A&A 448, 29-42 (2006)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20042564
T. Bertram1 - A. Eckart1 - M. Krips1 - J. G. Staguhn2 - W. Hackenberg3
1 - I. Physikalisches Institut, Universität zu Köln,
Zülpicher Str. 77, 50937 Köln, Germany
2 - NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, MD 20771, USA
3 - European Southern Observatory, Karl-Schwarzschild-Str. 2, 85748 Garching, Germany
Received 17 December 2004 / Accepted 23 September 2005
Abstract
We present millimeter CO line emission observations of 12 galaxies within the Abell 262 cluster, together with
data, in the context of a possible molecular gas deficiency within the region of the cluster center.
Several indications of the presence of such a deficiency are highlighted and connected to a model of cirrus-like cloud stripping.
The model predicts a drop in the average 100
m flux density of galaxies in the core of the cluster compared to the average 100
m flux density in the outer regions, which is actually indicated in the IRAS data of the cluster members.
This drop is explained by the decrease in the total hydrogen column density N(H) and, therefore, also includes a decrease in the molecular gas content.
In addition to results for the global CO content of the galaxy sample, high-resolution interferometric CO(1-0) observations of one of the cluster members, UGC 1347, exemplify the spatial distribution of the molecular gas in a galaxy of the cluster. With these observations, it was possible to confirm the existence of a bright off-nuclear CO-emission source and to derive molecular masses and line ratios for this source and the nucleus.
Key words: galaxies: clusters: individual: Abell 262 - galaxies: evolution - ISM: molecules - galaxies: individual: UGC 1347
A large number of mechanisms in rich galaxy clusters have been discussed (Couch et al. 1998; Butcher & Oemler 1978), and found to favor the transition from spiral-dominated, blue galaxy populations at higher redshifts towards the domination of early, red populations as observed at
.
The most detailed view of galaxy cluster members has been obtained for the Coma and Virgo galaxies.
Studies of these and other targets suggest interaction with either other cluster members or the cluster potential or the hot intra-cluster medium (ICM) seen as the main cause of both the truncation of the star-formation rate and the morphological transition.
Strong evidence of interaction between the interstellar medium (ISM) and the ICM is shown by the lack of atomic gas (Giovanelli & Haynes 1985) in those spiral galaxies that are in the vicinity of the centers of rich clusters with respect to similar, but isolated objects.
This HI deficiency is commonly explained by ram pressure stripping or sweeping, as the galaxy moves through the dense and hot gas in the core of the cluster.
Studies of the global CO distribution of cluster galaxies (Boselli et al. 1997; Casoli et al. 1998,1991; Lavezzi & Dickey 1998; Kenney & Young 1989), on the other hand, show either no or insignificant dependence of the molecular gas content on its location or on the degree of HI deficiency.
Molecular clouds do not seem, or at least seem less, affected by the gas stripping mechanisms.
The higher column densities and the concentration in the center of the disks and, therefore, the stronger binding within the galaxies' potential may allow molecular gas to better resist environmental influences.
Despite this negative global result, CO observations with high spatial resolution can provide important clues to the mechanisms that may influence the evolution of galaxies within a cluster. Vollmer et al. (2001), for example, discuss the indirect consequences of HI stripping by studying the lopsided molecular gas distribution in the case of the Coma galaxy NGC 4848. Although ram pressure stripping, in the long term, leads to an overall decrease in the gas mass, and hence to a reduced star-formation rate (SFR), it can cause a temporary increase in the gas density and, along with this, an increased SFR. Molecular gas can be regarded as required for the star-formation process. Since CO is the most important tracer for molecular gas, CO observations provide information on whether the environment within cluster members favors enhanced star formation activity or not.
In this paper we present the results of our CO observations of a small sample of Abell 262 cluster galaxies and discuss indications for environmental effects on the total molecular gas content of the sample members.
With
data, we substantiate our tentative findings indicating a dependency of the global molecular gas mass on the distance to the cluster core.
For a more profound analysis of the total molecular gas content of Abell 262 galaxies, it is essential to determine the extent and distribution of the CO emission regions with high spatial resolution interferometric observations.
We present the results of such interferometric CO observations of the Abell 262 cluster member UGC 1347 as an example of a more detailed analysis of the galaxy's CO distribution.
The spiral rich cluster Abell 262 has been subject to a variety of studies in
different wavelength domains.
Abell (1958) first analysed POSS photographic plates, and defined cluster richness classes by the number of galaxies in the cluster that are not more than 2 mag fainter than the third brightest member.
With 40 galaxies (Abell et al. 1989, corrected for background contamination) meeting this richness criterion, Abell 262 falls into richness class 0, and is far less densely populated then e.g. the Coma cluster with 106 members and richness class 2.
