A&A 370, 496-502 (2001)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20010237
L. L. Kiss1 - B. A. Skiff2
1 - Department of Experimental Physics and Astronomical Observatory,
University of Szeged, Dóm tér 9., 6720 Szeged, Hungary
2 -
Lowell Observatory, 1400 West Mars Hill Road, Flagstaff, AZ 86001, USA
Received 14 November 2000 / Accepted 12 February 2001
Abstract
We present an analysis of eleven years of Strömgren by photometry
of the red semiregular variable star AI Aurigae. An early period determination
of 63.9 days is confirmed by the long-term light curve
behaviour. The light curve shows semi-regular changes
with a mean period of 65 days reaching an amplitude of 0
6 in
some cycles. The b-y colour changes perfectly parallel
the V light curve, suggesting radial oscillation to be the
main reason for the observed variations. We estimate the main
characteristics of the star (mass, radius, effective temperature)
that suggest radial pulsation in fundamental or first overtone mode.
Key words: stars: pulsation - stars: AGB - stars: individual: AI Aur
The light variation of semiregular variables (SR) of subtype SRa and SRb is generally associated with the pulsation of these low and intermediate mass red giants located on the asymptotic giant branch (AGB) of the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram. Since the characteristic timescale of the variations is between 20 and 2000 days (usually hundreds of days), semiregulars are typical targets of amateur observers estimating visual brightnesses. There are very few high-precision light, colour, and/or radial-velocity measurement covering many cycles that confirm the pulsational origin of the variations. Very recently, Lebzelter and his co-workers (Lebzelter 1999a,b; Lebzelter et al. 1999) presented high-precision photometric and infrared radial-velocity data for a sample of bright SR stars. Their results both illustrate the ability of automatic telescopes to monitor this type of variable stars and support the assumption of pulsation (see also Percy et al. 1996 on involving amateur photoelectric observers into regular observations of small-amplitude red variables, SARVs).
However, one cannot ad hoc accept pulsation to be the main reason of variability. As has been noted by Percy & Polano (1998), virtually every M giant is variable in brightness. This has been also supported by the large-scale photometric surveys (Hipparcos, MACHO, OGLE) leading to the discovery of thousands of M-type variables. It has been pointed out by, e.g. Lebzelter et al. (2000) and Kiss et al. (2000), that specifying the physical reason responsible for the variation requires simultaneous light, colour, and radial-velocity data, as even consecutive cycles may show significant deviations. This kind of long-term observation is crucial when studying the possible mechanisms affecting the light changes of SR variables. Besides pulsation, other contributors to variability cannot be readily excluded, such as time dependent surface inhomogeneities due to large convective cells (Schwarzschild 1975; Lebzelter et al. 2000), ellipsoidal deformation due to the presence of a close companion, or spots on a relatively rapidly-rotating star. Most recently, Koen & Laney (2000) gave a detailed list of considerations concerning the possible reasons of variability and noted, that there is still no definite conclusion on this issue. Until the application of these mechanisms is better understood, each case must be studied separately.
AI Aurigae (HD 259342,
,
,
spectral type M5III - Chuadze 1973) is a poorly-studied red semiregular
(subtype SRa) variable star. In the General Catalogue of
Variable Stars (GCVS - Kholopov et al. 1985-1988)
a period of 63
9 is listed with an early epoch of maximum
(JD 2426029, due to Beyer 1937). Since then there has been no other
photometric measurement published for this star. Due to the relatively small
range of light changes, it is also neglected by the international
organizations of amateur variable star observers (American Assocation
of Variable Star Observers - AAVSO, Association Française des
Observateurs d'Étoiles Variables - AFOEV and Variable Star Observers'
League in Japan - VSOLJ). The AAVSO International Database does not contain
this star, AFOEV has 16 points which are wrongly identified with
AI Aur (they are 2 mag brighter), and VSOLJ collected only 30 individual
estimates between 1986 and 1999. Similar neglect is present concerning
other observations: there was only one radial velocity monitoring
(
km s-1, Feast et al. 1972),
while Dickinson & Dinger (1982) listed AI Aur among the negative
detections during their H2O survey. There is no
metallicity determination in the literature.
