A&A 416, 411-422 (2004)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20031713
A. Z. Dolginov 1 - I. N. Toptygin 2
1 - 125, B-2, Hillcrest Vil.E., Schenectady, NY, 12309, USA
2 -
St. Petersburg State Polytechnical University
195251, St. Petersburg, Russia
Received 4 March 2003 / Accepted 20 November 2003
Abstract
In this paper we propose a new mechanism for the
generation of a large-scale galactic magnetic field by the
electric current created by cosmic rays. A model with the sources
of relativistic particles, distributed homogenously and continuously in the galactic disk
is used, and intensities of the sources correspond to the observed
intensities. The anisotropic diffusion of cosmic rays in the
galaxy is considered and it is shown that the created magnetic
field depends strongly on the symmetry of the diffusion tensor as
well as on the relationship between the tensor's components. The
helicity of turbulence (
-effect) is not considered. Only
the small-scale "seed'' fields ejected from stars and generated by
cosmic rays are necessary to start the global magnetic field
generation. The diffusion of the field because of turbulent
motions and the differential rotation of the galactic disk are
taken into account. The diffusion coefficient values estimated
from the observed parameters of the galactic medium are used in
the calculations. The obtained magnetic field is approximately a
few micro-gauss which is of the same order of magnitude as the
observed galactic field. Therefore, it is concluded that the
relativistic particles are significant and, possibly, essential
for the process of the large-scale galactic magnetic field
generation. More precise determinations of the diffusion
coefficients for the field and the particles are needed to reach
the final conclusion about the field's value. The future
development of the theory should also include dynamo action, the
nonlinear effects, and the self-consistent approach to the
problem.
Key words: ISM: cosmic rays - diffusion - Galaxy: kinematics and dynamics - ISM: magnetic field
Observations show that galaxies have both irregular small-scale and regular large-scale magnetic fields, as discussed, for example, in the book of Rusmaikin et al. (1988), in reviews of Beck et al. (1996); and in Beck (2001). These observations are usually explained by the dynamo theory (see Beck et al. 1996). A review of theoretical methods is contained in Parker's (1979) book. The observed regular field has a predominantly toroidal structure. In some spiral galaxies this field has a symmetrical structure, while in others it is bisymmetrical. The differential rotation of the galactic disk can transform the poloidal component of the field to a toroidal one. The data on the poloidal field is not very accurate since it is difficult to observe the field component which is perpendicular to the galactic plane. The data on the plasma turbulent velocities in the galaxy, which determine the dynamo action, is also not very precise. Some reasonable assumptions (Rusmaikin et al. 1988; Beck et al. 1996) were used to compensate for the incompleteness of observational data, however, these assumptions make it impossible for the theory to be fully confirmed by observational data. The existing theory meets some other challenges. The nonlinear effects may stop the large-scale field generation by the dynamo process (Grusinov & Diamond 1994, 1996). The small-scale dynamo field increases much faster than the large-scale one and this small-scale field may kill the turbulence that is necessary to create the large-scale field (see: Vainstein & Rossener 1991; Vainstein & Cattaneo 1992; Kulsrud & Anderson 1992). A large-scale regular field was observed in the Magellan Clouds (Chi & Wolfendale 1993), which are irregular galaxies; however, no noticeable differential rotation needed for dynamo action was observed there.
The difficulties of the existing theories led us to consider field generation processes which are different from a dynamo. In this paper it will be shown that the electric current created by cosmic rays can generate a significant large-scale magnetic field.
The power, composition, and energy spectrum of cosmic rays have
been thoroughly investigated by many authors. Most of the
relativistic particles in the galaxy are protons, which have an
energy value on the order of 1 GeV. The acceleration process is
located mainly in the galactic disk (e.g. in supernova remnants,
strong stellar winds, etc.). The cosmic rays diffuse enormous
distances to the galaxy boundaries and leave the stellar system in
(1-
years. The total energy power of
relativistic particle production in the galaxy is estimated to be
-
erg s-1
(Berezinsky et al. 1990). The total power of relativistic particle
production is on the order of
particles per
second.
Energetic particles spread over the galaxy and interact with the background plasma. They create an effective electric current, which can act as a source of a large-scale magnetic field. The value of the galactic magnetic field will be calculated and compared with observational data.
