A&A 405, 663-676 (2003)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20030390
W. Borczyk1 - A. Schwarzenberg-Czerny1,2 - P. Szkody3
1 - Astronomical Observatory of Adam Mickiewicz
University, Sloneczna 36, 60-286 Poznan, Poland
2 -
Nicolaus Copernicus Astronomical Center, Bartycka 18, 00-716 Warsaw, Poland
3 -
Department of Astronomy, University of Washington, Seattle, WA
98195, USA
Received 5 July 2002 / Accepted 7 March 2003
Abstract
We present the results of a campaign of simultaneous
observations of V603 Aql in the X-ray and UV bands accomplished
with the IUE and ROSAT satellites. Simultaneous observations
cover 20 orbital cycles, while the total span of all the observations is 40
cycles. This constitutes
the longest continuous UV time series of simultaneous
space observations of a cataclysmic variable. As all high energy
radiation is ultimately powered by accretion, it is perhaps
remarkable that we observe some signs of correlations of the UV
line and continuum emission with the X-ray flux at zero lag, but
none over a range of time lags from
.
A hint of
some lagged correlation was revealed for UV color and X-ray flux.
We detect a very strong modulation of intensity of the UV lines of
CIV and SiIV. The modulation appears coherent over the range of
observation and its period of
is consistent with the
spectroscopic orbital period but differs significantly from the
period of photometric modulation. Furthermore, we observe variable
P-Cygni profiles of the CIV1550 line. Its absorption and emission
components are modulated with the orbital period of the binary.
These data present evidence for sustained asymmetry of the
supersonic wind excited from the accretion disc yet pose
difficulties for the current disc and wind models. Since no
periodic modulation was found in the X-ray band nor in the UV
continuum, the present data do not lend support to our earlier
classification of V603 Aql as an intermediate polar.
Key words: accretion, accretion disks - stars: individual: V603 Aql - novae, cataclysmic variables - stars: winds, outflows - ultraviolet: stars - techniques: image processing
V603 Aquilae made its debut in the annals of astronomy as Nova Aquilae 1918,
the brightest Nova of the 20th century. Although it eventually settled into
one of the brightest cataclysmic variable (CV) stars (
),
it remained neglected for a long time.
In his pioneering survey of the radial velocities of CVs, Kraft (1964) obtained
observations of V603 Aql
on two consecutive nights and found an approximate orbital period of
.
Only recently has this value been refined by Patterson et al. (1997, hereafter P97)
to
0.13809(12). Thanks to the unique prism spectrum revealed by Seitter (1990)
we know that 20 years before its outburst, V603 Aql did not differ
spectroscopically
from its current state, at least at low resolution.
Modulation of the light of V603 Aql was found by Drehsel et al. (1981). However it remained for Haefner
& Metz (1985) to demonstrate that the period of modulation was
,
definitely in excess of the orbital period.
Such peculiar behavior was previously discovered only in one other
star, the nova-like TT Ari.
This excess in period between the photometry and
spectroscopy was confirmed in extensive photometric studies reported by
Udalski & Schwarzenberg-Czerny (1989; US89) and P97 and references therein.
The latter authors advanced a plausible hypothesis, yet to be proven,
relating this phenomenon to the superhump oscillations in SU UMa dwarf novae. Interestingly, P97 in their campaigns in 1992, 1993 and 1994
detected the superhump periods alternatively shorter (
)
and longer than the orbital one.
They suggested that the effect was consistent with the hypothesis
of the prograde motion of the line of apsides and the retrograde motion
of the line of nodes in the accretion disk.
In June 1989, Schwarzenberg-Czerny, Udalski & Monier (1992, hereafter SUM)
obtained 28 IUE
observations covering 5 orbital cycles and reported UV continuum pulsations
with a period of
.
Motivated by a similar
period pattern in TV Col, they suggested that this may be the rotation period
of the white dwarf and thus V603 Aql might be an intermediate polar. US89 and P97
hinted at the possible presence of a weak related modulation in their
photometry. However, in their detailed discussion of this issue, P97 note
that given the negative results of Patterson et al. (1993) this may not be a
permanent feature in V603 Aql. Hence, the intermediate
polar hypothesis remained doubtful.
The complexity of the periodic variations in V603 Aql and the
dominance of the
energy losses in the high energy bands in this system called for a detailed UV and X-ray study. The high energy emission generally arises in several regions of a CV: its inner accretion disk with its boundary layer,
its disk's wind and, occasionally, from a hot spot. In the present paper we report the results of our campaign of simultaneous multiwavelength observations
of V603 Aql, the most extensive continuous UV observations so far for a cataclysmic variable.
Warner (1995) presented a comprehensive review of X and UV observations of CVs, including early HST observations. Summarizing, the average X-ray and emission line fluxes of CVs are mutually correlated with each other and with accretion rate (e.g. Patterson & Raymond 1985). Less is known about the correlation of these properties in any individual CV as simultaneous X-UV observations are scarce. Strong UV emission lines from low inclination CVs show P-Cyg profiles, indicating strong wind outflow. Warner (1995) lists numerous evidence for the variability of P-Cyg profiles with orbital phase. This conclusion needs qualification as observations available then and now typically cover one or two orbital cycles. Hence, the evidence for variability is strong but a demonstration of coherent orbital periodicity is still missing. Typical HST observations are unsuitable for orbital modulation studies as they tend to be short and are not contiguous because of Earth occultation. The breakthroughs brought by HST observations are due to its superior temporal and spectral resolution. In particular, in several systems HST studies of eclipse modulation and line details enable determination of the size of the emission region and wind velocities.
