A&A 401, 357-360 (2003)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20030097
S. J. Adelman
Department of Physics, The Citadel, 171 Moultrie Street, Charleston, SC 29409, USA
Received 9 December 2002 / Accepted 22 January 2003
Abstract
Differential Strömgren uvby observations from the Four College
Automated Photoelectric Telescope (FCAPT) are presented for the metallic-lined
stars 60 Tau and HR 1528 and the magnetic Chemically Peculiar stars HR 8216 and
HR 8770. The first star, which is a Scuti variable, was found not
to change its mean magnitudes. HR 1528 is best described as constant.
A decade of photometry of HR 8216 shows that its b and y values
have changed by -0.016 and -0.010 mag, respectively, over this time and
now can be considered a photometric variable. For
HR 8770 a period of 5.3923 days is derived with the photometric variability
being generally in phase. The light curves also suggest possible surface
abundance inhomogeneities.
Key words: stars: chemically peculiar - stars: individual: 60 Tau - stars: individual: HR 1528 - stars: individual: HR 8216 - stars: individual: HR 8770
Single-channel differential Strömgren uvby photometry from the Four College Automated Photoelectric Telescope (FCAPT) at Washington Camp, AZ, obtained in recent years is presented for the metallic-line (Am) spectroscopic binaries 60 Tau and HR 1528 and the magnetic Chemically Peculiar (mCP) stars HR 8216 and HR 8770. These investigations are part of a series of continuing studies of the stability of single non-magnetic CP stars and of the photometric variability of magnetic CP stars to determine both their rotational periods and the shapes of their light curves. This automated telescope measures the dark count and then in each filter sky-ch-c-v-c-v-c-v-c-ch-sky for each group of variable (v), check (ch), and comparison (c) stars where sky is a reading of the sky. Photometric information on the variables of this paper is summarized in Table 1 (Hoffleit 1982; Hoffleit et al. 1993). No corrections were made for any neutral density filter differences among the stars of each group. The comparison and check stars were chosen from presumably non-variable stars near the variables on the sky that had similar V magnitudes and B-V colors. Adelman et al. (1998) checked their stability using Hipparcos photometry (ESA 1997). The Scargle periodogram (Scargle 1982; Horne & Baliunas 1986) and the clean algorithm (Roberts et al. 1987) were used to help find the period of HR 8770.
For the mercury-manganese (HgMn) and metallic-lined (Am) stars, which constitute
the non-magnetic CP stars, a question of particular importance is whether there
exist any class members, which are not located in the variability strip, that
are not intrinsically constant. On the basis of their Hipparcos photometry
Adelman (1998) noted that four Am stars are possible variables including 60 Tau (HD 27628, HR 1368, HIP 20400) and HR 1528 (HD 30453, HIP 22407). Abt &
Morrell (1995) classified them as Am (A6/F0/F2) and Am (A7/F0/F2),
respectively, and noted that
for both is 14 km s-1. As
Celestia 2000 (ESA 1998) did not note the kind of variability for 60 Tau, the
author mistakenly assumed that it was unknown or the star was really constant.
Kurtz (1978) confirmed that 60 Tau was a spectroscopic binary Am star (Cowley
et al. 1969) of the classical Am variety. Horan (1979) discovered its Scuti nature. In three observing seasons, 1998-99, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001,
4, 29, and 52 sets of uvby measurements were made with the FCAPT. The
mean and values standard deviations in Table 2 are not particularly suggestive
of variability. However, Li (2000) found that this
Scuti
variable in 5 nights of observations covering 30 hours had two frequencies of
13.0364 and 11.8521 d-1, and amplitudes of 6.01 and 3.95 mmag in v
and of 3.35 and 1.99 mmag in y, respectively. He claims a measuring
error of 4.0 mmag. As our data was obtained in a one observation per
photometric night mode, its
Scuti nature is not particularly evident.
The mean uvby magnitudes of 60 Tau appear to remain constant, but within
the data set are some values which are suggestive of variability.
Harper (1932) discovered HR 1528 was a spectroscopic binary. Stockton & Fekel (1992) found lines of the secondary in the red. Both components appear to be synchronously rotating. Its photometry in Table 3 indicates that it is a constant star.
Of the two other potentially variable Am stars listed by Adelman (1998), HR 5341 was found to be constant by Adelman (2001) and HR 9044 is too far South to be properly observed by the FCAPT. As no Am stars which are located outside the variability strip are known to be intrinsic photometric variables, the constancy of such Am stars is now well established.
HD number | Star name | Type | V | Spectral type |
27628 | 60 Tau | v | 5.72 | A3m |
27397 | 57 Tau | c | 5.59 | F0 IV |
28867 | HR 1442 | ch | 6.25 | B9 IVn |
30453 | HR 1528 | v | 5.86 | A8m |
28459 | HR 1419 | c | 6.21 | B9.5 Vn |
32608 | HR 1639 | ch | 6.49 | A5 V |
204411 | HR 8216 | v | 5.13 | A6pCrEu: |
205314 | HR 8246 | c | 5.75 | A0 V |
203746 | BD +48![]() |
ch | 6.84 | A1 V |
217833 | HR 8770 | v | 6.50 | B9 IIIHewk |
217348 | HR 8745 | c | 6.43 | B9 III |
218753 | 2 Cas | ch | 5.70 | A5 III |
The mCP stars are photometric, spectrum, and magnetic variables with their emergent energy distributions, photospheric abundances, and magnetic field strengths dependent upon photospheric location. As their magnetic and rotational axes are not usually aligned, a distant observer sees a variety of variability as they rotate. Their anomalous photospheric abundances, which are thought to be produced by hydrodynamical processes especially radiative diffusion and gravitational settling in radiative envelopes containing strong magnetic fields, are functions of the local magnetic field strength and the time since the star was on the Zero Age Main Sequence (Michaud & Proffitt 1993 and references therein). Differential photometric studies with the FCAPT have improved their periods and light curves (see, e.g., Adelman et al. 1999) so that they can be used to better relate observations taken at different times, detect variable light curves, and study the period distribution of the mCP stars. Using spectra, surface maps of abundances for some stars which exhibit moderate rotation can be derived to serve as tests of mCP star theories.
