A&A 393, 1065-1072 (2002)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20021190
E. Dotto1,2 - M. A. Barucci3 - T. G. Müller4,5 - J. R. Brucato6 - M. Fulchignoni2,7 - V. Mennella6 - L. Colangeli6
1 - INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Torino,
Strada Osservatorio 20, 10025 Pino Torinese (TO), Italy
2 -
INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Roma,
via Frascati 33, 00040 Monteporzio Catone (Roma), Italy
3 -
LESIA - Observatoire de Paris, 5 place J. Jannsen, 92195 Meudon
Principal Cedex, France
4 -
Max-Planck-Institut fuer extraterrestrische Physik,
Giessenbachstrasse, 85748 Garching, Germany
5 -
Data Centre, ESA, Villafranca Del Castillo,
Apdo 50727, 28080 Madrid, Spain (until Dec. 2001)
6 -
INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Capodimonte,
via Moiariello 16, 80131 Napoli, Italy
7 -
Université Paris VII, Paris, France
Received 19 April 2002 / Accepted 20 June 2002
Abstract
The ISO observations presented here are devoted to low and moderate
albedo asteroids, which are supposed to be among the more primitive
objects of the solar system.
Spectroscopic and multi-filter photometric data of 77 Frigga, 114 Kassandra,
308 Polyxo, 511 Davida, and 914 Palisana have been obtained by
the ISO instrument ISOPHOT.
The subsystem PHT-P carried out photometric observations
at 10, 12, 25, and 60 m, while
low resolution spectra have been acquired by the subsystem PHT-S
between 5.8 and 11.6
m.
The Standard Thermal Model and a black-body fit have
been applied to the obtained data in order to model
the thermal continuum and to derive sub-solar and black-body
temperatures.
To interpret the obtained results and to investigate the surface composition
of the observed asteroids, we compare the ISO spectra with the whole sample of
mineral and meteorite laboratory spectra
available in the literature. New laboratory experiments performed
at the Capodimonte Observatory have been carried out to increase the available
sample.
A tentative spectral similarity with meteorites
is presented.
Key words: minor planets, asteroids - infrared: solar system
Low albedo asteroids are classified in the current taxonomies (Tholen
& Barucci 1989) as belonging to three different classes: C, P, and D.
They are believed to be formed in the outer part of the main belt,
to have been less thermally processed and to have preserved
primordial materials on their surface.
High albedo asteroids are supposed to have
been formed at small heliocentric distances and to have been more
thermally evolved.
As shown by several authors, asteroids in the main belt display a systematic
variation of spectral classes with heliocentric distance (e.g. Gradie et al.
1989).
The decline in hydrated silicate abundance with increasing heliocentric
distance seems to be due to the fact that hydrated silicates are
more thermally processed than pristine materials.
Jones et al. (1990) proposed a scenario for the formation of low albedo
asteroids: accretion of ice and anhydrous silicates from the solar
nebula
combined with relic interstellar organic kerogen, formed very dark,
volatile-rich asteroids, of which P and D-types may be representative.
Selective induction heating produces aqueous alteration at the surface.
This is the low temperature chemical alteration of materials by liquid
water which acts as a solvent and produces materials like phyllosilicates,
oxides, sulfates, carbonates and hydroxides.
The same selective induction heating perhaps produced in other cases
melting in the interior.