Particularly relevant observations are discussed in Sect. 5 and
apart from those quoted by Warner (1995, Sect. 2.7.3) involve papers by Szkody
& Mateo (1986), Friedjung et al. (1997), Ringwald & Naylor (1998) and Prinja et al. (2000).
Another preliminary report by Mauche et al. (2000)
concerns the longer, albeit discontinuous, series of HST and multiwavelength
observations of the magnetic system EX Hya.
Our observations are highly complementary to those by HST
in two respects. Namely, we adequately cover many (20) simultaneous
orbital cycles, corresponding to
a typical accretion time of the disc, enabling us to draw conclusions about
orbital and (possible) accretion modulation. Our observations are discussed in Sect. 2.
In Sect. 3 we investigate the presence of any periodic modulation in
our data. Due to multiwavelength coverage and extended time coverage our observations
yield a new capability to study the long term auto- and cross-correlation of multiwavelength signals (Sect. 4).
Section 5 is devoted to a discussion of the variable P-Cyg profile
of the CIV1550 line. In Sect. 6 we discuss the implication of our
observations for existing accretion and wind models in CVs.
![]() |
Figure 1: Timing of IUE (top) and ROSAT (bottom) observations. Time is in JD minus 2 448 900. Note that the orbital frequency of V603 Aql is 7.2 c/d. |
Open with DEXTER |
Our simultaneous observations in the UV and X-ray bands were obtained in October 1992. The X-ray observations obtained with the ROSAT satellite PSPC detector lasted 30 ks and were distributed more-or-less evenly with a filling factor of 7 percent. Gaps in these observations arise due to Earth occultation and satellite constraints on a low earth orbit. The UV observations were collected with the IUE satellite Short Wavelength Prime (SWP) camera in its low dispersion mode during a contiguous interval of 64 hs using 12 min exposures with a filling factor OF about 50 percent. Gaps lasting up to 25 min are caused by the read-prep operations of the satellite camera. Our time coverage with the ROSAT and IUE observations is shown in Fig. 1. The simultaneous X-ray and UV observations span almost 3 days, i.e. 20 binary orbits, while our total X ray observations span 40 orbits.
Table 1:
IUE observation Log,
.
The log of IUE observations is listed in Table 1. All SWP frames covered the wavelength band from 1000 to 1900 Å and were well exposed.
As we expected the presence of a short-period modulation (due to US89), it was necessary to minimize the time between successive integrations. On the other hand, the satellite hardware restricts the time resolution to about one frame per 40 min. To avoid this problem we decided to employ the technique invented by early spectroscopists - the "trailed spectra method''.
This technique is based on double-exposed frames. The spectrograph slit size was large enough to let us expose 2 spectra on the same frame, parallel to each other. After the first exposure was done, we changed the attitude of the satellite and then the second exposure began. Then, the whole frame containing the two UV spectra ("A'' and "B'') was transmitted to the Earth. Thus, the time separation between adjacent spectra in one pair could be as short as needed, while the separation between succeeding frames was still restricted by the IUE hardware and READPREP operation.
Because the spectrograph slit has finite height (in practice about
),
the spatial separation between two spectral images could not be
as large as desired without flux losses. The result is
that two spectra on the same frame overlap partially.
This unwanted effect is increased by the defocusing: focusing of the IUE
was very often switched off to maximize available power.
Due to the partial overlap, it was impossible to separate the individual spectra with the standard IUESIPS software. Thus, we used IUESIPS only to perform a geometric and photometric correction to the raw image and used the resolved line-by-line spectra (LBLS) and MXLO/MELO files with calibrated fluxes for further calculations.
We started with the "old style'' ELBL/MELO files produced by the older
version of IUESIPS software. After the NEWSIPS software had been employed
we repeated our procedure for new SILO/MXLO files. We obtained identical
results for both sets of data.
![]() |
Figure 2: Scan perpendicular to dispersion for a section of a raw spectrum (row m=300). Note the considerable overlap of individualexposures. |
Open with DEXTER |
In Fig. 2 we plot the section of a sample frame
perpendicular to the dispersion. Our first attempt to deal with
the overlapping spectra was based on fitting a double Gaussian
function to the subsequent perpendicular sections of each spectra
stored in the LBLS files. Fitting Gaussian functions gave us a
possibility to estimate the values of the "overlapped'' parts of adjacent
spectra "A'' and "B'' and then calculate the real total contribution
of both elements of the pair to the total flux. In this way we
calculated quotients
and
for
each row of pixels. After a simple multiplication of these
quotients by the absolutely calibrated total flux values taken
from the MELO/MXLO files for the same row, we obtained a pair of one
dimensional sets of calibrated flux values with the corresponding
wavelengths separately for "A'' and "B'' spectra.
