A&A 394, 729-734 (2002)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20021098
D. Shapakidze1,
- G. Melikidze1 - G. Machabeli2
1 - Institute of Astronomy, University of Zielona Góra,
Lubuska 2, 65-265 Zielona Góra, Poland
2 - Center for Plasma Astrophysics,
Abastumani Astrophysical Observatory,
Al.Kazbegi ave. 2a, Tbilisi 380060, Georgia
Received 5 June 2002 / Accepted 4 July 2002
Abstract
We present a plasma model for formation of
discontinuous position-angle curves observed in some radio pulsar
profiles. The model is based on the polarization properties of
radio waves excited by Cherenkov-drift instability developing in
pulsar magnetospheres. The radiation is confined in a cone of
emission and consists of two orthogonally polarized waves.
Examination of a quasi-linear stage of Cherenkov-drift instability
shows that the excitation mechanism provides the modes with
different spectral energy densities depending on the direction of
.
As a pulsar rotates, an observer's sight-line track
crosses different mode-predominated areas on the base of the
emission cone. Transition of the sight-line track from one
mode-predominated area to another results in the formation of
pulsar polarization fluctuations observed in polarization angle
distribution displays and average waveforms.
Key words: stars: pulsars: general - polarization - radiation mechanisms: non-thermal - plasmas - instabilities
We propose a plasma mechanism to explain the nature of
discontinuities observed in polarization position-angle (PA)
sweeps plotted on average pulse profiles of some radio pulsars
(Stinebring et al. 1984a; Gil & Lyne 1995;
Asgekar & Deshpande 2000). PA curves usually show a smooth
"S-shaped" variation across the pulse profile, which is
theoretically well interpreted in the framework of the rotating
vector model (Radhakrishnan & Cooke 1969). However, as
yet, there is no satisfactory explanation of observed
discontinuous jumps (almost equal to
)
of the PA curve
instead of the smooth S-shaped trace. The displays of
average-pulse profiles of such pulsars (Backer & Rankin
1980; Stinebring et al. 1984a, 1984b)
left no doubt that the PA curve discontinuities are due to the
presence of orthogonally polarized modes in pulsar emission. It
was supposed that the different orthogonal modes are dominant for
different parts of these profiles and, so, instead of the smooth
S-shaped curve of PA, there is a discontinuous step in the curve
(Lyne & Graham-Smith 1998).
In this paper we consider the plasma mechanism for generation of the orthogonally polarized radio emission from pulsars and study plasma energy redistribution between the orthogonal modes. Our mechanism is intrinsic to the plasma model of pulsar radio emission elaborated in the series of works by Kazbegi et al. (KMM) (1989,1991a,1991b); Kazbegi et al. (1989,1991) and also by Lyutikov et al. (1999).
In the framework of the plasma model, pulsar radiation can be
generated mainly by two types of plasma instabilities - by the
cyclotron instability and the so-called Cherenkov-drift
instability (ChDI). ChDI excites two orthogonally polarized plasma
modes. These are transverse (t) and longitudinal-transverse
(lt) waves. Applying the method used to treat the quasi-linear
theory of cyclotron instability (Lominadze et al. 1979,1983; Lyutikov 1998; Malov &
Machabeli 2001), we examine the quasi-linear stage of ChDI
and derive the ratio between the spectral energy densities of
these waves,
.
As we demonstrate in Sect. 2, the ratio
depends on the direction of the wave propagation. This means that
the waves of different polarization predominate in the adjacent
areas of a conical emission beam. So, the transition of the
observer's line of sight from one area to another should be
accompanied by a sharp change of observed polarization and
corresponding jumps in the PA curve of almost in
.
The organization of the paper is as follows. First, in Sect. 2 we discuss the development of ChDI in pulsar magnetospheres taking into account the curvature drift of the resonant particles and study a quasi-linear relaxation of the instability. In Sect. 3 we propose a model for explanation of the nature of discontinuities observed in polarization position-angle (PA) sweeps and finally, in Sect. 4, we offer a summary of our results.
The necessary condition for the development of Cherenkov-drift
instability (as for usual Cherenkov instability) is the presence
of a beam of particles in plasma. The plasma of pulsar
magnetospheres is assumed to be a steady, space charge separated
limited flow along the open curved magnetic field lines (Arons
1981; Muslimov & Tsygan 1992). It consists of i) a
bulk of secondary plasma particles, emanated with low Lorentz
factors
(Machabeli & Usov 1989),
and ii) a beam of primary particles (electrons or ions, depending
on the magnetic dipole orientation) ejected from the stellar
surface with Lorentz factors
.
