A&A 406, 975-980 (2003)
D. Kocer 1 - S. J. Adelman2,3 - H. Caliskan4 - A. F. Gulliver 3,5 - H. Gokmen Tektunali 4
1 - Department of Mathematics and Computer Science, Faculty of Science & Letters, stanbul Kültür University, E5 Karayolu Üzeri, 34510, Sirinevler, stanbul, Turkey
2 - Department of Physics, The Citadel, 171 Moultrie Street, Charleston, SC 29409, USA
3 - Guest Investigator, Dominion Astrophysical Observatory, Herzberg Institute of Astrophysics, National Research Council of Canada, 5071 W. Saanich Road, Victoria, BC, V9E 2E7 Canada
4 - Department of Astronomy and Space Sciences, stanbul University, 34452 University, stanbul, Turkey
5 - Department of Physics, Brandon University, Brandon, MB R7A 6A9 Canada
Received 31 March 2003 / Accepted 24 April 2003
The superficially normal stars And (A2 V), Del (B6 III), Aqr (A1.5 V), and And (B9 V), which have rotationally broadened line profiles, are analyzed in a manner consistent with previous studies of this series using 2.4 Å mm-1 spectrograms obtained with CCD detectors and . Their variable radial velocities strongly suggest they are spectroscopic binaries. As no evidence is seen for lines of their companions they are analyzed as single stars. Their derived abundances are generally near solar. But those for And suggest that it is possibly a fast rotating Am star.
Key words: stars: abundances - stars: individual: And - stars: individual: Del - stars: individual: Aqr - stars: individual: And
Although most stars studied in this series of papers are quite sharp-lined, some showed definite rotation (e.g., Merak, Adelman 1996; UMa and 29 Cyg, Adelman 1999). With high signal-to-noise spectrograms ( ) obtained with Reticon and CCD detectors, one can study such stars and still obtain quite decent derived abundances especially when km s-1. This permits some investigation of whether the sharpest-lined normal stars have abundances which are typical for their spectral type.
Our intent is to see how the technique of fine analysis works for two stars, whose values, we believe are near the upper limit for this technique, compared with spectral synthesis. We also contribute additional data concerning two stars apparently rotating at about half of this value and obtain initial values for future synthetic spectral analyses. Some atomic species which cannot be studied by fine analyses might be by synthesizing the spectrum. We recognize from the outset that we can use only those lines with at most minimal blending.
The stars And (24 And, HD 1280, HR 63), spectral type A2 IV (Abt & Morrell 1995), Aqr (2 Aqr, HD 198001, HR 7950), spectral type A1.5 V (Abt & Morrell 1995), and And (17 And, HD 222173, HR 8965), spectral type B9 V (Abt et al. 2002) are among the least variable stars in photometry from the Hipparcos satellite (Adelman 2001). Del (2 Del, HD 195810, HR 7852) is spectral type B6 III (Abt et al. 2002). Aqr has been used as a secondary spectrophotometric standard (see, e.g., Taylor 1984). Hill (1995) derived abundances from both And and Aqr, which have rotational velocities near 100 km s-1, using spectral synthesis techniques. Both Del and And have smaller values and hence are much more amenable to study. Glushneva et al. (1992) proposed And as a secondary spectrophotometric standard and Napiwotzki et al. (1993) derived K, .