Unfortunately, this algorithm did not work sufficiently well in many cases, particularly with the under exposed frames. It was also very sensitive to artifacts on the frames. It was clear that our rectification technique should be improved. We employed a novel method in order to extract individual spectra from the melted images, based on the Lucy-Richardson deconvolution method (Lucy 1974; Spruit 1994). This method helped us to reduce the spatial cross-talk of parallel spectra by numerical deconvolution. Details are described by Borczyk (1999).
The average properties of our extracted 1992 UV spectra, namely their average and standard deviation are displayed in Fig. 3. Note the excess variance in the blue wing of CIV1550 and the lack of it in the red wing. Comparison with the 1989 data reveals that in 1992, the scattering at continuum frequencies is largely due to flickering intrinsic to the star (cf. Sect. 2.1.4). Note also that the relative scatter of the continuum is wavelength independent.
Photometric UV measurements were obtained by integrating our
individual calibrated UV spectra over selected wavelength bands.
Five
bands were selected to cover broad continuum spectral regions that were
little affected
by lines:
1275-1375, 1425-1475, 1575-1625, 1650-1750 and 1800-1900 Å. To be
able to investigate changes in the continuum gradient we used UV
color defined as
![]() |
Figure 3:
Statistical properties of UV spectra: standard deviation
per single spectrum (a, shifted by -12) and average spectrum
(b), both in log Flux units, where flux is in
![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
To verify our new IUE reduction procedure for the multiple exposed spectra, we processed, in the same way as the present data, the archival IUE observations of V603 Aql and V795 Her from 1989 and 1992, and extracted their line and continuum lightcurves. Since the recovered light curves were consistent with the behavior described in the original publications by Schwarzenberg-Czerny et al. (1992) and Prinja & Rosen (1993) based on independent reductions, we conclude that our reduction procedure is correct.
Specifically, our newly reduced old 1989 data for V603 Aql did
reveal the pulsations reported by SUM and did not exhibit coherent
modulation in the lines (cf. Schwarzenberg-Czerny et al. 1992).
We shall demonstrate that our present observations exhibit quite
contrary results on both accounts. In this respect it must be
stressed that our new 1992 data are more reliable as they contain
5 times more observations than the 1989 ones. However, it may be
premature to solely blame poor statistics for the discrepant 1989
observations. In Fig. 5 we present the 1989 continuum
light curve (1575-1625 Å band). Despite the identical
instrument setup, the observing procedures and the data reduction
techniques, the amplitude of the scatter of the 1989 continuum and
line observations amounts to only a third of the corresponding
values in 1992, of 40 and 30 percent. Hence it is difficult to
avoid a conclusion that V603 Aql was in different states in 1989
and 1992, at least in some respects. It remains an open question
whether these differences in states affected the presence and/or
disappearance of any intrinsic oscillations.
![]() |
Figure 4: Continuum (wavelength band 1575-1625 Å) and CIV1550 emission line lightcurves. The continuum points are denoted by black diamonds and the CIV1550 points by open circles. The time is in JD minus 2 448 900. |
Open with DEXTER |
Photometry of V603 Aql was obtained by Francois Piche with the
0.76 m telescope of the University of Washington (WA) during the
1992 satellite observations. According to the results kindly
communicated to us they reveal a range in brightness between
11.65-12.0 mag. The AAVSO data from June 1989 indicate a similar
range, between 11.3-11.8. The decline of the average brightness by 0.2
mag in 3 yrs, if real, would be consistent with the average rate
of the decline 70 yrs after outburst.
![]() |
Figure 5: Same as Fig. 4 for observations from 1989 except that the horizontal axis id JD minus 2 447 689. Note that the scatter of observations is one third that observed in 1992 with the same instrument setup and reduction techniques. |
Open with DEXTER |
The X-ray observations were obtained by the ROSAT satellite in the pointing mode with the PSPC(2) detector over 30 ks. The satellite and its instrumentation are described by Trumper (1983). For further details see Voges (1992). Due to satellite constraints and Earth occultation, the observations of V603 Aql occur in 19 intervals lasting no more than 25 min each. The observations were reduced in a standard way using the EXSAS interactive software package (Zimmermann et al. 1992). Analysis of the spectral properties of V603 Aql will be published elsewhere. By selecting and binning photons into standard PSPC/SASS energy bands we obtained lightcurves in A, B, C, D energy bands plus an integrated light curve corresponding to 0.3-2 keV. Variability in each of the energy bands had a similar character. We discuss here in detail only the integrated PSPC light curve because its better statistics yielded tighter upper limits on any correlations and periodic modulation. As a compromise between the time resolution and sufficient count rate per bin, we binned our lightcurves into 400 s time bins.
If we denote the flux value of point (x,y) from LBLS file by
,
the rth approximation of the real (deconvolved) flux
value in point
by
and the
convolution kernel by
then the iterative scheme
can be described as:
![]() |
(2) |
![]() |
(3) |
In most cases the iterative process converged rapidly to the final solution and enabled us to avoid fitting Gaussian functions to the sections of spectra: after this procedure adjacent spectra were sufficiently well separated and no additional rectification was needed - the "contribution quotients'' of "A'' and "B'' were then easy calculated by a simple summation of the flux values in the proper areas of the deconvolved image.
