A&A 388, L13-L16 (2002)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20020558
J. H. M. M. Schmitt - J.-U. Ness
Hamburger Sternwarte, Universität Hamburg, Gojenbergsweg 112, 21029 Hamburg, Germany
Received 21 March 2002 / Accepted 10 April 2002
Abstract
Using the Ly-lines of carbon and nitrogen measured
in Chandra
Low Energy Transmission Grating Spectrometer (LETGS) spectra
we study the coronal abundances of these elements in a sample of late-type
stars including dwarf stars, the prototypical eclipsing
binary Algol, the single giant
Cet, and three RS CVn binaries.
In the main sequence stars of our sample
the flux ratio
between
the Ly
-lines of nitrogen and carbon is below unity, while
is found to be
8.5 for
Cet and >23.3 for Algol.
These values are more than an order of magnitude larger than expected from
a solar abundance plasma in collisional equilibrium regardless of the
chosen temperature structure. We therefore interpret the
anomalously large
-ratios as being due to the exposure
of CNO-cycle processed material at the surfaces and in the coronae
of Algol and
Cet.
Key words: stars: abundances - stars: activity - stars: coronae - stars: late type X-rays: stars - stars: individual: Algol
One of the most intensely studied binary systems is the bright eclipsing
binary Algol (= Per). Already
the Chinese noted Algol's brightness changes, but it was Goodricke
(1783),
who rediscovered its brightness changes, noted their periodicity, and
provided the essentially correct interpretation by attributing the brightness
change to a second, darker body in the system. In modern language Algol
is an eclipsing photometric and spectroscopic binary with
well determined system parameters. According to the recent
determination of system parameters by Al-Naimiy et al. (1985),
Algol contains a B8V primary (
,
)
and a K2III secondary (
,
). Thus
the two
stars have almost the same size, but their masses differ by almost
a factor of five. The more evolved secondary is lighter than
the less evolved primary in seeming conflict with stellar evolution
theory which predicts faster evolution for more massive stars. This
conflict can only be solved by assuming substantial mass transfer from
the present-day secondary to the present-day primary, a suggestion
first made by Crawford (1955).
Plenty of evidence now exists for mass transfer in Algol-type binaries
in the form of gas streams, disk- and related features.
The role of mass loss in the evolution of Algol systems
is presently not clear; in addition
to significant mass being donated to the present-day primary, significant
mass (and angular momentum) may be lost from the system due to a wind.
Stellar evolution theory predicts that in stars
more massive than 2
the CNO-cycle is the
dominant mode of energy generation. In the CNO-cycle the atoms of
carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen are used as catalysts to convert hydrogen
into helium. Its nuclear equilibrium
is such that most of the catalytic nuclei participating in the cycle
at any given time are found in the form N14. Therefore one expects
to find substantial nitrogen enrichment if the cycle is interrupted
by lowering the temperature and CNO-cycled material is
subsequently brought up to the surface.
Mass transfer in a close binary as in an Algol system is a rather dramatic
way to expose nuclearly processed material at the surface. Less dramatic
ways to achieve the same result also occur during the regular course of
stellar evolution. Once the hydrogen fuel in the stellar core is exhausted
nuclear burning moves further and further away from the center; the
star responds by expanding and thus
starts its giant evolution.
As discussed by Iben (1967), the rapidly
expanding outer convection zones of giants are in contact with the shell
burning zones and may again transport nitrogen-enriched material to the
surface.
These predictions of stellar evolution theory have of course been tested by optical spectroscopists. The principal source of information on the photospheric abundances of carbon and nitrogen in cool stars comes from CH and CN molecules which have absorption bands in the blue part of the spectrum (cf. Luck 1978; Parthasarathy et al. 1983). The measurements of carbon and nitrogen abundances are made even more difficult if the star is in rapid rotation; further, in Algol systems the much brighter primary star contaminates the spectrum, and useful data can only be obtained during a primary eclipse - if at all. Quantitative abundance determinations require the use of model atmospheres, which predict only relatively small effects in the blue part of the spectrum on varying the carbon and nitrogen abundances so that an accurate model of the atmospheric temperature stratification is required. Finally, a value for the oxygen abundance must be chosen or somehow determined from the data; this is particularly difficult if NLTE-effects are important as maybe the case for supergiants. Despite these difficulties, the secondaries of the Algol systems U Cep and U Sge have been studied by Parthasarathy et al. (1983), who find - relative to iron - a carbon deficiency and nitrogen enhancement as expected from theory. In the atmospheres of giants and supergiants anomalously large N/C-ratios were also reported (Luck 1978; Luck & Lambert 1981, 1985; Sneden et al. 1986). A summary of carbon/nitrogen abundance determinations is given by McCluskey & Kondo (1992).
