A&A 383, 338-351 (2002)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20011713
E. Griv1 - M. Gedalin1 - C. Yuan2
1 - Department of Physics, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev,
PO Box 653, Beer-Sheva 84105, Israel
2 -
Academia Sinica Institute of Astronomy and Astrophysics
(ASIAA), PO Box 23, Taipei 106, Taiwan
Received 4 September 2001 / Accepted 29 November 2001
Abstract
We analyse the reaction between almost aperiodically growing
Jeans-unstable gravity perturbations and stars of a rotating and
spatially inhomogeneous disk of flat galaxies. A mathematical formalism
in the approximation of weak turbulence (a quasi-linearization of the
Boltzmann collisionless kinetic equation) is developed.
A diffusion equation in configuration
space is derived which describes the change in the main body of equilibrium
distribution of stars. The distortion in phase space resulting from such a
wave-star interaction is studied.
The theory, applied to the Solar neighborhood, accounts for the observed
Schwarzschild shape of the velocity ellipsoid, the increase in the random
stellar velocities with age, and the essential radial migration of the Sun
from its birth-place in the inner part of the Galaxy outwards during its
lifetime.
Key words: galaxies: kinematics and dynamics - galaxies: structure - waves - instabilities
The theory of spiral structure of rotationally supported galaxies has a long history, but, as we emphasize below, is not yet complete. Even though no definitive answer can be given at the present time, the majority of experts in the field is yielded to opinion that the study of the stability of collective vibrations in disk galaxies of stars is the first step towards an understanding of the phenomenon. This is because the bulk of the total optical mass in the Milky Way and other flat galaxies is in stars. Recent measurements of the local dynamical density by Hipparcos rule out any disk-shaped dark matter (Crézé et al. 1998). Hipparcos data indicate a moderate contribution of unseen matter to the local potential (Haywood et al. 1997). In addition, spiral arms are smoother in images of galaxies in the near IR (Rix & Zaritsky 1995) indicating that the old disk stars participate in the pattern. Therefore, the spiral structures are intimately connected with the stellar constituent of a galaxy. We regard spiral structure in most flattened galaxies of stars as a wave pattern, which does not remain stationary in a frame of reference rotating around the center of the galaxy at a proper speed, excited as a result of the Jeans instability of gravity perturbations (those produced by a bar or oval structure in a galactic center, a spontaneous spiral perturbation, and/or a companion galaxy). It is our purpose to extend the investigation by studying the nonlinear effects. The problem is formulated in the same way as in plasma kinetic theory.
In the Solar neighborhood the random velocity distribution
function of stars with an age
yr
is close to a Schwarzschild distribution - a set of Gaussian
distributions along each coordinate in velocity space, i.e.,
close to equilibrium along each coordinate
(Binney & Tremaine 1987; Gilmore et al. 1990).
In addition, older stellar populations have a higher
velocity dispersion than younger ones (Mayor 1974; Wielen 1977;
Strömgren 1987; Meusinger
et al. 1991; Fuchs et al. 1994; Dehnen & Binney 1999). High-quality
Hipparcos data for a complete sample of nearly
main-sequence
and subgiant stars
show that the velocity dispersion of a coeval group
is found to increase with time (Binney et al. 2000). The latter
means that an unknown mechanism increases the velocity dispersion
of stars in the Galaxy's disk after they are born. It is argued
that the increase in velocity dispersion
(and the diffusion of stellar orbits in coordinate space)
with time is predominantly a gradual process.
Grivnev & Fridman (1990) have shown,
by using the observed stellar velocities, that the random
velocity distribution of youngest stars is close to a
-like one. As the
age of stars of spectral types B5-A9 increases from
yr to
yr, the distribution
functions of the residual velocities of stars along each
coordinate in the momentum space approach a normal distribution.
On the other hand, a simple calculation
of the relaxation time of the local disk of the Galaxy due
to pairwise star-star encounters brings the value
1014 yr (Chandrasekhar 1960;
Binney & Tremaine 1987, p. 187), which considerably
exceeds the lifetime of the universe.
Thus, observations indicate that the local disk is well relaxed,
so some form of scattering process is going on most likely in the
form of collisionless processes.
During the years several mechanisms have been proposed
to explain the growth of the velocity dispersion: encounters
of stars with massive gaseous clouds (Spitzer & Schwarzschild
1951, 1953), heating of the galactic disk by
transient spiral waves (Barbanis & Woltjer 1967), a
systematic increase in the velocity dispersion of protostellar
gas clouds as the region of space increases (Larson 1979;
Myers 1983), heating by proposed black holes in the Galactic
dark halo (Lacey & Ostriker 1985) or by dwarf galaxies
(Quinn & Goodman 1986). To date,
a convincing mechanism to explain the observed amount of the
disk heating has not been found. For instance,
it is difficult to explain the observed relaxation
by the usual binary encouters between stars and
giant molecular clouds. This is because Binney & Lacey
(1988) have shown that binary encounters with giant clouds of
an interstellar medium result in a stellar velocity dispersion
which will increase with age as t1/4, instead of the
observed roughly
law (Wielen 1977).
Also, if only giant molecular clouds are responsible for heating
the ratio of the vertical-to-radial velocity dispersion
will approach 0.75 and, if spiral structure
also contributes to the disk heating the ratio will be lower.
