A&A 366, 490-497 (2001)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20000213
D. Schönberner1 - S. M. Andrievsky1,2,3 - J. S. Drilling4
1 - Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam, An der Sternwarte 16,
14482 Potsdam, Germany
2 -
Department of Astronomy, Odessa State University,
Shevchenko Park, 65014, Odessa, Ukraine
3 -
Isaac Newton Institute of Chile, Odessa Branch, Chilei
4 -
Louisiana State University, Department of Physics and Astronomy,
Baton Rouge, Louisiana 70803, USAi
Received 8 September 2000 / Accepted 7 November 2000
Abstract
We performed for the first time a detailed LTE spectroscopic study
of a sample of blue straggler stars in the moderately old open
cluster NGC 7789. For eight stars the parameters and
abundances of several elements were determined. The cluster
members show a remarkable surface magnesium deficiency which is
quite unusual for late B - early A stars. Iron and titanium
abundances are in agreement with other photometric and
spectroscopic estimates of the NGC 7789 metallicity. All
the confirmed blue stragglers have rather low projected rotational
velocities (with one exception for K88,
kms-1).
Key words: stars: open clusters and associations: individual: NGC 7789 - stars: blue stragglers - stars: abundances
The moderately old open cluster NGC 7789 is among those having very rich blue-straggler populations. Ahumada & Lapasset (1995) give a cluster age of 1.6 Gyr, and the number of suspected blue-straggler candidates is reported to be 25. Despite this large blue-straggler population, no quantitative abundance analysis has been performed so far.
Twenty years ago NGC 7789 with its blue stragglers became a paradigm to explain the existence of such stars by assuming ad hoc additional internal mixing which extends the main sequence phase (Saio & Wheeler 1980). Such a putative mechanism was later discussed by Schönberner & Napiwotzki (1994) who determined accurate effective temperatures and gravities for several blue stragglers in NGC 7789. These authors have shown that the existence of blue stragglers does not result from internal mixing processes, but that they rather evolve like normal stars.
In recent years interest in the NGC 7789 blue stragglers (and in blue stragglers in general) has waned because of the failure to find any spectroscopic signature unique to this phenomenon.
Our third paper from this series is devoted to a detailed spectroscopic investigation of blue-straggler candidates in NGC 7789.
We have been able to secure spectrograms of a total of 8 blue-straggler
candidates at two different observatories (Kitt Peak National Observatory -
KPNO, and Calar Alto Observatory - CA).
Some essential information about our targets and details of their
observation are given in Table 1. Additional information about
the stars listed in the table can be also found in the WEBDA data base
(Mermilliod 1999). The well investigated star
Lyr (Vega)
has been chosen as a reference star in order to control our method of the
analysis.
K | GET | V | B-V | MP | Region,Å | Instrument |
K88 | 2873 | 13.10 | 0.38 | 0.98 | 4220-4525 | KPNO |
K316 | 5569 | 13.79 | 0.36 | 0.98 | 4220-4525 | KPNO |
K371 | 5951 | 12.95 | 0.36 | 0.98 | 4220-4525 | KPNO |
H![]() ![]() |
CA | |||||
K409 | 6268 | 12.98 | 0.31 | 0.53 | 4220-4525 | KPNO |
H![]() |
CA | |||||
K677 | 8404 | 11.16 | 0.16 | 0.53 | 4220-4525 | KPNO |
4450-4585, H![]() |
CA | |||||
K746 | 8804 | 12.74 | 0.39 | 0.98 | 4220-4525 | KPNO |
H![]() |
CA | |||||
K1211 | 13273 | 11.55 | 0.18 | 0.97 | H![]() ![]() |
CA |
4450-4580 | CA | |||||
K1270 | 14054 | 13.46 | 0.46 | 0.98 | 4220-4525 | KPNO |
Vega | 0.06 | 4220-4525 | KPNO | |||
K - Küstner (1923) number; GET - Gim et al. (1998a) number; MP - membership probability | ||||||
as determined by McNamara & Solomon (1981). |
KPNO spectra were obtained during October 1-3, 1985, with the 4-m telescope
equipped with an echelle spectrograph and CCD camera (resolution 0.12 Å/px,
S/N ratio varying from approximately 30 to 80 at the continuum
level, except for Vega). These spectrograms were extracted from the frames
in the usual manner by using the IRAF package.
