A&A 388, 587-608 (2002)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20020503
R. K. Prinja1 - D. Massa2 - A. W. Fullerton3,4
1 - Department of Physics & Astronomy, University
College London, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK
2 -
Raytheon ITSS, NASA/GSFC, Code 681, Greenbelt, MD 20771, USA
3 -
Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Victoria,
PO Box 3055, Victoria, BC V8W 3P6, Canada
4 -
Center for Astrophysical Sciences, Dept. of Physics and
Astronomy, Johns Hopkins University,
3400 N. Charles St,
Baltimore, MD 21218-2686, USA
Received 11 January 2002 / Accepted 28 March 2002
Abstract
We present the most suitable data sets available in the International
Ultraviolet Explorer (IUE) archive for the study of time-dependent
stellar winds in
early B supergiants. The UV line profile variability in
11 B0 to B3 stars is analysed, compared and discussed, based on 16 separate
data sets comprising over 600 homogeneously reduced high-resolution
spectrograms. The targets include "normal'' stars with moderate rotation
rates and examples of rapid rotators. A gallery of grey-scale images
(dynamic spectra) is presented,
which demonstrates the richness and range of wind variability and
highlights different
structures in the winds of these stars. This work emphasises the
suitability of B supergiants for wind studies, under-pinned by the fact
that they
exhibit unsaturated wind lines for a wide range of ionization.
The wind activity of B supergiants is substantial and has highly
varied characteristics.
The variability evident in individual stars is classified
and described in terms of discrete absorption components, spontaneous
absorption, bowed structures, recurrence, and ionization variability
and stratification.
Similar structures can occur in stars of different fundamental parameters, but
also different structures may occur in the same star at a given epoch.
We discuss the physical phenomena that may be associated with the
spectral signatures.
The diversity of wind patterns evident likely reflects the role
of stellar rotation and viewing angle in determining the observational
characteristics of azimuthally extended structure rooted at the
stellar surface.
In addition, SEI line-synthesis modelling of the UV wind lines is used to
provide further information about the state of the winds in our program stars.
Typically the range, implied by the line profile variability, in the
product of mass-loss rate and
ion fraction (
)
is a factor of 1.5,
when integrated between 0.2 and 0.9 ;
it can however be several times larger over localised velocity regions. At a
given effective temperature the mean relative ion ratios can differ
by a factor of 5. The general excess in predicted (forward-scattered)
emission in the low velocity regime is discussed in terms of structured
outflows.
Mean ion fractions are estimated over the B0 to B1 spectral classes, and
trends in the ionic ratios as a function of wind velocity are described.
The low values obtained for the ion fractions of UV resonance lines may
reflect the role of clumping in the wind.
Key words: stars: early-type - stars: mass-loss - ultraviolet: stars
One of the major discoveries made with IUE was the systematic nature of variability in the P Cygni-type line profiles of OB stars. The key developmental sequence was defined in a number of time-series UV investigations (e.g. Prinja et al. 1987; Prinja & Howarth 1988; Henrichs et al. 1988; Kaper 1993; Kaper et al. 1996; De Jong et al. 2001). A relatively broad, shallow absorption feature appears at 0.3 of the terminal velocity (), which then evolves blue-wards over several hours and perhaps even days, while narrowing in velocity width. The velocity at which these "discrete absorption components'' (DACs) are first detected is roughly constant for a given star, but may vary from star-to-star.
Subsequent IUE studies established a connection between stellar projected rotation velocity ( sin(i)) and the rate of recurrence and acceleration of DACs (Prinja 1988; Kaper et al. 1996). More recent IUE monitoring campaigns extending over a few weeks have shown that the stellar wind lines vary continuously, implying that OB star winds are structured over a range of spatial and temporal scales. They have also shown that variations in the profiles modulate on rather long time-scales (i.e. several days). Furthermore, the variability evident in Per (O7.5 III(f); De Jong et al. 2001) and Pup (O4 If; Howarth et al. 1995) appears to modulate on the stellar rotation rate. Rotation is plausibly also the key factor in the repetitive wind activity seen in HD 64760 (B0.5 Ib; Fullerton et al. 1997), HD 93843 (O5 III; Prinja et al. 1998) and HD 91969 (B0 Ia; Massa et al. 1998). Rotationally modulated wind fluctuations are also apparent in late B and early A supergiants (e.g. Kaufer et al. 1996), which have much larger radii and longer rotation periods.
The fundamental origin of wind variability on large spatial scales in hot stars remains uncertain. The causal link between inhomogeneities at the stellar surface and large-scale wind structure has not been directly established observationally or theoretically. A currently popular idea is that the large-scale variations discussed above (and some of those discussed in this paper) are spawned by photospheric irregularities which cause the wind from different longitudinal sectors on the surface to emerge with different densities and/or velocities. The surface structure may, for example, be due to the action of non-radial pulsations or the effects of ordered magnetic fields. Once different adjacent wind streams are initiated, they then meet to form co-rotation interaction regions (CIRs). The rotating CIRs inevitably evolve into spiral-shaped shock structures (Cranmer & Owocki 1996). In this model, variations in the wind absorption result from material flowing through a semi-permanent, co-rotating wind structure.
The stellar winds of early B supergiants (BIs) are particularly suitable for a study of wind dynamics and the effects of large-scale wind structure since, (i) their UV wind lines are often well-developed but unsaturated, (ii) these diagnostic lines cover a wide range of ionization, close to the dominant stage of the wind (see Table 2), (iii) it is generally easier to follow the progression of large-scale structure in the UV lines of BIs compared to O-type stars, (iv) the winds have lower terminal velocities, so individual structures evolve more slowly and the important Si IV 1400 resonance line doublets are mostly decoupled, (v) their strong UV photospheric lines are excellent effective temperature-luminosity diagnostics, and (vi) the strongest UV photospheric lines sample the wind/photosphere "interface'', often displaying wind behaviour.
