A&A 387, 82-97 (2002)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20020285
G. Giardino1 - A. J. Banday2 - K. M. Górski3,4 - K. Bennett1 - J. L. Jonas5 - J. Tauber1
1 - Research and Science Support Department of ESA, ESTEC,
Postbus 299, 2200 AG Noordwijk, The Netherlands
2 -
Max-Planck Institut für Astrophysik, Garching bei München,
85741, Germany
3 -
ESO, Garching bei München, 85748, Germany
4 -
Warsaw University Observatory, Warsaw, Poland
5 -
Department of Physics & Electronics, Rhodes University, PO Box 94,
Grahamstown 6140, South Africa
Received 21 December 2001 / Accepted 22 February 2002
Abstract
We have analysed the angular power spectra of the Parkes
radio continuum and polarisation survey of the Southern galactic plane
at 2.4 GHz. We have found that in the multipole range
l=40-250the angular power spectrum of the polarised intensity is well
described by a power-law spectrum with fitted spectral index
.
In the same multipole range the angular
power spectra of the E and B components of the polarised signal
are significantly flatter, with fitted spectral indices respectively
of
and
.
Temperature fluctuations in the E and B components are
mostly determined by variations in polarisation angle. We have
combined these results with other data from available radio surveys in
order to produce a full-sky toy model of Galactic synchrotron
intensity and linear polarisation at high frequencies (
GHz). This can be used to study the
feasibility of measuring the Cosmic Microwave Background polarisation
with forthcoming experiments and satellite missions.
Key words: radio continuum: ISM - surveys - polarization - cosmic microwave background
Current cosmological models predict the level of polarisation of the
Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) to be at 5-10% of the temperature
anisotropies at the 20 arcmin angular scale, that is at K level
(e.g. Bond & Efstathiou 1987). These temperature variations have to be detected
over a 3 K continuum with instrumentation whose typical noise
temperature is of the order of tens of Kelvin. The detection of the
CMB polarisation represents therefore a considerable challenge. To
date, only upper limits on the CMB polarisation exist. The most recent
results from ground based observations place an upper limit of 10
K on any polarised signal from the sky at the 7
angular scale
in the frequency band 26-36 GHz (Keating et al. 2001) and an upper
limit of 15
K at the 1
-05 angular scale at 90 GHz
(Hedman et al. 2001).
Current cosmological models also predict a shape for the angular power
spectra of the polarised component of the CMB, so the measure of these
spectra will provide additional information on the properties of the
primordial density fluctuations and on the thermal history of the
universe (e.g. Kosowsky 1996). The variation of polarised CMB
emission is predicted to peak at sub-degree angular scale. The NASA
satellite mission MAP will have enough sensitivity to detect the CMB
polarisation, if this is present at the K level (Kogut & Hinshaw 2000).
The future ESA mission Planck will have higher sensitivity and may
provide direct imaging of the CMB polarised signal
(Mandolesi & Puget 1998). The future SPORT experiment that is planned to
be placed on the International Space Station also has the sensitivity
to detect
K-level polarised signal from the CMB if this is
present at angular scales
(Fabbri et al. 1999).
A fundamental question for any measurement of the polarisation of the CMB is whether the expected signal can be distinguished from the foreground polarised signal from our galaxy. The interstellar magnetic field is illuminated by cosmic-ray electrons which spiral around field lines and thereby emit synchrotron radiation. This radiation is intrinsically highly linearly polarised, 70-75% in a completely regular field (e.g. Rybicki & Lightman 1979). Thermal emission from dust may also be highly polarised, depending on the shape and alignment of the dust particles (Wright 1987; Prunet et al. 1998).
As in the case of the unpolarised emission, knowledge of the angular power spectra of the foreground polarised component is essential when trying to recover the angular power spectra of the CMB. In this paper we use the Parkes 2.4 GHz polarimetric survey of the southern Galactic plane in order to derive the angular power spectra of the polarised component of the Galactic synchrotron emission. The survey has relatively small sky coverage but has 10 arcmin angular resolution, which allows the statistical properties of polarised synchrotron emission to be investigated at the angular scales where the CMB polarised signal is expected to peak.
In order to assess the feasibility of CMB polarisation measurements, study the effect of instrumental systematics and devise the data analysis strategy it is necessary to perform simulations of the satellite missions. For these simulations an input sky with all the known components of the emission is necessary. By exploiting existing observations of the microwave sky, we have to strive to construct a simulated sky which represents our best guess of some of the properties of the real sky in the unexplored regions and frequency channels. This will allow us to perform more realistic simulations of the mission and to be in a better position to interpret the real data when these become available.
We use the results of our analysis of the Parkes survey, combined with other data on synchrotron emission coming from total intensity large sky radio surveys, to produce a full-sky synthetic map of synchrotron polarised emission. The paper is organised as follows. In Sect. 2 the global angular power spectra of the Parkes 2.4 GHz polarimetric survey are derived. The simulations performed to assess the reliability of the spectra are presented in Sect. 3. The results are discussed in Sect. 4. In Sect. 5 the derived spectra are used as basis to construct a toy model of the all-sky polarised synchrotron emission.
The Parkes 2.4 GHz survey is a sensitive, polarimetric survey of the
southern Galactic plane carried out by Dancan et al. (1997). The
survey covers 127 of Galactic longitude (
), with a latitude coverage out to at least
5
(up to
b=7
and b=8
over some longitudes). The angular resolution
of the images is 10.4 arcmin. The nominal rms noise of the survey
(for the total and polarised intensities) is 5.3 mK. The survey is publicly
available and the data come split into 6 rectangular
fields sampled at a pixel resolution of 4 arcmin. The linear
polarisation signal is given in terms of the two Stokes parameters Qand U.