ChDI
develops when the beam particle curvature drift is significant.
The drift velocity is directed across the plane of magnetic field
lines curvature and is:
The waves are generated when the Cherenkov-drift resonance
condition fulfills:
One of the excited waves is a transverse t-wave, the electric
field of which is directed perpendicularly to the plane of the
wave vector and the external magnetic field (
,
). The other one is a longitudinal-transverse
lt-wave. Its electric field vector lies in the (
,
)
plane. So, t and lt waves, propagating in the
same direction, are orthogonally polarized. The growth rate of
these waves is written as:
Studying the back reaction of the excited waves upon the resonant
particles is the next step of investigation of ChDI. We treat the
problem in a quasi-linear approximation (see Shapakidze et al.
2002), when the energies of t and lt modes,
d
,
are still much less than the energy of
plasma particles,
.
The development of ChDI results in
the diffusion (in the momenta space) of the resonant particles of
a beam. The diffusion occurs along as well as across the magnetic
field lines. The expressions for diffusion coefficients along
(
)
as well as across (
)
the magnetic field lines are derived by Shapakidze et al. (2002).
The quasi-linear relaxation of ChDI is described by the following equation:
A stationary state (
)
may be reached
when the both righthand terms in Eq. (5) are equal to zero
or cancel each other. As for the transverse diffusion, it is
balanced by the perpendicular forces. To estimate the relative
importance of the parallel quasi-linear diffusion and
we have to consider the ratio between the terms
and
in Eq. (5). Estimations show that
for the parameters of a typical pulsar magnetosphere, the
contribution of the parallel diffusion significantly exceeds the
contribution of the parallel forces:
Keeping in mind that the parallel forces contribute to the
quasi-linear relaxation insignificantly, we write down the
quasi-linear equation for the distribution function as follows:
Let us assume that the quasi-linear reaction of both t and ltwaves change the distribution function in the same way. So, we can
substitute the following equation for Eq. (12):
From Eq. (15) we easily express the ratio between the energies of t and lt waves by means of
transverse components of the wave vector (kx,kr):
Cherenkov-drift radiation is confined within the emission cone of
a small opening angle
.
The radiation is generated
in the rotating pulsar magnetosphere and detected by an observer
while its line of sight is crossing the base of the emission cone.
Transverse components of the wave vector (kx,kr) define the
observed area of the base. On the other hand, they also define the
mode with predominant intensity (see Eq. (16)).
Consequently, we conclude that in our model the pulsar emission
occurs in one orthogonal mode or the other (i.e. an observer
should identify the t or lt waves of different polarization)
while passing through the different areas on the base of the
emission cone. Transition of the observers' line of sight from one
area to another should be accompanied by a sharp change in the
observed polarization and corresponding jump of the PA curve by
.
The area where t mode predominates should be separated from the
area of lt mode domination by the lines of the spectral energy
equality curve. It is handy to plot a diagram of the energy
equality curve - the solution of Eq. (16) in the case
- in polar coordinates
,
where
and
:
In Fig. 1 it is shown that the observer's line of sight
(sight-line track) crosses the energy equality curve
and passes in a sequence through t and ltwave predominated areas. That is why the arcs of PA curve,
corresponding to t and lt waves, can be obtained in a sequence
along the pulse window. PA itself should spontaneously change its
value by
at the pulse longitudes, where the
sight-line track intersects the energy equality curve.
![]() |
Figure 1:
Formation of orthogonal jumps in the shape of PA curve in
the framework of the proposed model. An area, bounded by the large
circle, presents the base of emission cone. Here y axis is
directed toward us and shows the direction of the magnetic field
lines in the wave generation region. Solid curve lines inside the
circle represent spectral energy equality lines
(
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
It seems that most cases of pulsar polarization fluctuations can
be explained in the framework of our model. Generation of t and
lt modes by ChDI is supported by evidence in both high and
low-frequency observations that the pulsar radiation is
orthogonally polarized (Cordes et al. 1978;
Backer & Rankin 1980; Stinebring et al. 1984a
and references therein). Two different polarization modes are well
defined while studying the PA distribution on the separated mode
profiles (see, e.g., Gil et al. 1992). However, the pure
orthogonality is presented either in the center or at the wings of
the profile and the modes are by no means orthogonal throughout
the whole window. Indeed, the deviation from pure orthogonality
may be caused by the fact that orientation of the magnetic field
(
)
could be different at the sites of t and lt mode
excitation. Hence, (
)
planes could be also
differently oriented if modes arrive from different places.