While the resonance generation of plasma waves and small-scale magnetic fields of the scale of the Larmor radius of the relativistic particles has been thoroughly investigated by many authors (see, for example, Völk & McKenzie 1982), large-scale field generation in the process of cosmic rays propagation has never been considered. We will consider the contribution of cosmic rays separately from other possible effects, such as dynamo action, which may also be important for the generation of the galactic magnetic field. In a more general theory all these effects would have to be considered.
The interstellar medium contains two kinds of plasma: the thermal
electron-ion plasma and the plasma of cosmic rays. The
hydrodynamical pressure of the cosmic rays is in equipartition
with the pressure of the interstellar thermal plasma. Protons and
helium ions are the main component of the relativistic particles
in the galaxy (Berezinskii et al. 1990). The number density
of helium ions and other heavy ions is much less than that of the
protons. The contribution of relativistic electrons is no more
than 1% of the total number of relativistic particles. The number
of relativistic particles decreases with the energy E as E-2.7. This allows the use of a simple model of the galactic
plasma consisting of relativistic protons, with average energy E
= 1 GeV, and number density
N = 10-9 cm-3, and
particles of interstellar thermal plasma with proton and electron
number densities
.
The real distribution of the discrete
cosmic ray sources in the galaxy is not well known. A stationary
model with parameters averaged over the volume of the galactic
disk will be used. The disk is described by its half-thickness hin the z direction and by the effective radius R. The
distribution of the cosmic-ray sources in the disk is assumed to
have azimuthal symmetry. Such distribution in the cylindrical
coordinate system is in the form
![]() |
(1) |
![]() |
(3) |
The magnetic field is frozen in the plasma component whose conductivity is larger. In particular, the magnetic field in the galaxy is frozen in the thermal plasma. Thermal electrons and ions cannot diffuse separately (this effect is known as ambipolar diffusion) and the average current is zero if there are no sources of particles in the plasma. The cosmic rays have sources in the galaxy and they leave the galaxy after some time of travelling.
Relativistic and thermal particles move in the galaxy by
anisotropic diffusion. The diffusion coefficients
of relativistic protons and
of thermal protons and electrons are dependent on the regular
magnetic field, the small-scale random magnetic field, the
turbulent motion of background plasma, and on the collisions with
neutral and charged particles. The regular motions, such as
galactic wind,are not included in the model, however, the
differential rotation of the disk is taken into account.
The diffusion rate of electrons and thermal protons is smaller
than that of cosmic ray ions. This difference leads to the
separation of charged particles and, hence, to the creation of the
electric field. In this paper it will be shown that an average
electric current generated by cosmic ray protons in the galaxy is
not compensated for by the electrons and that this current can
create a significant large-scale magnetic field. The energy losses
of cosmic ray ions with energy above 100 MeV can be ignored.
Cosmic ray protons leave the galaxy easily. Magnetic
inhomogeneities with sizes on the order of the Larmor radius of
the particle are the most effective for scattering. This radius is
large for cosmic ray particles. Unfortunately, the small-scale
magnetic field distribution is not well known. The different
scales of magnetic fluctuations are responsible for scattering
electrons and ions and are an additional cause for the differences
in diffusion of ions and electrons. Proton and electron currents
can be presented in the form
![]() |
(4) |
![]() |
(5) |
![]() |
(6) |
| (7) |
![]() |
(8) |
![]() |
(9) |
![]() |
(10) |
Obtaining the
and
values from Eqs. (4) through (10), the magnetic field created by the total
macroscopic current
in the turbulent
galactic medium can be calculated. The turbulence plays a
significant role in the problem because it determines the
dissipation of the field and the diffusion of the particles.
The local magnetic field (not averaged over the turbulent motion)
satisfies the equation
![]() |
(11) |
![]() |
(12) |
![]() |
(13) |
![]() |
(14) |
![]() |
(15) |
![]() |
(16) |
To estimate the term being averaged, we use the scalar
instead of the tensor
and
disregard the correlations of
with
and with
.
In this
case
![]() |
(17) |
![]() |
(18) |
In the absence of regular motions and in the static case
we obtain
![]() |
(19) |
Equations (6)-(10) are solved under the assumption that the
galactic disk is homogeneous, i.e., that the components of the
tensors of diffusion and conductivity are independent of the
coordinates inside the disk. The simplest way to get the solution
of Eqs. (6)-(10) is the method of Fourier transformation. Using
the three-dimensional integral Fourier expansion and Eq. (10) we
obtain
,
i.e.
