A&A 380, 245-250 (2001)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20011444
A. Nandi1 - S. K. Chakrabarti1,2 - S. V. Vadawale3 - A. R. Rao3
1 - S.N. Bose National Center for Basic Sciences, Salt Lake, 700 098, Kolkata, India
2 -
Centre for Space Physics, 114/v/1A Raja S.C. Mullick Rd., 700047, Kolkata, India
3 -
Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Homi Bhabha Road, 400 005, Mumbai (Bombay), India
Received 19 April 2001 / Accepted 4 October 2001
Abstract
We examine theoretically the behaviour of the inner accretion disk in GRS 1915+105
when soft X-ray dips are present in the X-ray light curve. We
assume the presence of a radial shock in the accretion disk, as
in some of the Two Component Advective Flow (TCAF) solutions. We discuss the
behaviour of the flux tubes inside a TCAF (which we name Magnetized
TCAF or MTCAF model for brevity) and compare various competing forces on the flux tubes.
In this MTCAF model, we find that the magnetic tension is the strongest force
in a hot plasma of temperature
K and as a result,
magnetic flux tubes entering in this region collapse catastrophically,
thereby occasionally evacuating the inner disk. We postulate
that this magnetic "rubber-band'' effect induced evacuated disk matter
produces the blobby components of outflows and IR/radio jets.
We derive the size of the post-shock region by
equating the time scale of the Quasi-Periodic Oscillations
to the infall time of accreting matter in the post-shock
region and found the shock location to be
.
We calculate the transition radius
,
where the Keplerian disk deviates
into a sub-Keplerian flow, to be
.
Based on the derived X-ray spectral parameters,
we calculate the mass of this region to be
1018g.
We conclude that during the X-ray dips the matter in the post-shock region,
which manifests itself as the thermal-Compton component in the
X-ray spectrum, is ejected, along with some sub-Keplerian matter
in the pre-shock region.
Key words: accretion, accretion disks - black hole physics - stars: winds, outflows - stars: individual: GRS1915+105 - X-rays: stars
GRS 1915+105 has proven to be an ideal source to study in detail many of the physical concepts regarding accretion onto black holes. Ever since its discovery (Castro-Tirado et al. 1992), it has been continuously bright in X-rays and it shows a variety of X-ray variability characteristics (Morgan et al. 1997; Muno et al. 1999; Yadav et al. 1999; Belloni et al. 2000). It has been monitored extensively in the radio band (Mirabel & Rodriguez 1994; Pooley & Fender 1997; Fender et al. 1999) and several episodes of high radio emissions, huge flares associated with superluminal motions, radio oscillations etc. are observed in this source. Several attempts have been made to associate the radio emission, presumably coming from jets, to the X-ray emission from the accretion disks (Fender et al. 1999; Naik et al. 2001; Naik & Rao 2001). The Spectral signature of winds from the Comptonising region has also been identified (Chakrabarti et al. 2001).
Chakrabarti & Manickam (2000, hereafter CM00) have applied the Two Component Advective Flow (TCAF) model of Chakrabarti & Titarchuk (1995) to explain various X-ray variability characteristics of GRS 1915+105. Recently there has been overwhelming evidence that the TCAF model is valid for many black hole candidates (Smith et al. 2001a; Smith et al. 2001b). CM00 invoked outflows from the inner accretion disk to explain a correlation between the QPO frequency and the duration of the burst-off states during a regular oscillations seen in the source. These outflows, however, are confined to the sonic sphere and fall back on the accretion disk after being cooled down by an inverse Compton effect. It was pointed out by Naik & Rao (2001) that the source does not show appreciable radio emission during such oscillations. A detailed inflow/outflow model has not been presented for this source to explain the radio emission, particularly to explain the superluminally moving radio blobs.
Recently Naik et al. (2001) have detected a series of soft X-ray
dips during the declining phase of a huge radio flare and have
postulated that such soft dips are responsible for the
jet emission. Vadawale et al. (2001) made a detailed study
of X-ray dips observed during the radio flare using the
Rossi X-ray Timing Experiment (RXTE) data and have presented
evidence for the disappearance of the inner accretion disk
during the dips. Since the disappearance of the inner disk is
seen to be correlated with intense radio activity,
the role of the magnetic field must be studied in order to
understand the system completely. Rodriguez & Mirabel
(1999) estimated the field in radio blobs to be
around tens of mG at 500-1000 AU (in 1994 observation).
