A&A 444, 643-649 (2005)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20053098
D. Pourbaix1,2,
- G. R. Knapp1 - P. Szkody3 - Z. Ivezic3 -
S. J. Kleinman4 -
D. Long4 - S. A. Snedden4 - A. Nitta4 -
M. Harvanek4 - J. Krzesinski4,5 -
H. J. Brewington4 - J. C. Barentine4 -
E. H. Neilsen6 - J. Brinkmann4
1 - Department of Astrophysical Sciences, Princeton University,
Princeton, NJ 08544-1001, USA
2 -
Institut d'Astronomie et d'Astrophysique, Université
Libre de Bruxelles, CP. 226, Boulevard du Triomphe, 1050
Bruxelles, Belgium
3 -
Department of Astronomy, University of Washington, Box 351580,
Seattle, WA 98195, USA
4 -
Apache Point Observatory, PO Box 59, Sunspot, NM 88349, USA
5 -
Mt. Suhora Observatory, Cracow Pedagogical University, ul. Podchorazych 2,
30-084 Cracow, Poland
6 -
Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, PO Box 500, Batavia,
IL 60510, USA
Received 21 March 2005 / Accepted 21 August 2005
Abstract
We have examined the radial velocity data for stars spectroscopically
observed by the
Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) more than once to investigate the
incidence of spectroscopic binaries, and to evaluate the accuracy of the
SDSS stellar radial velocities. We find agreement between the
fraction of stars with significant velocity variations and the
expected fraction of binary stars in the halo and thick disk
populations. The observations produce a list of 675 possible
new spectroscopic binary stars and orbits for eight of them.
Key words: instrumentation: spectrographs - stars: binaries: spectroscopic
This paper is based on an investigation of the radial velocity accuracy obtainable for stars observed in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) which we carried out in support of current and upcoming observations of Galactic stellar kinematics using SDSS spectroscopy (Beers et al. 2004). In the course of this investigation, we were able to identify a large number of confirmed and candidate binary stars. While SDSS data have been used in several recent studies of binary stars, in particular of dwarf M-white dwarf pairs and cataclysmic variables (Szkody et al. 2003b,2005; Smolcic et al. 2004; Szkody et al. 2002,2003a; Pourbaix et al. 2004a; Szkody et al. 2004; Raymond et al. 2003), this represents the first detection of spectroscopic binaries in SDSS. This paper presents both of these results. The SDSS data are described in Sects. 2 and 3, and in Sect. 4 we compare velocities observed at different epochs and examine their precision. Almost all of the stars with repeat observations have been observed only twice, and we analyze the distribution of velocity differences to derive the binary fraction. In a small number of cases (19) there are sufficient observations that a spectroscopic orbit can be derived, but only eight of these orbits prove to be robust. These objects are discussed in Sect. 5, where the full list of possible binary stars is also described.
The Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) is a 5-band photometric survey of
about 10 000 square degrees of the Northern sky to a depth of about
22.5 (r magnitude, point source) and a concurrent
redshift survey of up to a million galaxies and 100 000 quasars
selected from the imaging survey (York et al. 2000). The primary
science goals of the project are to provide the data to investigate the
large scale structure of the Universe and other extragalactic science.
The photometric data are acquired almost simultaneously in five bands,
u, g, r, i, and z, centered at approximate effective wavelengths
of 3551, 4686, 6166, 7480 and 8932 Å (Fukugita et al. 1996) using
a large-format CCD camera (Gunn et al. 1998) mounted on a dedicated
2.5 m telescope at the Apache Point Observatory (APO) in New Mexico.
The imaging data are automatically reduced through a series of software
pipelines which find and measure objects and provide photometric and
astrometric calibrations to produce a catalogue of objects with
calibrated magnitudes, positions and structure information
(Ivezic et al. 2004; Pier et al. 2003; Lupton et al. 2001,2003).
The instrumental fluxes are calibrated via a network of primary and
secondary stellar flux standards to
magnitudes
(Oke & Gunn 1983; Fukugita et al. 1996; Hogg et al. 2001; Smith et al. 2002) which
are accurate to about 1% in g,r, and i, 3% in u and 2% in zfor bright (<20 mag) point sources. The bright magnitude limit
is about 14. Absolute positions are accurate to about 50 mas in each
coordinate (Pier et al. 2003).
