A&A 365, 115-117 (2001)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20000089
Research Note
R. E. Mennickent 1
- J. Greiner 2 - G. Tovmassian 3
Send offprint request: R. E. Mennickent,
1 - Dpto. de Fisica, Facultad de Ciencias Fisicas y Matematicas,
Universidad de Concepcion, Casilla 160-C, Concepcion, Chile
2 - Astrophysical Institute Potsdam, An der Sternwarte 16, 14482 Potsdam,
Germany
3 - Observatorio Astronomico Nacional, Instituto de Astronomia,
UNAM, 22860 Ensenada, Mexico
Received 3 October 2000 / Accepted 30 October 2000
Abstract
We present optical and near infrared spectroscopy of the symbiotic star
candidate V589 Sgr. The presence of TiO and VO absorption
bands, along with strong H I and He I emissions, confirm the
symbiotic star classification, although the primary is clearly rather
cooler than is common in symbiotics. Following standard spectroscopic
methods, a spectral type of M4 III is derived for the cool component,
along with a distance of 8 kpc.
Key words: stars: binaries: general - stars: binaries: symbiotic - stars: evolution - stars: fundamental parameters - stars: V 589 Sgr
Author for correspondance: rmennick@stars.cfm.udec.cl
V 589Sgr was noted as an irregular variable with the comment ``RCB type
?'' in a study of Milky Way area 187 by Swope (1936). This author gives a
magnitude range of 14.2 mag to fainter than 16.5 mag (
mag according to Milone (1990) and Simbad), but no light curve is
shown in her paper. The probable RCB classification was recently
rejected by Kilkenny (1997) after the analysis of a spectrum showing
Balmer lines of hydrogen in emission with a steep Balmer decrement.
Instead, he proposed a classification as symbiotic-like, since
the spectrum, spanning the wavelength range of 3400-5200 Å,
shows marginal TiO bands but not the He I and He II
emissions which are typical of symbiotic stars.
Another point noted by Kilkenny (1997) is the slightly different position
of the object which he identified as the variable V589Sgr with respect to the
GCVS's position. We add here that we measured the coordinates of V589Sgr
as
= 18
05
17
1,
= -34
44
47
,
thus improving those
given in Milone (1990) and Simbad.
![]() |
Figure 1:
Spectrum of V589 Sgr obtained
with DFOSC grism #15. Main emission lines are labeled. The
H![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The low resolution spectrum, shown in Fig. 1, shows typical features of a
symbiotic star, viz. Balmer emissions with steep decrement, which are
signatures of the hot component, and TiO bands, probably originating in
the cool atmosphere of a red star. In addition to the features seen by
Kilkenny (1997), we find Fe I, He I and Fe II
emissions, and most notably the Ca II 8498, 8542, 8662 triplet in
emission. Based on the wavelengths, and the absence of Paschen 14, we
suspect that these emissions are truly Ca II and not the Paschen
P13, P15 and 16 lines. The emissions at
4730, 5197 and 6384 Å
are tentatively identified as Mn I whereas
5991 and 6300
Å probably correspond to O I. The narrow absorption lines of
the cool-star, often seen in symbiotics, do not appear in our spectrum.
The H
emission wings extend to velocities
1000 kms-1. The spectral characteristics described above, especially the
presence of the Ca II triplet in emission and the absence of
He II emission, places V589Sgr as a special member in the
class of symbiotic stars. The steep Balmer decrement, and the absence of
He II4686 emission, implies a temperature for the hot component
lower than in other members of the class.
Line |
![]() |
rv (kms-1) |
H![]() |
-143 | 13 |
H![]() |
-40 | 40 |
H![]() |
-21 | 11 |
H![]() |
-9 | -46 |
H![]() |
-8 | -162 |
He I 5875 | -8 | 14 |
He I 5015 | -10 | 105 |
He I 4922 | -9 | 60 |
Ca II 8662 | -1 | |
Ca II 8542 | -4 | |
Ca II 8498 | -7 | |
Mn I 4730 | -5 | 4 |
Mn I 5197 | -5 | -2 |
Mn I 6384 | -1 | -3 |
Fe I 4384 | -6 | 15 |
Fe I 4490 | -6 | 8 |
Fe I 4602 | -1 | 28 |
Fe I 5168 | -6 | 17 |
Fe II 4628 | -4 | 7 |
Fe II 5362 | -2 | 18 |
Fe II 6433 | -2 | 6 |
Fe II 6456 | -2 | 8 |
Fe II 6516 | -3 | 17 |
Fe I + Fe II 4232 | -5 | |
Fe I + Fe II 4414 | -10 | |
Fe I + Fe II 5316 | -5 | |
Fe I + Fe II 6417 | -1 | |
O I 5991 | -2 | -5 |
O I 6300 | -3 | 19 |
unknown 4618 | -2 | |
unknown 4666 | -3 | |
unknown 5234 | -4 | |
unknown 5275 | -3 | |
unknown 5534 | -2 | |
unknown 6147 | -2 | |
unknown 6317 | -2 | |
unknown 7633 | -10 |
Table 1 lists the equivalent width and the radial velocity for the main
spectral lines. Heliocentric radial velocities were measured by fitting
Gaussian functions to the profiles whereas the equivalent width
was obtained by integration of the flux between the points where the
profile merges with the continuum. Since the spectrum shows strong
gradients and severe line blending, it is not an elementary task to determine
the continuum, so the errors associated to the equivalent widths can be of
order of 30% for the weaker lines but certainly much lower for the stronger lines
(5% for H
for instance).
