A&A 366, 1035-1046 (2001)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20000266
S. Chaty1,2 - L. F. Rodríguez3 - I. F. Mirabel2,4 - T. R. Geballe5 - Y. Fuchs2 - A. Claret2 - C. J. Cesarsky6 - D. Cesarsky7,8
1 - Department of Physics and Astronomy, The Open University,
Walton Hall, Milton Keynes, MK7 6AA,
UK
2 -
Service d'Astrophysique, DSM/DAPNIA/SAp, CEA/Saclay,
L'Orme des Merisiers, Bât. 709, 91191 Gif-sur-Yvette Cedex, France
3 -
Instituto de Astronomía, UNAM, Campus Morelia, Morelia,
Michoacán 58190, Mexico
4 -
Instituto de Astronomía y Física del Espacio C.C. 67,
Suc. 28. 1428, Buenos Aires, Argentina
5 -
Gemini Observatory, 670 N. A'ohoku Place, Hilo, HI 96720, USA
6 -
ESO, Karl-Schwarzschild Strasse 2, 85748 Garching-bei-München, Germany
7 -
Université Paris XI, Institut d'Astrophysique Spatiale, Bât.
121, 91450 Orsay Cedex, France
8 -
Max Plank Institut für Extraterrestrische Physik, Postfach
1603, 85740 Garching, Germany
Received 25 July 2000 / Accepted 13 November 2000
Abstract
We have observed an extended region surrounding the first discovered
galactic superluminal source GRS 1915+105, seeking evidence of interaction
between the relativistic ejecta of that object and the interstellar
medium. We find two radio sources axisymmetrically aligned along the
sub-arcsecond relativistic ejecta of GRS 1915+105 and roughly 17
distant
from it, which coincide with the luminous IRAS sources 19124+1106 and
19132+1035. We have observed these sources at centimeter (VLA), millimeter
(IRAM 30 m), and infrared (ISO, UKIRT, ESO/MPI 2.2 m) wavelengths in both
line and continuum emission. At centimeter wavelengths a non-thermal
jet-like feature aligned along the outflow axis is located adjacent to the
inner edge of the southern source. Strong density enhancements are found
in the millimeter tracers CO and
at the positions of both
sources and some of the morphology is reminiscent of shock-like
interactions; however, linewidths are narrow. At infrared wavelengths
strong hydrogen recombination lines and weak lines of molecular hydrogen
are observed at the southern source. We discuss these results as possible
evidence of the sought-after interaction, both in terms of the regions
undergoing ongoing shock-heating and in terms of them being locations of
shock-induced star formation. The evidence for each of these is
inconclusive. Millimeter line mapping of a portion of W 50 where the
relativistic jets of the X-ray binary
interact with the interstellar
medium shows roughly similar morphology as
,
suggesting that the
phenomena observed at the IRAS sources may not be unusual for such a long
distance interaction.
Key words: stars: individual: GRS 1915+105, SS 433 -
ISM: individual objects: IRAS 19124+1106,
IRAS 19132+1035 -
ISM: jets and outflows -
X-rays: stars
The hard X-ray transient GRS 1915+105 was discovered in 1992 by the
all-sky monitor WATCH on GRANAT (Castro-Tirado et al. 1994). It has been
intensively studied since then in many wavebands,
including the radio, where ejected plasma clouds with
apparently superluminal velocities, a common extragalactic phenomenon,
were found for the first time in our Galaxy (Mirabel &
Rodríguez 1994).
Material ejected from
would be expected to interact with
the surrounding interstellar medium, providing an opportunity to study
in detail for the first time such a relativistic interaction
(for a review see Mirabel & Rodríguez 1999).
In a program to look for these interactions we have detected two compact
sources of bright radio emission, each coincident with a bright IRAS
source near
.
These sources are located axisymetrically with respect
to
and at same position angle as its normal sub-arsec ejections,
suggesting that they could be the zones of interaction between the ejecta
and the interstellar medium as described in Sect. 2. We
have observed these two IRAS sources at near-infrared (ESO/MPI 2.2 m,
UKIRT), mid-infrared (ISO), millimeter (IRAM 30 m) and centimeter (VLA)
wavelengths. The observations are detailed in Sect. 3.