Object | TDT | Detector | Observation | Obs. mid time | r | ![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
number | Date | (UT) | [AU] | [AU] | [deg] | [deg] | |||
(77) Frigga | on | 53500120 | PHT-P | 04-May-1997 | 02:30 | 2.7174 | 2.9556 | 19.9 | 66.6 |
on | 53500121 | PHT-S | 04-May-1997 | 02:45 | |||||
off | 53700122 | PHT-P | 06-May-1997 | 02:21 | |||||
off | 53700123 | PHT-S | 06-May-1997 | 02:37 | |||||
(114) Kassandra | on | 62500106 | PHT-P | 01-Aug.-1997 | 21:30 | 2.6388 | 2.3271 | 22.5 | 96.3 |
on | 62500107 | PHT-S | 01-Aug.-1997 | 21:45 | |||||
off | 62700108 | PHT-P | 03-Aug.-1997 | 21:23 | |||||
off | 62700109 | PHT-S | 03-Aug.-1997 | 21:38 | |||||
(308) Polyxo | on | 51600113 | PHT-P | 15-Apr.-1997 | 03:44 | 2.6455 | 2.6344 | 21.9 | 79.7 |
on | 51600114 | PHT-S | 15-Apr.-1997 | 03:59 | |||||
off | 51801215 | PHT-P | 17-Apr.-1997 | 13:27 | |||||
off | 51801216 | PHT-S | 17-Apr.-1997 | 13:42 | |||||
(511) Davida | on | 46502035 | PHT-P | 23-Feb.-1997 | 23:20 | 2.5953 | 2.5005 | 22.3 | 84.3 |
on | 46502036 | PHT-S | 23-Feb.-1997 | 23:35 | |||||
on | 46602237 | PHT-P | 24-Feb.-1997 | 23:13 | |||||
(914) Palisana | on | 71002224 | PHT-P | 26-Oct.-1997 | 05:48 | 2.7881 | 2.2624 | 19.3 | 111.7 |
on | 71002225 | PHT-S | 26-Oct.-1997 | 06:03 | |||||
off | 71102126 | PHT-P | 27-Oct.-1997 | 08:10 | 2.7898 | 2.2498 | 19.2 | 112.8 |
Spectroscopic investigation of low and moderate albedo asteroids is an essential tool to investigate their surface composition and the infrared range is certainly the most promising. The Infrared Space Observatory (ISO), an ESA project launched in November 1995 and operative until April 1998 (Kessler et al. 1996), gave the unique opportunity to observe asteroids in the unexplored range of the mid-infrared. Several ISO results on asteroids have been already presented and discussed (e.g. Dotto et al. 2000; Barucci et al. 2002; Müller & Lagerros 2002). Here we present the results obtained for a sample of five asteroids, selected among the brightest low and moderate albedo objects at the time of ISO observations.
The ISO observations presented here have been carried out between February and October 1997 with two different detectors of the instrument ISOPHOT: PHT-P and PHT-S.
In Table 1 the observational aspect data of the observed asteroids are listed. The background measurements (indicated in the Table as "off'') have been carried out at the same sky position, but 1 or 2 days later when the asteroid was outside the field of view. Davida and Palisana have no dedicated background measurements of the PHT-S observations. The second PHT-P Davida measurement was intended to be taken off-source, but by error done again on-source.
Multi-filter photometry
was carried by PHT-P with all 3 detector subsystems at wavelengths
of 10, 12, 25 and 60 m.
The apertures used were 23
diameter (10 and 12
m), 52
(25
m)
and 99
(60
m).
The integration times were: 64 s at 10
m and 32 s at 12
m (P1-detector); 32 s at 25
m (P2-detector);
32 s at 60
m (P3-detector).
ISOPHOT Interactive Analysis (PIA)
V9.0.1(e) was used for the standard data reduction up to
signal level, including linear ramp fitting, deglitching on ramp
and signal level and orbit dependent dark signal subtraction
(Gabriel et al. 1997). Unfortunatly the integration time
was in many cases not long enough to obtain stabilized signals.
In these cases (P1-detector, 10 and 12
m) the internal reference
measurements were replaced by the "default'' detector responsivity.
Additionally the used non-default apertures caused problems
in terms of absolute calibration of the background photometry
(in comparison with COBE-DIRBE values by Hauser et al. 1998).
For these reasons, all
background measurements were replaced by COBE-DIRBE values
(weekly maps, color corrected, PHT-P aperture size corrected).
All source measurements have been background subtracted and
color corrected. The following color correction values
have been used: 10 m: 0.99; 12
m: 0.91;
25 and 60
m: 1.07. These values correspond to temperatures
between 200 and 300 K.