Motivated by these attractions, we describe in this paper the time-dependent wind characteristics of eleven B0 to B3 supergiants, based on 16 separate IUE high-resolution time-series data sets, involving the inspection of 638 spectrograms in total. This work extends our knowledge of the characteristics of variable UV resonance lines in line-driven winds to cooler and less luminous stars. The data are used to demonstrate the presence of a range of empirical wind properties and implied varied perturbations in the outflows. We report here on the incidence and repetition of DACs, evidence for rotational modulation, ionization-state changes, shock formation, and spontaneous wind enhancements. The diverse wind variability signatures in early BIs are compared and contrasted to those previously noted in luminous O-type stars. The later sections of this paper present SEI line-synthesis modelling, which is used to explore further the ionization mixture and structured nature of the winds.
Our objective was to carry out a systematic survey of the temporal nature of wind activity in early B supergiants. We therefore restricted our selection to time-series of high-resolution (/ 104) IUE SWP ( 1150 to 1900 Å) data sets. A list of the program stars is given in Table 1. They include luminosity classes Ia and Ib for a spectral range B0 to B3, and have a wide range of projected rotation velocities. The corresponding 16 data sets analysed are also outlined in Table 1, and include 4 cases where short-term wind variability may be compared over two or more epochs separated by a few years. The majority of stars in our sample are "normal'', slow to moderate rotators, that are representative of their spectral sub-class. Two main exceptions are HD 64760 and HD 157246 ( Ara) which were selected to examine the effects of rapid rotation on wind structure.
HD | Sp. Type | Log | (kK) | sin (i) | (max) | Date of IUE | Duration | Sampling |
(km s-1) | (days) | time series | (days) | (hours) | ||||
37128 | B0 Ia N- | 5.78 | 28.6 | 91 | 17.7 | 1980 | 0.7 | 1 |
91969 | B0 Ia | 5.78 | 28.6 | 83 | 14.4 | 1996 | 30 | 9 |
164402 | B0 Ib N- | 5.38 | 28.6 | 77 | 13.3 | 1986/93/95 | 6/16/16 | 3-24/24/24 |
204172 | B0 Ib N- | 5.38 | 28.6 | 87 | 11.6 | 1990/93 | 2/16 | 3/24 |
64760 | B0.5 Ib | 5.10 | 23.1 | 216 | 5.2 | 1993/95 | 6/15 | 3/3 |
167756 | B0.5 Ib | 5.50 | 23.1 | 79 | 14.1 | 1986 | 5.5 | 12 |
150168 | B1 Iab-Ib | 5.38 | 20.3 | 121 | 13.3 | 1993 | 6 | 3 |
47240 | B1 Ib | 4.90 | 20.3 | 103 | 11.3 | 1993 | 16 | 24 |
157246 | B1 Ib | 4.90 | 20.3 | 245 | 4.8 | 1993/95 | 6/16 | 3/24 |
96248 | BC1 Ia | 5.12 | 19.4 | 83 | 24.3 | 1996 | 30 | 9 |
53138 | B3 Ia | 5.24 | 16.3 | 58 | 45.8 | 1987 | 13 | 12-36 |
The data were either extracted from the archives maintained at the Goddard Space Flight Center (USA) and the Rutherford Appleton Laboratory (UK), or they were originally part of our observing campaigns. All the spectra were extracted in a uniform manner from the two-dimensional, photometrically linearised images (PI) using the UK Starlink package IUEDR (Giddings et al. 1995). One of the advantages of the IUEDRextractions is the spectra are highly reliable at the shortest wavelengths, thus providing high data quality for the important lines at Si III 1206 and N V 1240. The wavelength scale calibration was improved by centering the spectra on selected interstellar lines (in an échelle order-dependent correction). The individual spectra were binned onto a wavelength grid with a regular sampling of 0.1 Å. Typically the signal-to-noise in the continuum is 20. Individual wind-formed line profiles were normalised to a local continuum by fitting a straight line through several adjacent "line-free'' windows.
The mean IUE SWP spectrum for each program star is shown in Fig. 1. The principal diagnostic wind and photospheric lines available in these spectra are listed in Table 2 (Massa 1989). The data sets for the following stars have been previously reported in the literature: HD 64760 (Massa et al. 1995b; Prinja et al. 1995; Fullerton et al. 1997; Howarth et al. 1998), HD 157246 (Prinja et al. 1997), and HD 91969 (Massa et al. 1998). These data are presented in this paper to place them into wider comparative context.
Figure 1: Mean normalised spectra for the IUE time-series of the 11 program stars. The important wind spectral lines are identified (see also Table 2). (An intensity shift of 1.5 has been used in this display between successive spectra.) | |
Open with DEXTER |
Ion | (Å) | I.P. (ev) | E.P. (eV) | region |
C II | 1334.53, 1335.71 | 24.4 | 0.00, 0.01 | wind |
C IV | 1540.20, 1550.77 | 64.5 | 0.0, 0.0 | wind |
N V | 1238.82, 1242.80 | 97.9 | 0.0, 0.0 | wind |
Al III | 1854.72, 1862.79 | 28.5 | 0.0, 0.0 | wind |
Si III | 1206.50 | 33.5 | 0.0 | wind |
Si III | 1296.73 | 33.5 | 6.55 | wind/photosphere |
Si III | 1312.24 | 33.5 | 10.28 | photosphere |
Si III | 1417.24 | 33.5 | 10.28 | photosphere |
Si IV | 1393.76, 1402.77 | 45.1 | 0.0, 0.0 | wind |
The characteristics of variable UV lines in our program stars are presented in this section. Fluctuations are present in the stellar wind lines of every B supergiant in our sample, and in every time-series data set examined here. The variations are primarily described by a gallery of grey-scale image representations (dynamic spectra) of the time-series data (Figs. 2 to 17). This image format is an effective method for identifying systematic patterns in variable line profiles, and for comparing the evolution of these features between different spectral lines. In cases where the Doppler shifted absorption profiles are unsaturated (i.e. the majority in our sample), quotient spectra are displayed after being normalised by the mean profile for the time-series. For saturated or "black'' absorption troughs in the C IV lines of HDs 37128, 91969, 157246 and 96248, we display residuals, subtracted from the mean profile. In all cases darker shades in the images indicate regions of enhanced absorption (reduced flux) with respect to the mean profile.