We discuss in Sect. 4 the possibility of a physical
association between the ejections of
and the two IRAS sources,
comparing some of the results obtained in the putative interaction zones
with new measurements of the interaction between one of the jets of SS 443
and the interstellar medium. Some of the observations and results
described here have been briefly described in Chaty (1998),
Chaty et al. (2000) and Rodríguez &
Mirabel (1998)
(hereafter RM98).
In order to search for interactions involving the energetic and
relativistic ejections of
,
the region surrounding
was
observed at radio wavelengths as described by RM98. This search was
performed at
cm, using the Very Large Array (VLA) of
NRAO
, in its C-configuration, giving
a resolution of
.
The resulting map is shown in Fig. 1.
The region in the map referred to as G45.45+0.06 was
mislabelled G45.46+0.06 in the original papers (e.g., RM98).
Characteristics of this radio
source are given in Downes et al. (1980) and in
Feldt et al. (1998).
No evidence of jets or elongated
clouds appears in the figure. However, two small radio continuum sources
positioned nearly axisymmetrically with respect to
were
found at angular separations of
each from
(RM98). These
small sources are coincident with the bright IRAS sources, 19124+1106 and
19132+1035. Their coordinates are given in Table 1. The
position angle of the line connecting the northwest source and
is
,
and their separation is
,
the equivalent
values for the southeastern source and
are
and
.
The position angles are very similar to the position angle of
the sub-arcsec radio-ejections from
(
150
)
(Mirabel & Rodríguez 1994;
Fender et al. 1999). The angle between these
ejections and the line of sight towards
is
,
with the
southeastern ejection approaching and the northwestern one receding
(Mirabel &
Rodríguez 1994).
The distance to
is crucial for determining many of the
physical parameters of the object (e.g., mass loss rate,
velocity of ejecta, energetics).
It was estimated to be
by
Mirabel & Rodríguez (1994) and by Chaty et al. (1996).
Recent VLBA observations are consistent
with this value (Dhawan et al. 2000).
However, the uncertainty may be larger than
,
as the above
lower limit was based
on a distance to G45.45+0.06 of
,
whereas Feldt et al.
(1998) have placed the Hii region at only
.
Moreover, Fender et al. (1999),
who derived an upper limit of
,
consider
that the source is constrained to lie between 7 and 12 kpc.
If the radio sources are at the same distances from the Sun as
,
and if we assume that the distance of this source is
,
their angular separations correspond
to the distance of 60 pc from
.
Source | J2000.0 coord. | gal. coord. |
GRS 1915+105 |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
IRAS 19124+1106 |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
IRAS 19132+1035 |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Figure 1:
Map of the surroundings of
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
Source |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
mag | mag | Jy | Jy | Jy | Jy | mJy | mJy | mJy | |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
3.9 | 19.6 | 260.6 | 581.5 | ![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
6.9 | 34.0 | 277.4 | 488.8 | ![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
2 | 5 |
High-resolution maps of the two radio sources have been obtained with the
VLA. Details of these observations can be found in RM98. These maps, at
three different wavelengths, 2, 6 and 20 cm, are shown in Fig. 2.
The morphology of the northern source resembles that
of a cometary HII region, but it also shows a bow shock-like structure to
the South-East, e.g. towards
.
At the southern lobe a non-thermal jet
extends to the northwest along the line between the source and
.
The
flux densities of this jet are
1, 2 and
at 2, 6and
,
respectively, indicating a spectral index of
(
), therefore noticeably different than that
of the rest of the southern radio lobe, which exhibits thermal emission,
as it can be seen in the Table 2.
We also reported in Fig. 3
a spectral index map of
IRAS 19132+1035 made from the 20 and 6-cm
maps. The southern lobe also shows a sharp edge to the south, which could be
either a bow shock, or the ionization front of an
region.
Additional radio observations of these sources in the Hrecombination line and adjacent continuum at
are detailed in
RM98. The line strengths, profiles, and radial velocities are typical of
regions at kinematic distances of
for the north
lobe and
for the south lobe
(distance errors are estimated from the mean value for deviations
of circular rotation of
given by Brand & Blitz 1993).