All spectra consisted of nine (not overlapping) orders, each covering
approximately 30 Å. Because of the small sizes of the observed bands we met
some problems with the correct continuum placement in the vicinity of the
H
line. To avoid the problems that could be caused by the wrong
continuum placement, the two adjacent orders from the spectrum of each star
ranging from 4320 Å to 4390 Å were discarded in the further analysis.
The CA spectral material was obtained during two runs in January and September
1986 with the 2.2-m telescope equipped with a Coudé spectrograph (resolution
0.26 Å/px, S/N ratio about 40-70). These observations were aimed
at getting reliable profiles of the hydrogen lines H
and H
.
The
spectral regions cover approximately 130 Å each.
The final spectra were treated using the DECH20 spectra processing package (Galazutdinov 1992).
The effective temperatures were estimated using the Strömgren photometric
indices (available for the program stars through the WEBDA data base, see
Mermilliod 1999) by means of the numerical code written by T.T. Moon
(based on the grid published in Moon & Dworetsky 1985) and
modified by Napiwotzki (1994). In the WEBDA data base, however,
the -index is given for only two of our program stars. For the
remaining ones we used either the measurements given in the paper of
Schönberner & Napiwotzki (1994), or obtained by Schönberner
(unpublished) with the same technique as explained in Schönberner &
Napiwotzki (1994).
In cases where H
and H
profiles were available (cf. Table 1)
the gravities were specified by matching observed and calculated
profiles. The profiles of the hydrogen lines were calculated with the help
of the SYNSPEC code (Hubeny et al. 1994).
For K88, K316 and K1270 hydrogen profiles are not available, and we used
gravities determined by photometry. However, for K316 and K1270 the
photometrically determined gravities appeared to be inconsistent with their
positions in the HR diagram (see Fig. 4 from Breger 1982).
For the less evolved star, K316, we adopted
,
and for K1270
.
Note that these adopted gravities differ
0.4 dex from the
photometrically estimated ones, but this difference has a small influence
on the derived abundances in the temperature region in question.
The finally adopted effective temperatures and gravities are collected in Table 2. Note that for K409, K677, K1211 and Vega the values given in Schönberner & Napiwotzki (1994) were used.
Projected rotational velocities were determined by matching observed and calculated profiles of the hydrogen and/or metallic lines (mainly Mgii) and are also listed in Table 2.
Knum |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
K88 | 8900 | 3.7 | 80 |
K316 | 8950 | 4.0 | 25 |
K371 | 8500 | 3.7 | 45 |
K409 | 9480 | 4.2 | 140 |
K677 | 10680 | 3.6 | 40 |
K746 | 8600 | 3.5 | 20 |
K1211 | 12630 | 3.6 | 30 |
K1270 | 8300 | 3.5 | 25 |
Vega | 9500 | 4.0 | 22 |
The atmosphere models of Kurucz (1991) and oscillator strengths for
the lines of interest from the VALD data base were used to determine
individual elemental abundances in conjunction with the LTE spectrum synthesis
method (SYNSPEC, Hubeny et al. 1994). For all the program
blue stragglers we adopted the microturbulent velocity
kms-1(the same value as adopted in Andrievsky et al.
2000 - Paper II),
while for Vega we used the literature value
kms-1(see, e.g. Sadakane & Nishimura 1981). For the sake of completeness,
we also calculated the abundances with the smaller value of
kms-1 recommended by Adelman & Gulliver
(1990).
Note that our implementation of the SYNSPEC code enables one to
calculate only the spectra of chemical elements with
,
therefore,
the lines of the heavier species (if observed) were ignored. The
steps of the analysis mentioned above are described in more detail
in Paper II.