Several empirical phenomena can be identified from the images in Figs. 2 to 17. They are defined below, prior to discussion of their occurrence in individual stars:
Discrete absorption components (DACs) - these are the features most commonly associated with variable UV resonance line profiles in luminous OB stars. They usually appear as localised (in velocity) absorption enhancements that migrate from (at least) intermediate velocities to the blue-ward profile edge, with a corresponding decrease in velocity width. Typically the accelerations of the DACs are 50% of values for the underlying wind, as determined from canonical " 1'' velocity laws.
Bowed structures - these are optical depth changes that appear suddenly over a wide velocity range, and which develop simultaneously towards lower and higher blue-shifted velocities (see e.g. Fullerton et al. 1997).
Other features - we use this term to identify either less organised "bursts'' of absorption that usually last a short time only (hours), or more substantial absorptions that appear suddenly over a large velocity range. These features do not show any clear evolution in their velocity or width as a function of time.
Near-zero velocity changes - cases where line profile variability can be traced to less than 0.05 of the terminal velocity. These fluctuations are due to deep-seated disturbances close to the stellar surface.
Recurrence - This is simply a descriptive term relating to a specific (extended) data set, to draw attention to repetitive structures. The repetition is normally due to the occurrence of DACs or bowed structures.
Ionization variation - implies that the ionization state of a specific wind feature changes with time. It may for example become more enhanced in absorption in some lines, while exhibiting an increased flux in other spectral lines.
Ionization stratification - cases where one of the phenomena identified above are seen at different velocities in different ions. This is usually an optical depth effect between low and high ionization lines.
Results on the occurrence of these variable wind phenomena in our program stars are summarised in Table 3. The winds of early BIs exhibit diverse patterns of stellar wind variability. Similar phenomena can occur in stars that vary in fundamental parameters, and different wind structures can co-exist in the wind of a given star at a particular epoch. Some notes on the temporal wind behaviour in the individual stars are presented in the remainder of this section.
HD | DAC | Bowed | Other | near-zero | ion | ion | recurrence |
structure | feature | var. | strat. | var. | |||
37128 | - | - | - | - | - | - | |
91969 | - | ||||||
164402 | - | ? | - | - | - | ||
204172 | ? | - | ? | - | - | - | |
64760 | |||||||
167756 | - | - | - | ||||
150168 | |||||||
47240 | - | - | - | ||||
157246 | - | - | - | ||||
96248 | - | - | - | - | |||
53138 | - | - | - | - | - |
Figure 2: Grey-scale representation of variability in HD 37128. | |
Open with DEXTER |
HD 37128 ( Ori, B0 Ia N-; Fig. 2). A well-studied, moderately nitrogen weak star (Walborn 1976), part of the Ori OB1 association. Ori has been cited as a single-lined spectroscopic binary (e.g. Frost 1909; Morrell & Levato 1991), however its binarity remains uncertain and, for example, Jarad et al. (1989) found it to be a radial velocity constant. Variability in the hydrogen lines has been reported by Gry et al. (1984) and Ebbets (1982). Previous suggestions that it is a variable thermal radio source are discounted by Blomme et al. (2002).
UV variability in the short intensive IUE time-series is shown in Fig. 2. We note the progression of a DAC feature between -900 to -1200 km s-1 over 14 hours. High velocity narrow absorption components are also present towards the short-ward edge. Strong photospheric lines (e.g. C III 1247 and Al III 1855) reveal radial velocity shifts of 20 km s-1.
Figure 3: Grey-scale representation of variability in HD 91969. | |
Open with DEXTER |
HD 91969 (B0 Ia; Fig. 3). A member of the Car OB1 association
(e.g. Humphreys 1978). It is one of the brightest members of the
NGC 3293 open cluster in the Carina region (e.g. Feinstein &
Marracu 1980). The IUE time-series data studied here were secured during
our "MEGA II'' campaign in 1996, and some of our findings have been summarised
by Massa et al. (1998). This star is an excellent example of the
variety of diagnostic UV lines available in early BIs. Massa et al. (1998)
reported a 7.8-days period for the repetition of DAC features
propagating blue-ward toward the profile edge. These features are
seen at very low velocities in Al III, and their progression "connects''
with corresponding events seen at higher velocities in
Si III, Si IV and N V. There is however evidence
for ion stratification between activity in Al III and Si IV.
The temporal coherency is
strongest in the low
ion species which form in the deeper regions of the wind. The periodic
line profile changes are seen down to very low velocities (less than
0.05 ), together with variations in photospheric lines
due to Si III, Fe III, and Fe IV. The latter may be tracers of localised
surface inhomogeneities responsible for wind activity.
