A&A 459, 415-422 (2006)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20065681
R. Lopes de Oliveira1,2 - G. B. Lima Neto1 - C. Mendes de Oliveira1 - E. Janot-Pacheco1 - C. Motch2
1 - Instituto de Astronomia, Geofísica e Ciências Atmosféricas,
Universidade de São Paulo, R. do Matão 1226, 05508-900 São Paulo, Brazil
2 -
Observatoire Astronomique, UMR 7550 CNRS, 11 rue de l'Université, 67000
Strasbourg, France
Received 23 May 2006 / Accepted 12 July 2006
Abstract
We report the discovery of Cl 2334+48, a rich cluster of galaxies in the Zone of
Avoidance, identified in public images from the XMM-Newton archive.
We present the main properties of this cluster using the XMM-Newton
X-ray data, along with new optical spectroscopic and photometric observations. Cl 2334+48 is located at z = 0.271
0.001, as derived from the optical spectrum of
the brightest member galaxy. Such redshift agrees with a determination from
the X-ray spectrum (z = 0.263
+0.012-0.010), in which an intense
emission line is matched to the rest wavelength of the Fe K
complex.
Its intracluster medium has a plasma temperature of
4.92+0.50-0.48 keV,
a sub-solar abundance of 0.38
,
and a bolometric
luminosity of 3.2
1044 erg s-1. A density contrast
is reached in a radius of
0.5 h70-1 Mpc, and the corresponding
enclosed mass is 1.5
.
Optical images show an enhancement of
galaxies around the central
galaxy, as expected if these were cluster members. The central object is a luminous E-type galaxy, which is displaced
40 h70-1 kpc from the
cluster X-ray centre. In addition, it has a neighbouring arc-like feature
(
or
90 h70-1 kpc from it), probably due to strong
gravitational lensing. The discovery of Cl 2334+48 emphasises the remarkable
capability of the XMM-Newton to reveal new clusters of galaxies in
the Zone of Avoidance.
Key words: galaxies: clusters: individual: XMMU J233402.7+485108 - galaxies: intergalactic medium - X-ray: galaxies: clusters
Rich clusters of galaxies have been successfully used as tracers of large-scale structure formation and evolution, which has allowed setting constraints on various cosmological parameters (see, e.g., Bardeen et al. 1986; Rosati et al. 2002; Henry 2000). In the past, the majority of rich clusters was first identified in the optical and later observed in X-rays. However, with the advent of large and deep X-ray surveys, X-ray observations have become one of the most useful techniques for discovering clusters of galaxies, especially for intermediate and high-redshift systems (e.g. Adami et al. 2000; Rosati et al. 1998; Gioia & Luppino 1994). On the other hand, X-rays may also be useful for detecting clusters near the Galactic plane, where the increasing number of stars and extinction makes the optical identification of background galaxies difficult (see, e.g., Kraan-Korteweg & Juraszek 2000, and references therein).
![]() |
Figure 1:
Dust map (E(B-V) map from Schlegel et al. (1998) in logarithmic
grey scale) superposed with all known clusters and groups found in NED with
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
The mapping of the large-scale structures hidden by the Galaxy has profound
cosmological implications, as can be exemplified by the discovery of
the Great Attractor at
(Kolatt et al. 1995; Lynden-Bell et al. 1988). Indeed, the mass distribution derived from the
large-scale distribution of galaxies and from the peculiar velocity field of
nearby galaxies and/or clusters is still a matter of debate (see,
e.g., Tonry et al. 2000; Hudson et al. 2004; Mieske et al. 2005). It is still not clear whether or not the
bulk flow of galaxies is due mainly to the Great Attractor, or if there is a large contribution from the Shapley supercluster or other more distant
large-scale structures (Nagayama et al. 2006; Radburn-Smith et al. 2006; Proust et al. 2006).