Fender et al. (1997) requires the field to be
around 8 G at around 1 AU (in their 1996 observations).
From the similarity of min oscillations in IR and Radio,
they concluded that the radio blobs are adiabatically expanding
and are independently ejected from the disk every 30-40 min.
If the trapped field inside a radio blob is of roughly 1/r (for toroidal
field) then its interpolated value close to a black hole
is around 107 G at around
which is
comparable to an equipartition value. Thus, one needs to correlate
fields ejected from the disk with those observed inside the
radio blobs. In this paper, we examine the mass ejection
based on the TCAF model in presence of a magnetic field
(we call this as Magnetized TCAF or MTCAF model)
amplified due to strong shear at the transition radius of
the Keplerian and a sub-Keplerian flow. In the next section,
we discuss forces which govern the motions of the flux tubes
and write equations of toroidal flux tubes inside
an accretion disk with a constant angular momentum.
We show that close to the black hole, where the flow could be
very hot (
K) the flux
tubes move at least with the Alfvén speed and may
catastrophically collapse like a stretched rubber band.
We conjecture that such rapid collapse would assist
evacuation of matter from the disk and cause X-ray "dips''
seen in the light curves. In Sect. 3 we estimate the mass of the
ejecta which agrees with observations. Finally, in Sect. 4 we draw
our conclusions.
Based on the global solutions of the most general advective
accretion disk solution (Chakrabarti 1990, 1996a),
Chakrabarti & Titarchuk (1995) presented a TCAF model
of accretion onto black holes. According to this model,
matter with high viscosity and angular momentum settles
into the equatorial plane, while matter with lower
viscosity and angular momentum surrounds the Keplerian
disk. This sub-Keplerian component is likely to form a
standing or an oscillating shock (Molteni et al. 1996; Ryu et al. 1997)
front near the centrifugal barrier (few tens of Schwarzschild
radii) depending on whether the Rankine-Hugoniot condition is
satisfied or the cooling time in the post-shock region is
comparable with the infall time. Soft photons from the
Keplerian disk in the pre-shock flow are intercepted
by the puffed up sub-Keplerian post-shock flow and are
reprocessed due to inverse Comptonization. If the post-shock
matter remains hot, the black hole exhibits a harder spectrum,
while if the post-shock region is cooled down by the
soft photons, the black hole exhibits a soft spectrum. There
could be a sub-Keplerian region just before the shock
as well since with low viscosity and accretion rates a
Keplerian disk recedes from a black hole and it is not
necessary that the shocks form right at the region
where a transition from Keplerian to sub-Keplerian flow takes place.
Figure 1 schematically shows this behaviour of the two components.
![]() |
Figure 1:
A cartoon diagram of the accretion disk near a black hole
which includes a shock (![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The centrifugal pressure supported boundary layer (or, CENBOL for short)
formed in a transonic, advective flow (Chakrabarti et al. 1996),
has most of the features of a thick
accretion disk although in advective disks, advection is included
self-consistently and in thick disks advection is totally ignored.
This is because at the CENBOL surface, matter undergoes a supersonic
to sub-sonic transition and it moves very slowly in the radial
direction. In some phases of accretion, matter can bring in a large
stochastic magnetic field. The field is sheared
due to strong azimuthal velocity and the toroidal field
becomes very strong. These field lines will have very little
matter within it and would likely be buoyant and emerge
from various parts of the accretion disk. Figure 1
schematically shows this behaviour. Toroidal magnetic
flux tubes released from the Keplerian disk are sheared,
amplified and are advected in the sub-Keplerian flow.
Due to the centrifugal barrier matter stays away from the axis.
Thus a so-called funnel wall is created exactly as in
a thick accretion disk (Paczynski & Wiita 1980).
Chakrabarti & D'Silva (1994, hereafter CD94) computed the
nature of their trajectories inside a thick accretion disk.