However, the cluster consists of many more members. Struble & Rood (1999) consider a total number of 151 galaxies that are associated with Abell 262.
As it is embedded in the main ridge of the Pisces-Perseus supercluster (Haynes & Giovanelli 1986), Abell 262 has a conspicuous appearance.
Its center [RA (J2000
,
Dec (J2000
]
coincides with the position of the cD galaxy NGC 708
.
The value for the cluster redshift of z=0.0163 (Struble & Rood 1999) results in a heliocentric velocity of
km s-1 and a distance to the cluster of 49 h-1 Mpc. An angular separation of 1
then corresponds to 238 h-1 pc.
The Abell radius (corresponding to
1.5 h-1 Mpc) follows
![]()
.
In these and the following calculations, whenever required,
H0 = 100 h km s-1 Mpc-1 and q0=0.5 were used, unless otherwise stated.
Fadda et al. (1996) state a line-of-sight velocity dispersion for
Abell 262 members of
km s-1, which
is similar to the result of Neill et al. (2001) (
km s-1 for a sample of 101 Abell 262 member
galaxies) and is only slightly higher than the average low-velocity dispersion
(
km s-1) of clusters in the richness class 0 (Fadda et al. 1996).
Several groups have carried out X-ray observations to investigate the properties of the hot ICM of Abell 262 (e.g. David et al. 1996; Neill et al. 2001; MacKenzie et al. 1996). Jones & Forman (1984)
identified Abell 262 as a dynamically young XD cluster, similar to Virgo,
that shows the typical signs of a less evolved system with a stationary,
dominant galaxy at its center: low X-ray luminosity
(
erg s-1), low ICM temperature (
K), high central gas density/cooling flow, high spiral fraction, low central galaxy density, and an irregular shape.
Since Abell 262 apparently is not yet in a relaxed state, the transformation mechanisms that are discussed in the context of higher redshift galaxy and cluster evolution may still be active.
And due to the cluster's low redshift, they can be studied with high spatial resolution.
Several studies of the signatures of galaxy interaction have included the case of Abell 262.
Similar to clusters such as Virgo, Coma, and several others, Abell 262
member galaxies are deficient in atomic gas towards the center
(Giovanelli et al. 1982; Solanes et al. 2001).
Bravo-Alfaro et al. (1997) used the Westerborg Synthesis Radio Telescope to
map the spatial HI distribution of 11 Abell 262 members.
They show that, in a few cases, the gas distribution is asymmetrical - again a sign of ISM-ICM interaction.
A few Abell 262 galaxies were included in CO(1-0) observations by Lavezzi & Dickey (1998), and H
emission of several members was investigated by Amram et al. (1994) and Moss & Whittle (2000).
Moss & Whittle (2000) discuss the H
emission of Abell 262
member galaxies together with other cluster galaxies in the context of tidally
induced star formation, whereas Amram et al. (1994) provide maps, as
well as rotation curves, of six Abell 262 galaxies - among them UGC 1347.
The SBc galaxy UGC 1347 [RA (J2000
,
Dec (J2000
], is located about 28
north
of the cluster center (cf. Fig. 1).
Based on HI observations, Haynes et al. (1997)
found the galaxy's redshift to be z=0.01849, corresponding to a systemic velocity of 5543 km s-1.
The difference between the cluster velocity of 4887 km s-1 and the
systemic velocity of UGC 1347 of about 650 km s-1 (
1.2 times the cluster's velocity dispersion) can be explained as motion of the galaxy within
the cluster.
UGC 1347 is the first extragalactic target that was observed
with a laser-guide-star assisted adaptive optics system.
Hackenberg et al. (2000) used the MPIA-MPE ALFA AO system at the Calar
Alto 3.5 m telescope to obtain NIR images at subarcsecond resolution.
They discuss their results in the context of published radio, FIR, and
H
data.
Since millimetric CO observations had not been carried out for this object by
that time, quantities related to the molecular gas content and
distribution had to be estimated.
Besides a bright nuclear source, UGC 1347 features a second prominent
component about 9
south of the center at the tip of the bar (cf. Fig. 1).
Hackenberg et al. (2000) found this region to be compact in the NIR and
identified it with a region of recent active star formation in the disk.
For several members of the Abell 262 cluster, we obtained millimeter CO-emission line data for different transitions and, in the case of UGC 1347, also for different isotopomeres. The observations were carried out with BIMA and the IRAM 30 m telescope.
![]() |
Figure 1: The location of UGC 1347 within the Abell 262 cluster - visual images from the Palomar Observatory Sky Survey (POSS). The bottom right image shows the nucleus and the bright southern source at the tip of the bar. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
12CO(1-0) observations of UGC 1347 were
carried out with BIMA
at Hat Creek, CA, USA in July 2000.