Its infrared colours (see later) place the star among the "blue''
SRs (Kerschbaum & Hron 1992) and the presently available data
suggest the star to be a regular member of this group.
The main aim of this paper is to present a continuous photometric monitoring of AI Aur between 1985 and 1996 which reveals the associated colour variations in addition to obtaining an accurate light curve. (We note, that the presented observations were acquired during a large-scale photometric survey of solar type stars, Lockwood et al. 1997, without any specific reason. Therefore, this study is a by-product of that long-term observing programme). The observed behaviour of AI Aur is very likely to be mainly due to radial pulsation, most probably in fundamental or low-degree overtone mode. The next section deals with the data aquisition, while the light- and colour-curves are discussed in Sect. 3 together with the physical parameters of the star. A summary of the conclusions is given in Sect. 4.
MJD | V | b-y | MJD | V | b-y | MJD | V | b-y | MJD | V | b-y |
46351.000 | 9.182 | 1.348 | 46765.900 | 9.346 | 1.330 | 47529.783 | 9.451 | 1.357 | 48991.754 | 9.477 | 1.376 |
46352.996 | 9.192 | 1.353 | 46768.933 | 9.354 | 1.336 | 47535.796 | 9.384 | 1.348 | 49016.708 | 9.659 | 1.402 |
46353.996 | 9.205 | 1.348 | 46777.838 | 9.367 | 1.360 | 47541.771 | 9.261 | 1.347 | 49020.617 | 9.708 | 1.427 |
46357.987 | 9.259 | 1.352 | 46806.787 | 9.159 | 1.341 | 47542.725 | 9.261 | 1.350 | 49051.654 | 9.435 | 1.394 |
46362.975 | 9.357 | 1.368 | 46807.771 | 9.168 | 1.329 | 47544.725 | 9.248 | 1.345 | 49054.658 | 9.396 | 1.406 |
46375.958 | 9.609 | 1.413 | 46827.758 | 9.463 | 1.389 | 47578.683 | 9.389 | 1.382 | 49058.675 | 9.373 | 1.385 |
46376.954 | 9.615 | 1.401 | 46828.763 | 9.450 | 1.398 | 47579.679 | 9.407 | 1.379 | 49325.792 | 9.474 | 1.382 |
46385.942 | 9.693 | 1.421 | 46831.833 | 9.447 | 1.396 | 47585.704 | 9.455 | 1.389 | 49326.829 | 9.463 | 1.389 |
46388.917 | 9.714 | 1.422 | 46832.750 | 9.442 | 1.385 | 47586.658 | 9.471 | 1.392 | 49329.821 | 9.425 | 1.403 |
46389.921 | 9.717 | 1.440 | 46848.721 | 9.332 | 1.352 | 47592.658 | 9.536 | 1.414 | 49330.871 | 9.407 | 1.389 |
46403.917 | 9.457 | 1.387 | 46853.692 | 9.275 | 1.338 | 47599.671 | 9.522 | 1.391 | 49371.754 | 9.363 | 1.378 |
46420.813 | 9.236 | 1.361 | 46857.658 | 9.217 | 1.319 | 47606.671 | 9.423 | 1.385 | 49373.775 | 9.358 | 1.385 |
46421.817 | 9.240 | 1.359 | 46858.683 | 9.198 | 1.325 | 47618.633 | 9.232 | 1.356 | 49382.812 | 9.326 | 1.354 |
46431.875 | 9.297 | 1.373 | 46862.700 | 9.164 | 1.314 | 47623.633 | 9.195 | 1.342 | 49384.687 | 9.311 | 1.371 |
46449.850 | 9.547 | 1.399 | 46867.650 | 9.127 | 1.321 | 47624.625 | 9.196 | 1.334 | 49395.692 | 9.398 | 1.382 |
46450.742 | 9.561 | 1.420 | 46880.638 | 9.358 | 1.359 | 47626.625 | 9.194 | 1.347 | 49398.725 | 9.467 | 1.436 |
