A&A 381, 951-958 (2002)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20011574
M. Heydari-Malayeri1
-
M.R. Rosa 2,
-
D. Schaerer 3
-
F. Martins 3 -
V. Charmandaris 4
1 - DEMIRM, Observatoire de Paris, 61 avenue de l'Observatoire,
75014 Paris, France
2 -
Space Telescope European Coordinating Facility, European Southern
Observatory,
Karl-Schwarzschild-Strasse-2, 85748 Garching bei
München, Germany
3 -
Laboratoire d'Astrophysique, Observatoire Midi-Pyrénées, 14 avenue É. Belin, 31400 Toulouse, France
4 -
Cornell University, Astronomy Department, 106 Space Sciences Bldg.,
Ithaca, NY 14853, USA
Received 14 August 2001 / Accepted 25 October 2001
Abstract
Using Hubble Space Telescope observations with
STIS, we study the main exciting stars of N81, a high excitation
compact 2 region in the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC). These far
UV observations are the first spectroscopic measurements of stars in
such a region and reveal features characteristic of an O6-O8 stellar
type. The astonishing weakness of their wind profiles and their
sub-luminosity (up to 2 mag fainter in MV than the corresponding
dwarfs) make these stars a unique stellar population in the Magellanic
Clouds. Our analysis suggests that they are probably in the
Hertzsprung-Russell diagram locus of a particularly young class of
massive stars, the so-called Vz luminosity class, as they are arriving
at the zero age main sequence.
Key words: stars: early-type - ISM: dust, extinction - ISM: 2 regions - ISM: individual objects: N81 - galaxies: magellanic clouds
Understanding the formation of massive stars, which is still a largely unsolved problem, requires studying them at the earliest phases where they can be reached through the enshrouding material at different wavelengths. While high resolution radio continuum observations allow the investigation of ultracompact 2 regions formed around newborn massive stars (Churchwell 1990), high angular resolution observations in the ultraviolet, visible, and infrared are also necessary to access accurate physical parameters of these stars in order to identify their evolutionary states (Walborn & Fitzpatrick 1990; Walborn et al. 1995b; Hanson et al. 1996). In particular, UV observations are of prime importance since massive stars emit the bulk of their energy in this wavelength range. In practice, though, observing newborn massive stars is not straightforward for several reasons. Mainly, they are very rare, and the relatively small evolutionary timescales involved make it difficult to catch them just at this very point in their evolution, that is when they become observable in the UV and visible (Yorke & Krügel 1977; Shu et al. 1987; Palla & Stahler 1990; Beech & Mitalas 1994; Bernasconi & Maeder 1996).
We have amply argued that the compact 2 regions known as
HEBs (High Excitation Blobs) provide the best opportunities for a
direct access to massive stars at very early stages of their evolution
(Heydari-Malayeri et al. 2001a and
references therein). The members of this distinct and very rare
class of ionized nebulae in the Magellanic Clouds are small and
compact (5'' to 10'' in diameter corresponding to
1.5-3.0pc), in contrast to the typical 2 regions in those
galaxies, which are extended structures (sizes of several arcmin
corresponding to more than 50pc, powered by a large number of
exciting stars). In general, HEBs are also heavily affected by local
dust, as one would expect from their very young age (Heydari-Malayeri
et al. 2001a and references therein, see also Israel &
Koornneef 1991). Also their study is pertinent to understanding
the process of massive star formation, especially in the context of the
Magellanic Clouds.
Our recent high-resolution imaging with the Hubble Space Telescope (GO6563, GO8246) using the Wide Field Planetary Camera (WFPC2) has for the first time resolved several HEBs which had appeared featureless to ground-based telescopes: SMC N81, N88A, LMC 159-5 (the Papillon nebula), N83B, and N11A (Heydari-Malayeri et al. 1999a, 1999b, 1999c, 2001a, 2001b). The HST observations uncover the stellar content hidden thus far, as well as the nebular features of these compact nebulae and display a turbulent environment typical of newborn massive star formation sites: outstanding emission ridges created by shocks and cavities sculpted in the ionized gas by the powerful winds of massive stars, prominent dust structures protruding from hot gas. The observations also bring to light even more compact 2 blobs, immersed in the HEBs, harboring newborn, hot stars.