We note that the distance uncertainties are
large because of the low velocity resolution (
)
of the H92
observations (RM98).
These estimates are most consistent with the distance to
G45.45+0.06 given by Feldt et al. (1998).
The radio luminosities of the sources derived using these
distances are similar to those of
regions powered by O9.5
ZAMS and B0 ZAMS stars (RM98).
If instead they are at the nominal distance
of
hotter individual stars or two stars of the above spectral types
would be required to power each source.
However, the interpretation of these objects as
normal
regions does not explain the presence of the
non-thermal jet-like structure in
.
Furthermore, given the large uncertainty in the distance of
,
we cannot a priori rule out the possibility that
is roughly at the kinematic distance of the Hii regions.
A search for OH maser emission was performed with the VLA in the vicinity of GRS 1915+105, at 1720 MHz. Such emission can be a signpost for interaction between a SNR and molecular gas (as in the case of IC 443, e.g. Denoyer 1979). No detection was obtained. However, this does not imply necessarily that there is no interaction (Rodríguez, Goss, Mirabel, private communication).
We imaged the IRAS sources in the J (
)
and K (
)
bands. The observations were made on 1997, April 5, with IRAC2b
installed on the Max Planck Institute's 2.2 m telescope at the
European Southern Observatory (ESO).
The IRAC2b camera, which contains a Rockwell
pixel
Hg:Cd:Te NICMOS 3 array detector was mounted at the f/35 infrared adapter
of the telescope. It was used with lens C, providing an image scale of
and a field of
.
The typical seeing for these observations was
.
Each final image is the median of 5 frames, each exposed for 2 min.
After taking each image of the object, an image of adjacent sky
was taken, to allow subtraction of sky emission. The images were processed by
removing bias and dark current, and applying a flat field correction.
These steps were performed using IRAF procedures, in particular the
DAOPHOT package for the photometry in crowded fields.
![]() |
Figure 2:
Maps of the two continuum radio sources
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The images reveal a compact near-infrared counterpart at the position of
,
with
mag and
mag, and a
brighter and more extended counterpart of
,
with
mag and
mag. Figure 4 shows the
central portions of the images containing
.
![]() |
Figure 4:
J (top) and K (bottom) band images of the source
![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
Spectroscopy
A low resolution K-band spectrum of
was obtained with the
facility instrument CGS4 on the UK Infrared 3.8 m Telescope
(UKIRT) on UT 1997 July 13, as part of the UKIRT Service Program. The
75 l/mm grating was used in CGS4 together with a slit of width
to provide a spectral coverage of
at a resolution of
(
at
)
on the
array of InSb detectors. The slit was oriented at a position angle of
and the telescope was moved to center the peak signal from the
infrared counterpart in one row of the array. Observations were obtained
in the standard stare/nod-along-slit mode. The total integration
time was 8 minutes. A near simultaneous spectrum of the F3V star HR 6987
(T=6700 K, K=4.50 assumed) was obtained at the same airmass; in order to
remove telluric absorption lines (the Brackett
(7-4) absorption line,
with a central depth of 0.88 of the continuum at this spectral resolution, was
artificially removed from the spectrum of the comparison star prior to
ratioing). Wavelength calibration was obtained from observations of an
argon arc lamp and is accurate to
.
The spectrum of
is shown in Fig. 5. It
is the sum of the spectra of three adjacent rows, covering an area of
arcsec. Most of the flux is contained in the central row.
The spectrum exhibits a very red continuum and a number of emission lines.
Most prominent are three recombination lines of atomic hydrogen: a very
strong Paschen
(4-3) line at
,
and weaker
Brackett
(7-4) and Brackett
(8-4) lines, at
and
,
respectively. The Pa
and Br
lines are uncorrected for the absorption due to the same
line in the comparison star and both it and the Br
line occur
near strong telluric absorption lines of water vapor; thus their strengths
and profiles are subject to systematic errors.