Figure 4: Grey-scale representation of variability in HD 164402 (1986). | |
Open with DEXTER |
Figure 5: Grey-scale representation of variability in HD 164402 (1993). | |
Open with DEXTER |
Figure 6: Grey-scale representation of variability in HD 164402 (1995). | |
Open with DEXTER |
Figure 7: Grey-scale representation of variability in HD 204172 (1990). | |
Open with DEXTER |
Figure 8: Grey-scale representation of variability in HD 204172 (1993). | |
Open with DEXTER |
Figure 9: Grey-scale representation of variability in HD 64760 (1993). | |
Open with DEXTER |
Figure 10: Grey-scale representation of variability in HD 64760 (1995). | |
Open with DEXTER |
HD 164402 (B0 Ib N-; Figs. 4 to 6). A member of the
Sgr OB1 association (Humphreys 1978), this star has one of the lowest
projected rotation velocities in our sample. It is moderately nitrogen
deficient, with no indication of binary companionship (e.g.
Levato et al. 1988). HD 164402 provides an opportunity to study
systematic wind activity over three separate epochs. The 1986 data set
(Fig. 4) has a poorer temporal sampling, but reveals a distinctive DAC
progressing from -1200 km s-1 to -1600 km s-1over 6 days. This feature is accompanied by more sporadic events, which
are well spread in velocity, but unresolved temporally (e.g. at
,
4,2 and 5 days, where T is time relative to the
first observation in the series).
The 1993 time-series (Fig. 5) spans almost
16 days and reveals a remarkably slowly migrating DAC, with a mean
acceleration of
km s-2. Other features
with different characteristics and more rapid evolution are also noted
at
and 12 days. Drastic variations are present in the 1995
data set (Fig. 6) around days. The highest velocity absorption
(at -1750 km s-1)
suddenly decreases and is accompanied by lower velocity DAC features
at -1300 km s-1 and -1000 km s-1. The sudden
reversal in optical depth across the lines may represent the signature
of a large scale shock.
Figure 11: Grey-scale representation of variability in HD 167756. | |
Open with DEXTER |
Figure 12: Grey-scale representation of variability in HD 150168. | |
Open with DEXTER |
Figure 13: Grey-scale representation of variability in HD 47240. | |
Open with DEXTER |
Figure 14: Grey-scale representation of variability in HD 157246 (1993). | |
Open with DEXTER |
HD 204172 (69 Cyg; B0 Ib N-; Figs. 7, 8). A moderately
nitrogen weak star (Walborn 1976), belonging to the Cyg OB2 association.
Lennon et al. (1992) highlight several discrepancies
between the B0 Ib spectral type assignment and the appearance of the
optical spectral line profiles, including H lines being too narrow and
Si IV too strong. They suggest a revision to B0.2 Ia. The UV resonance
lines of 69 Cyg are generally stronger than those of HD 164402, thus
favouring a slightly more luminous spectral type. The densely sampled
1990 time series (Fig. 7) reveals a gradual increase in profile
absorption strength over 2.2. days. The fluctuations extend over
a broad velocity range that cover almost the entire Si IV absorption
trough. Corresponding changes are seen at much lower velocity (extending
close to zero velocity) in C II 1335 and Al III 1855.
The velocity differences between low and high ions are principally an
optical depth effect. There are also traces of DAC features at
-1700 km s-1 (e.g.
to 0.5 days) in Si IV,
C IV and N V. Some changes are apparent in the
strong C III
1247 "photospheric'' line. The 1993 data set (Fig. 8) is more
extended and covers almost 16 days. Two enhanced absorptions are present
over a substantial velocity range. These may be similar events to the
phenomena seen with greater time resolution in 1990 (Fig. 7). There is
a tentative indication that the feature recurs over 12 days,
which is close to the estimated maximum rotation period of the star
(Table 1). Some variations are also noted in the deep-seated C III
1247 and Si III 1300 triplets.
Figure 15: Grey-scale representation of variability in HD 157246 (1995). | |
Open with DEXTER |
Figure 16: Grey-scale representation of variability in HD 96248. | |
Open with DEXTER |
Figure 17: Grey-scale representation of variability in HD 53138. | |
Open with DEXTER |
HD 64760 (B0.5 Ib; Figs. 9, 10). This is one of two rapid rotators in our sample. The data sets for the two epochs shown here were discussed in detail by Massa et al. (1995b) and Fullerton et al. (1997). HD 64760 exhibits a variety of spectral features that indicate co-existing wind structure. In fact, every category of stellar wind phenomena listed in Table 3 is present in this star! The "MEGA I'' campaign during 1995 (Fig. 10) in particular reveals a striking 1.2-day modulation, where individual features cover a large velocity range, and have a bow-shaped morphology such that they extend blue-wards and red-wards at the same time. Ionization variability is indicated by the fact that the N V data appear to have nearly twice the modulation frequency of Si III (Fullerton et al. 1997). Slower migrating, high velocity DACs are also present, which persist over several days. The recurrence time-scale for the DACs is not constrained. An exceptionally strong absorption event is present in high-ion species in the (shorter) time series data for 1993 (Fig. 9, around days). It is accompanied by variations essentially down to zero velocity in e.g. C II 1335 and Al III 1855, plus disturbances in the "photospheric'' Si III 1300 triplets. The onset of these substantial changes is also marked by changes in the relative ionization mixture, such that the overall ionization of the wind increases during this event (Massa et al. 1995b). It is possible that this strong event, and the overall enhancement seen at days (Fig. 9), are similar to the bowed structures apparent in the more extensive MEGA I data set (Fig. 10). HD 167756 (B0.5 Ib; Fig. 11). A distant halo star, located about 4 kpc away at a Galactic altitude of -0.85 Kpc (e.g. Savage & Massa 1985). Ionization shifts are apparent in the wind-formed lines, with the high velocity (-1500 km s-1) DAC seen in Si IV ( to 3 days) only being apparent at less than -500 km s-1 in Al III. The absorption enhancement seen in Si IV, N V, and C IV towards the end of the observing run ( days) may also be accompanied by variations close to zero velocity in Si III 1207 and Al III 1855.