46457.783 | 9.563 | 1.373 | 46881.658 | 9.387 | 1.336 | 47640.638 | 9.430 | 1.392 | 49439.617 | 9.435 | 1.362 |
46463.767 | 9.483 | 1.396 | 46885.675 | 9.435 | 1.340 | 47826.929 | 9.181 | 1.321 | 49447.642 | 9.378 | 1.383 |
46483.675 | 9.200 | 1.356 | 46898.629 | 9.408 | 1.333 | 47843.900 | 9.357 | 1.324 | 49633.958 | 9.200 | 1.349 |
46484.662 | 9.535 | 1.380 | 46899.629 | 9.419 | 1.310 | 47880.813 | 9.375 | 1.328 | 49670.883 | 9.617 | 1.388 |
46486.700 | 9.206 | 1.364 | 47103.987 | 9.305 | 1.358 | 47896.683 | 9.328 | 1.343 | 49684.858 | 9.678 | 1.411 |
46487.679 | 9.205 | 1.359 | 47115.937 | 9.055 | 1.334 | 47915.692 | 9.445 | 1.353 | 49685.842 | 9.662 | 1.418 |
46490.700 | 9.239 | 1.357 | 47118.950 | 9.066 | 1.341 | 47919.754 | 9.519 | 1.373 | 49687.800 | 9.639 | 1.411 |
46496.667 | 9.355 | 1.373 | 47125.892 | 9.205 | 1.336 | 47921.779 | 9.539 | 1.369 | 49707.787 | 9.479 | 1.381 |
46510.671 | 9.509 | 1.391 | 47140.846 | 9.572 | 1.416 | 47925.683 | 9.530 | 1.379 | 49750.696 | 9.480 | 1.390 |
46511.671 | 9.529 | 1.373 | 47148.838 | 9.765 | 1.425 | 47932.683 | 9.481 | 1.366 | 49752.713 | 9.450 | 1.386 |
46512.662 | 9.535 | 1.380 | 47150.871 | 9.786 | 1.444 | 47969.667 | 9.090 | 1.323 | 49754.692 | 9.449 | 1.378 |
46516.650 | 9.557 | 1.382 | 47170.763 | 9.267 | 1.369 | 47972.650 | 9.195 | 1.336 | 49757.708 | 9.438 | 1.381 |
46530.650 | 9.430 | 1.360 | 47172.829 | 9.239 | 1.365 | 47974.671 | 9.266 | 1.366 | 49767.625 | 9.484 | 1.393 |
46534.638 | 9.345 | 1.362 | 47199.692 | 9.480 | 1.385 | 48218.854 | 9.249 | 1.374 | 49783.625 | 9.520 | 1.379 |
46539.629 | 9.220 | 1.363 | 47200.696 | 9.511 | 1.405 | 48294.700 | 9.495 | 1.396 | 49979.942 | 9.342 | 1.358 |
46544.650 | 9.133 | 1.335 | 47203.721 | 9.598 | 1.407 | 48296.646 | 9.501 | 1.394 | 50007.917 | 9.530 | 1.380 |
46547.654 | 9.108 | 1.341 | 47204.729 | 9.616 | 1.410 | 48322.608 | 9.677 | 1.400 | 50010.954 | 9.502 | 1.378 |
46550.638 | 9.113 | 1.325 | 47205.729 | 9.636 | 1.407 | 48597.858 | 9.440 | 1.368 | 50034.871 | 9.082 | 1.330 |
46678.979 | 9.280 | 1.370 | 47206.679 | 9.651 | 1.419 | 48631.787 | 9.555 | 1.405 | 50035.875 | 9.082 | 1.319 |
46679.979 | 9.287 | 1.375 | 47211.692 | 9.725 | 1.441 | 48635.787 | 9.566 | 1.392 | 50051.867 | 9.359 | 1.364 |
46703.992 | 9.351 | 1.373 | 47212.692 | 9.740 | 1.431 | 48636.708 | 9.562 | 1.394 | 50052.846 | 9.389 | 1.365 |
46704.979 | 9.351 | 1.377 | 47214.704 | 9.758 | 1.427 | 48638.812 | 9.555 | 1.391 | 50094.737 | 9.463 | 1.399 |
46716.963 | 9.421 | 1.392 | 47221.658 | 9.654 | 1.415 | 48645.787 | 9.478 | 1.381 | 50097.696 | 9.435 | 1.384 |
46720.954 | 9.403 | 1.389 | 47228.646 | 9.406 | 1.381 | 48646.779 | 9.459 | 1.375 | 50101.742 | 9.360 | 1.371 |
46723.963 | 9.364 | 1.386 | 47233.667 | 9.244 | 1.357 | 48649.767 | 9.411 | 1.389 | 50145.633 | 9.460 | 1.380 |
