A&A 417, 1-11 (2004)
M. Gitti1,2,3 - G. Brunetti3 - L. Feretti3 - G. Setti2,3
1 - Institut für Astrophysik, Universität Innsbruck, Technikerstraße 25, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria
2 - Dipartimento di Astronomia, Università di Bologna, via Ranzani 1, 40127 Bologna, Italy
3 - Istituto di Radioastronomia del CNR, via Gobetti 101, 40129 Bologna, Italy
Received 11 June 2003 / Accepted 24 November 2003
Recently a theoretical model has been proposed that accounts for the origin of radio mini-halos observed in some cooling flow clusters as related to electron re-acceleration by MHD turbulence (Gitti et al. 2002). The MHD turbulence is assumed to be frozen into the flow of the thermal ICM and thus amplified in the cooling flow region. Here we present the application of this model to a new mini-halo candidate, the cluster A2626, and compare the results with those obtained for the mini-halo in the Perseus cluster. We present VLA data at 330 MHz and 1.5 GHz of the diffuse radio emission observed in A2626, and we show that its main properties can be explained by the model. We find that the power necessary for the re-acceleration of the relic electron population is only a factor of 0.7% of the maximum power that can be extracted from the cooling flow (as estimated on the basis of the standard model). We also discuss the observational properties of known mini-halos in connection with those of host clusters, showing that the radio power of mini-halos increases with the maximum power of cooling flows. This trend is expected in the framework of the model. Possible effects of new Chandra and XMM-Newton estimates of on this trend are considered: we conclude that even if earlier derived cooling rates were overestimated, cooling flow powers are still well above the radio powers emitted by mini-halos.
Key words: acceleration of particles - radiation mechanisms: non-thermal - galaxies: cooling flows - galaxies: clusters: general - galaxies: clusters: individual: A2626
A number of clusters of galaxies show extended synchrotron emission not directly associated with the galaxies but rather diffused into the intra-cluster medium (ICM). These radio sources have been classified in three classes: cluster-wide halos, relics and mini-halos (Feretti & Giovannini 1996). Both cluster-wide halos and relics have low surface brightness, large size (1 Mpc) and steep spectrum, but the former are located at the cluster centers and show low or negligible polarized emission, while the latter are located at the cluster peripheries and are highly polarized. They have been found in clusters which show significant evidence of an ongoing merger (e.g., Edge et al. 1992; Giovannini & Feretti 2002). It was proposed that recent cluster mergers may play an important role in the re-acceleration of the radio-emitting relativistic particles, thus providing the energy to these extended sources (e.g., Schlickeiser et al. 1987; Tribble 1993; Brunetti et al. 2001). The merger picture is consistent with the occurrence of large-scale radio halos in clusters without a cooling flow, since the major merger event is expected to disrupt a cooling flow (e.g., Sarazin 2002 and references therein).
In spite of the observed anti-correlation between the presence of cooling flows and extended radio emission in clusters of galaxies, there are several cooling flow clusters where the relativistic particles can be traced out quite far from the central galaxy, forming what is called a "mini-halo'' (e.g. Perseus: Burns et al. 1992; Abell 2390: Bacchi et al. 2003). Mini-halos are diffuse steep-spectrum radio sources, extended on a moderate scale (up to 500 kpc), surrounding a dominant radio galaxy at the center of cooling flow clusters. Until recently, because of the presence of the central radio galaxy, these sources have been considered of different nature from that of extended halos and relics, and the problem of their origin has never been investigated in detail.
Mini-halos do not appear as extended lobes maintained by an Active Galactic Nucleus (AGN), as in classical radio galaxies (Giovannini & Feretti 2002), therefore their radio emission is indicative of the presence of diffuse relativistic particles and magnetic fields in the ICM. Rizza et al. (2000) presented three-dimensional numerical simulations of perturbed jet propagating through a cooling flow atmosphere to study the interaction between the radio plasma and the hot ICM in cooling flow clusters containing steep-spectrum radio sources. The evolution and spectrum of relativistic particles, however, is not considered in these simulations. The point is that the radiative lifetime of the radio-emitting electrons injected at a given time in the strong magnetic fields present in cooling flow regions is of the order of 107-108 yr, much shorter than the transport time necessary to cover hundred kpc scales, so that the diffuse radio emission from mini-halos may suggest the presence of re-accelerated electrons.