The present paper is devoted to N81, also known as DEM138 (Henize 1956; Davies et al. 1976), a nebula only
10'' across and located in the Shapley Wing
at
1
.2 (
1.2kpc) from the main body of
the SMC. A first detailed study of this compact 2 region, carried
out by Heydari-Malayeri et al. (1988), revealed its nature and
some of its physical characteristics: gas density and temperature,
chemical composition, mass, age, etc. Subsequently, near infrared
observations showed the presence
of H2 emission towards N81 (Israel & Koornneef 1988),
while 12CO(1-0) emission at two points towards this
2 region was also detected (Israel et al. 1993).
However, due to the lack of sufficient spatial resolution, it was not
possible to view and study the exciting star(s) hidden inside the
ionized gas. Therefore, the rather important question,
which is often raised by star formation theories, of whether N81
was powered by a single massive star or a cluster of them, remained
unanswered. This is, however, a critical question for theories of
star formation.
High spatial resolution imaging with HST allowed us to
resolve N81 and revealed the presence of a tight cluster of newborn
massive stars embedded in this compact nebula (Heydari-Malayeri
et al. 1999, hereafter Paper I). Six of the stars are grouped
in the core region of 2'' diameter, with a pair of the
main exciting stars in the very center separated by only 0'' .27 or
0.08 pc. The images also displayed conspicuous marks of strong stellar
winds, shocks, and ionization fronts characterising turbulent massive
star forming regions. Moreover they revealed prominent dust lanes
dividing the nebula into three lobes. One of the lanes,
running over 15'' (4.5pc), ends in a magnificent curved plume.
A remarkable absorption "hole'' or dark globule of radius
0'' .25 (
0.07 pc) is situated towards the center of
the 2 region, where the extinction reaches higher values
(AV=1.3 mag). These absorption features are probably parts
of the molecular cloud which have given birth to the massive stars.
From the Strömgren uvby imaging with WFPC2 we carried out the photometry of some 50 stars towards N81. This allowed us, using color-magnitude diagrams, to select the main exciting stars of the region. This paper is devoted to the spectroscopy of these stars. We derive spectral classification for these very young massive stars and study their nature.
The General Observer Program No. 8246 devoted to observations of N81
was performed with Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph, STIS
(Woodgate et al. 1998) on board HST on 28 and 31 October
1999. The spectra were obtained with the far-UV
Multi-Anode Microchannel Array (MAMA) detector in the G140L mode covering
the wavelength range 1120-1715 Å. All the observations were made
through the 52'' 0
2 entrance slit. The effective
resolution was 0.6Å per pixel of 25
m, corresponding to a
dispersion of 24Åmm-1, or a resolution of 1.2Å
(FWHM). The exposure times were set according to the apparent
magnitudes of the stars in order to equalize the
signal-to-noise ratios (S/N) of the spectrograms. Total exposure
times varied from 1229 s (stars #1 and #2) to 3169 s (stars #3,
#4, and #8). Three relatively faint stars (#5, #7, #10), not
initially scheduled for observations, happened to lie on the slit when
observing their adjacent stars (#3 and #11). The S/N ratio is
particularly weak for these stars, yet we present the spectrogram of
star #5 which shows some interesting features.
STIS was also used to
obtain the spectra of the N81 stars in the visible domain. The
grating G430L covered the range of 2900 to 5700 Å with a
resolution of of 2.73 Å per pixel. The CCD pixels of 21
m
yielded a dispersion of 130Åmm-1. The exposure times ranged
from 24 s (star #1) to 750 s (star #8).
The calibrated output products from the standard pipeline use a
default extraction aperture of 22 pixels (0
53 on the sky). We
carefully reprocessed the 2D images using the most recent calibration
reference files applicable to the observations and extracted the
spectra using slits of both 6 and 2 pixels. We verified the centering
of the stars on the slits, and tested for the effects of different sky
background extraction on our spectra. The 6 pixel slit yielded
spectra which are very similar to
those produced by the standard pipeline with an insignificant loss in
S/N. Even the 2 pixel slit did not indicate any extraction effect due
to its size other than the expected loss in S/N. Comparing the
resulting line profiles as a function of the aperture width, we found
that other than an increase in noise when going to the smaller slits,
and slightly modifying the slope of the spectra (because of a slight
tilt of the spectral images), the line profiles do not change by any
significant amount. The spectra displayed in Figs. 1 and 2 are based
on 6 pixel extraction apertures.
