A&A 394, 271-274 (2002)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20021090
J. Kawamura1, -
T. R. Hunter2 -
C.-Y. E. Tong2 -
R. Blundell2 -
D. C. Papa2 -
F. Patt3 -
W. Peters3 -
T. L. Wilson3,4 -
C. Henkel4 -
G. Gol'tsman5 -
E. Gershenzon5
1 - California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, California,
91125, USA
2 -
Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, 60 Garden
St., Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138, USA
3 -
Submillimeter Telescope Observatory, 933 N. Cherry Ave., Tucson,
Arizona, 85721, USA
4 -
Max-Planck Institut für Radioastronomie, Postfach 2024,
53010 Bonn, Germany
5 -
Moscow State Pedagogical University, Moscow, 119435, Russia
Received 9 February 2001 / Accepted 24 July 2002
Abstract
Using a superconductive hot-electron bolometer heterodyne receiver
on the 10-m Heinrich Hertz Telescope on Mount Graham, Arizona,
we have obtained velocity-resolved 1.037 THz CO (
)
spectra toward several positions along the Orion Molecular Cloud (OMC-1)
ridge. We confirm the general results of prior observations of high-JCO lines that show that the high temperature,
,
high density molecular gas,
,
is quite extended,
found along a
4' region centered on BN/KL. However, our
observations have significantly improved angular resolution, and with
a beam size of
we are able to
spatially and kinematically discriminate the emission originating in
the extended quiescent ridge from the very strong and broadened emission
originating in the compact molecular outflow.
The ridge emission very close to the BN/KL region appears to
originate from two distinct clouds along the line of sight with
and
.
The former component dominates the emission to the south of BN/KL and the
latter to the north, with a turnover point coincident with or near BN/KL. Our
evidence precludes a simple rotation of the inner ridge and lends support
to a model in which there are multiple molecular clouds along the line of
sight towards the Orion ridge.
Key words: ISM: molecules - ISM: individual objects: Orion KL - submillimeter
At a distance of less than 0.5 kpc, the Orion Molecular Cloud (OMC) is the
nearest site of massive star formation (Genzel & Stutzki 1989). The OMC-1
core contains a tight cluster of energetic sources whose properties and
relations to one another are difficult to unravel because they are simply so
densely packed together. The Becklin-Neugebauer (BN) object, Kleinmann-Low (KL)
infrared nebula, intense SiO and water vapor masers, and a massive molecular
outflow (e.g., Menten & Reid 1995) all reside in a 30''-diameter
area, which we hereafter refer to as the BN/KL region.
When this region is explored with molecular lines, it is possible to
separate the emission sources into three components, which are distinguished
by their linewidths. In order of increasing velocity dispersion, the three
components are the extended quiescent cloud (the ridge), the hot core,
and the outflowing and shocked gas. For example, in single-dish
observations of low-J CO transitions the spectra consist of a blend
of emission from the quiescent gas and the outflowing gas.
Interferometric observations allow one to resolve the spatially
compact outflow, but filter out much of the emission from the extended
ridge. The velocity of the quiescent gas seems to follow a shallow gradient
along the ridge, becoming more positive in
from N to S. This has
been taken as evidence for rotation of the Orion molecular cloud along an
axis roughly lying in a E-W direction (Kutner et al. 1976, 1977;
Hasegawa et al. 1984; Vogel et al. 1985). Although there may indeed be
large-scale rotation of the cloud, more recent observations have shown that
the velocity and structure of the OMC ridge is too complicated to be
consistent with a simple rotation of the compact ridge (Wilson et al. 1986).
Observing these lines using a large ground-based submillimeter telescope
offers us an opportunity to study the warm and dense regions directly
associated with the energetic sources with good spatial detail.
In this paper we present
resolved 1.037 THz
CO(
)
spectra obtained from the ground.