There is much evidence that Vega is a mild metal deficient star,
therefore, we used the atmosphere model selected from the grid with
for its spectrum synthesis.
Elemental abundances for Vega and our program blue stragglers are given in Tables 3 and 4. For Vega we also give a comparison with the most recent study by Hill (1995) also based on the spectrum synthesis technique. It should be stressed that with this study we did not aim to enlarge the number of precise and detailed spectroscopic investigations of Vega. Our main reason was to have some external indication of the reliability of the analysis based on our homogeneous spectroscopic material. Although the number of lines used is limited, the agreement in the derived abundances with Hill (1995) is satisfactory.
All of our high-probability proper-motion members show a strong deficiency of magnesium and scandium. For example, in Figs. 1 and 2 the synthetic and observed spectra for program stars in the vicinity of the Mgii 4481 Å line are shown. The synthetic spectra were calculated with the parameters listed in Table 2 and magnesium abundances for individual stars from Tables 3 and 4.
The detected magnesium deficiency for blue straggler stars cannot be
removed by any reasonable changes in the atmospheric parameters, because
within the temperature region 8000 K-10000 K, the magnesium line
4481 Å appears to be practically insensitive to temperature
and gravity variations. This was also mentioned by Holweger, Gigas &
Steffen (1986) who performed a qualitative search for abundance
indicators in early A stars which are both temperature and gravity insensitive.
As an example, we have calculated the magnesium abundance for K1270 assuming
temperature and gravity uncertainties of about K and
dex respectively. The resulting changes in the abundance appeared to
be negligible, and even smaller for temperatures higher than 8500 K. The
response of the magnesium abundance (as derived from the Mgii 4481 Å line) caused by the parameter variations is given in Table 5.
The
means the difference between the magnesium abundance [Mg/H]
derived for K1270 with its basic model parameters (see Table 2) and with
varied parameters (e.g., 7750/4.0/3.0 denotes model with
=
7750K,
and
km s-1).
Present Paper | Hill (1995) | ||||
0.6 kms-1 | 2.0 kms-1 | ||||
El. | [El/H] | [El/H] | ![]() |
N | [El/H] |
Mg | -0.10 | -0.26 | - | 1 | -0.27 |
Ca | -0.63 | -0.73 | - | 1 | -0.47 |
Sc | -1.27 | -1.41 | - | 1 | - |
Ti | -0.30 | -0.64 | 0.09 | 7 | -0.46 |
Cr | -0.25 | -0.34 | - | 1 | -0.48 |
Fe | -0.18 | -0.46 | 0.11 | 7 | -0.54 |
Star | He | Mg | Ca | Sc | Ti | Cr | Fe |
K88 | -0.70 (-, 1) | -0.25 (-, 1) | -1.11 (-, 1) | -0.28 (0.18, 5) | -0.12 (0.20, 5) | ||
K316 | -1.04 (-, 1) | -0.53 (-, 1) | -1.31 (0.18, 4) | -0.41 (0.19, 3) | +0.09 (-, 2) | -0.23 (0.19, 11) | |
K371 | -0.20 (-, 1) | -0.77 (-, 1) | -0.13 (0.23, 4) | ||||
K409 | +0.00 (-, 1) | ||||||
K677 | +0.07 (-, 1) | +0.16 (0.18, 5) | -0.24 (0.22, 6) | -0.08 (0.17, 7) | |||
K746 | -0.64 (-, 1) | -0.14 (0.17, 4) | -0.92 (0.25, 5) | -0.23 (0.19, 15) | +0.03 (0.16, 4) | -0.13 (0.19, 13) | |
K1211 | -1.00 (-, 1) | -1.04 (-, 1) | -0.10 (0.23, 4) | ||||
K1270 | -1.14 (-, 1) | -0.71 (0.29, 4) | -2.03 (0.19, 5) | -0.39 (0.24, 11) | +0.00 (0.18, 4) | -0.20 (0.18, 15) | |
Given in the brackets are s.d. and number of used lines respectively. |
7750/3.0/3.0 | 7750/4.0/3.0 | 8750/3.0/3.0 | 8750/4.0/3.0 | 8300/3.6/2.5 | 8300/3.6/3.5 | |
![]() |
-0.12 | +0.18 | -0.05 | +0.05 | +0.09 | -0.05 |
For the iron-group (Ti, Fe), the abundances for the blue stragglers
do not differ from those determined for other stars in NGC 7789.