The Parkes survey has been recently analysed by
Baccigalupi et al. (2001) and Tucci et al. (2000). In both of these previous
studies, the data were split into twelve square patches, each of size
,
which were then individually analysed.
Our work differs from these in that the
power spectra of the different polarisation components
are derived from a global analysis of the complete
Parkes data.
In order to perform this global statistical analysis of the survey we have resampled the six fields of the original data into HEALPix tessellations. The iso-Latitude property of the HEALPix tessellation of the sphere makes it ideal for fast computation of the angular power spectrum of a field defined on the sphere (Górski et al. 1999). In the HEALPix tessellation the angular size of the pixels is determined by the nside parameter. We used a HEALPix tessellation with nside = 1024 which corresponds to pixels of linear size 3.4 arcmin. When resampling the survey, the pixel value in the HEALPix tessellation was assigned by weighted integration of the values of the original pixels that overlapped with the new pixel, where the weight of each pixel contribution is the fraction of its area intersecting with the new pixel. This approach ensures that no spurious pixel-to-pixel signal correlation is introduced by the resampling.
The three channels of the survey (T, Q and U), resampled into
HEALPix are shown in Fig. 1. The derived intensity
of linear polaristion,
,
is also shown. The
maps are in Galactic coordinates.
![]() |
Figure 1:
The Parkes survey at 2400 MHz. The six fields of the
original data have been resampled into one HEALPix tessellation
with a pixel size of 3.4 arcmin. The first three images (from the
top) give the three Stokes parameters of the signal: T, Q, U,
respectively; the lowest image shows the derived polarised
intensity
![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The most striking difference between the total intensity channel (T) and the polarisation channels (Q, U and L) is that the total intensity signal is dominated by the signal from the Galactic plane while in the polarisation channels the Galactic plane is hardly visible. Moreover many point sources which are clearly visible in the total intensity channel do not exhibit a polarised counterpart.
In the polarised intensity image the most apparent features are the
extended areas of polarisation, with sizes of the order of 5
or
so, which do not appear to be connected with discrete sources of total
power emission. Such regions lie around longitudes 265
,
280
,
320
to 330
and 355
to 5
.
While one of these structures
can be identified with the Vela supernova remnant at l=265
,
the
origin and nature of the other features is not yet explained
(Duncan et al. 1997).
Five regions that are bright in the T maps have been blanked out to prevent a significant fraction of instrumental polarisation from being introduced. These are Sgr A and the bright H II complexes G353.2+0.8, G284.14-0.3, G287.5-0.6 and G291.28-0.71.
The three Stokes parameters T, Q and U fully describe any state
of linearly polarised light. However, whereas the temperature is a
scalar quantity (invariant under rotation of the plane of the sky),
Q and U are not. They depend on the direction of observation
and on the Cartesian axes perpendicular to
used to define
them. Recent theoretical developments have shown that it is more
useful to describe the polarisation field in terms of two quantities
that are invariant under rotation (Zaldarriaga & Seljak 1997;
Kamionkowski 1997). These two quantities are usually called Eand B and they are obtained by a linear, non-local, transformation
of the Q and U map (hereafter we will refer to this transformation
as to the E-B transform). The E and B components differ in their
behavior under parity transformation: B changes sign while E does
not. Four power spectra are needed to characterise the fluctuations
in a Gaussian theory: the autocorrelation of each of T, E and Band the cross correlation between E and T.
Current cosmological models predict the CMB intensity and polarisation
variations to be a Gaussian field and therefore give predictions for
the four power spectra T, E, B and .
Galactic diffuse
emission is not a Gaussian field and so cannot be fully characterised
by the four power spectra, however, since we are interested in
comparing the statistical properties of this emission with predictions
for the CMB power spectra we have derived the four power spectra of
T, E, B and
of the Parkes data.
The power spectra have been obtained by performing a spin-weighted harmonic analysis of the field in the HEALPix grid with the ANAFAST program (the software is part of the HEALPix package). The results of the analysis for the whole set of data are summarised in the following subsections. The angular power spectra of the polarised intensity was derived by simple spherical harmonic decomposition, also using the ANAFAST program.
From the analysis of large sky surveys, the angular power spectra of
the various components of unpolarised Galactic foreground emission
appears to be well described by power law spectra with a spectral
index between 2 and 3. Below, we model the angular power spectra of
the different components of the Parkes data with power-laws of the
form:
The limited sky coverage of the survey and the FWHM resolution of 10.4 arcmin limit our spectral analysis to the multipole range l=40-250. Section 3 describes Monte Carlo simulations that were made to assess the effects of reduced sky coverage and finite resolution.
The angular power spectrum of the T channel of the Parkes survey is
shown in Fig. 2. In the multipole range
l
=40-250 a linear least-squares fit to this spectrum gives:
. In the
figure the angular power spectrum of the intensity of the polarised
signal L is also shown. Linear least-squares fit to this spectrum
gives
.
![]() |
Figure 2:
The global angular power spectra of T and
![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
From the images in Fig. 1 point sources are clearly
identifiable in the map of total emission while they are not
identifiable in the polarised channels.
In order to verify whether point sources or noise at pixel scale is
affecting the spectra derived from the Parkes survey, we median
filtered the intensity map (T) and the derived polarised intensity
map (L) by convolving the data with a kernel of 99
pixels. We have used this technique to derive the angular power
spectrum of diffuse emission from the large sky radio survey of
Jonas et al. (1998). We showed that median filtering can be used to
effectively remove point sources and derive the angular power spectrum
of the diffuse component (Giardino et al. 2001).
