A&A 377, L22-L25 (2001)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20011179
O. Kochukhov1 - T. Ryabchikova2,3
1 - Uppsala Astronomical Observatory, Box 515, S-751 20 Uppsala, Sweden
2 - Institute of Astronomy, Russian Academy of Sciences, Pyatnitskaya 48, 109017 Moscow, Russia
3 - Institute for Astronomy, University of Vienna, Türkenschanzstrasse 17, 1180 Vienna, Austria
Received 19 July 2001 / Accepted 22 August 2001
Abstract
We report preliminary results of our new time-resolved high-resolution spectroscopic observations of the roAp stars Cir and HR 3831.
Analysis of pulsational behaviour of individual spectral lines in the 6116-6156 Å spectral region revealed that in both stars it
is dominated by the strong rapid variations of the Nd III 6145.07 Å spectral line. Oscillations of the Nd III
spectral feature are also
rotationally modulated. In addition we observed strong rotational modulation of the average HR 3831 line profiles caused by abundance
spots on the stellar surface. Weaker rotational modulation was also discovered for the metal lines in the
Cir spectrum. This
variability agrees with the rotational period of
Cir obtained from the splitting of the principal pulsation frequency.
Key words: stars: chemically peculiar - stars: oscillations - stars: individual: Cir, HR 3831
Rapidly oscillating Ap (roAp) stars belong to the group of cool magnetic chemically peculiar stars, which pulsate in high-overtone p-modes with periods in the range of 4-16 min. Traditionally roAp stars are discovered and studied using high-speed photometric techniques (e.g. Kurtz et al. 1994). There are only a few oscillating Ap stars for which line-by-line analysis of radial velocity variations is available. Among them three stars of similar effective temperature (
K) -
Equ,
Cir and HR 3831 - are best studied. While high-resolution spectroscopic observations were used for
Equ (see Kanaan & Hatzes 1998; Savanov et al. 1999; Kochukhov & Ryabchikova 2001, hereafter Paper I), pulsational radial velocity (RV) analysis of
Cir and HR 3831 was based on low-resolution spectra (Baldry et al. 1998; Baldry & Bedding 2000), allowing study of lines blended together in short spectral regions, but not of individual metal lines. It was found that in
Equ spectral lines of Pr III and Nd III show the highest RV amplitudes (Savanov et al. 1999; Paper I). In Paper I we analysed published results of low-resolution time-resolved spectroscopic studies of
Cir and
HR 3831 and tentatively concluded that strong Pr III and Nd III lines as well as the lines of singly ionized rare-earth elements (REE) are present in most of the short spectral regions demonstrating the highest RV amplitudes. To confirm our conclusion about an importance of Pr III and Nd III lines in pulsational behaviour of roAp stars we performed high-resolution high S/N time-series
observations of
Cir and HR 3831 in the 6116-6156 Å spectral region, which includes the Nd III
6145.07 Å line. Both stars were observed at different rotational phases for the future analysis of the 3D distribution of the pulsational velocity and abundance inhomogeneities. In this letter we report preliminary qualitative results of our time-resolved spectroscopic observations.
A description of observations and the reduction procedure is given in Sect. 2. Pulsational behaviour of individual
metal lines in Cir and HR 3831 is presented in Sect. 3, while in Sect. 4 we
briefly discuss spectrum variability due to rotation in both stars.
![]() |
Figure 1:
Comparison of the average and standard deviation spectra of ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
We obtained time-resolved spectroscopic observations of Cir and HR 3831 with the Very Long Camera of the Coude Echelle
Spectrograph fiber linked to the Cassegrain focus of the ESO 3.6-m telescope. Observations were conducted during 6 nights in
February 2001 using the medium resolution CES image slicer and ESO CCD#61. This instrumental configuration allowed the detector to
record a 40.4 Å spectral region centred at
6136 Å with a resolution of
.
The
roAp star HR 3831 was the main target of our observing campaign and it was monitored during 8.5 hours each night. We used an exposure
time of 70
in order to resolve pulsational variations due to the main non-radial mode in HR 3831, which has a period of
(Kurtz et al. 1997). Additional time-resolved spectroscopy of
Cir was performed for 1 hour each night
using the same instrumental settings as we employed for HR 3831. For
Cir we limited integration times to 40
in order to
resolve spectroscopic changes associated with the pulsation period of
(Kurtz et al. 1994).
