A&A 405, 723-731 (2003)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20030633
J. D. do Nascimento Jr. 1 - B. L. Canto Martins 1 - C. H. F. Melo 2,1 - G. Porto de Mello 3 - J. R. De Medeiros 1
1 - Departamento de Física,
Universidade Federal do Rio
Grande do Norte, 59072-970
Natal, RN., Brazil
2 -
European Southern Observatory, Casilla 19001, Santiago 19, Chile
3 -
Observatório do Valongo, Ladeira do Pedro Antonio, 43, 20080-090, Rio de Janeiro, RJ., Brazil
Received 14 October 2002 / Accepted 15 April 2003
Abstract
The connection rotation-CaII emission flux-lithium
abundance is analyzed for a sample of bona fide subgiant stars, with
evolutionary status determined from HIPPARCOS trigonometric parallax
measurements and from the Toulouse-Geneva code. The distribution of
rotation and CaII emission flux as a function of effective temperature
shows a discontinuity located around the same spectral type,
F8IV. Blueward of this spectral type, subgiants have a large spread
of values of
rotation and CaII flux, whereas stars redward of F8IV show essentially low
rotation and low CaII flux. The strength of these declines depends
on stellar mass. The abundance of lithium also shows a sudden decrease. For
subgiants with mass lower than about 1.2
the decrease is
located later than that in rotation and CaII flux, whereas
for masses higher than 1.2
the
decrease in lithium abundance is located around the spectral type F8IV.
The discrepancy between the location of the discontinuities of rotation
and CaII emission flux and
(Li) for stars with masses lower
than 1.2
seems to reflect the sensitivity of these
phenomena to the mass
of the convective envelope. The drop in rotation, which results
mostly from a magnetic braking, requires an increase in the
mass of the convective envelope less than that
required for the decrease in
(Li). The location of the
discontinuity in
(Li) for stars with masses higher than 1.2
,
in
the same region of the discontinuities in rotation and CaII emission
flux, may also be explained by the behavior of the
deepening of the convective envelope. The more
massive the star is, the earlier is the increase of the convective envelope.
In contrast to the relationship between rotation and CaII flux, which is
fairly linear, the relationship between lithium abundance and rotation
shows no clear tendency toward linear behavior. Similarly, no clear
linear trend is observed in the relationship between lithium abundance and
CaII flux. In spite of these facts, subgiants with high lithium content also have high
rotation and high CaII emission flux.
Key words: stars: activity - stars: abundances - stars: rotation - stars: interiors - stars: late-type
The study of the influence of stellar rotation on chromospheric activity and on the mixing of light elements in evolved stars has undergone some important advances during the past decade. Several authors have reported a rotation-activity relation for evolved stars based on the linear behavior of the chromospheric flux with stellar rotation (e.g. Rutten 1987; Rutten & Pylyser 1988; Simon & Drake 1989; Strassmeier et al. 1994; Gunn et al. 1998; Pasquini et al. 2000). For a given spectral type, however, a large spread in the rotation-activity relation is observed, which suggests that rotation might not be the only relevant parameter controlling stellar activity. Indeed, results from Pasquini & Brocato (1992) and Pasquini et al. (2000) have shown that chromospheric activity depends on stellar effective temperature and mass.
A possible connection between rotation and abundance of lithium in evolved stars has also been reported in the literature (e.g. De Medeiros et al. 1997; do Nascimento et al. 2000; De Medeiros et al. 2000). Subgiant and giant stars with enhanced lithium abundance show also enhanced rotation, in spite of a large spread in the abundances of lithium among the slow rotators. In addition, do Nascimento et al. (2000) have pointed to a discontinuity in the distribution of Li abundances as a function of effective temperature later than the discontinuity in rotation (e.g. De Medeiros & Mayor 1990). Concerning the link between chromospheric activity and light element abundances, Duncan (1981) and Pasquini et al. (1994) have found a clear tendency of solar G-type stars with enhanced CaII surface flux F(CaII) to have a higher lithium content. This is consistent with the predictions of standard evolutionary models, according to which, activity and abundance of light elements should depend on stellar surface temperature, metallicity and age. In spite of these important studies showing evidence of a connection in between abundance of lithium and rotation and in between chromospheric activity and rotation, in practice, for evolved stars, the mechanisms controlling such connections and their dependence on different stellar parameters like metallicity, mass and age are not yet well established. In this paper, we analyze in parallel the behavior of the chromospheric activity, stellar rotation and lithium abundance along the subgiant branch. In the present approach, the stars are placed in the HR diagram to determine more clearly the location of the discontinuities for these three stellar parameters based on a sample of bona fide subgiants.