The local millimeter-wave radio interferometer, consisting of 10 antennae with a diameter of 6.1 m each, was used in C configuration.
Every 24 min the series of observations with this setup was interrupted by
measurement of the phase calibrator 0136+478 located 11.5
north of UGC 1347.
The good uv coverage obtained in the overall on-source integration time of 257 min resulted in an approximate beam size of 6.6
FWHM.
| Obs. | Line | Spectral | Array |
|
| date | resolution | configuration | FWHM | |
| [km s-1] | [
|
|||
| Jul. 00 | 12CO(1-0) | 8.3 | C | 6.6 |
Because of the data quality, it was possible to apply all standard reduction steps in an almost straightforward manner. A CLEAN algorithm was applied to the image data obtained. A comparison with single dish data is shown in Fig. 2. Only about 70% of the total flux is expected to be recoverable from observations of sources with small angular extensions, such as UGC 1347 in BIMA's C configuration (Helfer et al. 2002).
The following remarks on smaller problems in the dataset may be helpful for archive users.
An inspection of the uv dataset revealed that the first channel of each
of the 16 spectral windows was malfunctioning.
Both channels neighboring a malfunctioning channel showed reduced dynamics with respect to the other channels.
While the spectral information of the malfunctioning channels was
completely corrupted and therefore lost, the data of the neighboring
channels with damped performance was recoverable by applying a
correction factor.
One of the malfunctioning channels unfortunately represents the 8.3 km s-1 wide spectral region starting at -4 km s-1 - right in the
center of the emission line region of UGC 1347.
In order to obtain a reasonably integrated intensity distribution
of the galaxy and the integrated flux of the central source, the
missing channel map was interpolated.
![]() |
Figure 2:
Comparison of two 12CO(1-0) spectra, obtained
with BIMA and with the IRAM 30 m telescope. The BIMA flux density
was integrated over the inner 21
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
![]() |
Figure 3: IRAM 30 m 12CO spectra of the selected Abell 262 galaxies. The cases in which the 12CO(2-1) emission line region extended over the bandwidth of the receiver have been excluded. In these cases a continuum subtraction was impossible. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
The IRAM
30 m telescope on Pico Veleta (Spain) was used to acquire
12CO(2-1) and 13CO(1-0) emission line data
of UGC 1347 in parallel. These observations were carried out in July 2003, together with 12CO(1-0) and
12CO(2-1) measurements of 11 other Abell 262 cluster
galaxies.
Besides the observations mentioned, initial IRAM 30 m measurements of the 12CO(1-0) and 12CO(2-1) emission of
UGC 1347 were performed in June 2000, prior to the BIMA observations.
Except for a few cases in which the line emission extended over the
spectral range of the receiver, linear baselines were subtracted from the spectra (cf. Fig. 3) and peak temperatures, as well as line intensities, were determined.
In order to obtain main beam temperatures, the main beam efficiencies
and the forward efficiencies
given in
Table 2 were applied to
.
The resulting values for
and peak
,
as well as the
velocity ranges over which the lines were integrated, are shown in Table 3.
The errors of
in Table 3 represent the rms per channel after smoothing the spectra.
To compare the two 12CO(1-0) spectra obtained with
BIMA and the IRAM 30 m telescope shown in Fig. 2, the IRAM 30 m telescope
spectrum was converted using the factor
Jy K-1.
The inverse conversion of integrated flux densities measured by BIMA into
,
as given in Table 6, was done analogously with a factor
Jy K-1.
Table 2: IRAM observation parameters.
Table 3: Measured 12CO properties of the centers of selected Abell 262 member galaxies. The corresponding observation parameters are shown in Table 2.
The primary goal of the observations with the IRAM 30 m telescope was to determine the global CO content of a set of gas rich galaxies in the Abell 262 cluster and to investigate a possible dependency on the distance to the cluster center. The CO bright galaxies are candidates for interferometric high resolution followup observations that allow detailed studies of the spatial distribution of molecular gas. In the case of UGC 1347, such observations have been carried out using BIMA. They represent an example of how detailed investigations should be carried out on a much larger sample. For this reason a description of the results is presented in Sect. 3.2.
A possible impact of the galaxies' environment on the gas distribution and star-formation properties may be investigated most easily for the brightest candidates.
In order to maximize the chances of detection, the well-established CO-IR correlation (Stark et al. 1986; Sanders et al. 1991) was used in the selection.
All galaxies selected for observation show IRAS 100
m fluxes of more
than 2.5 Jy, with the exception of UGC 1344, which was included
because it was discussed by Hackenberg et al. (2000), together with
UGC 1347.
In addition to the FIR criterion, we only chose galaxies of known HI content, as determined by Giovanelli & Haynes (1985).
