A&A 378, 116-131 (2001)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20011098
A. Mora1 - B. Merín2 - E. Solano2 - B. Montesinos2,3 - D. de Winter4 - C. Eiroa1 - R. Ferlet5 - C. A. Grady6 - J. K. Davies7 - L. F. Miranda3 - R. D. Oudmaijer8 - J. Palacios1 - A. Quirrenbach9 - A. W. Harris10 - H. Rauer10 - A. Cameron11 - H. J. Deeg3 - F. Garzón12 - A. Penny13 - J. Schneider14 - Y. Tsapras11 - P. R. Wesselius15
1 - Departamento de Física Teórica, Módulo C-XI, Facultad de
Ciencias, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, 28049 Cantoblanco, Madrid, Spain
2 -
Laboratorio de Astrofísica Espacial y Física Fundamental (LAEFF),
Apartado de Correos 50727, 28080 Madrid, Spain
3 -
Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía-CSIC,
Apartado de Correos 3004, 18080 Granada, Spain
4 -
TNO/TPD-Space Instrumentation, Stieltjesweg 1, PO Box 155,
2600 AD Delft, The Netherlands
5 -
CNRS, Institut d'Astrophysique de Paris, 98bis Bld. Arago,
75014 Paris, France
6 -
NOAO/STIS, Goddard Space Flight Center, Code 681, NASA/GSFC,
Greenbelt, MD 20771, USA
7 -
Joint Astronomy Centre, 660 N. A'ohoku Place, Hilo, Hawaii 96720,
USA
8 -
Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Leeds,
Leeds LS2 9JT, UK
9 -
Department of Physics, Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences,
University of California San Diego, Mail Code 0424, La Jolla, CA 92093-0424,
USA
10 -
DLR Department of Planetary Exploration, Rutherfordstrasse 2,
12489 Berlin, Germany
11 -
Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of St. Andrews,
North Haugh, St. Andrews KY16 9SS, Scotland, UK
12 -
Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, c/Via Láctea s/n, 38200
La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain
13 -
Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, Chilton, Didcot, Oxfordshire OX11 0QX, UK
14 -
Observatoire de Paris, place Jules Janssen, 92195 Meudon, France
15 -
SRON, Universiteitscomplex "Zernike", Landleven 12,
PO Box 800, 9700 AV Groningen, The Netherlands
Received 2 April 2001 / Accepted 30 July 2001
Abstract
In this paper we present the first comprehensive results
extracted from the spectroscopic campaigns carried out by the EXPORT
(EXoPlanetary Observational Research Team) consortium. During 1998-1999,
EXPORT carried out an intensive observational effort in the framework of
the origin and evolution of protoplanetary systems in order to obtain
clues on the evolutionary path from the early stages of the pre-main
sequence to stars with planets already formed.
The spectral types of 70 stars, and the projected rotational velocities,
,
of 45 stars, mainly Vega-type and pre-main sequence, have
been determined from intermediate- and high-resolution spectroscopy,
respectively. The first part of the work is of fundamental importance in
order to accurately place the stars in the HR diagram and determine the
evolutionary sequences; the second part provides information on the
kinematics and dynamics of the stars and the evolution of their angular
momentum. The advantage of using the same observational configuration
and methodology for all the stars is the homogeneity of the set of
parameters obtained. Results from previous work are revised, leading in
some cases to completely new determinations of spectral types and
projected rotational velocities; for some stars no previous studies were
available.
Key words: stars: fundamental parameters - stars: pre-main sequence - stars: rotation
In the last few years interest in the formation and evolution of planetary systems has been boosted by the discovery of the first extrasolar planet orbiting around 51 Peg (Mayor & Queloz 1995). Since then, many planets have been detected and the number of new objects increases steadily.
In addition, the presence of infrared excesses in the spectral
distributions of Vega, Pic and other main-sequence stars is now
commonly accepted to be caused by dust particles in disks around these
objects (Aumann et al. 1984; Smith & Terrile 1984).
Transient spectroscopic events in the ultraviolet and optical lines of
Pic, and asymmetries in the shape of its disk, have been
interpreted in terms of infalling cometary bodies and even by the presence
of a planet around this star (Lecavelier des Étangs 2000).
There is mounting evidence of a clear evolutionary chain leading from
pre-main sequence stars (PMS hereafter) with infrared excesses in their
spectra, i.e. circumstellar envelopes or disks, to stars with planets
already formed (see e.g. Mannings et al. (ed.) 2000, part II).
Therefore, it is an attractive perspective to study the evolutionary
stellar path from the very early stages of pre-main sequence evolution,
where even a population of stars might be Pic progenitors (Grady
et al. 2000), to the main sequence, where, according to the
results of the radial velocity surveys, a fraction of the solar-type stars
may have massive planets. This was the philosophy behind the international
observing time at the observatories in the Canary Islands allocated in 1998
to the EXPORT (EXoPlanetary Observational Research Team) collaboration. A
large sample of PMS and main-sequence stars, was observed simultaneously
with four telescopes, collecting high and intermediate resolution
spectroscopy, optical and near-infrared photometry and polarimetry (Eiroa
et al. 2000; Eiroa et al. 2001; Oudmaijer et al.
2001).
One of the goals of the proposed research was to obtain detailed information on the evolution of protoplanetary disks, a prerequisite of which is the determination of physical parameters of the stars in order to accurately place them in a HR diagram and establish evolutionary sequences for objects with different masses. Therefore, the rational underlying the choice of the sample was to select a fairly large group of stars of different classes, namely Vega-type, Herbig Ae/Be, classical and early T Tauri, most of them archetypal and representative of their group, although obviously, not unique. The environments where these stars are placed are not related, because we wished to observe objects with different ages. There is a balance between cool and hot objects: Among the 70 stars observed in intermediate resolution, 26 are low-mass - spectral type F or later - objects, so they represent 37% of the whole sample.
In this paper we present the spectroscopic data of the stars in the sample observed. From these, we have determined the spectral types and the projected rotational velocities. The first is an essential step since a homogeneous classification of all the stars, using the same observational configuration, method and standards, is the most reliable way for obtaining a coherent set of parameters for the whole sample; in addition, some of the stars observed had poorly accurate or incomplete classifications. The determination of rotational velocities will have implications on the dynamics and kinematics of the potential disks and therefore on the evolution of the protoplanetary systems around the stars.