Lucy's algorithm proved to be an efficient and powerful tool to process our data. All UV observations referred below were reduced in this way. We processed all 50 frames containing double exposed spectra and obtained 100 single spectra as a result. The log of the observations is listed below. The first column contains the frame number, the second and the third are the mid-times of exposure for the "A'' and "B'' spectra (Julian day number minus the constant offset = 2 448 900.0) The barycentric corrections had been included before the observations were used to calculate the light curve.
Further discussion in the present section and in Sect. 4 is based on the following time series: UV continuum, F1575-1625 (Sect. 2.1.3), UV color C (Eq. (1)), combined PSPC X-ray count rate RX (Sect. 2.2) and flux in the emission line CIV1550 Å (Sect. 2.1.3). Some trials with other energy band combinations did not yield results much different from these presented here. However, the number of different combinations soon became unwieldy.
For period analysis we used both power spectra and AoV periodograms (Schwarzenberg-Czerny 1989). No significant features were found in the [take out either] periodograms for UV continuum, UV color and X-ray cont rate. The periodogram for the CIV emission revealed the presence of an oscillation. The last two periodograms are discussed below in some detail.
Table 2: ROSAT observations.
Periodograms were calculated for both the UV and X-ray observations to search for any oscillations. We covered a range from 0 to 70 cycles per day. The periodogram for the entire X-ray band observed by the PSPC detector is displayed in Fig. 6. There is no evidence of any periodic modulation of the X-ray radiation. Similar but noisier results are obtained separately for the soft and hard PSPC bands. No modulations are seen in the 1992 UV continuum observations. This contradicts our claim of a 23 c/d modulation of the UV continuum observed in 1989 (Schwarzenberg-Czerny et al. 1992, SUM). Clearly the 23 c/d oscillation may not be persistent. Note that the 1992 UV observation lasted 5 times longer than the 1989 one. Intermediate polars generally exhibit persistent X-ray pulsations. In view of the absence of X-ray pulsations in the V603 Aql X-ray lightcurve and the lack of persistent UV and optical modulation, our current data do not support the proposed classification of V603 Aql as an intermediate polar.
To check our new reduction procedures we re-extracted lightcurves from the 1989 raw spectra images and produced light curves in the same way as for the 1992 data. We recovered the lightcurves and UV continuum periodogram with the 23 c/d feature resembling those obtained by SUM, demonstrating that our new and old UV reductions are mutually consistent. Since our instrumental setup and reductions for 1989 and 1992 were similar, the 23 c/d feature might be both real and transient. Some evidence of a change intrinsic to the star comes from a factor of 2 increase in UV flickering between 1989 and 1992. While our 1992 optical lightcurves are too short to adequately search for this feature, possible optical detection of a related 23 c/d quasi-periodic oscillation is discussed by Patterson et al. (1997).
In strong contrast to the UV continuum, the periodogram
of the emission line intensity indicates modulation with a
frequency of 7.24 c/d in both the CIV1550 and
SiIV1393/1402 Å doublet lines. This frequency agrees with the orbital period
previously found from the radial velocities of the optical lines.
The distinct peak near the frequency
is
easily visible in Fig. 7.
There is no doubt that it corresponds to a real effect.
Less certain is the reality of a high frequency feature around
,
which has never been seen before and has no simple relation to any frequencies claimed in the past.
The high frequency feature is rather robust and persists after prewhitening of
the other (orbital) frequency. This should be no surprise as our window function
is particularly clean and devoid of any artifacts exceeding
the 10 percent level. Since our 1992 data are quite extensive, the periodogram feature is
quite clean and its frequency does not exceed half of the maximum
sampling frequency of order 100 c/d, we must conclude that the
modulation is real and at least temporarily persistent.
As the width of the
and
features are similar,
we have no evidence of any incoherence of the latter modulation.
It is rather frustrating to observe that
is close but
significantly different from any possible frequencies discussed
in V603 Aql in the past (US89,
SUM, P97). However, until more evidence is available,
we refrain from further discussion of the nature of any related process.
Our effective Nyquist frequency is about 50 c/d, so the feature at 64.8 c/d
could be a ghost of a peak at lower frequency.
![]() |
Figure 6: Power spectrum for the integrated X-ray lightcurve in 400 s bins. On the horizontal axis is frequency in cycles per day. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 7: Power spectrum for the CIV1550 Å emission line. |
Open with DEXTER |
To study the cross-correlation between the data series listed at the
beginning
of Sect. 3 we adopted
the method by Edelson & Krolik (1988).
For each pair of two data series ai(t) and bj(t) we
calculate its time lag
and its contribution
to the unbinned discrete cross-correlation function
![]() |
(4) |
We investigated ACF for the following time series: log UV continuum flux, UV color, log X-ray flux and CIV1550 emission. Most of them revealed nothing except for the feature at 0 lag, to be expected by default (see examples in Figs. 8 and 9). The real effect in the ACF was found for CIV1550 emission. This is predictable, as the correlation of a periodic function with an arbitrary function is also a periodic function. This is best seen by noting that the periodic function shifted by its period is identical with itself. Since we found the orbital modulation of the CIV1550 line (Sect. 3.2), the orbital modulation with the period of 0.138 d reappeared in any correlation involving CIV1550. This effect for the ACF CIV1550 is shown in Fig. 10.