More specifically, Gitti et al. (2002, hereafter GBS) suggested that the diffuse synchrotron emission from radio mini-halos is due to a relic population of relativistic electrons re-accelerated by MHD turbulence via Fermi-like processes, with the necessary energetics supplied by the cooling flow.
Alternatively, Pfrommer & Enßlin (2004) in a very recent paper discussed the possibility that the radiating electrons in radio mini-halos are of secondary origin and thus injected during proton-proton collision in the ICM.
The main aim of the present work is the application of GBS's model to a new mini-halo candidate, A2626 (z=0.0604, Rizza et al. 2000), and the discussion of the observational properties of the population of radio mini-halos so far discovered.
In Sect. 2 we briefly review GBS's model and its application to the Perseus cluster. In Sect. 3 we consider the radio source observed in A2626: first, we present VLA data analysis and discuss the possibility that this source belongs to the mini-halo class, then we apply GBS's model to this cluster and discuss the results. In Sect. 4 we present the observational properties of other radio mini-halo candidates in relation to those of host clusters and discuss them in the framework of GBS's model.
For consistency with GBS, a Hubble constant is assumed in this paper, therefore at the distance of A2626 1' corresponds to 95 kpc. The radio spectral index is defined such as and, where not specified, all the formulae are in cgs system.
The radiative lifetime of an ensemble of relativistic electrons
losing energy by synchrotron emission and inverse Compton (IC) scattering off
the CMB photons is given by:
To evaluate the radiative losses in the cooling flow region at any distance from the cluster center it is necessary to parameterize the radial dependence of the field strength, which depends on the compression of the thermal gas in the cooling region (i.e., on , being the cooling radius). However, while the X-ray brightness and low resolution spectra are generally in agreement with the standard cooling flow model, recent observations with the Reflection Grating Spectrometer (RGS) on board XMM-Newton do not show evidence of gas cooling at temperatures lower than 1-2 keV (e.g., Peterson et al. 2003) as expected in the standard picture. In addition, both Chandra and XMM-Newton results indicate that the mass deposition rates in cooling flows have been previously overestimated by a factor 5-10 (e.g., Fabian & Allen 2003). The new rates lead to mass values not too different from the large masses of cold gas derived from the studies of the CO emission line detected in a number of cooling flow cluster candidates (Edge 2001; Salomé & Combes 2003). These findings, although not inconsistent with the idea that the gas cools down and is thus compressed towards the central region, point to a more complex situation than that described by the standard cooling flow model. Unfortunately, no successful model alternative to the standard model has been proposed yet and, therefore, we will evaluate the radial behaviour of the physical quantities in the ICM by making use of the standard - single phase - cooling flow model.
In the framework of this model, the intensity of the frozen-in magnetic field increases as for radial compression (Soker & Sarazin 1990) or for isotropic compression (Tribble 1993).
The time evolution of the energy of a relativistic electron
is determined by the competing processes of losses and re-accelerations
(both related to the magnetic field):
|Figure 1: Evolution of inside the cooling flow region for two different cases of re-acceleration: given by Fermi-like processes related to the MHD turbulence in the cooling flow (bold line; Eq. (4) for typical values of the parameters), and = constant (dashed line).|
|Open with DEXTER|
Under these assumptions, the stationary spectrum of the relativistic
electrons is given by:
The most striking evidence in favour of our model is provided by
the case of the Perseus cluster (A426, z=0.0183).