The layout of the paper is as follows. In Sect. 2 we give some notes on the nomenclature used in the paper. In Sect. 3 we describe the observations and the reduction procedures. In Sect. 4, we give details on the tools used and processes followed to carry out the spectral classification; the results of this classification are given and discussed. Section 5 is devoted to show the method used to determine the projected angular velocities and the results obtained. The final remarks are given in Sect. 6.
Through this work we will use some terminology that is worth clarifying. The PMS can be divided in a first approximation into T Tauri and Herbig Ae/Be stars. The former are the precursors of solar-type stars, with spectral types later than F0, whereas the latter are precursors of stars with an intermediate range of masses and have spectral types earlier than F0. Both of them show emission lines in their spectra. In their turn, the T Tauri stars can be grouped into classical T Tauri stars (CTTs), with spectral types G2 and later, and early-type T Tauri stars (ETTs), with spectral types between F0 and G2.
The so-called Post T Tauri stars are older than the CTTs but they have not yet reached the main sequence. From the infrared emission discovered around some Post T Tauri stars (Ray et al. 1995) and the radio emission, it has been inferred that the amount of dust in the disks around these stars is one or two orders of magnitude less than that in the disks around CTTs and Herbig Ae/Be. The specific PTT subset in the EXPORT sample was taken from Lindroos' catalogue (Lindroos 1986) of visual binary systems composed of a primary main-sequence star with an early spectral type and a late-type secondary thought to be in the PTT phase.
In the main sequence we distinguish between the Vega-type stars and the
A-shell stars. The Vega-type stars are named after their prototype,
Lyr, and are main-sequence stars with dusty disks - i.e. showing
infrared excess;
Pic is a typical Vega-type star. The A-shell
stars are A stars in fast rotation showing non-photospheric absorption
components in Ca II and in the Balmer lines, especially in H
.
Grady et al. (1996) detected, from ultraviolet spectra,
material falling onto this kind of star, showing that the accretion
phenomenon is not exclusive of the Vega-type stars. Finally, by MS we
denote normal main-sequence stars without any infrared excess in their
spectra.
![]() |
Figure 1:
The normalized average INT spectrum of BM And. Above the spectrum
we give the identification of some prominent lines: Na I 5890 and
5896 Å, Ca I 6102, 6122 and 6162 Å, Fe I 6495 Å and
Li I 6708 Å. Below the spectrum we show some other lines formed,
at least partially, in the interstellar or circumstellar medium: DIB's at
5780, 5797 and 6192 Å, He I 5875 Å and H![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
Intermediate resolution spectra obtained with the 2.5 m Isaac Newton Telescope (INT) and high resolution spectra obtained with the 4.2 m William Herschel Telescope (WHT), both at the Observatorio del Roque de los Muchachos (La Palma), were used for the spectral classification and for the determination of the rotational velocities, respectively. In the following two subsections we describe the details of each set of observations and some noteworthy aspects of the reduction procedures. A list of the stars observed with each telescope, dates and number of spectra, can be found in Tables 1 and 2. The reduced observations can be requested to EXPORT under certain conditions; please contact Carlos Eiroa (carlos.eiroa@uam.es) for details.
The observations were taken with the INT equipped with the Intermediate Dispersion Spectrograph (IDS) during four observing campaings: 14-17 May, 28-31 July, 23-27 October 1998 and 28-31 January 1999. This distribution of dates allowed us to do short-term (hours) and medium- to long-term (days, months) spectroscopic monitoring of the stars.
Two different instrumental setups were used. An EEV CCD was used in the May
1998 run, the spectral range covered from 5854 to 6728 Å, with a
resolving power of
.
An upgraded EEV CCD was used during the
other three observing runs. The wavelength coverage was 5712 to 6812 Å,
with a resolving power of
.
The slit width was always set to
1.0 arcsec projected on the sky.
During the four runs, 70 target stars were observed, and a total of 491 individual spectra collected; 28 spectroscopic standards were also observed (see Sect. 4). The standard extraction and reduction procedures were used and the spectra were normalized to their continua in order to carry out the spectral classification by comparing the relative intensity of spectral features of the target stars with the same features in a grid of standard stars (see Sect. 4). In Fig. 1 we show an example of a typical INT spectrum for one of the stars in the sample, the T Tauri star BM And with some line identifications.
![]() |
Figure 2:
The WHT merged spectrum of UX Ori. Some stellar lines affected by
circumstellar material are shown: H![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The high resolution spectra were obtained with the WHT equipped with the
Utrecht Echelle Spectrograph (UES). The observing runs coincided with
those above-mentioned for the INT, but two nights in the May run and
two in the October run were used for systematic monitoring of Boo
and 51 Peg (Harris et al. 2000).
UES was set to provide a wavelength coverage between 3800 and 5900 Å. The spectra were dispersed into 59 echelle orders with a resolving power of 49000. The slit width was set to 1.15 arcsec projected on the sky. A total of 47 stars were observed and 189 spectra obtained.
The echelle reduction procedure was divided into seven steps: order detection, background subtraction, filtering of cosmic rays, flat-field correction, spectrum extraction, wavelength calibration and blaze correction. The MIDAS echelle context was used to perform the first six stages, while the IRAF continuum fitter was selected to flatten the orders of the spectra.
The detection of the orders was performed using a bright standard star and
the Hough transform method. The background was modelled by a
two-dimensional cubic spline smooth surface, obtained by sampling the
inter-order space. Cosmic rays were detected and eliminated by comparing
every single spatial profile at every order with a local average profile.
The flat-field correction frames were obtained with a tungsten lamp. An
optimal extraction was performed defining a different numerical slit for
each target star, which gathered the light within a 3Gaussian interval around the centre of each order.
The wavelength calibration was done using Th-Ar and Fe-Ar arc lamp
exposures. The calibration errors are typically about 20 mÅ
( pixels) and lower than the spectral resolution
(
mÅ). The lower sensitivity at the order edges typical of
echelle spectra (blaze effect) was corrected by fitting the continuum of
the standard stars observed. A blaze function was derived for each order.