They showed that in the event a strong flux tube enters a
hot region with ion temperature
K, the
magnetic tension becomes the strongest force and the flux
tube catastrophically collapses. Because of strong similarity
of the thick accretion disk and an advective flow, especially
inside the CENBOL, we believe that a similar mechanism could be
working and flux tube collapse would take place.
We shall consider the motion of the flux tubes on the equatorial plane of an
accretion flow around a Schwarzschild black hole described by
Paczynski-Wiita (1980) pseudo-Newtonian acceleration
g=-1/[2(x-1)2].
We use the geometric units. Masses are measured in units of the
mass of the central black hole,
;
distances from the axis (x) will be
measured in units of the Schwarzschild radius
;
and the time scales are measured in units of
.
Inside the
disk, we choose the polytropic equation of state,
,
where K and
are constants. The magnetic flux tubes brought
in by advection are assumed to be sheared and axisymmetric toroidal
flux tubes of random shape and size could be produced inside the flow. We
however assume that the flux tubes are thin, i.e., the flux tube
cross-sectional radius
is smaller than the local pressure
scale height of the disk. Close to a black hole, angular momentum of the flow remains constant
(Chakrabarti 1996a) even in presence of moderate viscosity.
Thus, we choose specific angular momentum
in the
sub-Keplerian region to be constant.
The equations of motion for thin flux tubes
have been given in CD94 and we do not repeat here.
For the sake of completeness, we write down the radial equation only valid for
the equatorial plane (
),
![]() |
(1) |
![]() |
(2) |
![]() |
(3a) |
![]() |
(3b) |
From Eq. (1), we note that there are four forces in
operation: (i) The second term inside the bracket of the
left hand side is the Coriolis force
,
where
is the angular velocity of the flow. The Coriolis acceleration is given by (CD94),
![]() |
(4) |
![]() |
(5) |
![]() |
(6) |
![]() |
(7) |
Equating the acceleration due to buoyancy with that due to magnetic tension (Eq. (6))
on the equatorial plane, we get the critical temperature of the external gas as (CD94),
![]() |
(8) |
The buoyancy timescale
is estimated from Eq. (5):
,
where,
is the half thickness of the disk in vertical
equilibrium at x and
is the speed of sound.
Note that
is very large in a Keplerian disk (
).
For a sub-Keplerian flow,
with
at x=30,
,
.
Collapse time
of a flux tube is estimated in the following way:
when tension is the most dominant force, the radial
equation of the flux tube (Eq. (1)) is simplified to:
![]() |
(9) |
![]() |
(10) |
So far, we have ignored many non-axisymmetric effects
such as Parker instability (1979 and references therein) and shearing
instability (e.g., Balbus & Hawley 1991). Foglizzo & Tagger (1995) treated this problem
comprehensively in the context of a standard disk embedded in a
large scale field. They found that (a) if the wave-length is larger than the
disk thickness then the flux tube is very unstable and buoyantly comes
out of the disk and (b) instability is strongest if the field is weaker.
According to Parker (1979), submerged field tubes may break
up into filaments in timescales of around
,
where
is the scale height and the field is able to escape from the gas
in timescales
.
If
,
which is especially true
in CENBOL region, the time scale of the
escape of the field may be comparable to the
as obtained above.
As a result, the flux not only collapses
catastrophically, but also escapes upwards following a curved trajectory as depicted in Fig. 1.
In presence of a differential rotation, Balbus & Hawley (1991) suggested that even a small
initially vertical field would be amplified to create all the components
in the dynamical timescale
(at x=30,
).
Numerical simulation (Hawley et al. 1995) has verified this instability
neglecting the tension effects. Even though the time scales of the collapse, the Parker
instability and the shear instability are of the same order, we believe that the
rubber-band effect would still be important for the destruction of the inner disk.