The peak of the Br
emission line occurs at
in the Local Standard of Rest (LSR). The Full Width at
Half Maximum (FWHM) of the profile is only marginally broader than the
instrumental resolution, but the profile appears to exhibit a weak
high-velocity wing, displaced towards the red. No such wing is present in
the profile of either of the other two atomic hydrogen lines. We note that
lines displaced towards the blue are much more common in the Hii regions,
because the front part of an expanding Hii region is more easily
detected.
Two fainter emission lines also are visible: the singlet He I 2P-2S
transition at
and the H
21-0S(1) line at
.
The flux in the
line is
.
There is also evidence for the presence of the
H
line at
,
at roughly one-fourth the
strength of the 1-0 line, which suggests that most of the excitation of
H2 is due to absorbed UV radiation rather than collisions. The 1-0
line appears partly resolved with a deconvolved FWHM of
500
,
but new measurements are required to confirm this. The signal-to-noise
ratio of the 2-1 line is too low to determine if its profile is resolved.
![]() |
Figure 5:
K-band spectrum of
![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
Both infrared sources were imaged in six wavebands from 7 to
with the infrared camera ISOCAM
(Cesarsky et al. 1996), on the Infrared Space
Observatory (ISO) satellite mission as part of the Guaranteed and Open
Time Programme. The observations were performed on 1996 April 28 and on 1997
October 20. The log of the observations and the derived fluxes in all
bands are found in Table 3. The images were taken through the
Large Width (LW) filters at angular resolutions given in this Table.
Data reduction used the CIA package and included subtraction of the dark
current, suppression of the cosmic ray impacts by a multiresolution median
method, correction of the detector transient behaviour, flat field
correction and when necessary a distortion correction (see
Starck et al. 1999 and references therein).
The observation at
of the south lobe, shown at the bottom of
Fig. 6
,
is particularly striking, because it shows
thermal emission, presumably from heated dust, exactly coincident with the
radio counterpart. One component of this emission is localized, between
the maximum and the jet feature seen at radio wavelengths, on a line
connecting
and
.
The other component is more
extended, and closely resembles the remainder of the radio image with its
bow-shock morphology at the south-east edge. The
image of
the north lobe is shown at the top of Fig. 6. The
morphology is similar to the radio images, resembling a common cometary Hii
region, but with two bow shock-like structures facing each other.
Source | Date | Filter | PFOV | Flux |
![]() |
28/04/96 | LW2 (5-
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
28/04/96 | LW7 (8.7-
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
28/04/96 | LW3 (12-
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
20/10/97 | LW10 (8-
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
20/10/97 | LW9 (14-
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
We used the 30 m radio telescope of the Instituto de Radio Astronomía
Milimetrica (IRAM) to observe molecular lines which are good density tracers and are
diagnostics of shock excitation and chemistry.
The observations, totalling 70 hours, took place during 1997 April 17-24,
November 29-December 3, and during 1997 December 31-1998
January 5. The observed molecules and transitions, together with their
respective frequencies were:
at
GHz,
at
GHz,
at
GHz,
at
GHz,
at
GHz,
at
GHz and
at
GHz. Details are given in Table 4.
We used position switching during the observations, with the off-source
position located (
,
)
from the position of
.
Tests demonstrated that the off position contained no significant
line emission. The treatment and analysis of the millimetric data were
standard, consisting for each spectrum of a subtraction of a polynomial
baseline of first or second order, in order to remove instrumental
fringes.
Abbr | Transition | Frequency | Receiver | Banks | Beam |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
230g2 | b44 b34 |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
230g1 | b43 b33 b20 |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
3mm1 | b42 b32 |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
3mm1 | b41 b31 |
![]() |
SiO 2-1 |
![]() |
![]() |
3mm2 | b41 b31 |
![]() |
SiO 3-2 |
![]() |
![]() |
2mm | b42 b32 |
![]() |
SiO 5-4 |
![]() |
![]() |
230g1 | b43 b33 b20 |
![]() |
Results for
,
,
and
Figure 7 contains position-velocity plots with an
expanded velocity scale for the observed lines of
,
,
and
.
