A&A 390, 155-166 (2002)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20020611
M. Della Valle 1 - L. Pasquini 2 - D. Daou 3 - - R. E. Williams4
1 - Osservatorio Astrofisico di Arcetri, Largo E. Fermi 5, Firenze,
Italy
2 -
European Southern Observatory; KarlSwarschildstrasse 2, Garching bei
München, München, Germany
3 -
California Institute of Technology MS: 220-6 1200 East California Blvd.,
Pasadena, CA 91125, USA
4 -
Space Telescope Science Institute, 3700 San Martin Drive,
Baltimore, MD, USA
Received 25 February 2002 / Accepted 22 April 2002
Abstract
We report results of spectroscopic observations of V382
Vel (Nova Vel 1999) carried out at La Silla between 5 and 498 days
after maximum light (23 May 1999, V(max)
). The
analysis of the photometric and spectroscopic evolution shows this
object to be a fast nova belonging to the Fe II broad
spectroscopic class. A distance of 1.7 kpc (
)
is derived
from the maximum magnitude vs. rate of decline relationship after
correcting for the small reddening toward the nova, E(B-
.
From the measured H
flux and the associated rate of
expansion we derive an approximate mass for the ejected shell,
.
We have also observed during the
early decline a broad, short-lived (
2 weeks) feature at
6705-6715 Å for which several identifications are possible, one of
which is the lithium doublet at 6708 Å and which could place an
empirical limit on the lithium production that might occur during the
outburst of a fast nova.
The high luminosity at maximum,
,
and the relatively small
height above the galactic plane (
pc) suggest that V382
Vel originated from a massive white dwarf, likely in the mass range
1.1-1.2
.
Key words: stars: novae, cataclysmic variables
Nova Velorum 1999 (=V382) was independently discovered by P. Williams
(1999) and A. Gilmore (1999), on May 22, as a star brighter than
,
located at RA = 10
44
4839, Decl. = -52o25'307
(equinox 2000.0, Garrad 1999). Early spectroscopy obtained by Lee et al. (1999) confirmed the object to be a classical nova undergoing
outburst. V382 Vel achieved optical maximum roughly 1 day
later. This brightness makes V382 Vel the brightest
galactic nova since V1500 Cyg 1975 and one of the brightest novae of
the century (see Table 1),
| # | Nova | Year | V(max) |
| 1. | v603 Aql | 1918 | -1.1 |
| 2. | GK Per | 1901 | 0.2 |
| 3. | CP Pup | 1942 | 0.5 |
| 4. | RR Pic | 1925 | 1.0 |
| 5. | DQ Her | 1934 | 1.3 |
| 6. | v476 Cyg | 1920 | 1.6 |
| 7. | v1500 Cyg | 1975 | 1.8 |
| 8. | CP Lac | 1936 | 2.1 |
| 9. | V382 Vel | 1999 | 2.3 |
| 10. | v533 Her | 1963 | 2.5 |
| 11. | Q Cyg | 1876 | 3.0 |
| v446 Her | 1960 | 3.0 |
The lightcurve of the nova and its color evolution are shown in Fig. 1 using the photometric measurements of Gilmore &
Kilmartin (1999) with the 0.6 m telescope at Mount John University
Observatory.
![]() |
Figure 1: The lightcurve of v382 Vel (top) and its color evolution (bottom). |
| Open with DEXTER | |
The mean magnitude of the nova at quiescence has been determined
by Platais et al. (1999) by examing photographic plates from the
Yale/San Juan Southern Proper Motion program. They derived
and an average (B-V)=0.14, which is consistent with the
unreddened colors of novae at minimum (cf. Bruch 1984). The
outburst amplitude of
magnitudes is larger than the average outburst for galactic
novae (
12 mag), but is not unusual for fast novae (for
example, CP Pup 1942 and V1500 Cyg 1975 exhibited amplitudes of
16 mag and
19 mag, respectively). This amplitude
and the derived absolute magnitude at maximum lead to
at minimum, which falls in the faint tail of the
distribution for classical novae (see Della Valle & Duerbeck 1993,
their Fig. 3).