From Table 1 the mean radial velocities are:
= 22
14 kms-1 (3 lines),
=
67
42 kms-1 (3 lines),
= 17
7 kms-1 (4 lines),
= 13
5 kms-1 (5 lines)
and
= 7
12 kms-1 (2 lines). The errors reflect the
root mean square of the averages. Several lines cannot be identified.
Possible causes are line blending or existence of lines of high
excitation ions. The radial velocities here reported were measured on the
grism #7 spectrum, since
this spectrum provided the best set of radial velocities, compared
with the spectra taken with lower resolution grisms. For this reason
we do not give velocities of lines with
> 6900 Å, since
these measurements showed a great scatter.
The above average of H I velocities does not consider the low
velocity H
and H
lines, since these lines are likely
contaminated with Fe I and Fe II and might suffer of
wavelength calibration biases on the CCD blue edge. The velocities
reported here are different from those given by Kilkenny (1997), viz.
kms-1 and
kms-1. A long-term study is necessary to confirm the radial
velocity variability of this star.
We intended a classification of the red component, based on the fact that the
TiO bands are good indicators of the spectral type
(Kenyon & Fernandez-Castro 1987). We measured the [TiO]1, [TiO]2and [VO] indices defined by Kenyon & Fernandez-Castro (1987), obtaining
0.115(5), 0.37(0) and 0.22(0) respectively. These indices yield spectral
types of M3, M5 and M4, using Eqs. (5-7) of
Kenyon & Fernandez-Castro (1987). The spectral type
M4 is close to the mean of a sample of 100 symbiotic stars
(see Mürset & Schmid 1999).
The absence of Ca II absorption and other luminosity indicators (e.g. Na II and Fe I absorption lines, Zhu et al. 1999) makes any estimation of the luminosity class almost impossible. However, in the case where the secondary is a giant, like in most symbiotic stars, the calcium triplet in emission could not be understood as chromospheric activity, as sometimes occurs in dwarfs. An alternative explanation is an origin in the outer cool parts of an accretion disk as seen in some cataclysmic variables (e.g. Persson 1988).
We can use the emission line ratios to estimate the
interstellar extinction. Assuming a theoretical ratio
= 2.8 (nebulae case B, Osterbrock 1974),
we derive, from the observed ratio of 4.13, a selective extinction
E(B-V) = 0.42 (see Seaton 1979 for details of the method). This figure
yields
AV = 1.33. This deduced extinction is similar to the total
galactic extinction in the direction of V589 Sgr (
Dickey & Lockman 1990), when using the conversion according to Predehl & Schmitt
(1995). This fact implies that V589 Sgr is beyond all the
galactic column. At a galactic latitude of
deg this
yields a distance larger than 1 kpc. Based on the intensity in the
spectra we deduce a brightness of
mag,
corresponding to a stage of intermediate brightness. The distance,
inferred by assuming
MV = -0.3 for a M4 giant and the extinction
above, is d = 8 kpc. On the contrary,
when assuming a dwarf companion with
mag, the deduced
distance would have to be of the order of 40 pc only, inconsistent with
the deduced extinction of the Balmer lines.
A check of the ROSAT All-Sky survey archive reveals no X-ray source at the position of V 589 Sgr. This corresponds to an unabsorbed flux limit of < 10-12 erg cm-2 s-1 in the 0.1-2.4 keV range. Given the above extinction, this is no surprise.
Acknowledgements
We thank the referee, Dr. D. Kilkenny, for useful comments about a first version of this manuscript. This work was supported by Grant Fondecyt 1000324 and DI UdeC 99.11.28-1.