The diffuse radio emission from the mini-halo
(see left panel in Fig. 2)
has a total extension of 15' (at the redshift of the cluster
1' corresponds to 30 kpc)
and its morphology is correlated with that of the cooling flow X-ray map
(Sijbring 1993; Ettori et al. 1998).
|Figure 2: Left panel: 327 MHz map of the mini-halo in the Perseus cluster at a resolution of (Sijbring 1993). The cross indicates the position of the cD galaxy NGC 1275 and the dashed line represents the direction considered for the application of GBS's model. Right panel: X-ray (grey scale)/radio (contours) overlay for the central part of the Perseus cluster around NCG 1275 (Fabian et al. 2000); X-ray data are obtained with Chandra.|
|Open with DEXTER|
On smaller scales (1'), there is evidence of interaction between the radio lobes of the central radiogalaxy 3C 84 and the X-ray emitting intra-cluster gas (e.g., Böhringer et al. 1993; Fabian et al. 2000; see Fig. 2, right panel). A recent interpretation is that the holes in the X-ray emission are due to buoyant radio lobes which are currently expanding subsonically (Churazov et al. 2000; Fabian et al. 2002). The spectral index in these lobes ranges from 0.7 in the center to 1.5 in the outer regions (Pedlar et al. 1990), which is a value similar to the spectrum of the mini-halo extended over a scale 10 times larger. Therefore, it is difficult to find a direct connection between the radio lobes and the large-scale mini-halo in terms of simple buoyancy or particle diffusion: the expansion and buoyancy of blobs would produce adiabatic losses and a decrease of the magnetic field causing a too strong steepening of the spectrum which would prevent the detection of large-scale radio emission. In addition, the diffusion time (R2, with R= scale of interest; see also Sect. 3.2) is about 100 times longer than the radiative lifetime of the radio electrons.
Thus, if relativistic electrons are of primary origin, efficient re-acceleration mechanisms in the cooling flow region are necessary to explain the presence of the large-scale radio emission in Fig. 2; in particular, the detailed modelling of the radio properties of the mini-halo in Perseus (brightness profile, integrated spectrum and radial spectral steepening) resulted in good agreement with the data in case of isotropic compression of the magnetic field (GBS).
The cluster A2626 hosts a relatively strong cooling flow (White et al. 1997) and contains an amorphous radio source near to the center (Roland et al. 1985; Burns 1990) which is extended on a scale comparable to that of the cooling flow region with an elongation coincident with the X-ray distribution (Rizza et al. 2000).
X-ray image deprojection analysis of Einstein IPC derives a
mass deposition rate
a cooling radius
kpc and an average
keV (White et al. 1997).
From Soker & Sarazin (1990), one can estimate the proton number density
at the cooling radius as:
To extend the application of GBS's model to A2626, we have requested and analyzed some of the VLA archive data (Table 1) of A2626 with the aim to derive the surface brightness map, the total spectral index and the spectral index distribution of the diffuse radio emission.
Table 1: VLA data archive.
Standard data reduction was done using the National Radio Astronomy Observatory
(NRAO) AIPS package.
We used the 1.5 GHz C array data and the 330 MHz B+DnC array data
to produce low resolution images with a circular restoring beam of
17 arcsec. The imaging procedure at each frequency was performed using
data with matched uv coverage.
These images (Figs. 3 and 4)
allow to derive morphological and spectral information of the
|Figure 3: 1.5 GHz VLA map of A2626 at a resolution of . The contour levels are -0.06 (dashed), 0.06, 0.12, 0.24, 0.48, 0.96, 1.92, 2.5, 4, 8, 10, 12 mJy/beam. The rms noise is 0.02 mJy/beam. The cross indicates the position of the cluster center.|
|Open with DEXTER|
|Figure 4: 330 MHz VLA map of A2626 at a resolution of . The contour levels are -8.5 (dashed), 8.5, 17, 34, 68, 100, 135, 160 mJy/beam. The rms noise is 3.1 mJy/beam. The cross indicates the position of the cluster center and the dashed region defines the central brightness hole.|
|Open with DEXTER|
The diffuse structure at 330 MHz (Fig. 4) is smaller in extent, because of the lower sensitivity. It consists of two elongated almost parallel features located to the north and south of the core, respectively. No radio emission is detected at the location of the 1.5 GHz radio nucleus. Assuming for the 330 MHz core flux an upper limit of 3, we obtain that the radio core has an inverted spectrum (Table 2).