During the whole observing run we obtained 1860 spectra of
HR 3831 with a typical S/N ratio of 100 per pixel as well as 290 spectra of
Cir with
.
Basic steps of spectroscopic reduction (bias subtraction, division by normalized flat field, extraction of 1-D spectrum,
continuum normalization and wavelength calibration) were performed with a set of IDL routines specially adapted for the optimal
extraction of CES spectra. This reduction procedure was very similar to the reduction of time-resolved spectroscopic observations
of Equ, which we described in detail in Paper I.
We computed the standard deviation (SD) of the intensity variations for each pixel of the continuum-normalized spectra and compared
it with the average observations of Cir and HR 3831 in order to identify variable spectral lines. The upper panel in Fig. 1
shows average spectra of the roAp stars, while the lower panel displays SD spectra. These profiles were produced by averaging SD spectra
computed for short sequences of time-resolved spectra, obtained typically within 1-1.5 hours, and thus contain information only
about spectral variability due to non-radial oscillations, but not due to rotational modulation caused by abundance spots.
![]() |
Figure 2:
Rotational and pulsational variability of ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
Analysis of SD profiles shown in Fig. 1 clearly reveals outstanding variations of the Nd III 6145.07 Å spectral line.
Weaker pulsational changes are also seen for Ba II 6141.71 Å and an unidentified feature in the blue wing of
Fe II 6149.26 Å, which probably belongs to a singly or doubly ionized REE. The overall picture of the pulsational
variability of Cir and HR 3831 is very similar to the pulsational behaviour of
Equ (Paper I). In particular, for all
three roAp stars we observed maximal variability for doubly ionized REE lines, weaker pulsations for singly ionized REE and
Ba II spectral features, and the absence of any variations for strong lines of lighter elements (e.g. Ca I 6122.22,
Si I 6155.15 Å).
Another spectroscopic signature that distinguishes all roAp stars from non-pulsating Ap stars with similar effective temperature is anomalous strength of doubly ionized REE lines. Ryabchikova et al. (2001) showed that abundances derived for roAp stars using Nd III and Pr III spectral lines are 1-2 dex higher than abundances obtained from lines of singly ionized Nd and Pr. This spectroscopic anomaly, which is absent in non-pulsating Ap stars points to inhomogeneous vertical distribution of REE in the atmospheres of roAp stars. Combined analysis of vertical abundance stratification and pulsational amplitudes of individual spectral features allows us to suggest that doubly ionized REE lines are formed in the atmospheric region where pulsational amplitude reaches its maximum. Thus, REE lines serve as invaluable tracers of the roAp pulsations. Pulsational behaviour of all roAp stars analysed with high time and spectral resolution techniques is broadly consistent with this picture and seems not to depend on pulsational periods, magnetic field strengths or rotation rates. This allows us to speculate that all members of the class of roAp pulsators feature similar vertical distributions of REE and pulsational amplitudes.
Strong pulsational variability of the Nd III 6145.07 Å line offers a possibility to go beyond simple time-series analysis of
periodic radial velocity changes and study in detail line profile variability caused by non-radial oscillations in order to
identify pulsational mode(s) and deduce other physical characteristics of non-radial pulsations. The high quality of our
observational material allows us to pursue this detailed analysis. Indeed, in the left panel of Fig. 2 we show a 1 hour
sequence of the time-resolved Cir spectra acquired at rotational phase 0.78 (according to the ephemeris of Kurtz et al.
1994). High-amplitude rapid profile changes are evident in the difference spectra of
Cir, with pulsational waves
propagating from the blue to the red wing of the Nd III 6145.07 Å line profile. (Note the absence of strong variability of the
nearby Ba II 6141.71 Å line.) These profile changes cannot be attributed to only RV and/or equivalent width
variations. This is the first detection of metal line profile variability induced by pulsations in
Cir.