Targets for spectroscopy are selected from the imaging data on the basis
of their photometric properties. As well as the primary SDSS targets,
stars in many different locations of color-magnitude space are selected
to serve as spectrophotometric standards and to provide backup
targets in regions of low galaxy density. The target objects are mapped
(Blanton et al. 2003) onto aluminum
diameter fiber plug
plates which feed the spectrographs. The pair of dual fiber-fed
spectrographs (Uomoto et al. 1999) can observe 640 spectra at one
time with a wavelength coverage of 3800-9200 Å and a resolution
of 1800 to 2100. The fibers subtend an aperture of 3
on the sky.
The spectroscopic observations usually consist of three fifteen-minute
exposures per spectroscopic plate.
The data are optimally extracted from the CCD images, flat-fielded and wavelength calibrated using arc spectra and the night-sky lines observed on the plate. A mean sky spectrum is subtracted from each object spectrum, which is then flux-calibrated with respect to the F star calibration spectra. Regions of the spectrum with bad data (for example, in the immediate wavelength vicinity of strong night sky lines) are flagged so that they will not be used in subsequent analysis. The resulting calibrated 1D spectra are fit to a series of templates of galaxies, quasars and stars to derive the spectral classification, redshift and redshift error of each object (D. Schlegel, in preparation).
There are several extensive libraries of stellar spectra, which can be used
as templates for spectral type and radial velocity fitting. Our work
began with the flux-calibrated spectra from the Elodie library (Prugniel & Soubiran 2001; Moultaka et al. 2004). However, since the Elodie spectra do
not have as large wavelength coverage as do the SDSS spectra, they are
not ideal for direct use as templates. The stellar templates were therefore
used as follows. First, the Elodie spectra were matched against the SDSS
spectra and used to extract spectra with a good signal-to-noise ratio (>15 per spectral resolution element), to assign best-fit spectral types and
to correct the SDSS spectrum to a velocity of 0 km s-1 (the Elodie spectral
library has systematic errors less than 1 km s-1). Next, the calibrated
and typed SDSS spectra were used to select representative
spectra of all observed spectral types. These spectra were used
to construct templates by combining individual spectra and defining
the principle components (see Heyer & Schloerb 1997) to produce a set of
templates simulating a wide range of effective temperature, gravity and
metallicity. These templates were then fit to all SDSS spectra directly in
flux density-wavelength space, using
minimization to assign
the most likely spectral type and redshift. For the subset of objects
classified as stars, the assigned spectral type of each star is that
of the best fit stellar template, and the radial velocity is calculated
from the redshift necessary to bring the template spectrum and object
spectrum into optimum alignment in wavelength space.
This process produces both a radial velocity and a radial velocity error for the best fit template, but there is a second source of radial velocity error, that arising from template mismatch. To evaluate this error, each SDSS stellar spectrum is fit to all 900 Elodie spectra and the standard deviation of the radial velocities of the 12 best-fit templates computed. This quantity can sometimes be much larger than the random error if there is significant template mismatch, and it is included in the total radial velocity error.
For the particular application discussed here, the investigation of radial velocity changes for a given star which are larger than the random errors and therefore may be due to binary motion, the errors introduced by template mismatch are less important, since the same template will be fitted to the stellar spectrum for each epoch of observation (except in very rare cases, such as that shown in Fig. 6 below), and indeed this was checked for the multiply-observed stars analyzed in the next sections. Some stars, however, may have no good template available because their lines are broadened by rapid rotation, and the velocity errors will not be well determined. Fortunately, such stars are very seldom found in the SDSS data base.
The SDSS data are described in the data release papers by Abazajian et al. (2005,2004,2003) and documented at the web sites listed therein and at http://www.sdss.org, where the sky coverage of the SDSS observations is also described.