The sample was composed to contain both a subset of 7 galaxies located close to the cluster center and a subset of 5 galaxies with a distance to the center that exceeds the Abell radius. The results of the measurements are shown in Fig. 3 and listed in Table 3 and a discussion follows in Sect. 4.
The CO emission region can extend somewhat beyond the region covered by the 21.5
IRAM 30 m telescope beam at 115 GHz. This can be seen in the case of UGC 1347 in Sect. 3.2, and it is also indicated by the off-center measurements in some other cases.
Therefore, to estimate the overall intrinsic CO content and to derive molecular gas masses,certain assumptions on source sizes and distributions were necessary - namely both beam and sources were assumed to be Gaussian.
Please note that the need for source-size estimates introduces a serious uncertainty in the gas mass estimates.
Better statistics and high resolution information indicating the actual sizes of the CO emission regions, as obtained with BIMA for the case of UGC 1347, are mandatory for verifying the results of this study.
Young et al. (1995) found the CO emission region of galaxies to be confined to the center of the disk and correlated with the 25.0
/arcsec2isophotal diameter D25.
The mean ratio of the CO scale length of a simple exponential model to D25was determined to be 0.10.
Similar to the approach of Young et al. (1995), the FWHM of the
sources were taken as
,
except for the case of UGC 1347, in
which the interferometric measurements allowed a more accurate determination of
the source size.
The size estimates were then used to determine beam filling factors
that were applied to correct the measured values of
.
Lavezzi & Dickey (1998) observed UGC 1302, UGC 1319, and UGC 1456 in 12CO(1-0) line emission using the 12 m NRAO telescope with a beam size of 55
and obtained values for
of
K km s-1 (
K km s-1 in this paper),
K km s-1 (
K km s-1), and
K km s-1 (
K km s-1) respectively.
The differences of the values presented in this paper result from different beam sizes.
Considering the different sizes by correcting with
yields intrinsic
values of 6 K km s-1 (15 K km s-1 in this paper) for UGC 1302, 68 K km s-1 (42 K km s-1) for UGC 1319, and 37 K km s-1 (31 K km s-1) for UGC 1456.
The remaining differences are explicable with uncertainties in the source-size estimates.
Especially UGC 1302 is likely to be resolved in the IRAS 30 m telescope beam.
Determination of the H2 content using
(especially
optically thick line emission) as the tracer has to be handled with care.
The common approach of using a "standard'' N(H2)/
conversion
factor X derived from galactic observations has the shortcoming of disregarding
the dependency of X on the metallicity of the region of interest
(Israel 1997).
Nevertheless, since only global mass estimates can be derived and since they are caused by the lack of information on metallicity, a "standard'' conversion factor
cm-2 (K km s-1)-1 (Strong et al. 1988) was
adopted.
This also allows the results to be compared to published data.
The resulting molecular mass estimates are listed in Table 4, where a linewidth of 500 km s-1 was assumed for the upper mass limit of UGC 1344, and plotted against their projected
distance to the cluster center in Fig. 4.
In this plot the horizontal lines represent the median molecular gas estimates
and the common median absolute deviation for the two subsamples.
To compare a more homogenous set of galaxies, the peculiar galaxy UGC 1655 with its outstanding flux density was not considered in the calculation of the median.
Nor was UGC 1344, which does not meet the 100
m selection criterion.
If both galaxies were included, the median values of the two subsamples would be even further separated.
Table 4:
Molecular gas mass estimates of the sample. The sources are assumed do be Gaussian with a FWHM
,
with the exception of UGC 1347, for which a more accurate FWHM could be determined from the interferometric measurements. The CO deficiency indicator CODEF follows the definition given in Casoli et al. (1998).
![]() |
Figure 4: Molecular mass vs. the distance to the cluster center. The horizontal lines represent the median value for each of the two subsamples and the common median absolute deviation. To be able to compare the mass estimates of a homogeneous sample, the peculiar galaxy UGC 1655 and the FIR weak galaxy UGC 1344 were not considered (see text). |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Table 5:
Properties of the IRAS FIR flux limited sample of Abell 262 galaxies with a distance to the cluster core of less than 3 Abell radii, as observed in HI by Giovanelli & Haynes. The morphological classification, as well as the inclination estimate (with respect to the line of sight), were taken from
Nilson (1973), D25 from de Vaucouleurs et al. (1991),
and
IRAS flux densities from
Moshir et al. (1990), and HI deficiency from
Giovanelli & Haynes (1985). An inclination value of 1 indicates a face-on, and a 7 indicates an edge-on view onto the galaxy.