A systematic search for clusters of galaxies in the Zone of Avoidance,
,
was carried out by Ebeling et al. (2002), where they made use of
the ROSAT All Sky Survey Bright Source Catalog
(RASS-BSC Voges et al. 1999; Ebeling et al. 1996) coupled with optical and near infrared
follow-ups. A major difficulty with this approach is the low-energy band of
RASS (0.1-2.4 keV) in which X-rays are strongly affected by the Galactic
absorption, notably when
cm-2.
In this work we report the discovery of Cl 2334+48, a rich cluster of galaxies
with z = 0.271, projected onto the Galactic plane and identified in the
XMM-Newton data archive. The source is described in Sect. 2. The main properties of this object were determined through
the analysis of XMM-Newton X-ray data (described in
Sect. 3.1), complemented by optical data (Sect. 3.2).
The X-ray analysis is shown in Sect. 4, followed by a mass determination in Sect. 5. The optical data analysis is
described in Sect. 6. For distances and luminosities, we use a
CDM cosmology with
,
,
and
H0 = 70 h70 km s-1 Mpc-1.
A search in NED
shows that
there are 812 known clusters and groups (221 with measured redshift) in the
Zone of Avoidance. Figure 1 shows the clusters and groups in a strip around
,
superposed on the dust map
from Schlegel et al. (1998). The number of known clusters and groups drops to 134
(59 with known redshift) in a region limited by
.
Within about 2 arcmin from the well-known Z And symbiotic star, an X-ray source, 1E 2331.6+4834, is located at RA
,
Dec
(hereafter Cl 2334+48, following the
usual nomenclature), found on a Galactic plane survey with Einstein
IPC (Hertz & Grindlay 1984). Even after optical and radio follow-ups by Hertz & Grindlay (1988)
and Nelson & Spencer (1988), respectively, the nature of this source remained
unknown. This position corresponds in Galactic coordinates to
,
,
where the Galactic extinction is
E(B-V) = 0.211 mag (Schlegel et al. 1998).
This source was also observed by the ROSAT PSPC and catalogued as
1WGA J2334.0+4851, with an estimated flux of 2.57
10-13 erg cm-2 s-1 (White et al. 2000). XMM-Newton also observed
1E 2331.6+4834 serendipitously in 2001. The MOS and pn sensitivities
and spatial resolution allowed us to identify the source
(XMMU J233402.7+485108) as a rich cluster of galaxies. This is thus the
second cluster discovered this way by XMM-Newton in the
Zone of Avoidance; the other one was XMMU J183225.4-103645, a hot (kT
= 5.8 keV), z = 0.124, rich cluster (Nevalainen et al. 2001).
Cl 2334+48 was observed twice by XMM-Newton (EPIC), in revolutions 209 on 28 January 2001, and 276 on 11 June 2001. In both observations the symbiotic
system Z And was the main target. About 80% of the
14 ks of
the second observation (obsID 0093552801) was lost due to high soft-proton background. We
report only on results obtained from the first observation (exposure time
of about 24 ks; obsID 0093552701), which was partially contaminated by solar
particles. This observation was made in prime full window mode
with the medium filter.
The data were reduced with the Science Analysis System (SAS) software v6.5. All EPIC data were reprocessed using the epproc and emproc tasks. The data were cleaned following standard procedure, keeping only standard event grades (patterns 0-12 for MOS1/2 and 0-4 for the pn; flag = 0 always). Periods of high particle background were filtered out based on E > 10 keV band light curves. For the MOS detectors, we imposed an upper threshold of 0.4 count/s and a 1 count/s for the pn. The remaining usable exposure time was 21.2 ks for MOS1 and MOS2, and 14.2 ks for the pn observation.
Since this cluster is located at a very low Galactic latitude, the use of standard EPIC background files (e.g. Lumb et al. 2002) is not recommended. Therefore we estimated the background using large areas free of cluster emission on the same CCD chip as the source in each camera, after removing X-ray point sources.
The spectral analysis was performed with the X-ray package XSPEC 11.3.0. The energy channels were grouped such that each bin contained at least 25 events. In all cases, the three EPIC spectra were fitted simultaneously with the same model, but allowing a free normalization factor between the different instruments.