The objects which were both targeted and spectroscopically classified as stars were extracted from the spectroscopic data base using all data obtained up to January 4, 2005. Because the SDSS observes the high-latitude sky and has a bright limit of about 14, most of the stars observed lie in the Galactic halo and thick disk. In particular, the F subdwarfs, sixteen of which are observed for every plate to act as photometric standards, lie in the halo. A small fraction of stars has been observed spectroscopically more than once, either to provide quality checks for the data or occasionally by chance (this is especially true for the spectrophotometric standard stars). The data for stars observed more than once, 10 647 in all, were then identified.
The u-g vs. g-r color-color diagram for these stars is shown in the left panel of Fig. 1. The stars cover essentially the full range of stellar colors observed by SDSS (see Finlator et al. 2000). The large number of stars in the F subdwarf region occurs because of the use of these objects as spectrophotometric standards; they are the only stars for which SDSS observes a representative sample.
![]() |
Figure 1: ( Left panel) Color-color diagram of the 10 647 stars with multiple SDSS spectral observations. The colors are uncorrected for interstellar extinction. ( Right panel) Mean radial velocity uncertainty (km s-1) versus color. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
For a given multiply-observed
star, we have a set of observations of
,
the heliocentric
radial velocity and its uncertainty. The right panel of Fig. 1 shows the mean
versus color for the sample of stars. As expected, the uncertainty of the radial velocities is color-dependent, with large values for u-g<0.5. This occurs because many
of the blue stars are white dwarfs, whose very broad lines preclude the
measurement of the radial velocity to accuracies of 10
,
which are typical for the observations of main sequence stars (see below).
Note also that the 45-min exposure time for the spectroscopic observations
will lead to broadening of the spectral lines of stars with rapidly-varying velocities, and that additional uncertainties can be introduced by
the assumption of a single radial velocity for all spectral lines.
First, we check the quoted accuracies
of the radial velocities
by comparing them with the velocity dispersion
for multiply-observed stars. In most of these cases,
the star has been observed only twice, but 182 stars in the
SDSS "Southern Survey'' - a region of sky
in declination along the celestial equator (J2000) between
right ascensions
to
- have been observed
often enough (six or more times) that a reasonable estimate can be made of the
dispersion
in radial velocity.
The resulting values of
were compared
with
for each star, and the ratio
computed
(upper left panel of Fig. 2). This distribution is expected to
have a tail to high values because of the presence of spectroscopic binaries
in the sample, but if the fraction of binaries is small (see below) the median
value of
will be little affected by their presence (upper right panel of Fig. 2).
We find the median to be 1.5, and it does not depend on the available number of observations for each star - i.e. the same median is found for stars with six or more observations, seven or more, and so on. Thus the data suggest that the fitted velocity uncertainties
may underestimate the true errors
by a factor of about 1.5.
![]() |
Figure 2: ( Upper left panel) Ratio of the standard deviation of the velocity of stars observed six times or more reckoned in mean quoted velocity uncertainty versus color. ( Upper right panel) Distribution of that ratio. ( Lower left panel) Percentage of stars with u-g>0.5 and significant velocity excursions (see text). ( Lower right panel) Color distribution of the 10 674 stars (dashed line) and those with significant velocity excursions (solid line). |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Let us now turn to binary detection. Since the
number of observations of each star is small, we search for radial
velocity variations by determining the maximum excursion of the
observed velocities,
,
and asking if its
value is consistent with the quoted uncertainties.
If
are n values drawn from a
distribution, then
Table 1:
Number of stars (
)
versus the
number of repeated observations (
). f is the
multiplier for the standard deviation
when the maximum excursion of the data is measured (see text) and grows
with
.
The lower left panel of Fig. 2 shows the percentage of stars for
which
as a function of color. The mean percentage
(for
)
is about 15% but it does not seem to be constant
with color. After a steep raise at
,
it decreases at a nearly constant rate up to
.
It is likely that such a decrease is related to the capacity of the method to detect binaries rather than to a genuine feature of the binary distribution. Still, this mean percentage is about 50 times
higher than the rate expected if the radial velocities were constant and
the velocity errors Gaussian. The
quantity
was computed for the entire sample
of 10 647 stars. The fraction of stars for which this quantity is
greater than 3 drops to 6.5%.