HD 150168 (B1 Iab-Ib; Fig. 12). A member of the Ara OB1 association (Humphreys 1978). The UV time-series reveals a radial velocity motion in strong UV photospheric lines (e.g. C III 1247) due to binary motion. Several interesting wind effects are apparent in this star. Near the start of the time-series there is a maximum in absorption in N V which corresponds to a minimum in Si IV (i.e. ionization variability). Close to days a bowed structure is present, with the absorption minimum in N V lagging the Si IV minimum (i.e. ion stratification). A much weaker bowed feature may be present at days. Multiple high velocity DACs (-1500 km s-1) are seen in Si IV, C IV and N V.
HD 47240 (B1 Ib; Fig. 13). A member of the Mon OB2 association. Binary radial velocity motion is seen in strong UV photospheric lines (e.g. C III 1247). The double DAC feature seen at the start of the time-series at -700 km s-1 in Si IV is present at a lower velocity (-500 km s-1) in C II and Al III. This enhancement is seen at almost zero velocity in C IV, however there is very little line flux in Si III 1207. The variations in Si IV between -500 and -1000 km s-1 may be repetitive over a 3 to 5 day time scale.
HD 157246 ( Ara, B1 Ib; Figs. 14, 15). This star has the highest projected rotation velocity in our sample of stars (Table 1). The 1993 UV time-series was discussed by Prinja et al. (1997; see Fig. 14). The data reveal a complex pattern of co-existing discrete features at low velocities (red-ward of -750 km s-1) and high velocities (blue-ward of -1500 km s-1). These regions are "divided'' by the appearance of a very sharp (in velocity width) DAC-like feature. The location of this narrow feature is shifted by 400 km s-1between Si IV and Al III (or C III). The two-component wind properties, and overall profile morphologies, suggest evidence for an equatorially compressed wind, with structure in the polar components (Prinja et al. 1997). The narrow DAC-like feature is not seen in the 1995 IUE time-series (Fig. 15), and the high speed wind between -1000 and -1500 km s-1 is also no longer present. The line profiles in the 1995 data are more representative of the normal state of Ara (e.g. when compared to isolated archival spectra taken at earlier epochs). Some ionization state variability is observed between Si IV and N V (see e.g. the fluctuations between to 8 days in Fig. 15). In both data sets variations are present down to near-zero velocities in the low ions.
HD 96248 (BC1 Ia; Fig. 16). Carbon enhancement has been reported in this star by Dufton (1972) and Walborn (1976). HD 96248 is a radial velocity constant (e.g. Levato et al. 1988). The 30 day time-series shown in Fig. 16 is from the "MEGA II'' Campaign of 1996. The Si IV and C IV profiles are nearly saturated, and the line profile variability is confined to the blue edges (i.e. -750 to -1000 km s-1). A gradual increase in absorption in the blue edge occurs from the start of the time-series to almost the end of the run, only weakening slightly after days. These variations are mimicked in the low ions (Al III and C II), but at slightly lower velocities. Additional variations due to DACs are also seen between -200 and -600 km s-1 in Al III, but they do not evolve into the structure seen at high velocities. The blue edge in C II 1335 is not as shallow or extended as in the other lines.
HD 53138 (o2CMa, B3 Ia; Fig. 17). A member of the Coll 121 association. HD 53138 exhibited very complex and highly variable characteristics in the H profile survey of Ebbets (1982), with variable absorption and emission components. Low velocity (red-ward of -500 km s-1) UV variability is present in the 13 day time series shown in Fig. 17. A DAC feature is present between to 4 days, which is essentially confined to high velocities. Various sporadic changes are apparent later in the run. Some degree of ion stratification is present, such that C II variations during the first 4 days appear at lower velocities than in Al III.
It is interesting to compare the BI wind activity presented here with that of 10 O-type stars described by Kaper et al. (1996), also based on high-resolution IUE spectroscopy. The O stars generally do not exhibit such a variety of temporal phenomena, and in particular show limited evidence for ionization related effects. (The comparisons are restricted, however, since Si IV is often the only reliable indicator of wind activity in O-type stars, as N V and C IV are saturated and the sub-ordinate N IV 1718 is only weakly present.) The fundamental characteristic patterns of variability in the O star data are in the form of blue-ward migrating DACs, though their properties may differ a lot between e.g. acceleration rates, multiplicity, and line-of-sight velocity dispersions. The coherence of systematic structure is generally greater in the UV lines of BIs compared to those of O stars. In terms of clearly defined - obviously modulated - wind structure, the B supergiant examples of HD 64760 and HD 91969 described above, are best matched by the O7.5 III stars Per (HD 24912) and 68 Cygni (HD 203064).
Figure 18: Temporal variance (rms) for the Si IV spectral lines in our program stars. The velocity scale is with respect to the red component of the doublet, and the rest wavelength of the blue component is marked by an arrow. The horizontal dashed lines mark the level of significance for a probability of 95%. | |
Open with DEXTER |
In order to quantify
the extent of variability as a function of velocity, we computed the
temporal variance spectrum (TVS, see Fullerton et al. 1996) for the
Si IV line profile for all our program stars:
(1) |
The maximum amplitude of the variations in Fig. 18 mostly occurs between 0.7 to 0.9 . HD 91969 and HD96248 exhibit the largest amplitude changes in Si IV. Though the variance diagnostics in Fig. 18 reveal no case of substantial variation in the emission components of the P Cygni profiles, weak systematic changes have been noted in the UV emission lobes of HD 64760 (e.g. Fullerton et al. 1997).