In Fig. 2 a WHT spectrum of the star UX Ori, including some
line identifications, is shown.
The determination of the precise spectral type of stars with circumstellar
material is extremely useful. The immediate result of the classification is
a derivation of the effective temperature that allows us to fix the
position of the star in the
axis of a luminosity-effective
temperature HR diagram. In addition, the comparison of the target spectra
with spectra of standard stars may reveal the presence of non-standard
features, which provide valuable information on the physical conditions of
the photospheres and the surrounding medium.
The spectral classification was done mainly by comparing the INT spectra of the target stars with spectra of standard stars obtained with the same or a very similar instrumental configuration.
Two sets of standard stars were used for the spectral classification: 28 standards observed with the INT during the four EXPORT campaigns; and a library of spectra of 116 late-type (F to M) field stars (Montes et al. 1997).
The instrumental configuration used to observe the standards with the INT was the same as the one used for the target stars. The spectra contained in the library compiled by Montes et al. (1997) were observed with different telescopes - the INT was one of them - and cover different spectral intervals with different resolutions. The closest configuration to those used during the EXPORT runs is the one labelled with number "8'' in the paper by Montes et al.; it covers the range 5626 to 7643 Å, therefore, it overlaps the spectral interval of the target stars completely, although the spectral resolution is lower (1.58 Å per pixel).
The first step in the classification procedure was a visual inspection of the average spectrum and each one of the individual target spectra. This analysis allowed us to identify significant changes in the spectral type, which lines are variable, the presence of permitted and forbidden lines appearing in emission, and lines caused by interstellar absorption.
The spectra of the standard stars were broadened with the rotation profile
corresponding to the target star, and then a comparison among them was
carried out. When available, values of
obtained by us (see Sect. 5) were used; otherwise, published values were taken at this point.
This usually provided quite an exact determination of the spectral type.
In some cases the classification was assigned by bracketing the spectrum of
the target star between those of two standards with slightly different
spectral types, taking the mean as the correct result. In Fig. 3 we can see an example of the efficiency of this step. In
the upper panel the spectrum of the target star HD 199143 (solid line) is
shown along with the spectrum of the slow-rotator (
km s-1)
standard star HR 4606 (F6 V) (dotted line); in the lower panel, the
spectrum of the standard has been broadened with a rotation profile
km s-1. The match with the spectrum of the problem star is
remarkable.
![]() |
Figure 3:
Upper panel: the spectrum of HD 199143 (solid line) and the
spectrum of a slow-rotator standard star HR 4606 (F6 V) (dotted line).
Lower panel: the spectrum of the standard has been broadened with
![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The presence of veiling in some of the stars in the sample, mainly CTTs, poses an additional difficulty in the determination of spectral types. Since the effect of veiling is a global weakening, or even the disappearance of the absorption features in the spectral region affected, the comparison of a spectrum affected by veiling with the grid of spectra of normal stars would lead to the derivation of an earlier spectral type to the target star instead of the correct one, therefore this effect must be treated properly. We illustrate this problem with a typical case, that of DR Tau, in Sect. 4.4.
Some additional tools may be applied for confirming the spectral
classification of these stars. One of them is the use of ultraviolet
spectra. For those objects observed with IUE (International
Ultraviolet Explorer), a
comparison with synthetic energy distributions computed using the ATLAS9
code (Kurucz 1993) was done. The ultraviolet spectra provided by
IUE are calibrated in absolute flux, so a direct comparison, after
correcting for reddening, with the synthetic models was feasible.
The IUE spectra themselves have been used to estimate
,
taking advantage of the wide feature in absorption around 2200 Å caused
by the interstellar medium. The process consisted of correcting the
spectra for reddening with different values of
until the
absorption feature disappeared; at this point that particular value of
was assigned to the star. The Galactic extinction law by
Howarth (1983) was used. This method is applicable only when there
is a substantial amount of flux in the continuum around 2200 Å, i.e. it
is only suitable for stars hotter than F0. Otherwise, published values of
the colour excesses were used. In Table 3 we give the values of
the colour excesses and their uncertainties determined in this way; in the
last column values of
computed as
are given, being
the
colour index of a standard with the same spectral type as the target star.
An uncertainty of 0.05 in the colour index leads to an error in the
classification of three subtypes, so the more dubious confirmation of the
spectral type following this method would be for VX Cas.
In 27 stars, this confirmed the spectral type obtained from the optical
spectra. The use of IUE spectra is particularly powerful for
Vega-type and A-shell stars since the spectral region covered
(1150-3350 Å) is not affected by excesses or veiling. In the
remaining cases, an accurate determination of the spectral type in the
ultraviolet requires the knowledge of these peculiar features (Catala &
Bertout 1990; Valenti et al. 2000) and also of the
potential variability of the object in this range. In any case, the fact must
be taken into account that the IUE spectra are not simultaneous with
the EXPORT observations. Different determinations of the spectral type from
optical and ultraviolet observations might be attributable to long-term
intrinsic variability of the stars.
Star |
![]() |
![]() |
HD 58647 | 0.16 ![]() |
0.16 |
HD 179218 | 0.10 ![]() |
0.08 |
VX Cas | 0.30 ![]() |
0.26 |
17 Sex | 0.07 ![]() |
0.02 |
WW Vul | 0.20 ![]() |
0.30 |
![]() |
Figure 4: An example of fitting of synthetic energy distributions (dashed lines) to the IUE spectrum of a Vega type star, HD 109085 (solid line). The two models correspond to spectral types F1 V (top) and F3 V (bottom). The original models were normalized to the target spectrum and shifted for clarity. The spectral type derived for HD 109085 from optical spectra is F2 V. |
Open with DEXTER |
In Fig. 4 we can see an example of a fit, in the ultraviolet range, of two synthetic Kurucz's models to the spectrum of HD 109085, a Vega-type star with a spectral type F2 V as determined from the comparison with optical spectra of standards. We show the ordinates in logarithmic units. The two models (dashed lines) correspond to spectral types F1 V (top) and F3 V (bottom) and were computed with the solar abundance. The synthetic energy distributions were normalized to the target spectrum (solid line) and shifted 0.7 dex up and down for clarity. The similarity of the synthetic spectra with the energy distribution of the target star is remarkable.