The angular power spectrum of a population of point sources randomly
distributed in the sky is Poissonian, that is with constant power at
all l. Therefore, if point sources contribute significantly to the
temperature fluctuation in the field of sky, the power spectrum of
that field is expected to steepen when the point sources are removed
and only the diffuse components remain. The same happens if the signal
is dominated by instrumental random noise. On the other hand if the
signal in the field is dominated by the diffuse component, median
filtering will not have any effects on the spectrum of the emission up
to the multipole order where the high-frequency fluctuations of the
emission are averaged out. We estimated by Monte Carlo simulation
that, for a beam with a FWHM of 10.4 arcmin and a map with pixel size
of 3.4 arcmin, median filtering with a
pixel kernel allows
the input angular power spectrum of a diffuse component (with a
spectral index of
)
to be derived up to l=150 with an
error lower than 3%.
The results of the analysis of the median filtered T and L maps are also shown in Fig. 2.
From the figure it is apparent that the spectrum of the total emission
steepens significantly upon the application of the filtering
process. The fitted spectral index values, in the l range 40-150,
before and after median filtering are respectively
and
(only the formal
fit errors are given in this case
). This indicates that a significant fraction of
the power spectrum at intermediate and high l is due to the presence
of discrete signals: either a population of point sources or
instrumental noise at the pixel scale. In fact instrumental noise at
pixel scale is unlikely as the nominal noise level is well below the
spectrum derived for the total intensity. We therefore interpret the
steepening observed as due to the removal of the point source
contribution.
Figure 2 shows no comparable change in the slope (for
l<150) of the angular power spectrum of the derived L map after
median filtering. The fitted spectral index values before and after
median filter are respectively
and
.
This analysis implies that, up to multipole order l = 150, the fluctuations in the polarised emission are of diffuse nature and they are not due to the presence of discrete signals such us point sources or instrumental noise at pixel scale.
Even though we can exclude contamination of the polarisation spectrum by point sources and instrumental noise at pixel scale only up to multipole l=150, in the following sections we derive the spectral indices for the other components of the Parkes data over the entire multipole range l=40-250 that can be directly probed given the survey's sky coverage and angular resolution. The reader should note from Fig. 2 that the slope of the power spectrum of the unfiltered polarised emission does not obviously change between an l of 150 and 250, and therefore the fits given up to 250 should also be consistent with those made only up to 150. Indeed, we have explicitly established this.
![]() |
Figure 3: The power spectra of the E and B components for the Parkes data. The linear least squares fits to the spectra in the multipole range 40-250 are also shown. |
Open with DEXTER |
The power spectra of the E and B components derived from the
Parkes survey are shown in Fig. 3. In the multipole
range l =40-250 linear least-squares fits to the spectra give
and
respectively for E and B. As can be seen from the figure the
power spectra of the E and B components are very similar in slope
and amplitude. This is expected if the observed emission field does
not show clear patterns or symmetries (Zaldarriaga 2001).
The cross-spectrum of the E and T components is shown in Fig. 4.
In order to assess whether the computed correlation signal corresponds
to null correlation between E and T we performed a series of
simulations. We generated ten random Gaussian polarised fields using
the spectral indices and normalisation derived from the Parkes data to
define the power spectra of T, E and B and setting
to zero. The same sky coverage and beam FWHM of the Parkes
survey were reproduced (see Sect. 3).
The
spectra derived from the ten simulations showed a
standard deviation around 0 of
.
The grey shaded region in
Fig. 4 shows the area within
.
The
comparison of the data points with this area is consistent with the
absence of correlation between E and T. If a level of correlation
between E and T exists, this is below the level that can be probed
with the Parkes data, given the survey's sky coverage and beam FWHM.
The power spectrum derived from E and the
median filtered T is also shown in the figure. The level of
correlation is hardly affected by the filtering process (up to the
multipole order l = 150 where the two spectra are directly
comparable), implying that the lack of correlation between the
T and the E component is not due to the presence of unpolarised
point sources (which only affect the T map).
![]() |
Figure 4:
The cross-correlation
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
In order to quantify the statistical properties of the polarisation
angle variations we constructed the maps of
and
,
where
is the polarisation angle. These
maps are simply given by Q/L and U/L respectively. The sinus and
cosinus maps were then E-B transformed to obtain the rotationally
invariant quantities, e and b. The power spectra of e and bwere also derived by spin-weighted harmonic analysis. The result of the
analysis is shown in Fig. 5.
![]() |
Figure 5:
The power spectrum of the E-B transform of
![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
In the multipole range
l=40-250, the power spectra of e and bare well described by power law spectra with fitted spectral
indices of
and
respectively. These values are very close to the spectral
indices of the power spectra of the E and B components.
The averaged power spectra from the 10 simulations are shown in
Fig. 6. The top panels shows the derived average power
spectra of T and the bottom panels the derived average power spectra of
E and B. The two different cases of sky coverage are shown. The
effect of the incomplete sky coverage is visible in the
spectra in the right panels where the average of the derived spectra
deviates significantly from the input spectra (the true value) for
l < 40. Above multipole order l > 250 the derived power spectra are
affected by the beam cut-off.