Figure 3 shows the histogram of velocity offsets. Almost all of
the data (>90%) are consistent with Gaussian velocity errors.
![]() |
Figure 3:
Distribution of errors for multiply-
observed stars, showing the number of stars versus the normalized
velocity excursion,
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
Table 2:
Stars for which there are enough observations to
potentially derive a spectroscopic orbit. N is the number of observations
and
the mean of the quoted radial velocity
uncertainties (km s-1). The remaining columns list the ugriz magnitudes and
the derived spectral type Sp.
Since we have only a few (mostly only two) observations of each star,
and these are randomly distributed in terms of the orbital
periods, we do not expect to be able to identify every binary
star even for those with velocity amplitudes several times the
SDSS velocity uncertainties. In order to estimate the detection rate,
synthetic observations with same time distribution and uncertainty as the
original observations are generated using
the compilation of orbital elements for 2405 spectroscopic
binary stars from
![]()
(Pourbaix et al. 2004b). Each one
of the 10 647 stars is tested against every single orbit.
The maximum velocity excursions
is derived and so is the
percentage of simulated observations
with
,
where
is defined to be
1.5 times the mean quoted velocity error
.
This simulation shows that only 39% of these synthetic binaries would be
identified by the existing SDSS observations.
The percentage reaches 57% for stars observed six times or more. Combining this result with the 6.5% of
binaries within the
sample of stars observed more than once by SDSS which show detectable velocity
variations, one ends up with 16.7% of stars
in the halo which are spectroscopic binaries, very consistent with the value
of
found by Carney et al. (2003). Owing to the effect of
the rotation on the precision of the radial velocities and, therefore, on the
significance of the largest radial velocity difference, our inferred percentage
of binaries is a lower bound.
![]() |
Figure 4: Plots of the orbits given in Table 3. The dashed line shows the systemic velocity. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Nineteen multiply-observed stars have enough observations
and a large enough velocity excursion with respect to the
errors that an orbit can in principle be found (a minimum of
six observations is required to define an orbit, but these must
be accurately measured and well distributed with phase),
as shown by the simulations described above.
Since
the maximum number of observations per object available from
our observations is thirteen and these are not necessarily
well distributed, a robust orbit
determination is unlikely and the orbits calculated in
this section must be regarded as preliminary. The nineteen objects
are listed in Table 2 along with their SDSS ugrizmagnitudes and the spectral type assigned by the velocity fitting
program. Upon examination of the data,
four of these were discarded: SDSS J030953.46+002747.5, J031505.31+002120.4, J031559.14+002803.2, and J032937.49+000443.7. For example, the orbit
fit to SDSS J030953.46+002747.5 is very eccentric (e = 0.978),
which would make it an outlier in the
diagram
(Pourbaix et al. 2004a), and discarding the most discrepant observation
leaves only five points, too few for an orbital fit.
The situation for the three other stars is essentially the same.
These four stars are among the faintest of the sample.
Even when the most discrepant velocity
is removed, the remaining data still exhibit a significant velocity excursion,
supporting their identification as binary stars.
For seven other stars, either the amplitude or the period is poorly
constrained, and these preliminary solutions are not included.
The orbits for the remaining eight stars are reasonably robust and
are given in Fig. 4 and Table 3.
This table lists the name of the object, its systemic velocity V0,
the eccentricity e, the argument of the periastron
,
the projected radial velocity amplitude K,
the period P, and one epoch of periastron passage T0. Also
listed are the projected semi-major axis of the absolute orbit of the
primary
,
the mass function f(M) (Binnendijk 1960),
the value of
and the goodness of fit F2 (Kovalevsky & Seidelmann 2004)
SDSS J031404.97-011136.6 has the largest signal to noise ratio of the
sample and also exhibits the largest mass function f(M).
The colors, r-i=1.32 and i-z=0.78, correspond to an M3 star
(Hawley et al. 2002) and the fits to all 7 spectra also yield M3.
Examination of the spectra (one of which is shown in Fig. 5)
shows that this is a dM/WD pair, consistent with the white
dwarf being the more massive of the pair. However, the mass
function,
solar masses is about
different from typical values found for these objects.