There are
(42) = 6 different combinations of our data for the
CCF. Among them, the 3 which involve the CIV1550 line display
periodic features as discussed in the preceding paragraph (e.g.
Fig. 11). Nothing significant was observed in X-rays vs. UV
color nor in UV continuum vs. UV color. In the latter case, the slight
anti-correlation at 0 lag is not significant at
level.
The X-ray vs. UV continuum plot revealed a feature at 0 lag and
nothing for lags exceeding 10 min. Note that for CCF no such
feature is to be expected by default hence we discuss this case in
Sect. 4.2. The cross-correlation function for UV color vs.
X-ray flux is presented in Fig. 12 and discussed in Sect. 4.3.
We calculated the CCF for UV and X-ray fluxes for time lags
extending from
till
.
For lags
our plot
becomes noisy because of dearth of the X-ray data sampled before
the UV observations. The only structure visible in the remaining
part of the plot is located at 0 lag. In order to investigate it
further we took a small interval time
centered at 0 and
selected all n pairs of X-ray and UV continuum observations
separated by no more than
.
Next we calculated their
correlation coefficient
and the statistics
![]() |
(5) |
![]() |
Figure 8: Autocorrelation function for UV continuum. On the horizontal axis is the time lag in days. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 9: Autocorrelation function for X-ray. Scales as in Fig. 8. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 10: Autocorrelation function for CIV1550 Å emission line (vertical axis). Scales as in Fig. 8. Note that the maxima repeat with the orbital period. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 11: Cross-correlation function (CCF) for CIV1550 emission vs. X-ray integrated flux (vertical axis). Horizontal axis is time lag in days. The lag is positive when X-ray variations trail behind CIV1550. Note a periodic structure related to orbital modulation of CIV1550 (see text). |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 12: The same as in Fig. 11 for UV color vs. X-ray integrated flux. Note the feature at the lag +0.11 d discussed in Sect. 4.3. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 13:
UV continuum against X-ray flux at zero lag (<
![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
Figure 12 reveals the presence of conspicuous structure around
the lag of +0.11 d. This lag roughly corresponds to the orbital
period, hence it deserves some attention. Unlike most structures
due to noise it extends over a whole interval of lags and it
remains there for a range of time lag grids selected for
calculation of the CCF following Edelson & Krolik (1988). To
verify our calculations we repeated the calculations using a different
method. Namely, for each time-lag interval l we selected all
pairs of points from both data sets with time lags falling into
the interval. Then we calculated the correlation coefficient
of the values in the selected pairs. Our plot of
resembles that in Fig. 12. Thus we are confident that the
feature at +0.11 d is not a numerical artefact. A correlation
analysis similar to that performed in Sect. 4.2 yields for
lags
,
n=17 and the significance
level
.
In summary, there is some indication of the
cross-correlation of X-ray flux with the UV color, such that
the X-ray variations are delayed with respect to the UV color by
about an orbital period. The time scale and the cause of the
effect might be related to an orbital modulation and/or accretion
time scale of the inner region of the disc. However, the evidence
proving the reality of this correlation is not overwhelming, hence we
refrain from further speculations on its nature.
Szkody et al. (1986) undertook a pilot study of the modulation of P-Cyg profiles in the spectra of dwarf novae, specifically in the CIV1550, SiIV1393/1402 doublet and NV1240 Å lines in Z Cam. Their observations were obtained over 2 IUE shifts on 10 and 12 December 1983, covering about 2 orbital cycles of Z Cam and, similarly to our data, using the large-aperture and low resolution mode. Szkody et al. (1986) reported that in both cycles the maximum of the absorption corresponds to the phases 0.6-0.8 and suggested a possible role of the mass-transfer stream. However, dearth of data prevented a periodogram analysis and firm establishment of the coherent nature of the discovered modulation. Additionally these authors noted that the strength of the P-Cygni absorption is greater after outburst than during the standstill, while the final velocities and wavelengths of the central absorption component remain the same. No corresponding changes in the emission component of the CIV1550 lines were observed.
Friedjung et al. (1997) used HST high dispersion ultraviolet spectra to discover the P-Cygni-like profiles of the CIV1550 line of V603 Aql. They also noticed that despite apparent similarity to "typical'' P-Cygni profiles, this structure in V603 Aql exhibits a number of peculiarities. For example, the emission part is much stronger then the absorption one and almost exactly symmetrical. As a possible explanation, he suggests that the source of the emission lines is the hot, external part of the chromosphere of the disk, while the absorption lines are created in the colder stellar wind.
Friedjung et al. (1997) also noticed that the intensity of the lines varies on a time scale of minutes. Further detailed analysis of this effect was hampered since their observations covered only a fraction of the orbital period. Similar results were reported by Selvelli et al. (1998). Using 108 IUE SWP observations, part of which belongs to the present data, they were unable to find definite periodicities in the variations in the absorption features. They reported that the CIV1550 and NV1240 Å lines reveal only irregular variations, indicative of variable wind outflow and of sudden ejection of optically thick material with time-scales of the order of 10 min. Note however, that these authors performed only a preliminary study of the observations, did not reduce all double exposed frames and attempted no state-of-art periodogram analysis.
