Since this research includes an iterative process, one has to be very
careful not to introduce (and so to propagate) any errors.
The strategy in its entirety therefore encompasses a number of steps, including
(1.) a spectral coverage of standard infrared sources from A0 to M8,
(2.) a homogeneous data reduction, (3.) a detailed literature study, (4.)
a detailed knowledge of the impact of the various parameters on the
spectral signature, (5.) a statistical method to test the
goodness-of-fit (Kolmogorov-Smirnov test) and (6.) high-resolution
observations with two independent instruments. Some points (in
particular, points 4 and 5) have already been demonstrated in the case
of Tau in Paper I. Points 1, 2 and 6 will be elaborated
on in Sects. 3, 4 and 5 respectively.
In its totality, the general method of analysis - based on these 6
points - may be summarised as follows:
a large set of standard stars (A0-M8) has been observed with
ISO-SWS (Sect. 3). The observational data first have been
subjected to a homogeneous data-reduction procedure (Sect. 4). Thereafter, the carefully reduced ISO-SWS data
of one warm and one cool star were compared with
the observational data of two independent instruments (FTS-KP and FTS-ATMOS,
see Sect. 5). This step is very crucial,
since this is the only secure and decisive way to point out
calibration problems with the
detectors of ISO-SWS. The complete observational data-set, covering a
broad parameter space, was then
compared with theoretical predictions. By knowing already some
problematic points in the calibration of ISO-SWS, these comparisons
led both to a refinement of our knowledge on the calibration problems
and to a determination of theoretical modelling problems (Sect. 6).
The knowledge on the relative importance of the different molecules
- displaying their characteristic absorption pattern somewhere in the broad
ISO-SWS wavelength-range - and on the impact of the various stellar
parameters on the infrared spectrum
enabled us also to determine the fundamental stellar parameters for
the cool giants in our sample Paper I.
Due to severe calibration problems with the band-2 data
(see Sect. 4), only band-1 data were used for this part of the process.
Once a high-level
of agreement between observed and synthetic data was reached, a
statistical test was needed to objectively judge on the different
synthetic spectra. A choice was made for the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test
Paper I. This statistical test
globally checks the goodness-of-fit of the observed and
synthetic spectra by computing a deviation estimating parameter
(see Eq. (5) in Paper I). The
lower the
-value, the better the accordance between the
observed data and the synthetic spectrum.
Using this method, the effective temperature, gravity,
metallicity, microturbulent velocity together with the abundance
of C, N and O and the
-ratio were estimated for the cool stars.
From the energy distribution of the synthetic spectrum between
2.38 and 4.08
m and the absolute flux-values in this
wavelength range of the ISO-SWS spectrum, the angular diameter was
deduced. We therefore have minimised the residual sum of
squares
![]() |
The error bars on the
atmospheric parameters were estimated from 1. the intrinsic
uncertainty on the synthetic spectrum (i.e. the possibility to
distinguish different synthetic spectra at a specific resolution,
i.e. there should be a significant difference in -values)
which is thus dependent on both the resolving power of the
observation and the specific values of the fundamental parameters,
2. the uncertainty on the ISO-SWS spectrum which is directly
related to the S/N of the ISO-SWS observation, 3. the value
of the
-parameters in the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test and 4. the still remaining discrepancies between observed and synthetic
spectra.
It should be noted that an error on the effective temperature
introduces an error on the angular diameter. The IR flux of the cool
giants does not follow the Rayleigh-Jeans law for a black-body, and we
can write
.
Thus, with
and
,
one obtains
From the angular diameter and the parallax
measurements (mas) from Hipparcos (with an exception being
Cen A, for which a more accurate parallax by Pourbaix et al. 1999, is
available), the stellar radius was
derived. This radius, together
with the gravity - determined from the ISO-SWS spectrum - then yielded
the gravity-inferred mass. From the radius and the effective
temperature, the stellar luminosity could be extracted.
This method of analysis could however not be applied to the warm stars of the sample. Absorption by atoms determines the spectrum of these stars. It turned out to be unfeasible to determine the effective temperature, gravity, microturbulence, metallicity and abundances of the chemical elements from the ISO-SWS spectra of these warm stars, due to
Copyright ESO 2003