![]() |
Figure 1:
Terahertz CO(
![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
Our spectra were taken at the Heinrich Hertz Telescope atop Mt. Graham,
Arizona (Baars et al. 1999) using a superconductive hot-electron bolometer
(HEB) mixer receiver (Kawamura et al. 2000; Tong et al. 1999).
The receiver was tuned to position the CO(
)
line, which
has a rest frequency of
,
in the lower sideband.
The double-sideband receiver noise temperature is
.
The observations occurred on 7 January 2000, when the 225 GHz sky opacity
at zenith, as measured by a tipping radiometer, fell to less than
.
Opacity measurements with a 345 GHz SIS receiver
made before and after the THz observations indicated that the upper
limit to the precipitable water vapor was between 0.5 mm and 0.7 mm.
The sources were observed using a chopped secondary, for which the throw
was 4' in azimuth and the chop frequency was 1 Hz. The spectra were
calibrated using the standard ambient temperature chopper method to obtain
spectra calibrated to above the atmosphere,
.
For sources at high
elevation angle, we measured a single-sideband system temperature of about
,
which implies a sky transmission
of about 3% at zenith.
Region | integ. | peak | |||
(Offset) |
time |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
(
|
min. | K |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Orion BN/KL |
|||||
"a'' (+25, +200) | 4.2 | ... | ... | ... | ... |
"b'' (+25, +140) |
2.1 | 33 | 9.8 | 5.1 | 86 |
"c'' (0, +60) | 4.2 | 49 | 11.0 | 20.9 | 1100 |
"d'' (0, 0) |
6.3 | 50.3 | 6.1 | 40.0 | 2200 |
"e'' (0, -45) |
4.2 | 65.5 | 7.6 | 7.3 | 1500 |
"f'' (0, -90) |
4.2 | 58 | 7.2 | 8.5 | 530 |
NGC 2024 |
6.3 | ..... | ..... | ..... | ..... |
W 3(OH) | 8.6 | 9 | -47 | 11 | 100 |
All planets suitable for determining the telescope efficiency were too low
on sky at the time of the observations to permit any measurements.
With the same receiver tuned to 0.81 THz, we measured a main-beam efficiency
of about 41% (Kawamura et al. 1999b). Fitting the efficiencies of all the
receivers on the HHT to the Ruze formula, we expect a main beam efficiency of
near 1 THz. Simply extrapolating forward coupling efficiencies
measured at the HHT at lower frequencies (Wilson et al. 2001) to 1.036 THz,
we get an efficiency on the Moon of about 60%, which is an upper limit to
the coupling efficiency to our source. Since the sources are somewhat extended
in CO(
), the actual coupling efficiency lies at some
intermediate value between 19% and 60%. We take
for the source
coupling efficiency with a conservative uncertainty of about 25%.
At the level of our sensitivity, we do not expect the error beam contribution
in the spectra to be significant. Scaling the beam size we measured near
800 GHz, we expect it to be about 8.5'' FWHM at 1.036 THz. The pointing
model was previously established by observations of CO (
)
with the same receiver, and the pointing accuracy is about
.
A log of our observations is given in Table 1.
We observed a position toward BN/KL and 6 offsets to the N and S along a
ridge centered roughly on BN/KL. These are all in OMC-1.
We also observed two other regions, W 3(OH) and NGC 2024.
Emission was detected in OMC-1 and
tentatively from W 3(OH), but not toward NGC 2024.
The spectra taken in Orion are shown in Fig. 1
along side a SHARC
continuum image (Lis et al. 1998)
indicating where the spectra were taken.
Line emission from the CO(
)
transition was detected with
approximately the same peak intensity,
,
at 5 pointings
extending about 4' N-S along the ridge, centered near BN/KL. This
antenna temperature is similar to that measured by a KAO instrument
(Röser et al. 1991), which has a source coupling efficiency roughly
similar to our receiver. There are several spurious features apparent in
the spectra in Fig. 1: a peak near
in panel a, and components near
in panels c
and d. These features were identified as spurious because they appeared as
narrow strong spikes in only one of the scans that were averaged.