For all four stars we obtained Dominion Astrophysical Observatory (DAO) 2.4 Å mm-1 SITe-2 or SITe-4 CCD spectrograms with a typical signal-to-noise ratio of 200 and a wavelength coverage of 63 or 144 Å, respectively. The two pixel resolution is 0.072 Å which at 4500 corresponds to a resolving power of 62 500 or 4.8 km s-1. The observations were started with the SITe-2 CCD with the intent of obtaining exposures with central wavelengths between 3830 and 4740 with 55 Å offsets. Later when the longer SITe-4 CCD became available, the program was changed to exposures with central wavelengths between 3898 and 4864 with 138 Å offsets. For all four stars, we obtained at least the originally planned coverage. Further 20 Å mm-1 DAO spectrograms containing the H region were acquired for And and Aqr. We extracted the H profiles for Del and And from SITe4 spectra centered at 4864. To flat field the exposures we used exposures of an incandescent lamp in the Coudé mirror train, which was viewed through a filter to eliminate first order light. A central stop removed light from the beam in the same manner as the secondary mirror of the telescope. We rectified the exposures with the interactive computer graphics program REDUCE (Hill et al. 1982) and applied a 3.5% correction for scattered light in the dispersion direction (Gulliver et al. 1996) for many of the SITe-2 spectrograms. The scattered light for the remaining SITe-2 and for all SITe-4 spectrograms was removed during the extraction procedure using the program CCDSPEC (Gulliver & Hill 2002).
We fit rotational profiles through the metal lines of all four stars. Rotational velocity estimates from clearly single, medium-strength lines near 4481 are 93 km s-1 for And, 54 km s-1 for Del, 110 km s-1 for Aqr, and 60 km s-1 for And. Often the He I lines showed Gaussian or Lorentzian profiles. The lines of And with equivalent widths 30 mÅ usually showed Gaussian profiles and were so fit. In measuring the spectrum with VLINE (Hill et al. 1982) the fixed parameter feature was applied, particularly to the line widths, as needed to better fit close blends. In any star with moderate rotation one has to be selective in choosing lines to be analyzed due to a substantial amount of line blending. Measuring And was more difficult than Aqr despite its slightly greater rotational velocity.
In comparison Hill (1995) finds km s-1 and 108 km s-1for And and Aqr, respectively. Abt & Morrell (1995) quote km s-1 for both And and Aqr. Abt et al. (2002) find 70 and 50 km s-1, respectively, for And and Del.
The stellar lines were identified with the general references A Multiplet Table of Astrophysical Interest (Moore 1945) and Wavelengths and Transition Probabilities for Atoms and Atomic Ions, Part 1 (Reader & Corliss 1980) as well as Huldt et al. (1982) for Ti II, Iglesias & Velasco (1964) for Mn II, Nave et al. (1994) for Fe I, and Johansson (1978) for Fe II. Lines of Mg I, Mg II, Al I, Si II, Ca I, Ca II, Ti II, Cr I, Cr II, Mn II, Fe I, Fe II, Ni I, Ni II, Sr II, Y II, Zr II, and Ba II were sufficiently unblended for abundances to be derived in the observed spectrum of And. For Del we found lines of He I, C II, N II, O I, Mg II, Al II, Si II, Si III, S II, Ca II, Ti II, Cr II, Fe II, Ni II, and Sr II. While for Aqr, we used lines of C I, Mg II, Al I, Si II, Ca I, Ca II, Ti II, V II, Cr I, Cr II, Fe I, Fe II, Ni II, Sr II, Zr II, and Ba II. The And spectra provided lines of He I, C II, O I, Mg II, Al II, Si II, S II, Ca II, Ti II, Cr II, Fe II, and Ni II for analysis.
The radial velocities (Table 1) were found from comparisons of the stellar and laboratory wavelengths after corrections were applied for the Earth's orbital velocity. All four stars apparently have variable radial velocities. Although often these values depend on measuring only a few lines, in general when listed in JD order the differences between values obtained on adjacent nights are small. A few values may be discrepant. As there was no evidence for the lines of the secondaries, we analyze these stars as if they are single.
Abt & Biggs (1972) show values for the radial velocity of And between -4.7 and +6.2 km s-1. Duflot et al. (1995) give 0.9 km s-1 based on 36 values. Those from 6 SITe-4 DAO spectrograms average 2 5 km s-1 and those from 5 SITe-2 DAO spectrograms km s-1. The uncertainty in the individual spectrum measurements averages 1.0 km s-1. Those based on SITe-4 spectrograms contain about 2.3 times the number of lines as those based on SITe-2 spectrograms. Although this star has a difficult spectrum to measure, these values suggest possible variability.