46724.950 | 9.343 | 1.402 | 47234.654 | 9.226 | 1.352 | 48652.754 | 9.375 | 1.378 | 50149.608 | 9.388 | 1.367 |
46728.958 | 9.238 | 1.367 | 47238.642 | 9.191 | 1.333 | 48693.642 | 9.398 | 1.389 | 50151.608 | 9.363 | 1.364 |
46731.950 | 9.149 | 1.354 | 47247.654 | 9.317 | 1.382 | 48697.633 | 9.420 | 1.373 | 50153.608 | 9.319 | 1.368 |
46739.921 | 9.061 | 1.337 | 47250.658 | 9.380 | 1.375 | 48866.975 | 9.259 | 1.358 | 50161.617 | 9.211 | 1.337 |
46740.971 | 9.057 | 1.357 | 47254.646 | 9.461 | 1.375 | 48874.967 | 9.088 | 1.355 | 50172.650 | 9.175 | 1.344 |
46741.946 | 9.074 | 1.338 | 47523.808 | 9.455 | 1.383 | 48888.925 | 9.408 | 1.382 | 50175.621 | 9.224 | 1.342 |
46742.954 | 9.062 | 1.360 | 47524.838 | 9.457 | 1.377 | 48891.904 | 9.466 | 1.366 | 50366.967 | 9.338 | 1.362 |
46747.933 | 9.104 | 1.335 | 47525.787 | 9.467 | 1.363 | 48927.879 | 9.396 | 1.340 | 50425.900 | 9.386 | 1.357 |
46759.933 | 9.326 | 1.328 | 47526.783 | 9.459 | 1.373 | 48976.812 | 9.384 | 1.355 |
AI Aurigae was observed on 199 nights between 12 Oct. 1985 and
8 Dec. 1996. The observations were carried out at
Lowell Observatory with the 0.53 m telescope. The detector
was a single-channel photoelectric photometer (EMI 6256S tube)
equipped with Strömgren b and y filters. The measurements
were obtained almost always through a 29
diaphragm; some
measurements in bad seeing were made through a 49
aperture,
and in bright Moonlight a 19
aperture was occasionally used.
The differential magnitudes were aquired relative to HD 46159 (V=8
054,
b-y=0
623, G8III), while the photometric stability was checked against
HD 259662 (V=9
556, b-y=0
639, K0III).
The data were corrected only for differential extinction using
long-term monthly means for kb and ky (Lockwood & Thompson 1986).
The standard transformations are represented with slight colour terms
(roughly
V=y+0.05(b-y)i,
b-y=1.08(b-y)i).
The internal consistency is of order of 0
005 as suggested by
the rms errors of the means for the comparison stars in y and b(0
0046 and 0
0048). The quoted standard values for the comparison
stars were determined on four nights
from standard star observations (extending to several very red
Landolt stars). Due to the red colour of the variable, there might
be some remaining systematic shift of 0
020-0
025 in the Vbrightness. In any case, the scatter of the observations is
essentially negligible compared to the range of the variations.
The data (mean values of var-comp and var-check) are
presented in
Table 1
and plotted in Fig. 1.
![]() |
Figure 1: The light and colour curves of AI Aur between 1985 and 1996. Note the 600-day break between MJD 48000 and 48600 |
Open with DEXTER |
In the following, we characterize the observed light variations, discuss the importance of the colour measurements and compare AI Aur with other semiregulars with available similar data series.