For this study we have selected a large sample of 121 single stars
classified as subgiants in the literature, along the spectral region F, G
and K, with rotational velocity, flux of CaII and (Li) now
available. The rotational velocities
were taken from De Medeiros
& Mayor (1999). By using the CORAVEL spectrometer (Baranne et al. 1979)
these authors have determined the projected rotational velocity
for
a large sample of subgiant and giant stars with a precision of about 1 km s-1 for stars with
lower than about 30 km s-1.
For higher rotators, the estimations indicate an uncertainty of about
10%. The F(CaII) was determined from the CaII H and K line-core
emission index S1 and S2 listed by Rutten (1987), using the procedure of
conversion from the emission index S1 to flux at the stellar surface F(CaII)
given by Rutten (1984). The values of
(Li) were taken from Lèbre et al. (1999) and Randich et al. (1999). Readers are referred to these
works for discussion on the observational procedure, data reduction
and error analysis. Stellar luminosities were determined as follows. First,
the apparent visual magnitudes
and trigonometric parallaxes, both
taken from HIPPARCOS catalogue (ESA 1997), were combined to yield the
absolute visual magnitude
.
Bolometric correction BC, computed from
Flower (1996) calibration, was applied giving the bolometric magnitude which
was finally converted into stellar luminosity. The effective temperature
was computed using Flower (1996) (B-V) versus
calibration.
The rotational velocity
,
stellar surface flux F(CaII), abundance of lithium
(Li)
and stellar parameters of the entire sample are presented in
Table 1.
HD | ST | log(L/Lo) |
![]() |
![]() |
F(CaII) | ![]() |
400 | F8IV | 0.45 | 6265 | 5.6 | 6.635 | 2.30a |
645 | K0IV | 1.33 | 4844 | 1.8 | 5.551 | 0.50a |
905 | F0IV | 0.68 | 7059 | 31.6 | 7.137 | |
3229 | F5IV | 1.00 | 6524 | 5.0 | 6.932 | 1.30a |
4744 | G8IV | 1.49 | 4724 | 3.4 | 5.326 | |
4813 | F7IV-V | 0.21 | 6223 | 3.9 | 6.658 | 2.80a |
5268 | G5IV | 1.68 | 5024 | 1.9 | 5.646 | 0.40a |
5286 | K1IV | 1.04 | 4821 | 1.6 | 5.573 | |
6301 | F7IV-V | 0.65 | 6528 | 20.3 | 6.829 | 1.00a |
6680 | F5IV | 0.63 | 6735 | 36.4 | 7.086 | |
8799 | F5IV | 0.85 | 6628 | 65.9 | 6.934 | |
9562 | G2IV | 0.57 | 5755 | 4.2 | 6.327 | 2.40a |
11151 | F5IV | 0.80 | 6637 | 34.0 | 6.834 | |
12235 | G2IV | 0.54 | 5855 | 5.2 | 6.423 | 1.30a |
13421 | G0IV | 0.91 | 6006 | 9.9 | 6.415 | 1.30a |
13871 | F6IV-V | 0.77 | 6546 | 9.1 | 6.763 | |
16141 | G5IV | 0.31 | 5653 | 2.3 | 6.269 | |
18262 | F7IV | 0.80 | 6375 | 9.9 | 6.621 | 2.10b |
18404 | F5IV | 0.57 | 6656 | 24.7 | 6.902 | |
20618 | G8IV | 1.22 | 5137 | 1.0 | 5.984 | |
23249 | K0IV | 0.51 | 5015 | 1.0 | 5.770 | 0.90b |
25621 | F6IV | 0.83 | 6261 | 15.3 | 6.758 | 3.01b |