The most accurate measurements using the Hipparcos data indicate
a ratio
of
(Dehnen & Binney 1999). This
behaviour is again consistent with the predictions of disk-heating
by spiral structure. Scattering by giant molecular clouds plays
only a modest role (Binney & Tremaine 1987, p. 470; Gilmore et al. 1990, p. 174; Binney 2001)
.
In this paper a statistical mechanism of smoothing out stellar plane velocities, necessary to make them agree with a Schwarzschild distribution is suggested. This mechanism explains the observable increase in stellar velocity dispersion with age. In our approach, collisionless relaxation by virtue of interaction between Jeans-unstable density waves and stars does play a determining role in the evolution of stellar populations of the Galactic disk. In this regard, recent data from the Hipparcos satellite already made it clear that the Galaxy is by no means in a steady state (Dehnen & Binney 1999; Binney 2001). There are preliminary indications that we see in the local phase-space distribution the dynamical footprints of long-dissolved unstable waves.
The classical Jeans instability of gravity disturbances is one of the most frequent and most important instabilities in the stellar and in the planetary cosmogony, and galactic dynamics. The instability is driven by a strong interaction of the gravity fluctuations with the bulk of the particle population, and the dynamics of Jeans perturbations can be characterized as a fluidlike interaction. The gravitational Jeans-type instability does not depend on the behavior of the particle distribution function in the neighborhood of a particular speed, but the determining factors of the instability are macroscopic parameters like the random velocity spread, mean density, and angular velocity of regular rotation. The Jeans instability associated with departures of macroscopic quantities from the thermodynamic equilibrium is hydrodynamical in nature and has nothing to do with any explicit resonant effects; a relatively simple hydrodynamical model can be used to investigate the instability (Lovelace & Hohlfeld 1978; Lin & Lau 1979; Drury 1980).
The criterion for a rotationally flattened stellar disk to be
Jeans-unstable to substructure formation by self-gravitation is that
Toomre's (1964) stability parameter Q be less than
-2.5 (see Sect. 3.3 below). Here Toomre's Q-value,
,
is a measure of the ratio of thermal and rotational
stabilization to self-gravitation,
is the radial dispersion of
residual (random) velocities of stars,
is the Toomre (Toomre 1964; see also Safronov 1960)
critical velocity dispersion,
is the local projected surface density of stars, and
is the local epicyclic frequency. Combined with the Lin-Shu type
dispersion relation for density waves, this is a venerable suggestion
as to why disk galaxies almost always exhibit spiral structure.
The reaction of the distribution function of stars to the
Jeans-unstable field fluctuations is such that the random velocity
dispersion (or "temperature'') increases until the difference
,
and the system tends toward marginal
stability. Hence, in differentially rotating galaxies, once the entire
disk has been heated to values
,
no
further spiral waves can be sustained by virtue of the Jeans
instability - unless some "cooling'' mechanism is available leading
to Toomre's Q-value, under approximately 2. By using N-body
simulations, first Miller et al. (1970), Hohl (1971), and then Sellwood
& Carlberg (1984), Tomley et al. (1991), and
Griv & Chiueh (1998) have shown that the process of formation
of fresh particles, which move on nearly circular orbits,
plays a vital role in prolonging spiral activity in the plane of
the disk by reducing the random velocity dispersion of the entire
stellar component. Also, in good conformity with observations
(van der Kruit & Freeman 1986;
Bottema 1993) and the theory outlined above, both
N-body simulations (Sellwood & Carlberg 1984; Tomley et al. 1991) and
numerical solutions of the collisionless Boltzmann equation (Nishida et al. 1984) showed that the stability number Q of Toomre in relaxed
equilibrium disks does not fall below a critical value, which lies about
2-2.5. Liverts et al. (2000) used computer simulations to test the
validity of the modified stability criterion
.
The investigations carried out in the linear approximation allow us to determine only the spectrum of the excited oscillations and their growth rates during the first stages of the excitation. Arbitrary perturbations can be expressed as a superposition of eigenmodes, with each eigenmode evolving independently. Other problems, which can be treated within the framework of nonlinear theory, are account of the reaction of the oscillations on the equilibrium parameters of the system and the determination of the amplitude of the oscillations that are produced. The quasi-linear approach to nonlinear plasma theory is usually referred to as the theory of weak turbulence, i.e., the case when the dynamics of the system can be described in the language of weakly interacting linear waves. That is, there are many random collective oscillations present in the system and it is permissible to treat the phases of these oscillations as being random in some sense. It can be justified if the energy in the excited spectrum is small compared with the total mechanical energy in particles but large compared to thermal noise. The theory of strong turbulence is still far from complete.
As applied to the fluidlike Jeans instabilities connected with a
"thermodynamic nonuniformity'' of the stellar disk (the system is
not sufficiently "hot'' in the equatorial plane), the nonlinear
effects appear in the following fashion. The velocity dispersion
of a young stellar population is small, and their
space and velocity distribution are not completely relaxed.
