To follow the flux history of V4641 Sgr in 1999 we used publicly available data of RXTE/PCA scans over the Galactic Center region, that were performed almost bi-weekly during the whole year. The statistical significance of the data and the accuracy of the background subtraction allow us to detect any source down to the level of approximately 1-2 mCrab (if the Galactic diffuse emission do not contribute much to the detected X-ray flux at the position of the source). The method of Galactic Center map construction and the extraction of the source flux is described in Revnivtsev & Sunyaev (2002).
For the first time the V4641 Sgr was statistically significantly detected in PCA scan on Feb. 18, 1999 (Markwardt et al. 1999) and since then it was seen in almost every scan. We present the obtained light curve of V4641 Sgr in Fig. 1. The results of our analysis (61 data points) are in agreement with the 7 data points reported in Markwardt et al. (1999) and Markwardt et al. (1999).
After almost 6 months of moderate X-ray activity, during the
first half of Sep. 1999 V4641 Sgr demonstrated several X-ray outbursts.
The first, the weak one, was detected by BeppoSAX and RXTE/ASM on
Sep. 10.1, 1999. The source X-ray flux reached 300 mCrab
(in't Zand et al. 2000). On Sep. 14-15, 1999 three more powerful flares
were detected. The segment of the light curve of V4641 Sgr around
Sep. 14-15, 1999 is presented in Fig. 1 (lower panel).
It is seen that the source rose up to 4, 12 and 2 Crabs on Sep. 14.9,
Sep. 15.7 and Sep. 15.9 respectively. The observed large changes in X-ray flux
(factor of 10 at least) occurred on the time scales of one-two hours.
The X-ray luminosities of the source in the energy band 1-12 keV
during these outbursts could be
estimated to be
ergs/s,
and
ergs/s respectively (with adopted distance to V4641 Sgr
kpc, 2001).
The last X-ray flare finished on Sep. 15.95, 1999 by the rapid drop
in X-ray flux from the level of
100 mCrabs by a factor of 10 and
after this the source returned to the quiescent state -
1 mCrab.
Note, that at such low flux levels some contamination from
the Galactic diffuse emission is possible. Our estimates of the
contribution of the Galactic diffuse emission at the position of V4641 Sgr
showed that it is small, but not negligible. As a very conservative
estimation of the source flux the detected 1 mCrab flux at the
position of V4641 Sgr should be treated as the upper limit.
In spite of the fact that the significance of the source detection in
the RXTE/ASM data is lower than in the RXTE/PCA
data (during one day of observations), ASM points have advantage from
the point of view of their quasi-uniform coverage over the period
of Feb.-Sep., 1999. This helps us to
search for the source period in X-ray data. Periodicities of V4641 Sgr were
sought by means of the Lomb-Scargle periodograms (Lomb 1976;
Scargle 1982; Press et al. 1992). In Fig. 2 we present the Lomb-Scarge
periodogram obtained for V4641 Sgr lightcurve taken in the period of steady state
activity Mar. 13- Aug. 20, 1999 (
TJD 11250-11410)
![]() |
Figure 2: The Lomb-Scargle periodogram of the lightcurve of V4641 Sgr , during period of moderate source activity, Mar. 13-Aug. 20, 1999. The value of the optical period is marked by an arrow. |
It is seen that almost at the position of detected optical period
P=2.8173 days (Orosz et al. 2001) a peak at the X-ray Lomb-Scarge periodogram is
present. This peak corresponds to the period
days.
The uncertainty of the period value was estimated by a Monte-Carlo
bootstrap method, assuming the gaussian distribution of values of ASM
lightcurve points.
The false-alarm probability of this detection (taking into account the
number of trial periods) is slightly less than 10-3,
if we assume the exponential distribution of Lomb-Scargle power values.
It is not very high significance to rely on X-ray data alone.
However, the marginally detected X-ray periodicity has the value of the
period that coincides within 1-
errors with the firmly detected optical one P=2.8173 days. This strongly supports the detection of the binary period in X-rays.
We have folded the lightcurve of V4641 Sgr with the measured optical
period of the system in order to search for the orbital dependence of the
X-ray flux. The obtained orbital profile of the X-ray flux (1.5-3.0 keV,
lowest ASM energy channel) is presented in
Fig. 3. In order to make the comparison of optical and X-ray
folded lightcurves easier we have used the same reference time T0 as
Orosz et al. (2001) in their Fig. 3. It is seen that the folded X-ray
lightcurve demonstrates peak, when the black hole is located between the
observer and the optical star, and the minimum - when the star is located
between the observer and the black hole. We also detected strong dependence
of the amplitude of orbital modulations of X-ray flux on the photon energies:
for the lowest energies, 1.5-3.0 keV, the amplitude of the sinusoidal
variations is %, in the energy band 3-5 keV -
%,
and in the energy band 5-12 keV the modulations is undetectable with an
upper limit <15%(2
). It should be noted, that the observed
energy dependence of the X-ray orbital modulations and the position of the
X-ray minimum on this modulation suggest that the detected X-ray variations
could be caused by an absorption in the line of sight near the optical star.
This suggests that the inclination of the system is close to
65-70
,
in agreement with the optical data (Orosz et al. 2001).
The scan observations give us an important opportunity to
follow the spectral shape of the source during a year.
Unfortunately the acceptable "on-source''
exposure of a scan observation is
only of the order of 10-20 s. Therefore the statistics in the
obtained spectra is quite poor. During the period Feb.-Sep. 1999
the source was detected with quite soft spectrum - which
could be roughly described by the model of bremsstrahlung
emission with temperatures 2-3 keV or by multicolor disk model
(Shakura & Sunyaev 1973) with the inner disk temperature
keV.
The typical spectrum of V4641 Sgr at that time is presented in
Fig. 4 (upper panel).
The spectrum of V4641 Sgr
obtained by BeppoSAX observatory on Mar. 13, 1999 (see in't Zand et al. 2000)
has the statistically
significant emission line at the energy 7 keV with
equivalent width
270 eV. Therefore we also searched
for the emission line in the PCA scan data. Unfortunately, due to poor
statistics, the emission line could not be detected in a single
PCA scan observation with an upper limit on its equivalent width
EW< 0.7-1.0 keV.
However, a fit to spectrum of Sgr, averaged over the period Feb. 18-Sep. 02,
1999 gives an emission line at the energy
keV with the equivalent width
eV.
![]() |
Figure 4: The spectrumn of V4641 Sgr averaged over period Mar.-beginning of Sep. 1999. The lower spectrum represents the set of spectra obtained during the period Sep. 6-Sep. 12, 1999. |
The X-ray spectrum of the source strongly changed in the beginning of
Sep. 1999 after the dip in the light curve (see Fig. 1). The photon
spectral index hardens - to
1 - and the emission line
became stronger -
1-2 keV (with typical uncertainty
200-300 eV). The spectrum averaged over Sep. 6-12, 1999
is presented in Fig. 4 (lower panel). The spectrum resembles the
one obtained by BeppoSAX on Sep. 10, 1999 (in't Zand et al. 2000). Note, that
approximately simultaneously with the dramatic changes in the X-ray
spectral properties of the source the increase of the source optical activity
was detected (Kato et al. 1999).
During the outburst activity on Sep. 14-15, 1999, the source demonstrated at least three powerful X-ray flares (Fig. 1), two of which were detected by the ASM instrument. ASM data indicated that during the flares the spectral hardness of the source was generally anticorrelated with the X-ray flux.
Between the two ASM flares, on Sep. 14.9, the source
flux dropped by a factor of 20 at least and became undetectable by the
ASM. Fortunately, at this time, on Sep. 15.1, 1999 a PCA scan
observation was performed, allowing us to investigate
the spectrum of V4641 Sgr between the two flares.
During this observation a remarkable spectrum was obtained
(Fig. 5). The spectrum is dominated by the emission line
at
keV with enormous equivalent width of
keV. Remarkably, this spectrum is very similar to an
X-ray spectrum of SS433 (e.g. Margon 1984).
![]() |
Figure 5: The spectrum of V4641 Sgr on Sep 15.1, 1999, between the two bright X-ray flares (see Fig. 1). |
The third of the detected bright flares occurred during the decaying
part of the outburst and was missed by the ASM because of 1.5
hour gap between the ASM points.
Coincidentally, it occurred during the pointed observation of RXTE.
As it was previously mentioned by Markwardt et al. (1999) the
spectrum of the source at the peak of the X-ray light curve during this
RXTE observation was quite hard and resembled the typical spectra of
the black holes in the low/hard spectral state with the 3-50 keV
photon index
2.0, the cutoff at the
energies 100-200 keV, and pronounced fluorescent Fe line at 6.4 keV.
![]() |
Figure 6: The spectral evolution of V4641 Sgr during the first 1500 s of the RXTE pointed observation. The solid lines in the lower panel represented the intervals used for the accumulation of the broad band spectra of V4641 Sgr (see Fig. 7). |
However, time resolved spectral analysis of the RXTE/PCA data revealed
significant quantitative and qualitative evolution of the source
spectrum during 1500 s of the pointed RXTE observation.
In Fig. 6 we present the light curve of the
source with 16 s time resolution, softness ratio (3-5 keV to 15-20 keV),
the centroid energy of the Gaussian line and its equivalent width
as a function of time. The position of the line and its
equivalent width were determined using a simple power law + Gaussian line
approximation of the spectrum in the 3-12 keV energy band.
In the uppermost panel we also show behavior of the integrated
fractional rms (in percents) of the source flux variations (3-20 keV
energy band, 0.5-10 Hz frequency range).
In order to illustrate the spectral evolution of V4641 Sgr
we show in Fig. 7 the broad band spectra accumulated
during four intervals, marked in Fig. 6 (lower panel) by
the horizontal lines.
As is apparent from Figs. 6 and 7 the RXTE
observation can be divided into two parts with qualitatively different
spectral properties with the boundary at
s (in the
units of Fig. 6) corresponding to the final drop of the
X-ray flux and change of the iron line energy from
6.4 keV
to
6.6-6.8 keV.
During the first part the source had a strong emission line centered
at 6.4 keV with the equivalent width varying between 200 and 900
eV, sufficiently hard spectrum extending to the hard X-ray energies
and significant aperiodic variability with fractional rms
15-40%. In order to qualitatively illustrate the character of the
spectral evolution, we show in Fig. 8 three spectra,
accumulated during individual 16 s intervals,
corresponding to significantly different values of the line equivalent
width and fractional rms.
The Figs. 6 and 8 demonstrate that the
spectral evolution can be qualitatively understood as a result of
absorption/reprocession in the extended medium with varying absorption
column density. Indeed, assuming that the primary spectrum does not
change significantly, decrease of the absorption column density
would lead to the apparent softening of the outgoing spectrum and
decrease of the equivalent width of the fluorescent iron
line. If the absorbing/reprocessing medium has a
significant spatial extend with the light crossing time of 10-50 s the variations of the primary emission would be smeared
out in the reprocessed emission, the effect depending on the fraction
of the scattered/reprocessed emission in the outgoing radiation. Thus,
decrease of the absorption column density would lead to increase of
the apparent fractional rms. It should be noted, that
absorption by the neutral medium with solar element abundances does
not adequately explain the observed spectra - certain ionization of
the absorbing gas is required by the data. The maximal
value should be of the order of
.
We have not found any strong soft component in the spectrum during this part of the observation. However, this issue is rather complicated taking into account the absence of the spectral data at energies lower than 3 keV.
![]() |
Figure 7: The spectra of V4641 Sgr, accumulated over time intervals, shown in Fig. 6. The change in the hardness and in the strength of the fluorescent line is clearly seen. |
![]() |
Figure 8:
Three spectra of V4641 Sgr obtained at different times.
Open circles represent the spectrum obtained at ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
After the final drop of the X-ray flux at
s a
significant softening of the spectrum occurred and the line shifted
from
6.4 keV to
6.6-6.8 keV indicating a
significant change of the emission regime.
At the maximum of X-ray lightcurve, when the absorption
was presumably weak the source had ordinary hard spectrum,
typical for black holes in the low spectral state
(Figs. 7 and 9). Remarkably,
V4641 Sgr have demonstrated this type of spectrum while it's luminosity exceeded by
10 times that of Cyg X-1 in the hard and, probably by
3-5
times in the soft spectral states. Let us mention that masses of black
holes in both systems are comparable. Therefore the difference in
luminosity might give an information about the accretion rate.
![]() |
Figure 9: Comparison of the spectra of V4641 Sgr , accumulated during the peak of the observed light curve (Fig. 6) and Cyg X-1 in the hard state. The distance to Cyg X-1 was assumed to equal to 2.5 kpc. |
The only data suitable to study short term variability of V4641 Sgr during
the period of flaring activity in Sep. 1999 are that of the pointed
RXTE observation discussed in the previous subsection.
The brief description of the source variability during this
observation can be found in Wijnands & van der Klis (2000).
During the first 1100 s of the observation the V4641 Sgr was
found to be strongly variable (rms amplitude
50%)
with a power law power spectrum in the 10-2-5 Hz frequency range. At the frequency of
5 Hz the power
spectrum changed from
to
.
It is
interesting to note that in spite of similarity of the spectral
properties of V4641 Sgr with the spectral properties of Cyg X-1 in the hard
state the power spectrum of V4641 Sgr flux variability is more similar to
that of Cyg X-1 in the soft state.
We discuss below change of the aperiodic variability properties with time, photon energy dependence of the fractional rms and time delay of the reflected emission.
As was shown in the previous subsection, during the RXTE
observation the source demonstrated a strong spectral evolution
accompanied with significant change of the fractional rms
(Fig. 6). Similar to the spectral properties,
the variability level changed significantly
after the rapid drop of the X-ray flux at 1100th s (Fig. 6). The fractional rms droped from
30-40% to the level, undetectable with PCA, with the
upper limit of
1-2% in the
-10 Hz frequency band.
A notable feature of the energy dependence of the fractional rms is
the decrease near the energy of the Fe K
line.
Note that some indications on such behavior could be noticed in Fig. 3
of Wijnands & van der Klis (2000). However the authors concentrated on the properties
averaged the entire outburst.
In Fig. 10 we present the dependence of rms amplitude of the
source variability calculated for
two different periods - intervals <300th s in the time units
of Fig. 6 (high EW of the line) and
-700th s
(low EW of the line). One can see that there exist a definite dip
approximately at the position of the Fe 6.4 keV fluorescent
line. Moreover, it is seen that
the stronger the line in the source's energy spectrum,
the stronger the dip at the rms-energy dependence.
The presented rms-energy dependence clearly demonstrate that the
fluorescent Fe line is less variable than the continuum.
The simplest interpretation of this fact could be the smearing of the
reprocessed emission (in particular the flux in the Fe fluorescent line)
because of the finite light crossing time of the reprocessing medium
(see e.g. discussion in Revnivtsev et al. 1999, or Gilfanov et al. 2000).
![]() |
Figure 10:
The dependence of the rms amplitude of X-ray variability of V4641 Sgr on
the photon energy during the episode of low equivalent width of the Fe line
during two time intervals - <300th s (lower points) and
![]() |
![]() |
Figure 11:
The crosscorrelation between the continuum X-ray flux from
V4641 Sgr and the flux in the Fe fluorescent line, calculated over period
![]() |
The reprocessing in medium of large light crossing time can also
result in the time delay between the direct continuum emission and
the photons of the reprocessed spectrum, in particular - the Fe line
photons. In order to check this hypothesis
we have crosscorrelate the continuum flux of V4641 Sgr and the flux in the
fluorescent Fe line. Flux in the Fe line was taken from the spectral
approximation used for Fig. 6.
In order to avoid possible contamination by long term trend in the
parameters we used only data during the period with relatively stable
value of equivalent width of the fluorescent line - from
350th to
700th s (in the time units of
Fig. 6). The obtained crosscorrelation is presented in
Fig. 11. The
time interval of the acceptable data is rather short and we could not
calculate the uncertainties on the crosscorrelation function directly
from the data. Therefore we estimated the error bars using Monte Carlo
bootstrap method. From Fig. 11 one can see that the
crosscorelation function is strongly asymmetric with respect to the
zero delay, implying that the flux in the Fe fluorescent line is
delayed with respect to the continuum flux. The approximate time of
the delay is
s.
Copyright ESO 2002