![]() |
Figure 5: FIR luminosity as function of the distance to the cluster center. The plot contains all Abell 262 galaxies down to the IRAS flux limit, with distances to the cluster core not exceeding 3 Abell radii. The filled circles represent the objects for which CO data were obtained. Median values of 3 regions are shown by the horizontal lines. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
To be able to discuss a possible selection bias due to the FIR selection criterion, FIR luminosities were calculated for all Abell 262 galaxies in the Giovanelli & Haynes sample within 3 Abell radii down to the IRAS flux limit (Table 5).
Following Helou et al. (1988) the FIR luminosity can be written as:
![]() |
Figure 6:
Overlay of the 12CO map obtained with BIMA
and the POSS-II Red image. The contours have an increment of 1
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
![]() |
Figure 7: Global 12CO(1-0) and 13CO(1-0) spectra of UGC 1347, obtained with the IRAM 30 m telescope. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
| |
Figure 8:
Overlay of the 12CO(1-0) maps obtained with BIMA
(white contours), the 12CO(2-1) maps obtained with the IRAM 30 m
telescope (black contours), and the POSS-II Red image. The integrated intensity maps cover the velocity ranges in which at least a 2 |
| Open with DEXTER | |
The overlay of the POSS-II Red
image and the BIMA CO map in Fig. 6 clearly shows that CO emission extends over almost the entire inner disk of UGC 1347.
Continuum emission was not detected.
A comparison of the two CO(1-0) spectra can be found in Fig. 7.
With the high resolution 12CO(1-0) observations obtained with BIMA, it was possible to identify reservoirs of molecular gas at the positions of the nucleus and in the southern component.
Figure 8 shows maps of the two components.
Only channel maps with a contribution of at least 2
to the individual components were used for compiling the integrated intensity maps.
This resulted in corresponding velocity ranges of 5464-5589 km s-1 for the
central component, 5555-5613 km s-1 for the southern component, and 5456-5613 km s-1 for the total galaxy (Fig. 6).
The IRAM 30 m 12CO(2-1) flux densities were integrated over the same velocity ranges as the BIMA maps.
To coincide better with the BIMA contour map and the POSS-II Red data, the IRAM maps were shifted by 1.6
towards north-east - a correction which agrees with the pointing accuracy of the 30 m telescope.
Table 6 lists the molecular line emission data determined for
both regions, based on the BIMA 12CO(1-0) and the IRAM 30 m 12CO(2-1) observations.
Their sizes were determined in the BIMA integrated intensity maps (Fig. 8, white contours) assuming a
Gaussian brightness distribution with an additional underlying disk, both contributing to the total flux density.
For the central region, the 65% peak intensity contour was chosen, while for the southern component the 60% contour was chosen to represent the FWHM of the distribution.
The nucleus remains unresolved at the BIMA beam with a
,
whereas the southern region shows extended CO emission at this resolution.
To consider the error caused by the uncertainty in the determination of the
size of the southern component, the 50% and 70% contours were taken as upper
and lower limits.
The derived intrinsic 12CO(2-1)/ 12CO(1-0) line
ratios R are listed in Table 7, together with the observed
line ratios
and the corresponding correction factors
,
where
Due to the lack of any information on metallicity in UGC 1347, the estimate of
the molecular gas mass
), as listed in Table 8, has a significant amount of uncertainty.
To account for the higher metallicity in galaxy centers, the value of
)
for the central region given in Table 8
was based on a lower conversion factor than the other two values, as suggested
in Israel (2001).
Table 6: Integrated temperatures for both CO-bright components and for the disk of UGC 1347. Both components were assumed to be Gaussian. A disk flux contribution was taken into account in the determination of the source sizes. The central component is not resolved. The values for the total galaxy represent IRAM 30 m single-beam measurements centered on the galaxy. A comparison of the two CO(1-0) spectra can be found in Fig. 7.
Table 7:
12CO(2-1)/ 12CO(1-0) line ratio R for
both CO-bright components of UGC 1347. The listed ratios R and source sizes
are intrinsic values based on the integrated temperatures
and observed sizes given in Table 6 and assuming Gaussian
distributions for the beams and sources.
Table 8: Molecular gas masses of the nucleus, southern component, and total galaxy. The size estimates given in Table 7 were applied.
![]() |
Figure 9:
12CO(1-0) position-velocity diagram of UGC 1347 with
the origin in the center of the galaxy and a position angle of 20 |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Amram et al. (1994) investigate the H
velocity field and the
H
rotation curve of UGC 1347. They derive an approximate inclination of 30
,
as well as a position angle of 20
.
As shown in Fig. 9, the H
rotation curve is in good
agreement with the 12CO(1-0) velocity pattern along the same
axis.
The H
rotation curve was scaled by a factor of 0.5 along the velocity axis to compensate for the inclination correction that was applied to the Amram et al. (1994) data.