As the result of the reaction of the oscillations, the
velocity dispersion of the main part of the distribution
function of young stars would be expected to increase in the field
of unstable waves with an amplitude increasing with time. Because
the Jeans instability is characterized by the critical value of
velocity dispersion
,
the
rise in temperature in turn leads to a decrease in the growth rate of
the wave amplitude. Eventually, as a result of such "heating'', the
Jeans instability will be switched off and finally the spiral cannot
be maintained (Binney & Tremaine 1987, p. 479). This process
of the self-suppression of instability by the growing wave amplitude
is reminiscent of the nonresonant relaxation in a plasma, which can
effectively heat the medium even in the absence of collisions between
particles (Alexandrov et al. 1984, p. 420; Krall & Trivelpiece 1986,
p. 520). Apparently, Toomre (1964, p. 1237) first advanced the idea that
the stars in the galactic disk would tend to develop random motion from
the gravitational energy via this tendency toward gravitational
instability. In addition, the nonlinear relaxation causes the diffusion
of stars in coordinate space, that is, mass re-distribution. Romeo (1990)
already discussed the role played by instabilities in the disk's secular
evolution. The collective relaxation of stars may be done by
their interaction with the gravitational field of unstable waves, solely.
In interaction with standing waves, with the exception of spatially
small resonant regions, there is no energy exchange in the wave-star
system (Binney & Tremaine 1987, p. 482).
At the qualitative level, Goldreich & Lynden-Bell (1965) and Marochnik (1968) have suggested instabilities as a cause of enhanced relaxation in galaxies. Lynden-Bell (1967) and later Shu (1978) considered the problem of the collisionless relaxation in a vigorously nonstationary process of formation of the equilibrium state. A very nonequilibrium initially configuration was studied (the virial theorem is strongly violated). Kulsrud (1972) also discussed the inverse effects of different instabilities of gravity oscillations on the averaged velocity distribution function of stars by collective interaction. It was stated that, because of its long-range Newtonian forces, a self-gravitating medium (a stellar "gas'', say) would possess collective motions in which all the particles of the system participate. These properties would be manifested in the behavior of small gravity perturbations arising against the equilibrium background. Collective processes are completely analogous to two-body collisions, except that one particle collides not with another one but with many which are collected together by some coherent process such as a wave. The collective processes are random, and usually much stronger than the ordinary two-body collisions and leads to a random walk of the particles that takes the complete system toward thermal quasi-steady state. Thus, relaxation in stellar systems could occur without binary star-star enconters through the influence of collective motions of the stellar gas upon the particle distribution.
Barbanis & Woltjer (1967) studied almost circular orbits of stars of a rotating galaxy in the gravitational field of spiral arms on the basis of both epicyclic theory (see also Binney & Tremaine 1987, p. 478) and numerical integration of the equations of motion. Lynden-Bell & Kalnajs (1972) treated the resonant regions separately. Carlberg & Sellwood (1985) re-derived Dekker's (1975) basic equation governing the response of a rotating stellar disk to any transient-perturbing potential, and then calculated numerically the resonant response to a model slowly-varying wave in the vanishing growth rate limit. Binney & Lacey (1988), Jenkins & Binney (1990), and Jenkins (1992) developed a formalism to describe a heating of the local disk due to gravitational scattering by an imposed weak, time-varying perturbing potential. They showed that such a heating process could be described by a diffusion equation in action space and solved the diffusion equation by Monte Carlo simulation for cloud and spiral wave scatterers. Although all of these studies showed that the disk perturbations affect the dynamical evolution significantly, they focused mainly on a test particle responce to a given field of waves having adopted the model form for spiral perturbation and assumptions as to the typical wavelength, etc. of the spiral waves (Carlberg & Sellwood 1985, p. 81; Jenkins 1992, p. 623). The exact velocity dependence of the velocity diffusion tensor, and the resultant evolution in velocity space, were not completely pinned down.
We present a self-consistent quasi-linear theory of dynamical relaxation of two-dimensional self-gravitating, rotating stellar disks toward a thermal quasi-steady state via collective effects. In the process a star "collides'' with almost aperiodically growing inhomogeneities of a galactic gravitational field which result from the development of the fierce Jeans instability. The dominant interactions, which change the velocities and orbits of stars, are those with transient, rapidly-varying gravity perturbations. We find that the theory successfully accounts for several basic observations of the Galaxy, given that the growth rate of the perturbations is comparable to the epicyclic period of stars. In particular, we find that the off-resonant character of the interaction leads to a velocity diffusion tensor that is independent of velocity, and leads to an anisotropic Maxwellian distribution whose velocity dispersion grows with time. Nonlinear effects near resonances in a Jeans-stable system deserve separate research (e.g., Rauch & Tremaine 1996). To emphasize it again, unlike Carlberg & Sellwood (1985), Binney & Jenkins (1988), and Jenkins & Binney (1990) we solve a self-consistent Boltzmann-Poisson system of equations. The relaxation mechanism suggested in the present paper has an essential dependence on the equilibrium of the disk matter, and it has nothing to do with Lynden-Bell's violent relaxation. Brief first reports have been published by Griv et al. (1994) and Griv et al. (2001).
A thin rotating disk is taken as a model of the flat galaxy in
many papers for analysis of the gravity perturbations. This is because
stars of the nonrotating spherical-like subsystem, if it
exists at all, which have large random velocities, will make a relatively
small contribution to the wave field (Marochnik & Suchkov 1969). In the
spirit of Griv & Peter (1996a), we solve the system of the collisionless
Boltzmann equation and the Poisson equation describing the motion of a
self-gravitating ensemble of stars in such a system within an accuracy
of up two orders of magnitude with respect to small parameters
and
for radial wavenumber
,
radius r,
and angular velocity
,
looking
for waves which propagate in a two-dimensional galactic disk.