The derivation of the luminosity class was also done by comparing the
target spectra with those of standards with different luminosity classes.
A consistent check of this parameter can also be obtained by estimating, if
possible, the absolute magnitude MV of each star, and then comparing it
with standard values of that magnitude for standard stars of different
luminosity classes. One must be cautious with the results obtained
following this method since we are comparing magnitudes of stars with
peculiar features with magnitudes of standard, normal stars. MV can be
easily found from V and the distance (parallax), provided the colour
excess
is known. A total of 38 stars have parallaxes available
from Hipparcos, these have been retrieved from SIMBAD
.
In general, the comparison between the spectra of the target stars and the
standards has made use of all the lines present, excluding only those whose
origin was clearly circumstellar or interstellar. Particular care was taken
in excluding the so-called DIB's (diffuse interstellar bands) at the
following wavelengths: 5780, 5797, 5850, 6196, 6234, 6270, 6284, 6369, 6376
and 6614 Å (Schmidt-Kaler 1982; Moutou et al. 1999).
Line identification | Spectral types |
Ca I 6102 Å | |
Ca I 6122 Å | K0 V-K5 V |
Fe II 6129 Å | |
Fe I 6546 Å | F0 V-F9 V |
N II 6596 Å | |
Ca I 6162 Å | |
Fe I 6136 Å | F0 V-M0 V |
Fe I 6677 Å | |
Ca I/Fe I 6494 Å |
In Table 4 we list some specific lines especially useful for classifying late-type stars (F to M) due to their gradual variation in intensity as one moves from earlier to later spectral types. We show in the table the interval of spectral types where the changes in intensity are significant for discriminating between similar types. In addition to these lines, the molecular bands TiO and VO appear in the spectra of late-type stars cooler than K7 V and their depth increases for later spectral types. Further information on lines useful for classifying this kind of object in other spectral intervals can be found in Cohen & Kuhi (1979), Schmidt-Kaler (1982) and Jaschek & Jaschek (1990).
For hot stars (B and A) the He I lines at 5875 and 6678 Å have been used to confirm the B types when these lines are clearly photospheric, i.e., when no significant changes were observed when comparing spectra of the same star obtained on different dates. The presence of variability in these lines probably indicates that they are formed in the circumstellar environment and therefore they are not appropriate for classification.
The classification is based on comparisons of the target spectra with those of standards broadened with the rotational profile corresponding to the target star. Therefore, when the projected rotational velocity is of the order of 200 km s-1 or larger, the lines in the spectra are blended and it is not possible to carry out a comparison line by line of both sets of spectra, although a comparison of the broad features is still feasible. In that case, it is possible to give an estimate of the spectral type but with around five subtypes of error; the use of IUE spectra could help to classify these stars, since the shape of the continuum is not very much affected by the high rotational velocity, although, as we mention in Sect. 4.1, the lack of simultaneity between the ultraviolet and optical observations could lead to the assignment of different spectral types if some kind of variability is present. The uncertainties in the fitting of Kurucz's synthetic models to the ultraviolet spectra arise mainly from the fact that some ultraviolet excess may be present, as it is observed in some T Tauri and Herbig Ae/Be stars. In these cases we have not attempted any fit, thus avoiding a wrong classification of the star.
Another source of error in the determination of the spectral type of a young star is the potential variability in the equivalent width and shape of the lines and even the appearance and disappearance of some lines in intervals of a few days due to intense circumstellar activity. Therefore, it is very important to have several spectra of the same star, obtained with enough separation in time to distinguish which lines are photospheric and which are formed in the circumstellar environment.
The phenomenon of veiling can be defined as the superposition of a continuum on the stellar spectrum proper. The interpretation of this phenomenon is a matter of debate and different scenarios have been proposed in the last few years. It is not whithin the scope of this paper to discuss which one is the most physically sound.
It is clear that this effect must be taken into account when attempting to classify a PMS star. A star with strong veiling would have spectral lines attenuated with respect to the global continuum, therefore one would tend to use standard stars corresponding to an earlier spectral type - compared with the real one - since these show fewer and less intense lines than the spectra of late-type templates.
In a first step of our work, five stars in the sample, namely HR 26 B, HR
5422 B, BO Cep, CW Tau and DR Tau, were classified with spectral types much
earlier than those reported in previous studies. This led us to consider
the effect of veiling in their spectra. DR Tau has been studied
extensively and a strong veiling has been reported, as we explain in detail
below; CW Tau shows veiling in the near infrared range (Folha & Emerson
1999). For HR 26 B, HR 5422 B and BO Cep, it turned out that a
classification taking into account veiling effects was much more accurate.
In Table 5 we give the values for the veiling we have found
for these five stars with their correspondent uncertainties. Note the
variability in DR Tau from October 1998 to January 1999.
Star | Veiling |
HR 26 B | 0.1 ![]() |
HR 5422 B | 0.3 ![]() |
BO Cep | 1.0 ![]() |
CW Tau | 0.7 ![]() |
DR Tau (Oct) | 1.0 ![]() |
DR Tau (Jan) | 3.0 ![]() |
Hessman & Guenther (1997) give a detailed description of how the
veiling can be parametrized (see Sect. 4 of their paper). We have used as
a working definition of veiling the ratio between the non-stellar to the
stellar continuum. In order to classify the stars with veiling we have
added a flat continuum to the spectra of the grid of standards with several
values of the veiling, in the sense described above, and normalizing
afterwards to unity again. Given the subtle difference among these spectra,
it is impossible to decide only by visual inspection which one is the
closest to the target spectrum. To overcome this difficulty we have carried
out cross correlations between the target spectrum and the grid of standard
stars, both unaffected and affected by veiling, in order to determine the
correct spectral type.
