A&A 379, 864-869 (2001)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20011454
F. Maragoudaki1 - M. Kontizas1 - D. H. Morgan2 - E. Kontizas3 - A. Dapergolas3 - E. Livanou1
1 -
Section of Astrophysics Astronomy & Mechanics, Department of
Physics, University of Athens,
15783 Athens, Greece
2 -
Institute for Astronomy, University of Edinburgh,
Blackford Hill, Edinburgh EH9 3HJ, UK
3 -
Institute of Astronomy and Astrophysics, National Observatory of Athens, PO Box 20048,
11810 Athens, Greece
Received 28 June 2001 / Accepted 15 October 2001
Abstract
We investigate the spatial distribution of stars of different ages towards
the main body of the SMC, in an attempt to further understand the nature
of the complex structure of the SMC.
The old stellar population of the galaxy shows a rather regular and smooth
distribution which is typical for a spheroidal body. On the contrary, the
distribution of the younger stellar component is highly asymmetric and
irregular giving evidence for the severe impact of the SMC during its close
encounter with the LMC some 0.2 to 0.4 Gyr ago.
In a series of isodensity contour maps of stars within selected
ages, the recent structural evolution of the SMC is presented.
Key words: galaxies: Magellanic Clouds - galaxies: interactions - galaxies: evolution - galaxies: structure
The Magellanic Clouds are an ideal laboratory for studing
the consequences of galaxy interactions on the formation and evolution
of stellar populations. It is believed that they have been bound to
the Galaxy for at least the last 10 Gyr (Murai & Fujimoto 1980;
Fujimoto & Murai 1984),
during which time significant interactions between the LMC and the SMC
as well as between the Clouds and the Galaxy have led to structural
and kinematical peculiarities (Westerlund 1997).
In particular, the structure of the SMC is considered to have been
severely affected by the previous SMC perigalactic passage which
coincided with a close encounter between the Clouds 1.5 Gyr ago,
and also by the more recent close encounter between the Clouds some
0.2 to 0.4 Gyr ago (Gardiner & Noguchi 1996;
Kunkel et al. 2000). Consequently, various dynamical models
and simulations have been constructed to try to describe the mechanisms
dominating these interactions.
The SMC shows an asymmetric appearance with an irregular Bar and an eastern extension, while it is highly stretched along the line of sight; the Wing and the northeastern part of the Bar are closer than the southwestern regions (Mathewson et al. 1986, 1988; Hatzidimitriou & Hawkins 1989; Hatzidimitriou et al. 1993). Recently, Zaritsky et al. (2000) confirmed that this asymmetric structure is almost exclusively due to young main-sequence stars, the older stellar population showing an extremely regular distribution. The same conclusions were drawn by Cioni et al. (2000) from the DENIS near-infrared survey.
Even so, the structural evolution of the SMC is still obscure. There remain the questions of whether the so-called "Bar'' is simply the projection effect of a severely damaged galaxy along the line of sight or a real dynamical structure, and, if so, what could have caused it?
We have begun an investigation in order to further understand the structure of the SMC. As well as finding a regular distribution for the older stellar component and an asymmetric appearance for the younger stars, we show for the first time the evolution of the perturbations developed by the LMC-SMC interactions and give a possible explanation for the absence of an SMC rotational velocity.
In order to study the large-scale properties of nearby galaxies such as
the SMC, we need wide-field observational materal. So, for this work we
used direct photographic plates taken with the 1.2 m UK Schmidt Telescope
in the U, V and I wavebands. The plates cover an area of
in the plane of the sky centred on
,
(B1950). (This plate centre is ESO/SERC Survey
Field 29 which is offset somewhat from the main body of the SMC.)
The U plate is ideal for showing the young blue stars of the upper
main sequence and the I plate provides a good picture of the
old stellar component. The V plate is, of course intermediate between
these showing both main-sequence stars and large numbers of giants and
supergiants. Its primary use is to provide a plate that can be paired
with both U and I plates and so generate photometric colours.
A direct pairing of the U and I plates is not useful because
too many of the faint blue stars seen on U plate are not detected
on the I plate and vice versa.