Cl 2334+48 optical imaging was obtained by the XMM-Newton Survey
Science Center (XMM-SSC) team in the framework of the XID programme
(Yuan et al. 2001; Watson et al. 2001).
The Z And field is also part of the XMM-SSC survey of the Galactic plane (Motch et al. 2003).
We report on the public data taken with the optical
mosaic Wide Field Camera (WFC) on the 2.5 m Isaac Newton Telescope (INT)
with the
and
(Sloan system) filters on 16 July 2001. The
image has 600 s exposure and 1
seeing, while the
has 1200 s and a seeing of 1.2
,
both observed in photometric
conditions.
The pre-processed and flat-fielded mosaics have astrometric solutions
that are accurate to better than 0.5'', confirmed by us from comparison with the
USNO-A2.0 catalogue (Monet et al. 1998). The positions and magnitudes of all
detected objects were derived using the program SExtractor (Bertin & Arnouts 1996). Calibration
to the standard SDSS system was made with the general extinction
coefficients provided by the Wide Field
Survey
(WFS). It was possible to make a star-galaxy separation down
to
= 21 mag.
A spectrum of the brightest cluster galaxy was obtained in order to check
the redshift derived from the X-ray data. The observation was acquired on 14 May 2005 at the Keck II telescope, equipped with the Echellette Spectrograph
and Imager (ESI) in echelle mode. A 1.25
slit was used, yielding
a velocity resolution of about 93 km s-1. The useful range of wavelength
was
6480-7625 Å (orders 7 and 8), which corresponds to
5100-6000 Å at the galaxy rest
wavelength. A redshift for the object was obtained from cross-correlation techniques with a stellar spectrum of HD 19476 (a K0III star), from the Elodie
database
(Sect. 6).
![]() |
Figure 2:
Top: EPIC MOS1+MOS2 image of Cl 2334+48 in the 0.5-8.0 keV
band. The lines are adaptively smoothed contours in logarithmic scales.
Bottom: the smoothed X-ray contours superposed on the
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
Both EPIC-MOS and pn have a point spread function (PSF) with FWHM
5''; however, their PSF have somewhat extended wings and the half energy
width
is
.
The PSF was not taken into account in our analysis.
The X-ray emissivity map shows that Cl 2334+48 is quite a regular cluster.
Figure 2 displays the X-ray (0.5-8.0 keV; top panel) and
-band (bottom panel) images, both with the smoothed
X-ray contours overlaid. There are a few features to note. The peak X-ray emission is
displaced from the brightest cluster member by
westwards.
At the cluster redshift (z = 0.271; see Sect. 6), this
offset corresponds to
40
h70-1 kpc.
A number of point sources close to Cl 2334+48 are identified with active stars and AGNs (Motch et al. 2006).
The bottom panel of Fig. 2 shows the probable cluster members inside a radius of
270
h70-1 kpc (see details in Sect. 6).
Using the task ellipse from STSDAS/IRAF
, we derived the
X-ray brightness radial profile I(R). We used a 0.5-8.0 keV band image,
combining exposure-map corrected MOS1 and MOS2 data, binned such that 1 image
pixel corresponds to
.
The CCD gaps and point sources have been
masked out.
In Fig. 3, we show the brightness profile, together with two different fits: a Sérsic profile (Sérsic 1968) given by
![]() |
Figure 3:
X-ray surface brightness fitted with a |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Table 1:
Surface brightness fitting results, where
(
-model) and a(Sérsic profile) are in
h70-1 kpc, and n0 is in
10-2 cm-2.
The Sérsic profile gives a slightly better fit due to the first three surface brightness data points (the ones most strongly affected by the PSF),
while the
-model flattens too much
towards the centre in comparison to the peaked X-ray profile (see
Fig. 3). Notice that the background starts to have an important
effect already at
from the centre.
In order to estimate the central electronic density, n0, which is related
to I0, we integrated the bremsstrahlung emissivity along the line-of-sight
within
in the central region. The result was compared to the flux
obtained by spectral fitting of the same region (the normalization parameter
of the thermal spectral model in XSPEC, which is proportional to
;
Table 1).