26913 | G5IV | -0.20 | 5621 | 3.9 | 6.646 | 2.20a |
26923 | G0IV | 0.03 | 6002 | 4.3 | 6.712 | 2.80a |
29859 | F7IV-V | 0.83 | 6103 | 9.0 | 6.457 | |
30912 | F2IV | 1.56 | 6877 | 155f | 6.914 | |
33021 | G1IV | 0.36 | 5803 | 2.0 | 6.357 | 2.00a |
34180 | F0IV | 0.74 | 6721 | 80f | 7.015 | |
34411 | G2IV-V | 0.25 | 5785 | 1.9 | 6.360 | 2.00a |
37788 | F0IV | 0.92 | 7160 | 31.2 | 7.196 | |
39881 | G5IV | 0.18 | 5718 | 1.4 | 6.329 | |
43386 | F5IV-V | 0.45 | 6582 | 18.8 | 6.927 | 2.30b |
53329 | G8IV | 1.73 | 5028 | 1.3 | 5.702 | |
57749 | F3IV | 2.43 | 6955 | 40f | 6.759 | |
60532 | F6IV | 0.94 | 6195 | 8.1 | 6.590 | 1.60a |
64685 | F2IV | 0.70 | 6873 | 67.2 | 7.087 | |
66011 | G0IV | 0.97 | 6002 | 13.6 | 6.489 | 1.20a |
71952 | K0IV | 1.11 | 4828 | 1.0 | 5.520 | |
73017 | G8IV | 1.50 | 4915 | 1.2 | 5.618 | |
73593 | G0IV | 1.38 | 4857 | 1.0 | 5.561 | |
76291 | K1IV | 1.50 | 4614 | 1.2 | 5.282 | |
78154 | F7IV-V | 0.59 | 6328 | 5.8 | 6.600 | 1.10a |
81937 | F0IV | 1.15 | 6916 | 145f | 7.084 | |
82074 | G6IV | 0.95 | 5188 | 2.1 | 5.951 | 0.30a |
82328 | F6IV | 0.88 | 6388 | 8.3 | 6.751 | 3.30a |
82734 | K0IV | 2.06 | 4800 | 3.8 | 5.413 | 1.10a |
84117 | F9IV | 0.27 | 6142 | 5.6 | 6.627 | 2.50b |
89449 | F6IV | 0.63 | 6488 | 17.3 | 6.763 | 1.30a |
92588 | K1IV | 0.57 | 5091 | 1.0 | 5.863 | 1.00a |
94386 | K3IV | 1.36 | 4525 | 1.0 | 5.133 | 0.20a |
99028 | F2IV | 1.05 | 6619 | 16.0 | 7.015 | 3.25b |
99329 | F3IV | 0.91 | 6989 | 130f | 7.186 | |
99491 | K0IV | -0.14 | 5338 | 2.6 | 6.206 | 1.40a |
104055 | K2IV | 2.22 | 4388 | 2.0 | 5.003 | 0.20a |
104304 | K0IV | -0.04 | 5387 | 2.0 | 6.127 | 0.90a |
105678 | F6IV | 1.08 | 6236 | 29.6 | 6.766 | 1.60a |
107326 | F0IV | 0.98 | 7185 | 120f | 7.191 | |
110834 | F6IV | 1.27 | 6414 | 145f | 6.880 | |
117361 | F0IV | 1.09 | 6707 | 85f | 6.973 | |
119992 | F7IV-V | 0.36 | 6341 | 8.3 | 6.624 | 2.70a |
121146 | K2IV | 1.52 | 4520 | 1.0 | 5.116 | |
123255 | F2IV | 1.17 | 6980 | 140f | 7.119 | |
124570 | F6IV | 0.73 | 6130 | 5.6 | 6.494 | 2.80a |
125111 | F2IV | 0.69 | 6839 | 9.3 | 7.075 | |
125184 | G5IV | 0.39 | 5491 | 1.3 | 6.229 | 0.80a |
125451 | F5IV | 0.55 | 6796 | 46.0 | 7.048 | 1.80a |
125538 | G9IV | 1.79 | 4731 | 1.0 | 5.363 | |
126943 | F1IV | 0.99 | 6873 | 80f | 7.078 | |
127243 | G3IV | 1.71 | 5128 | 3.6 | 5.802 | 0.60a |
127739 | F2IV | 0.94 | 6768 | 68.0 | 6.991 | |
127821 | F4IV | 0.45 | 6596 | 45.5 | 6.954 | |
130945 | F7IVw | 0.93 | 6358 | 18.7 | 6.689 | 2.30b |
133484 | F6IV | 0.77 | 6502 | 21.2 | 6.786 | 2.70a |
136064 | F9IV | 0.65 | 6079 | 5.0 | 6.511 | 2.00a |
143584 | F0IV | 0.84 | 7273 | 70f | 7.271 | |
145148 | K0IV | 0.63 | 4867 | 1.0 | 5.612 | 0.00c |
150012 | F5IV | 1.05 | 6573 | 35.5 | 6.968 | 2.50a |
154160 | G5IV | 0.47 | 5360 | 1.2 | 5.856 | 1.60a |