Tiede et al. (1997) estimated the metallicity of
NGC 7789 by IR photometry of the giant branch to be
.
Recently, Vallenary et al. (2000) revised this value
by an improved method using new IR photometry and found
.
Friel & Janes (1993) carried out low-resolution spectroscopy for several
giants and obtained a mean metallicity of
.
Pilachowski
(1985) performed a high-resolution spectroscopic investigation of six
giant stars and found
,
in excellent agreement with our
mean iron abundance (-0.16 dex).
As to other elements, there is only one indication in the literature that the relative-to-solar abundances of atomic species like Ca, Sc, Ti, etc. scatter only slightly about that of iron (Pilachowski 1985). Our results for titanium and chromium agree very well with those of Pilachowski, that of calcium only marginally. The only really discrepant case is for scandium where our blue stragglers appear to be deficient between a factor of 10 to 100. It is known, however, that A-type stars very often show peculiarities of certain elements (see Sect. 5.2).
![]() |
Figure 1: Observed ( thin line) and calculated ( thick line) fragment of the spectra in the vicinity of Mgii 4481 Å line |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 2: Same as Fig. 1 |
Open with DEXTER |
The membership probabilities for our blue-straggler candidates in NGC 7789 have been determined by several investigations:
We also revised the radial velocities for several blue stragglers previously
analysed by Drilling & Schönberner (1987). We used the KPNO spectra
and applied the very accurate method of line mirroring. The results are given
in the corresponding column of Table 6. We checked the method by applying
it to our reference star Vega. From 14 lines of its KPNO spectrum we derived the
mean value of
kms-1, in good agreement with
the recommended value of -13.9 kms-1 (SIMBAD data base).
The problem of the determination of true, i.e. physical, cluster memberships is somewhat delicate and prone to personal opinions. The necessary condition for an object to be a (physical) cluster member is the agreement of its proper motion and radial velocity with those of the cluster.
Spectroscopy, as performed by Schönberner & Napiwotzki (1994), serves as a final criterion because it provides a distance information. If, however, spectroscopy indicates membership, it must be supplemented by the proper motion and radial velocity data in order to distinguish between the physical members and field interlopers (see the case of K677 in Table 6).
The membership assignments of Table 6 are based on the philosophy outlined above. Note that in the two cases (K409 and K1211) where spectroscopy indicates non-membership, this statement is supported by the radial velocity measurements. Altogether we consider 11 of the 26 blue-straggler candidates to be the members of NGC 7789.