![]() |
Figure 4: EPIC spectra with the best-fit model (solid lines; see Table 2). |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Table 2: Spectral fit results with a PHABS*MEKAL model (see Sect. 4.2). Uncertainties are at the 90% confidence level.
We extracted integrated EPIC spectra in the 0.3-8.0 keV band from a circular region of
radius (
270 h70-1 kpc at z = 0.27),
centred on the cluster X-ray image (see Fig. 4).
The source's photons correspond to about 90% of the total good events (
1700 photons in each MOS camera, and
3400 in the pn camera), the
remaining being due to background contributions.
The X-ray spectral properties of the ICM can be described very well by the MEKAL model (thermal plasma emission; Kaastra & Mewe 1993; Liedahl et al. 1995), associated to the PHABS model (Balucinska-Church & McCammon 1992) to account for the photoelectric absorption (Table 2). We opted for the standard Anders & Grevesse (1989) abundance table.
A relatively strong emission line was detected at
5.27+0.08-0.10 keV,
with an equivalent width of
669+315-284 eV. Setting all parameters free
during the fit, we found that this line is compatible with the Fe K
complex emitted by a thermal X-ray gas located at z = 0.263
+0.012-0.010. This fit results in a plasma temperature of
kT = 4.84+0.50-0.42 keV and a sub-solar abundance of
.
The resulting hydrogen column density,
1021 cm-2, is only slightly
higher than the mean Galactic value obtained in the Dickey & Lockman (1990) HI survey
(
1021 cm-2). Therefore, there is no
evidence of any notable local excess absorption. To verify this statement, we fitted the whole cluster by fixing the
to the Galactic value. The
derived temperature, metal abundance, and redshift are compatible with
those of the first model (see Table 2).
The redshift derived from the X-ray spectrum of Cl 2334+48 agrees very well
with the z = 0.271
0.001 obtained from the optical spectrum of the
brightest cluster member (Sect. 6). Since there are lower
uncertainties in the optical redshift determination, this redshift was used in
the X-ray spectral fits. As before, similar results are obtained if the
absorption column is taken as a free parameter, or if freezing it to the Galactic
value. Both results are also statistically indistinguishable from those
obtained freeing the redshift in the fits.
In order to determine the temperature profile, we divide the cluster image in a central circular region and three concentric rings. Their dimensions are such that the signal-to-noise ratios are approximately constant in each accumulated data set, as a compromise between the spatial resolution and the quality of the spectral fitting.
The EPIC spectra of each spatial region were fitted with the
PHABS*MEKAL model exactly as in
Sect. 4.2, but the absorption column (
1021 cm-2), metallicity (
), and
redshift (z = 0.271) were kept fixed to the adopted values of the integrated spectrum
(Table 2). The resulting temperature profile is shown in
Fig. 5, where we can see that it shows the
characteristic rise from the centre and then falls outward. However, given the
large error bars and the low spatial resolution, the temperature profile is
still consistent with an isothermal profile at least up to
.
Hence, we adopt an isothermal profile with
kT =
4.92+0.50-0.48 keV, as derived in Sect. 4.2.
![]() |
Figure 5:
Radial temperature profile (see Sect. 4.2.1). The
dashed line represents the mean temperature ( |
| Open with DEXTER | |
The gas mass was obtained by simply integrating the gas density obtained in Sect. 4.1. The dynamical mass was computed with the assumption of spherical symmetry and hydrostatic equilibrium of the X-ray emitting gas, with the density and temperature profiles obtained above.
We used the
-model and Sérsic law. Both models can be integrated
analytically, resulting in
Figure 6 shows the resulting gas mass profiles, together with the
dynamical mass. Both models predict quite the same gas mass profile in the
range
(corresponding to
kpc), where the data are most reliable. Beyond these limits,
the gas mass profiles diverge. The total gas mass at
is either
3.2
or 3.5
depending on
whether using the Sérsic profile or the
-model, respectively. The difference
between the total mass profiles is more marked than the gas profiles,
especially near the centre. At
,
the dynamical mass is either
3.8
for the
Sérsic profile or 2.3
for the
-model.