However, the coincidence of both curves is valid only relative to each other, since Amram et al. find a systemic velocity of only 5478 km s-1.
Another remarkable feature visible in the position-velocity diagram is a
discrepancy in the velocity of the southern component and the disk at the
same position.
The gas appears to be blue-shifted by approximately 10 km s-1 with respect to the underlying disk.
A weak evidence of a component, which is to a lesser extent red-shifted at that position is also indicated in the diagram.
This may be explained by an expected cloud-cloud velocity dispersion of
km s-1.
However, the blue-shifted (as well as the indicated red-shifted) emission coincides with the position of the southern component. Therefore, the shift may alternatively be explained by the model of an asymmetrically expanding gas shell or of large scale outflow with a substantial amount of entrained molecular gas.
It supports the hypothesis of enhanced star formation in that region, as indicated by Hackenberg et al. (2000).
As expected, the largest velocity dispersion can be found at the position of the nuclear source.
An upper limit for the dynamical mass confined in the unresolved center can be derived by considering the maximum velocity measured at the center position in the position-velocity diagram of
50 km s-1.
When accounting for an inclination of 30
(resulting in
km s-1) and assuming a maximum radius of below 1.5
,
an upper limit of
can be derived.
In the following the question about possible environmental influence on the global molecular mass content of cluster galaxies is revisited. In Sect. 4.1 we present several indicators of the presence of a molecular gas deficiency in the cluster core. This deficiency is discussed further in the framework of a cirrus model in Sect. 4.4. Section 4.2 comments on a previously introduced CO deficiency parameter and in Sect. 4.3 the morphological composition of the subsamples of Abell 262 is discussed.
The molecular gas mass estimates shown in Fig. 4 indicate a
dependency of the total molecular gas content in Abell 262 galaxies on the projected distance to the cluster core.
The median molecular gas mass of the sample members located in the vicinity of the cluster center was found to be
,
whereas a value of
was determined for the more distant subsample.
The difference in the two median values is
4 times larger than the
median absolute deviations.
So far, data exist only for the brightest FIR galaxies in the cluster.
With the caveat of a small statistical base, such a trend must be restricted to these objects.
For a more general statement, a larger amount of galaxies has to be targeted in upcoming CO observations.
Figure 5 shows that the application of the FIR selection criterion results in the inclusion of galaxies (such as the peculiar galaxy UGC 1655, UGC 1672, or UGC 1437) with outstanding
compared to the bulk of IRAS galaxies in Abell 262.
The strong FIR flux density of UGC 1437, the location within the IRAS color-color diagram (cf. Sect. 4.4), and the fact that it is not HI deficient, together indicate that this galaxy is a more distant object that is projected into the central region.
Other indicators can be found in the
data that support the presence of an environmental influence on the molecular gas content of cluster galaxies.
With the exception of UGC 1437 mentioned above, the
brightest Abell 262 galaxies are found at distances that exceed one Abell radius, whereas the faintest sources detected by IRAS are located close (in projection) to the core of the cluster.
Moreover, the ratio of sources detected by IRAS in the Abell 262 sample of Giovanelli & Haynes drops from
65% within the region of the annulus from 1 to 3 Abell radii to
45% in the central region of the cluster (cf. Fig. 10).
Due to projection effects, the intrinsic fraction of FIR-detected sources in the center (
)
appears to be overestimated.
There
,
where
26) represents all galaxies found within the central Abell radius, including a number of foreground or background galaxies
that are projected along the line of sight into the central region.
This number can be approximated by the product of the surface number density of galaxies of the outer region and the area of the central region:
Aside from the IRAS detection rate, the median
value of detected galaxies in Abell 262 also varies with the projected distance to the cluster core.
While in the region between 2 and 3 Abell radii, the median value amounts to
,
it drops to
(cf. Fig. 5) in the region of the central Abell radius.
Again, the intrinsic value is likely to be lower, since more distant galaxies with higher
values are projected into the core region.
![]() |
Figure 10: The ratio of galaxies detected by IRAS varies with the distance to the cluster core. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Assuming the validity of the M(H
correlation, the drop in the IRAS detection rate and median
value in the center may imply a loss of molecular gas of galaxies in the core region of the cluster.
This tentative result is not expected from previously published studies of molecular gas in galaxy clusters.
However, our results are not necessarily inconsistent with previous investigations.
The existing studies are rather inhomogeneous in terms of selection criteria and focus. Therefore the results are difficult to compare.
A conclusion common to all studies is that the influence of the environment on the molecular gas content of cluster galaxies is minor (in many cases insignificant) and not comparable to the environmental impact on HI abundances.
Kenney & Young (1989) study the CO content of a blue-magnitude limited sample of Virgo galaxies as a function of the HI deficiency of these objects.