154417 | F8.5IV-V | 0.13 | 5972 | 5.9 | 6.723 | |
156697 | F0-2IV-Vn | 1.56 | 6782 | 160f | 6.931 | |
156846 | G3IV | 0.69 | 5972 | 4.9 | 6.468 | 0.80a |
157347 | G5IV | 0.00 | 5621 | 1.1 | 6.360 | 0.70c |
157853 | F8IV | 1.79 | 5511 | 3.2 | 6.488 | 2.20a |
158170 | F5IV | 1.28 | 6002 | 8.0 | 6.587 | 1.20a |
161797 | G5IV | 0.43 | 5414 | 1.7 | 6.109 | 1.10a |
162003 | F5IV-V | 0.74 | 6569 | 12.9 | 6.795 | 2.60a |
162076 | G5IV | 1.50 | 4967 | 3.2 | 5.959 | 1.10a |
162917 | F4IV-V | 0.57 | 6610 | 50f | 6.891 | |
164259 | F2IV | 0.76 | 6772 | 80f | 6.997 | |
165438 | K1IV | 0.82 | 4907 | 1.0 | 5.647 | 0.12c |
173949 | G7IV | 1.71 | 4909 | 2.6 | 5.614 | |
176095 | F5IV | 0.91 | 6375 | 13.2 | 6.795 | 2.90a |
182572 | G8IV | 0.25 | 5384 | 1.7 | 6.135 | |
182640 | F0IV | 0.90 | 7119 | 68.4 | 7.154 | |
184663 | F6IV | 0.58 | 6660 | 69.0 | 6.992 | 1.90b |
185124 | F3IV | 0.72 | 6592 | 85f | 6.943 | |
188512 | G8IV | 0.78 | 5148 | 1.2 | 5.905 | 0.10c |
190360 | G6IV+M6V | 0.06 | 5417 | 1.7 | 6.197 | |
190771 | G5IV | 0.01 | 5705 | 2.7 | 6.685 | 2.30a |
191026 | K0IV | 0.60 | 5160 | 1.3 | 6.295 | |
191570 | F5IV | 0.58 | 6754 | 33.6 | 7.008 | 2.60a |
192344 | G4IV | 0.45 | 5547 | 1.4 | 6.234 | |
195564 | G2.5IV | 0.44 | 5593 | 1.9 | 6.185 | 1.97c |
196755 | G5IV+K2IV | 0.87 | 5553 | 3.3 | 6.218 | 1.10a |
197373 | F6IV | 0.52 | 6528 | 30.9 | 6.816 | 1.00a |
197964 | K1IV | 1.34 | 4764 | 1.0 | 5.466 | |
198149 | K0IV | 0.96 | 5022 | 1.4 | 5.737 | |
201507 | F5IV | 1.23 | 6844 | 16.4 | 7.051 | |
201636 | F3IV | 0.91 | 6791 | 67.9 | 7.025 | |
202444 | F1IV | 1.02 | 6758 | 26.1 | 7.039 | |
202582 | G2IV+G2IV | 0.60 | 5803 | 3.1 | 6.479 | 2.20a |
205852 | F1IV | 1.68 | 7109 | 180f | 7.127 | |
207978 | F6IV-Vvw | 0.56 | 6605 | 7.2 | 6.770 | 1.00a |
208703 | F5IV | 0.84 | 6829 | 15.4 | 7.078 | |
210210 | F1IV | 1.31 | 7160 | 80f | 7.089 | |
212487 | F5IV | 0.85 | 6345 | 8.8 | 6.582 | 2.20b |
216385 | F7IV | 0.68 | 6336 | 5.9 | 6.610 | 1.20a |
218101 | G8IV | 0.64 | 5078 | 1.1 | 6.096 | |
219291 | F6IVw | 1.43 | 6506 | 53.1 | 6.944 | |
223421 | F2IV | 1.11 | 6688 | 66.6 | 7.001 | |
224617 | F4IV | 1.29 | 6637 | 49.9 | 6.913 | 3.20b |
As a first step, the stellar luminosity and the effective temperature listed in
Table 1
were used to construct the HR diagram to better locate the evolutionary stage of
the stars in the sample. In fact, such a procedure seems important because in preceding
studies on the link between
rotation and chromospheric activity in subgiant stars, only the spectral type was used as
a criterion for identifying the stars. Evolutionary tracks were computed from the
Toulouse-Geneva code
for stellar masses
between 1 and 4 ,
for metallicity consistent with solar-type
subgiant stars (see do Nascimento et al. 2000 for a more detailed description).