![]() |
Figure 6: Top: gas and dynamical (total) mass cumulative profiles. The vertical lines indicate the r2500 and r5000 radii (see text). Bottom: the gas mass fraction (baryon fraction minus the contribution from galaxies). |
| Open with DEXTER | |
We also computed the dynamical mass density as a function of radius, which can,
for example, be compared to the density of dark matter halos formed in
cosmological N-body simulations. In Fig. 7 we show the
dynamical mass density compared to a steep
r-1profile, the same inner slope of the Navarro et al. (1997, NFW) "universal'' profile
for dark halos.
Note that the inner slope of the total mass density
is close to
,
like the NFW profile.
While the use of the Sérsic law resulted in a very steep total density
profile, adopting the
-model resulted in a central flat total density
profile. However, both profiles are steep up to the X-ray image resolution;
the flattening of the
-model is actually seen only when the profile is
extrapolated inwards.
We estimated the radius corresponding to some values of the density contrast
.
For
,
we have the usual
r200, frequently associated with the virial radius.
The available data are restricted to about
,
which corresponds to a ratio
,
and therefore well inside the virial radius.
Extrapolating the derived mass profile (Eq. (3)) from the
available data, we obtained
r200 = 3.4 h70-1 Mpc and a corresponding
virial mass of 3.8
for the Sérsic law, or else
r200 = 1.7 h70-1 Mpc and 4.8
for the
-model. Such a large discrepancy comes from the extrapolation of two models, owing to the different asymptotical behaviours, and those values are
highly uncertain.
![]() |
Figure 7:
Total mass density profile for both |
| Open with DEXTER | |
![]() |
Figure 8: The optical spectrum of the central galaxy, de-redshifted and smoothed with a boxcar filter. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Using the mean cluster temperature as an estimator of the virial
radius (Evrard et al. 1996),
For
,
the equivalent radius can be calculated more precisely.
We obtain
kpc for both models, which corresponds to an enclosed mass of
M5000 = 8.1
.
For
,
the radius is still within the X-ray data image, and we have
r2500 = 0.5 h70-1 Mpc and
M2500 = 1.5
.
These values are very close to the ones from a similar cluster, Abell 1068, which has
r2500 = 490 h70-1 kpc,
M2500 = 1.47
,
and kT = 4.67 keV (Arnaud et al. 2005).
The gas mass fraction,
,
is computed simply as the ratio between
the gas mass and the total mass at a given radius, and is related
to the baryon fraction as
Figure 6 (bottom panel) shows the obtained gas mass fraction. For
the
-model,
rises up to the outer limit of the X-ray
data, while this fraction rises up to
r2500(
500 h70-1 kpc) and then decreases very slowly for the Sérsic model. This difference
in behaviour comes from the different form of the dynamical mass for each
model. At
,
is
0.16 for the
-model and
0.09 for the Sérsic profile. These values are close to those obtained
by Allen et al. (2002),
0.005 at r2500, for six regular clusters.
Within the interval
,
the derived dynamical
properties, dynamical mass, gas fraction, and total mass density profile could
be considered as normal if compared to the established properties of the regular
rich clusters of galaxies.
The redshift of the central galaxy (RA =
,
Dec =
)
was derived from echelle
spectroscopy, as described in Sect. 3.2. In particular, the
Mg
band and the Na lines are very prominent in the spectrum
(Fig. 8). We derived a redshift z = 0.271
0.001,
which confirms the value independently obtained from the X-ray analysis.
![]() |
Figure 9:
Density of galaxies with 16.3 <
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
The
and
images were used to estimate the extent of the
cluster and obtain the colour-magnitude diagram. We show the density of galaxies with observed magnitudes
in Fig. 9, in concentric annuli of increasing radii around
the central galaxy (which has
mag). As expected, the
density increases steeply towards the centre of the cluster within a radius of
about
(or
270 h70-1 kpc at z = 0.27). We then use
all identified galaxies in this region to obtain the colour-magnitude diagram
shown in Fig. 10. The most probable cluster members have
.