![]() |
Figure 6:
The average spectra of T (top) and of E and B (bottom) obtained from the spin-weighted harmonic analysis of 10
different realisations of a polarised Gaussian radiation field
(continuous lines). The dashed lines indicates the input power
spectra for T, E and B. These are power law with spectral
indices
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
In order to quantify the accuracy of the recovery we have computed the
best-fit power law of the spectra obtained from the 10 realisations,
in the two different cases of sky coverage. The spectral indices of
these best-fit power laws can be compared with the true spectral
indices of the power spectra used as inputs for the 10
realisations. The standard deviation of the derived spectral indices
with respect to the true (input) values provides an estimate of the
standard error on the spectral index. The results are summarized in
Table 1. In the case of full sky coverage and
considering the multipole range l = 3-250, one can recover the input
spectral indices of T, E and B with an error of approximately
2% (as can be seen by taking the ratio of the SD over the mean in
three columns of the table). The limited sky coverage of the Parkes
survey implies that one can only fit a power law to the recovered
spectra in the multipole range l = 40-250. By considering the
spectrum in this limited multipole range the error on the recovered
spectral indices increases significantly even when using spectra
derived from full-sky maps (around 5%, as taken from
Table 1). The error is around 10% when
recovering the indices of the T, E and B spectra from maps with
the limited sky coverage of the Parkes survey.
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|||||
l range | Sky coverage | mean | SD | mean | SD | mean | SD |
3-250 | Full | 1.70 | 0.02 | 1.51 | 0.03 | 1.51 | 0.03 |
40-250 | Full | 1.76 | 0.08 | 1.56 | 0.08 | 1.55 | 0.08 |
40-250 | Parkes | 1.78 | 0.15 | 1.57 | 0.12 | 1.55 | 0.12 |
The spectral index of
that we derived from
the Parkes data for the total intensity (T) is significantly lower
than the spectral index values derived from large sky radio survey
(Bouchet & Gispert 1999; Giardino et al. 2001). However this value refers to
the raw data which beside the diffuse emission contains a significant
population of point sources. After point source removal the index
steepens to
.
This value can be compared
with the value of
for the spectral index of the same
region of the sky of the Rhodes/HartRAO survey after point source
removal.
The spectral index of the Rhodes/HartRAO survey steepens with Galactic
latitude from
when all the data are considered to
when only the data at galactic latitude |b| > 20
are taken into account (Giardino et al. 2001). Therefore it is not
surprising that when a region within Galactic latitude |b| =8
is considered the derived spectral index is flatter. The reason for
this is probably a combination of the contributions from
supernovae remnants and from the high concentration of diffuse
H II emission regions in the Galactic plane.
As earlier noted, the Parkes survey was previously analysed by Baccigalupi et al. (2001) and Tucci et al. (2000). Baccigalupi et al. restricted their analysis to the total intensity and the polarised intensity data (L) while Tucci et al. (2000) present results for the power spectra of T, E and B, but not L.
Baccigalupi et al. (2001) obtained an average value of
for the spectral index of the angular power spectrum of the
polarised intensity of the twelve patches in the l-range 100-800.
This value is significantly lower than the value of
that we derived for the multipole range
l=40-250.
However, there are two issues to consider:
Clearly, Baccigalupi et al. derived a flatter spectral index by fitting the spectrum of L in the l-range 100-800 without accounting for the slope break. As to the reason why their analysis did not see evidence for a change in slope of the power spectrum of L, it is likely that by analysing small patches, the derived individual spectra are noisier, thus rendering it more difficult to detect such a change.
Unfortunately, assessing the significance of this flattening is difficult precisely because the analysis for l > 250 is sensitive to assumptions about the noise amplitude and its distribution.
Tucci et al. (2000) derived the average angular power spectra of the Eand B components for the twelve patches and concluded that in the
multipole range
they are both well approximated by
power laws with spectral index
.
This value is very
similar to the values of
and
that we derived for the E and B components
respectively.
The angular power spectrum of e and b, the E-B transform of the
sinus and cosinus of the polarisation angle, were first derived in the
present work. In the multipole range
l=40-250 the power spectra of
the e and b components of the Parkes data are well described by
power laws with fitted spectral indices of
and
.
These values are very close to
the spectral indices derived for the E and B components.
Fluctuations in e and b are only determined by
variations in polarisation angle. Therefore this analysis shows that
fluctuations in the E and B components are mostly determined by
variations in the polarisation angle rather than polarisation intensity,
which, over this multipole range, is characterised by a significantly
steeper power spectrum.
Finally, we did not find evidence of correlation between E and Tin the Parkes data. This lack of correlation can be interpreted as a direct consequence of the fact that fluctuations in the Ecomponents are mostly determined by changes in the polarisation angle, which T remains unaffected by.
Since we are interested in using these results to construct a toy model of the full-sky synchrotron polarisation at high frequencies (30-100 GHz), there are two fundamental questions that we need to ask.
i) What is the effect of Faraday rotation on the Parkes data?
As a result of propagation through an ionized medium, the direction of
linear polarisation is rotated by an angle proportional to the
radiation wavelength:
.
Gaensler et al. (2001) have made high resolution (1 arcmin)
polarimetric observation of a 28
region in the Parkes
field (
,
)
at
1.4 GHz. For this region, they derive a mean RM over the entire
region of
.
This at 2.4 GHz corresponds
to approximately
.
However, the RM values span from 10 to
1000
,
with typical uncertainties in RM measurements
of
.
At a frequency of 2.4 GHz and
resolution of 10.4 arcmin, a linear gradient of 5
in a foreground screen can significantly depolarise
background radiation (Sokoloff et al. 1998) and affect the measured
variation of polarisation angle. Beam depolarisation is also
significant at this frequency and resolution for a level of dispersion
in RM of 30
(e.g. Tribble 1991).
Gaensler et al. (2001) conclude that the brightest polarised features seen in this direction of the Galactic plane most likely represent intrinsic structure in the source of emission, but fainter structures are best explained as being imposed by Faraday rotation on a uniformly polarised background by foreground material.