Due to discrepancies in various published descriptions of its spectra and its UBV colors Preston (1970) suggested that the cool mCP star HR 8216 (HD 204411) might be a very long period photometric and/or spectroscopic variable. Caliskan's (1995) comparison of overlapping regions of spectra taken at the Dominion Astrophysical Observatory at a reciprocal dispersion of 2.4 Å mm-1, resolution = 0.072 Å, and S/N = 200+ between 1988 and 1993 provide strong evidence for constancy within this period. Adelman et al. (1994) presented 67 uvby FCAPT observations taken over four observing seasons which also strongly indicated constancy. Later Adelman & Rice (1999) published data for four additional observing seasons. At least 24 values were obtained during four of these eight seasons. At best one could suggest possible small long term variability due to minor discrepancies between the mean averages. In this paper 35, 52, and 29 sets of uvby FCAPT photometry of HR 8216 obtained during the 1998-99, 1999-2000, and 2000-01 observing seasons, respectively, (Table 4) are summarized in Table 5. Between the 1997-98 and 1998-99 data, a neutral density filter was changed for the ch star so that it became approximately 2.5 mag brighter and slightly decreased the standard deviations in the ch-c values.
Heliocentric | u | u | v | v | b | b | y | y |
Julian Date | v-c | ch-c | v-c | ch-c | v-c | ch-c | v-c | ch-c |
1998-99 | ||||||||
35 values | ||||||||
average | 0.033 | -1.316 | -0.300 | -1.189 | -0.417 | -1.134 | -0.472 | -1.095 |
std. dev. | 0.003 | 0.007 | 0.004 | 0.007 | 0.002 | 0.005 | 0.002 | 0.004 |
1999-2000 | ||||||||
52 values | ||||||||
average | 0.032 | -1.314 | -0.299 | -1.188 | -0.417 | -1.134 | -0.470 | -1.095 |
std. dev. | 0.003 | 0.007 | 0.003 | 0.005 | 0.002 | 0.005 | 0.008 | 0.007 |
2000-2001 | ||||||||
29 values | ||||||||
average | 0.030 | -1.316 | -0.300 | -1.189 | -0.419 | -1.136 | -0.473 | -1.095 |
std. dev. | 0.005 | 0.005 | 0.004 | 0.004 | 0.003 | 0.003 | 0.002 | 0.003 |
![]() |
Figure 1: The mean b magnitudes of the mCP star HR 8216 as a function of year of observation. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 2: Differential uvby photometry of the mCP star HR 8770 with the ephemeris HJD (light minimum ) = 2451427.9203 +5.3923 E. |
Open with DEXTER |
When the mean v-c magnitudes for ,
v,
(see Fig. 1),
and y are plotted against the midpoint of the observing season and
linear fits are made, the slopes are 0.00057, -0.00035, -0.00164, and -0.00098 mag y-1, respectively, with the relations for
and y
being the most convincing. Thus in 10 years, the changes in
and
v are about the same order as the yearly standard deviations while
those for
and y of -0.016 and -0.010 mag, respectively, are
larger and significant. The complete dataset implies that the variability
period is probably at least 20 years with a longer period being more
likely. If similar observations are subsequently obtained every few
years, eventually they should lead to
the determination of its rotational period. The amplitudes in
each color depend both on the surficial abundance inhomogeneities and the
aspect at which HR 8216 is viewed. The existence of photometric changes also
suggests those in the spectra. But their small sizes and the study by
Caliskan (1995) indicates that those in the spectra are likely to be minimal
except perhaps for lines of some trace element which is distributed over the
surface in a manner quite different than most of the more common metals.
This type of search requires obtaining spectra with high resolution and S/N
ratios. As it is virtually non-rotating, any information about its spectral
variability provides some evidence concerning the magnetic field of this star
which is nearing the end of its main sequence lifetime.
HR 8770 (HD 217833, HIP 113797, V638 Cas) is classified as B9 III weak. Veto et al. (1980) detected photometric variability and found a period of 5.4 days. Celestia 2000 (ESA 1998) gives a period of 5.3933 days. Using 29 and 32 FCAPT uvby observations from the 1999-2000 and the 2000-2001 observing seasons, respectively, I found a period of 5.3923 days. The ch-c values indicate constancy, but the mean values from the two years are slightly offset. This could be real or due to some minor change in differential extinction which is not evident in other data sets between the two observing seasons. It is important to obtain additional photometric observations to determine the most probable cause of the discrepancies in the v-c values. In Table 6 the photometric values have not been adjusted for this effect. However, in displaying the light curves the 2000-2001 values were adjusted by 0.005 mag for uby and 0.010 mag for y.
From this data the derived ephemeris was
Acknowledgements
This work was supported in part by NSF grant AST-0071260. I appreciate the continuing efforts of Louis J. Boyd, Robert J. Dukes, Jr., and George P. McCook to keep the FCAPT operating properly. This research has used the SIMBAD database, operated at the CDS, Strasbourg, France.