A&A 405, 5-14 (2003)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20030557
D. Bettoni1 - G. Galletta2 - S. García-Burillo3
1 - Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova, Vicolo Osservatorio 5, 35122 Padova, Italy
2 -
Dipartimento di Astronomia, Università di Padova, Vicolo Osservatorio 2, 35122 Padova, Italy
3 -
Observatorio Astronómico Nacional-OAN, Apartado 1143, 28800 Alcalá de Henares, Madrid, Spain
Received 19 February 2003 / Accepted 1 April 2003
Abstract
We have compiled a catalogue of the
gas content for a sample of 1916 galaxies, considered to be a fair
representation of "normality''. The definition of a "normal'' galaxy
adopted in this work implies that we have purposely excluded from the catalogue
galaxies having distorted morphology (such as interaction bridges, tails
or lopsidedness) and/or any signature of peculiar kinematics (such as
polar rings, counterrotating disks or other decoupled components). In
contrast, we have included systems hosting active galactic
nuclei (AGN) in the catalogue. This catalogue revises previous
compendia on the ISM content of galaxies published by Bregman et al. (1992)
and Casoli et al. (1998), and compiles data available in the literature
from several small samples of galaxies. Masses for warm dust, atomic
and molecular gas, as well as X-ray luminosities have been converted
to a uniform distance scale taken from the Catalogue of Principal
Galaxies (PGC). We have used two different normalization factors to
explore the variation of the gas content along the Hubble sequence:
the blue luminosity ()
and the square of linear diameter (D225).
Our catalogue significantly improves the statistics
of previous reference catalogues and can be used in future studies to
define a template ISM content for "normal'' galaxies along the Hubble
sequence. The catalogue can be accessed on-line and is also available
at the Centre des Données Stellaires (CDS).
Key words: catalogs - galaxies: ISM - galaxies: general - infrared: galaxies - radio lines: galaxies - X-rays: galaxies - submillimeter
Different surveys have been conducted thus far to establish whether
galaxies can be characterized by a canonical gas content that may vary
significantly along the Hubble sequence (early-type versus late-type
objects) and/or depend on the particular environment (isolated versus
strongly interacting galaxies) (Fabbiano et al. 1992; Burstein et al. 1997; Beuing et al. 1999; Knapp et al. 1989; Bregman et al. 1992; Casoli et al. 1998). A global study of the ISM content in
galaxies requires a multi-wavelength approach: far infrared (FIR)
observations at 60 and 100 m trace the warm dust content, while
those at 140-200
m the cold dust; mm lines of carbon monoxide
(CO) and the 21cm line of HI must be used to infer the molecular and
atomic gas content, respectively: the X-ray wave-band is used to
study the hot gas component. However, results obtained from previous
surveys have strong biases due to poor statistics (uneven coverage
along the Hubble sequence) and, also, due to the inclusion of galaxies
which are known to be "peculiar''. As an example, the selection of
candidate galaxies to be observed in CO surveys have been typically
based on Far Infrared Luminosity (FIR) criteria. This often favors the
inclusion of "peculiar'' galaxies in surveys and introduces a bias
against "normal'' systems.
In this work we present a new catalogue describing the Interstellar Medium (ISM) content in a sample of 1916 "normal'' galaxies. A first preliminary version of this catalogue was used by Bettoni et al. (2001) (Paper I) as a reference in their study of the gas content of gas-accreting galaxies. First of all, this requires the adoption of a non-obvious definition for "normality''. In this work we will consider a galaxy to be "peculiar'', hence to be excluded from the catalogue, if it has any sign of perturbed morphology due to a recent or ongoing interaction like tidal tails, bridges, warps or disk lopsidedness. Furthermore, with our definition of normal galaxy, we also exclude from this catalogue any galaxy having any sign of peculiar kinematics, revealed by the presence of polar rings, counterrotating cores/disks or other decoupled components. With this definition, we do not exclude in principle galaxies belonging to groups or clusters: here, a "normal'' galaxy is not necessarily an "isolated'' galaxy, but rather a dynamically relaxed stable system. Nuclear activity is far from universal among galaxies, although most galaxies are known to host super-massive black holes in their nuclei. We purposely include active galaxies in our sample, considering that activity may represent just an episodic stage in the evolution of normal galaxies that appear as globally unperturbed, and therefore fitting our requirements.