The BN/KL region itself exhibits very broadened line
emission with a peak antenna temperature of
,
and the line is
well-fitted by a single Gaussian component whose FWHM line width is
centered at
.
The uncertainty in the velocity is approximately
.
Elsewhere, the spectra are composed of much narrower components.
At 2.3' north of IRc2, the line emission occurs at a single velocity
component near
.
At 1' north of IRc2,
the spectrum peaks at
,
but has a noticeable asymmetric
profile with a pronounced blue-shifted emission wing. At the
midpoint between Orion-S and KL, 0.75' south of IRc2, there are three
distinct components, two
near
and
,
and
tentatively another at
.
At
the position of Orion-S, 1.5' south of KL, there is a component at
and another at
.
Line emission was not detected 3.3' N of KL, where the 1-
upper
limit to the integrated line strength is
.
We can immediately make several general suppositions regarding the physical
conditions along the central 4' region near KL/IRc2.
First, the peak antenna temperature is fairly constant within this extended
region, with
.
Since the CO(
)
line
towards Orion KL, which was observed with the same receiver, has almost
exactly the same peak brightness temperature (Kawamura et al. 1999a), the
line center is most certainly optically thick. In their survey of giant
molecular clouds, Boreiko & Betz (1991) determined that the line emission of
is optically thick in all cases, and we
would expect Orion-KL to be similar to these, in contrast
to earlier work by Goldsmith et al. (1981) and Schultz et al. (1985) who
claimed that
lower-J CO lines at line center were optically thin towards Orion-KL.
Since the line is optically thick, the line brightness temperature can
be used to compute the excitation temperature of the gas,
.
This value is consistent with many other
independent measurements of the gas temperature near the plateau/core
region made using high-density molecular tracers (Boreiko et al. 1989;
Schloerb et al. 1983; Blake et al. 1987). The critical density of the
CO(
)
transition at these
temperatures is
.
Since the emission appears to be very strong
everywhere along the ridge, we conclude that the gas responsible for
the emission has a minimum density of
with gas
temperatures near
.
As might be expected, the size
of the region traced by CO(
)
is similar to that measured
using CO(
)
(Schmid-Burgk et al. 1989), although it appears
somewhat larger than those measured with higher-J lines of CO, which showed
that the emission extends to
1' at the
line
(Boreiko et al. 1989) and about 1.5' FWHM in
(Storey et al. 1981). The fact that the line emission is thus extended
allows us to identify the material as belonging to either the warm
components in the ridge or to photon dominated regions.
We identify three physical components in the spectra, distinguished by their
Doppler velocities and spectral profile. The large linewidth at the position
of Orion KL marks the site of the powerful molecular outflow located here
(Zuckerman et al. 1976; Kwan & Scoville 1976). Previous observations
have shown that the molecular outflow, which appears to originate near the
source IRc2, is spatially very compact, weakly bipolar, and extends only
30'' across in CO (
)
(Erickson et al. 1982) and
about 10'' as traced by SiO (
)
(Wright et al. 1983). We do not detect any component
in our
spectra, but we may be limited by sensitivity.
The minimum beam-averaged
column
density towards IRc2 is
,
assuming that
the gas is thermalized at
.
Away from KL/IRc2, there are two quiescent components in the spectra. We
see a dominant feature at
to the
north, and another at
appears to become
more prominent towards the south of KL.
Ho & Barrett (1978) observed
Womack et al. (1991) observed the ground-state rotational transition of
Wang et al. (1993) exploited this technique further by observing methyl
acetylene (
Our new CO data with superior angular resolution supports the
model that there are 2 quiescent clouds in the Orion ridge, and that
they overlap or intersect in the vicinity of BN/KL.