Here, in particular, we use the evolutionary tracks computed
with solar metallicity because most of the stars in the present
sample have
.
The HR diagram with the evolutionary
tracks is displayed in Figs. 1, 2 and 3, which in addition show the
behavior of the rotational velocity
,
surface flux CaII and
(Li) abundance respectively. In these diagrams the
dashed line indicates
the evolutionary region where the subgiant branch starts, corresponding to
hydrogen exhaustion in stellar central regions, whereas the dotted line
represents the beginning of the ascent of the red giant branch. One observes,
clearly, that most of the stars in the present sample are effectively
subgiants. Nevertheless a small number of stars located in particular on the
cool side of the diagrams are rather stars evolving along the red giant
branch. In this context, for the purpose of the present analysis, these
deviating stars will not be considered as subgiants, in spite of the spectral
types assigned in the literature.
Figure 1 shows the well
established rotational discontinuity around the spectral type F8IV
(e.g. De Medeiros & Mayor 1990),
corresponding to
). As shown by
these authors, single subgiants blueward of this spectral type show a wide range
of rotational velocities from a few km s-1 to about one hundred times the
solar rotation, whereas subgiants redward of F8IV are essentially slow rotators,
except for the synchronized binary systems. Figure 1 shows clearly that
single subgiants redward of the discontinuity with high
are
unusual. The root cause for such a discontinuity seems to be a strong
magnetic braking associated with the rapid increase of the moment of inertia,
due to evolutionary expansion, once the star evolves along the late F
spectral region (e.g. Gray & Nagar 1985; De Medeiros & Mayor 1990).
![]() |
Figure 2: Distribution of subgiant stars in the HR diagram, with the behavior of the F(CaII) surface flux as a function of luminosity and effective temperature. Luminosities have been derived from the HIPPARCOS parallaxes. Evolutionary tracks are defined as in Fig. 1. |
![]() |
Figure 3: Distribution of subgiant stars in the HR diagram, with the behavior of Li abundance as a function of luminosity and effective temperature. Luminosities have been derived from the HIPPARCOS parallaxes. Evolutionary tracks are defined as in Fig. 1. |
Figure 2 shows clear evidence of a discontinuity in the surface flux F(CaII) paralleling the one observed in rotational velocity. In fact, such a sudden decrease in CaII flux of subgiants also parallels that in CIV emission flux found by Simon & Drake (1989). Stars with typical subgiant masses showing the highest CaII flux are located blueward of this discontinuity. Such a drop in the surface chromospheric flux is interpreted by Simon & Drake (1989) as the result of the drop in rotation near the spectral type G0IV. According to these authors, there is a development of a dynamo in late F stars, which induces a strong magnetic braking in a preexisting wind that acts on the outermost layers of the stellar surface. As a consequence the stellar surface will spin down.
Figure 3 shows the behavior of the lithium abundance,
with a sudden decrease in (Li) for subgiant stars with mass
lower than about 1.2
,
located a somewhat later than the
discontinuity in rotation and in surface F(CaII). Evidence
for this decrease in
(Li) was first pointed out by do Nascimento et al. (2000). According to these
authors, such a drop in
(Li) abundances of subgiants seems
to result from the rapid increase of the convective envelope at the late F
evolutionary stage. Due to the convective mixing process, Li-rich
surface material is diluted
towards the stellar interior. For higher masses, the drop in
(Li) shows a tendency to parallel the discontinuities in
and F(CaII), near F8IV, corresponding to
.
![]() |
Figure 4:
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
An additional trend is present in Figs. 1 and 2, which show that the fastest rotators
and those subgiants with the highest CaII emission flux, namely the stars blueward of
F8IV, are mostly stars with mass higher than about 1.2 .
Subgiants with mass
lower than about 1.2
show moderate to low rotation as well as
moderate to low surface F(CaII). In the region blueward of F8IV,
the abundances of lithium show a more complex behavior for stars with
masses between 1.2 and 1.5
.