Table 3:
Orbital elements and their uncertainty.
V0 and K are in km s-1,
in degrees, P in days,
epoch T0 is in days + 2 400 000,
in 106 km and f(M) in solar masses.
![]() |
Figure 5:
Spectrum of SDSS J031404.97-011136.6.
This star is an example of a white dwarf-M dwarf pair, as shown by the
blue continuum (well in excess of that expected from a dM3 star) and
the strong H |
| Open with DEXTER | |
![]() |
Figure 6:
Spectra of the CV SDSS J090628.25+052656.9
labelled by MJD (-2 400 000) of observation. The system is observed
in both its low and high states. In the high state, rotationally
broadened Balmer absorption lines are seen, and H |
| Open with DEXTER | |
In all, we found 675 stars with velocity excursions large enough that they are likely to be spectroscopic binaries. This list is given in Table 4 (available only in electronic form at CDS). It includes 13 M dwarf-white dwarf (dM/WD) pairs and 7 cataclysmic variables (CVs), easily identified by eye examination of the spectra. These latter are described by Szkody et al. (2003b,2005,2003a,2002,2004), but one observation of note is not included in those papers. The second observed spectrum of SDSS J090628.25+052656.9, on MJD 2 452 674, is presented by Szkody et al. (2005) and shows both red and blue stellar components and hydrogen Balmer line emission. A spectrum obtained a month earlier, however (MJD 2 452 649) catches the star in its high state. These spectra are shown in Fig. 6 and are available at the SDSS web site (they can be located using the information in Table 4). Szkody et al. (2005) note that this star is a likely dwarf nova, and the outburst spectrum shown in Fig. 6 lends support to this classification. Further, the four observations of this object (Fig. 6 and Szkody et al. 2005) find it in outburst twice - thus the outbursts likely repeat on a fairly short timescale.
Finally, none of the 35 carbon stars with multiple observations shows significant radial velocity deviations.
We examine some 10 000 stars for which multiple SDSS spectra have been obtained. The dispersion of the measured velocities is found to be about 1.5 times the quoted uncertainty of the radial velocity fits for stars of all observed colors (spectral types) and magnitudes. A group of objects with large velocity excursions is identified and the percentage of such stars (6%) shown to be consistent with the expected fraction of binary stars.
We identify 675 possible new binary stars. Most of these, like most of the observed stars, are F subdwarfs, but the list includes 13 dM/WD pairs and 7 CVs. One of these, SDSS J090628.25+052656.9, is observed in both its low and high states. The identification of these 675 stars as binaries is very preliminary, being based on a very small number of observations. The number of false positive identifications is estimated to be about 40 from simulations. However, since these stars will not be further observed by SDSS, they are presented here as candidates for possible future study.
Eight of the stars have enough observations (6-13) and show
large enough velocity excursions with respect to the
uncertainties that the fitted orbit is reasonably robust.
These orbits and the corresponding radial velocities are available on
.
Acknowledgements
We thank the referee for many helpful comments which significantly improved the paper. Partial support for the computer systems required to process and store the data was provided by NASA via grant NAG5-6734 and by Princeton University. D.P. thanks the American Astronomical Society for the award of a Chrétien International Research Grant. We also thank Princeton University for generous support. This research made use of the IDL Astronomy User's Library at Goddard.
Funding for the creation and distribution of the SDSS Archive has been provided by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation, the Participating Institutions, the National Aeronautics and Space Administration, the National Science Foundation, the US Department of Energy, the Japanese Monbukagakusho, and the Max Planck Society. The SDSS Web site is http://www.sdss.org/. The SDSS is managed by the Astrophysical Research Consortium (ARC) for the Participating Institutions. The Participating Institutions are The University of Chicago, Fermilab, the Institute for Advanced Study, the Japan Participation Group, The Johns Hopkins University, the Korean Scientist Group, Los Alamos National Laboratory, the Max-Planck-Institute for Astronomy (MPIA), the Max-Planck-Institute for Astrophysics (MPA), New Mexico State University, University of Pittsburgh, University of Portsmouth, Princeton University, the United States Naval Observatory, and the University of Washington.