![]() |
Figure 5: Two examples of classification of stars with veiling. Upper panel: from top to bottom, the spectra of DR Tau obtained in January 1999 and October 1998, the spectrum of a standard K5 V with a veiling of 1.0 (see text for details) and a standard F6 V, which was the first choice for the spectral type before veiling was considered. Lower panel: the spectra of HR 26 B, a standard K0 V with a veiling of 0.1 and the spectrum of a G7 V standard. |
Open with DEXTER |
We show in Fig. 5 two examples of this process. In the
upper panel the average INT spectrum of DR Tau obtained in October 1998
(thick line) is compared with both the spectrum of a K5 V standard affected
by a veiling of 1.0 (i.e. a flat continuum has been added to the spectrum
with the same level as the stellar continuum), and the spectrum of a F6 V
standard which could lead to erroneous classification if veiling is not
considered. The three spectra are normalized and the standards have been
shifted downwards for clarity. At the very top of the graph the spectrum of
DR Tau obtained in January 1999 is shown, shifted upwards. A similar
comparison is done for the star HR 26 B in the lower panel. It can be seen
how subtle the differences are, especially in the case of HR 26 B, which
can easily lead, if one is not careful enough, to a wrong determination of
the spectral type.
![]() |
Figure 6:
Five examples of the final results of the spectral classification.
The spectra of the target stars are drawn with thicker lines, the
spectra of the standards have been shifted down 0.35 units for clarity.
From top to bottom, BD+31 643 (Vega type) and the standard HR 930 (B5 V)
broadened with
![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
We have very accurately determined the spectral type of the 70 stars observed with the INT. Out of them, 58 stars (83%) have been classified with an error less than two spectral subtypes and 12 (17%) with an error of up to five spectral subtypes. 31 stars (43%) now have a new spectral type from our work, this means that the former spectral types are outside the error bars of our new determination or that we have different or new information about the luminosity class.
In Fig. 6 we show some representative examples of the
spectral classification of several types of stars in the sample. From top
to bottom we can see the spectra of BD+31 643 (Vega type), HR 10 (A-shell
star), HD 190073 (Herbig Ae/Be), CO Ori (early T Tauri) and LkH
200
(classical T Tauri) (thick lines) and the spectra of the standards,
broadened with the corresponding rotation profiles, (thin lines, shifted
0.35 units down in the intensity scale), that give the best fits to the
target spectra.
In Table 6 we give the result of the spectral classification for the 70 target stars. Column 1 is the star identification, Col. 2 gives the class of star, in Cols. 3 and 4 we give the result of our classification and those from previous work, respectively. The class of star (Col. 2) for each object has been assigned according to the spectral types found in this work. We have adopted the criterion of assigning a main-sequence type to the primary stars of the Lindroos' binaries and a PTT type to the secondary stars.
Almost all the PMS in the sample present spectral variability. Some
non-photospheric features appearing in the spectra are: H
in
emission, forbidden emission lines ([O I] 6300 Å, [O I] 6363 Å, [S II] 6716 Å, [S II] 6731 Å, [N II] 6583 Å,
[N II] 6548 Å and [N II] 6527 Å) which may be related
to winds; and variable lines of He I 5875 Å, 6678 Å and Na I D1 D2 5890, 5896 Å that may be produced in the
circumstellar environment.
In this subsection we comment on the stars marked with an asterisk in Table 6 and also on those showing some peculiarity.
HD 58647, HD 141569, HD 163296, HR 2174 and VX Cas have very high projected
rotational velocities and show many non-photospheric features in their
spectra. VY Mon also shows a lot of circumstellar or interstellar lines
contaminating its spectrum; V1686 Cyg and VV Ser show very variable
emission lines; MWC 297 has very few useful lines in absorption for
classification due to the blends caused by its high
(
km s-1, Drew et al. 1997); HD 123160, RR Tau and LkH
262
show changes in the continuum in time spans of days to months; HR 26 B, HR 5422 B, BO Cep, CW Tau and DR Tau show veiling that attenuate the
absorption lines.
In addition, HK Ori shows a composite spectrum from a non-resolved binary system; HR 10 has an INT spectrum classified as a A0 Vn but shows an IUEspectrum only compatible with a G1 V Kurucz model.
HD 23362 and HD 233517, thought to be Vega-type stars, are now classified according to our analysis as K-type giant stars and under the hypothesis that they are PMS stars, they should be considered as CTT objects. However, this classification must be taken with caution; Castilho et al. (1998) and Balachandran et al. (2000) classify these stars as post-main sequence giants, with the peculiarity of both being Lithium rich.
One of the major gaps in our understanding of stellar physics is the role of angular momentum in the formation and early life of a star. Two problems of great interest are the transport of angular momentum in collapsing interstellar clouds and the subsequent braking of young stars during the PMS contraction. Accurate rotational velocities of young stars are essential for further progress in these areas. Also, the knowledge of the behaviour of the distribution of rotational velocities as a function of the spectral type puts important constraints on models of the stellar angular momentum evolution and provides information on what physical process controls the rotational velocity across the HR diagram.
Different methods have been developed to calculate rotational velocities,
all of them relying, to some extent, on the geometrical technique,
suggested originally by Shajn & Struve (1929), that relates line
profiles and line widths to the apparent rotational velocity, .
Until the advent of solid-state detectors about two decades ago, most of
the rotational velocities were determined by measurements of one or two
relatively strong lines. The method consisted in identifying a particular
point on the line profile (usually the full width at half maximum) and
calibrating this parameter in terms of a rotational standard. Although
helpful in identifying older sources of
measurements, catalogues
such as those of Bernacca & Perinotto (1970) and Uesugi &
Fukuda (1982) pose serious problems because they attempt to
combine observations that have different resolutions obtained with a
variety of techniques.