Star number | Radial velocity | Spectroscopy | Membership | |||||||
M | K | SS70 | SH84 | DS87(CA) | DS87(KPNO) | MPMR89 | ML94 | This work | SN94 | |
257 | 2 | - | - | - | - | - | N | - | - | N |
317 | 68 | - | - | - | - | - | N | - | - | N |
325 | 88 | - | - | - | - | - | Y |
![]() |
- | M* |
377 | 168 | -21 | - | - | - | - | U | - | - | U |
389 | 192 | - | - | - | - | - | U | - | - | U |
396 | 197 | -31 | - | - | - | - | N | - | - | N |
419 | 234 | -26 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | N |
460 | 282 | - | -47 | -54 | - | -43 | M | - | M | U |
482 | 316 | - | - | - | -58 | - | Y |
![]() |
- | M |
502 | 342 | -45 | -51 | -56 | - | -51 | U | - | M | M |
500 | 349 | -34 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | N |
518 | 371 | -56 | -56 | -55 | -65 | -58 | Y |
![]() |
- | M |
543 | 409 | -20 | -45 | -27 | -29 | - | N | -28 (1) | N | N |
574 | 453 | -41 | -52 | -41 | - | -71 | U | - | M | M |
747 | 677 | - | -37 | -27 | -23 | -18 | N |
![]() |
M | N |
752 | 696 | - | - | - | - | - | U | - | - | U |
789 | 746 | - | - | -53 | -52 | - | Y |
![]() |
- | M |
913 | 934 | - | - | - | - | - | N | - | - | N |
1011 | 1095 | - | - | - | - | - | Y | - | - | M |
1054 | 1168 | -49 | - | - | - | - | Y | - | - | M |
1088 | 1211 | -33 | -41 | -31 | - | - | N | - | N | N |
1133 | 1270 | - | - | - | -61 | - | Y |
![]() |
- | M |
144 | - | - | - | U | - | - | U | |||
459 | - | - | - | -44 | - | - | U | - | M | M |
808 | - | - | - | - | - | - | U | - | - | U |
1060 | - | - | - | - | - | - | U | - | - | U |
M - McNamara (1980) number.
K - Küstner (1923) number. M, N, U - denotes the members, non-members and stars with an uncertain membership respectively. SS70 - Strom & Strom (1970). SH84 - Stryker & Hrivnak (1984). DS87(CA) - Drilling & Schönberner (1987), Calar Alto spectra. DS87(KPNO) - Drilling & Schönberner (1987), Kitt Peak spectra. MPMR89 - Manteiga et al. (1989). ML94 - Milone & Latham (1994). SN94 - Schönberner & Napiwotzki (1994). * - Based on the study of Milone & Latham (1994), Gim et al. (1998a) considered the membership of K88 to be uncertain. However, by looking at the original data of Milone & Latham (Table 2 therein), it became evident that Gim et al. used erroneously the data of K68 instead, which is a radial-velocity non-member. |
The fact that the blue stragglers in NGC 7789 display abundance anomalies for some chemical elements, which are not seen in the convectively well-mixed cluster giants, indicates that these anomalies are purely surface phenomena. All investigated blue stragglers fall in the domain of late B - early/mid A-type stars. It is well known that stars of these spectral types demonstrate a great variety of chemical peculiarities. Our investigated blue stragglers possess projected rotational velocities which are lower than is expected for their spectral classes. It is therefore interesting to compare their abundance anomalies (for the confirmed cluster members only, see Sect. 5.1) with those of chemically peculiar stars.
![]() |
Figure 3:
Comparison of different abundance distributions.
Open circles: mean values of "normal'' A-type stars from
Caliskan & Adelman (1997) and Adelman (1999);
open squares: mean values from Hill (1995);
filled squares: individual values of the blue stragglers investigated in
this paper; large open circles: our data for Vega.
Note that the literature values are horizontally shifted by ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
Numerous studies of sharp-lined late B - early A-type stars were performed
by Adelman with co-authors (see, e.g. Caliskan & Adelman 1997 and
references therein). They showed that some of these stars have solar-like
elemental distributions. For example, Caliskan & Adelman (1997) and
Adelman (1999) provide elemental abundances for 17 stars (without
Vega and the
Boo type star 29 Cyg). From this sample one can derive
a mean magnesium abundance (from the Mgii lines only) of
.
This value is significantly larger than
the magnesium abundance of our blue stragglers. In Fig. 3 we compare
their abundance distribution (that of Vega from Table 3 included) with
data from the literature on A stars possessing small projected rotational
velocities.
As one can see from Fig. 3 the blue straggler abundance distribution
follows the general trend, with the exception of Mg and Sc which appear to be
depleted.
