intensity,
shown in Fig. 2, was used.
The respective correction factor for the total H
flux is 1.66.
The number of O stars is derived from the number of ionizing photons
,
which is related to the total luminosity
of the H
emission line
(H
)
by
![]() |
(3) |
Assuming the luminosity of a single WN7 star to be
ergs s-1 in the broad He II
4686 line or
ergs s-1 in the blue bump (SV98), we estimate
from the WR line
fluxes derived on
the MMT spectrum,
to be either 500, or 860. Adopting the average
of the two estimates for WN stars, we get the sum number of WR stars (WN+WC) in the young starburst to be
1000.
Following to SV98
and using the observed value of EW(H
Å,
we estimate the burst age and the parameter
(updated model
version of 1999, as presented in Starburst99) in
HS 0837+4717 as 3.7 Myr, and
0.65, respectively.
The total number of O stars in HS 0837+4717 is found
to be
.
This yields a relative number
of WR stars to O stars N(WR)/(N(O + WR) of 0.02,
coinciding with the model prediction in SV98.
The possibility of enhanced N abundance in galaxies with the spectral
signatures of WR stars, in comparison to other galaxies of similar
metallicity
was first noticed by Pagel et al. (1986) where no details on
the strength of this effect were given. The occurrences of a significant
nitrogen excess in galaxies are very rare. For example, among more
than one hundred BCGs with well measured heavy element
abundances (e.g., IT99; Ugryumov et al. 2003)
only four galaxies (Mkn 996, UM 420, Mkn 1089 and UM 448)
exhibit a nitrogen excess of a factor of 3 and larger,
relative to the value appropriate for their O/H (Thuan et al.
1996; IT99).
All four have
and show broad WR lines (Guseva et al. 2000; Thuan et al. 1996).
One more similar galaxy, Haro 11 is found among the luminous BCGs studied by
Bergvall & Östlin (2002).
With
it has
a nitrogen abundance excess
of a factor of
6. Strong signatures of WR population are detected
in this BCG as well.
An excess of the nitrogen abundance by a factor of 3 is also detected
in two central H II regions (both with detectable WR population)
of the nearby starbursting dwarf irregular galaxy NGC 5253
with
(Kobulnicky et al. 1997, and references
therein). In Table 6 we summarize the parameters of
all known such
galaxies,
and below
draw some tentative empirical correlations.
First, most of these galaxies could be identified as various
stages of mergers. Second, as a subgroup of starbursting galaxies, 70% of them are luminous
(
), thus are not classical dwarf
galaxies.
Third, all these
objects are WR galaxies.
Fourth, all these BCGs but one have
in
the range of
7.9 to 8.16. HS 0837+4717 is the only such galaxy
belonging to the XMD group.
The scenarios of localized nitrogen enrichment, as well as the
constraints
imposed by the known mechanisms of fresh elements mixing and dispersal
were
discussed in detail by Kobulnicky et al. (1997) (see also Roy
& Kunth 1995). They concluded that, in the light of the expected
short timescales for dispersal in the interstellar medium (ISM) of a few Myr,
the localized nature of the N enrichment suggests a very recent pollution
event, probably connected with the onset of massive star winds.
The alternative analysis of Tenorio-Tagle (1996) suggests the
timescale
of 100 Myr to mix fresh metals from a cluster of massive stars with
the gas in a disk galaxy. However, this can be barely applicable for very
complex flow patterns expected in the vicinity of merger starbursts.
In particular,
the very
rare occurrence of objects with a large N overabundance, similar to that
observed in Mkn 996 and HS 0837+4717,
favors
the general idea of
the both short-time scales: for localized N pollution and its fast
dispersal.
It is worth noting that a selection effect, related to the starburst strength and its trigger mechanism, will affect the observed frequency of this phenomenon, probably determining the overall scale of the polluted region. In particular, the large N excess in the central starbursts of NGC 5253 would be barely detected with ground-based spectroscopy, if this galaxy was a few times more distant.
On the large scales, the volume
around HS 0837+4717
is well sampled only by the objects from the Updated Zwicky Catalog
(Falco et al. 1999), which is complete to
.
At the BCG distance
they all are luminous,
with
,
and are located
outside the sphere with R = 8.4 Mpc, centered at HS 0837+4717.
This implies that HS 0837+4717 is situated in a void
(as several other XMD BCGs are, Pustilnik et al. 2003a).
New data on the distribution of fainter galaxies with measured redshifts
from the SDSS DR1 database (Abazajian et al. 2003) around HS 0837+4717
show no objects within this sphere, corroborating the classification
HS 0837+4717 as a void galaxy.
One of the goals of detailed studies of the properties of individual XMD BCGs is to establish how homogeneous is this group of galaxies. Current models suggest various evolution scenarios that would result in a large metal deficiency of a galaxy's ISM. They include both a significant loss of fresh metals via galactic superwinds, related to strong starbursts, and/or the infall of unprocessed intergalactic matter onto normally evolved galaxy. The third option is a very slow astration due to very low surface gas density and the stabilizing role of the Dark Matter (DM) halos (as, e.g., for LSB galaxies). Finally, one of the most intriguing options is that of truly young XMD galaxies.