The mean radial velocity from 20 spectrograms of Del was km s-1 which is suggestive of variability. We did not include a radial velocity based on only one line. The uncertainty in the individual spectrum measurements averages 1.4 km s-1. Abt & Biggs (1972) list values between -17.2 and -29.3 km s-1 while Duflot et al. (1995) give -19.3 km s-1.
From 8 SITe-4 spectrograms, we derived a mean radial velocity of km s-1 for Aqr. The uncertainty in the individual spectrum measurements averages 1.9 km s-1. Abt & Biggs (1972) list values between -15 and -20 km s-1 while Duflot et al. (1995) give -16 km s-1 based on 21 values and Grenier et al. (1999) -15.5 km s-1 while Hill (1995) finds -8.6 km s-1. One of our values agrees with Hill's while the others with those of other studies. This suggests Aqr is a radial velocity variable.
From 17 spectrograms, we found a mean radial velocity of km s-1 for And with the uncertainities in the individual values of order 1 km s-1. Abt & Biggs (1972) give values betwen 0 and -30 km s-1 while Duflot et al. (1995) give -0.5 km s-1.
Two possible ways to detect the presence of a companion would be to look for
strong lines in the red and examine high quality optical spectrophotometry.
Either would permit estimates of the effects of the companions on our analyses,
which we anticipate will be small.
|(Å)||Julian Date||(km s-1)|
|And||4740||2 450 752.822||-18*|
|3970||2 451 028.001||-3*|
|3915||2 451 471.812||-5*|
|3860||2 451 472.705||-2*|
|4685||2 451 478.965||3*|
|4036||2 451 740.990||-4|
|4450||2 451 741.983||7|
|4864||2 451 742.942||9|
|4174||2 451 746.910||6|
|4312||2 451 747.957||2|
|4588||2 452 210.783||-4|
|Del||4520||2 450 302.887||-21*|
|4465||2 450 305.014||-24*|
|4410||2 450 306.014||-26*|
|4080||2 450 307.011||-25*|
|4135||2 450 308.012||-25*|
|3915||2 450 309.119||-27*|
|3860||2 450 309.836||-21*|
|5070||2 450 592.986||-24*|
|5015||2 450 649.989||-24*|
|4740||2 450 652.987||-35*|
|3970||2 450 653.998||-23*|
|4025||2 450 654.991||-22*|
|4190||2 450 656.002||-20*|
|4300||2 450 657.001||-22*|
|4355||2 450 658.003||-32*|
|4575||2 450 658.996||-23*|
|4630||2 450 661.009||-18*|
|4245||2 450 696.023||-30*|
|6600||2 451 744.832||-22|
|4864||2 451 774.000||-21|
|Aqr||4864||2 451 742.882||-17|
|4036||2 451 740.958||-18|
|4450||2 451 741.864||-17|
|4174||2 451 746.858||-15|
|4726||2 451 749.892||-19|
|3898||2 451 778.928||-20|
|4588||2 452 090.050||-7|
|4312||2 452 103.875||-20|
|And||3970||2 450 653.998||-7:*|
|4575||2 450 658.996||-4*|
|4630||2 450 661.009||-2*|
|4080||2 450 753.741||3*|
|4245||2 451 404.916||-9*|
|4355||2 451 407.834||4*|
|4300||2 451 408.024||-1*|
|4025||2 451 413.813||7*|
|4410||2 451 442.840||-1*|
|5015||2 451 470.778||15*|
|4740||2 451 477.709||13*|
|4685||2 451 478.965||8*|
|4465||2 451 480.898||7*|
|4520||2 451 483.677||7*|
|4174||2 451 739.984||4|
|4864||2 451 742.923||5|
|3898||2 452 167.971||13|
Table 2 lists our effective temperature and surface gravity estimates with the last values for each star being those adopted. We began with the calibration algorithm of Napiwotzki et al. (1993) and the homogeneous data of Hauck & Mermilliod (1998). The uncertainties are about 150 K and 0.2 dex (Lemke 1989). To refine these values we calculated synthetic spectra of the H regions from ATLAS9 LTE plane parallel model atmospheres (Kurucz 1993) with Program SYNTHE (Kurucz & Avrett 1981) as well as the predicted fluxes with ATLAS9 for comparison with the observations which are from Adelman et al. (1980) for And and Schild et al. (1971) as recalibrated by Breger (1976) with the Hayes & Latham (1975) calibration of Vega for Aqr. As the resulting model for the latter star did not yield equal mean abundances from Fe I and Fe II lines, we accepted a good, but a slightly less perfect fit to the spectrophotometry and H profile resulting in derived mean abundances from Fe I and Fe II lines which were close to agreement.