This approximation of an infinitesimally thin disk is a valid
approximation if one considers perturbations with a radial wavelength
that is greater h, the typical disk thickness.
In actual spiral galaxies for a subsystem of young, low-dispersion
stars,
pc. The dimensionless
parameters
and
are small,
and in addition
.
The fact is took into account that because of the nature of the
gravitational force, disks of spiral galaxies are always spatially
inhomogeneous and are far from uniform rotation.
We assume that the stars move in the disk plane so that vz=0.
This allows us to use the two-dimensional distribution function
such that
,
,
and
,
where
is the surface density.
In the rotating frame of a disk galaxy, the local distribution
function of stars
must satisfy the
collisionless Boltzmann equation (Lin et al. 1969)
As the equilibrium state an axisymmetric, weakly inhomogeneous in the
radial direction stellar disk is adopted. The system in the equlibrium
is described by the equation:
In the quasi-linear theory, one may follow the procedure
of linearization by writing
and
with
and
for all
and t. The functions f1 and
are functions oscillating rapidly in space and time, while
the functions f0 and
describe the slowly developing
"background'' against which small perturbations develop;
and
.
Linearizing Eq. (1) and separating fast and slow
varying variables one obtains the equation for the fast developing
distribution function
Making use of expressions for the unperturbed epicyclic trajectories
of stars in the equilibrium central field
,
The partial derivatives in
Eqs. (3) and (4) transform as
follows (Shu 1970; Morozov 1980; Griv & Peter 1996a):
![]() |
(8) |
To determine oscillation spectra, let us consider the
stability problem in the lowest (or local) WKB approximation;
this is accurate for short wave perturbations only, but
qualitatively correct even for perturbations with a longer
wavelength, of the order of the disk radius R.
In galaxies,
kpc. In the local WKB approximation
in Eqs. (3) and (4), assuming
the weakly inhomogeneous disk,
the perturbation of equilibrium parameters is selected in
the form of a plane wave (in the circular rotating frame)
,
where
is an amplitude that is a constant in space
and time, m is the nonnegative azimuthal mode number (= number of
spiral arms),
is the Doppler-shifted
complex wavefrequency,
,
,
suffixes
denote the
th Fourier component, and
means the complex conjugate. In the
local WKB approximation it is assumed that the wave vector and the
wavefrequency vary continuously. By utilizing the more accurate
nonlocal WKB approximation, it may be shown that in fact the
characteristic oscillation frequencies of an inhomogeneous disk must
be quantized, i.e., must pass through a discrete series of values.
In galaxies, discrete spiral modes were already found in
stellar population by Rix & Zaritsky (1995), Zaritsky & Rix
(1997), Rudnick & Rix (1998), and Block & Puerari (1999).
In the near-infrared, the morphology of older star-dominated disk
indicates a simple classification scheme: the dominant Fourier
m-mode. Fridman et al. (1998) and Burlak et al. (2000) detected
m=1-9 spiral modes in relatively young stellar population of the
nearly face-on galaxies from observations in the H
line.
A ubiquity of low-m (m=1-4) modes was confirmed.
In the linear theory, one can select one of the Fourier harmonics:
0.5 [
.
The solution in such a form represents
a spiral wave with m arms.
Using the transformation of the partial derivatives
and
given by
Eqs. (9), the solution of the linearized kinetic
Eq. (3) may be written immediately:
Integrating Eq. (11) over velocity space and equating the
result to the perturbed surface density given by the improved solution
of the Poisson equation
(Lin & Lau
1979; Griv & Peter 1996a), the generalized dispersion relation may
easily be obtained
The asymptotic expansion of the Bessel function
Il (x) in the short-wavelength limit,
(the case of epicyclic
radius that is large compared with wavelength):
In Eq. (12), the functions
appear commonly in a theoretical treatment of
Maxwellian plasmas in a magnetic field. It is instructive to note:
(a)
;
(b)
decreases
monotonically from
;
and (c)
for
start from
,
reach maxima, and then decrease.
Equation (12) replaces the standard Lin-Shu
dispersion relation (Lin & Shu 1966; Lin et al. 1969; Shu 1970),
to take into account all terms up to 2 orders in small parameters
and
.
Also, the terms
were
omitted in Toomre (1964), Lin & Shu (1966), Lin et al. (1969),
Shu (1970), Mark (1977), Lynden-Bell & Kalnajs (1972)
studies. The main difference from
the original Lin-Shu dispersion relation is in the factor
,
which makes the generalized dispersion relation to
be correct even in the regime of open perturbations (see Griv &
Peter 1996a for a discussion). Actually, Lin & Shu (1966),
Lin et al. (1969), Shu (1970), and Mark (1977)
allowed for a departure from axial symmetry of the perturbations
only partially by introducing a Doppler-shifted in a rotating
reference frame wavefrequency
but omitting all other m and
-dependent terms in
Eq. (12), on the grounds that they were
interested in almost axisymmetric perturbations.