Casoli et al. (1991) take a similar approach and analyse the CO content of a FIR-selected sample of 9 HI-deficient Coma galaxies with 9 HI normal Coma galaxies.
Horellou et al. (1995) focus on the fact that FIR or blue-magnitude selected samples are biased towards strong CO emission. They detected 11 of 21 Fornax cluster galaxies in CO emission.
All 3 studies suffer from a very limited number of observations.
In contrast, Boselli et al. (1997) present a study on an optically selected sample of 27 galaxies in the Coma and Abell 1367 clusters and compare their CO content with a sample of 37 relatively isolated galaxies. Their search for a CO deficiency of cluster galaxies as a function of the distance from the cluster center shows a higher dispersion in the central region, thus leaving room for a minor environmental influence on the CO content. With a total of 582 galaxies from their own observations and from the literature, the study of Casoli et al. (1998) is based on the broadest statistical base. Their definition of the CO deficiency is discussed in the following.
![]() |
Figure 11: Star-formation efficiency and CODEF parameter as a function of the distance to the cluster core. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Similar to the definition of the HI deficiency in Giovanelli & Haynes (1985),
Casoli et al. (1998) propose a CO deficiency parameter:
In the way it is defined above, CODEF instead forms a morphology dependent parameter that is similar to the star-formation efficiency
(cf. Fig. 11 and Solomon & Sage 1988, and references therein).
The SFE can be regarded as an indicator of the morphological type of galaxies and, therefore, is likely to be an indirect measure of their overall molecular gas content rather than their deficiency.
The CODEF values for the Abell 262 sample galaxies of known galaxy type are shown in Table 4 and plotted in Fig. 11. A Hubble constant H0=75 km s-1 Mpc-1 was assumed to comply with the Casoli et al. (1998) parameters. Because of the restriction to non-peculiar galaxies, the number of galaxies in our sample for which CODEF can be derived is even smaller than the number of galaxies with measured CO-line intensities. For the remaining galaxies, a dependency of CODEF on the distance to the cluster core cannot be identified.
However, for the
bright subsample and the CO subsample discussed in this paper, such a clear segregation is not visible.
Thirteen of the 36 objects with known FIR flux densities are located in the central Abell radius - 4 late-type and 3 early-type galaxies - whereas 7 late-type and 5 early type galaxies are found in the outer region between 1 and 3 Abell radii.
Of the 12 objects that have been observed in CO emission, 7 are located in the central region. Of these, 2 are early and 3 are late-type galaxies. One SBa and 2 late-type classifications were found for the outer objects.
Neglecting the morphological distribution of the subsamples, therefore, should not result in a misinterpretation of
or CO-line intensity based quantities in terms of environmental influences.
Gas clouds do not consist of atomic gas alone; molecular gas and cold dust are also associated with them. Several authors (e.g. Helou 1986; Rowan-Robinson 1992) have discussed the presence of cold dust in the ISM resulting in multiple-component models of galaxy emission in the IRAS wavelength domain. Besides warmer emission from active star-forming regions and eventually a Seyfert component, a relatively constant disk or cirrus-like component from cold interstellar dust contributes to the IRAS colors of galaxies.
In the course of the HI removal processes, which these cirrus-like clouds in cluster galaxies are subjected to, it is likely that the associated molecular gas and cold dust are also lost.
This is supported by Doyon & Joseph (1989), who convincingly show the existence of dust deficiency in HI deficient galaxies in the core region of Virgo.
By analyzing the FIR properties of the galaxies, they discuss the lack of dust in the context of the HI removal.
Since dust must be associated with molecular gas, there must be a CO deficiency present at a low level as well.
As shown in Sect. 4.1, a FIR deficiency is indeed present
in the set of IRAS detected galaxies in the core of Abell 262.
A total difference of
Jy (Fig. 12) between the median values of the core (
)
and outer galaxies (
)
can be identified.
HI and FIR deficiency, as well as the other indications of a core distance dependency of the molecular gas content in Abell 262 galaxies, suggests the applicability of a model for cirrus-like cloud stripping. This model is introduced in Sect. 4.4.1 and applied to the case of Abell 262 in Sect. 4.4.2. The derived estimates are not inconsistent with the presence of simultaneously occuring CO-deficiency in the core region.
Another indication that supports the stripping hypothesis of cirrus-like clouds can be found in the IRAS color-color diagram (cf. Fig. 13). IRAS colors of normal galaxies are influenced by several factors. While the cirrus-like contribution is fairly constant for all galaxies, the importance of star formation varies and may significantly influence the galaxy's position within the color-color diagram. The presence of varying star-formation components on top of the cirrus-like component creates a distribution of galaxies within the color-color diagram that is non-Gaussian (cf. Helou 1986). Therefore, mean values are not adequate measures for comparing the colors of the cirrus-like components of central and more distant galaxies. Objects with a strong star-formation component should be excluded from the analysis. For the remaining objects, the median value of the core galaxies differs slightly from the value for the more distant galaxies, with the latter closer to that of typical cirrus colors.