Measurements were also made of the ratios of minimum flux to maximum flux as a function of velocity for selected lines in the time-series data of each star. The overall trend in N V, Si IV and C IV is of a gradual decrease in (i.e. greater relative absorption or optical depth) with increasing velocity. The mean ratios (over all stars) vary as: [N V] 0.81 (at 0.2 ) to 0.68 (at 0.7 ), [Si IV] 0.80 (0.2 ) to 0.33 (0.7 ), and [C IV] 0.53 (0.2 ) to 0.05 (0.7 ). The most extreme variations in lines other than Si IV (Fig. 18) occur in HD 150168 and HD 47240 in N V and C IV. The weaker Al III flux ratios do not exhibit a clear trend in velocity and mean values vary between 0.75 to 0.9 - stronger absorption variations are seen in this line in HDs 47240, 157246 and 96248.
Variability in the Si IV lines is compared more directly in the images shown in Fig. 19, where the stars are ordered in terms of estimated maximum rotation period. There is perhaps some overall similarity between the moderate rotators HDs 47240, 204172, 164402 and 91969. Only HD 150168 shows bowed features that resemble the striking patterns seen in HD 64760. There is also a resemblance between the very slowly propagating, high velocity DAC seen in HD 64760 (blue-wards of -1200 km s-1) and DACs seen towards the short-ward profile edge in HD 204172 and HD 164402.
In O-type stars the UV resonance line profile variability is usually dominated by the blue-ward migrating, recurrent, DACs. The apparent connection between modulated wind activity and stellar rotation in these stars is then based on measured trends in the recurrence and evolution time-scales of the DACs. We have shown in Sects. 3 and 4 that the line profile behaviour of BIs is more complex, such that the variance (e.g. Fig. 18) is generally not due to a single phenomenon such as DACs, but instead reflects the contributions of different variable structures. Furthermore, the empirical properties of these co-existing features do not all follow the same evolution time-scales. Examples of fairly localised (i.e. velocity widths 0.1 to 0.3 ) blue-ward migrating features that resemble DACs in O-type stars are seen in our sample in HDs 91969, 164402, 64760 (1995), 150168, 157246 (1993) and 96248. The measured mean accelerations for the DACs in the highest sin(i) stars, HDs 64760 and 157246, are 90 km s-1 d-1 and 140 km s-1 d-1, respectively. The corresponding values for the slower rotators, HDs 96248, 150168 and 164402 are 7 km s-1 d-1, 35 km s-1 d-1and 20 km s-1 d-1. Therefore, aside from the other variability phenomena identified in Sect. 3.1, these results are consistent with the view that the time-scale of stellar wind activity in radiation-pressure-driven, luminous early-type stars is related to the rotation period of the underlying star. However, our study also highlights other broad absorption features which can arise and evolve substantially over comparatively short time-scales (1 to 2 days) in seemingly moderate or slow rotators, such as HD 204172 and HD 150168 (see e.g. Fig. 19).
Figure 19: Comparison of the Si IV variability characteristics of selected program stars; the estimated maximum rotation period is increasing from left to right. | |
Open with DEXTER |
In this section we present the results from wind line profile modelling, to derive further details of the UV variability characteristics and ionization states of early B supergiants. Specifically, our objective was to derive values for the product of mass-loss rate and ion fraction ( qi), for the mean line profiles of the time-series and for cases of overall maximum and minimum observed absorption. We also examined trends in the relative ionization ratios. Our approach in this analysis is limited to the simplified method of employing steady-state line synthesis models to match observed profiles that are obviously affected by temporal wind structure and inhomogeneities in the outflow. Nevertheless, some useful information can still be derived from the success and failures in matching line profiles due to different ions.
We modelled the N V, C IV, Si IV and Si III
(1207) wind lines (and in a few cases
also Al III and C II) using the "Sobolev with exact integration''
(SEI) method described by Lamers et al. (1987). In addition, we adopted
the modified treatment of the wind optical depth law introduced by Massa et al.
(1995b), such that the radial optical depth
is
treated in 10 independent velocity bins (each 0.1
wide).
This approach provides greater flexibility in matching absorption
optical depths in a wind that is affected by time-variable structure.
We assume a standard parameterised law for the wind of the form
(2) |
Since the UV photospheric spectrum of early BIs can be fairly strong, it
is necessary to allow for their effects in the SEI profile fitting.
The high-resolution IUE photospheric spectra of the following
stars were adopted (by spectral type) as "standards'' and explicitly included
as a lower boundary for the calculations: HD 36512 (B0 V),
HD 36960 (B0.5 V), HD 31726 (B1 V), HD 36959 (B1.5 V), HD 35468 (B2 III),
HD 207330 (B2.5 III) and HD 209008 (B3 III).
These "standard'' stars were selected as low
targets, covering the
range of
spectral types of our program stars, and exhibiting very weak or no evidence
for winds in their resonance lines. The input photospheric spectra were
convolved with a rotational profile to match the
rotational broadening of the program stars, and generally the
agreement between the corresponding photospheric absorption lines
was very good.