![]() |
Figure 2: The Fourier spectrum of the whole dataset. The insert shows the window function with the same frequency scale |
Open with DEXTER |
Data presented in Table 1 are plotted in Fig. 1. Note that some parts are excluded from the presentation due to the sparse light curve coverage (between MJD 48000-48600). However, when analysing the whole dataset, we have also used those data that are not presented in Fig. 1. Qualitatively the light curve is that of a typical semiregular without strictly repeating cycles. This has been investigated in detail by means of standard Fourier analysis implemented with Period98 of Sperl (1998).
First, we have calculated the power spectrum of the whole dataset.
It is shown in Fig. 2, where the insert shows the window function. One main
peak is present at f=0.01604 c/d (A=0
14) corresponding to
a period of 62
345. After a simple prewhitening with this frequency,
the power spectrum of the residuals contains a closely
separated frequency
(f=0.01548 c/d, A=0
10).
However, it is a direct consequence of the unstable period, since
the whole dataset could be fitted neither with a single period nor
with a sum of two close periods. Therefore we studied the light curve
in four separate subsets (each being about 1000 days long)
plotted
in the left panels of Fig. 3.
We performed similar frequency analysis as for the whole light curve and the results can be summarized as follows:
![]() |
Figure 3: The four subsets and the corresponding phase diagrams of AI Aur |
Open with DEXTER |
The conclusions presented so far are typical for semiregular variables (see, e.g. Kiss et al. 1999). The novelty in our results is the presence of colour measurements. To our knowledge, there have not been really long-term (covering tens of cycles) time-series multicolour data in the literature for any semiregular variable star. Although Hipparcos Epoch Photometry (ESA 1997) contains typically 100-200 points for thousands of variables, the limited time span does not permit accurate period determination for red variables. High-precision V-band observations of different SRs were presented, for instance, by Percy et al. (1989), Cristian et al. (1995), Percy et al. (1996) and Lebzelter (1999), but none of these studies dealt with the colour variations.
One of the most extensive time-resolved multicolour photometric surveys was published by Smak (1964), who reported UBV observations of twenty-nine Mira stars and twelve semiregulars during two years, covering typically only one cycle per star. He did not find any clear correlation of the B-V colour and the V brightness for the SR stars. Jerzykiewicz (1984) studied the light and colour variations of HD 157010 (V818 Her), concluding that the star's UBV magnitudes are effective temperature parameters through the sensitivity of the continuous spectrum and TiO blanketing. Wisse (1981) presented UBV observations for 35 SRs for classification purposes. He found that well-defined correlations and anti-correlations exist among the variables, where the phase difference of the V and B-V maxima is either 0 or 0.5. Cadmus et al. (1991), in their study of three SRs, noted only that the colour changes were small compared to the changes in brightness. Narrow-band observations of SR variables in the literature are quite scanty. An interesting application can be found in Wasatonic & Guinan (1998), who used three colors of the Wing near-infrared system to trace the temperature and radius variations of V CVn. These authors measured the highest temperature (from an infrared index) around the maximum light.
The most important feature of our observations is the almost
perfectly parallel light and colour curves. This is a characteristic
behaviour in radially pulsating variables, where the temperature maximum
occurs close to the maximum light. It means that the star appears bluer when
it is at maximum light, which is in good agreement what is expected
from pure thermal variations driven by pulsation. In the case of FS Comae
(SR star with
d), Torres et al. (1993)
reached the opposite conclusion based on UBV data series.
The star showed reversed colour changes explained
by the fact that B-V colour in FS Com is a molecular absorption index,
rather than a temperature indicator. The Strömgren b filter
(centered near 4700 Å) has a relatively clear spectral region in the
center of the passband, but the wings on both sides have
moderately-weak TiO absorption, particularly the 2,0 transition
with bandhead at 4761 Å. The y filter is not so strongly affected, with
only the usual Fe, Ti, etc. lines. Unlike the B-V colour,
b-y is completely unaffected by the wide TiO bandhead at
5167 Å.
We conclude that the observations imply radial oscillation with dominant
thermal effects as the main reason for the light variability.