Star | Type of star | Spectral type | Previous classifications | ![]() |
![]() |
Previous work | |||||
HD 23362 | CTT | K5 IIIm | K2 V, K2 | 6 ![]() |
|
HD 23680 | CTT | G5 IV | G5 | ||
HD 31293 | 97 ![]() |
80 ![]() |
|||
HD 31648 | HAeBe | A5 Vep | A3ep+sh, A3ep+sh, A2 | 102 ![]() |
80(1) |
HD 34282 | HAeBe | A3 Vne | A2 Ve+sh, A0e, A0 | 129 ![]() |
|
HD 34700 | ETT | G0 IVe | G0 V | 46 ![]() |
|
HD 58647* | HAeBe | B9 IVep | A0 IVe, B9 II-IIIe, B9e | 118 ![]() |
|
HD 109085 | Vega | F2 V | F2 V, F3 V, F2 III-IV | 68 ![]() |
51(2), 81(3) |
HD 123160* | CTT | K5 III | G5 V, K5 | 7.8 ![]() |
9 ![]() |
HD 141569 | HAeBe | A0 Vev | A0 Ve, B9.5 Ve, B9e | 258 ![]() |
236 ![]() |
HD 142666 | HAeBe | A8 Ve | A7 V, A8 V, A8 Ve | 72 ![]() |
70 ![]() |
HD 142764 | Vega | K7 V | K5 | 7.8 ![]() |
|
HD 144432 | HAeBe | A9 IVev | A7 Ve, A9/F0 V, A7 Ve | 85 ![]() |
74 ![]() |
HD 150193 | HAeBe | A2 IVe | A2 Ve, A1 V, A1 Ve | ||
HD 158352 | MS | A8 Vp | A7/8 V+sh, A8 Vsh | ||
HD 163296 | HAeBe | A1 Vepv | A3 Vep+sh, A1 V, A0-A2 | 133 ![]() |
120(6) |
HD 179218 | HAeBe | A0 IVe | B9/A0 IV/Ve, B0e | ||
HD 190073 | HAeBe | A2 IVev | B9/A0 Vp+sh, A0 IV esh | ||
HD 199143 | MS | F6 V | F6 V | 155 ![]() |
|
HD 203024 | MS | A5 V | Ae | ||
HD 233517 | CTT | K5 III | K2, A2 | 16 ![]() |
15(7), 17.6(19) |
HR 10 | Ash | A0 Vn | A2 V-A5 V, A6 Vn | 294 ![]() ![]() |
220(8), 195(9) |
HR 26 A | MS | B9 Vn | B9 Vn, B8.5 Vnn | 266 ![]() |
275(10) |
HR 26 B | PTT | K0 V | G5 Ve | ||
HR 419 | 162 ![]() |
||||
HR 1847 | Vega | B5 V | B7 IIIe | ||
HR 2174* | Vega | A2 Vnv | A3 Vn, A1 IV-sh, A3 V | 252 ![]() |
|
HR 4757 A | MS | B9.5 V | B9.5 V | 239 ![]() |
205(11) |
HR 4757 B | PTT | K2 V | K0 V, K2 Ve, K1 V | 5.7 ![]() |
|
HR 5422 A | MS | A0 V | A0 V, B9.2p, B9 Vp | 7.4 ![]() |
14(12), 20(13) |
HR 5422 B | PTT | K0 V | K1 V | ||
HR 9043 | Vega | A5 Vn | A5 V, A3 Vn | 205 ![]() |
210(8) |
AS 442 | HAeBe | B8 Ve | B8e | ||
BD+31 643 | Vega | B5 V | B5, B5 V | 162 ![]() ![]() |
|
MWC 297* | HAeBe | B1 Ve | O9e, Be, B1.5, 09 | ||
BM And | CTT | K5 Ve | K5 V | ||
![]() |
Vega | A1 V | A0 Vpsh, A0p | 129 ![]() |
100(14) |
VX Cas | HAeBe | A0 Vep | A0/3e, A0, A3, A0e | 179 ![]() |
|
BH Cep | ETT | F5 IIIev | A/F5 Ve, F5 IVvar | 98 ![]() |
|
BO Cep | CTT | F5 Ve | F2e, F2e | ||
SV Cep | HAeBe | A2 IVe | A0e, A | 206 ![]() |
|
49 Cet | Vega | A4 V | A3 V, A1 V | 186 ![]() |
|
24 CVn | Ash | A4 V | A5 V, A4 V, A5.5 A | 173 ![]() |
145(3), 160(1) |
V1685 Cyg | HAeBe | B2 Ve | B2 Ve+sh, B2, B2 Ve | ||
V1686 Cyg* | HAeBe | A4 Ve | G2 V, A0 V, A7 V | ||
R Mon | HAeBe | B8 IIIev | B0e, B.., B2 | ||
VY Mon* | HAeBe | A5 Vep | B9/A0e, B8, B-A | ||
51 Oph | HAeBe | B9.5 IIIe | A0 V, B9.5 Ve,A0 II-III(e) | 256 ![]() ![]() |
267(4) |
KK Oph | HAeBe | A8 Vev | B3, B-Ae, A5 Ve, A6 | 177 ![]() ![]() |
|
T Ori | HAeBe | A3 IVev | A3/4e, A3, B9, A5 e | 175 ![]() |
130 ![]() |
BF Ori | HAeBe | A2 IVev | A5/6 IIIe+sh, A5e, A6e | 37 ![]() |
100(15) |
CO Ori | ETT | F7 Vev | F9/G Ve, F9: e, F8 | 65 ![]() |
48 ![]() |
HK Ori* | ETT | G1 Ve | A5, A4, G:ep, B8/A4ep | ||
NV Ori | ETT | F6 IIIev | F0/8 IVe, F 4/0 III,V | 81 ![]() |
80 ![]() |
RY Ori | ETT | F6 Vev | F6/Gep, F8:pe | 66 ![]() |
Star | Type of star | Spectral type | Previous classifications | ![]() |
![]() |
Previous work | |||||
UX Ori | HAeBe | A4 IVe | A3e, A2/3 IIIe, A1-3IIIe | 215 ![]() |
175(17), 70 ![]() |
V346 Ori | HAeBe | A2 IV | F1:III:e, A5 III:e | ||
V350 Ori | HAeBe | A2 IVe | A5e, A0 | ||
XY Per | HAeBe | A2 IV | B6/A5e, B6, A2 II+B6e | 217 ![]() |
|
VV Ser* | HAeBe | A0 Vevp | A2e, B1-3e:, B1/3e/A2: | 229 ![]() ![]() |
|
17 Sex | Ash | A0 V | A1 V, A1 Vsh, A5 | 259 ![]() ![]() |
180(3) |
CQ Tau | ETT | F5 IVe | F2:e, A8 IV/F2 IVe | 105 ![]() |
110 ![]() |
CW Tau* | CTT | K3 Ve | K3, K5 V:e | ||
DK Tau | CTT | K5 Ve | M0 V:e, K7 V, K7 | ||
DR Tau* | CTT | K5 Vev | K4 V:e | ||
RR Tau* | HAeBe | A0 IVev | F:e, A2 II-IIIe, B8ea | 225 ![]() ![]() |
|
RY Tau | ETT | F8 IIIev | F8 V:e, K1 IV, G5e, K7 | 55 ![]() |
52(18) |
PX Vul | ETT | F3 Ve | F0 V:e, F0, F5 | ||
WW Vul | HAeBe | A2 IVe | A3e, A0/3 Ve, A0, A1e | 220 ![]() |
|
LkH![]() |
CTT | K3 Ve | K1 V, Ke, dK0 | ||
LkH![]() |
HAeBe | B5 Vev | B5.7e, B5/7, B9/A0e, A7 | ||
LkH![]() |
CTT | M1 IIIe | K?, M0 |
Notes to Table 6: The meanings of the lower case
suffixes are: "e'' emission lines, "v'' variable spectrum, "p'' peculiar
spectrum (presence of non-standard components), "n'' broad or weak lines
in the spectrum, "m'' unexpected lines from metals or metal lines with
unusually large strengths.