The ISM catalogue has been compiled making use of several sources
available in the literature. All values have been re-scaled using a
common distance reference taken from the Catalogue of Principal
Galaxies (PGC). We derive mean values for the ISM content along the
Hubble sequence, using a survival analysis method that properly takes
into account upper limits. The various gas content estimators have
been normalized using both the galaxy absolute blue luminosity
and the size D225. The latter allows the direct comparison of our results
with those of previous works that used either
(Bregman et al. 1992) or D225 (Casoli et al. 1998) to derive canonical mean values for galaxies of
different Hubble types.
The new catalogue significantly improves the statistics of previous reference catalogues. This is especially relevant in the case of early type galaxies: compared to previous studies, our sample improves the number of early-type galaxies included by a factor >3 (from ellipticals to lenticulars). This catalogue is intended to be used in future studies as a reference for the ISM content in normal galaxies. The catalogue can be accessed on line and is also available at the Centre des Données Stellaires (CDS).
We searched in the literature for the different available papers (both survey papers and those dealing with case-by-case studies (Fabbiano et al. 1992; Burstein et al. 1997; Beuing et al. 1999; Knapp et al. 1989; Casoli et al. 1998; Roberts et al. 1991)) and collected all the published data on the different tracers of ISM in galaxies. This produced a preliminary list of more than 3400 candidate galaxies. From this list, all the systems having an acknowledged peculiarity had to be excluded. In addition, we found 148 galaxies, included in this preliminary compilation, that are listed in the Veron et al. (2000) catalogue of active galaxy nuclei (AGN). For the reasons explained above, we decided to include these galaxies in our sample, although they will be discussed separately.
We considered all the systems belonging to at least one of the following categories to be globally peculiar and we therefore removed them from our sample:
After exclusion of all the systems belonging to one of the three categories enumerated above, the final sample of normal galaxies includes 1916 objects. The data presented in this catalogue have been collected from the following sources:
For each galaxy we also collected the distance, the blue luminosity
and the size. To standardize the information contained in our
catalogue we decided to use the morphological classification,
distances, sizes and optical luminosities derived from a single
source: the LEDA archive. These data were used to normalize the values
of FIR and X-ray luminosities as well as the atomic and molecular gas
masses. More precisely, we have extracted the following items for each
galaxy: PGC number, morphological type and related numerical parameter t, distance modulus and absolute magnitude. The distance moduli are
mainly derived from redshifts, corrected for Virgocentric inflow and
adopting
km s-1 Mpc-1. When redshift was not available,
we used the photometric distance modulus, if present in LEDA. Information
lacking in LEDA for some galaxies was completed using the ADS bibliographic
archive, the NED database or the SIMBAD service of the Strasbourg Centre
of Donnée Stellaire (CDS). Finally, the very few galaxies having no
classification in the literature were classified by us looking at the
optical images extracted from NED.
![]() |
Figure 1: Luminosity function and distribution according to morphological type derived for the galaxies in the catalogue. Darker histograms represent AGN hosts, while light gray bars include all galaxies in the sample. |
Open with DEXTER |
The luminosity function and the distribution of morphological types
are shown in Fig. 1. The distribution of morphological
types has two maxima for ellipticals and lenticulars. However, the
rest of morphological types are equally represented in the catalogue
with similar percentages. Altogether, spirals and irregulars ()
represent 40% of our sample. In Fig. 1 galaxies
hosting AGN are represented with dark shaded histograms. At first
sight, their mean blue luminosity is slightly above the average value
for the whole sample; on the other hand, the morphological type
distribution of AGN is more weighted by spiral galaxies compared to
the whole sample.
Table 1: An illustration of the catalogue format.
We have estimated total gas masses and/or luminosities following standard procedures (e.g. see Roberts et al. 1991). The number of detections and upper limits in our sample are listed in Table 2. In the following formulae, the distance d is always in Mpc.
From the value of the IR fluxes at 60 and 100 m we estimated the
dust temperature (K):
HI gas masses were derived mainly from 21 cm fluxes S21 or
from the m21 magnitudes of LEDA. From individual papers giving HI masses
only, we have scaled the published values to the adopted galaxy distance.