The analysis of similar measurements on calibration targets
in the same apertures revealed that the internal calibration source
of ISOPHOT (the Fine Calibration Source, FCS)
leads in some cases to a flux overestimation up to 20% (P2-detector,
25 m)
and a flux underestimation up to 20% (P3-detector, 60
m). This is
reflected in the asymmetric uncertainties in the values.
In case of strong signal transients the error values have been
increased accordingly.
PHT-S, which consists of two low-resolution grating spectrometers,
covered the wavelength ranges 2.5-4.9 m (PHT-SS) and 5.8-11.6
m (PHT-SL).
The obtained spectra have a resolution
of
about 85 for PHT-SS
and of about 95 for PHT-SL.
All PHT-S observations have been performed in staring mode with a
default of 32 s dark exposure at the beginning of the
measurement.
The integration time was of 1024 s for 77 Frigga, 114 Kassandra, 308 Polyxo,
914 Palisana, and 512 s for 511 Davida.
PIA V8.2(e)
was used for the standard data reduction up to signal level, including
linear ramp fitting, deglitching on ramp and signal level and
orbit dependent dark signal subtraction (Gabriel et al. 1997).
The flux calibration is done with the dynamic response method
(Laureijs et al. 2002) by taking the ratio between the signals from the target
and the calibrators along the observing time and then deriving the mean
and median values, which are scaled by the known flux from
the chosen calibrators. The dark current subtraction was performed
before the dynamic calibration application.
![]() |
Figure 1: PHT-S background measurements at the positions of the asteroids Frigga, Kassandra and Polyxo. The fitted blackbody curve (solid line) and the corresponding COBE-DIRBE value (box) are also shown. |
Open with DEXTER |
The on-source measurements have been background subtracted in the following way: 1) cross check of the absolute background level with COBE-DIRBE data (weekly maps, color corrected, PHT-S beam size corrected) for the 3 dedicated background spectra (see Fig. 1); 2) fit of a blackbody curve to the observed background spectra (blackbody temperatures taken from Ábrahám et al. 1999); 3) for Davida and Palisana the blackbody fit was done directly to the COBE-DIRBE values since no dedicated background measurements exist; 4) subtraction of the blackbody fits from the on-source measurements. This procedure avoids the noise introduction from the background subtraction. Figure 1 shows the PHT-S background spectra of Frigga, Kassandra, and Polyxo together with the fitted blackbody curve and the corresponding COBE-DIRBE values.
The uncertainties from the signal processing
by PIA are 3-5%, which reflect also the relative accuracy from
pixel to pixel. The absolute uncertainty is generally stated
better than 30% (Klaas et al. 1997). Since we used an interactive
analysis with improved calibration we believe that the absolute
calibration is better than 15% for Frigga, Kassandra and Palisana
and better then 10% for Polyxo and Davida. This is also in agreement
with
our cross-calibration experiences between different ISO instruments
and with stellar models.
The PHT-SS 2.5-4.9 m part of the asteroid spectra is at a very
low signal
level, close to the detection limit. Therefore
we exclude in this paper this part of the spectrum.
In Fig. 2 the low-resolution PHT-S spectra between 5.8 and 11.6 m
together with the
PHT-P data are shown with the uncertainties produced by the signal processing
procedure.
![]() |
Figure 2:
PHT-S spectra between 5.8 and 11.6 ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The emission of asteroids beyond 5
m is
dominated by radiation thermally emitted from their
surface.
A blackbody fit and the Standard Thermal Model (STM)
have been applied to the obtained infrared data to determine the
range of surface (blackbody and sub-solar) temperatures.
To determine the black-body temperature of the observed asteroids we fitted the infrared data with a Planck function multiplied by the solid angle of the objects. Both the solid angle and the black-body temperature were treated as free parameters.
The sub-solar temperature of the observed objects was computed
by applying the STM
(Lebofsky & Spencer 1989), already
used by Tedesco et al. (1992) in the IRAS asteroid
survey.
It assumes a non-rotating spherical asteroid, in
instantaneous equilibrium with solar insolation, observed at 0solar phase angle.
In this ideal situation, in which the thermal inertia is neglected,
and the asteroid nightside emission is thus not taken into
account, the sub-solar temperature is given as:
![]() |
(1) |
In Table 2 the sub-solar and
black-body temperatures, and
the albedo and diameter values
estimated by applying STM to our data
are reported.
The table shows also the absolute magnitude H and the slope parameter G
used as input, and diameters and albedos obtained
by Tedesco et al. (1992) on the basis of
IRAS data.
Our estimations of diameters and albedos are in agreement with the
values given by Tedesco et al. (1992), with the exception
of the albedos of
511 Davida and 914 Palisana which deviate from the IRAS results.
This can be due to differences in the viewing geometry
between the IRAS and ISO observations.
In the simplified STM the real shape of the asteroid is not taken into
account:
this can influence the albedo and diameter calculations.
To model the thermal continuum of previous ISO observations, Dotto et al. (2000) and Barucci et al. (2002) used the advanced thermophysical model
(TPM) developed by Lagerros (1996, 1997, 1998). To properly apply this
advanced model we need the knowledge of several physical parameters of
the analysed asteroids. Unfortunately, we do not have a good estimation of
the pole direction, shape, infrared beaming
and thermal inertia of the five asteroids
here discussed.
A comparison between the diameter and albedo values obtained by STM and
TPM has been possible only for 77 Frigga, for which an estimation of
the rotational state is available (Erikson 2000).
We applied TPM, considering the wavelength dependent
emissivity as stated by Müller & Lagerros (1998), and default values for
thermal inertia
and beaming parameters
and f,
and we obtained results similar to those computed by STM.
Since the
rotational and physical parameters of the asteroids here discussed
are not sufficiently well
known, we preferred to apply the simplest STM, with the
minimum number of free parameters, without introducing new possible
sources of error.
Using STM we computed the expected flux at the time of ISO observations.
Then we divided the observed spectra for the STM expected flux,
obtaining the "Relative Obs/Mod''.
Object | H | G | Diameter | Albedo | Black-body | Sub-solar | IRAS | IRAS | IRAS | IRAS |
temp. | temp. | D | ![]() |
pH |
![]() |
|||||
(mag) | (km) | (K) | (K) | (km) | (km) | |||||
77 Frigga | 8.52 | 0.16 | ![]() |
![]() |
223 | 259 | 69.25 | 2.1 | 0.144 | 0.009 |
114 Kassandra | 8.26 | 0.15 | ![]() |
![]() |
228 | 265 | 99.64 | 1.9 | 0.0884 | 0.003 |
308 Polyxo | 8.17 | 0.21 | ![]() |
![]() |
232 | 265 | 140.69 | 3.8 | 0.0482 | 0.003 |
511 Davida | 6.22 | 0.16 | ![]() |
![]() |
232 | 268 | 326.07 | 5.3 | 0.054 | 0.0023 |
914 Palisana | 8.76 | 0.15 | ![]() |
![]() |
220 | 257 | 76.61 | 1.7 | 0.0943 | 0.004 |
In order to interpret the obtained spectral behaviours we compared the observational results with the whole sample of mineral and meteorite emissivities available in the literature (Salisbury et al. 1991a,b, ASTER spectral library on http://speclib.jpl.nasa.gov). Moreover, new laboratory spectra of a few selected samples at different grain dimensions, have been obtained with the Capodimonte Observatory Bruker IFS66v interferometer, following the procedures already described in Dotto et al. (2000) and Barucci et al. (2002). Since asteroid spectra seem to be dominated by the effect of fine particles (Le Bertre & Zellner 1980), all the laboratory samples we considered are particulate.
In Figs. 3-7 we plot the "Relative Obs/Mod''
obtained for each observed asteroid,
compared with the emissivities of some mineral and/or meteorite analogs.
In the considered wavelength range the most diagnostic feature is the
Christiansen peak which is associated with the principal
molecular vibration
band, where the refractive index changes rapidly,
and occurs at a wavelength that for silicates is just short of the Si-O stretching vibration bands.
This feature, directly related to the mineralogy and the grain size,
appears generally as a peak between 7.5 and 9.5 m.
77 Frigga.
The taxonomic classification of this object is still an open problem.
It has been classified as MU-type (Tholen 1989),
D2-type (Barucci et al. 1987), and Xe (Bus & Binzel 2002).
![]() |
Figure 3: Relative PHT-S Obs/Mod of 77 Frigga compared with the winonaite meteorite Winona (continuous line). The spectrum of Winona is vertically offset for clarity. |
Open with DEXTER |
On the basis of our ISO data we obtained a diameter of km and an albedo of
,
in close agreement
with the previous IRAS determinations. These values have been computed
using STM on PHT-S and PHT-P data,
eliminating the observation at 25
m which gives an overestimation of
about 40% in the diameter.
Figure 3 shows the emissivity obtained by dividing the PHT-S data by the STM expected flux. The comparison of this spectrum with the whole sample of available meteorite and mineral emissivities was unsuccessfull. The only possible analogy, even if very weak, seems to be with the emissivity of the Winona meteorite sample belonging to the ASTER database. Winona belongs to the winonaite meteorites, a group of primitive achondrites associated with the IAB/IIICD iron meteorites. Its structure is characterized by silicate inclusions in IAB irons. Although this is just a tentative interpretation of the obtained ISO mid-infrared spectrum of Frigga, the silicated iron nature of the meteorite Winona seems to be in agreement with the debated classification of this asteroid.
114 Kassandra and 308 Polyxo. Asteroids 114 Kassandra and 308 Polyxo have been classified as belonging to the T class by Tholen (1989), as a D2-type object by Barucci et al. (1987), and as Xk and T, respectively, by Bus & Binzel (2002). On the basis of ISO PHT-P and PHT-S data we obtained diameter and albedo values which are in agreement (to within 10%) with the previous determinations obtained on the basis of the IRAS data.
Britt et al. (1992) showed that 114 Kassandra has a 0.4-2.5 m spectrum
very similar to troilite, while 308 Polyxo shows in the same wavelength
range a completely different
spectral behavior.
In the mid-infrared range, on the contrary, these two objects show a
spectral behavior similar to that
one of Ornans, a CO3 carbonaceous chondrite meteorite.
Figures 4 and 5 show the comparison between the emissivity of Kassandra and
Polyxo and the laboratory emissivity of an Ornans sample
at grain sizes between 0 and 20
m.
The behaviour of the spectrum around 9.2
m seems to be consistent with
the Christiansen peak of the Ornans sample.
This result is surprising since
Ornans is a type 3 carbonaceous meteorite
chondrite (CO3) which seems to show the presence of aqueous alteration
processes (Zolensky & McSween 1988).
308 Polyxo has been shown to have a
strong feature of water of hydration feature at 3.0
m
while in the spectrum of 114 Kassandra this feature is completely absent
(Jones et al. 1990).
These differences in the interpretation of the surface
composition can be due to possible
variations with different rotational phases.
Further observations at
near-infrared wavelength of these two asteroids are needed in order to
investigate the possibility that these objects have really undergone some
aqueous alteration processes.
511 Davida.
Asteroid 511 Davida is the fifth
biggest asteroid with an IRAS diameter of 326 km.
For this object PHT-P obtained multi-filter photometric data only at 10,
25, and 60 m.
On the basis of our complete ISO data sample
we computed a diameter of 303 km and an
albedo of 0.064.
![]() |
Figure 4: Relative PHT-S Obs/Mod of 114 Kassandra compared with the CO3 carbonaceous chondrite meteorite Ornans (continuous line). The spectrum of Ornans is vertically offset for clarity. |
Open with DEXTER |
![]() |
Figure 5: Relative PHT-S Obs/Mod of 308 Polyxo compared with the CO3 carbonaceous chondrite meteorite Ornans (continuous line). The spectrum of Ornans is vertically offset for clarity. |
Open with DEXTER |
Davida as been classified by Tholen (1989), Barucci et al.
(1987) and Bus & Binzel (2002) as belonging to the C class.
Jones et al. (1990) detected hydrated silicates (via 3-m
spectrometry) on the surface of this asteroids, while Hiroi et al.
(1996) found a good match between the 0.3-3.6
m
spectrum of Davida and that one of
the unusual CI/CM meteorite B-7904.
On the basis of the analysis of heated Murchison samples they inferred
that B-7904 has probably been heated up to 500-600
C.
Figure 6 shows the emissivity of Davida between 5.8 and 11.6 m which is
consistent with that one of carbonaceous chondrites as reported by
Salisbury et al. (1991a). In particular the spectral behaviour between 6.5 and 11.5
m suggests the comparison with the emissivity of
the CM-type carbonaceous chondrite meteorite
Murchison given by the ASTER database.
This result seems to confirm that Davida is a large body which suffered
aqueous alteration processes.
914 Palisana.
Asteroid 914 Palisana is classified as CU-type by Tholen (1989) and as a
D3-type by Barucci et al. (1987).
On the basis of our ISO data we computed a diameter of 71 km and an albedo
of 0.113.
Also in this case the PHT-P measurement at 25 m
gives an overestimation of diameter and albedo of more than 30%.
![]() |
Figure 6: Relative PHT-S Obs/Mod of 511 Davida compared with the CM-type carbonaceous chondrite meteorite Murchison (continuous line). The spectrum of Murchison is vertically offset for clarity. |
Open with DEXTER |
Fitzsimmons et al. (1994) showed that Palisana exhibits in the visible range large-scale absorption characteristic of phyllosilicates.
The spectral behavior, shown in Fig. 7, is after 7 m
flat and featureless. We tried
to compare this object with many mineral and meteorite emissivities.
In particular we compared the obtained spectrum with the emissivity
of phyllosilicates and CI/CM carbonaceous chondrite
meteorites which are related to aqueous
alteration products.
None of the available laboratory spectra of minerals and meteorites
matched the observed spectrum.
As an example we report in Fig. 7 the emissivities of a sample of the
CI-type meteorite
Orgueil at grain sizes between 0 and 50
m and a sample
of powdered kaolinite (phyllosilicate), obtained by laboratory
experiments at the Capodimonte Observatory.
![]() |
Figure 7: Relative PHT-S Obs/Mod of 914 Palisana compared with the CI-type carbonaceous chondrite meteorite Orgueil (dashed line) and a phyllosilicate kaolinite (continuous line). The spectra of Orgueil and kaolinite are vertically offset for clarity. |
Open with DEXTER |
The interpretation of the obtained spectra is neither easy nor unique. A tentative interpretation has been suggested by comparing the observed spectral behaviours with the emissivities of meteorites which are our best available analogs of asteroidal surface materials. The theories about the thermal history of C-type asteroids seems to be confirmed by the match between the spectrum of 511 Davida and the emissivity of the CM-type carbonaceous chondrite meteorite Murchison. While the tentative analogy between the spectrum of Frigga and the emissivity of Winona is consistent with the still debated taxonomic classification of this asteroid.
Problems relative to the calibration of these faint objects due to
non-standard instrument configurations have
affected the quality of the ISO data, especially the point at 25 m.
For this reason and due to the difficulty in interpreting the surface spectra,
the obtained results and the suggested interpretations
cannot be conclusive. This work can be considered a support for future
observations of asteroids in these wavelengths
by space platform projects,
planned to be operative in
next future (e.g. the Space Infrared Telescope Facility SIRTF).
Acknowledgements
J.R.B., V.M., and L.C. whish to thank ASI and MIUR for supporting the experimental work.