The products of mass-loss rate and ionization fraction ( ) are derived from fits to the mean profiles. (X.XX(-Y) = X.XX 10-Y yr-1). The range in this value determined from cases of overall minimum and maximum absorption is also listed. The IUE SWP images corresponding to the cases of minimum and maximum absorption that were modelled are: HD 37128 (8100, 8130), HD 91969 (57187, 57426), HD 164402 (54200, 54225), HD 204172 (38957, 48914), HD 64760 (53522, 53709), HD 167756 (29001, 29049), HD 150168 (47098, 47198), HD 47240 (48953, 48930), HD 157246 (54172, 54103), HD 96248 (57069, 57204), HD 53138 (30153, 30264). We also obtained a few results from fits to Al III - HD 204172, 2.72(-9); HD 47240, 2.47(-9); HD 96248, 3.38(-8) and C II - HD 53138, 6.84(-10). |
Figure 20: SEI model line profile fits for N V, C IV, Si IV, and Si III lines in our program stars. Examples are shown for the cases of constructed mean profiles (see also Table 4). | |
Open with DEXTER |
With the parameters in the velocity law and photospheric input fixed, the bins were the only free parameters in the line fitting scheme. The procedure adopted was to fit the individual profile, bin by bin, progressing from the blue-ward profile edge to less negative velocities (see Massa et al. 1995b). We modelled in this manner the mean N V, C IV, Si IV, and Si III profiles for the time-series data of each program star. In addition, to gauge the range in parameters due to profile variability, we also modelled for N V, Si IV, and C IV, the representative (overall) maximum and minimum absorption spectra (the IUE SWP images used in these cases are listed in Table 4). The Si III 1207 lines are generally too weak and their photospheric absorption lines are less well matched by the standard stars, to determine variability characteristics by profile fitting. Therefore only the results of fits to the mean Si III line profiles are quoted in Table 4. The mass-loss rate results are summarised in Table 4, where the values are integrated over 0.2 to 0.9 . Examples of the fits to the mean profiles are shown in Fig. 20. We note the following key points from this analysis.
The overall quality of the line profile matches is good, which partly reflects the flexible optical depth "law'' adopted. It is notable that mostly in C IV - and to a lesser extent in Si IV - the low velocity absorption (i.e. below about 0.25) is not well matched. The spherically symmetric models often predict excess forward-scattered emission in the low-velocity part of the P Cygni absorption trough. The discrepancy scales qualitatively with the strength of a given spectral line, such that it is generally worse for the maximum absorption cases than the minimum ones for a single star. Puls et al. (1993) discuss in detail the fact that reduced emission results when account is taken of back-scattering in several different resonance zones in structured winds. The reduced emission acts so as to yield an apparent increased absorption in the low velocity region between 0 and 0.3. Also if the winds are not spherically symmetric, then the models will produce too much scattered light at low velocities. It is also possible that to some degree the mis-match at low velocities reflects clumping in a highly structured wind so that parts of the stellar disk are being obscured by very different amounts of material than others.
The mean values of listed in Table 4 are consistent with the dependence on luminosity for B supergiants reported by Prinja & Massa (1997), who presented preliminary results for a wider, time-averaged survey. Typically the range in implied by the variability between minimum and maximum absorption line profiles is a factor of 1.5. A clear exception is the factor of 7 change noted in for HD 150168; this star showed strong evidence for ionization variability in the time-series data (e.g. Fig. 12 and see below). This quantity describes the change in structures integrated over a velocity range from 0.2 to 0.9 , and is therefore intended to reflect variations in the global mass-loss rate. However, the localised variations (i.e., in a given velocity bin) can be several times larger. For example, at 0.7 (cf. temporal variance in Fig. 18), the product of may vary between a factor of 4 to 15 for supergiants in the spectral range B0 to B0.5. These changes reflect the degree of structure in the wind.
Our sample of stars is too small to derive useful information on the temperature dependence of the relative ion ratios. However, at a given effective temperature the values of , or , can differ by up to a factor of 5. We find that there are no significant differences (or trends) in an individual star between the relative ion fraction derived from the mean profiles, minimum absorption profiles and maximum absorption profiles. Over the spectral range B0 to B1 (Ia and Ib) the mean ion ratios are 2.5, and . HD 150168 and HD 157246 ( Ara) exhibit the most exceptional mean ion ratios of . In HD 150168 the ratio is almost 3 times larger than for other stars of similar parameters. The difference is linked to the ionization change (of unknown origin) that occurred during the run (see Sect. 3.2); the increase in the ion ratio points to a temporal ionization shift from a "normal state'' to a `high state'. The ratio of in Ara is also several times larger than for other BIs. This result may reflect a nitrogen rich stellar surface due to rotational mixing (in a rapid rotator). As expected, the ratio of the BC star HD 96428 is abnormal, and the mean ratio is between 4 to 8 times larger than the other stars in our sample.
The behaviour of the ionic ratios as a function of velocity is shown in Fig. 21 for our program stars (based on fits to the mean profiles of the time-series). The ratio does not depend on abundance and its observed trend indicates a decrease in ionization state of the wind as a function of velocity. The relative ion mixture of q( seems to be more stable between 0.4 to 0.8 (or 2 to 5 stellar radii for the adopted empirical velocity law).
HD 37128 (
Ori) is the only star in our sample
with a measured radio flux, which
may be used to provide a reliable estimate of the mass-loss rate.
Blomme et al. (2002) have conducted a radio and sub-mm study of
Ori, and they derive a
value of
yr-1.
The (mean) results in Table 4 therefore give ion fractions for this
star of
,
,
,
and
.
Alternatively,
using the theoretical mass-loss recipe of Vink et al. (2001) to determine
the mass-loss rates for our target stars,
yields mean ionization fractions over B0 to B1
of
,
,
,
and
.
The line-fitting analysis suggests therefore that
none of the spectral lines modelled here represent the
dominant stage of ionization for early B supergiants (over
the UV line-formation region). This is particularly surprising for
the case of Si3+ and C3+ in the earliest B stars studied,
such as
Ori.