For Del, which lacks published spectrophotometry, we corrected the effective temperature as did Adelman et al. (2002). To check the surface gravity value we compared the observed H profile with that calculated using an ATLAS9 model with the corrected photometric values and found that they were in good agreement.
For And we used spectrophometry from Wolff et al. (1968) as recalibrated by Breger (1976) with the Hayes & Latham (1975) calibration of Vega. The adopted effective temperature is about 250 K less than the photometric value.
Hill (1995) finds by comparison
And these values differ from ours
by 40 K and 0.05 dex, but for
Aqr these differences are 420 K and -0.11 dex. Thus, the derived abundances values
between these studies should be somewhat discrepant for this
reason alone for the latter star.
|And||8968||3.87||Napiwotzki et al. (1993) with photometry|
|9000||4.00||Spectrophotometry and H profile fitting, solar model|
|Del||13755||3.65||Napiwotzki et al. (1993) with photometry|
|13679||3.65||same with correction from Adelman et al. (2002)|
|13679||3.65||same with H fitting|
|Aqr||9229||3.56||Napiwotzki et al. (1993) with photometry|
|9200||3.50||Spectrophotometry and H profile fitting, solar model|
|9050||3.75||Spectrophotometry and H profile fitting, solar model, iron equilibrium|
|And||11845||3.35||Napiwotzki et al. (1993) with photometry|
|11600||3.35||Spectrophotometry and H profile fitting, solar model|
|Star||Species||of Lines||(km s-1)||(km s-1)||gf values|
|And||Fe I||34||3.9||3.9||MF + KX|
|Fe II||23||3.2||3.2||MF + KX|
|Del||Fe II||32||0.0||0.0||MF + KX|
|Aqr||Fe I||33||3.1||3.1||MF + KX|
|And||Fe II||44||1.3||1.2||MF + KX|
The metal abundances were determined using program WIDTH9 (Kurucz 1993) with metal line damping constants from Kurucz & Bell (1995) or semi-classical approximations in their absence. Abundances from Fe I and II lines were derived for a range of possible microturbulences whose values given in Table 3 result in the derived abundances being independent of the equivalent widths () or having a minimal scatter about the mean () (Blackwell et al. 1982). As the microturbulence for And was found using models with km s-1, resulted in a value of 3.6 km s-1, we changed to the use of a model calculated with the same effective temperature and surface gravity but with a 4 km s-1 microturbulence. This resulted in derived Fe abundances with values of 0.01 to 0.03 dex smaller.
We assumed that the helium abundances were solar for both
Aqr for which we do not see any He I lines. Thus to convert their
values to H values -0.04 dex were added. A
is the number density of a specific element N relative to the total density of
all species while a N/H value is the number density relative to hydrogren.