Our quest for high temporal resolution forced us to use the low resolution mode of IUE. This mode is considered to yield an insufficient resolution for studies of spectral line profiles. Still, given the large size of our dataset, we decided to take a closer look at the P-Cygni profiles. Our attempt was vindicated when it turned out that the width and shapes of the emission and absorption components in our data sometimes closely matched those obtained with HST GHRS. Coordination with ROSAT and long time coverage, rather difficult to attain with HST, were a bonus in our study. However, HST complements our results in providing high temporal resolution.
At first, we prepared the average spectrum from 100 IUE spectra. The vicinity of the CIV1550 line in this spectrum is shown in Fig. 14.
The absorption depression is easily visible on the short wavelength side of the CIV1550 Å emission line.
Figure 15 shows the vicinity of the CIV1550 line at different
phases
of orbital motion (
is relative only).
![]() |
Figure 14:
Average
profile of CIV1550 Å line, from 100 IUE spectra. On
horizontal axis wavelength in Å. Error bars indicate
![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 15:
CIV1550
line, at phases
![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
Notice that the absorption part of the profile changes in time. Furthermore, measuring the position of the absorption maximum and of the blue edge, we can determine the average and highest values of the radial velocity of the gas as 2100 km s-1 for the maximum absorption and 3100 km s-1 for the blue edge. Both values are measured in relation to the maximum of the emission. The radial velocity corresponding to the maximum of emission, measured by Friedjung et al. (1997) is equal to about 50 km s-1 and can be neglected in the present circumstances.
Radial velocities obtained from our IUE observations are similar to values calculated by Friedjung (1400 to 2100 km s-1 for the maximum of absorption and 2500 km s-1 for the blue edge). This suggests that the P-Cyg profile in our IUE low resolution data is sufficiently resolved.
We proceed to perform the analysis of the long term variability of the absorption and the emission components of the CIV1550 Å line (Sect. 2.1.3). The analysis of the absorption component lead to the discovery of the modulation with the period close to the orbital one. This is clearly visible in the periodogram for the absorption component in Fig. 16. Note the presence of a strong first harmonic of the orbital frequency. The power in the harmonic compared to that for the base frequency is much greater than its strength for the emission component (Fig. 7). Since the sampling of the lightcurves for the emission and absorption components is the same, the difference in the relative power reflects a true difference in the absorption and emission lightcurves and not any sampling/window function effects.
We obtained final estimates of the frequencies by fitting the lightcurves with
a Fourier series truncated at the second harmonic. The residuals from the fit are
uncorrelated, hence our error estimates should be realistic
(Schwarzenberg-Czerny 1991, 1996).
The results for the emission and absorption components of the
CIV1550 line are compared
in Table 3.
Additionally in the table we list orbital and photometric periods
obtained by Patterson et al. (1997) from independent observations made
between 3-8 June 1992, 3-26 June 1992, 24 July-11 August
and 8 August-14 September. We intentionally used results of
photometric observations obtained at almost the same time as our IUE
observations.
These results suggest that the frequencies of modulation of the
emission and absorption components of CIV1550 line are the same within
and equal to the orbital frequency. Indeed the weighted mean of the two former frequencies and the latter frequency are in excellent agreement.
However, the average frequency of the CIV1550 modulation differs from the
average photometric period by as much as
.
So it seems safe to
conclude that the CIV1550 line is modulated with the orbital period
and not with any of the photometric ones.
In Fig. 17 we display the phase folded and binned light curve of the
CIV1550 emission line. Note the large amplitude of the modulation
of the intensity, of order of 20 percent.
It is difficult to explain by a
pure aspect effect and particularly so at an inclination of
.
Hence explanation of both the amplitude and irregularity of the modulation of the emission line,
and its P-Cygni profile calls for an asymmetric wind
of optical thickness varying between
different lines of sight. In order to explain the coherent periodic modulation, the asymmetry
must remain fixed over the whole interval of observations. We defer
discussion of the rather stringent requirement imposed on any models
by such an asymmetry to Sect. 6.7.
![]() |
Figure 16: Power spectrum of strength of the absorption component of CIV1550 line. X axis is frequency in cycles per day. |
Open with DEXTER |
Similar but more noisy results are obtained for SiIV1393/1402 Å doublet. They are presented in Figs. 18 and 19. In particular, the period also agrees within the errors with the orbital one.
After we finished our investigation, Prinja et al. (2000) presented the results of their analysis of the absorption line profiles in V603 Aql spectra, based on rapid Hubble Space Telescope ultraviolet spectroscopy. They reported the presence of episodic blue-shifted absorption (up to 2500 km s-1). During 5 hrs of observations (consisting of 4 observing blocks), they recorded three absorption events, each lasting 10-15 min. They concluded that the derived velocity, acceleration and optical depth properties provided a picture of stochastically variable structure in the outflow. They didn't find any cyclic or modulated behavior in the overall absorption properties. They also didn't notice any significant time-dependent changes in the emission components. But, note that the time intervals used by the authors - due to peculiarities of the HST orbit - were much shorter then our IUE coverage and indeed shorter than the time scales of the modulations discussed by us. For this reason, it is not surprising that Prinja et al. (2000) missed the underlying regularity in the line modulation. The importance of their and other HST work lies in the demonstration of the dramatically short time scales of the spectral variations in V603 Aql.