This is likely to be the case also at 2.4 GHz and implies that a significant fraction of the angular variations which determine the power spectra of E and B for the Parkes data are likely to be induced by Faraday rotation. This scenario would predict that the angular power spectra of E, and B of synchrotron emission derived from the Parkes survey may be flatter than if they were derived from observations at frequencies higher than 10 GHz, where Faraday effects are negligible (Beck 2001).
ii) How representative are the results here derived on the angular power spectrum of linearly polarised emission at low Galactic latitudes of what may happen at high Galactic latitudes?
Duncan et al. (1997) show that over much of the longitude range covered by
the survey, there exists a background polarised component which
appears to be independent of latitude (over the range of latitudes
covered by the survey). Besides the Parkes data, Baccigalupi et al. (2001)
also analysed five 10-patches from the Northern galactic plane
survey by Duncan et al. (1999) at 2.7 GHz and three patches of different
sizes at medium Galactic latitudes (
)
from the survey of Uyaniker et al. (1999) at 1.4 GHz. By
averaging the derived spectral indices for the polarised emission from
all twenty fields they obtain
.
They concluded that synchrotron polarisation maintains
essentially the same statistical properties up to Galactic latitude
.
However, by comparing high Galactic latitude fields with
observations of the Galactic plane at 1.4 GHz Gray et al. (1999) find that
the magneto-ionic medium which induces the Faraday rotation on
polarised emission appears to be concentrated in the disc component
of the Galaxy (
). This would imply that higher
latititude observations of synchrotron polarised emission at low
frequencies and for similar angular resolution may yield steeper
angular power spectra.
Indeed, if there is a variation of the slope with Galactic latitude one may expect this change to be in line with what is observed for the total emission, for which the angular power spectrum steepens with Galactic latitude. Moreover, as pointed out by Davies & Wilkinson (1999), the magnetic field pattern may be more ordered at high Galactic latitudes, resulting in less small-scale structure.
As a starting point for creating a toy model of Galactic synchrotron
polarisation at high frequencies we assume that the polarised
component of synchrotron emission in a given direction is proportional
to the unpolarised intensity, which in this case is expressed in terms
of brightness temperature, T:
The brightness temperature spectrum of synchrotron emission is well
described by a power law,
The 408-MHz survey of Haslam et al. (1982) provides, up to date, the best image of the total intensity of the full-sky Galactic synchrotron emission. At this low frequency the synchrotron emission dominates the Galactic diffuse signal (Beuermann et al. 1985; Lawson et al. 1987). We used the 408-MHz survey processed by D. P. Finkbeiner, M. Davis and D. Schlegel (private communication). They have removed the point sources and de-striped the map by applying a Fourier filtering technique. Hereafter we will refer to this processed version of the 408-MHz survey as to the Cleaned 408-MHz map.
The angular resolution of the 408-MHz survey is 0.85.
The
angular resolution of Planck will vary from the 33 arcmin FWHM in the
30 GHz channel to 5 arcmin FWHM in the 857 GHz channel. Since it is
conservative to assume that synchrotron emission will present
structure also at the smaller angular scale, we have superimposed
artificial fluctuations at angular scale
on the original
map.
The map of artificial fluctuations was obtained from a full-sky
realisation of a Gaussian field having a power law spectrum with index
for l > 150 and vanishing to zero for l<150. Before
being added onto the Cleaned 408 MHz
the fluctuation map is weighted by the Cleaned
408 MHz map itself
. This operation can be viewed
as an extrapolation of the spectrum of the Cleaned 408 MHz map beyond
l=150 with a power law spectrum with index
.
A power law
spectrum with spectral index
is similar to that derived
for the total synchrotron emission at high galactic latitude
(|b|>20
)
from the analysis of the three large sky radio survey
up to
(Bouchet & Gispert 1999; Giardino et al. 2001).
The Cleaned 408 MHz map with extrapolated fluctuations provides us
with a realistic image of the full-sky total intensity of synchrotron
emission at 408 MHz up to the degree angular scale and an estimate of
how this emission may look like at the smaller unobserved angular
scales. We use this map as the template for the Stokes T channel
of the synthetic polarisation maps. The template at 408 MHz is shown
in Fig. 7.
![]() |
Figure 7: Mollweide projection of the Cleaned 408 MHz map with extrapolated fluctuations (i.e. the template for the Stokes parameter T of the synthetic polarisation maps). The map is in Galactic coordinates. The color scale has been histogram equalised. |
Open with DEXTER |
Besides the 408-MHz survey the other two high quality, large sky radio
surveys available to date are: the northern sky survey of
Reich & Reich (1986) at 1420 MHz and the more recent southern sky survey of
Jonas et al. (1998). The sky coverage of the 1420-MHz survey and of the
2326-MHz survey are complementary to each other. The two surveys
overlap over the Galactic declination range
in the right ascension interval
and over Galactic declination range
in the right ascension interval
.
Therefore we can combine the 408-MHz survey and the
1420-MHz survey in order to derive a map of the spectral index of
radio emission in the northern sky and the 408 MHz and the 2326 MHz
survey in order to derive a map of the spectral index in the southern
hemisphere. We obtained three homogeneous maps in the following way:
we took the surveys, as they are publicly available, resampled them
into a HEALPix tessellation with nside = 256 and then median
filtered with a box kernel of
pixels in order to suppress
the point source signal.