The N81 stars observed with STIS are listed in Table 1, and their
physical location can be seen in Fig. 2 of Paper I. The table also
presents the corresponding photometry of the stars (Paper I). The
color excesses E(B-V) were derived from E(b-y) using the intrinsic
color
(b-y)0=-0.15 mag for hot stars (Relyea & Kurucz 1978)
and assuming that our observed colors represent the standard
Strömgren system. The relation
E(B-V)=1.49 E(b-y) (Kaltcheva
& Georgiev
1992) was then used to transform into the Johnson system, which
finally yielded the extinctions
AV=3.1 E(B-V). The estimated
absolute magnitudes are based on a distance modulus
M-m=19.0 mag (corresponding to a distance of 63.2kpc, e.g.
Di Benedetto 1997 and references therein) and assuming that the
Strömgren y filter is equal to the Johnson V.
Star number | ![]() |
![]() |
y | b-y | AV | MV |
(J2000) | (J2000) | (F547M) | ||||
(mag) | (mag) | (mag) | (mag) | |||
1 | 01:09:13.1 | -73:11:38.3 | 14.38 | -0.10 | 0.22 | -4.84 |
2 | 01:09:13.0 | -73:11:38.0 | 14.87 | -0.11 | 0.19 | -4.32 |
3 | 01:09:13.4 | -73:11:38.4 | 16.10 | -0.08 | 0.31 | -3.21 |
4 | 01:09:12.8 | -73:11:38.3 | 17.41 | +0.07 | 1.02 | -2.61 |
5 | 01:09:13.3 | -73:11:37.6 | 18.29 | -0.05 | 0.46 | -1.17 |
8 | 01:09:12.8 | -73:11:40.2 | 17.84 | +0.15 | 1.40 | -2.56 |
11 | 01:09:13.7 | -73:11:33.3 | 15.74 | -0.10 | 0.22 | -3.48 |
13 | 01:09:16.1 | -73:11:29.1 | 16.65 | -0.08 | 0.31 | -2.66 |
The final reduced spectrograms are presented in Figs. 1 and 2, where
the former figure includes the four brightest stars of the sample,
whereas Fig. 2 displays the fainter ones. The main stellar features
(CIII1176, NV
1239, 1243,
OV
1371, SiIV
1394, 1403, CIV
1548, 1551, and
He II
1640) are distinguished with tick marks.
The labels appearing below the features indicate cases where
contamination with an interstellar component is possible. The
identification of SV
1502Å is based on the work of Werner
& Rauch (2001).
An outstanding aspect of these spectra is the extreme weakness of the
UV wind profiles. Weak stellar wind features in SMC O stars
have already been found by several workers (Hatchings 1982;
Garmany & Conti 1985;
Walborn et al. 1995b), who
ascribed them to the metal deficiency of the SMC leading to a reduced
radiation pressure responsible for driving the winds of early-type
stars. More recent observations have further confirmed this result
(Smith Neubig & Bruhweiler 1997; Walborn et
al. 2000).
However, the wind features observed in the stars of N81
are even weaker. If we consider the usually stronger wind lines seen
in O stars (such as the NV1239, 1243 and CIV
1548,
1551 in dwarfs, or the SiIV
1394, 1403 in
giants/supergiants), with the exception perhaps of star #5, none
shows the emission part of a P-Cygni profile and the absorption is
extremely weak, particularly for NV
1239, 1243.
For stars which we classify as O types (see below), such a behavior is
observed for the first time.
![]() |
Figure 1:
Rectified HST/STIS ultraviolet spectrograms of the four
brightest stars in SMC N81. The prominent absorption feature at
![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 2: Spectrograms for the remaining four less bright stars of N81. The notation is the same as in Fig. 1. |
Open with DEXTER |
Traditionally the spectral classification schemes of stars are based on their optical spectra. However, recent studies comparing spectral features in the optical and UV have resulted in a global, coherent picture of classification criteria (Walborn et al. 1985, 1995a; Smith Neubig & Bruhweiler 1997, 1999). In particular, Smith Neubig & Bruhweiler (1997) have proposed a UV classification system for O and B stars of the SMC which is defined by a set of standard, low resolution spectra observed with the International Ultraviolet Explorer (IUE). This UV scheme, which was used by the authors to derive classifications for 133 O and B stars of the SMC, while independent of the MK system, shows general agreement with those deduced from visual data.
The low S/N ratio of our STIS optical spectra and in particular their contamination with strong nebular emission lines limit their practical use for spectral classification. This can be understood since N81 is a very bright compact 2 region with strong nebular emission lines in the visible part of the spectrum (Paper I). Although nebular emission lines are present also in the UV part, they are much less troublesome. Therefore, we will use the method put forward by Smith Neubig & Bruhweiler (1997). However, given some morphological differences of the N81 UV spectra with previously well studied stars, the limitations of the optical part of the spectrum mentioned earlier, and the constraints available from the UV classification scheme (Smith Neubig & Bruhweiler 1997), it is clear that there is no unique solution to the spectral classification of our targets.