Ultraviolet emission lines provide another means to obtain information on
elemental abundances. Böhm-Vitense & Mena-Werth (1992) use the emission
lines from C II, C IV, and N V measured
with the IUE satellite, to determine elemental abundances. Their
approach heavily relies on the underlying form of the
differential emission measure distribution function, which is assumed to have
the form
,
with T denoting temperature.
The two constants B and
are found from
the C II and C IV emission lines at 1330 Å and 1550 Å respectively, and the abundances of other elements (i.e., nitrogen and silicon)
are then computed from a comparison of the observed
line flux with those expected from the above power law emission measure
distribution. With this method Böhm-Vitense & Mena-Werth (1992) find
N/C-abundances in general agreement with photospherically derived
abundances, but an inspection of their Table 4 reveals differences of
up to
for individual stars.
X-ray spectroscopy opens up a new window to determine elemental abundances and to independently test the above described evolutionary scenarios. The specific advantage of X-ray lines is that they come directly from the atomic species, not from molecules with their sometimes rather complicated chemistry. Further, no assumptions on the abundance of oxygen have to be made. Here we will pursue an approach even independent of the coronal temperature stratification and only relying on hydrogen-like lines, the atomic physics of which appears to be well understood. We stress that the results derived in this paper do not assume a power-law emission measure distribution, and thus the only assumptions entering our abundance studies are the ionization equilibrium for carbon and nitrogen and the excitation rates for those lines.
The secondaries of Algol systems are - almost per
definitionem - rapidly rotating and hence active late type stars.
Most single giants in a volume-limited sample around the Sun are found to
be X-ray sources (cf. Schröder et al. 1998), and only for a
few stars really sensitive low upper limits to the absence of
any X-ray emission have been established (cf. Ayres et al. 1991).
Therefore for the secondaries of Algol systems as well as single
giants X-ray emission is the rule rather than the exception.
This X-ray emission is produced by plasma in collisional
equilibrium at temperatures where carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen are
predominantly found as helium-like and hydrogen-like ions.
The strongest line from hydrogen-like ions is the
Ly-line, from helium-like ions it is
the resonance line
in the triplet transition array.
The Ly
lines of carbon, nitrogen, and
oxygen are located at 34.74 Å, 24.74 Å, and 18.97 Å, and
the helium-like resonance lines at 40.3 Å, 28.7 Å, and 21.6 Å respectively. They can therefore be perfectly observed
with the LETGS onboard Chandra.
![]() |
Figure 1:
LETGS spectra (background subtracted) of Algol, ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
N VII | C VI |
![]() |
|
![]() |
24.74 | 33.74 |
![]() |
![]() |
15.26 | 11.59 |
![]() |
Procyon | 206.9 ![]() |
697.5 ![]() |
0.31 ![]() |
![]() |
17.9 ![]() |
14.78 ![]() |
1.25 ![]() |
![]() |
17.67 ![]() |
117.65 ![]() |
0.16 ![]() |
![]() |
32.07 ![]() |
102.86 ![]() |
0.32 ![]() |
![]() |
178.85 ![]() |
289.88 ![]() |
0.64 ![]() |
YY Gem | 91.8 ![]() |
138.4 ![]() |
0.69 ![]() |
AD Leo | 146.35 ![]() |
203.38 ![]() |
0.74 ![]() |
HR 1099 | 501.93 ![]() |
627.51 ![]() |
0.83 ![]() |
Capella | 2280.3 ![]() |
2151.1 ![]() |
1.10 ![]() |
UX Ari | 602.85 ![]() |
309.36 ![]() |
2.02 ![]() |
![]() |
200.53 ![]() |
24.48 ![]() |
8.48 ![]() |
Algol | 1119.05 ![]() |
<50 | >23.3 |
The LETGS onboard Chandra covers the spectral range between
6 Å-170 Å (i.e., including the spectral range covered with the
ROSAT PSPC) with a spectral resolution of 0.03 Å; a
detailed description of this
instrument is given by Predehl et al. (1997).
In Fig. 1 we show portions of the accumulated LETGS spectra covering
the O VII triplet and the nitrogen Ly
-line (left panel) and
the carbon Ly
-line (right panel) for our sample stars
Algol (=
Per), the single giant
Cet (spectral type K0III),
the RS CVn binary UX Ari (spectral type G5V+K0V), and the nearby
subgiant star Procyon (spectral type F5IV-V); the LETGS spectra of
Procyon, Algol, and YY Gem
have been discussed by Ness et al. (2001), Ness et al. (2002), and
by Stelzer et al. (1998), respectively. The O VII triplet and the nitrogen Ly
-line are seen in all
stars, while the strength of the carbon Ly
-line varies considerably.