Figure 3 shows a number of stars
in this mass interval with low to moderate
(Li). Such a fact appears to
reflect the so-called dip region observed by Boesgaard & Tripicco (1986).
As a second step of this study we have analyzed the direct relationship
between rotation, F(CaII) and (Li) for the stars of the sample. Figure 4 shows the surface F(CaII) versus the rotational velocity
,
where stars are separated by intervals of (B-V). Stars earlier
than the rotational discontinuity, typically those with
,
are represented by open circles, solid circles stand for stars with
,
triangles stand for stars with
0.75 < (B-V)
and squares represent stars with
(B-V) > 0.95. The well
established correlation between rotation and chromospheric emission flux (e.g.
Simon & Drake 1989), here represented by the surface F(CaII),
is clearly confirmed for the present sample of bona fide subgiants.
![]() |
Figure 5:
![]() ![]() |
Figure 5 presents the behavior of (Li) as a function of the rotational
velocity
,
confirming the trend of a fair connection in between
abundance of Li and
in subgiant stars already observed by other
authors (e.g. De Medeiros et al. 1997).
Finally, Fig. 6 shows the surface F(CaII) as a function of (Li).
In spite of more a limited number of stars than in Figs. 4 and 5, we
observe a trend for a connection between F(CaII) and
(Li) following
rather the behavior observed
in the
versus
(Li) relation.
![]() |
Figure 6:
![]() ![]() |
A close examination of the rotation versus F(CaII) relation presented in Fig. 4
shows that the amount by which it deviates from a linear correlation depends on the
(B-V) color interval. A similar color dependence was observed by Noyes et al. (1984),
who removed such an effect by introducing the dimensionless Rossby
number
,
as a
mesure of the rotational velocity. This dependence was also noted by Simon & Drake (1989) for subgiant stars, by analysing the relation F(CIV) versus rotation. These results
confirm that rotation is not the only parameter expected to influence stellar chromospheric
activity; another is the stellar mass, or equivalently, the position of the star in
the HR diagram, which dictates the properties of the stellar convective zone. The deepening
of the convective zone, or its convective turnover time is, in particular, expected to play
a relevant role in the dynamo generation. The Rossby number, in fact, determines the extent
to which rotation can induce both helicity and differential rotation required for
dynamo activity in the convective zone.
To analyse the connection F(CaII) emission flux-Rossby number, we have computed
for all the stars of the present sample. The convective turnover time
was estimated from
the iterated function in (B-V) given by Noyes et al. (1984), whereas the rotation period was estimated indirectly from the
given in Table 1. A statistical correction of
was taken in consideration, to compensate for
effects. The stellar radii were estimated following the standard expression as a function of effective temperature
and luminosity. Figure 7 presents the behavior of F(CaII) as a function of the Rossby number
,
with two
clear different features. For stars with
(B-V) > 0.55 the correlation of chromospheric
activity, given by F(CaII), with
is significantly better than with rotational
velocity, whereas stars with
show F(CaII) rather uniformly high and
independent of the
.
A similar result was found by Simon & Drake (1989), by
analysing the F(CIV) versus
relation.
![]() |
Figure 7:
The F(CaII) versus the Rossby number ![]() |
The level of dilution of lithium depends strongly on the level of convection. In this
context it sounds interesting to analyse the behavior of lithium abundance as a function
of the deepening of the convective zone for the present sample of stars. For this
purpose we have estimated the mass of each star M* from the HR diagram presented in
Sect. 3.1 and then estimated the mass of the convective zone
from an iterated
function
(M*,
)
constructed on the basis of the study by do Nascimento et al. (2000) on the deepening (in mass) of the convective envelope of evolved
stars. These authors present the behavior of
as a function of
for stars with
masses between 1.0 and 4.0
.
Figure 8 shows the behavior of
(Li) in the
versus
diagram. It is clear that most of the stars with high lithium
content present an undeveloped convective envelope, whereas stars with low
(Li)
have a developed convective envelope.
At this point we can inquire about the root cause of the apparent
discrepancy in the location of the discontinuities in
and
F(CaII) and that for
(Li). In fact, should one expect, from
the evolutionary point of view, that the discontinuity in
(Li)
follows the one in
as well as that in F(CaII)? First of all,
let us recall that in the specific case of late-type evolved stars,
chromospheric activity reflects the presence of magnetic fields which are relevant for the
heating of the chromosphere as well as for mass and angular momentum losses. The
intensity and spatial distribution of magnetic fields are very probably determined by a
dynamo process, whose mode of operation and efficiency depends on the interplay between
stellar rotation and subphotospheric convective motions. In this context one should
expect a direct link between the discontinuities in
and F(CaII), with a drop
at the same spectral region, if chromospheric activity is directly controlled by
rotation. As shown by Fig. 7, this is true, in particular, for stars located redward of the
spectral region of the discontinuity.