For all transitions the line peak
occurs at an LSR velocity of 67
,
close to the velocity of
of the H92
recombination line observations as seen by RM98
with much lower velocity resolution. The intensity distributions of the
millimeter lines are not symmetric, each showing a sharper edge to the
south (positive RA offset), as seen in the VLA images, and a slightly
shifted peak velocity. The
transition, which is a high density
tracer, exhibits a peak shifted to the northwest (more negative RA
offsets), towards the jet-like feature.
SiO
The SiO 2-1 transition was detected only close to the position (-10, 14);
the spectrum at that location is shown in Fig. 8.
The line is weak, but its velocity,
and width,
are similar to those seen for much stronger
lines and give us confidence that it is real. The 3-2 transition was not
detected at any individual position, but the average of the spectra
between (0, 0) and (-17, 25) yields a
detection of a narrow (
)
line at
,
exhibiting an antenna
temperature of
T*A = 0.044 K and an intensity of
Kkms-1
(Fig. 9). The SiO 5-4 transition
was not detected at any individual location or when all of the spectra
were averaged.
![]() |
Figure 8:
Spectrum of the SiO 2-1 line at IRAS 19132+1035,
obtained at the offset (![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 9: Spectrum of the SiO 3-2 line at IRAS 19132+1035, averaged over all positions from (0, 0) to (-17, 25) |
Open with DEXTER |
Discussion
Figure 7 demonstrates clearly that brightness maxima for transitions with higher critical densities are displaced increasingly towards the northwest where the non-thermal jet-like structure is located. What little SiO emission is detected also originates largely in this region. The very densest region could be the main interaction zone between the putative jet and the ambient medium. However, the narrow lines that are observed are difficult to explain in the above scenario, as an energetic shock might be expected to lead to line emission over a much wider range of velocities than is observed. If a shock is present, it apparently must be of very low velocity.
For the
,
,
and SiO 2-1 transitions,
we acquired 24 spectra at positions separated by
,
along the line
joining
to the northern lobe. As in the case of the southern lobe,
the reference position (0, 0) is defined as the position of maximum radio
continuum signal in the northern lobe, as observed by the VLA. The
integration time at each position was 5 min, except at the reference
position, where it was 10 min. Each of the above transitions was
detected over a wide range of positions. Spectra of the CS 2-1, SiO 3-2
and SiO 5-4 transitions were obtained only at the (0, 0) position, each
with an integration time of 15 min. None of the three SiO transitions
were detected at any position at an upper limit of 0.05 K, or when
all positions were averaged.
Results for
,
and
Position velocity diagrams for
,
and
are presented using an expanded velocity scale in Fig. 10
. Two strong velocity components are readily apparent
in all three transitions. For
at the (0, 0) position, the
strongest component is centered at
,
with a
width of
,
an intensity of
,
and an
integrated brightness of
.
For
,
this
component is peaked at
,
and has a width of
,
an intensity of
,
and an integrated brightness of
.
A second velocity component occurs at
with a width of
,
an intensity of
and an
integrated brightness of
at the
(0, 0)
position. The velocities of these two components are close to that of the
H92
recombination line peak at
(RM98). A third
velocity component, at
6
is visible in the northwestern part
of this cloud for CO and in the southeastern part for
.
Given the
very different velocity the line emission probably originates in a
foreground or background cloud.
Results for
The single spectrum obtained at (0, 0), shown in Fig. 11,
contains a strong component centered at
,
of width
,
intensity
and integrated brightness
.
Adjacent to it is a weaker component at
,
with width
,
intensity
and
integrated brightness
.
These velocities
are similar to those detected in other molecules and in H92
(RM98).
Discussion
As already noted by RM98 from the centimeter observations, the morphology
of the northern source is that of a cometary Hii region. The millimeter wave
spectroscopy, which reveals two velocity components, is consistent with
this morphology.
![]() |
Figure 11:
IRAS 19124+1106, ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The new data do not definitively prove or disprove an association between
GRS 1915+105 and either of the IRAS sources. The strongest lines of
evidence supporting an association are (1) the axisymmetric locations of
the two sources at nearly the same position angle as the recent
sub-arcsecond ejections observed at radio wavelengths, (2) the spatial
coincidence of the non-thermal radio jet with the inner edge of the
southern source,
,
as well as the orientation of this jet along
the axis, (3) the location of the highest densities in
and
on the sides closest to
and, in the case of
,
close to the non-thermal jet, and (4) the bow shock - like structure in
the portion of
most distant from
.