Table 2: Radio results for A2626.The total flux density of the diffuse emission is Jy. The unrelated source, detected at 1.5 GHz to the west of the diffuse radio emission, is not detected at 330 MHz; this implies a spectrum with .
In order to estimate the total integrated flux density
of the diffuse radio emission at 1.5 GHz and derive the surface
brightness map and spectral trend, it is necessary
to subtract the emission from the central nuclear source.
One way is to make a high-resolution image and then
extract the clean components of the central source.
By using the 1.5 GHz B array data
we produced the high resolution
image (Fig. 5) with a restoring beam of
|Figure 5: 1.5 GHz VLA map of A2626 at a resolution of . The contour levels are -0.09 (dashed), 0.09, 0.18, 0.36, 0.7, 1.4, 3, 5.5, 11, 20 mJy/beam. The rms noise is 0.03 mJy/beam.|
|Open with DEXTER|
As discussed in Sects. 3.2 and 3.3,
we believe that the elongated structures visible in Fig. 5
(or that they may represent an earlier evolutionary stage)
from the diffuse emission, and that the diffuse radio source
may belong to the mini-halo class.
The total flux density of these structures is 6.6 mJy,
thus contributing to only 20% of the flux of
the diffuse radio emission.
Since we are interested in studying and modelling the diffuse radio emission,
we produced a new low-resolution map at 1.5 GHz where these discrete
radio features have been subtracted (Fig. 6).
|Figure 6: 1.5 GHz VLA map of A2626 at a resolution of after the subtraction of the two elongated features visible in Fig. 5. The cross indicates the position of the cluster center. The contour levels are -0.18 (dashed), 0.18, 0.36, 0.72, 1.2, 1.85, 2.3 mJy/beam. The rms noise is 0.08 mJy/beam. The dash-dotted circle defines the nuclear region excluded in modelling the diffuse radio emission, while the solid line represents the direction we have considered for the surface brightness profile (see Fig. 8).|
|Open with DEXTER|
Unfortunately, due to the lack of a high-resolution image, the two elongated features cannot be subtracted at 330 MHz as well. Therefore, in deriving the spectral information of the diffuse emission we considered for consistency the low-resolution images in Figs. 3 and 4, which both include the contribution of the two features to the total flux.
The integrated spectral index of the diffuse emission between MHz and GHz is . If the two features consist of relatively fresh injected plasma (as discussed in Sect. 3.3), their spectrum is expected to be relatively flat and thus the real spectrum of the diffuse emission would be slightly steeper ( in the extreme case in which the two features do not contribute to the flux measured at 330 MHz).
In Fig. 7 we show a grey scale image of the spectral index map of the diffuse radio emission between MHz and GHz. The spectrum steepens from the central region towards the north and south direction, with the spectral index increasing from 1.2 to 3. The steepening in the northern region is slightly smoother than in the southern one.
|Figure 7: Spectral index distribution between MHz and GHz at a resolution of . The contours are in steps of 0.2, where the lightest grey is in the range 2.8 to 3. The lighter the grey, the steeper the spectral index. We have excluded the region in which the error is >0.2. The cross indicates the position of the subtracted radio core and the solid line represents the direction we have considered for the spectral steepening profile (see Fig. 10).|
|Open with DEXTER|
Electrons emitting at frequencies 1 GHz in magnetic fields of the order of 1-3 G (see Sect. 3.3) have a radiative lifetime (Eq. (1)) 7 yr.
The radio results are summarized in Table 2.
As presented in Sect. 3.1, the extended radio source observed at the center of A2626 is characterized by amorphous morphology, lack of polarized flux and a very steep spectrum that steepens with distance from the center. Finally, the morphology of the diffuse radio emission is similar to that of the cooling flow region (Rizza et al. 2000). These results indicate that the diffuse radio source may be classified as a mini-halo.