The question now turns to the apparent discrepancy in the location of the
discontinuity in (Li) in relation to the location of the discontinuities in
and
F(CaII) for subgiant stars with masses lower than about 1.2
.
This discrepancy can be understood as a result of the sensitivity of these phenomena to the mass of
the convective envelope. In the case of the rotational discontinuity, a small increase in the mass
of the convective envelope is enough to turn the dynamo on. This same dynamo will be responsible
to the magnetic braking causing a drop in the rotation rate and the consequent shutdown of the dynamo itself. Later, the convective envelope will continue to deep reaching a region previously devoid of Li. At this point, the Li brought from the surface layers is diluted and its abundance drops.
This fact explains clearly the discrepancy between
the location of the discontinuity in
(Li) in relation to the one for
and F(CaII),
as observed from Figs. 1 to 3. The fact that a magnetic braking might operate with very small changes in the
mass of the convective envelope is further reinforced by the location of the discontinuity in the
F(CaII) flux at the late F spectral region. Previous studies (e.g. do Nascimento et al.
2000) show that the development of the convective envelope towards the stellar interior
starts at this spectral region, reaching a maximum within the middle to late G spectral
region. In short, the drop in
and
F(CaII) is earlier than that in
(Li) because, in contrast to the former, this latter requires
a large increase in the mass of the convective envelope. Figure 8 shows that Li dilution
increases abruptly with the deepening of the convective envelope. In fact, the observed discontinuity in
(Li) seems to be controlled directly by the increasing of the deepening of the
convective envelope.
The observed trend for a same location,
of the discontinuities in
and
(Li) for stars with masses larger than about 1.2
may
also be explained by following the behavior of the deepening of the convective envelope.
As shown by do Nascimento et al. (2000, see their Fig. 4), the changes in the mass of the convective envelope at a given effective temperature in the range from
to
,
are more important for stars with masses in the
increasing sequence of masses from 1.0
to 2.5
.
The more massive the
star is, in this range of masses, the earlier is the increasing of the convective envelope.
In this context, a sudden decrease in
(Li) of stars with masses larger than about
1.2
,
paralleling the rotational discontinuity, should be expected.
The relationship between
and surface F(CaII), as
presented in Fig. 4, confirms the results found by other authors for subgiant stars
(e.g. Strassmeier et al. 1994) and for other luminosity classes (Strassmeier et al. 1994;
Pasquini et al. 2000).
In addition, one observes a trend of increasing scattering in
the
versus
F(CaII) relation, confirming previous claims that rotation might not be the only relevant parameter controlling
chromospheric activity. In this context, Pasquini et al. (2000) have found for giant
stars a clear dependence of F(CaII) flux with a high power of stellar effective
temperature, whereas Strassmeier et al. (1994) have found that the CaII flux from the cooler evolved stars
depends more strongly upon rotation than the CaII flux from the hotter evolved stars.
The behavior of F(CaII) as a function of the Rossby number
,
presented in Fig. 7, shows two clear
trends: For stars with (B-V) larger than about 0.55 the F(CaII) tends towards a linear correlation
with
;
stars with (B-V) lower than about 0.55 show F(CaII) rather uniformly high
and independent of
,
pointing for a component of chromospheric activity independent of
rotation. Different authors (e.g. Wolff et al. 1986) suggest that the chromospheres of
early F stars may be heated by the shock dissipation of sound waves, rather than by the dynamo
process that control the chromospheric activity in G- and K-type stars.
The dependence of lithium abundance upon rotation observed in Fig. 5 exists in the sense
that the fastest rotators also have the highest lithium content. Nevertheless, there is no
clear linear relation between these two parameters. Figure 5 also shows a large spread
in the Li content at a given
value, covering at least 2 mag in
(Li). Such
a spread shows a clear tendency to increase with rotation and effective temperature. For
lower than about 10 km s-1, in particular, the
(Li) values range from
about 0.0 to about 3.0. Such a spread was also observed by De Medeiros et al. (1997) & do Nascimento et al. (2000). Finally, the behavior of
(Li) as a function of
CaII emission flux presented in Fig. 6 seems to follow roughly the same trend observed for the relation
versus
(Li). Subgiants with high lithium content also show high F(CaII), but
there is no clear linear relation between these two parameters.