Known XMD galaxies can, in principle, be the products of any of these evolutionary scenarios. Therefore, their properties could show significant diversity. HS 0837+4717 is, in this context, an outlier among XMD BCGs and could yield important information on alternative evolutionary scenarios.
What are the main differences between HS 0837+4717 and
prototypical
XMD BCGs
I Zw 18 and SBS 0335-052E,
both known to show WR features (Sect. 4.3),
but not an excess nitrogen abundance?
The BCG discussed here, is the most luminous
and is probably the largest galaxy in
this
group. The latter
implies a rather massive baryon and DM configuration, capable
in the isolated state
of
maintaining a large fraction of the newly produced metals.
Its
value of M(H I)/
implies
either significant processing of neutral gas,
or a very strong starburst,
or both.
Also, a significant gas mass fraction could be
hidden in molecular form. The latter is more
characteristic of
luminous IR galaxies, a class of galaxies tightly connected to powerful starbursts
due to the merging of gas-rich galaxies.
The strong starbursts, in turn,
occur
when they encompass
a significant part of the galaxy gas mass, what
is expected in case of
strong disturbances. Merging of two galaxies
provides the strongest possible
disturbance. This allows the breaking of the gas equilibrium even in
very stable configurations, and results in the efficient gas sinking
into
the dynamical center of merged object with a subsequent intense SF burst (e.g., Mihos & Hernquist 1996).
The
important aspect of star formation in a merger is related to
the processes taking place in the pre-merger phase.
As shown by Elmegreen et al. (1993), the interstellar gas
of pre-merger galaxy
is highly agitated. This results in a
significant
increase of the Jeans mass for forming gravitationally bound molecular
clouds
(up to 10
8-109 M).
The latter
could be progenitors of the HS 0837+4717 very massive starbursts.
As discussed, e.g., by Elmegreen
(1999), in regions with very high SF activity one should
expect a shift of the IMF to higher masses. Similarly, due to the lower
cooling efficiency at very low metallicity, the Jeans mass
is expected to be
higher, again resulting in an upward shift of the respective IMF.
This could result in a significant increase of the relative fraction of
massive stars, and
a larger effect of WR stars on
the local nitrogen enrichment.
Thus, the option of
merging of two slowly evolving XMD LSB galaxies could be a plausible
explanation for the XMD BCGs with such atypical properties.
We performed a complex study of one of the very metal-deficient BCG HS 0837+4717. The long-slit high S/N ratio spectrophotometry was complemented by a study of the ionized gas velocity distribution, by H I radio line 21-cm total flux measurements and by broad-band imaging photometry. The observed properties of this object are extreme in several aspects.
This is the most luminous BCG with a metallicity less than or of the
order of Z/20. Its observed unusual colours are
caused mainly by the very strong [O III] emission lines shifted into
the
V-band due to its significant redshift. The factor of 6 nitrogen
overabundance in its supergiant H II region, in comparison to
other very metal-deficient BCGs, implies either a non-typical evolution
track for HS 0837+4717, or some very short transitional phase of star
formation, or both.
The ionized gas kinematics appears rather disturbed. There is an
indication of either counter-rotation, or of a supershell.
The BCG overall disturbed optical morphology with the "double-nucleus''
central structure, and two small appendages at its periphery, may
support the hypothesis of an advanced merger.
Recent images of this BCG from the SDSS DR1 database corroborate
the described appearance.
Among the known BCGs with the well measured N/O, there are two objects with the larger N excesses, and three more BCGs with an excess of a factor of 3 relative to the norm for this type of objects. All of them are WR galaxies; almost all belong to the group of luminous BCGs; and all can be interpreted as various stages of mergers. This suggests that HS 0837+4717 could presumably be the most metal-poor representative of this group.
From the results and discussion above we draw the following conclusions:
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to the referee D. Kunth for useful suggestions, which allowed to improve the analysis and results presentation. The authors acknowledge the partial support from INTAS grants 96-0500 and 97-0033. SAO authors acknowledge the partial support from the Russian Federal program "Astronomy''. Y.I. thanks the support of National Science Foundation grant AST 02-05785 and of the Swiss SCOPE 7UKPJ62178 grant. N.B. acknowledges support from the Israel Science Foundation and from Austrian Friends of Tel Aviv University. This research has made use of the NASA/IPAC Extragalactic Database (NED), which is operated by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, under contract with the National Aeronautics and Space Administration. The SDSS DR1 database is completed for public use thanks to the funding by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation, the SDSS member institutions, the National Aeronautics and Space Administration, the National Science Foundation, the U.S. Department of Energy, the Japanese Monbukagakusho, and the Max Planck Society. The SDSS Web site is http://www.sdss.org/.