![]() |
Figure 1: a) The (U, U-V) colour-magnitude diagram of stars detected in both U and V. There is a clear separation between the main sequence stars and the other stellar populations. (Only one tenth of the paired stars are plotted here.) |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 1: b) The (V, V-I) colour-magnitude diagram of stars detected in both V and I. There is a clear separation between the giant stars and the other stellar populations. (Only one tenth of the paired stars are plotted here.) |
Open with DEXTER |
All the plates were digitized using the fast measuring machine SuperCOSMOS in Edinburgh and catalogues of detected images were generated. We calibrated the instrumental stellar magnitudes for the U plate using photoelectric sequences by Butler (1972), the V plate using CCD photometric data from the Guide Star Photometric Catalogue II (Postman et al. 1997) and the I plate using a match with 4500 DENIS I-band measurements. The poorest calibration is for the faint end of the U data where the accuracy of the calibrating sequence is known to be poor. The U and V catalogues were then paired, as were the V and I catalogues. The pairing was carried out using standard SuperCOSMOS coordinate comparison techniques.
Histograms of of the calibrated magnitudes for each plate show that
completeness is good down to
mag,
mag
and
mag. The paired catalogues suffer from further
image loss through the pairing process. Statistics of the U-V pairing
show that the numbers of images unpaired are less than 5% of the total
detected between U=10 and U=18, 6% for U=18-19
and 19% for U=19-20. The higher level of pairing loss found for
the faintest range is due to the fact that the bluest of these faint
stars are too faint to be seen on the V plate. These numbers apply
to areas of the plate with relatively low stellar surface densities.
In the crowded parts they rise to 6%, 21% and 47% respectively.
The (U, U-V) and (V, V-I) colour magnitude diagrams are shown in Fig. 1. We have used these CMDs to select different stellar populations. The areas occupied by the main sequence and the red giants/supergiants are indicated by the lines drawn in Figs. 1a and 1b respectively. Figures 1a,b show clearly the incompleteness in the U-V paired data fainter than U=18.5 mag due to the cutoff of the V plate.
We then divided the stellar catalogues into subcatalogues according to the apparent magnitude of the stars and population type (colour index) as marked in Figs. 1 and 1b. We assigned an age to each magnitude "slice'' from the empirical CMD of main sequence stars (Zombeck 1990) as given by the U magnitude after allowing for the distance modulous of the SMC (m-M=19.0 according to Westerlund 1997). Using theoretical isochrones with various metallicities, we derived a range of ages which expresses the error given for each magnitude slice's age. The slice corresponding to the red giants was selected to represent stars older than 2 Gyr (Zombeck 1990).
![]() |
Figure 2:
Stellar density profiles of an east-west cross section around
![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
A first glance at the contour maps shows how stellar age changes the
spatial appearance of the SMC. It should be noted that the appearance of
the SMC north of
is not real but is due to
the proximity of the plate edge.
Figure 3 shows the old stellar population to be rather smooth
and regular, leading us to describe the SMC as a spheroidal system.
(The central region of the SMC in Fig. 3 was masked because
the high concentration of bright red stars distorts the very faint
population.) The spheroidal nature of the system can also be seen
in the density profile shown in Fig. 2a. It is consistent
with the distribution of other old stellar components, such as the
carbon stars (Morgan & Hatzidimitriou 1995) and the red
giants (Zaritsky et al. 2000). Nor is there any difference
between our data and the SMC morphology in I as given by Cioni et al.
(2000) for AGB and RGB stars down to their detection limit of
.
However, our data reach much fainter magnitudes
(
)
with a very good completeness factor. Although
these magnitudes have been derived from an extrapolation of the calibration
curve and consequently have a relatively large uncertainty, they
are good enough for us to be sure that Fig. 3
represents a very old SMC stellar population which show
no signs of tidal or hydrodynamical distortion.
Figures 4-9 which show the spatial distribution
of the blue stars, illustrate the "transition'' of an initially
spheroidal body to a highly asymmetric and irregular system. We can now
see many of the common features of the SMC that were absent from
Fig. 3, such as the Wing, the so-called
"SMC Bar'' and the Tail. Although Fig. 4 was produced
from a "slice'' which suffers from significantly greater incompleteness
than the others, it is included because it shows that both the Wing and
the Tail are already evident (
yr). The "Bar'' is most
prominent in Figs. 8 and 9.