In the search for a better understanding of the influence of stellar rotation on
chromospheric activity and lithium dilution, we have analyzed the relationship
rotation-CaII emission flux-Li abundance along the subgiant branch, on the
basis of a sample of bona fide subgiants, reclassified from HIPPARCOS data.
The evolutionary status of all the stars was determined from trigonometric
parallax taken from this data base and evolutionary tracks computed from the
Geneva-Toulouse code.
The distributions of the rotational velocity and of the CaII emission flux
show similar behavior. For both
parameters we observe a sudden decrease around the spectral type F8IV,
confirming previous studies. Nevertheless, the extent of these discontinuities
depends on the stellar mass. Stars with masses around 1.5
show a more
important decrease in rotation and CaII emission flux,
than stars with masses lower than about 1.2
.
Clearly, stars blueward of
F8IV, with masses higher than 1.2
,
rotate faster and are more active than
those with masses lower than about 1.2
.
The distribution of Li abundance
versus effective temperature, in spite of a sudden decrease in the late-F region
shows a trend for a more complex behavior. First, stars with masses lower than
about 1.2
show a discontinuity in
(Li) somewhat later than the
discontinuities in rotation and CaII emission flux, whereas stars with higher
masses present a decline in
(Li) rather around the spectral type F8IV. In
addition, a group of stars blueward of F8IV with masses between 1.2 and 1.5
shows moderate to low
(Li), which seems to reflect the effects of the so-called
Boesgaard-Tipico dip region. The discrepancy in the location of the
discontinuities of rotation-CaII emission flux and
(Li) for stars with masses
lower than 1.2
,
seems to be the result of the sensitivity of these phenomena
to the mass of the convective envelope. The drop in rotation, resulting mostly
from a magnetic braking, requires an increase in the mass of the convective
envelope less than that required for the sudden decrease in
(Li), this later resulting
from the dilution due to the rapid increase of the convective envelope.
The location of the discontinuity in
(Li) for stars with masses higher than
1.2
,
in the same region of the discontinuities in rotation and CaII emission
flux, may also be explained by following the behavior of the deepening of the
convective envelope. The more massive the star is, the earlier is the increase of the
convective envelope. The present work confirms that the dilution of Li depends strongly
on the deepening of the convective envelope.
The relationship between rotation and CaII emission flux confirms previous
results found by other authors. CaII emission flux shows a correlation with rotation.
Nevertheless, the large spread in the CaII flux-
relation
reinforces previous suggestions that rotation might not be the only relevant
parameter controlling stellar chromospheric activity. In fact, the relation F(CaII) versus Rossby
number confirms that chromospheric activity of subgiant stars with (B-V) larger than about 0.55 depends
rather linearly on rotation, whereas for stars with (B-V) lower than about 0.55 activity is rather independent of rotation.
The relationship between
(Li) and rotation shows a behavior
less clear than that between CaII flux and
rotation. Of course the present study confirms a dependence of lithium abundance
upon rotation, in the sense that stars with the high rotation have also high lithium content.
In spite of this fact, there is no clear linear relationship
between these two parameters, with a spread more important than that observed in
the F(CaII) -
relation. The behavior of the relationship between lithium abundance and
CaII emission flux seems to follow that observed for
(Li)-
.
Stars with
the high activity also show high lithium content. In both cases there is a
remarkable increase in scattering in the
(Li)-
and
(Li)-CaII flux
relations with increasing
and CaII flux, respectively. Such a fact appears
to indicate that the influence of rotation on stellar activity is greater than
on lithium dilution. Finally, the present study point to a pressing need for new
measurements of chromospheric emission flux and lithium abundance for an
homogeneous and larger sample of bona fide subgiant stars, with a larger range
of metallicities, than that analyzed
here. With these additional data it will be possible to analyze the influence of
rotation upon activity and lithium dilution on a more solid basis, taking into
account the stellar age and metallicity.
Acknowledgements
This work has been supported by continuous grants from the CNPq Brazilian Agency. J.D.N.Jr. acknowledges the CNPq grant PROFIX 540461/01-6. Special thanks to the referee, Dr. R. Cayrel for very useful comments, which greatly improved the quality of this paper.