As we wish to determine the spectral index of the Galactic emission
only, the extragalactic emission must first be subtracted. This is
made up of two isotropic components, the CMB and the sum of unresolved
extragalactic background. The CMB brightness temperature is
2.73 K. A phenomenological expression to estimate the integrated
brightness temperature of extra galactic unresolved radio sources at
different frequencies is given by Lawson et al. (1987). Lawson uses it to
estimate this contribution in the 408 MHz and in the 1420 MHz
surveys. We have adopted it to evaluate this contribution at 2326 MHz. The total amount of extragalactic contribution for the three
surveys together with basic information about their uncertainties is
summarised in Table 2. For the 1420 MHz
survey we adopted a baseline correction of -0.13 K (Lawson et al. 1987).
Survey | Scale | Base level | Extragalactic | Baseline | Reference |
Frequency (MHz) | error (per cent) | error (K) | background (K) | correction (K) | |
408 | 5 | 3 | 5.92 | - | Lawson et al. (1987) |
1420 | 10 | 0.6 | 2.83 | -0.13 | Lawson et al. (1987) |
2326 | 5 | 0.080 | 2.75 | - | Jonas et al. (1998) |
After subtraction of the extragalactic contribution, the brightness
temperature frequency spectral index
of the
Galactic radiation can be calculated. It is simply given by:
All the surveys are affected by scan-to-scan baseline errors. When the
ratio of brightness temperatures at two different frequencies is
calculated the effect of these residual errors is enhanced. Because
of this, the map of
and the map of
do not match in the overlapping region. We tried
various techniques to look for a baseline offset for one of the three
input maps that would minimise the differences between the two
spectral index maps. However discontinuities between the two spectral
index maps always remained apparent.
In order to construct the full-sky map of the spectral index,
therefore, we used
for regions of the sky at
declination
and
for regions at
declination
.
In the overlapping region of the 1420
and 2326-MHz surveys (
)
we set
the spectral index to:
The spectral index map obtained in this way is however still affected
by the striation due to the scan-to-scan baseline errors in the input
data. It is possible to remove the effect by Fourier filtering the
data but, because the scanning direction differs from one survey to
the other, one would not then be able to combine like with
like. Following Lawson et al. (1987) we adopted the simpler procedure of
convolving the data to a lower resolution, so that the baseline errors
are averaged sufficiently for the striation on the color-scale to
disappear. The final map of the spectral index is at a resolution of
10
(at FWHM), as shown in Fig. 8.
![]() |
Figure 8: Mollweide projection of the full-sky map of radio spectral index obtained by combining the 408-MHz survey, the 1420-MHz survey and the 2326-MHz survey (see text). The map is in Galactic coordinates. |
Open with DEXTER |
We found that the power spectra of the E-B transform of the sinus and
cosinus of the polarisation angle of the Parkes data are described by
power laws with spectral indices of
and
in the multipole range
l=40-250. One can
construct a full-sky map of a random angle having E-B transform of
its sinus and cosinus with the same spectra of the e and bcomponent of the Parkes data in the following way. Generate two
full-sky realisations of a Gaussian field characterised by a power law
spectrum with spectral index
.
Let us call these maps xand y. Normalise x and y to the interval [-1, 1]. Generate the
full-sky map of the random angle by computing
,
where
.
We used the
random angle map obtained in this way as the
polarisation angle of our toy model of Galactic synchrotron emission.
Figure 9 shows the map of the polarisation angle derived
from the Parkes data and the map of the synthetic polarisation
angle for the same region of sky. The structure of the angle
fluctuations in the two maps looks similar.
![]() |
Figure 9: Polarisation angle from the Parkes survey (top) and from the synthetic map of synchrotron polarisation (bottom). Maps are in Galactic coordinates. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 10: The Q and U channel of the synthetic map of Galactic synchrotron linear polarisation at 30 GHz. The map is in Galactic coordinates. |
Open with DEXTER |
In order to generate the synthetic maps of synchrotron emission
and linear polarisation at higher frequencies the total intensity map
at 408 MHz has to be extrapolated. One can use the spectral index
map directly, assuming a fixed power law to higher frequencies, or use
it in conjunction with the local electron spectrum, as in
Bennett et al. (1992), in order to derive maps of
between any two
given frequencies and to attempt to allow for the observed steepening of
with increasing frequency (Lawson et al. 1987; Banday & Wolfendale 1990).
For the local electron spectrum, we used the polynomial fit to the
spectral shape of electron measurements given in Bennett et al. (1992),
for energies
,
and likewise a power law
for E > 100 GeV. By interpreting the spatial
variation in
(408-1420 MHz and 408-2326 MHz) as due solely to
variations in a synchrotron effective Galactic magnetic field,
,
we derived a full-sky map
of
,
with
G and a median value of 1.4
G. This is remarkably close
to the values derived by Bennett et al. (1992) who did not have the data
from the 2326-MHz survey for the southern hemisphere.
The same expression for the local electron spectrum and the map of
synchrotron effective Galactic magnetic field were then used to obtain
the maps of the spectral index between 408 MHz and 30 and 100 GHz,
necessary for extrapolating the total emission map. The
maps mean values are
and
.
The
value of
is consistent with the
upper limit of
between 408 MHz and 31.5 GHz obtained by
Kogut et al. (1996) and the value of
between 1420 MHz and
19 GHz derived by de Oliveira-Costa et al. (1998).
The Q and U channels of the synthetic linear polarisation maps of Galactic synchrotron emission at 30 and 100 GHz were then obtained by combining the intensity map (T) extrapolated at 30 and 100 GHz with the corresponding spectral index map and the random angle map, according to Eqs. (1) and (3). The Q and Uchannels at 30 GHz are shown in Fig. 10. The three input maps are sampled into a HEALPix tessellation with a pixel size of 6.9 arcmin (nside=512). Therefore also the synthetic maps of T, Q and U are at a pixel resolution of 6.9 arcmin.