Therefore, in fact these authors as well as
Toomre (1964) obtained a criterion for an instability
of axisymmetric perturbations of the Jeans kind only - the widely
used Toomre critical radial velocity dispersion. It says
nothing about the stability of Jeans modes which are not tightly wound,
particularly the dominant open instabilities of the differentially
rotating disks. The effects of the azimuthal forces have been analyzed
by Lin & Lau (1979) by adopting
the hydrodynamical model. Important conclusions were obtained about
the enhanced amplification of nonaxisymmetric density waves in a
differentially rotating system (Bertin & Mark 1978; Lin & Lau 1979;
Bertin 1980). The free kinetic
energy associated with the differential rotation of the system under
study is one possible source for the growth of the energy of these
spiral perturbations, and appears to be released when angular
momentum is transferred outward.
In disk-shaped galaxies,
.
In the Solar vicinity of the Galaxy
the value of the radial scale length |L| is about 3 kpc, which
is a typical value for the radial scale length of the exponential
component of the disk when compared with external galaxies of
similar morphological types (Porcel et al. 1998).
The dispersion relation (12)
is valid for relatively open spirals
throughout a weakly inhomogeneous disk excluding resonance
zones.
The existence of solutions of
Eq. (12)
with
,
,
and
implies
oscillating instability, while the solutions with
and
describe
the absorption of waves. The solutions with
and
describe
the natural (harmonic) oscillations, and the solutions with
,
describe the Jeans instability.
The quantity
characterizes the rate of rigid-body rotation of the wave pattern.
![]() |
Figure 1:
The generalized Lin-Shu dispersion relation of a
homogeneous (
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
A general impression of how the spectrum of nonaxisymmetric Jeans
perturbations behaves in a homogeneous nonuniformly rotating disk can be
gained from Fig. 1, which shows the dispersion curves in the cases of
Jeans-unstable systems ((a) and (b)), a marginally Jeans-stable system
(c), and a Jeans-stable one (d) for values of
,
and
(as determined on a computer from Eq. (12)).
In this figure, the ordinate is the effective wavenumber k*
measured in terms of the inverse epicyclic radius
and the abscissa is
,
i.e.,
the dimensionless angular frequency at which the stars meet with
the pattern, measured in terms of the epicyclic frequency
.
In general, for fixed dimensionless wavefrequency
there are two solutions in
,
comprising a long-wavelength wave,
,
and a short-wavelength wave,
.
A property of the solution (12) is that in a homogeneous
system the Jeans-stable modes those with
are
separated from each other by frequency intervals where there is no
wave propagation: gaps occur between each harmonic (cf. the Bernstein
modes in a magnetized plasma).
In summary, the generalized dispersion
relation (12) can be explored
to investigate detailed stability properties of an
inhomogeneous stellar disk for the Schwarzschild distribution function
.
In particular this relation can be applied to
study the excitation of Jeans-unstable density waves. This problem
has been studied by Morozov (1980, 1981a), Polyachenko (1989),
Griv & Peter (1996a), Polyachenko & Polyachenko (1997),
Griv et al. (1999). In Sect. 4 of the present paper,
the problem is studied in the framework of the quasi-linear theory.
The generalized dispersion relation (12)
is complicated: the basic dispersion relation above is highly
nonlinear in the frequency .
Therefore, in order to deal
with the most interesting oscillation types analytically, only
various limiting cases of perturbations described by some
simplified variations of dispersion relation may be considered.
Let us first restrict ourselves to consideration of the principal part
of a system between the inner and outer Lindblad resonances, ,
by considering low-frequency perturbations with
(which dispersion laws are given in Fig. 1 by curves 1 and 2).
That is,
less than the epicyclic frequency of any
disk stars, and the consideration is limited to the
transparency region between the turning points in a disk.
In the opposite case of the high perturbation
frequencies,
,
the effect of the disk
rotation is negligible and therefore not relevant to us:
in this "rotationless'' case the star motion is approximately
rectilinear on the time and length scales of interest which are
the wave growth/damping periods and wavelength (cf. Alexandrov et al.
1984, p. 110). Resonances of a higher order,
,
are dynamically less important.
Secondly, in Eq. (12) one can
consider two asymptotic limits: the limit of long-wavelength
perturbations,
,
and the opposite limit of
short-wavelength perturbations,
.
Finally, we consider the weakly inhomogeneous system and the
most important for the problem of spiral structure low-m perturbations:
from now on in all equations
and
.
Additionally, in the local version of the
WKB method
.
Therefore, in small terms proportional
to L-1 we include only l=0 harmonics. As a result, from
Eq. (12) the simplified dispersion relation reads
The resulting dispersion relation (15) is a third
order equation with respect to
with real coefficients,
which describes three branches of oscillations: two
Jeans branches (short-wavelength and long-wavelength
ones) modified by the inhomogeneity, and an additional
gradient branch.
The frequency of the most important for the problem of disk's
stability Jeans oscillations slightly modified by the inhomogeneity
gradient in the frequency range
The Jeans perturbations can be stabilized by the random velocity
spread. Indeed, if one recalls that such unstable perturbations
are possible only when
,
then by using the condition
for all possible k, from
Eq. (15) the stability criterion to suppress the
instability of all Jeans perturbations can be obtained.