From m21, we used the expression:
Table 2: Number of detections ( Det) and upper limit values ( UL) available for the galaxies in Table 1. N(t) represents the total number of galaxies per morphological type bin.
The data needed to derive the molecular gas content have been taken from various sources (see
Appendix A). The formula used to derive molecular gas masses from
CO(1-0) line fluxes (
in Jy km s-1) is:
X-ray emission in galaxies may derive from diffuse gas and/or from discrete sources. This means that the mass estimate of hot gas strongly depends on the prevalent mechanism at work in a particular galaxy. Hence, mass estimates cannot be described by a simple formula. We thus decided to use the X-ray luminosities, instead of the masses, to describe the canonical X-ray yield for galaxies in our sample. A discussion of the differences existing in literature data on X-ray observations with different telescopes has been made by Beuing et al. (1999).
We have 325 detections and 626 upper limits among the inactive galaxies; and 84 detections and 29 upper limits from galaxies indicated in the Veron et al. (2000) catalogue as AGN (139) or containing quasars (6) or BL Lac (3).
To avoid zero-order biases we have normalized the gas masses and
luminosities using two different normalization factors: the total blue
luminosity - - and the square of the linear diameter measured at 25 mag arcsec-2 - D225. These parameters are available for all the 1916 galaxies
of our sample. The absolute blue magnitudes (from LEDA catalogue) are
corrected for dust absorption and cosmological reddening. The global
correction is also a function of the type
(Paturel et al. 1997); the correction factor increases toward later types.
The mean value of
,
derived for the galaxies in our sample is:
In principle, M/
and M/D225 ratios do not depend at all on the
adopted distance of the galaxy. This makes our results
insensitive to the specific value of the Hubble constant
adopted. However, distances and magnitudes are affected differently by
the corrections for the Virgocentric motion and by the galactic and
internal absorptions. Hence, M/
and M/D225 may change
significantly. Since the first approach to this catalogue
was published by Bettoni et al. (2001), the LEDA database has been
modified, because the stored data are continuously being updated. In
addition to these changes, a significant amount of new data from other
sources have been included in the new catalogue.
While these changes forced us to recalculate all the ratios, this
allowed us to test the stability of our results. Comparing the data
extracted from this database in different dates in the last two years,
we found that the 90% of the Log M/
and the 98% of the Log M/D225 values calculated from these different data extractions
differ by less than 1
,
with no variation larger than 2
.
Within these ranges we expect our conclusions to be stable.
In order to define the mean content of each tracer according to the
type, we made use of survival analysis methods
(see Feigelson & Nelson 1999), applied to the different ensembles of M/
and M/D225 data. This analysis tool properly takes into
account both detections and upper limits (UL) in order to derive
representative averages. The mean values are derived and shown in the
following Tables, binned according to the morphological type
code. This method also allows a more direct comparison of our data
with that from literature.
Survival analysis (Feigelson & Nelson 1999) programs are part of several
packages of data analysis, such as IRAF, and may be applied when a
number of upper or lower limit values are available together with
values from detections. Making use of the Kaplan-Meier
estimator, we derived, for each t, mean values of mass/light
and mass/area ratios and the corresponding standard deviations.
When all the galaxies considered within an interval of t are
detected, these values coincide with that from arithmetic
means. On the contrary, the method cannot be applied when both upper
and lower limits are present, for instance when considering the mass
ratios (e.g.
/
). In such a case, we present ratios of mean
values.
Table 3:
Mean warm dust content according to morphological type. N represents the
total number of galaxies which have data (detections and upper limits), while
indicates the number of detections resulting from the survival analysis
statistics. When upper limits exist, mean values are
derived making use of survival analysis. All values are normalized to
,
the
corrected blue luminosities, and to D225, the square of the diameter in kpc
at the isophote of 25 mag arcsec-2.