Because our toy model for f is a very slowly varying function of the
position in the sky the maps of Q and U derived according to
Eq. (1) have temperature fluctuations mostly determined by the
polarisation angle. Therefore, like for the Parkes data, the angular
power spectra of the E and B components of the synthetic linear
polarisation maps reflect the spectra of e and b. They are
power-law spectra with indices
and
over the l range 40-250 (
and
for the lrange 3-250, that can be probed since in this case the power spectra
are derived from full sky maps). These values are very close to the
values derived for the spectra of the E and B components of the
Parkes data.
For CMB studies one is particularly interested in the properties of
radio emission at high Galactic latitudes because this is where the
Galactic signal is weaker and where sensitive CMB measurements can be
made. Therefore, we computed the angular power spectra of the T, Eand B components of the extrapolated maps with a Galactic plane
cut-off at latitude |b|=20.
The results are shown in
Fig. 11, where they can be compared with the signal
expected from the CMB. The CMB spectrum has been computed assuming a
flat inflationary model with purely scalar scale-invariant
fluctuations, vacuum energy
,
cold dark
matter density
and baryon density
,
(where h = 0.7 is the assumed Hubble
parameter), as derived by Netterfield et al. (2001) from combining the
latest CMB observations with constraints derived from measurements of
the large scale structure and results from recent measurements of type
Ia supernovae.
The top panel of Fig. 11 shows the angular power spectra
of the T components of the two extrapolated maps and of the CMB. Note
the absence of a perceivable change in the slope of the power spectra of the
T components of the synthetic maps at l=150, the multipole order
at which artificial signal was added to the observed signal at 408 MHz.
From the figure, it is apparent that at 100 GHz the contribution to
the total sky signal from high latitude synchrotron emission is
negligible. At 30 GHz synchrotron emission can be a significant
contribution to the sky anisotropy at scales larger than
,
but it is more than an order of magnitude weaker than the
computed cosmological signal at degree angular scales where the first
"acoustic'' peak of the CMB is observed. This confirms the results
discussed in Giardino et al. (2001) that were obtained with a different
approach using the index of the angular power spectra of the survey at
2326 MHz by Jonas et al. (1998) and the COBE DMR upper limit to
synchrotron temperature fluctuations at 31.5 GHz at the 7
scale. The COBE DMR upper limit (Kogut et al. 1996) is indicated in the
figure by a pentagonal point.
The angular power spectra of the E and B components of the synthetic maps are shown in the lower panel of Fig. 11. At small angular scale the power of temperature fluctuations in the E and B components are mostly determined by change in the polarisation angle rather than a change in the degree of polarisation. This is the reason why temperature fluctuations in the E and B components can become more intense than temperature fluctuations in the T channel.
The figure shows that at 30 GHz the high latitude synchrotron signal
may dominate the cosmological polarised signal over the entire
multipole range. The extrapolated signal at 30 GHz is consistent with
the current upper limit on linearly polarised signal of 10 K at
the 7
scale in the 26-36 GHz band (Keating et al. 2001) and with
the upper limit of 16
K at degree scale in the 26-46 GHz band
(Netterfield et al. 1995). These upper limits also refer to regions of
the sky at galactic latitudes
.
At 100 GHz the synchrotron signal can make a significant contribution to the sky polarisation at large angular scale but it is significantly weaker than the CMB E component at sub-degree angular scale. Therefore even using the most conservative assumptions one can conclude that the contribution of synchrotron polarisation to the sky signal will not hinder detection of the CMB E component, if this is present at sub-degree angular scale at the intensity predicted by current cosmological models.
From the diagram the absence of the beam cut off in the spectra of the
synthetic maps is noticeable. These are artificial maps and therefore
they were generated at full resolution.
![]() |
Figure 11:
The power spectra of the T, E and B components of the
synthetic maps of Galactic synchrotron polarisation at 30 and 100 GHz
(dashed lines), for |b|>20![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
To study the effects of polarised foreground on MAP observations of
the CMB, synthetic maps of polarised synchrotron emission have been
generated by Kogut & Hinshaw (2000). They also assumed the polarised signal
to be proportional to the total intensity T, with the Stokes Q and
U components given by Eq. (2). For the polarisation degree, f, they
assumed a varying Gaussian field such that
.
They constructed the polarisation angle starting from Gaussian random
fields, x and y, with flat power spectra
, which lead to E and B components whose spectra have
indices of
.
The polarisation maps were only
generated for a fiducial frequency of 40 GHz.
We have constructed the synthetic maps by combining in a conservative way many of the observational data currently available on synchrotron total emission and polarisation. The maps that can be obtained at higher frequencies by extrapolating the total intensity map with the spectral index map are consistent with available observational upper limits on synchrotron emission and polarisation at frequencies higher than 10 GHz. There remain however some inconsistencies between the synthetic polarisation maps extrapolated at 2.4 GHz and the Parkes data.
The synthetic polarisation maps reproduce the slope of the angular
power spectra of the E and B components of the Parkes survey, but
not their amplitude at 2.4 GHz. Moreover, the power spectra of T,
and L differ both in shape and normalisation to the ones
of the Parkes data. This is because of the way that the toy model has
been constructed. We derived information on the polarisation angle
(and the E and B power spectra) from the Parkes survey, while for
the intensity channel T we used the data from the Haslam survey and
for the polarisation fraction f we assumed the theoretical value
given by the synchrotron spectral index in a uniform
magnetic field. The reasons behind these choices are the following.
