A&A 392, 143-150 (2002)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20020909
V. G. Klochkova1,2 - M. V. Yushkin1,2 - A. S. Miroshnichenko3,4 - V. E. Panchuk1,2 - K. S. Bjorkman3
1 - Special Astrophysical Observatory of
the Russian Academy of Sciences,
Karachai-Cirkassian Republic,
Nizhnij Arkhyz 369167, Russia
2 - Isaac Newton Institute of Chile, SAO Branch
3 - Ritter Observatory, Dept. of Physics & Astronomy, University of
Toledo, Toledo, OH 43606-3390, USA
4 - Central Astronomical Observatory of
the Russian Academy of Sciences
at Pulkovo, 196140 Saint-Petersburg, Russia
Received 1 March 2002 / Accepted 29 May 2002
Abstract
We present a study of the high-resolution spectroscopic data for
the proto-planetary nebula candidate IRAS 01005+7910. For the
first time a careful spectral line identification is carried out,
and a significant variability of the optical spectrum is detected.
We found absorption lines of C II/ III, N II,
O II, Al III, Si III, and Mg II
(
Å), as well as emission lines of Si II
and [Fe II]. Both absorption and emission components are
present in the Balmer lines, Na I resonance D1,2lines, He I, and Fe III lines. The He I line
profiles vary from straight to inverse P Cyg-type on a timescale
of days to months. The resonance Na I lines show 5
absorption components at a resolution of R=60 000. Additionally,
the Na I D2 line exhibits a variable emission
component with a width comparable to that of the Balmer line
emission components. Using the model atmospheres method
within the LTE-approximation, the effective temperature
(
K), the metallicity
,
and the ratio
is
reported. Finally, we suggest that IRAS 01005+7910 is a
carbon-rich post-AGB star with a luminosity
at a distance about 3 kpc.
Key words: stars: evolution - stars: AGB and post-AGB - stars: emission-line - stars: individual: IRAS 01005+7910 -techniques: spectroscopic
Proto-planetary nebulae (PPNe) are post-AGB objects evolving
toward the Planetary Nebula (PN) stage with increasing effective
temperatures (
)
and almost constant luminosities
(e.g. Blöcker 1995). They span a range of spectral types
between B and G and are surrounded by a significant amount of
circumstellar dust, thanks to which many such sources were detected
by the IRAS satellite (Parthasarathy & Pottasch 1989).
Follow-up observations showed that PPNe, especially those of early
spectral types, exhibit variable emission-line spectra
(Parthasarathy et al. 2000). Spectroscopic studies are
crucial for constraining PPNe masses through determination of the
fundamental parameters and their evolutionary state with
measurements of the chemical composition and mass loss rate.
Spectroscopic monitoring programmes, which are still rare, are
important for studies of physical processes in the objects'
immediate vicinity and for detecting binary PPNe (Van Winckel et al. 1995), whose population recently began to grow as a
result of such programmes (see Van Winckel 2001 for a
review).
Here we present the first results obtained in the course of
spectroscopic monitoring of a poorly-studied PPN candidate
IRAS 01005+7910 (hereafter IRAS 01005) at the 6-m
telescope of the Russian Academy of Sciences. The object is
located far from the Galactic plane (
)
and is
identified with an 11-mag. peculiar star. Its IRAS colours are
similar to those of PPNe, lying in the region V in the IRAS
two-colour diagram of Van der Veen & Habing (1988). However,
in contrast to most of the PPNe, maser emission from IRAS 01005
has been detected neither in
CO nor in OH bands (Likkel
1989; Likkel et al. 1991; Omont et al. 1993).
According to a chronological sequence suggested by Lewis
(1989), this result indicates that the object is very close
to the PN stage. The IR spectrum of IRAS 01005 (Hrivnak et al.
2000) contains emission bands at 3.3, 6.2, 7.7, 8.6, 11.3, 26,
and 30
m which are characteristic of carbon-rich PPNe. At the
same time, IRAS 01005 does not show the famous emission at
21
m, whose presence is attributed to an excess of
the s-process elements (Klochkova 1998; Decin et al.
1998).
So far only low-resolution spectra of IRAS 01005 have been
published by Hu (2001), who classified the object as B2
Ie. This author also mentioned no changes in a P Cyg-type
H
line profile in his spectra, obtained 10 years apart.
No photometric variations of the object have been reported.
The observations were obtained at the 6-m telescope of the Special
Astrophysical Observatory (SAO) of the Russian Academy of Sciences
with the échelle-spectrograph PFES (mounted at the prime focus,
1K
1K CCD-chip, resolving power R=15 000, Panchuk et al. 1998), the multimode échelle-spectrograph LYNX
(Nasmyth-2 focus, 1K
1K CCD-chip, R=30 000, Panchuk et al.
1999a), and the échelle-spectrograph NES (Nasmyth-2
focus, 2K
2K CCD-chip, R=60 000, Panchuk et al.