At the limit of gravitational stability, the two conditions
and
are fulfilled.
The first condition determines the most unstable Jeans
wavelength
,
corresponding to the minimum
on the dispersion curve
.
In the Solar
vicinity for the subsystem of young, low-dispersion
stars,
kpc.
Interestingly, from observations in the Galaxy, the distance between
spiral arms is also
kpc. So, the radial scale of
the perturbations is small,
.
Use of the second
condition determines the marginal radial velocity dispersion for the
stability of arbitrary but not only axisymmetric perturbations:
![]() |
Figure 2:
The growth rate of the Jeans instability of a
homogeneous stellar disk (arbitrary units) in the case
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The growth rate of the Jeans instability as determined on a computer
from the expression
is shown in Fig. 2. As one can see visually in this figure, the growth rates have maxima
with respect to
.
It means that of all harmonics of initial perturbation, one
perturbation with the maximum of the growth rate
and
with
will be formed asymptotically in time.
The low-m spiral modes (m < 10) are more unstable than the
radial one (m=0) and the high-m ones (
).
These low-m spiral modes are only important in the problem of
galactic spiral structure because in contrast to the high-m modes,
they do extend essentially over a large range of the galactic disk
(Lin et al. 1969; Shu 1970). Interestingly,
the study of the azimuthal structure of the stellar disk of 18 face-on
spiral galaxies, using
-band photometry, shows that most of
them exhibit lopsided (m=1) or two-armed structures (Rix &
Zaritsky 1995). Fourier analysis of the spiral structure of the galaxy
NGC 4254 already revealed the dominance of the m=1 component
(Iye et al. 1982). It was
stressed that theories of the origin of spiral structure of galaxies
must explain the asymmetric structure of this galaxy without the help
of spiral exciters such as tidal companions or a bar.
About
of all late-type spiral galaxies and
54 early-type disk galaxies have the strong m=1azimuthal component of the surface brightness in the
near
-band and the R-band, confirming lopsidedness as
a dynamical phenomenon (Zaritsky & Rix 1997; Rudnick & Rix 1998).
A similar fraction of galaxies
has lopsided
H I distributions or kinematic asymmetries (Baldwin et al. 1980;
Bosma 1981; Richter & Sancisi 1994; Swaters et al. 1999; Kornreich
et al. 2000). In the single-arm galaxy NGC 4378 the spiral arm can be
traced over most
revolutions (Kormendy & Norman
1979). Disk ellipticity (m=2) may also be common (Andersen
et al. 2001).
The shape and the number of spiral arms depend on the equilibrium parameters of a galaxy. For the Galaxy the most unstable pattern is that of 1-4 arms, the radial distance between the arms being about 2 kpc.
In the another frequency range,
,
Eq. (15) has another root,
which describes the gradient,
,
branch of oscillations.
The gradient perturbations are stable and are independent of the
stability of Jeans modes (Griv & Peter 1996b). These
low-frequency,
,
oscillations
are not important in dynamics of galaxies.
Although Eq. (15) can be analyzed directly and even
solved analytically in the case ,
graphical representation
of the roots is much more convenient. A graphic method
of solution of Eq. (15) is indicated in Fig. 3.
It is seen in Fig. 3 how the usual Jeans oscillations with
as shown in Fig. 1 by curves 1 and 2 are
deformed and the additional low-frequency
gradient oscillations appear in an inhomogeneous disk.
We anticipate that the fluidlike Jeans-unstable oscillations must influence the distribution function of the main part of stars in such a way as to hinder the wave excitation, i.e., to increase the random velocity spread ultimately at the expense of circular motion or gravitational energy. This is because the Jeans instability, being essentially a gravitational one, tends to be stabilized by random motions of stars (Eqs. (16) and (17)). Therefore, along with the growth of the oscillation amplitude the velocity dispersion must increase, and finally in the disk there can be established a stationary distribution so that the Jeans-unstable perturbations are completely vanishing. Eventually the disk evolves toward a quasi-stationary, marginally Jeans-stable distribution. (In turn, the Jeans-stable perturbations are subject to a weak Landau-type oscillating instability; Griv et al. 2000a,b.)
Next, we substitute the solution (11)
into Eq. (4) and average the latter
over time. Taking into account that the terms
vanish for
axially symmetric functions f0, after averaging over
we
obtain the equation
As usual in the quasi-linear theory, in order to close the system
one must engage an equation for
.
Averaging
over the fast oscillations, we obtain
Two general physical conclusions can be deduced without solving
Eq. (20). First, the initial distribution of
stars will change upon time only under the action of growing
perturbations (
). Therefore,
only transient, gravitationally unstable patterns heat the disk and
cause star's guiding centers to diffuse radially
. Secondly, the distribution function of
random velocities
will change under the action of both the radial
and the tangential forces (this is because in
Eq. (20)
). But the mean surface mass density (that is,
star's guiding centers positions)
will change under
the action of only the azimuthal forces (
): the
requirement that
is required for shifts in guiding centers.
Since the guiding center encodes angular momentum, this is merely a
statement of angular-momentum conservation. As angular momentum is
transferred outward, inner material falls to the center and outer
material migrates outward (Lynden-Bell & Pringle 1974). Thus, the
diffusion of star's guiding centers leads to the core-dominated
mass density profile in rotating galaxies, together with the
buildup of an extended outer envelope.