In Procyon the strength of carbon Ly
exceeds
that of nitrogen Ly
,
in Algol the carbon Ly
-line cannot
be detected. In Table 1 we list the observed number of counts (and
their errors) in the carbon and nitrogen Ly
-lines and their
flux ratio
;
the line strengths were determined
with the same methods as discussed by Ness et al. (2001). In addition to the
stars shown in Fig. 1 we included Capella
(spectral type G1III+G8/K0III)
and HR 1099 (spectral type K1IV+G5IV), two RS CVn
binaries, and the dwarf stars
Eri (spectral type K2V),
Cen A
(spectral type G2V) and B (spectral type K0V), YY Gem
(spectral type dM1e+dM1e),
UMa (spectral type G1.5V), and AD Leo (spectral type dM4.5Ve).
In Fig. 2
we plot our measurements and a theoretical curve (solid line)
of the expected ratio
of the nitrogen and
carbon Ly
-line
fluxes as a function of plasma temperature (solid line in Fig. 2 as
calculated by Mewe et al. (1985) under the assumption of
collisional equilibrium and cosmic abundances). Under those
assumptions one expects
independent of the actual plasma
temperature (cf., Fig. 2). Since the
precise plasma temperature is not known, and in fact a whole distribution of
plasma at different temperatures is likely to be present in stellar coronae,
the true value of
should be <0.57.
![]() |
Figure 2:
LETGS flux ratios of N VII and C VI for twelve stars
compared to MEKAL flux ratio vs. temperature T (solid line).
Algol, ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
An inspection of Fig. 2 and the corresponding measurements given in
Table 1 shows for the stars Eri,
Cen A and B,
YY Gem,
UMa, and AD Leo that the measured values of
are
consistent (to within the measurement errors) with the theoretical expectations
from a cosmic abundance plasma in collisional equilibrium. However, the
giant stars Capella, HR 1099, UX Ari,
Cet, and Algol
lie - in increasing strength - significantly above the theoretical
expectations. For the latter no emission from C VI (or any other carbon
ion) has been measured so that only a lower limit (
)
can be derived, and the value measured for
Cet (
)
deviates by more than one order of magnitude from
theoretical expectations. Thus all giants in our sample show
significantly enhanced
-ratios, while all dwarf stars have
-ratios consistent with cosmic abundances.
We propose to attribute these anomalously large
-values
to the nitrogen enrichment expected from mass transfer in Algol and
nitrogen dredge-up in
Cet and suggest that also in the cases
of HR 1099 and UX Ari CNO-cycle burning with ensuing nitrogen dredge-up
has begun.
If we accept a value of
as the maximally possible one for
a cosmic abundance plasma, the measured
-values can be directly
converted to lower limits for the deviations of the N/C abundance with
respect to cosmic abundances. We note that these values are independent
of the actually prevailing differential emission measure distribution.
We specifically find for Algol
,
for
Cet
,
while for UX Ari we find
and
for HR 1099
.
How reliable are those numbers? In Table 1 we quote the statistical
measurement errors. In order to obtain flux ratios, one has to multiply
with the ratio of the effective LETGS areas at 24.74 Å and 33.74 Å, i.e.,
only the relative error enters, which is expected to be <5%. The
theoretical
ratio depends on the collisional excitation rates
and the ionization equilibrium. These errors are difficult to specify;
the former are believed to have accuracies of
20%. As far as
the latter are concerned, different equilibrium calculations may result
in a small shift in temperature scale. We therefore conclude
that the deviations
of the observed
ratio for HR 1099, UX Ari, and specifically of
Cet and Algol cannot be attributed to errors in the model,
but have a physical cause.
How unique is our
proposed interpretation? Can we be sure that we actually do see the
late-type star in the Algol system? While a mathematical proof for the
absence of X-ray emission from Algol A cannot be given, such an
assumption appears extremely
unlikely. First, none of the single A-type stars in the solar neighborhood are
X-ray sources (cf. Schmitt 1997). Second, in the case of the eclipsing
binary CrB, consisting of a primary of spectral type A0V and a
secondary of type G2V, a total X-ray eclipse is observed, demonstrating
that the early-type star can contribute a minute fraction of the total
X-ray flux at best (Schmitt & Kürster 1993). And third, a long
duration flare observed on Algol with BeppoSAX (Schmitt & Favata 1999) shows a
total eclipse of the flare plasma at (optical) secondary minimum, when Algol A
is seen in front of Algol B, thus demonstrating that at least the flare was
associated with Algol B. We therefore conclude that it is extremely unlikely
that Algol A significantly contributes to the total X-ray flux
from this system.
In summary, we have shown that the LETGS spectra of Algol, Cet,
and the RS CVn binaries Capella, HR 1099, and UX Ari can only be understood
by an enhanced nitrogen abundance. It is natural to attribute this
enhancement to the CNO-cycle
operating in the cores of these stars. X-ray spectroscopy can
therefore be used to test the predictions of stellar evolution theory.
Acknowledgements
J.-U.N. acknowledges financial support from Deutsches Zentrum für Luft- und Raumfahrt e.V. (DLR) under 50OR98010. Fruitful discussions with Prof. H. Kähler on stellar evolution are acknowledged.