All the data of this catalogue are listed in Table 1, which is only
available in digital form. The first page is shown in Table 1 of this
paper, as an illustration of the on-line catalogue format. The
columns are: (1) the PGC identifier and (2) the galaxy name, (3) the
numerical type code t (Paturel et al. 1997; de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991), (4) this column indicates
the presence of nuclear activity (Veron et al. 2000) with the letter "a'',
(5) the adopted distance d (in Mpc), (6) the logarithm of the total
blue luminosity
in solar units, (7) the logarithm of the linear
size D25 in kpc corresponding to the 25 mag arcsec-2isophote. The values for each tracer (dust, HI, molecular gas, X-ray)
span four columns: the first two are mass vs.
and the next two
are mass vs. area, defined as D225. Values corresponding to
detections of a galaxy in the corresponding tracers are in the first
and in the third columns while upper limits are in the second and
fourth columns. All masses and luminosities are in solar units.
Following this scheme, the following columns contain: Log
/
detections (Col. 8) and upper limits (Col. 9), Log
/D225 detections (Col. 10) and upper limits (Col. 11), Log
/
detections (Col. 12) and upper limits (Col. 13), Log
/D225 detections (Col. 14) and upper limits (Col. 15), Log
/
detections (Col. 16) and upper limits (Col. 17), Log
/D225 detections (Col. 18) and upper limits (Col. 19), Log
/
detections (Col. 20) and upper limits (Col. 21), Log
/D225 detections
(Col. 22) and upper limits (Col. 23).
References for the gas masses are listed in the last column (24). The
reference codes are given in the Appendix.
This table contains all the essential information compiled for this catalogue. This compilation is intended to serve as a template for future studies on the gas content in selected types of galaxies.
Table 4: Mean HI content according to morphological type. Notation as in Table 3.
Table 5: Mean content of molecular gas according to morphological type. Notation as in Table 3. The values for t=-4 and t=8 are based on a low number of galaxies and are more uncertain.
Table 6:
Mean X-ray luminosity of the galaxy
versus the morphological type t.
All values are normalized to
,
the corrected blue luminosities, or D225, the
square of the diameter in kpc at the isophote of 25 mag arcsec-2. The values of the first table
were calculated excluding the galaxies hosting AGN. The second table includes them.
Tables 2-6 give the normalized mean gas
contents - Log M/D2 and Log
- and the detection rates for the
galaxies of the sample, as a function of the Hubble type. The
galaxies are identified according to the numerical code t (RC3 morphological type). Some types have two numerical codes: elliptical
galaxies span the types -5 and -4; S0-a the types -1 and 0 and Sc galaxies fill the types 5 and 6; all the remaining galaxy types are
identified by a single code. Note that the code 5.00 also includes
spiral galaxies with ambiguous classification (type S?). In our sample
there are only 7 galaxies falling into this category.
Bregman et al. (1992) and Casoli et al. (1998) have previously addressed the study
of the ISM content in galaxies and its variation along the Hubble
sequence. Both groups based their study on two samples of 467
(Bregman et al. 1992) and 582 (Casoli et al. 1998) galaxies, compiled and processed
according to different criteria. Our catalogue improves by a significant
factor (3-4) the overall statistics of previous samples. The most
significant improvement corresponds to the left branch of the Hubble
sequence: compared to previous works, the number of early-type
galaxies (t <0) with firm detections processed for this
catalogue is >3 times larger.
Bregman et al. (1992) analyzed their sample using other non-parametric
tests, based on rank,
to study the variation of the mean gas content with morphological
type. The estimated averages were normalized to the galaxy blue
luminosity. Their results indicate that the mean content of atomic
gas (in
scale) decreases by two orders of magnitude from
early-type spirals (Sa) to ellipticals (E). A similar result is
obtained for the mean content of molecular gas. Altogether, these
results underlined that ellipticals have a neutral gas content
significantly lower than lenticulars (see Fig. 2). The
sample of Bregman et al. (1992) has only 7 (35) firm detections in CO (HI)
for galaxies spanning the lenticular-elliptical range.
![]() |
Figure 2:
Comparison between the mean Log M/L ratios for HI (left panels) and for molecular gas
(right panels) extracted from the present catalogue and mean Log M/L ratios of previous studies
(Casoli et al. 1998;
Bregman et al. 1992). In the upper panel the mean masses are normalized with respect to D225,
as adopted by Casoli et al. (1998), while in the lower panel ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The scenario depicted by Casoli et al. (1998) seems at odds with Bregman et al. (1992)'s results, however. Casoli et al. (1998) used a survival analysis method and normalized their data by D225. According to Casoli et al. (1998), the atomic mean gas content shows little variation going from elliptical to lenticular galaxies (see upper panel of Fig. 2). Within the same type range, the molecular gas content varies by less than one order of magnitude: i.e., significantly less than shown by Bregman et al. (1992). Casoli et al. (1998) excluded from their sample galaxies in cluster environments, tagged as HI-deficient. This might explain why, in contrast to Bregman et al. (1992), Casoli et al. (1998) find no significant trend for the HI content. The sample of Casoli et al. (1998) has 11 (13) firm detections in CO (HI) for galaxies spanning the lenticular-elliptical range.