The
0
1 amplitude of the b-y curve corresponds
to a temperature change of <300 K (as estimated from the
synthetic colour grids of Kurucz 1993).
Adopting radial pulsation for AI Aur, further constraints can be drawn
on the basic stellar parameters. Unfortunately, there is no parallax
measurement for AI Aur, thus only spectroscopic parallax or various
empirical period-colour-luminosity relations (e.g. Barthès et al. 1999)
can be used to determine
its luminosity. We have chosen the former approach, because
we wanted to estimate stellar properties without any assumption
on its pulsation. In the following we have neglected the
interstellar reddening since the observed mean b-y colour (1
35)
is close to the expected value for an M5 giant star (see Jorissen
et al. 1995 for Strömgren photometry of red giants).
The IRAS [12]-[25] colour is
.
Following the
definitions by Kerschbaum & Hron (1992), this means that AI Aur
belongs to the "blue'' semiregulars (no indication for circumstellar
shells,
,
K).
The infrared brightnesses (K=2
71, I=6
18),
taken from the IRC catalogue (Neugebauer &
Leighton 1969), combined with the mean V magnitude imply
colour indices V-K=6
8 and V-I=3
3.
The latter value results in a
K using the temperature
scale by Dumm & Schild (1998). A less biased estimate can be inferred from
twenty M5III-type stars in the sample of Dumm & Schild (1998):
K.
For an independent check we have used the
(V-K)-(710-888) and
(I-K)-(710-888) relations in Alvarez et al. (2000) resulting in
K from their
calibration.
Similarly, one can get a mean radius and mass for the given spectral
type of
and
.
Adopting these
spectral type-mass and spectral type-radius values we calculated
a pulsational constant
.
Recently, Percy & Parkes (1998) discussed the pulsation modes in
small-amplitude red variable stars reaching a conclusion that
some stars are likely to pulsate in up to the third overtone mode.
Within these frameworks AI Aur seems to pulsate in the
fundamental or first overtone mode as is suggested by theoretical
models of Xiong et al. (1998) or Ostlie & Cox (1986).
The overtone pulsation is favoured by the position of AI Aur
in the K-band P-L diagram of long-period variables derived
by Bedding & Zijlstra (1998) from Hipparcos parallaxes.
For this, we estimated MK from the V-K colour and
MV-spectral-type calibration of Thé et al. (1990).
The resulting
and log
place
AI Aur close to the upper sequence in Fig. 1 of Bedding & Zijlstra
(1998), which may be interpreted as a consequence of pulsation
in a different mode than that valid for most Mira stars
(represented by the lower sequence in Fig. 1 of Bedding & Zijlstra
1998).
Finally, there is an interesting period-gravity relation for a wide
range of radially pulsating variable stars presented by Fernie (1995),
which can also be used to test the assumption of radial oscillation.
The adopted mass and radius give a log
which is
coincidentally the same as predicted by Eq. (1) of Fernie (1995).
Plotting AI Aur in Fig. 1 of Fernie (1995), its position is as
deviant as that of Mira itself suggesting the first
overtone to be somewhat more likely. However, the universality of this
period-gravity relation has no firm theoretical background and
verification; therefore, this comparison should be considered only
as a possible hint for the mode of pulsation.
The presented considerations are on the whole consistent with the recent observational and theoretical results regarding the mode of pulsation in Mira and semiregular variables. For example, Feast (1996) found that semiregular variables, independently of their metallicity, pulsate probably in the first overtone mode. Further supporting arguments were listed by Feast (1999). However, semiregulars form a quite heterogeneous group, in which stars may pulsate in the fundamental, or 1st, 2nd or even 3rd overtone mode, as has been clearly demonstrated by Wood et al. (1999). That is why every individual case study has to be performed without any definite preconception.
The main results presented in this paper can be summarized as follows:
Acknowledgements
This research was supported by the "Bolyai János'' Research Scholarship of LLK from the Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Hungarian OTKA Grant #T032258 and Szeged Observatory Foundation. The NASA ADS Abstract Service was used to access data and references. This research has made use of the SIMBAD database, operated at CDS-Strasbourg, France.