As in O-type stars, the other likely candidates for the dominant ion stages
are Si4+, C4+, and N3+.
Figure 21: The relative ion ratios (qi/qj) are plotted as a function of velocity, based on SEI model fits to the mean line profiles of our program stars. | |
Open with DEXTER |
It may be that the low ionization fractions derived here are due to the effects of clumping in the stellar winds (e.g. Massa et al. 2002, in preparation). If the winds are principally composed of optically thick clumps separated by transparent "voids'', then each constant velocity surface will only partially contribute to the emission line. Furthermore, the face of the star would not be completely covered by optically thick material at any velocity. This means that the absorption part of the profile will not be very deep, thus also giving the impression of an unsaturated line. As a result, when fitting the spectral line with a homogeneous wind model, we derive a finite optical depth (and lower values of qi), even though the optical depth of the wind might be much larger if the wind material was homogeneously distributed.
The first of the two phenomena are usually linked with the effects of CIRs (e.g. Owocki et al. 1995; Cranmer & Owocki 1996) passing through the line-of-sight. Specifically, localised features or inhomogeneities at the stellar surface are predicted to alter the radiative force, which leads to the formation of high-density low-speed gas streams. These streams are then rammed by the faster moving `underlying' wind as the star rotates, leading to a spiral pattern. The enhanced absorption identified above arises from an extended layer of near-uniform velocity that marks the initial response of the unperturbed wind to the slower CIR ahead.
A further possibility then is that the slowly migrating DACs (item 2 above) are also related to CIRs, but originate in the radiative-acoustic kinks which are predicted to trail the CIRs in the hydrodynamical simulations of Cranmer & Owocki (1996).
It is important to realise that both observational phenomena highlighted above are not always present in every OB star. In many O-type stars for instance, only the long-lived DAC features are present, i.e. without evidence for co-existing "bowed'' structures or periodic absorption modulations. In this respect, we believe the "wavelength drift'' model developed by Hamann et al. (2001) is more appropriate for a star with a distinctly structured wind such as HD 64760 (Fig. 10) or Per (Kaper et al. 1997), than for Pup where the dominant (19.2-hr) variability pattern is due solely to blue-ward migrating DACs.
The strong ionization changes seen in HDs 150168, 91969, 64760 and 157246 (Table 3) are likely shock signatures, though we cannot easily assign them to the same physical origin. If the interface between slow and fast wind streams in the CIR model is associated with strong shocks, then we can expect some ionization changes in the UV lines as the structure crosses the line-of-sight to the stellar disk. In cases where the variability phenomenon is seen at different velocities in different ions (Table 3), this behaviour may also relate to the action of spatially confined shock regions in the wind, where the post-shock gas is denser, lower speed, and less highly ionized than the pre-shock material. Mullan (1984) and Cranmer & Owocki (1996) discuss scenarios which may potentially result in velocity jumps of several hundred km s-1.
An important result from our study is the variety of wind activity patterns that are present in the UV time-series data of BIs. However, this diversity of behaviour does not necessarily indicate that there is a corresponding variety of fundamental processes responsible for generating wind structure. The combination of stellar rotation rate and viewing (aspect) angle to the observer are among the most variable factors in our sample of B0 to B1 stars; more so than e.g. , ), and wind density. Inclination angle and could play an important role in determining the precise observational manifestation of azimuthally-extended large-scale wind structure that has its roots at the photosphere.
An interesting signature of spiral-shaped structure in a hot star wind is the appearance of bowed features. Since the winding of a spiral is determined by radial expansion and stellar rotation, the visibility of bowed features in UV time-series data is largely determined by the ratio of /. Though we only know the projected rotation velocity, and our statistical sample in this paper is small, the ratio of sin(i)/ is largest for HD 64740 (0.14) and HD 157246 ( Ara; 0.41 for 1995 data set). HD 64760 of course exhibits the clearest examples of phase bowing in our UV sample (Fig. 10), and indeed it is the best known case for this behaviour out of all the UV time-series data available for OB stars. Fast rotation is also undoubtedly the key to Ara's extreme behaviour, i.e. the transient two-component (polar and equatorial) wind. Interestingly, HD 150168 is the only other star in our study that shows bowed structures which are similar to those evident in HD 64760 (Fig. 12). The projected rotation velocity of this star is not exceptional and sin(i)/ is 0.09. This is possibly then an example where either the inclination angle and/or the density contrast of gas in the interacting spiral streams favours the detection of phase bowing.
We have discussed in this paper the best UV time-series data sets of early B supergiants available in any of the public archives. With the demise of IUE, these collections will not be improved for the forseeable future. One of our key objectives was to collect these homogeneous data sets into a single comparative study. Over the next few years these results will be complemented by extended time-series studies of luminous early-type stars in the Magellanic Clouds using the Far Ultraviolet Spectroscopic Explorer satellite (FUSE; 900 to 1200). We anticipate in particular more sensitive searches for ionization variability in the far-UV lines, and an examination of the dependence of wind variability on metallicity. Additionally, 2 m class optical telescopes are currently being used to monitor time-dependent behaviour over rotational time-scales in Balmer and He lines of OB supergiants. A key goal in these studies is to exploit the recombination-dominated lines to determine the coherence of large-scale wind structure in the deeper, near-star wind regions, close to potential photospheric inhomogeneities.
Acknowledgements
We are indebted to the staff at the NASA and ESA IUE Observatories at Goddard Space Flight Center, USA, and Villafranca, Spain for their hospitality and assistance. DM acknowledges support from NASA contract NAG5-7372 to Raytheon ITSS. This research made use of the Simbad database, which is operated at CDS, Strasbourg, France.