There is no doubt that all the non-stellar energy radiated by CVs comes from accretion. However, the role of different wavelengths in the exchange of energy within the binary is not so clear. Empirical investigations are hampered by the dearth of extended multiwavelength and truly simultaneous observations. Our data yield a unique opportunity to glimpse the energy flow between the sources of X-ray and UV continua.
Table 3: Frequency of modulation for absorption and emission part of CIV1550 line.
On the one hand the results discussed in Sect. 4 indicate
some correlation of continuum X-ray and UV fluctuations at zero
lag, at least in the lightcurves binned at the rather long time
scales exceeding
.
If confirmed by further observations and
with an improved time resolution, this result favors illumination
as a possible means for the re-distribution of energy as
corresponding lags are less than
.
Although observations give
no clue as to which energy form is primordial, theory favors
X-ray illumination as the cause of UV flickering as the photon
energy degradation occurs much easier than the reverse.
On the other hand modulation of the accretion energy sources
between the hot spot and disk and/or the disk and its boundary
layer would correspond to lags considerably over
.
This
time scale is predicted by the time-dependent models of the
accretion by Meyer & Meyer-Hoffmeister (1984) and Smak (1984),
and confirmed by the multiwavelength observations of the outbursts
of dwarf novae (e.g. Schwarzenberg-Czerny et al. 1985). Our
observations do not show noticeable correlation of UV and X-ray
fluxes at lags significantly different from 0. The only hint that
some lagged correlation might be present is in the UV color and
X-ray flux CCF discussed in Sect. 4.3. The evidence of the
correlation is weak. If true, it would favor a scenario producing UV
radiation as the primary effect of accretion, and X-rays as an
after-effect. There are several effects possibly masking the
lagged correlation in the UV and X-ray fluxes. We already
mentioned the first cause involving the energy transport by
illumination (Sect. 6.1).
![]() |
Figure 17:
Intensity of CIV1550 emission line phase,
in
![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 18:
Average profile of SiIV1393/1402 Å doublet line,
from 100 IUE spectra. Error bars indicate
![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The second cause may be purely observational. Our resolution in
time and/or in intensity is limited, due to the finite UV exposure
time and the demand for adequate X-ray statistics. We could not
discriminate between 0 and 10 min lags in the correlation. Note that the
correlation at 0 lag is detected most reliably for bins as wide as
min. The quality of UV calibration and X-ray statistics
at the adopted binning/exposure resolution yield noise amounting
to over 5 percent of the signal. Hence our observations do not exclude
the presence of a correlation with shorter lags and/or smaller
amplitudes.
The third cause may concern the statistical properties of the
accretion sources of radiation at different rings. Naively one
would expect cooler
radiation modulated at longer time scales of the flow from the outer regions
of
the accretion disk. With due
time lag for mass flow inwards this modulation should affect
the accretion rate in the inner regions of the disk. If the UV and
X-rays originate predominantly from different regions, such a
lagged correlation should be observed. However, the inner rings of the
disk cause intrinsic variability at still higher frequencies, with
a cut off at the local thermal time scale. A sufficiently steep
rise of power at high frequencies may cause enough drift of power
to lower frequencies to mask any accretion driven modulation.
![]() |
Figure 19: Power spectrum of intensity of the SiIV1393/1402 Å doublet emission line. |
Open with DEXTER |
Clearly, our observations call for a more thorough review of the time effects consistent with the current accretion disk model. However, it would be premature to imply serious inconsistency of our observations with the accepted accretion model without prior thorough analysis of the listed thee alternative explanations.
The stream and orbital velocities and their radial components are
small compared to the width of the line features, exceeding
km s-1.
For this reason, the hot spot does not seem a likely place for excitation of the
wind (Rozyczka & Schwarzenberg-Czerny 1987). The sole remaining source
of the high-velocity wind remains the inner
parts of the accretion disk and the vicinity of the white dwarf itself.
Indeed, for a white dwarf mass exceeding
the near-surface Kepler and escape velocities amount to at least 2700and
.
These high velocities are observed by us and by Prinja
et al. (2000). So, the explanation of line features corresponding
to a wind velocity of order w poses no problem, even after allowance
is made for a factor of 2 for projection effects.
The keplerian period at the inner disc radius constitutes a fraction of a minute. This time scale corresponds to the fastest variability time scale (<1 min) registered by Prinja et al. (2000). Summarizing, both lines of reasoning favor the vicinity of the white dwarf as the source of the wind. Popular scenarios of wind excitation involve radiation pressure (e.g. Proga 1999 and references there).
We observe a modulation of the P-Cyg emission and absorption components with the orbital period. The modulation of the absorption component must be tied to the variable density in the line of sight, due to the variable aspect and/or ejection of gas bubbles. A smooth variation would favor aspect while a sharp variation may be caused by an inhomogeneous gas flow. Our observations provide no clear clues in this respect. However, Prinja et al. (2000) observed a modulation of the absorption component decomposed into separate events lasting about 15 min and variable on a time scale as short as 1 min. This kind of modulation would favor inhomogeneous flow.