In addition, we notice that there are some concerns in interpreting this source without assuming the presence of particle re-acceleration. One possibility would be that the radio-emitting region is being supplied with fresh relativistic plasma that ultimately comes from the nucleus. Thus the observed diffuse radio emission would result from a bubble-like structures expanding into the surrounding cluster gas, as suggested for the large-scale radio structure of M 87 presented by Owen et al. (2000). Following the model adopted by these authors for M 87, by assuming that the bubble pressure remains comparable to the external pressure (that is approximately constant in a cooling flow region, resulting at ) we estimate that the age of the radio structure of A2626 at a radius 100 kpc would be yr (we adopted an internal adiabatic index of and the jet power P in units of ). We notice that, with a typical value , this age would be at least 10 times longer than the lifetime of the radio-emitting electrons, thus in situ acceleration would be necessary to energize the radio electrons. In addition we notice that this scenario is not able to explain the observed spectral steepening of the radio emission with distance. Another possibility, which instead may be able to explain a radial spectral steepening, would be particle diffusion out of the central region. The diffusion length is defined as (e.g., Fujita & Sarazin 2001), where is the spatial diffusion coefficient and the diffusion time. By assuming the commonly adopted Kolmogorov spectrum of the magnetic field it is possible to verify that for radio-emitting electrons (which typically have Lorentz factors and radiative lifetimes 108 yr) the diffusion length (by adopting the parallel diffusion coefficient, ) during their lifetime is kpc (e.g., Brunetti 2003). This diffusion length is thus a factor 3 shorter than the scale of interest in the radio source of A2626 (100 kpc). As a consequence, diffusion may be an efficient process only for electrons with energy 10 times smaller than that of those responsible for the large-scale radio emission. Anomalous diffusion may considerably increase the propagation of electrons perpendicular to the magnetic field lines (e.g., Duffy et al. 1995). This kind of diffusion increases with increasing the turbulence energy density; however, the ratio between anomalous and parallel diffusion coefficients is (Giacalone & Jokipii 1999; Enßlin 2003) and thus parallel diffusion still remains the most efficient way for particle diffusion also in the case of relatively powerful turbulence (i.e., ). One possibility to enhance anomalous diffusion is to significantly increase the turbulence energy density and change, at the same time, the ratio between large-scale and small-scale turbulence. This possibility has been discussed in the literature to allow a more efficient escape of cosmic rays from the cocoon of radio sources (Enßlin 2003). However, given typical conditions in a cooling flow region, an unlikely high level of MHD turbulence should be injected (e.g., 15-20) in order to guarantee an electron diffusion length of 100 kpc in <108 yr via enhanced anomalous diffusion, but this would also yield an extremely efficient particle acceleration via wave-particle scattering.
Given the above difficulties in explaining the amorphous radio structure observed in A2626, we apply GBS's model. However, the application is not straightforward as in the case of Perseus because of the presence of the two structured radio features observed about 20'' on either side of the nucleus in the high resolution image (Fig. 5), which may indicate that there is still some injection of relatively young (108 yr) relativistic plasma in the cooling flow region. This suggests that A2626 has physical properties in between those of the well known case of M 87 (in which there is only marginal evidence for electron re-acceleration, e.g., Owen et al. 2000) and of the prototype of mini-halo, in the Perseus cluster.
One important conclusion reached in the application of GBS's model to the Perseus cluster is that the results are compatible with the observations by assuming an isotropic compression of the magnetic field in the cooling flow region. This is consistent with the fact that the turbulent velocity results greater than the mean inflow velocity at the cooling radius, (Soker & Sarazin 1990), and isotropic compression of the field is expected (Tribble 1993). By assuming a relatively powerful turbulence (i.e., ), the turbulence energy density at the cooling radius is ( is a fudge factor) and thus the velocity of the eddies of turbulence would be . This value is greater than that of the mean inflow velocity of A2626 ( ) and thus we considered only the case of an isotropic compression of the magnetic field.