The abbreviations in Col. 2 mean: CTT (classical T Tauri), ETT (early T
Tauri), HAeBe (Herbig Ae/Be), MS (main sequence), PTT (Post-T Tauri) and
Ash (A-shell star). The stars marked with an asterisk (*) have been
classified with an error of about five spectral subtypes because they
present peculiar spectra, too many diffuse interstellar bands or veiling.
In Sect. 4.6 we give particular details on these stars.
A blank in Col. 5 means that the star was not observed with the WHT,
furthermore no determination of
was feasible. The symbol
indicates that
has been obtained using only the Mg II 4481
Å line.
References to
in Col. 6: (1) Jaschek et al. (1988);
(2) Wolff & Simon (1997); (3) Abt & Morrel (1995);
(4) Dunkin et al. (1997); (5) Fekel (1997); (6) van
den Ancker et al. (1998); (7) Jasniewicz et al.
(1999); (8) Welsh et al. (1998); (9) Lecavelier des
Etangs et al. (1997); (10) Ghosh et al. (1999); (11)
Baade (1989); (12) Ramella et al. (1989); (13)
Millward & Walker (1985); (14) Paunzen et al.
(1999); (15) Böhm & Catala (1995); (16)
Fernández & Miranda (1998); (17) Grady et al.
(1996); (18) Petrov et al. (1999);
(19) Balachandran et al. (2000).
![]() |
Figure 7:
Determination of projected rotational velocities via Fourier
transform. Left panel: influence of rotational broadening on spectral
lines. The synthetic line Fe I 4476 Å is shown for different
broadenings. Right panel: Fourier transforms and their relation with
rotational velocities. The frequency used to calculate ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 8: The spectra of DR Tau and HK Ori. The position of the Mg II 4481 Å line is shown for clarity. |
Open with DEXTER |
In this paper, we make use of the technique proposed by Gray
(1992). In short, the method is based on the relation between
and the frequencies where the Fourier transform of the rotational
profile reaches a relative minimum: the dominant term in the Fourier
transform of the rotational profile is a first-order Bessel function that
produces a series of relative minima at regularly spaced frequencies (Fig. 7). Unlike the above-mentioned methods which require the
building up of a calibration library of rotational velocities, Gray's
method provides a direct measurement of
.
Moreover, it also allows
the differentiation of rotation from other potential competing broadening
sources such us, for instance, macroturbulence in late-type stars.
Projected rotational velocities, in km s-1, calculated using the high
resolution spectra taken with the WHT are given in Col. 5 of Table 6; results from previous work are shown in Col. 6. Metallic
lines of photospheric origin covering the full wavelength range and whose
main source of broadening is rotation were used in this analysis.
Projected rotational velocities were not calculated for two stars of our sample: DR Tau and HK Ori (Fig. 8). DR Tau shows, in the range covered by the WHT observations, a spectrum of complex nature characterized by the absence of absorption photospheric features caused by a high degree of veiling, whereas HK Ori is a visual and spectroscopic binary showing a composite spectrum where the contribution of a companion classified as a T Tauri star is superimposed (Corporon & Lagrange 1999) (see Sect. 4.6).
In general, our results agree with those found in previous work. There
are, however, some cases where clear discrepancies are apparent. Figure 9 shows those stars for which our
values are clearly
discrepant with previous determinations. In all cases our values produce
better fits to the observations. Also, in some other cases, the blending is
so severe that only one spectral line, Mg II 4481 Å, can be
used to determine the rotational velocity. These objects are labelled with
"
'' in Table 6. The Mg II 4481 Å doublet
is considered an ideal indicator in these cases as it is free of strong
pressure broadening and yet is strong enough that the rotation-broadened
profile can be easily measured. Moreover, the large rotational broadening
means that the 0.20 Å splitting of the doublet is not a problem.
![]() |
Figure 9:
Comparison between the observed spectrum and a synthetic spectrum
generated with ATLAS9 (1993) convolved with the labelled
rotational velocities. In all cases, our ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 10:
Influence of the intrinsic profile of blended features on the
Fourier transform. The observed spectrum (solid line) is compared to a
synthetic spectrum (dotted line) with similar physical parameters
(
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
Limb darkening: According to Eq. (17.12) of Gray
(1992), one of the uncertainties in the calculation of
comes from the limb-darkening law. In this work, a linear law with
has been assumed. Following Díaz-Cordovés &
Giménez (1992), the difference in the total emergent flux
between the linear and the quadratic laws is less than 5% in the range of
temperatures of our programme stars. Moreover, the dependence of
with wavelength is also negligible: according to Díaz-Cordovés
et al. (1995), we expect a variation in
of 0.55
0.85 in our range of temperatures, gravities
and wavelengths. Solano & Fernley (1997) demonstrated that such
a variation implies, in the worst case, a change in
of less than 5%.