![]() |
Figure 10:
Colour-magnitude diagram in the
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
The colour-magnitude diagram shows that the next three brightest galaxies after the first-ranked galaxy of the cluster (Fig. 2, lower panel, and Fig. 10) have luminosities from four to six times lower than that of the central galaxy. These three objects are located in the northeastwards region. Without redshifts, we can just speculate at this point that these could form a foreground group, although they do have the right colours to be in the cluster.
We obtained the surface brightness profile of the central object with only the
image (Fig. 11), since the
image did not
have sufficient signal-to-noise ratio. An r1/4-profile was fitted to the galaxy surface
brightness profile between 1.5
and 22
.
There is no significant light excess
over the de Vaucouleurs profile, as one would expect for a cD galaxy.
An arc-like structure is identified in both the
and
images (see Fig. 2, lower panel). Its relative position,
tangential to the semi-major axis of the expected mass distribution of the
cluster, suggests that this feature could be due to strong gravitational
lensing. Such an arc-like feature is compatible with what is expected for a distant galaxy at z > 1, lensed by a cluster with mass similar to that
derived for Cl 2334+48 in Sect. 5.1.
![]() |
Figure 11:
Surface brightness of the central galaxy in the
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
Assuming that such an arc-like feature is indeed a lensed background galaxy,
we use the singular isothermal sphere (SIS) model to roughly estimate the
cluster mass up to its angular position. We further assume that the arc is
located at the Einstein radius, in this case,
(
90 h70-1 kpc at the cluster distance) from the centre of the
brightest cluster galaxy. If the background galaxy has
,
then
the mass is
.
That is roughly 3
to 4 times the total mass obtained with the X-ray observation (see
Fig. 6).
The total mass derived by gravitational lensing tends to be different from the mass obtained with X-ray observations (e.g. Allen et al. 2002; Cypriano et al. 2004) for hot and/or disturbed clusters. Moreover, the mass derived from lensing may be higher than the X-ray derived mass due to the mass concentrations along the line-of-sight of the cluster (Metzler et al. 2001). The candidate arc lies at a position where it can indeed be an image of a lensed background object. However, only deeper and higher resolution imaging and/or spectroscopy of the arc itself would confirm its nature.
In this paper we report on the discovery of Cl 2334+48, a cluster of galaxies in the Zone of Avoidance, from XMM-Newton X-ray images. New photometric and spectroscopic observations of the system are presented. The main results of our analysis of the X-ray and optical data can be summarised as follows.
The X-ray emission is almost spherically symmetric and the temperature profile
has the usual shape (although the error bars are large) observed in relaxed
clusters (Figs. 2 and 5). The X-ray
derived properties based on hydrostatic equilibrium follow the scaling
relations of nearby regular clusters. However, the X-ray peak emission does
not coincide with the brightest member galaxy by an offset of
(
40 h70-1 kpc; see Fig. 2). If this
displacement is real, it indicates that this cluster is not quite relaxed and some dynamical event (possibly a sub-cluster merging we may surmise) took
place a few Gyrs ago. The central galaxy is not a cD, owing to the lack of an extended stellar envelope, which may be interpreted as a sign of the relative youth of this cluster.
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank G.J.M. Luna for his participation in this discovery. We would also like to thank P. Coté and M. West for obtaining the Keck spectrum of the central galaxy of the cluster, M. Bolte for reducing the spectroscopic data, D. Bortoletto for the help with Figs. 9-11, and the referee, D. Proust, for his suggestions and comments. The INT is operated on the island of La Palma by the Isaac Newton Group in the Spanish Observatorio del Roque de Los Muchachos of the Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias. R.L.O. acknowledges financial support from the Brazilian agencies FAPESP (grant 03/06861-6) and CAPES (grant BEX0784/04-4), and the Observatoire de Strasbourg. G.B.L.N. acknowledges support from CNPq and CAPES/Cofecub Brazilian-French collaboration. C.M.d.O. and G.B.L.N. would like to thank support from FAPESP through the Thematic Project 01/07342-7.