As already mentioned, the Haslam map provides the best image of the total intensity of the full-sky synchrotron emission, to date. It is natural to adopt it as a template for T as opposed to using the Tchannel of the Parkes survey. This is limited in sky coverage and being at low Galactic latitude and a higher frequency contains a higher fraction of thermal emission from ionised gas.
The Parkes survey provides us with information about the statistical
properties of the polarisation angle, so we adopt it for this
purpose. Using the statistical properties of the polarisation angle
derived from a survey at decimetric frequency is a conservative
approach (i.e. it will unlikely lead to an underestimate of the level
of fluctuation of polarised synchrotron emission). This is because
Faraday rotation of a synchrotron background due to a foreground
"screen'' of ionised medium will tend to increase the level of
fluctuations in the observed polarisation direction. On the other
hand Faraday differential rotation may decrease the polarised fraction
of the synchrotron signal at the Parkes frequency. Therefore using the
amplitude of the E and B components of the Parkes data may lead to
an underestimate of the polarisation fraction at higher frequencies
(10 GHz).
Calculating the theoretical fraction of synchrotron polarisation by
assuming a completely uniform magnetic fields could be considered an
overly conservative approach because it is known that the interstellar
medium is pervaded by an isotropic random ("turbulent'') field. In
the presence of a random magnetic field the observed level of
polarisation is given by
.
Here f is the
intrinsic level of polarisation (given by Eq. (3)) and
d is a coefficient (
1) which depends on the relative intensity
of the random field,
,
and the field which is regular in
the whole resolution element,
(Burn 1966; Beck 1998).
Synchrotron polarisation observations at decimeter wavelength imply a
ratio of regular to total field strengths within about a kpc from the
Sun of
(Beck 2001),
which, in the popular assumption of energy equipartition between cosmic rays
and magnetic fields would imply an average level of depolarisation of
.
However the actual value varies
substantially between points and may depend on the size of the
resolution element. These values are derived from decimeter wavelength
surveys with degree-scale resolution. The level of depolarisation by
the random component of the magnetic field can be expected to decrease
as the sky is observed at higher resolution and the projected size of
the beam approaches the field coherence length. Indeed convolution of
our synthetic maps with a Gaussian beam with a FWHM of 1
yields
an average level of depolarisation of
.
In order to obtain information about the statistical properties of
synchrotron polarised emission, we have derived the global angular
power spectra of the Parkes survey, a radio continuum and polarisation
survey of the Southern galactic plane at 2.4 GHz. The angular power
spectrum of the polarised intensity (L) is well approximated by a
power law with fitted spectral index
in the
multipole range l=40-250 that can be probed given the Parkes survey
sky coverage and angular resolution. We exclude that up to multipole
order l = 150, the spectral index value is affected by the presence
of discrete signals such us point sources or instrumental noise at
pixel scale.
The angular power spectra of the E and B components of the
polarised emission is significantly flatter than the spectrum of
L. They have fitted spectral indices respectively of
and
,
in the multipole range
l=40-250. This is because temperature variations in the Stokes
channels Q and U of the data are mostly determined by variation in
polarisation angle rather than polarisation intensity. The E-Btransform of the sinus and cosinus of the polarisation angle, the eand b components, are in fact also well described by power laws with
fitted spectral indices of
and
,
in the same multipole range
l=40-250.
We generated a full-sky map of a random polarisation angle having eand b components with power spectra with the same spectral indices of the e and b components of the Parkes data. We combined this map with a template of synchrotron emission at 408 MHz, derived from the 408-MHz survey, and with a full-sky spectral index map, that we obtained by combining the 408-MHz survey with the 1420-MHz survey and the 2326-MHz survey. The simple recipe on how to combine the three maps in order to derive a map of linear polarisation is given by Eq. (1) and Eq. (3).
In this way we have constructed synthetic maps of the Stokes parameters (T, Q and U) of Galactic synchrotron emission at 30 and 100 GHz. The angular power spectra of the E and Bcomponents of these synthetic maps have slope very similar to the Eand B components of the Parkes data. Their polarisation intensity is proportional to the total intensity T as determined by the frequency spectral index in the conservative hypothesis of a uniform magnetic field.
We have compared the angular power spactra of the synthetic maps with predictions for the CMB and conclude that while direct observations of the CMB E component at 30 GHz may be precluded by synchrotron polarisation, at 100 GHz, this component of Galactic emission will not hinder the observation of cosmological polarisation, if this is present at the predicted levels.
The synthetic maps of the linear polarisation of Galactic synchrotron can be useful as a toy model to study the effect of the polarised foreground on planned observations of the CMB. Moreover they can serve as the basis for the development of more advanced models which incorporate data on the structure of the Galactic magnetic field. In turn these refined models will be of fundamental importance in interpreting the microwave polarisation data that will be provided by the Planck and MAP satellite missions and the SPORT experiment.
The synthetic maps of the Stokes parameters T, Q and U of Galactic synchrotron emission at 30 and 100 GHz together with the full-sky spectral index map are available for down loading at ftp://astro.esa.int/pub/synchrotron.
Acknowledgements
We thank D. P. Finkbeiner, M. Davis and D. Schlegel for providing us with the Cleaned 408 MHz map, E. Hivon for helpful discussions, A. R. Duncan, R. F. Haynes, K. L. Jones and R. T. Stewart for making the Parkes survey publicly available and U. Seljak & M. Zaldarriaga for their CMBFAST software, which was used to generate the CMB angular power spectra. The HEALPix analysis package (http://www.eso.org/science/healpix) was used extensively throughout this paper. We gratefully acknowledge very useful comments from an anonymous referee.