Continuum placement: The determination of the local continuum
is another unavoidable source of error: a displacement in the continuum
level can change the line profile, especially the wings, and thus distort
the shape of the Fourier transform, modifying the position of its zeroes.
Many objects in our sample have broad line profiles typical of high
values. In this case, the continuum placement cannot be set by simply
connecting the highest points in the observed spectrum since this would
produce an underestimation of the equivalent widths. This problem was
solved by defining the "true'' continuum level as that of a synthetic
spectrum of physical parameters similar to those of the observed object.
Blending: The high
values of many of the stars of our
sample make it very difficult to apply the method to isolated lines.
Blended features were used instead. A careful inspection using synthetic
spectra was performed to avoid contamination in the Fourier domain due to
the intrinsic profile of the blended features (Fig. 10).
Sampling frequency: Another limiting factor in the calculation
of
is the sampling frequency. Defining this frequency as
and considering the spectral resolution quoted in Sect. 3, a minimum value of
6 km s-1 can be achieved.
Hence, for stars with
lower than this value it is not possible to
calculate a proper value of
but only an upper limit (Table 6).
The stellar angular momentum is known to change dramatically along the
evolutionary sequence. This is particularly relevant for T Tauri stars for
which a large angular momentum loss is expected during the early stages of
the star formation, where rotational velocities might decrease from values
near break-up, typical of protostars, to velocities in the range from less
than 10 km s-1 up to 30 km s-1 with a mean value about 15 km s-1 for a 1
T Tauri star (Vogel & Kuhi 1981). Within the T Tauri
stars it is also possible to find statistically significant differences
between classical (CTTs) and weak (WTTs) T Tauri stars in the sense that
the latter rotate faster suggesting a different rotational evolution
(Bouvier et al. 1993). These differences can be interpreted as
an evidence of the spinning-up of the WTTs as they contract while CTTs are
prevented from doing so by e.g. strong winds or magnetic coupling between
the star and the inner accretion disk. Solar-mass ZAMS stars in young
stellar clusters represent the subsequent step in the evolutionary
scenario. Contrary to TTs, these stars exhibit a much larger range of
, peaked at low velocities (typically 10 km s-1) with a wide
high-velocity tail up to 200 km s-1 (Allain et al. 1996). The
question of how to account for the rotational distribution of ZAMS stars
starting from that of TTs is not well understood yet. Bouvier et al.
(1993) proposed linking the observed rotational distribution of
ZAMS stars with the two T Tauri subclasses: according to this, WTTs and
CTTs would be the progenitors of the ZAMS fast and slow rotators
respectively. Shortly after their arrival on the ZAMS, solar-type stars
are then drastically braked and, at the age of the Hyades, (600 Myr) have
rotation rates lower than 10 km s-1 irrespective of the initial angular
momentum (Endal & Sofia 1981).
![]() |
Figure 11: Distribution of rotational velocities as a function of the spectral type. |
Open with DEXTER |
The use of projected rotational velocities in the determination of the
rotational properties of stars is limited by the unknown geometric effect
included in .
Moreover, the number of
determinations,
too low for a statistically significant analysis, is an additional limiting
factor in our study. Nevertheless, it is possible to interpret the observed
distribution in a qualitative way. Figure 11 displays the
rotational velocities of our program stars as a function of their spectral
type as given in Table 6. For comparison, we have also plotted
mean rotational velocities of B, A-type stars (solid line, Fukuda
1982), F, G-type stars (dotted line, Fekel 1997) and
Be stars (dashed line, Steele et al. 1999) of luminosity class
V. Two stars appear to be clearly discrepant in this figure: HR 5422 A (A0
V,
= 7.4 km s-1) and BF Ori (A2 IVev,
= 37 km s-1 ). HR 5422 A is a
Am star in a double system (Ramella et al 1989) whereas the
value of BF Ori is confirmed by the large number of data used in the
analysis (four spectra in two different observing runs with 8, 12, 15 and
13 lines used respectively) which suggests that the low
value may be
due to an inclination effect.
One of the results that can be deduced from Fig. 11 is
that the PMS stars tend to rotate faster than stars in the main sequence
with similar spectral types. The qualitative behaviour in the overall
distribution of
for pre-main sequence and main sequence stars is
similar, namely, rotation is large for early-type stars dropping rapidly
through the F-stars region. In the main sequence stars, this behaviour is
tied in with the appearance of convective envelopes and the magnetic brake
generated by its interaction with rotation in the dynamo process. Dudorov
et al. (1994) proposed a similar hypothesis for PMS stars
where the sudden transition in spin rates at F-spectral types would also
occur as a consequence of the onset of a magnetic field in the star
envelopes. Figure 11 also confirms the basic conclusions
from Finkenzeller (1985) concerning the distribution of
the projected rotational velocities of Herbig Ae/Be stars: Herbig Ae/Be
stars are depleted of slow rotators and rotate at intermediate velocities
systematically more rapidly than T Tauri stars.
For F-G spectral types, a clear difference in
between the PMS stars
and their counterparts of luminosity class V can be deduced from Fig. 11. Concerning the B, A-types, there is a smooth transition
in the PMS group from high
values, typical of Be stars, to values
lower than the average ones for objects of luminosity class V. This result
fits nicely with the two scenarios proposed by Finkenzeller
(1985) in which the further evolution of
in PMS
stars would depend on the relative strength of two opposite processes,
namely, a speeding up due to a further contraction and the associated
conservation of the angular momentum or a spin down due to a net angular
momentum loss (e.g. by stellar winds). Depending of the leading mechanism,
one could expect the formation of either a "normal'' B, A-type main
sequence star or a rapidly rotating Be star.
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to the referee, Prof. Gibor Basri, for his careful reading of the manuscript, suggestions and criticisms that helped us to improve the first version of this paper. We acknowledge the International Scientific Committee of the Canary Islands' Observatories for the allocation of observing time in the International Time programme. The work of C. Eiroa, B. Merín, B. Montesinos, A. Mora and J. Palacios has been supported in part by the Spanish grant ESP 98-1339. A. Mora wishes to thank Dr. J. R. Barnes for valuable discussions about echelle reduction procedures. Part of this research has made use of the SIMBAD database, operated at CDS, Strasbourg, France.