Some of these lines of
evidence are associated only with the southern source. Evidence against an
association includes (1) the lack of detected high velocity gas at the
IRAS sources, (2) the luminosities of the IRAS sources, which are
consistent with each of them being powered by one or more hot stars, and (3)
the cometary morphology of the northern source,
,
which is
common in star forming regions.
Although the physical alignment of the IRAS sources could be a background
coincidence, the probability of this is low in view of the small number of
IRAS sources, the existence of a jet at
,
and the locations of
these sources within the Galaxy. It remains possible that the jet at
is an extragalactic background source. This should be tested by
radio observations at higher resolution. Because an association between
and these objects may be real we explore in the following the
potential characteristics of interactions of ejecta from
with the
interstellar gas and compare these examples with observations of another
somewhat similar source.
The angular separation between each IRAS sources
and
is
.
The measured proper motions
of the most recent ejections from
are
respectively for the approaching and receding ejecta
in the interval
mas/d and
mas/d
(
&
1994; Fender et al. 1999).
This implies typical travel times to reach the lobes
of 140 years for the approaching ejecta
and of 300 years for the receding ejecta.
It is therefore interesting to note that the impact due to the
South lobe with the southern IRAS source
would appear to occur much earlier
than that of the North lobe with the
northern IRAS source.
Evidence for precession of the
jets during the last five years is marginal
(Rodríguez &
Mirabel 1999), with the maximum angle no more than 10 degrees.
Thus a close alignment of currently observed jets close to
with
those from long past outbursts that may be responsible for the IRAS
sources may not be a coincidence.
It is perhaps surprising that the separations from
of the two
possible interaction zones are identical to better than two percent. These
are determined not only by properties of the outflow from
,
but also
by the density and uniformity of the interstellar medium. In order for
ejected matter to travel up to 60 pc, a large scale cavity must have been
created around
.
Over time this cavity could tend to extend an equal
distance in each direction. The probable existence of a cavity around
already has been pointed out by Mirabel &
Rodríguez (1996).
The plasma clouds ejected during the last few years exhibit ballistic motions (i.e.,
with no evidence of deceleration), indicating that the density in the
interstellar medium through which they have passed is less than 0.05
protons cm-3 (Mirabel & Rodríguez 1996). These clouds have been
observed until their emission faded out or became unobservable with the
available VLA configuration, typically at distances of one arcsecond from
the central source.
Although direct evidence for a cavity is limited to a region very close to
,
it is likely that the cavity extends well beyond one arcsecond
from it. Apart from the two IRAS sources, no phenomena that might be
associated with deceleration of recent ejecta have been observed from
1
angular separation from
to 17
.
In order to produce
a cavity with a linear dimension of many tens of parsecs, even a
relativistic source must be active for a much longer period of time than
has been observed. From EXOSAT measurements (Reynolds et al. 1999)
was active in 1985 but much fainter than it has been since 1992.
For the second discovered superluminal galactic source,
,
Kolb et al. (1997)
suggested that the activity of the source is caused by the companion
crossing the Hertzsprung gap, a transient phase lasting
1 Myr. The
companion of
(Martí et al. 2000) is believed to be more massive than
the companion of
(Shahbaz et al. 1999), and thus the duration of
the active phase would be much shorter, although still sufficiently long,
especially since
has been much more active than
.
Considerable heating of the gas must occur at the ends of the cavities,
where the ejecta, whether or not partially decelerated en route, impact
ambient material. One would expect that much of heating would occur via
shock excitation. For the case of
the speed and density of the
incident material and the relative amounts of atomic and molecular gas
(both in the incident and impacted material) are not known, and thus the
spectrum of the shock-heated gas is uncertain. The southern IRAS source
shows strong infrared lines of atomic hydrogen and weak infrared line
emission from molecular hydrogen, very unlike the emission observed in
molecular clouds impacted by protostellar winds having speeds of up to
100
,
in which lines of molecular hydrogen dominate and hydrogen
recombination lines are nearly non-existent (e.g. Geballe & Garden
1987).