![]() |
(21) |
Thus, a magnetic field in a homogeneous system can be generated by a current created in the diffusion process of energetic particles only if the medium has anisotropic properties. This assertion is valid irrespective of the distribution of the sources. This result can be easily understood from qualitative considerations. In the case of isotropic diffusion, any small source of relativistic particles will produce a spherically symmetrical current that does not generate any magnetic field. Therefore, the field strength is very sensitive to the symmetry of the diffusion tensors and to the relationship between their components.
It should be noted, however, that in an inhomogeneous system,
which the galaxy and, in particular, the galactic disk actually
are, the curl of the current can be nonzero if the diffusion
coefficients depend on the coordinates. In this case instead of
Eq. (4) we have
In this paper only the effect of anisotropic propagation of cosmic rays in a homogeneous medium is considered. The calculations of electric current and magnetic field in the inhomogeneous medium is a separate and more complicated problem, which is out of the scope of this paper.
The relativistic protons have the longest
free path in the galaxy. In this case the efficient diffusion
coefficient
cm2 s-1 (Beresinsky
et al. 1990).
The local tensor of diffusion in the
galaxy is strongly anisotropic:
,
where the
indices
and
determine the directions
perpendicular and parallel to the large-scale field respectively.
Magnetic field fluctuations are of the same order of magnitude as
the average field,
.
It makes the average
diffusion tensor much more isotropic. In this case
is of the same order of magnitude as
,
but not
equal to it. This problem was considered in detail by Bykov &
Toptygin (1992) and equations for
and
were obtained. These authors used a
renormalization method to calculate the average diffusion tensor
for strong turbulence. This method leads to a system of
transcendental equations for the components of the diffusion
tensor:
The turbulent transfer is insignificant for relativistic protons
in galaxy. We assume u'=0 and consider a static random velocity
field with a single correlation scale:
The observed galactic large-scale magnetic field has spiral field
lines in the plane of the disk (Rusmaikin et al. 1988). The data
about the field perpendicular to the disk are not well known
because this component is much weaker than the field in the plane
of the disk. We will consider all six components of the symmetric
tensors
and
,
including the cross
components such as
.
These components are very important. It follows from the
well known anti-dynamo theorems (Elsasser 1946; Zeldovich 1956)
that the asymmetry of the system is necessary for the magnetic
field generation. In our case the symmetry of the diffusion tensor
has to be different from the cylindrical symmetry of the accepted
model of the galaxy. The components of the diffusion tensor can be
presented in the form
![]() |
(37) |
The magnetic field value also depends on the viscosities
and
.
The
can be estimated using
the formula
,
where
pc for the most important component of the interstellar turbulence
and
cm s-1. It gives
cm2 s-1. The viscosity
is different in the
different regions of the galaxy. There are clouds of neutral
hydrogen, warm areas with ionized hydrogen
cm-3), and hot regions
cm-3) created by supernova remnants. Hot regions
occupy a significant part of the disk's volume. The magnetic field
dissipation is predominantly due to the ambipolar diffusion of
electrons and ions through the neutral gas in the "cold'' dense
non-ionized hydrogen clouds and in the "warm'' regions where the
percentage of the non-ionized atoms is high. The ambipolar
diffusion in these regions is determined by:
cm2 s-1 and
cm2 s-1 respectively (Rusmaikin
et al. 1988). The collisionless damping of plasma waves in
the hot regions gives
cm2 s-1. The
value averaged over the disk of the galaxy is
cm2 s-1 and
![]() |
(38) |
The magnetic field can be calculated using Eq. (18), in which we
should set
,
where
is the angular velocity of the differential rotation
of the disk. The equations for the field components are
We do not assume that the global large-scale magnetic field exists during the initial period of the disk's existence. However, the majority of the active stars, forming in the disk, have internal magnetic fields. We do not claim to explain the origin of the magnetic field in stars.
Magnetic fields are ejected from stars by plasma streams, such as stellar winds, and by supernova explosions. The plasma streams produce local fields in the environments of stars and create inhomogeneities in the interstellar medium. The acceleration takes place near shock fronts in the presence of the local magnetic fields. The generation of small-scale fields by accelerated particles (Völk & McKenzie 1982; Lucek & Bell 2000; Bell & Lucek 2001) intensifies the acceleration process.