The presence of He II1640 and OV
1371 in all spectra,
except perhaps in stars #13 and #8 which have lower S/N ratios, is
the first and strongest evidence that we are observing O type stars.
These spectra though display characteristics suggesting that the stars
also belong to the dwarf luminosity class since the features
SiIV
1394, 1403 as well as NV
1239, 1243 and
CIV
1548, 1551 are weak (even weaker than usual).
Star #5 may be a different case as explained below.
These features are known to increase with luminosity, ranging from
weak P-Cyg profiles on the main sequence to very pronounced P-Cyg
profiles in the supergiants (Walborn et al. 1995a; Smith
Neubig & Bruhweiler
1997). A dwarf luminosity class is also supported by the
optical spectra which show no
He II
4686 and NIII
4640 emission. Although the
morphology of the N81 spectra differs qualitatively from that of the
known O types, we may classify them as "zero age main sequence
dwarf'' Vz, based on the weakness of the wind lines (Walborn & Parker
1992; Walborn & Blades 1997; Walborn et al. 2000).
Note that the original definition of the Vz class is He II
4686
absorption much stronger than He II
4541 or HeI
4471, and
therefore the association of these stars with that class is indirect.
No clear distinction between the various subtypes can be made based on
the available spectral features, but it is very likely that all stars
are of a late O type (O6-O8). This is supported by the
following three facts. First, the presence of the OV
1371
feature indicates a spectral type earlier than
O8 (Smith Neubig
& Bruhweiler 1997). Second, the weakness of the
SiIII
1300 feature, which appears in the wing of
OI+SiII
1304, excludes much later types. Finally, the
NV
1239, 1243 feature is weaker than CIV
1548, 1551,
which is only seen in O types
O6-O7 or alternatively in OC
stars (Walborn & Panek 1985).
Star #5 shows some puzzling emission features in its spectrum
(1480, 1508, 1616, and 1640 Å), at least one of which,
He II
1640, is apparently part of a P-Cyg profile. It should be
stressed though that the S/N ratio is not high enough to be absolutely
certain about their presence. If these were indeed wind induced
features, their presence would confirm the fact that the
CIV
1548, 1551 profile has a particularly marked emission
component compared to the other stars of the sample. Since both of the
He II
1604 and SV
1502 lines show P-Cyg profiles in Of and
Wolf-Rayet spectra (Walborn et al. 1985; Willis et al. 1986), star #5 appears to be an Of or WR candidate in N81.
![]() |
Figure 3:
The absolute MV magnitude versus effective temperature
diagram of the N81 stars is compared to the zero age main sequence
(ZAMS) and 4Myr isochrones at various metallicities. The
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
To constrain the stellar wind properties we have examined the line
profiles of the strongest UV lines. The best indications for velocity
shifts come from the CIV1548, 1551 feature. The profiles of
stars #1 and #2 show blue-shifted absorption reaching up to velocities of
1700 and 2000 kms-1 respectively. These values
are compatible with terminal velocity measurements in other SMC O
stars of similar spectral type (Walborn et al. 1995b; Prinja
& Crowther 1998). For star #5 we derive a terminal velocity of
1000 kms-1, while blue-shifts with smaller velocities are seen in
the remaining profiles. However, these profiles also show asymmetries
which are more important
on the red side. Further investigations will be necessary to
understand the detailed behavior of the line profiles.
Using an effective temperature derived from the estimated
spectral types (O6-O8), in particular the one from Vacca et al. (1996) for dwarfs, and the absolute magnitudes from Table 1,
we place the N81 stars (filled circles) in an HR-like diagram
(Fig. 3). For further comparison we also include the mean
MV magnitudes for O3-B0 dwarfs based on a compilation by Vacca
et al. (1996), as well as the mean MV relation of Walborn
(1972) used by Walborn & Blades (1997) for 30 Doradus stars.
Figure 3 clearly shows that most of the stars
in N81 are sub-luminous compared to the mean MV for dwarfs. This
finding still holds even if the spectral types are shifted by 1-2 subtypes towards later types. Compared to the so-called Vz luminosity
class, the sub-luminosity of the N81 stars is more pronounced. Our
targets are up to 2 mag fainter in MV than the mean
relation for dwarfs! Although this is not the defining characteristic
of the Vz class, the above indications as well the weakness of the UV
wind lines further attest to the possibility that these stars belong to the Vz class.