|Figure 8: Fit to the surface brightness profile (black circles) observed at 1.5 GHz along the radial direction indicated in Fig. 6. The dotted line defines the observed region of values of the brightness distribution at any radius, while the large dashed line represents the 2 rms noise level of the map subtracted from the elongated radio features (the errorbars are at 1). The fit is obtained with the following set of parameters: , , s=-0.5. For comparison, we also report (with triangles) the brightness profile taken along the same radial direction from the 1.5 GHz map including the contribution of the elongated features (Fig. 3). The small dashed line represents the 2 rms noise level of the non-subtracted map.|
|Open with DEXTER|
We have already noticed that after the subtraction of the two elongated features, the morphology of the diffuse radio emission becomes roughly spherical (see Fig. 6), thus justifying the application to A2626 of GBS's model, which indeed assumes spherical symmetry. In particular, in fitting the brightness profile we are authorized to choose a particular radial direction and give the deviations from the spherical symmetry in other directions with respect to the one considered.
In order to test the predictions of the model we have calculated the following expected observable properties:
The values of the parameters required by the model to match the three observational constraints at the 90% confidence level are: -1 < s < 0, -G, -180 pc, where the lower s corresponds to the lower and . For these parameters, one obtains that the break energy at the cooling radius is . In Figs. 8-10 we show the fits to the surface brightness profile, total spectrum and radial spectral steepening for one set of the parameters which best reproduces all the observational constraints.
|Figure 9: Fit to the total spectrum of the synchrotron emission obtained with the same set of parameters of Fig. 8. The flux densities observed at 330 MHz and 1.5 GHz are taken from Table 2, while the flux density at 609 MHz is obtained by subtracting the estimated core emission from the total flux given by Roland et al. (1985). The contribution of the elongated features to the flux of the diffuse emission (as estimated in Sect. 3.1) is included in the errorbars.|
|Open with DEXTER|
|Figure 10: Fit to the radial spectral steepening between MHz and GHz obtained with the same set of parameters of Fig. 8. The data are taken from the spectral index distribution along the direction indicated in Fig. 7. The effect induced by the contribution of the elongated features to the flux of the diffuse emission (as estimated in Sect. 3.1) is included in the errorbars.|
|Open with DEXTER|
The physical implications derived by applying GBS's model to A2626 are discussed and compared with the results obtained for the Perseus cluster. For completeness the X-ray and radio data for these clusters are listed in Table 3 while the model results for both clusters are summarised in Table 4.
Table 3: Observational data for the cooling flow and mini-halo in Perseus and A2626.
Table 4: Model results for Perseus and A2626.
It is worth pointing out that GBS's model is able to reproduce all the observational constraints of A2626 for physically-meaningful values of the parameters (Table 4). First of all we found that in the case of A2626 the range of values obtained for , although somewhat higher than that of Perseus, is in agreement with the measurements of magnetic field strengths in the ICM (Carilli & Taylor 2002 and references therein).
We also notice that the value required by the model for A2626 is higher than that found for Perseus (see Col. 3 of Table 4). Even though we can not discriminate between the two contributions to this parameter, it is more likely that in A2626 is smaller than in Perseus, as depends on the micro-physics and is not expected to change considerably. In particular, in the general theory of turbulent plasma one can calculate the wavelength which carries most of the turbulent energy in a spectrum of Alfvén waves (e.g. Tsytovich 1972). When applied to the case of the ICM, with standard values of the physical parameters, it gives results of the order of tens to hundreds pc (GBS).
Concerning the energy density of the relativistic electrons, we find that it is approximately constant inside the cooling flow region (). Since depends very weakly on the radial distance, this means that the radial distribution of the number density of the electrons before the re-acceleration is nearly constant, producing a sort of "plateau'' of relic electrons in the cooling flow region. On the other hand, in the case of Perseus, GBS found that the energy density of the relativistic electrons increases towards the center. A possible qualitative explanation of the "plateau'' is that past radio activity may have released electrons in the cooling flow region. That this might be the case is suggested by the presence of the two extended features in Fig. 5 which, indeed, may be buoyant plumes recently ejected by the central source. As shown by several authors (e.g., Gull & Northover 1973; Churazov et al. 2000; Brüggen & Kaiser 2002), the outflow is accompanied by adiabatic expansion and further mixing of the energetic relativistic electrons with the ambient ICM; the time-scale of this process (107-108 yr) is comparable to (or bigger than) the lifetime of the electrons producing synchrotron radiation. The disruption of the bubbles produced in past radio outbursts would then have left a population of relic relativistic electrons mixed with the thermal plasma in the cooling flow region. These relic electrons could diffuse in the thermal plasma up to 100 kpc scale in a few Gyr (e.g., Brunetti 2003) filling the whole region inside the two elongated parallel features observed in Fig. 5, thus forming the "plateau'' of relic electrons requested by our modelling.