In the most important low-frequency limit, ,
the function
starts from
,
reaches a maximum
at
(Figs. 1 and 3), and then decreases. Hence,
the growth rate has a maximum at
(or
).
As an application of the quasi-linear theory we investigate
the relaxation of low-frequency and Jeans-unstable (
and
,
respectively)
oscillations in the weakly inhomogeneous (
)
disk of the Galaxy.
In the following, we restrict ourselves to the fastest growing
long-wavelength,
and
,
and low-frequency,
perturbations (see the explanation
just at the end of Sect. 4 and Fig. 1). Then in Eqs. (12)
and (20) one can use the expansions
,
and e
.
Equation (20) takes the simple form
An expression for f0 at
can
be deduced from Eq. (22). We introduce the
substitution
,
.
Then Eq. (22) can be re-written
This mechanism increases (a) the velocity dispersion of stars
in the Galaxy's plane after they are born (Eq. (24)),
and (b) the radial spread of the disk (Eq. (25)). The
collisionless relaxation mimics thermal relaxation in a two-dimensional
stellar disk, leading to Maxwell-Boltzmann type velocity distributions
with an effective temperature that increases with time. To repeat
ourselves, sufficient random velocity spread prevents the
Jeans instability from occuring (Griv et al. 1994; Griv et al. 1999).
The diffusion of the bulk of stars in configuration space takes place
because they gain wave energy as the instability develops.
The instability-induced diffusion, however,
presumably tapers off as Jeans stability is approached: the radial
velocity dispersion
becomes greater than the critical one
.
Observations already convincingly indicated
a secular dynamical evolution in spiral galaxies on the Hubble
time scale or even smaller (Martinet 1995).
Thus, the true time scale for relaxation in the Galaxy may be
much shorter than its standard value 1014 yr for the
Chandrasekhar collisional relaxation; it may be of the
order
yr, i.e., comparable with 2-3
periods of the Galaxy rotation. This short relaxation time is in
agreement with both observations (Binney & Tremaine 1987, p. 473;
Grivnev & Fridman 1990) and N-body simulations (Hohl 1971;
Morozov 1981a; Sellwood & Carlberg 1984; Tomley et al. 1991;
Griv & Chiueh 1998).
We have shown above that the squared plane velocity dispersion
of stars increases with time t as
One concludes that the proposed mechanism of wave-star interaction is able to account for both the shape of the velocity ellipsoid (the anisotropic Maxwellian, that is, Schwarzschild distribution) and the form of the age-velocity dispersion law in the plane of the Galaxy.
Transient spiral arms excite random motions parallel to the
equatorial plane. According to Eq. (24), the heating
efficiency of unstable density wave features depends on their spatial
and temporal form. Let us evaluate the heating
for a
realistic model of the disk of the Galaxy in the Solar vicinity.
In accordance with the theory as developed above,
we consider the fastest growing mode with
kpc-1 and
.
According to observations, in the Solar
vicinity
(Lin et al.
1969; Yuan 1969),
,
kpc,
kms-1, and
.
From Eq. (24), one obtains
kms-1, where t=109 yr. This value of
is in agreement with both estimates
based on the observed stellar velocities (Mayor 1974; Wielen 1977;
Strömgren 1987; Meusinger et al. 1991; Grivnev & Fridman 1990;
Dehnen & Binney 1999) and N-body simulations (Hohl 1971; Quirk 1972;
Sellwood & Carlberg 1984; Tomley et al. 1991). Thus already in the
first 4-5 galactic revolutions, in say about 109 yr, the stellar
populations see their epicyclic energy vary by a factor of ten.
There is considerable scatter in the metallicities of stars that have a common guiding center and age. On the other hand, it is widely believed that all interstellar material at a given time and radius has a common metallicity. The paradox can be resolved if one assumes that these stars were born at different radii and then migrated to its present locations as a result of a series of uncorrelated scattering events (Wielen et al. 1996; Binney 2001).
The migration may be explained naturally by "collisions'' of
stars with the Jeans-unstable density waves. Let us estimate the
scale of radial migration
of the Sun's guiding center.
According to observations, we adopt the ratio
,
,
,
kpc,
and
,
.
Then from Eq. (22) we obtain
kpc.
This
is in fair agreement with the estimate
of Wielen et al. (1996)
kpc
based on a radial galactic gradient in metallicity. We conclude
that the Sun has migrated from its birth-place at r = 6-7
kpc in the inner part of the Galaxy outwards by 2-3 kpc
during its lifetime of
yr.
Under the influence of Jeans-unstable perturbations, the random
velocity dispersion of the main part of the stellar distribution
function increases essentially on a dynamical time scale (on the
time scale of only 2-3 galactic rotations).
Because the Jeans instability is characterized by the critical
value of velocity dispersion
,
eventually as a result of such heating the gravitational instability will
be switched off rapidly. Therefore, from the theoretical point of view,
the Jeans-unstable density waves in a collisionless stellar disk
have to be short-lived, and they should dissipate after a few
rotations of the system.