We note that if the non-thermal feature near the southern lobe is an
element of the interaction involving the ejecta of
,
the collimation of the jet is
,
ten
times larger than the most highly collimated Herbig-Haro objects (see e.g.
Bachiller 1996).
This implies a jet opening angle of
which is consistent with the limit of <
derived by Fender et al. (1999) based on observations
of the core, but is more highly constraining.
This jet opening angle seems to be in agreement with the jet full
opening angle as function of distance from the core
for M 87 (Junor et al. 1999),
if we take into account the scaling factor between galactic and extragalactic
black holes. Therefore, as for extragalactic jets, it would require in the galactic case
ongoing confinement of the jet at large distances from the source, ruling
out free expansion of a relativistic gas.
Induced star formation?
The similarity of the luminosities of the IRAS sources to those of compact
Hii regions containing one or more massive stars, as well as the spectrum
of
,
which shows strong hydrogen recombination line emission,
suggest the possibility that ejecta from
have induced massive star
formation at the locations of the IRAS sources, via compression of the
interstellar gas. In this scenario the non-thermal radio jet observed at
might be interpreted as a Herbig-Haro-like feature, the result
of a protostellar wind breaking out of the natal cloud. However, given the
length of time for star formation to proceed to this phase, such an
explanation would require activity from
at a much earlier time than
mentioned above. Moreover, there appears to be no reason for star
formation at
to produce a close coincidence between the
position angle of the radio jet at
and that of the line
connecting
and
,
as is observed. Finally, the radio
emission from Herbig-Haro jets usually is thermal (free-free;
Rodríguez 1999). In view of these arguments, we do not regard
induced star formation to be a likely explanation for the luminosities of
and
.
Dubner et al. (1998) note that in the case of
the relativistic jets from SS 433 there is no evidence of induced star
formation in the impacted gas.
In view of the inconclusive evidence linking the IRAS sources with
activity originating at
,
it is perhaps useful to examine other
possible examples of such an interaction. Like
,
the famous X-ray
binary SS 433 ejects beams of material at relativistic speeds. This object
is located inside the radio shell/supernova remnant W50, which exhibits
two lateral extensions with dimensions of tens of parsecs
(Dubner et al. 1998). The morphology can be attributed to continuous
ejection of magnetic field and high-energy particles from the central
source. Sub-arcsecond jets are present at SS 433, with 5 orders of
magnitude difference between their extents and those of the far lobes. The
power injected into these jets is
according to
Dubner et al. (1998),
who also estimate that the kinetic energy transferred
to the surroundings of
during the last
2 104 years
amounts to
.
Major ejection events in GRS 1915+105 are more sporadic than in SS 433,
and therefore the average kinetic energy injected into the surroundings
over long periods of time may be smaller (Mirabel & Rodríguez 1999). The
kinetic energy of the 1994 March 19 event in
was
(Rodríguez & Mirabel 1999).
would need to exhibit one ejection
event per hour similar to this one in order to match SS 443. A more likely
rate is one event per month (Rodríguez & Mirabel 1999), in which case
2 107 years would be required to equal the energy output of
SS 443 in 2 104 years. However, we note also that the jets
emanating from
always are compact close to the source
(Dhawan et al. 2000), which indicates that a continuous injection of energy
from
is occuring. In addition to the large events described above,
there are also smaller ones, observed at X-ray, radio and infrared
wavelengths, where the mechanical luminosities are in the range
,
and where the synchrotron emission is seen up to
the infrared wavelengths (e.g. Mirabel et al. 1998;
Fender & Pooley 2000).
A comparison of the energetics of
with SS 433 and a Herbig-Haro
object is reported in Table 5.
Despite the differences between
and SS 433, each may have created a
cavity of similar linear extent. In view of the uncertainty as to what
effects might be observable at the putative ends of the cavity produced by
,
we have observed the western tip of W50 where the ejecta of SS 443
and the shell remnant interact, in some of the same millimeter lines of
,
,
and SiO as were observed for the
IRAS sources. The observed region in W50 is at the constant declination
and right ascensions between
and
(B1950) (see
Dubner et al. 1998, Figs. 1a and 1b).