That the overlap is coincident within about 20'' of the place of
extreme activity in the Orion core is suggestive of
a causal relation, as was postulated by Ho & Barrett (1978).
The fact that there appears to be line emission at an intermediate velocity of
the two clouds, as evidenced by the
We briefly turn our attention to the asymmetry in the line profile
in the spectrum taken 60'' N of IRc2. We have explicitly favored
that the cause of the blue wing is a second component at a lower
velocity. However, at 60'' N of KL, we are about 20'' N of a peak in
To conclude, our experiment convincingly demonstrates the feasibility of
conducting observations from a ground-based site at THz frequencies,
especially in the context of heterodyne-mode observing. FTS
radiometer measurements at and near the ALMA site (Matsushita et al. 1999;
Paine et al. 2000) as well as Mauna Kea (Pardo et al. 2001)
show that there are several potentially useful windows between 1.0 THz
and 1.5 THz, where the transmission reaches
This work is based in part on measurements made with the Heinrich
Hertz Telescope, which is operated by the Submillimeter Telescope
Observatory on behalf of Steward Observatory and the Max-Planck-Institut
für Radioastronomie.
towards the BN/KL core and
detected blended
line emission from two apparently distinct kinematic components, and
interpreted this as arising from two clouds along the line of sight
with
differing by about
.
They further
speculated that the clouds were colliding and that this collision was somehow
triggering the energetic events in the core region. In their study of
the core region of Orion, Boreiko et al. (1989) also identified two blended
velocity components in their CO(
)
spectra,
which they called the "wide-'' and "narrow-'' components, at
and
,
respectively, in good agreement with those seen by Ho & Barrett (1978).
However, both observations have low angular resolution and could
not unambiguously determine whether the lines originated from the same
spatial location, or were simply emission from different regions but
blended by their instrument. Boreiko et al. (1989) also did not examine
the issue of the kinematic relationship between these cloud components.
Several cloud components are also seen by Boreiko et al. (1988)
who observed the
C II
during a survey and discovered that it was depleted in the
most energetic core region, but could be detected from the quiescent
material. Using this tracer they were able to
filter out the wide line emission in the outflow, which tends to dominate
the spectra taken with instruments with low angular resolution. Their
observations indicated that there are two
quiescent cloud components, at
and
,
which are spatially separated for the most part,
but which neatly overlap along the line of sight towards the BN/KL region.
), a molecule that apparently behaves
in a way chemically similar to
.
With the angular resolution of the map improved by a factor of better
than 2, they were able to largely confirm the conclusions of Womack et al.
(1991). However, Wang et al. (1993) detected three spatially distinct
velocity
components and that the two that overlap near BN/KL have velocities of
and
.
The
cloud detected furthest south has a velocity of
.
The
velocity component detected by Wang et al. (1993)
is apparently detected at only one position by Womack et al. (1991), and is
not seen in the region by other methods. This may indicate a possible
complication in using a tracer whose chemistry in the interstellar
medium is at best uncertain, especially in a region of vigorous activity.
and
observations, further suggests that there is activity between or at the
interface of the two clouds.
In any case, the evidence unequivocally rules out the possibility
that the observed velocity gradient along the ridge stems from a rotation
of the inner ridge.
vibrational emission detected by Beckwith et al. (1978). We do not
believe that the emission in the blue wing in the CO spectrum taken N of KL
originates in a shock front causing the
emission. This is
because of the fact that even though an extended blue wing is seen
in the
vibrational spectrum (Nadeau et al. 1982), the line profile
in CO
is simply not as wide. Also, the fact that we
see the same velocity component at other positions leads us to
prefer a simple two-component quiescent gas model, as favored by
Boreiko et al. (1989).
,
and that such
conditions occur reasonably frequently. Efforts are currently underway
to measure the sky characteristics at a nearby site with yet higher
elevation (Paine & Blundell, private communication). This introduces
the exciting prospect of developing a site for a THz telescope.
References
Copyright ESO 2002