Galactic cirrus clouds, which are predominantly found at high galactic latitudes, consist of atomic and molecular gas.
Embedded in the gas is cold dust, which reradiates absorbed energy in the FIR.
For the galactic cirrus in Ursa Major, de Vries et al. (1987) have proposed
a two-component model to explain its infrared emission as a function of the total hydrogen column density, N(H)=N(HI)+2N(H2):
![]() |
Figure 12:
IRAS 100 |
| Open with DEXTER | |
![]() |
Figure 13:
Color-color diagram of Abell 262 galaxies detected in all four IRAS bands. Objects with a projected distance to the cluster core of less than 1 Abell radius are represented by a cross, and objects exceeding this distance are represented by open circles. The dotted symbols represent the respective median values. The ellipse marks the region of cirrus colors (cf. references in Helou 1986). The lowest cross belongs to UGC 1437, which is most likely a distant galaxy that is projected into the center. Therefore it was neglected in the median. In the median value of the more distant galaxies, only the objects with
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
Due to the large IRAS beam,
comprises the source-integrated flux density for each Abell 262 galaxy.
In order to extend the de Vries et al. (1987) model to extragalactic sources, two assumptions are necessary: 1) the 100
m flux density traces N(H) on galactic scales, and 2) the background emission is similar over the whole extension of the cluster.
A difference between representative values of
for the cluster core and for the outer region may be proportional to:
The HI-deficiency HIDEF of galaxies in Abell 262, as defined and determined by Giovanelli & Haynes (1985), amounts to an average value of 0.33 for galaxies in the cluster's core region, with projected distances to the center of less than 1 Abell radius.
For galaxies in the outer region, with distances exceeding 1 Abell radius, the average value for HIDEF is 0.
HIDEF refers to a comparison sample of isolated galaxies (Haynes & Giovanelli 1984), for which the authors claim the average mass of all galaxies to be log (
.
HIDEF and the average mass of a galaxy in the comparison sample can be used to derive an average HI-mass difference between the core and the outer region, and hence a value for
of 0.68
+1.58-0.55 Jy.
The error mainly results from the uncertainties in the average HI mass and the factor a.
The H2 mass estimates given in Sect. 3.1.1 were used to obtain a gross estimate for
of
Jy.
Indeed, the estimates for the two components are in agreement with the
the total difference
Jy found in the IRAS data of Abell 262 galaxies.
Abell 262 is a spiral-rich cluster. Based on the classification given in Table 5, no clear tendency toward morphological segregation can be identified in the samples discussed in this paper (cf. Sect. 4.3). The trend that the galaxies with less luminous CO-line emission and FIR-emission are located towards the center of the cluster (i.e. within the Abell radius) suggests that these objects show a deficiency in molecular gas and dust. Such an effect has not been reported so far. As in the case of the HI-deficiency, a CO-deficiency may be a result of interaction between neighboring galaxies or of interaction with either the central cluster potential or the central cluster gas reservoir.
The model by de Vries et al. (1987), explaining the FIR emission of galactic cirrus clouds, can be generalized to the case of a global cirrus/disc component in galaxies.
One prediction of this model is a drop in the 100
m flux density (
), which indeed is indicated in the existing IRAS data for the cluster.
A small part of the decrease in
can be expected to be caused by a deficiency of molecular gas mass in the cluster, which is traced by
.
The derived contributions to
of
Jy for
the molecular gas mass deficiency and of 0.68
+1.58-0.55 Jy for the atomic gas mass deficiency is consistent with the overall drop in the median 100
m flux density of
1.1 Jy.
It can be expected that a certain amount of molecular gas is associated with the
more diffuse HI material.
This is especially the case for high-latitude cirrus clouds that are also bright in their FIR emission.
The weak indications of a CO- and
-deficiency observed in Abell 262 may, therefore, be a direct consequence of the HI-deficiency found by Giovanelli et al. (1982).
As for UGC 1347, a second bright source south of the nucleus can be identified not only in the visual and NIR but also in the mm wavelength domain.
Both sources are optically thick in their CO line emmission.
The velocity profile is in good agreement with a previously published H
rotation curve.
Within the position-velocity diagram, the southern component deviates from the rotation curve of the disk.
This may indicate an asymmetrically expanding gas shell or a large scale outflow at the position of the southern source, which supports a scenario of enhaced star formation in that region, as was indicated by Hackenberg et al. (2000).
Acknowledgements
This work was supported in part by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) via grant SFB494.