The off position was 15
arcmin east and north of the reference point located at
;
.
Measurements at W50 were
separated by
,
with integration times of 5 min each, except
at (0, 0) where the integration time was 10 min.
The results are shown in Fig. 12 over the relevant velocity
range. Emission from
,
and
are found
roughly 200-300
west of the reference position, at the
westernmost edge of the radio shell (Dubner et al. 1998,
Figs. 1a and 1b).
The emission from the high density tracer
is the most
compact and probably indicates the location of the strongest interaction.
The line profiles of all three species are asymmetric but narrow. SiO 2-1 emission
was not detected. These results are very similar to those for
.
These similarities between SS 433/W50 and
/
and
suggest that high density, low velocity molecular clumps
may not be unusual products of the interaction of the ejecta of a distant
energetic source and the surrounding medium.
HH | SS 433 | GRS 1915 | |
Velocity | 1-500 kms-1 | 0.26 c | 0.92 c |
Separation | 1 au-10 pc | 50 pc | 60 pc |
Range | 106 | 105 | 104-105 |
Collimation | 2-10 | ![]() |
![]() |
Kinetic Pow. |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
We have performed extensive multi-wavelength observations from IR to radio
of two radio/IRAS sources axisymetrically located with respect to
and aligned with the position angle of the subarcsec jets. The northern
source has the morphology of a common cometary Hii region. The
observations of the southern cloud reveal a collimated non-thermal
structure which may be the far end of a jet of material from
.
Both
sources contain dense clumps of molecular material. Overall the evidence
for these regions being interaction zones seems inconclusive. An
abbreviated study of what may be a very similar interaction between the
ejecta of SS 433 and the surrounding interstellar medium reveals
strikingly similar (and also apparently inconclusive) phenomena, perhaps
indicating that such phenomena might be produced by sources which via
their violent behavior have created large cavities over long periods of
time.
Acknowledgements
We thank F. Comeron for allowing us to use part of his time at the ESO/MPI 2.2 m telescope of the ESO/La Silla. S.C. thanks the astronomers on duty at IRAM, particularly R. Moreno and D. Reynaud, for much assistance and many fruitful discussions during the observations. He thanks also G. Pineau des Forêts and B. Le Floch for helpful discussions. S. C. would like to acknowledge the invitation to work in the dynamic Instituto de Astronomia de Morelia, group of the Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico (UNAM), and the fruitful discussions leading to some of the ideas in this paper. He thanks also the Groupe de Recherche Accrétion-Disque-Jets (GdR ADJ) of the French Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS) altogether with the UNAM for the financial support of this journey. We thank R. P. Fender for pointing out to us the previous mislabelling of the region G 45.45+0.06. We also thank the anonymous referee for prompt and useful comments, which allowed us to improve the manuscript. S. C. acknowledges support from grant F/00-180/A from the Leverhulme Trust. I. F. M. acknowledges support from CONICET/Argentina. The UK Infrared Telescope is operated by the Joint Astronomy Centre on behalf of the UK Particle Physics and Astronomy Research Council. The ISOCAM data presented in this paper were analysed using "CIA'', a joint development by the ESA Astrophysics Division and the ISOCAM Consortium.
![]() |
Figure 3: Spectral index map of IRAS 19132+1035 made from the 20 and 6-cm maps. The color coding for the spectral index is given at the bottom of the figure. Note the negative, non-thermal spectral index of the jet feature to the northwest |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 6:
Top: ISO map of the source
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 7:
Observations of IRAS 19132+1035.
Offsets are relative to the position of maximum radio emission
observed at the VLA.
The black contours are antennae iso-temperature:
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 10:
Observations of IRAS 19124+1106.
Offsets are relative to the position of maximum radio emission
observed at the VLA.
The black contours are antennae iso-temperatures:
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 12:
Observations of W50, the supernova remnant shell surrounding SS 433.
Offsets are relative to the position of the central source.
The black contours are antennae iso-temperatures:
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |