A&A 475, 843-849 (2007)
N. Mauron1 - K. S. Gigoyan2 - T. R. Kendall3
1 - GRAAL, CNRS and Université Montpellier II, Place Bataillon, 34095 Montpellier, France
2 - 378433 Byurakan Astrophysical Observatory and Isaac Newton Institute of Chile, Armenian Branch, Ashtarak d-ct, Armenia
3 - Centre for Astrophysics Research, Science and Technology Research Institute, University of Hertfordshire, College Lane, Hatfield AL10 9AB, UK
Received 28 June 2007 / Accepted 23 August 2007
Aims. The goal of this paper is to present and analyse a new sample of cool carbon (C) stars located in the Galactic halo.
Methods. These rare objects are discovered by searching the 2MASS point-source catalogue for candidates having near-infrared colours typical of C stars. Optical spectroscopy is subsequently performed.
Results. Twenty-three new C stars were discovered, with their magnitude in the range 6 to 13.3. Spectra are typical of N-type carbon stars with C2 and CN bands and sometimes H in emission. One object is a S-type star. When the objects are bright enough ( ), the data of the Northern Sky Variability Survey can be exploited. In all cases, stars belonging to this survey show light variations confirming that they are AGB stars. Distances and galactocentric XYZ coordinates have been estimated by assuming these stars to be similar in luminosity to those of the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy. Four objects are particularly red with J- , with two located at more than 5 kpc from the Galactic plane. Eight additional objects with similar properties are found in the literature and our previous works. These 12 C stars could be useful to study mass loss at low metallicity. Two other objects are remarkably far from the Sun, at distances of 95 and 110 kpc. They are located, together with two other C stars previously found, in the region Z < -60 kpc in which the model of Law et al. (2005) predicts the Sgr Stream to have a loop.
Key words: stars: carbon - Galaxy: halo - Galaxy: stellar content
Cool carbon (C) stars are objects evolving on the asymptotic giant branch (AGB). This is a brief phase of stellar evolution characterized by high luminosity, low effective temperature, and the appearance at the surface of the star of nuclear products fabricated in its internal layers (for reviews on AGB and C stars, see Habing 1996; Wallerstein & Knapp 1998). The progenitors of these C stars have intermediate masses, from about 1.3 in most cases, up to about 4 . C stars are variable sources. They can be recognized by their very red colours and the strong spectral features arising from carbon-rich molecules. Because evolution on the AGB is fast, they are not very abundant in the Galactic disc. However, because of their luminosity, they have been detected and studied in many galaxies of the Local Group and beyond. They are more numerous in systems with an average low metallicity, and generally indicate the presence of an intermediate age population (see for example Wallerstein & Knapp 1998; Van den Bergh 2000; Mouhcine & Lançon 2001; Groenewegen 2005).
In the Galactic disc and close to the Sun, i.e. at distances less than 5 kpc, AGB C stars have a scale height of 200 pc (Claussen et al. 1987; Groenewegen et al. 1992; Bergeat et al. 2002). Therefore, very few of them are expected at more than about 1 kpc above or below the Galactic plane. In the old halo population, all stars with masses similar to those of C stars have evolved beyond the luminous AGB phase. However, it has long been known that some faint and cool carbon stars do exist at large distances and at high galactic latitude. Totten and Irwin (1998, hereafter TI98) listed 41 previously known objects, this number including some warmer CH-type objects. They discovered 36 additional cases, with 29 N-type and 7 CH-type (for more information about classification of C stars, see Wallerstein & Knapp 1998). One of their goals was to show that these halo C stars might arise from the disruption of dwarf galaxies captured by the Galaxy. This was eventually proved by Ibata et al. (2001) who found that more than half of these C stars are coherently clustered on a great circle on the sky, and trace the debris stream of the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy.
The goal of this paper is to present new discoveries of halo cool C stars and to study their properties. In our previous works (Mauron et al. 2004, 2005), we followed the approach of TI98 to search for these rare halo cool C stars. However, rather than using visible photometry from photographic plates to select candidates, we have exploited the recent 2MASS near-infrared survey and its point-source catalogue (Cutri et al. 2003). This survey provides us with accurate photometry, enabling the potential discovery of C stars via their near-infrared colours. Follow-up spectroscopy is then performed to determine whether these candidates are carbon-rich, and show the expected signatures of evolved AGB objects.
A first result of our research was that 50 new cool halo C stars were discovered. This suggested that, firstly, the observational strategy was correct (for details on the candidate selection process, see Mauron et al. 2005). Secondly, it was found that a majority of these objects belong to the Sagittarius (Sgr) stream, but not all of them do, in agreement with previous findings. Finally, we found several remarkably faint ( ) objects; interesting probes of the halo at distances from the Sun as large as 60-120 kpc.
In this paper, we report on our continuing program to enlarge the sample of these halo C stars. We wish eventually to establish a complete -band limited inventory. Two new very distant sources were discovered with . Observations and data reduction are described in Sect. 2. In Sect. 3 we analyse our new sample of 25 halo C stars, and we discuss global properties of the sample and individual cases, including consideration of colours, spectra and variability. Very red sources are discussed in Sect. 4. In Sect. 5, we estimate the distances of the sources and discuss their location in the Galactic halo. A summary of this work and our conclusions are finally given in Sect. 6.
At Haute-Provence, the observations were made during the nights September 5 to 9, 2005 and September 27 to October 2, 2006. The instrument was the CARELEC spectrograph mounted at the Cassegrain focus of the 1.93-m telescope. The spectrograph was used with a 150 g mm-1 grating and an EEV 20481024 CCD chip with 13.513.5 m pixels. The dispersion is 3.6 Å per pixel. The slit width was 2.0 arcsec. The resolving power is = 460, and = 13 Å at 6000 Å , with a spectral coverage of 4400 to 8400 Å.
Typical exposure times were from about 1 minute for the brightest candidate carbon stars () to about 1 h for the faintest ones (). The low spectral resolution was chosen to allow spectroscopy of these faint stars in a reasonable time, and the spectra have sufficient signal to noise ratio (20) to perfectly recognize the strong molecular features of carbon-rich objects. Most of the contaminants in our list of C candidates are cool M giants or M dwarfs. Faint sources required clear conditions with good seeing. When these conditions were not fulfilled, only bright sources were observed.
Standard data reduction for slit spectroscopy was carried out with the ESO Midas software. It included bias subtraction, flat-fielding, extraction of one-dimensional spectra for the object and for the sky, subtraction of the sky spectrum, cleaning of cosmic rays, and wavelength calibration. Then, a correction was applied to take into account the instrumental spectral efficiency, and this was done with the spectrum of a standard photometric star observed with the same instrumental set-up. The spectra are thus proportional to a flux expressed in erg s-1 cm-2 Å-1 and can be compared to those shown by TI98. However, no absolute calibration could be achieved because the sky was most of the time not photometric, and because strong slit losses occured when the seeing was bad. Therefore, only relative spectral distributions can finally be considered and are drawn in our plots.
|Notes: (1) carbon star identified by TI98. It was reobserved because of its peculiar blue index B-R = -0.6 in USNOC-A2.0; (2) carbon star identified by Cruz et al. (2003). A first spectrum is shown in this work; (3) this object is a S-type evolved object.|
|Figure 1: Colour-magnitude diagram with plotted versus J - for known cool halo C stars. Filled circles are objects of this work. Encircled crosses are the objects listed in TI98. Empty circles are objects found in other previous studies, with most of them being from Mauron et al. (2004, 2005). The vertical dotted line at = 1.2 approximatively separate the CH-type stars to the left and the cool N-type stars to the right.|
Table 1 lists the main parameters of the 25 objects that are under analysis in this work. In the first column, the object serial number is given, following the numbering of Table 1 of Mauron et al. (2005). Coordinates and (J2000) are given in the object 2MASS J names as HHMMSS.ssDDMMSS.s. The quantities l, b are galactic coordinates in degrees. The B & R magnitudes are from the USNO-A2.0 catalogue (Monet et al. 1998) as given in the 2MASS catalogue. If these data are not available, we have adopted the B and R values given in the APM database (Irwin 2000), or we have estimated them from the USNO-B1.0 data (Monet et al. 2003). Uncertainties on B and R of the order of 0.4 mag (1). The magnitudes and the J- colour are from the 2MASS catalogue, with uncertainties on of about 0.02-0.03 mag in most cases.
One can see in Table 1 that the R magnitudes are in the range 11 up to 17. Nine sources are brighter than R=13.0 and three are fainter than 16.0. The B - R colour is often greater than 3.0 . More precisely, of the 25 objects, 20 have their B - R greater than 3.0. Here, it is interesting to note that if B - R had been requested to be larger than 3.0 in our selection process, we would have missed the two most interesting objects (#59 and #81), with the faintest magnitude and the largest distances (see below).
The listed magnitudes cover the range 6 to 13. All objects have > 1.30. Figure 1 shows the colour-magnitude diagram of our sample. The objects of Table 1 are plotted with filled circles. The encircled crosses show the 77 objects listed in TI98, and the empty circles indicate objects found in previous works aimed at discovering new faint and cool halo C stars (e.g., Mauron et al. 2004, 2005; Liebert et al. 2000). The vertical line at J - = 1.20 is the approximate limit between CH-type stars at left and cool AGB C stars at right. Only cool N-type objects were searched in the present study. In this diagram, a cool C star located at a distance of 50 kpc like the Large Magellanic Cloud (hereafter LMC) has a typical magnitude . One can note in Fig. 1 that the number of objects in the upper right region , has progressively increased, with in particular two objects, #59 and #83, which have and respectively.
|Figure 2: Spectrum of object #59, the faintest source in the band ( = 13.28, R = 16.7). The spectrum is typical of cool N-type stars, with a flux increasing with wavelength, and with characteristic molecular features, i.e. C2 bands at Å and the flux break at 7800 Å due to CN.|
There are two objects that were already known as carbon stars. One is #63, that was already in TI98 under the name C*30 or APM 0207-0211. It was reexamined by us because of its intriguing colour B - R = -0.6 in the USNO-A2.0 catalog. Usually, this colour for cool C stars covers the range from 2.5 to 4, or even redder. We wished to detect a possible blue excess near 4500 Å , but found none. Our spectrum is very similar to that of TI98, the only difference being the presence of a small H emission at 6563 Å . Because the APM catalogue gives R=12.16 and BJ - R = 4.08 (adopted in Table 1), our conclusion is that the USNO-A2.0 data is probably simply flawed.
The other object which was known as a C star is #69. This object was found by Cruz et al. (2003) during their search for brown dwarfs. It was observed by us to obtain a first spectrum and because it was faint, = 11.2, implying a large distance.
All obtained spectra are presented in the on-line Appendix. In Fig. 2, we show only the spectrum of the most distant star (#59). This spectrum has the lowest S/N in our sample, but the characteristics of a cool C star, such as a rising continuum and the C2 and CN bands, are obvious. One object, #80, is a S-type star, with strong VO absorption near 7400 Å . Its H (6563 Å ) line is in emission and this star displays important light variations (see below). Of the 25 C stars observed, 10 show the H line in emission, representing 40% of the sample, which is in agreement with previous findings of Mauron et al. (2004, 2005).
In order to study variability of our objects, we have considered the Northern Sky Variability Survey (NSVS) of Wozniak et al. (2004). This survey provides light curves for sources with V-band magnitudes of 8 to 15.5. The length of each record is typically 300 days. Some data points are obvious outliers and should be ignored. Only the general trend of the light curves must be considered. Not all the objects in our sample have a counterpart in the NSVS, especially the faintest ones. In all cases in which data is available and sufficiently numerous, they suggest regular or irregular variations with V-band amplitudes of about 1 mag. up to several magnitudes. For illustration, Fig. 3 shows the light curves of objects #60 and #78. Light curves for objects # 66, 71, 73, 75, 76, 78, 79, 80, 82, and 83 are given in the on-line appendix. Note that the S star (# 80) displays the largest variation and linearly decreases from V=12.5 to V=15.0 over a period of 200 days.
|Figure 3: Light curves for objects #60 and #78, from NSVS data. Only the general trend should be considered and a few outliers have to be ignored.|
One of the result of this paper is the discovery of four very red C stars seen in Fig. 1 as filled circles with J - between 3 and 4. By searching the literature about high latitude, cool and faint C stars, we have found 8 other objects out of the Galactic plane having a similarly red J - colour, 5.5, and |b| > 20. In our research for these stars, we also require the IRAS 12 m flux to be less than 7 Jy in order to exclude nearby, very dusty objects like IRC+10216 or AFGL 3068. The data for this sample of 12 cases are listed in Table 2. Object #82 has no 12 m flux because IRAS scans do not pass over a narrow lane in which this source lies. For 2MASS J194850.65-305831.7, the 12 m data is a conservative upper limit derived from the examination of the IRAS Faint Source catalogue sources close to it. Distances to the Sun and from the Galactic plane were derived as explained below. One can see that the stars #79 and #82 are moderatly out of the plane by 1.3 kpc, but all others are clearly at very large heights, and this remains true even if our distances are overestimated by 40% (-2, see next section).
The best studied case is IRAS 12560+1656, discovered by Beichman et al. (1990) in a sample of faint IRAS sources located at high b and having faint counterparts in the POSS plates. This object has been further investigated by Groenewegen et al. (1997) who found a remarkably low expansion velocity of its circumstellar envelope, measured in CO (3 km s-1). They also found that this object is deficient in oxygen relative to the Sun, by 0.7 dex. IRAS 08546+1732, not detected in CO, is deficient as well. Therefore, our 12 objects deserve interest because it is established that already two of them are metal-poor, with one having very unusual wind properties. Because these 12 objects do not belong to the Galactic disc, they may come from the debris of the Sgr dwarf and have a metal abundance [Fe/H] around -1.0 (Van den Bergh 2000).
Are their infrared colours different from those of C stars having a much higher 12 m flux? In order to test that, we considered the sample of 330 bright infrared C stars of Groenewegen et al. (2002). Most of these stars are close to the Galactic plane and might suffer some interstellar extinction in J and . So we selected a subsample of their stars with |b| > 10. Their f12 fluxes are between 13 and 250 Jy. Figure 4 shows the colour-colour plot with versus . The  magnitude is taken to be zero for Vega, thus  = -2.5 log10(f12/41.6), with f12 in Jy. This plot shows that the objects in Table 2 are located on the sequence of ordinary disc C stars going from warm cases at lower left to very cool dusty objects at upper right. The 12 objects of Table 2 do not seem different from brighter objects as far as the J- and - colours are concerned.
To conclude, in addition to IRAS 12560+1656 and IRAS 08546+1732 quoted above, the 10 other stars of Table 2 may be useful to study mass loss of low metallicity AGB C stars. They are generally much closer to the Sun than similar carbon stars in the Magellanic Clouds.
|IRAS name||2MASS name||l||b||f12||d||Z||Note|
|not IRAS||2MASS J194850.65-305831.7||9.433||-25.076||<0.3||10.21||3.39||25||-10.0||6|
|not IRAS||2MASS J215526.97+234214.4||78.911||-23.760||-||5.50||3.40||3||-1.3||#82|
|Notes: (1) discovered by Liebert et al. (2000); (2) discovered by TI98 as APM 0418+0122; (3) this star is CGCS 6306 in the Catalogue of Galactic carbon stars, Alksnis et al. (2001); (4) discovered by Cutri et al. (1989); (5) discovered by Beichman et al. (1990); (6) discovered by Mauron et al. (2004).|
|Figure 4: Colour colour diagram versus . Crosses represent a subsample of bright carbon stars of Groenewegen et al. (1992). Circles indicate the objects of Table 2, which appear to follow the trend of the bright carbon stars|
The distances of our objects were estimated by using their observed J- colour and magnitude. The band is used because it is less sensitive to temporal variations than other filters and suffers less interstellar extinction. Absolute magnitudes were determined as in Mauron et al. (2004, 2005). Briefly, values are obtained by considering the magnitudes of LMC carbon stars averaged over colour bins of 0.1 mag and adding 0.5 mag. The colour-magnitude diagram versus of the LMC can be seen in Fig. 3 of Nikolaev and Weinberg (2000). The supplementary 0.5-mag term is due to the average difference between C stars in the LMC and C stars in the Sgr dwarf galaxy (see Mauron et al. 2004, for details). This calibration on the C stars of Sgr is adopted because a majority of halo C stars originate from this dwarf galaxy. If they were calibrated on LMC C stars, our objects would have distances and Z values 25% larger. The scatter on the adopted absolute magnitude is around 0.3-0.4 (1). Concerning the S star (# 80), it was assumed that its was similar to that of C stars.
For each star, interstellar colour excesses EB-V were taken from the maps of Schlegel et al. (1998) and a colour excess of 0.13 was adopted for LMC stars. The J and extinctions were calculated as AJ=0.902 EB-V and EB-V. In general, these corrections for interstellar reddening are low, but for a few stars EB-V is of the order of 0.5-0.6 mag, so that reaches 0.2 mag and cannot be neglected. Table 3 shows the adopted values of EB-V, the dereddened colour ( , the absolute magnitude and the derived distance d in kpc. Due to the scatter on , the uncertainty on distances is about 20 percent (1).
It can be seen in Table 3 that distances are from 5 kpc to 110 kpc. Two stars have d < 5 kpc, 15 have d between 5 and 20 kpc and 8 have d between 20 and 110 kpc. Some of these distances could be improved in the future if the stars are shown to be periodic variables. For example, if we assume that stars #60 and #78 (with light curves in Fig. 3) are periodic, we can apply the K-band period-luminosity relation for semiregular variables established by Knapp et al. (2003). The NSVS light curves suggest that their periods could be 240 and 320 days, respectively. Then, with the P-MK relation MK = -1.34 log P -4.5, and assuming that the (average) K magnitude is not too different from , we find for #60, MK = -7.69, d = 7.6 kpc, a distance close to the one in Table 3 (5.9 kpc). As for #78, we obtain MK = -7.86, d = 14.7 kpc, and this distance is 40% larger than that found in Table 2 (10.5 kpc).
|Figure 5: Plots in galactocentric XYZ of the observed halo C stars, with those found in this paper indicated by circle with a overplotted cross. Left panel: in this Z versus Y the Sgr Stream is seen nearly edge-on, slightly tilted clockwise with respect to the Z axis. Note that Y is positive to the left. The two new very distant C stars found in this paper(# 59 and #81) are on the lower left. Their distances to the main plane of the Sgr Stream are about 25 kpc. Right panel: Z versus X plot. X is positive to the left and = - 8.5 kpc. The positions of the C stars at Z < -50 kpc suggest that the Sgr debris have a broad extent, 100 kpc, along the X-coordinates.|
Galactocentric XYZ coordinates were calculated in the system of
Newberg et al. (2003), in which the Sun is at X = -8.5 kpc,
Y = 0, Z = 0; the Y-axis is positive towards
l = +90
and the Z axis is positive to b = +90
Figure 5 displays the YZ and XZ plots of previously known C stars and
those of Table 1. In this system, the Sgr Stream as traced with the M-type giants
(Majewski et al. 2003) is approximatively given by the following equation
(Newberg et al. 2003):
There are two new stars that are especially distant, #59 at 110 kpc and #81 at 95 kpc. Figure 5 shows that four carbon stars are now known in the region Z < -60 kpc and none are known in the symetrical region Z > +60 kpc, although a large number have been discovered closer to us and with kpc. This asymmetry qualitatively supports the existence of an extended branch of the Sgr Stream as in the model of Law et al. (2005, see Fig. 4 of Mauron et al. 2005). The width of this branch along the X direction is 90 kpc, which is in fair agreement with the positions of our four C stars.
We note however that, recently, the Sgr Stream has been mapped by analysing the data of Sloan survey (Belokurov et al. 2006; Fellhauer et al. 2006). The map puts strong constraints on the Stream geometry and is well explained within a model where there is no matter at Z < -60 kpc. It is then possible that our four C stars with high negative Z are part of another stream. It will be interesting in the future to see if any new distant star can be detected close to them. In both cases, the fact that cool carbon stars are found indicate that an intermediate-age population is present in this region of the halo.
By searching the 2MASS catalogue for rare cool carbon stars located out of the Galactic plane (|b| > 20), we have found 23 new cases with magnitudes covering the range 6 to 13.3. Their colours and spectra are typical of AGB stars, which is also supported by important variability for those objects bright enough to be detected by the NSVS survey.
We have discovered four cases of C stars with J - > 3 and located well above the Galactic plane. After including those already published in the literature, we could made a list of 12 objects with similar properties. Previous works (Groenewegen et al. 1997) show that two of them are deficient in oxygen and one has a very small wind expansion velocity. This suggests that some (or all) members of this sample could be metal deficient as well. Because they are closer to us than the Magellanic Clouds, supplementary observations of these stars, especially their CO emission, could help to better know AGB winds at low metallicity.
Distances were estimated by using the 2MASS J and data and by assuming our objects to be similar to those of the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy. It is found that two objects are at remarkably large distances from the Sun (100 kpc). Their galactocentric XYZ coordinates suggest that they might belong, together with two other distant carbon stars previously found, to a distant loop of the Sgr stream extending at large negative Z. Additional detections of distant stars in this region of the halo should help to confirm this conclusion.
We would like to thank our referee, E. Lagadec, for useful comments. We thank also the staff of Observatoire de Haute-Provence, which is supported by the French Centre National de Recherche Scientifique. We acknowledge the use of the Two Micron All Sky Survey (2MASS), which is a joint project of the University of Massachusetts and the Infrared Processing and Analysis Centre/California Institute of Technology, funded by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) and the National Science Foundation (NSF). This publication also makes use of the data from the Northern Sky Variability Survey (NSVS) created jointly by the Los Alamos National Laboratory and University of Michigan. The NSVS was funded by the Department of Energy, NASA and NSF. Finally, this work benefited from using the CDS database of Strasbourg (France).