In 1987, Bothun et al. reported the serendipitous discovery of
the extraordinarily large low surface brightness (LSB)
galaxy now known as Malin-1. In spite of
having a projected B-band central surface brightness of only
26.5 mag arcsec-2, Malin-1 is the largest spiral galaxy known,
with a disk scale length of 73 kpc (assuming H0=75 kms-1 Mpc-1), and an
exceptionally high H I mass (
)
and optical luminosity (
MB=-23.1).
Subsequently, through systematic
searches of photographic survey plates, other galaxies with
similar (albeit slightly less
extreme) properties to Malin-1
have been uncovered (Bothun et al. 1990;
Sprayberry et al. 1993; Sprayberry et al. 1995b). We hereafter refer
to these as ``LSB Giants''. A handful of
LSB Giants are also found
in the UGC (Nilson 1973), NGC (Dreyer 1953), and ESO (Lauberts &
Valentijn 1989) catalogues (see Gallagher & Bushouse 1983;
Impey & Bothun 1989;
Walsh et al. 1997; Pickering et al. 1997; Schombert 1998).
Nonetheless, while recent photographic and CCD surveys have
uncovered large numbers of new small and medium-sized, moderate-to-low
surface brightness spiral galaxies (e.g., Schombert et al. 1992;
Impey et al. 1996; O'Neil et al. 1997),
LSB Giants have remained relatively rare. Having
faint, diffuse disks, but
sizes, H I masses, and luminosities at the high end for disk galaxies,
the LSB Giants occupy a unique realm of physical
parameters space and may share
evolutionary histories distinct from other LSB galaxies
(e.g., Hoffman et al. 1992).
Since a continuum of values exists for galaxy properties such as
surface brightness, luminosity, and scale length,
Sprayberry et al. (1995b) proposed to define LSB Giants as those
objects meeting a ``diffuseness
index'' criterion:
, where
is the extrapolated, deprojected
B-band disk central surface brightness in
magnitudes arcsec-2, and
is the
disk scale length in kpc. Among seven LSB
Giants described by Sprayberry et al. (1995b), mean properties
include:
,
mags
arcsec-2, and
kpc.
The colors of these LSB
Giants are thus comparable to those of normal spirals (Sprayberry
et al. 1995b),
but are redder than typical colors of many small and
moderate-sized LSB disks (e.g., McGaugh & Bothun 1994; Matthews &
Gallagher 1997; de Blok et al. 1996; Beijersbergen et al. 1999).
In addition, the LSB Giants are distinct from other more common
LSB spirals in that they often have a
significant bulge component (e.g., Gallagher & Bushouse 1983;
Knezek 1993, 1998), and
frequently their centers harbor an
active nucleus (e.g., Schombert 1998).
The origin and evolutionary histories of LSB Giant
galaxies are still enigmatic. Hoffman et al. (1992) have proposed a
formation scenario whereby these systems form in very low density
regions from rare, 3
density fluctuations. They predict
these galaxies should exhibit quiescent, unevolved, gas-rich disks, with
rotation curves that flatten near
.
Knezek (1993)
has suggested an alternative scenario, based on Kormendy (1989),
whereby LSB Giants may have dissipatively formed from massive, metal-poor dark matter halos.
Testing formation and evolution scenarios for LSB Giants requires an accurate knowledge of the neutral gas properties and linewidths of these galaxies. And only by combining such measures with optical data can we begin to build a picture of the star-formation histories of these systems and their relationship to other types of LSB galaxies.
Other motivations also exist for improved H I observations. Hoffman et al. (1992) have argued that for the enormous disks of LSB Giants to remain quiescent over a Hubble time, they must be very isolated. Yet studies hint that LSB Giants are in fact less isolated than other LSB spirals, although redshift surveys in the vicinities of these objects are still incomplete (Sprayberry et al. 1995b). Pointed H I observations in the vicinity of LSB Giants can thus reveal if these galaxies have any yet-undiscovered gas-rich neighbors.
Another important use of H I data is for exploring the Tully-Fisher (TF) relation for giant LSB spirals. Sprayberry et al. (1995a) have shown that at least two of the presently known LSB Giant galaxies are extreme outliers from the TF relation defined by normal galaxies. This is unlike the bulk of moderate-sized, moderate luminosity LSB galaxies, which tend to follow TF (Sprayberry et al. 1995a; Zwaan et al. 1995; Verheijen 1997). It is of considerable interest therefore to assess from a larger sample whether LSB Giants deviate systematically from the TF relation.
While previous
H I observations
have established that LSB Giants are in general very gas-rich
(
;
e.g., Sprayberry et al. 1995b; Walsh et al. 1997;
Pickering et al. 1997, 1999), unfortunately
existing H I data for many LSB Giants are of dubious quality (i.e.,
the galaxy was confused or resolved by the telescope beam,
the spectra are of low
signal-to-noise, or measurements from different workers are highly
discrepant; see also Table 5 and Sect. 4).
For example, based on Arecibo 21-cm observations of 3 objects,
Sprayberry et al. (1995b) suggested that peculiar,
asymmetric H I profiles may be commonplace for LSB
Giants. However, since the H I extents of these galaxies were
expected to be comparable to the size of the telescope beam, it is
important to verify that these ``peculiar'' spectra do not
result from some combination of source resolution and telescope
mispointing. In addition, independent checks on derived H I parameters are valuable since it is more difficult to accurately
measure integrated
fluxes and linewidths when the global H I profiles are quite
broad compared to the bandwidth used, and when sources are at large
recessional velocities (
15000 kms-1),
where flux calibration can become
increasingly uncertain. Finally, there are still a handful of known
LSB Giants for which no H I data have previously been obtained.
Quality single-dish H I spectra for LSB Giants are also
a useful precursor and complement to H I aperture synthesis studies
of these galaxies (e.g., Walsh et al. 1997; Pickering et al. 1997, 1999). H I mapping is of course a critical part of
understanding the dynamics and gas distributions for these galaxies,
but since many of the known examples of LSB Giants are
rather distant (
kms-1) and of relatively modest optical angular
size (D25<2'), such observations are challenging and
benefit from careful planning based on prior H I measurements.
Moreover, because LSB Giants are generally expected to have disks
with relatively low H I surface densities (e.g., Pickering et al. 1997),
diffuse emission can be missed in aperture synthesis measurements, and
total flux and maximum rotational velocity measures from H I pencil
beam observations serve as an important check.
Based on the above motivations, we have used the Nançay Radio Telescope to obtain new global observations of a sample of 16 LSB Giant galaxies for which existing global H I measurements were incomplete, required reconfirmation, or were nonexistent. We measure integrated H I line fluxes, linewidths, and recessional velocities, and attempt to clear up conundrums surrounding several of these objects in the literature.
© ESO 2001