According to the classical definition, Am stars have apparent surface underabundances of Ca and Sc (see Cayrel et al. 1991). This is also the case for the blue stragglers studied here. Am stars are, however, also characterized by a moderate overabundance of the iron-group and heavier elements, but this is not seen in NGC 7789 (we recall that we did not investigate elements heavier than iron). Also, the remarkable magnesium deficiency of the NGC 7789 blue stragglers is not reported for Am stars.
Ap stars show even more pronounced abundance anomalies, especially for heavy species. On the other side, magnesium, calcium and scandium can often be substantially depleted. With the spectral material at our disposal we are not able to decide whether our blue-straggler sample contains Ap stars. For example, the Srii 4215 Å classification feature is not covered by the observed spectral region, although the rather strong lines of Zrii 4496.96 Å and Yii 4398.02 Å are seen in the spectra of K746 and K1270. It should be also mentioned that Stryker & Hrivnak (1984) noted that K1211 shows relatively strong Siii lines and an absence of the helium lines (the latter is in agreement with our result on helium abundance in this star). The above mentioned authors classified K1211 as Ap(Si) star.
The weak Mgii 4481 Å line is an inherent feature of some A stars,
as described by Abt & Morrell (1995). These authors
consider them as a mild version of the
Boo-type stars (see the next
item).
Using the data of Abt & Morrell (1995) we plot the equivalent widths
of the magnesium line vs. spectral class for normal A-type stars,
Mgii 4481 Å-weak stars, and NGC 7789 blue stragglers
(see Table 7 for the spectral class assignments for program stars).
As can be seen, several of the stragglers resemble the most extreme
Mgii 4481 Å-weak stars. In spite of this, the stragglers have
rather low projected rotational velocities (cf. Table 2) as compared
with the Mgii 4481 Å-weak stars for which a mean of more than
100 kms-1 appears to be appropriate (Abt & Morrell 1995).
Interestingly, the two certain non-members, K409 and K677, show virtually
solar magnesium abundances, thereby giving additional evidence for their
non-membership.
Chemically peculiar A stars of the
Boo type occur at various
rotational velocities with a typical
value of
100 kms-1.
Several recent studies of the
Boo-type stars (see, Andrievsky
et al. 1998; Paunzen et al. 1999) have shown that
in their atmospheres many metals have significantly reduced abundances.
In particular, magnesium, calcium and scandium may be depleted by a factor
of about 10-100. Similar underabundances are also detected for titanium
and iron. At present, there is accumulating evidence that there should be
a link between the
Boo phenomenon (extreme abundance anomalies)
and Vega-like stars characterized by a milder metal deficiency.
Dunkin et al. (1997) recently analysed several Vega-like
stars and found in some cases relatively strong depletion of magnesium and
calcium, while the abundances of iron-group elements are solar within 0.25 dex.
![]() |
Figure 4: Equivalent width of the Mg II 4481 Å line vs. spectral class: small circles - class V, small filled squares - class IV, asterisks - class III, large filled squares - program blue stragglers, large open circle - Vega, dots - Mgii 4481 Å-weak stars |
Open with DEXTER |
Concluding this investigation of the blue stragglers in the NGC 7789 field we state that:
Acknowledgements
Authors are thankful to the referee, Dr. S. J. Adelman, for his valuable comments. SMA is also grateful to the Astrophysikalisches Institut of Potsdam (Germany) for the financial support and the opportunity to perform this work using its institutional facilities. The necessary information has been obtained through the SIMBAD and VALD data bases.
Star |
![]() |
Sp* | EW(4481)(mÅ) |
K88 | 8900 | A2-A3 | 320 |
K316 | 8950 | A2 | 280 |
K371 | 8500 | A4 | 490 |
K746 | 8600 | A3-A4 | 353 |
K1270 | 8300 | A4-A5 | 270 |
K409 | 9480 | A0 | 640 |
K677 | 10680 | B9 | 460 |
K1211 | 12630 | B7-B8 | 280 |
Vega | 9500 | A0 | 311 |
* - spectral types are roughly estimated by us between | |||
III-V luminosity classes using Lang (1992). |