Platais et al. (1999) also point out the discovery on a photographic plate obtained on 28 April 1970 of a flaring of 0.5 magnitudes. Such flaring is not uncommon in the years before a major outburst in classical novae (e.g. Robinson 1975).
Spectroscopic observations of the nova began at ESO five days past
maximum as part of a target of opportunity campaign (Della Valle
et al. 1999). We have for the first time exploited the
potential of the ESO 1.5 m telescope equipped with FEROS (see Kaufer et al. 1999) on a bright galactic nova, and have collected a series of
13 spectra in the optical range 3800-9000 Å with a resolution of
48 000. Five representative spectra are shown in Fig. 2.
![]() |
Figure 2: The spectroscopic evolution of v382 Vel 1999. Spectra obtained (from top) on May 28, Jun. 6, Jun. 25, Jul. 31 and Nov. 22, 1999. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
![]() |
Figure 2: continued. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
![]() |
Figure 3:
The evolution of the H |
| Open with DEXTER | |
![]() |
Figure 4:
The evolution of the FWHM of H |
| Open with DEXTER | |
| Date |
|
% error | |
| 28 May 99 | 5 | 2.54e-11 | 0.39 |
| 29 May 99 | 6 | 2.20e-11 | 0.30 |
| 30 May 99 | 7 | 1.54e-11 | 0.25 |
| 1 Jun. 99 | 9 | 1.13e-11 | 0.21 |
| 2 Jun. 99 | 10 | 8.96e-12 | 0.17 |
| 3 Jun. 99 | 11 | 1.02e-11 | 0.28 |
| 5 Jun. 99 | 13 | 5.34e-12 | 0.42 |
| 6 Jun. 99 | 14 | 3.50e-12 | 0.29 |
| 25 Jun. 99 | 33 | 2.89e-12 | 0.06 |
| 14 Jul. 99 | 53 | 1.82e-12 | 0.07 |
| 19 Jul. 99 | 58 | 1.63e-12 | 0.37 |
| 31 Jul. 99 | 69 | 1.07e-12 | 0.22 |
| 22 Nov. 99 | 183 | 3.89e-13 | 0.45 |
| 2 Oct. 00 | 498 | 5.62e-14 | 0.30 |
The nova entered the nebular spectral stage by the end of June, roughly
40 days after maximum light. At that time the spectra were
characterized by the increasing strengths of [O III]
Å and He I lines, and the gradual disappearance of the Fe II
lines and the absorption systems. The spectra obtained on Nov. 22,
1999 and Oct. 2, 2000 show [O III]
brighter than H
+[N II] and exhibiting a flat-top, castellated
structure with a HWZI of
2000 km s-1, with the He I lines fading and soon disappearing. During this stage we note
also the emergence of strong [Ne III]
Å, and [Fe VII]
Å,
which are typical of the nebular
stages of novae belonging to the He/N and Fe II "broad'' spectroscopic
class (see Williams 1992).
As previously mentioned the nova showed little evidence for
extinction near maximum light. An independent estimate of the
reddening at subsequent times can be made from a comparison of
predicted and observed emission lines ratios within the same ion
which are not sensitive
to radiative transfer effects (Robbins 1968a,b).
Unblended H and He recombination
lines may be used for this purpose if they are optically
thin and not affected by collisions. Because H
is seriously
blended with the [NII] lines the HeI lines offer the best possibility
for this purpose, and data presented in Table 3 provide ratios at 6
epochs with a median value of
,
All nova spectra show clear insterstellar NaI D and Ca II H and K
absorption. Na D1 and D2 are saturated, and the minimum intensity of
the lines is zero intensity, however the Ca II H line does show some
residual intensity. For both doublets only one absorption component is seen
at our resolution. The equivalent widths of the lines as measured from our
FEROS spectra are 360 and 395 mÅ for the D1 and D2 lines, and
203 and 382 mÅ for H and K of CaII. The IS component has a
velocity of 4.4 km s-1 and the width of the lines (given as the FWHM
of the Gaussian fitting of the different lines), is 0.23 and 0.25 Å for Ca II H and K (17.4 and 19.1 km s-1), and 0.322 and 0.345
angstrom for the D1 and D2 components (16.4 and 17.6 km s-1). By
applying crude estimates for the reddening vs. Na D equivalent widths,
e.g. E(B-
(D lines)
(Benetti, private communication) we find E(B-
.
Although this scaling relation is approximate, a
comparison with the Na EW observed in detailed IS studies with
resolved single components
(e.g. the SN 1987a field Molaro et al. 1993) indicates a reddening slightly higher than that
estimated from emission line ratios, viz.,
mag. In general, however, all methods confirm a rather low
reddening and therefore a moderate distance to the nova.
Measurements of the intensities of emission lines in nova spectra
have shown an anomalous ratio of the [O I]
Å nebular lines (see Williams 1994). The relative
intensities of these lines is usually not 3:1 (an exception
was FH Ser 1970, see Rosino et al. 1986), as expected from their atomic
transition probabilities. Nova Vel 1999 is no exception as the data
shown in Table 3 averaged over 11 epochs lead to
a
6300/6363 ratio of
.
Williams (1994) has
discussed this situation in novae, and has suggested that optically
thick [O I] lines must be formed in very dense (n(H
), small blobs of neutral material embedded within
the ionized ejected shells.
During early decline when the density of the ejecta is in the
high-density limit of the [O I] lines the intensity ratio
can be used to determine the temperature
(e.g. Osterbrock 1989) from the relation:
The evolution of the nebular and auroral [O III] emission lines,
,
(
1, on 31 July 1999;
3.1, on 22 November 1999; and
36.7 on 2 October 2000),
suggests (cf. Filippenko & Halpern 1984) for the typical range of
temperatures
(see Williams 1994, his Table 3),
values of the density initially (31 July) close to the high density limit
,
and eventually decreasing to
.
The most reliable distances to classical novae are parallaxes derived
from angular size measurements of the expanding ejecta. Currently
this method can be applied to about thirty galactic novae (out of more
than 200 objects discovered to date), therefore most nova distance
measurements involve the use of the maximum magnitude vs. rate of
recline relationship. First noted by Zwicky (1936), it is
characterized by an intrinsic scatter of 0.16 mag (
), (Della
Valle & Livio 1995) corresponding to a distance uncertainty of ![]()
(
). The photometric data presented in the introduction
yield a reddening-corrected distance modulus (m-M)=11.04, which
corresponds to a distance of
(1
)
pc. The emitted
luminosity of H
follows from the distance, from which an
estimate of the mass of the ionized hydrogen content in the ejecta can be
made. The H
emission from the envelope is
erg-1 where
erg cm3 s-1 is the emission coefficient per
cm3, for
(and
)
and
the volume
filling factor. Assuming the volume of the expanding shell to be
,
where
(
days from the maximum light and
km s-1) and
(with f smaller than 1) is the
thickness of the shell. From the data of Tables 2 and 3 (2 Oct. 2000),
we obtain:
![]() |
Figure 5: The correlation between the rate of decline and the mass of the ejected envelope. Data from Gehrz (1988), Snijders et al. (1987), Hjellming (1990) (V1500 Cyg), Gehrz (1988), Stickland et al. (1981) (v1668 Cyg); Hjellming (1990), Hartwick & Hutchings (1978) (HR Del); Ferland et al. (1984), Martin (1989) (DQ Her); Woodward et al. (1992) (v838 Her); Pottasch (1959), Ferland (1979) (CP Lac); Gehrz (1988), Hassal et al. (1990) (GQ Mus); Williams & Gallagher (1979) (RR Pic); Hartwick & Hutchings (1978), Hjellming (1990), Della Valle et al. (1997) (FH Ser); Gehrz (1988) (LW Ser); Raikova (1990) (LV Vul); Gehrz (1988) (NQ Vul); Gehrz (1988), Saizar et al. (1991) (PW Vul); Taylor et al. (1988), Saizar et al. (1992) (QU Vul); Gehrz et al. (1993) (QV Vul), de Freitas Pacheco (1977), Ferland (1979) (IV Cep), de Freitas Pacheco et al. (1989) (v842 Cen); Snijders et al. (1987) (v1370 Aql). |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Observations of the [O I] line intensities formed when the
density in the ejecta exceeds critical density, after correction for
reddening and optical depth effects, yield the oxygen mass of the
neutral component into the ejected shell when the distance and the
electron temperature are known (e.g. Williams 1994). The previous data
give M(O
which is only ![]()
of the total mass of the shell. On the other hand, this should be
regarded as a lower limit for the total amount of oxygen present in
the ejecta (typically ![]()
,
see Gehrz et al. 1998), because
this procedure does not include the contribution of other O ions.
A close inspection of the early spectra reveals the presence at
6700/6715 Å of a weak and broad emission line (see Fig. 6) which
increases in strength during the early decline and reaches
maximum intensity about 10 days past maximumm,
![]() |
Figure 6: The evolution of the broad feature at 6705-6715 Å. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Novae have been predicted to be sources of galactic lithium (e.g. Romano et al. 1999 and reference therein, although see Travaglio et al. 2001 for a different view), however attempts to detect lithium (see Friedjung 1979) have been unsuccessful. According to Starrfield et al. (1978) and Boffin et al. (1993) (see also Norgaard & Arnould 1975) Li should be produced by the radioactive decay of 7Be, whose half-life time is 53 days, and therefore it is not expected to be detectable during the earliest stages of a nova. This constraint may be relaxed if one assumes that Li begins to form prior to the peak of TNRs and the observed variation of the intensity of the line during the early nova evolution is dominated by ionization effects in the ejecta.
The observed intensity of the unidentified
feature with respect to the emission lines of hydrogen is
10-6. Assuming an abundance of H in the ejected shell of
(see above) the unidentified
feature represents at most an injection of Li into the interstellar
medium of
,
if it is formed by recombination.
If 104 is the average number of outbursts
experienced by a nova during its lifetime (Bath & Shaviv 1978), then
about
could be assumed as an upper
limit to the possible production of Li during the lifetime of a
fast nova. This value is appoximately
the theoretical prediction of lithium produced by a nova during
its lifetime (D'Antona & Matteucci 1991; Romano et al. 1999).
According to the quantitative criteria defined by Della Valle & Livio (1998) there are two classes of novae drawn from two populations of progenitors:
a) Slow Novae achieve an absolute magnitude of
at maximum, their lightcurves exhibit a slow decline (often
characterized by secondary maxima) with
days (or
days), and they normally belong to the Fe IIn (n = narrow)
spectroscopic class defined by Williams (1992). They occur at
distances of up to
1 kpc above the galactic plane and are
probably related to the Pop II stellar population of the bulge/thick
disk, and are therefore associated with less massive white dwarfs,
-1
;
b) Fast Novae have lightcurves characterized by very bright peak
luminosities,
,
followed by rapid, smooth declines
(
days, or
days), and they mostly belong to the
He/N or Fe IIb spectroscopic classes defined by Williams (1992). The
progenitors originate from a relatively old Pop I stellar population
of the thin disk/spiral arm, and therefore they are located
close to the galactic plane, typically
-200 pc. The associated white dwarfs are rather massive,
-
.
Nova Vel 1999 was the brightest nova to occur in the Milky Way in the
last 25 years, and the rate of decline implies that this nova achieved
an absolute magnitude of
,
suggesting that it probably
originated from a massive white dwarf, with
,
and likely originating from an O-Ne-Mg WD (see Shore et al. 1999a,b). We also note: a) its location relatively close to
the galactic plane,
pc; b) the fast and smooth
decline (
,
), without the secondary maxima or sudden
variations in brightness (e.g. DQ Her 1934) that are indicative of
dust formation in the ejecta; c) quick evolution to the nebular
stage (
40 days, i.e. from 1/3 to 1/10 of the time required by a
typical slow nova; d) the presence of strong Fe II lines,
characterized (to start from phase
10 days, i.e. at the time
when most envelope had been already ejected) by almost "flat-topped''
profiles and high expansion velocities (
3500 km s-1 at half of
FWZI), indicating that this nova was forming the emission lines in a
discrete shell, and e) the presence during the nebular stage of
forbidden lines of high ionization, such as [Fe VII], [Fe X] and [Fe XI]. All of this toghether points out that this nova belongs to the
broad Fe II class (Fe IIb) of Williams (1992) scheme of
spectroscopic classification (see also Williams et al.
1994) and it qualify as one of the best examples of a prototypical
fast nova.
The analysis of the spectroscopic data has shown the existence of a
short-lived (
2 weeks) emission feature in the
region 6700-6715 Å. There is no unambiguous identification for this
feature, and one possibility is the 6708 Å lithium
doublet. Novae are believed to be sources of Li for the galactic ISM,
and the intensity of this emission line implies
as an upper limit to the
lithium produced by a fast nova in a single outburst, a value
that is near the
theoretical predictions currently circulating in literature (see
Romano et al. 1999; Jose & Hernanz 1998 and references therein).
We have also estimated the mass of ionized hydrogen in the envelope
from the emitted flux in H
,
and under simple geometrical
assumptions we obtain
which
corresponds to a rather small mass envelope, although not atypical for
a fast nova. There is also a considerable uncertainty in this
value due to the unknown filling factor. If the filling factor of the
envelope is close to 10-2/-4 rather than
1, as HST
observations of the Recurrent Nova T Pyx suggest (Shara et al. 1997), then a large decrease in the mass of the nova ejecta will
result. Evidence in favor of a moderately small value for the filling
factor is indicated by the high optical depth of [O I] lines for Nova
Vel 1999, which suggest that part of the ejecta are condensed blobs of
neutral material immersed in the ionized environment of the
shell. Our data (collected on 2 October 2000) may suggest
a value for the filling factor as small as
.
A second source of uncertainty is our estimate of the thickness of the
shell. In the past, the simple assumption
has
led to underestimates of the thickness of the ejected shells for two
cases, DQ Her 1934 (Humason 1940) and FH Ser 1970 (Della Valle et al. 1997) by a factor
3-4.
The relatively small distance to V382 Vel (which partially explains the lack
of reddening toward the nova, in spite of the small value of its
galactic latitude) and the high expansion velocity of the ejecta, make
Nova Vel 1999 a suitable target for HST observations,
within a short time. A systematic follow-up of the nova remnant, in
H
and [OIII] emission, coupled with simultaneous ground-based
high-resolution spectroscopic observations, would offer us the unique
opportunity to study the detailed evolution of the ejecta and
to provide a reliable estimate of the mass of envelope with greater
accuracy, and thus to properly evaluate the
contribution of classical novae to the galactic nucleosynthesis.
Acknowledgements
The authors are deeply grateful to the La Silla staff for having promptly activated the service-mode and providing the spectroscopic follow-up of the nova. MDV thanks Space Telescope Science Institute, where part of this work was done, for its hospitality. The authors are also indebted with F, Matteucci, H. Duerbeck, S. Starrfield, P. Kilmartin and A. Gilmore for helpful discussions and with an anonymous referee for his remarks, which have improved the presentation of this paper.