The acceleration time at the shock front may be estimated as
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
(50) |
| |
= | ||
| (51) |
| |
= | ||
| (52) |
| |
= | ||
| (53) |
![]() |
(54) |
| |
= | ||
| (55) |
The integration of Eqs. (39)-(41) is very complicated, but we can use
reasonable approximations, such as the fact that expression (55)
is positive for all
values,which becomes obvious in the
coordinate system where the tensor
is diagonal.
In this case
.
The relative change
of
is small in the interval
.
This makes it possible to use the
value averaged over the angle
,
i.e.
![]() |
(56) |
![]() |
(57) |
| Br(r,z) | = | ![]() |
|
![]() |
(58) |
| |
= | ![]() |
|
![]() |
(59) |
| Bz(r,z) | = | ![]() |
|
![]() |
(60) |
![]() |
(61) |
Consider now the field value in the vicinity of the solar system (r=10 kpc, R=16 kpc,
kpc,
Q0=1043 particle/s, the ratio of
magnetic viscosities is given by Eq. (38)).
Under the assumptions above, the dimensional factor B0(r) has
the value
![]() |
(62) |
![]() |
(63) |
![]() |
![]() |
(64) |
The differential rotation of the disk stretches the Br component of the
poloidal field in the direction of the linear velocity of the
medium and transforms it into the toroidal field
.
This component can be calculated using Eq. (40)
where we
have to put
:
![]() |
(65) |
Our galaxy is relatively young (about 1010 years old) and
there were not too many revolutions of the disk. This makes it
possible to solve Eq. (65) by the method of subsequent
approximations. In the first approximation we can disregard the
dissipation, keeping in mind that the dissipation has no time to
evolve. The remaining equation has the solution
![]() |
(66) |
The consideration of the energy balance is additional evidence in
favor of the proposed model of field generation. The time required
for the magnetic field and turbulence regeneration by the energy
input from supernova explosions is about 107 years. This time
is enough for the supernova remnants to fill the volume of the
disk (one explosion per 30 years or a little less frequently) and
for the magnetic field to become turbulent. This time is also
enough to create cosmic rays with a total energy on the order of
erg s
s
erg. The energy required to restore the regular magnetic field is
erg, if the disk volume is
cm3. This means that the energy of
cosmic rays is sufficient to support the observed magnitude of the
galactic large-scale magnetic field.
The considered process of toroidal field amplification does
not lead to an additional dissipation of the field. Equation (65)
has a stationary solution for
.
This solution can be
presented in the form
![]() |
(67) |
![]() |
(68) |
![]() |
(69) |
The proposed model for the large-scale galactic magnetic field generation is a good example of self-organization in a strong non-equilibrium interstellar plasma. Discrete sources in the disk, such as exploding stars, produce relativistic particles which perturb the ambient plasma and create the electric current. The nonsymmetric electric current generates a magnetic field with a space scale much larger than the scale of regions occupied by the sources of the current. The large-scale field changes the kinetic coefficients of the ambient plasma, introducing anisotropy into the system and supporting, in this way, the anisotropy which is necessary for the field generation. The anisotropy of the distribution of the electric current is connected not only with the small-scale magnetic field structure but also with the geometry of the galaxy that leads to maximum leaking of the relativistic particles perpendicular to the plane of the disk. The process considered does not need an initial large-scale "seed'' field to start the field generation. The existence of small-scale magnetic fields ejected from stars is sufficient to start the process of particle acceleration up to relativistic energies. Then, the cosmic ray propagation in the galaxy creates an electric current and corresponding large-scale magnetic field.
The simple model considered in this paper shows that the processes
of generation and propagation of relativistic particles (cosmic
rays), together with the differential rotation of the disk, are
sufficient to explain the structure and value of the observed
large-scale magnetic field in the galaxy avoiding the
dynamo process. The proposed mechanism can
generate a magnetic field also in galaxies where exploded
stars are present but differential rotation and turbulence
helicity are insignificant.
The next step in the development of this theory should include a more realistic model of the galaxy, a more precise definition of diffusion coefficients for the magnetic field and particles and finally, the solution of the self-consistent problem. The magnetic field generated by cosmic rays, gyrotropic turbulence, and differential rotation should be calculated together with the coefficients of diffusion of the field and of the particles.
Acknowledgements
The authors are thankful to B. V. Kuteev, V. A. Rozhansky and L. D. Tsendin for the discussion of the plasma aspects of the theory. The paper was performed with the partial support of the Russian Foundation of Basic Research (grant 01-02-16654).