Note that we found an electron distribution with . We stress that this is not inconsistent with the value adopted in the discussion of diffusion of radio-emitting electrons (Sect. 3.2), because a re-accelerated electron population with is able to emit at GHz frequencies thanks to the shape of the re-accelerated spectrum which is peaked at (see Eq. (5)), while the spectrum of non re-accelerated electrons (a power-law with a high energy cut-off at such a ) does not allow to emit efficiently in this band. As a consequence, without acceleration (i.e., simple diffusion model), electrons with are necessary to account for the radio flux.
The energetics associated with the population of electrons re-accelerated in the cooling flow region can be estimated as:
The total number of relativistic electrons can be estimated from the energetics as: .
With the model parameters found for A2626, one obtains erg and . It is worth noticing that both the energetics and the number of electrons re-accelerated in the cooling flow region are about one order of magnitude smaller than those found in Perseus. This is consistent with the fact that the radio power of the mini-halo in A2626 is about one order of magnitude smaller than that in Perseus.
The power necessary to re-accelerate the emitting electrons is given by the minimum energy one must supply to balance the radiative losses of these electrons: , where is the same as in Eq. (2). By assuming an average magnetic field in the cooling flow region of order 3 G (this value is justified by considering the intensity obtained in the model and the radial behaviour of field amplification expected in the case of isotropic compression), we obtain:
To explore the properties of mini-halos we selected a small sample of candidates among known diffuse radio sources in the literature. The clusters in the sample were selected based on the presence of both a cooling flow and a diffuse radio emission with no direct association with the central radio source. In particular, since GBS's model assumes a connection between the origin of the synchrotron emission and the cooling flow, to be conservative we selected those clusters where the size of the diffuse radio emission is comparable to the cooling radius. For this reason we excluded Abell 2052, the Virgo cluster and 2A 0335+096, which host amorphous radio sources with a size considerably smaller than the cooling flow region. Relevant X-ray and radio data are reported in Table 5, along with references, while in Fig. 11 we report the radio power at 1.4 GHz of the mini-halos (in terms of integrated radio luminosity ) versus the maximum power of the cooling flows .
Table 5: Observational data for mini-halos.A general trend is found, with the strongest radio mini-halos associated with the most powerful cooling flows.
|Figure 11: Integrated radio power at 1.4 GHz, , vs. cooling flow power, , for the mini-halo clusters in Table 5.|
|Open with DEXTER|
Since for A2626 the only available X-ray observation is from Einstein IPC, for consistency the X-ray data were taken, when possible, from the compilation of White et al. (1997) with Einstein Observatory. For A2390, not detected as a cooling flow cluster by Einstein IPC, the value of is taken from more recent observations with ROSAT PSPC, which have shown the presence of a cooling flow in this cluster (Böhringer et al. 1998). Note that when both measurements from Einstein and ROSAT are available (e.g., Perseus, A2142, PKS 0745-191), the Einstein-based is a factor 2 below the ROSAT-based value.
We notice that the maximum powers which can be extracted from cooling flows are orders of magnitude larger than the integrated radio powers (see Fig. 11), in qualitative agreement with the very low efficiencies calculated in the model (see Col. 10 of Table 4).