N-body experiments have shown similar behavior for a hot system of stars repeatedly. A spiral structure usually develops in a numerical model during the first rotation of the system. These spirals are evidently Jeans-unstable density waves and not material arms, since test particles pass right through them (Miller et al. 1970; Quirk 1972). Sellwood & Carlberg (1984), Sellwood & Athanassoula (1986), and Griv et al. (1999) presented evidences that the spirals arise from collective processes. The growth of these perturbations then saturates due to the increasing velocity dispersion of the particles, and the Jeans-unstable modes decay during the next two to three rotations. The increase of velocity dispersion in those experiments cannot be explained by usual two-body encounters (Hohl 1973; Griv et al. 1999). It seems likely, the fast heating in the N-body models is due to collective effects discussed in the present paper, i.e., due to density fluctuations as a result of the Jeans instability. The violent Jeans instability occurs in numerical models because the Toomre stability criterion, satisfied for an initial computer model, is not applicable to nonaxisymmetric gravity perturbations in a differentially rotating, inhomogeneous disk. Density perturbations arising from the instabilities of the nonaxisymmetric perturbations grow into spiral structures. These density waves, which have growth rates comparable to the mean orbital frequency, dynamically heat the disk and exert torques which redistribute both mass and angular momentum. In a final, quasi-steady state after two to three rotations, the stars in acomputer model acquire large random velocities about 2 times more than Toomre's criterion predicts (Hohl 1971; Morozov 1981a; Sellwood & Carlberg 1984; Tomley et al. 1991; Griv et al. 1999). Thus, in the nonlinear regime, the stars (and indeed also the gas before their formation) can continue developing Jeans-unstable condensations only if some effective mechanism of cooling exists, leading to Toomre's Q-values smaller than 2-2.5.
Cooling of a numerical model through dissipation in the gas layer, accretion, and/or star formation (injection of new-born stars which are formed on almost purely circular orbits) has already been proposed as a mean to prolong collective instabilities in the plane of the stellar disk (Miller et al. 1970; Quirk 1972; Sellwood & Carlberg 1984; Tomley et al. 1991; Griv & Chiueh 1998). The cold interstellar medium may play a dominant role in determining the wave-like structure in galaxies with a high star formation rate because it is the site of the generation of dynamically cold objects. The star formation process fuels the Jeans instability, favoring the excitation of short-lived spiral modes exponentially growing through a recurrent instability cycle in the disk of newly formed stars. In this regard, no prominent spirals are seen in S0 galaxies that have little or no interstellar matter. Martinet (1995) already pointed out the connection between dynamical evolution and efficiency of star formation in galaxies of various morphological types. We expect that stellar disks of flat galaxies are rife with many transient, chaotic-looking Jeans-unstable wakes. Such short-lived spirals develop in young stellar population in rapid succession and possible interaction (cf. Sellwood & Carlberg 1984; Tomley et al. 1991). Summarizing, multiple armed spiral patterns in gas-rich galaxies may result from the simultaneous excitation and superposition of different Jeans-unstable modes. The coexistence of several spiral waves is possible. The low-m modes (m=1-4) are the dominant ones. Interestingly, many spiral structures in galaxies do not appear to be well-organized grand designs. Galaxies dominated by a single and symmetric pattern are exceedingly rare (Binney & Tremaine 1987, p. 391; Elmegreen & Elmegreen 1989).
The kinetic theory of the Jeans instability
is extended by deriving a diffusion equation in configuration
space for the main part of the distribution function of stars
in the rotating disk of a flat galaxy. The analytical
method of the quasi-linear kinetic theory is applied. It is
shown that in the collisionless case diffusion leads to effective
temperatures, i.e., to velocity dispersions relative to the bulk
velocities of the galaxy stars, increasing in time in the field of
the Jeans-unstable waves. Fluidlike stellar encounters with almost
aperiodically growing Jeans-unstable gravity perturbations can
explain the observed form of the age-velocity dispersion
correlation, the observed amount
heating of the local stellar disk in the plane of the Galaxy
kms-1 as well as the observed Schwarzschild shape of
the stellar random velocity distribution. This result is in agreement
with suggestions of previous work (Griv et al. 1994; Griv & Peter
1996a; Griv et al. 1999; Griv et al. 2000b). Sufficient velocity
dispersion prevents the Jeans instability from occurring but cooling
of a galaxy through dissipation in the gas layer, accretion, and/or
star formation (injection of new-born dynamically cold stars) reduce
the residual velocities of stars so that the Jeans instability may
be an effective long-term generating mechanism for the spiral
2 kpc structure of a disk galaxy. We conclude that
the spiral arms in gas-rich galaxies may be of transient nature in
systems with gas cooling, accretion, and/or star formation. In such
a way, we are able to reconcile the apparent conflict between the
theory of the Jeans instability and the fact that spiral
patterns in disk galaxies of stars must be long lived.
The diffusion of stellar orbits in coordinate space leads to the
core-dominated mass density profile in disk galaxies. As a result of
wave-star scattering, the Sun's guiding center diffused radially
from its birth-place in the inner part of the Galaxy outwards;
kpc.
Acknowledgements
We have benefited from numerous discussions with Tzihong Chiueh, David Eichler, Alexei Fridman, Muzafar Maksumov, Frank Shu, Irina Shuster, and Jun-Hui Zhao. This work was supported in part by the Israel Science Foundation and the Israeli Ministry of Immigrant Absorption.