Consequently, the angular difference between
and
is not always
,
but can vary along the
pulse window.
The fact that intensities of individual orthogonal modes are not
equally distributed within the pulse window (Stinebring et al.
1984a,1984b; Gil 1987) is well supported by our
result (see Eq. (16)). A fine example of the observed
intensity distribution within the pulse profile of PSR 0834+06
(Gil 1987, Fig. 3) demonstrates a good fit of our model with
observations. It naturally follows from the model that if the
sight-line track passes through
waves dominated areas (as it is shown in Fig. 1), then the
lt mode should dominate the center of the profile, while the tmode should dominate the wings - exactly as in the case of PSR
0834+06.
A rapid orthogonal jump occurs on the total PA curve at longitudes where modes are of comparable equal intensity (see, e.g., PSR 0329+54 in Gil & Lyne 1995). PSR 0329+54 is one of the best examples of almost orthogonal separation between the modes throughout the whole profile. The characteristic S shape of the PA curve can be seen in both modes. However, the total PA curve is discontinuous (its shape deviates from the pure S-shaped swing) which clearly indicates the existence of adjacent areas of mode intensity domination. Consequently, we suggest that our model well suits the case of PSR 0329+54 (compare the modelled PA curve in Fig. 1 with that of PSR 0329+54, see Fig. 1 in Gil & Lyne 1995).
Many profiles of pulsars show the discontinuity of the PA curve at
more then one pulse longitude (so-called multi-discontinuity). For
example, we can refer to the averaged waveforms of PSR 2020+28
(Stinebring et al. 1984b), PSR J0846-3533 at 327 MHz and
PSR 0834+06 at 35 MHz (Asgekar & Deshpande 2000). The
multi-discontinuity of the shape of the total PA curve can be
naturally obtained from our model. Generally, four branches of the
energy equality curve compose the solution of
equation. Here the drift velocity
(
)
acts as a scaling factor. Indeed, if the condition
is fulfilled, then only two
branches of the spectral energy equality curve appear within the
base of the emission cone (Fig. 1). If
,
then the same two branches still appear
within the base, but two additional branches (passing out of the
origin of the reference frame) come closer to the origin and touch
the circle delineated by the base of emission cone (dashed circle
in Fig. 2).
![]() |
Figure 2:
All four branches of a spectral energy equality curve -
the roots of equation
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
The various observed waveforms can be modelled by choosing the proper direction of the sight-line tracks relative to the energy equality curves. Indeed, the sight-line track does not necessarily pass the x axis transversely (as it is drawn in Figs. 1 and 2), but could be directed suitably to the given observed waveform (note that sight-line track by definition is transverse to the pulsar rotation axis). That is why our model seems to be flexible concerning the case of multi-discontinuities as well.
In this paper we present a qualitative model for the formation of discontinuous steps in position angle curves observed in emission of some radio pulsars. The model is based on the polarization properties of plasma waves generated in pulsar magnetospheres due to Cherenkov-drift instability.
In the vicinity of the pulsar light cylinder, two orthogonally
polarized, transverse (t) and longitudinal transverse (lt)
radio waves can be excited by ChDI. The excitation mechanism
provides the modes with different spectral energy densities for
different values of the wave vector
.
Particularly, we
find that the ratio of energy spectral densities between t and
lt waves is defined by transverse components of the wave vector
(kx,kr). This relation is obtained by studying the
quasi-linear stage of ChDI and the ratio depends on the direction
of the wave propagation. This means that intensities of individual
orthogonal modes are not equally distributed within the base of
the emission cone.
Consequently we obtain adjacent areas on the base of the emission cone, where one mode predominates another and vice versa. The areas are separated by the energy equality curves. The sight-line track crosses different mode-predominated areas in a sequence, resulting in the observed variations in the shape of the total PA curve. The discontinuities in the shape of the total PA curve should be observed at the longitudes, where the sight-line track intersects the energy equality curve. Most of the cases of pulsar polarization fluctuations could be explained according to the model proposed in this paper.
Acknowledgements
We thank J. Gil for useful discussions. DSh was partially supported by UNESCO Fellowship, International Center for Dense Magnetized Plasma, Institute of Plasma Physics and Laser Microfusion, Warsaw, Poland. The paper is supported in part by KBN Grant 2 P03D 00819 of the Polish State Committee for Scientific Research. We also thank an anonymous referee for useful notes.