Vadawale et al. (2001) have shown that during the soft X-ray dips a thermal-Compton component in the X-ray spectrum gets suppressed. Several works in the literature talk about the disk-evacuation (e.g., Belloni et al. 1997; Feroci et al. 1999) in this context. We like to understand this using Two Component Advective Flow (TCAF) models of Chakrabarti & Titarchuk (1995) in presence of a Magnetic field (i.e., MTCAF model) and its time variability properties described in Molteni et al. (1996); Ryu et al. (1997) and Chakrabarti & Manickam (2000). The observation of possible disk-evacuation is clearly in line with the TCAF model and the shock oscillation model of the quasi-periodic oscillations (CM00; see also, Rao et al. 2000) which showed that the Comptonising post-shock region participates in oscillation. The sub-Keplerian region in the pre-shock flow does not emit much radiation and it is possible that some of this region may also be disrupted during the rapid collapse of the flux tube. Once we accept the destruction of the sub-Keplerian region by the magnetic rubber-band effect, we can compute the mass of this region in the following way:
The shock location is computed by equating the infall time from the shock with the
time scale of QPO. This time scale
can be written in the form (CM00):
![]() |
(11) |
If the magnetized sub-Keplerian disk is removed by imploding flux tubes
as described in the earlier section, one requires to know the location of the inner edge of
the Keplerian disk to estimate the complete mass involved.
From the model fit (Vadawale et al. 2001), the Keplerian disk
temperature turns out to be
keV. With a hardening factor
of around 1.7 (Shimura & Takahara 1995), the mass of the black hole as
and Shakura-Sunyaev viscosity parameter
,
the above
temperature corresponds to a transition radius at around
(Shakura & Sunyaev 1973). Assuming density falling off as
,
the mass of the sub-Keplerian flow of size
(
with
)
is around 1020 g.
These computations assume no pair production, i.e., there is exactly one
electron for each proton in the Comptonising region.
Once the evacuation is complete, the disk is filled in quickly
by sub-Keplerian matter in timescale of:
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
= | ![]() |
(12) |
In this paper, we have given a physical basis for a sudden
mass ejection in GRS 1915+105. We showed that if matter brings in a particularly
strong magnetic field, this would be sheared and amplified to a value much above the
equipartition value before it can be expelled by buoyancy. Magnetic tension
collapses these toroidal flux tubes at a highly supersonic speed, much faster
than the flow velocity. This has the effect of displacing matter from the
disk in transverse direction (much like a fast boat causing spillage
on a shore) and depositing it to outflowing winds. From the observed fits of
Vadawale et al. (2001) we estimated the electron number density and the mass of the
post-shock region and the sub-Keplerian flow to be around 1018 g
and 1020 g respectively. Our estimate of the post-shock mass
is a factor of ten less than the mass estimate (1019 g)
of "baby-jets'' (Mirabel et al. 1998) associated with IR and radio flares
and could therefore be due to ejection of some sub-Keplerian matter as well.
These "baby-jets'' are found to be associated with class
light curves
which have soft X-ray dips. These dips are also seen in class
light curves.
During a major portion of the huge radio flares associated with superluminal blob
emission a series of soft dips are present (Naik et al. 2001).
Mirabel & Rodriguez (1999) have pointed out that in each epoch of this type of outflow,
the mass condensation is around 1023 g. In order to achieve this, we
require that matter is accumulated from disk evacuation at each "dip'' and
within each epoch, successive mini-blobs move faster than the earlier blob
in order to "catch up''. This may indicate some other runaway process with a
longer time scale of tens of days. Naik et al. (2001) have observed such X-ray dips
at a rate of once in a few hundred seconds during the peak or the radio
flare. If there are
evacuation events during an episode of superluminal blob
ejection (in a few days), then total mass condensation would be 1023 g.
Hence in order to explain the observation of Mirabel & Rodriguez (1999),
one must require that in each epoch, matter is accumulated from at least
a thousand evacuation events. Future observation would tell if such is the case.
It is to be noted that the mass of the condensation as estimated by Mirabel & Rodriguez (1999) is based on the presence of one electron per proton, i.e., no pair production is assumed. With a pair density, say, ten times larger, the estimated mass would be ten times less. However, at the same time, estimated mass of the disk would also be reduced by the same factor. Hence, the number of ejection events is not affected.
Acknowledgements
SKC and AN acknowledge receiving grants from DST project entitled Analytical and Numerical Studies of Astrophysical Flows Around Compact Objects. The authors thank the referee for helpful comments.