Two sets of ZAMS and isochrones of 4 Myr are presented in
Fig. 3 using the Geneva stellar evolution tracks for
metallicities bracketing approximately that of the SMC (Lejeune &
Schaerer 2001). One set has been computed for a metallicity 1/20
Solar (Z=0.001) and is marked with a long-dashed line, while the
second has a metallicity of 1/5 Solar (Z=0.004) and is marked with a
dotted line. The observed MV and spectral types are roughly
compatible with positions close to the theoretical ZAMS or young ages.
Given mostly the lack of an accurate spectral subtype determination we
cannot firmly establish if the lower luminosity stars (#8, #13) are
really hotter than the ZAMS. Atmospheric modeling is in progress to
obtain more accurate stellar parameters of these unique young stars in
the SMC (Martins et al., in preparation). Based on the
tracks, the ZAMS luminosities and masses corresponding to the observed
MV are between
4.2-5.5 and
14-50
respectively.
The HST spectra of N81 presented here are the first ones ever obtained from a tight cluster of stars in a HEB. The reason is that these stars, embedded in a compact emission nebula, have not been reachable by ground-based telescopes. And even with recent developments in ground-based instruments, taking spectra of individual stars in the visible remains still practically infeasible. As a result, contrary to other massive stars in the SMC that have been observed from space in the UV (Walborn et al. 1995b, 2000; Smith Neubig & Bruhweiler 1997), the N81 stars lack high quality spectra in the visible. Our low-resolution HST spectra in the visible, imposed by stringent time allocation constraints, were intended to be a first exploratory attempt.
Massive stars observed from the ground and also with HST are
typically much brighter than the ones seen in N81 and comparably
they are much less affected by nebular emission and dust.
The decoupling from nebulae is presumably
due to the evolutionary state of these stars; they have had enough
time to entirely and/or effectively disrupt their 2 regions and
the associated dust.
This means that those bright stars are older than the N81 members, as
supported by their
spectra. Among the 15 SMC stars studied by Walborn et al.
(2000), 9 are clearly giants, 5 are peculiar and
have already developed emission line features of NIV4058,
NIII
4640, or CIII
4650 (two of them being on the
main sequence),
and the last one is a pure main sequence.
The fact that all the observed exciting stars of N81 display the Vz
characteristics further supports the very young age of the cluster
(Paper I). This observed concentration of Vz stars in a small region
is intriguing since in the LMC region of 30 Doradus
only 6 of the 104 O and
early B stars classified by Walborn & Blades (1997), that is
6%, belonged to the Vz category. If we assume that all 20 bright stars we detected towards N81 (Paper I) are of O or B type,
then the lower limit for the fraction of Vz stars in N81 is nearly
35%, which is quite considerable!
The exact nature and evolutionary stage of Vz stars is still unknown.
Presumably these objects are close to a transition from their
formation locus in the HR diagram to the main sequence. However,
several issues regarding their properties, which are relevant to our
observations of compact low-metallicity 2 regions, remain open:
Given the present uncertainties on the
determination of
the N81 stars, one may speculate that some of the objects are indeed
hotter than the ZAMS, as indicated by Fig. 3. If
true, this "blue straggler'' like behavior could be indicative of
stellar collisions (e.g. Benz & Hills 1987), and
thus a signature of formation of massive stars via this process, as
advocated among others by Bonnell et al. (1998).
Our HST/STIS observations of the brightest massive stars powering the high excitation compact 2 region SMC N81 reveal that the stars have strikingly weak wind profiles and a pronounced sub-luminosity which are clear indications of their early evolutionary state. Most likely they belong to the Vz category of massive Magellanic Cloud stars (Walborn & Parker 1992; Walborn & Blades 1997), which are very young stars just arriving at the ZAMS or already located near it. These stars may also serve as templates for newborn massive stars of distant metal-poor galaxies which cannot be individually resolved. Therefore, a more detailed study and modeling of their properties is highly desirable as it will help shed some more light on the intricacies and consequences of the early stages in stellar evolution.
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the referee for a critical reading of the paper which contributed to its improvement. We are also grateful to Dr. Nolan R. Walborn (Space Telescope Science Institute) for very helpful comments and suggestions. VC would like to acknowledge the financial support for this work provided by NASA through grant number GO-8246 from the STScI, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under NASA contract 26555. DS, FM, and MH-M received partial support from the French "Programme National de Physique Stellaire'' (PNPS).