Some chromospheric emission on top of the photospheric absorption
might be present in the Ly-
line but it is masked by the
geocoronal emission. However, such effects are not expected in
such a high excitation line as CIV1550 Å . Generally, P-Cygni
profiles are explained by self-absorption in the accelerating and
cooling wind (Castor et al. 1975; Proga et al. 1998).
An explanation of the coherent modulation of the lines is prone to difficulties.
The nebular expansion of V603 Aql provided
a textbook example of the successful
reconstruction of the geometry from an
analysis of the radial velocities of the ejecta,
yielding an orbital inclination
(Mustel & Boyarchuk 1970;
Weaver 1974). This estimate agrees with the small orbital velocity,
which gives an
inclination
(Warner 1995)
and with the lack of eclipses and, indeed, lack of any
traces of orbital modulation in extensive X-ray, UV continuum and
visual range lightcurves. At this low inclination, eclipses and aspect
effects are negligible, so that a coherent modulation
of the emission lines is difficult to explain.
In cataclysmic binaries white dwarfs come in two brands: magnetic and non-magnetic. The magnetic white dwarfs often manifest themselves by polarization of their radiation and/or by pulsed radiation due to the light-house effect. X-ray observations are most sensitive in a search for magnetic white dwarfs. Thus in the present context, lack of any X-ray modulation argues against a magnetic white dwarf in V603 Aql. An exactly on-axis and/or isotropically radiating magnetic pole does not seem a likely configuration deserving further consideration. For a non-magnetic white dwarf there are no obvious reasons to break the axial symmetry of the disk-star interface powering the wind. Because of viscosity and negligible tidal action, the inner disk should be perfectly circularized. By symmetry arguments the boundary layer, radiation field and acceleration of the wind should also remain axially symmetric. It is difficult to find other external reasons for breaking the axial symmetry of the highly supersonic wind.
Difficulties with aspect effects, the amplitude and irregularity of the modulation and the presence of P-Cygni profiles all indicate that an explanation of the observed effects should involve the absorbing wind. The absorption in the wind must be varying between different lines of sight in a non-axisymmetric fashion. However, in order to explain the coherent periodic modulation, the asymmetry should last over the whole interval of observations.
Let us assume that the intensity of an emitted line depends solely on the
cosine
of the angle between the directions from the disc center towards the observer and
the secondary star,
.
Writing explicitly in terms of the orbital phase
one obtains
![]() |
(6) |
A unique event of spontaneous breaking of the symmetry by a kind of hydrodynamic instability
does not solve the difficulty. In order to explain a modulation of the
absorption coherent over
days, the asymmetry
must be preserved over the same time interval. However, the distance
covered by the wind during such an interval reaches
,
i.e. a hundred times the size of the binary.
To produce the absorption component the envelope would have to still remain
opaque in the lines at this large distance.
Such a potent wind may be feasible during nova explosions
but certainly not during our observations in quiescence.
Permanent asymmetry in the source of the wind appears as
a more likely alternative. In view of the
lack of evidence for a strong magnetic field, the cause of such an asymmetry
remains mysterious. Perhaps some residual weak magnetic field?
The first analysis of a continuous long series of UV and X-ray simultaneous observations of V603 Aql has been performed. Our results show that the Lucy-Richardson deconvolution algorithm can be successfully used for the extraction of the UV spectra from multiply exposed IUE frames. Our tests also suggest that this method leads to better results than the older algorithm based on the classic Gaussian fit.
The absence of any periodic modulation of the X-rays lends no support to a classification of V603 Aql as an intermediate polar.
Comparing the old US89 results with the results from our new observations, we noticed that the behavior of the star changed in 3 yrs. The short period modulation, which US89 found in the 1989 UV continuum lightcurve and which was recovered in the same data re-reduced with our new software, is undetectable in the new data. Our discovery of a strong modulation in the CIV1550 emission line intensities, with a period consistent with the orbital period, and the absence of such a modulation in the UV continuum seem to suggest that the UV continuum and emission lines are being produced in different parts of the accretion disk.
Our observations hint at a correlation between the X-ray and UV emission at nearly zero lag. This leads us to speculate that the underlying mechanism of UV flickering is X-ray illumination.
The reason behind the modulation in the emission and absorption components of the spectral lines is still not clear. As we showed earlier, both parts of the P-Cygni profile are strictly correlated with the phase of orbital motion. One possible explanation may be that the source of emission is the external, hot chromosphere of the disk, while the absorption is created in a colder and asymmetrical stellar wind.
P-Cygni profiles with variations in the spectral line intensities in the visual band were noticed by Ringwald & Naylor (1998) in the case of BZ Camelopardalis. But it's not obvious whether the mechanism of a cold stellar wind causing this effect in BZ Cam is similar to the hot, highly excited wind in V603 Aql.
Acknowledgements
This paper reports observations made possible thanks to a stipend of the Max-Planck-Geselschaft to ASC and hospitality of the Max-Planck Institut fuer Extraterrestische Physik in Garching. We thank Wolfgang Pietsch for his expertise and interest in the present project and to F. Piche for communication of the optical observations. We are grateful to J. Smak for discussions and for numerous detailed comments. The presentation of our paper benefited from the critical yet thoughtful comments by the anonymous referee. We acknowledge funding of our research by NASA grant NAG 5-2315 to PS and by KBN grants 2P03D01818 (ASC), 5P03D00220 (WB).