These two scenarios might only be reconciled if the mean /D225 ratios were seen to strongly depend on morphological type in the
"conflicting'' range: ellipticals would need to be much fainter, by at
least two orders of magnitude, with respect to S0 of comparable
sizes. As it has been discussed in Sect. 3.1, the estimated
trend of
is much smoother, however; this is confirmed
by the similar trends obtained using either M/
or M/D225 as gas
content indicators.
The strong disagreement between these two studies should be
attributable to their poor statistics. This is probably the reason
why our estimates of the neutral gas content match neither of previous
claims in this range. As it is shown in Table 2, the
present catalogue is based on 31 CO detections and 132 HI detections
within the range of early type galaxies (ellipticals to
lenticulars). Our results, normalized with respect to
and D225 both indicate a similar trend: a moderate one order of magnitude
decrease of the mean neutral gas content (atomic and/or molecular)
going from S0 to E galaxies.
It is worth noting that, in contrast to Casoli et al. (1998), we found that
the
/
ratio is roughly constant along the Hubble sequence,
except for the latest type systems (Sd and Irr) where this ratio
decreases by one order of magnitude. Early-type galaxies and early
spirals possess
40% of their neutral gas content in the
molecular phase, while late-type spirals and irregulars have
90% of their neutral gas content in atomic form. In
Fig. 3, we plotted our data together with values derived by
Casoli et al. (1998).
![]() |
Figure 3: The mean molecular to atomic gas content ratio as a function of Hubble type. The open symbols are derived from our catalogue, while full symbols represent ratios published by Casoli et al. (1998, full symbols). |
Open with DEXTER |
We have found no significant differences in the neutral gas content between galaxies hosting AGNs and those considered as non-active. For this reason, the mean data in Tables 3-4 do not distinguish between active and inactive galaxies, even if it is possible to identify both categories of galaxies in our catalogue.
In our database there are 20 active galaxies that are more luminous than
Log /
=-2, while most of the remaining galaxies have values between -2 and -4. Apart from the overluminous galaxies, the mean ratios
/
and
/D225 show an almost flat trend going from elliptical galaxies
to Sa and a slowly decreasing trend for later types (Fig. 4).
In Table 6 we publish the mean values obtained by both including and
excluding AGN.
![]() |
Figure 4:
Variation of mean Log ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
We have presented a catalogue devoted to a study of the ISM content in a sample of normal galaxies. The catalogue has been compiled based on previous catalogues with the addition of a significant volume of new data. This is intended to serve as a reference defining the canonical gas content of "normal'' galaxies along the Hubble sequence. The latest version of the catalogue is also available at http://dipastro.pd.astro.it/galletta/ismcat/. The number of galaxies included, 1916 systems, is 3-4 times greater than previous studies, and fills a gap currently existing in the ISM studies of cold gas for early-type galaxies. All the catalogue data have been homogenized and reduced to the same distance scale and can be accessed as a single text list, formatted in columns, or consulted at CDS. Upon request, it can be obtained from the authors as an Excel-formatted database.
Acknowledgements
The authors thanks Dr. D. Hogg for the useful comments to this work.This research made use of Vizier service (Ochsenbein et al. 2000), the SIMBAD database (operated at CDS, Strasbourg, France), the NASA/IPAC Extragalactic Database (NED) (which is operated by JPL, California Institute of Technology, under contract to NASA) and NASA's Astrophysics Data System Abstract Service (mirrored in CDS of Strasbourg). The authors would like to thank Dr. G. Paturel for kindly making the LEDA database's FIR raw data available and Dr. F. Ochsenbein for the changes made to the Vizier's query form on our request. GG made use of funds from the University of Padova (Fondi 60%-2002).