For Del and
And, their helium abundances (Table 4) were found by comparing
the line profiles with theoretical predictions calculated using programs
SYNSPEC (Hubeny et al. 1994) which were convolved with the rotational velocity
and the instrumental profile. The average values show that
And have solar He/H ratios.
|(K)||13 679||11 600||9050||9000||5800|
Table 5, the analyses of the metal line spectra, contains for each line the multiplet number (Moore 1945), the laboratory wavelength, the logarithm of the gf-value and its source, the equivalent width in mÅ as observed, and the deduced abundance. Source references are given at the end of this table. Letters are used in place of multiplet numbers to indicate sources other than Moore (1945): D = Dworetsky (1971) and J = Johansson (1978).
This study's abundances are compared with those of the Sun (Grevesse et al. 1996) in Table 6. For And, that the derived abundances for the light elements tend to be close to solar and those for Fe and heavier species are greater than solar suggests that this star might be a fast rotating Am star. The results from Mn II and Zn I lines should be considered tentative. For the other 12 atomic species (with mean values used for Mg I and II, Ca I and II, Cr I and II, Fe I and II, and Ni I and II lines), the mean value for the abundances with respect to solar is dex.
The mean of 7 metallic elements based on 2 or more lines of Del relative to solar is which is solar. Of these elements only Ni is underabundant. Of the elements whose abundances are based on single lines, C, O, Ca, and Ti are solar, N and Al are underabundant, and Sr is overabundant. These all require confirmation as well as the Ni value. On the whole, the abundance pattern is best considered as solar.
For Aqr the results for 13 atomic species (with the mean value used for Ca I and II, Cr I and II, and Fe I and II lines) is dex. Most notably both Al and Sr appear to be quite underabundant. Both results are somewhat dependent on the adopted microturbulence. Still it appears that Aqr has abundances for the most part which are close to solar.
The mean abundance of 10 elements for And relative to solar is revealing a tendency to be slightly metal poor. Ca is the most underabundant relative to solar. That the He abundance is solar excludes the possibility of its belonging to many of the peculiar classes near A0. Clarification of its status is hampered by its relatively high rotation that makes it difficult to obtain the abundances of other species which would be expected to be found in sharp-lined stars of similar effective temperature and surface gravity.
Table 7 compares the values found for And and Aqr by Hill (1995) with this study. We include in the table values for Mg II 4481 that are probably too large, are marked uncertain, and not used further in this comparison. In addition we markedly disagree with the Sr abundances of And. The mean discrepancy (Hill - this study) for And (9 species, Mg and Sr not included) is and for Aqr (10 species) is dex. For the latter star, corrections for the differences in the adopted effective temperature would ease many, but not all of the discrepancies of which that of Ca is the most serious. Correcting for the temperature discrepancy will make our values more metal-rich while the surface gravity discrepancy will tend to reduce the values for the singly-ionized species. We in fact used spectra which covered parts of three of Hill's four regions, but did not necessarily use the same spectral features. That Hill was able to deduce the abundances of additional species indicates that spectral synthesis studies have an advantage over the fine analysis approach. The discrepancy in the effective temperature determinations may reflect the possibility that the companion to Aqr makes a small contribution to the visible light of the system.
That our values tend to be close to Hill's despite the difference in techniques indicates that our goal of reasonably good initial abundance estimates has been achieved for And and Aqr and by inference for the other two stars. Spectrum synthesis techniques depend on the underlying template of lines and their atomic data. If this data is of sufficient quality, then this technique can produce high quality results even for stars which show some rotation. Any template must be tested upon high signal-to-noise, high dispersion spectra of several sharp-lined stars which cover the range of abundances, surface gravities, and effective temperatures expected in the faster rotating stars.
This research was supported in part by the Research Fund of the University of Istanbul, project numbers BA-47/1204200. SJA and AFG thank Dr. James E. Hesser, Director of the Dominion Astrophysical Observatory for the observing time. SJA's contribution to this paper was supported in part by grants from The Citadel Foundation and AFG's contribution by grants from the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada. We acknowledge the useful comments of Dr. F. Spite.