![]() |
Figure 3:
Isodensity contour map of SMC giants (17<V<20 and
![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
This series of the isodensity maps (Figs. 5-9)
provides strong evidence for a subsequent fragmentation of
"star filaments'' in the area around
,
,
followed by a concentration of star formation in the south west part
of the SMC and in the Wing. It seems that the new generations of
stars preferentially appear along a Northeast-Southwest direction,
giving rise to the so-called Bar. Another interesting feature
seen in these maps is a rather circular concentration of stars, a "shell'',
centred on
,
,
also
mentioned by Zaritsky et al. (2000).
![]() |
Figure 4:
Isodensity contour map of main sequence stars with 19<U<20 and
-0.4<U-V<1.2, corresponding
approximately to age
![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 5:
Isodensity contour map of main sequence stars with 18<U<19 and
-0.8<U-V<0.7,
corresponding to age
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 6:
Isodensity contour map of main sequence stars with
17 < U < 18 and
-1.1<U-V<0.2,
corresponding to age
![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 7:
Isodensity contour map of main sequence stars with
16 < U < 17 and
-1.3<U-V<-0.2,
corresponding to age (1.2-3)
![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 8:
Isodensity contour map of main sequence stars with
15 < U < 16 and
-1.4<U-V<-0.6,
corresponding to age
![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 9:
Isodensity contour map of main sequence stars with U<15 and
-1.5<U-V<-0.8, corresponding to
age younger than
![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
These results are also evident in the cross-sections of Figs. 2b-d
which show the absolute star counts. For example, the counts
between positions
and
are approximately one
twentieth of the
peak counts associated with the Bar (at position
)
in the bright
"slices'', but rise by a factor of
13 to around two thirds of
the peak counts for the faint slice of Fig. 2d. Whilst, we
expect the greatest loss of image detection to be in the Bar region,
this differential loss cannot explain the observed thirteen-fold change
in the count ratio.
The asymmetric appearance of the young population of the SMC as seen here and by Zaritsky et al. (2000) and Cioni et al. (2000) is also consistent with the patterns of the associations, clusters and HII regions (Bica & Schmitt 1995). The distribution of the HI in the SMC (see Fig. 3 in Stanimirovic et al. 1999) is dominated by a central concentration associated with the optical Bar and an eastern Wing, with the Bar and the Wing being connected by a "bridge''; this pattern is also seen in Figs. 6-8. The fact that the old population has no signs of any of these features means that it has remained undisturbed by the recent LMC-SMC encounter. Therefore, forces other than just tidal must have played a key role in the dynamics of the HI and the evolution of the SMC.
According to the numerical simulations of Gardiner & Noguchi
(1996), many of the observed features of the SMC are the
result of the close encounter with the LMC 0.2-0.4 Gyr ago (or
0.3-0.4 Gyr - Kunkel et al. 2000).
Figure 4 clearly shows that at the time of
yr
the Wing and the Tail were already prominent features in the structure
of the SMC.
Comparing the isodensity maps of the SMC with those presented by Maragoudaki et al. (1998) for the LMC, it becomes clear that in each galaxy the distribution of stellar populations tends to become more regular and well ordered as its age increases. It is also evident that, at the time of close approach, the LMC Bar was already a well defined structure, in the contrast with the SMC. The interaction of the two galaxies also affected the structure of the LMC by triggering extended bursts of star formation, though in a less dramatic way than in the case of the SMC.
If we accept that we are witnessing the formation of a Bar in the SMC, then we have to explain the lack of angular momentum, since no obvious angular velocity has been so far observed (Kunkel et al. 2000). According to Gerin et al. (1990), special conditions of the geometry of the two interacting galaxies can lead to a decrease in the angular momentum of the one of the interacting bodies. However, it is not certain that this feature is a "genuine bar'', and not a temporary extended star burst region. In any case, additional velocity observations are needed to clarify the exact kinematical properties of the SMC. Improved numerical models also need to take into consideration hydrodynamic effects as well as tidal forces, to reproduce all the characteristics of the observed SMC structure through time.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank the referee D. Bomans for his constructive suggestions and critical comments. They would also like to express their thanks to the 1.2 m UK Schmidt Telescope Unit for the loan of the plates and the SuperCOSMOS for the digitization of them. Financial support for this project was provided by the British Council and the General Secretariat of Research and Technology.