![]() |
Figure 3: Comparison between rotational variability of the average (over 50 pulsational cycles) line profiles of Nd III 6145.07 Å and Ba II 6141.71 Å (left panel) and rotational modulation of the standard deviation spectrum (right panel) for the same wavelength region in HR 3831. The profiles for the consecutive rotational phases are shifted in the vertical direction. The bars at the lower right corner of each panel indicate the scale (in units of continuum flux) used for the figures. |
Open with DEXTER |
In addition to line profile variations induced by non-radial pulsations, many roAp stars show rotational
modulation of their metal lines due to inhomogeneous surface distribution of chemical elements. Though well-known
for many magnetic Ap stars, this phenomenon has never been reported for Cir. The rotational period of this star (
)
was derived by Kurtz et al. (1994) indirectly from pulsational analysis. Owing to the high resolution
and S/N of our
Cir observations we were able to detect subtle changes of the average line profiles from
one night of our observations to another. The right panel in Fig. 2 illustrates this rotational variability for
Ba II, Si I and Nd III spectral lines. Though poor phase coverage of our spectra does not allow us to make an
independent estimate of the
Cir rotational period, we tentatively concluded that our spectroscopic data agrees with the period
found by Kurtz et al. (1994). Further spectroscopic monitoring of Ba II and REE lines
is needed to verify this conclusion.
According to the phenomenological oblique pulsator model, pioneered for roAp stars by Kurtz (1982), the pulsational axis
of oscillations in roAp stars is aligned with the axis of the (roughly dipolar) magnetic field, which is usually inclined with
respect to the rotational axis. As a roAp star rotates, the angle between an observer and pulsational axis changes and
therefore one expects to see rotational modulation of the amplitude and phase of non-radial oscillations. For Cir we
detected modulation of RV amplitude of the Nd III 6145.07 Å spectral line, which varied between 300 and 500 ms-1 during our
observing run. However, preliminary analysis showed that this modulation is not consistent with simple sinusoidal variations of
the photometric amplitude obtained by Kurtz et al. (1994). Furthermore we detected changes in RV amplitude on time
scales much shorter than the rotational period of
Cir. Clearly further analysis of line profile variations of REE lines as well as
additional observations are required to clarify the question of the modulations of non-radial pulsations in
Cir.
We observed even more dramatic rotational modulation of the average line profiles and pulsational behaviour for HR 3831. This star
has a well-known rotational period
(Kurtz et al. 1997), supported by the variability of light,
magnetic field, line strengths and non-radial oscillation amplitude. For HR 3831 the dense phase coverage of our observations allowed
us to follow in detail both modulation of rapid profile variability and changes of the average profiles caused by abundance
spots. Figure 3 illustrates how the average and the SD spectra of HR 3831 change with rotational phase. HR 3831 pulsates in
the principal dipole (
)
non-radial mode (Kurtz et al. 1997; Baldry & Bedding 2000). Its signature is
clearly visible as a jump in the pattern of SD profiles of the Nd III 6145.07 Å line, occurring at phases 0.25 and 0.75 (see right
panel in Fig. 3), as well as modulation of RV pulsational amplitude of the same line, which changes from no detectable
variability at phases 0.25 and 0.75 up to 200 ms-1 at phases 0.0 and 0.5. The strong influence of the inhomogeneous abundance
distribution on the shape of the average line profiles must be studied in detail with Doppler imaging techniques. Spatial filtering
associated with abundance spots must also be taken into account in pulsational analysis based on modelling rapid
variations of individual spectral lines. Such analysis (which we plan to present in forthcoming papers)
will reveal the relation between the inhomogeneous surface abundance distribution and the pulsation velocity field. It will also help
to understand which of the two abundance inhomogeneity effects, vertical stratification or surface patches, is primarily
responsible for the high-amplitude rapid variations of the Nd III spectral feature.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by Swedish Naturvetenskapliga forskningsrådet and by the Fonds zur Förderung der wissenschaftlichen Forschung (project S 7003-AST and P 11882-PHY). T. R. also acknowledges financial support by the "Jubilaeumsfonds der Oesterreichischen Nationalbank". We thank the referee Dr. I. K. Baldry for very constructive remarks.