As already discussed in Sect. 2, new Chandra and XMM-Newton results obtained for a limited number of objects hint at an overestimate of derived by earlier observations: in particular, the consensus reached in these studies (e.g., McNamara et al. 2000; Peterson et al. 2001; David et al. 2001; Tamura et al. 2001; Molendi & Pizzolato 2001; Böhringer et al. 2001; Peterson et al. 2003) is that the spectroscopically-derived cooling rates are a factor 5-10 less than earlier ROSAT and Einstein values (e.g., Fabian & Allen 2003). This factor seems to be similar for all clusters in a large range of , giving a systematic effect that will not spoil the correlation reported in Fig. 11.
In addition, we stress that the trend seen in Fig. 11 is expected in the framework of GBS's model. Qualitatively, , where and are the average values of and magnetic field in the cooling flow region, while is the number density of relativistic electrons with Lorentz factor . We remind that the bulk of the observed radio emission is indeed produced by the electrons with Lorentz factor . On the other hand, the maximum power which can be extracted from a cooling flow estimated on the basis of a standard cooling flow model is (see Sect. 3.3), where (Fabian et al. 1984). Thus from Eq. (6) one has: and, since cooling flows are pressure-constant processes, it results: , i.e. is expected to increase with , with an efficiency which depends on details (related to the micro-physics of the complicated parameterization of ) not considered in the model.
The trend presented in Fig. 11 is based on few objects with still relatively large errors on the parameters. If true, this trend would clearly indicate a connection between the thermal ICM and the relativistic electrons in cooling cores in qualitative agreement with our theoretical expectations. It should be stressed that we may have introduced a bias in our sample since, in order to deal with objects belonging to the radio mini-halo class, we have selected only those objects with an extension similar to that of the cooling flow region. These are well developed radio mini-halos which would have a relatively high efficiency in the particle acceleration process. The trend between radio and cooling flow powers in Fig. 11 may thus result from the fact that the efficiency of the particle acceleration is similar in the selected clusters.
In general, the efficiency in converting the cooling flow power into particle acceleration depends on relatively unknown quantities: the energy transport from large-scale turbulence towards the smaller scales, and the details of the coupling between the turbulence at small scales and the relativistic electrons. All these quantities depend on microphysics and it may likely be that this would lead to a situation of broad ranges of efficiencies.
If low efficiency radio mini-halos exist, they will fill the bottom-right corner of Fig. 11. These objects may be less extended and fainter than typical mini-halos. In addition, it may likely be that the electrons in these objects are not re-accelerated to the energies necessary to produce GHz synchrotron emission, and thus that they would emit only at much lower frequencies. It is evident that future surveys of radio mini-halos in cooling flow clusters combined with X-ray studies of the ICM would shed new light on the link between thermal and relativistic plasma in clusters and on the physics of turbulence and particle acceleration in these regions.
We have reported a detailed study of the radio properties of a new mini-halo candidate in A2626. We have shown that a particle re-acceleration model (GBS's model) with a set of physically-meaningful values of the parameters is able to account for the observed brightness profile, the integrated synchrotron spectrum and the radial spectral steepening. We conclude that A2626 has physical properties in between the case of M 87, for which there is only marginal evidence for electron re-acceleration, and the prototype of mini-halos in the Perseus cluster. Moreover, we obtain that the maximum power of the cooling flow is more than 2 orders of magnitude larger than the emitted radio power, thus indicating that the cooling flow power (even if considerably reduced by the recent observational claims) may play a leading role in powering the radio mini-halo.
We have selected a small sample of well developed radio mini-halos and shown that the radio power of these objects correlates to the cooling flow power. GBS's model for particle re-acceleration in cooling flow is consistent with the observed trend. If confirmed, in the re-acceleration scenario this trend would indicate that the conversion of the cooling flow power into magneto-plasma turbulence and particle acceleration is similar in well developed radio mini-halos.
We thank the referee Torsten Enßlin for helpful comments. M.G. would like to thank Simone Dall'Osso for useful discussions. M.G. and G.B. acknowledge partial support from CNR grant CNRG00CF0A. This work was partly supported by the Italian Ministry for University and Research (MIUR) under grant Cofin 2001-02-8773 and by the Austrian Science Foundation FWF under grant P15868.