1999b). The observing log is presented in Table 1.
The cosmic ray traces were removed by median averaging of two
subsequent spectra. A hollow cathode Th-Ar lamp was used for the
wavelength calibration.
First steps of the data reduction process (cosmic ray trace
removal, background subtraction, and spectral order extraction)
were done under the ECHELLE context of MIDAS (version 01FEB),
while the final steps (normalization to the continuum level and
radial velocity (
)
and equivalent width
measurements) were completed using a package DECH20 (Galazutdinov
1992).
The optical spectrum of IRAS 01005 is a combination of the
photospheric spectrum of a hot star and circumstellar emission
lines. The line identification was completed using several line
lists of Kilian & Nissen (1989), Parthasarathy et al.
(2000), a multiplet table of Moore (1945) and our
own experince in identification of spectra of related objects
IRAS 18062+2410 (Arkhipova et al. 2001a) and
V1853 Cyg (Arkhipova et al. 2001b). Refined
line wavelengths, oscillator strengths and excitation potentials
were taken from the data base VALD (Piskunov et al. 1995).
Absorption lines of C II/ III, N II, O
II, Al III, Si III, and the Mg II line at
Å are present in the spectrum of IRAS 01005.
Pure emission features were identified with Si II lines and
forbidden lines of [Fe II]. Both emission and absorption
components are detected in the hydrogen Balmer lines, the resonance
lines of the Na I D1, 2 doublet, He I lines, and
Fe III lines. We also found the Si II doublet
4128, 4131 Åin absorption with the equivalent
widths of 60 and 70 mÅ, respectively. The absence of lines with
low excitation potentials and those of neutral elements (except
for those of H I, He I, and Na I) indicates
that the star has a high
.
The full list of
identified emission and absorption lines in the spectrum of
IRAS 01005 in the region 4300-7800 Å is presented in
Table 2. Unidentified lines are denoted by "UN".
![]() |
Figure 1:
Nitrogen lines in the spectrum of IRAS 01005+7910 (thick
line). The dashed line represents a
synthetic spectrum for
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
Our spectra of IRAS 01005 contain several diffuse interstellar
bands. The most intense of them are the following:
Å (
mÅ),
Å
(
mÅ) and
Å
(
mÅ). Their
km s-1agree with the interstellar origin. The strength of the
Å band corresponds to the interstellar reddening
EB-V=0.2 or AV=0.6 (Herbig 1993).
In order to estimate the spectral type of IRAS 01005 we used a
calibration for supergiants based on the line equivalent widths
from Didelon (1982). Using only the lines without
noticeable emission components (Mg II
Å,
Si III
4553, 4575 Å and Si II
Å), we derived an average type of B
which is in agreement with the abovementioned result of Hu
(2001). We also compared the spectrum of IRAS 01005 with
that of the normal supergiant 9 Cep (B2 Ib) and found them
very similar (Fig. 1). While the
strength of the nitrogen and oxygen lines in the spectrum of
IRAS 01005 is in agreement with the estimated spectral type, the
carbon lines are somewhat stronger (Fig. 2) suggesting its
overabundance. The latter agrees with the object's carbon-rich IR
spectrum.
![]() |
Figure 2: Carbon lines in the spectrum of IRAS 01005+7910 (thick line). Other lines have the same meaning as in Fig. 1. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
|
Spec. (mult) | log(gf) |
|
|
|
|
Spec. (mult) | log(gf) |
|
|
|
||
| Å | Å | km s-1 | km s-1 | Å | Å | km s-1 | km s-1 | ||||||
| 4317.136 | O II (2) | -0.386 | a | 0.107 | -39 | 5073.903 | Fe III (5) | -2.557 | a | 0.034 | -40 | ||
| 4319.625 | O II (2) | -0.380 | a | 0.145 | -46 | 5086.701 | Fe III (5) | -2.590 | a | 0.032 | -21 | ||
| 4325.764 | O II (2) | -1.099 | a | blend | 5127.463 | Fe III (5) | -2.057 | e | 0.017 | -72 | -68 | ||
| 4325.993 | C II (28) | -0.089 | a | blend | a | 0.027 | -27 | -23 | |||||
| 4331.813 | O II (41) | -0.090 | a | 0.027 | -39 | 5133.121 | C II (16) | 0.107 | a | 0.062 | -46 | -27 | |
| 4336.861 | O II (2) | -0.762 | a | 0.078 | -42 | 5143.497 | C II (16) | -0.212 | a | 0.050 | -49 | ||
| 4340.462 | H I (1) | -0.447 | e | 0.205 | -43 | 5145.167 | C II (16) | 0.189 | a | 0.098 | -54 | -31 | |
| 4345.558 | O II (2) | -0.346 | a | 0.105 | -50 | 5151.085 | C II (16) | -0.179 | a | 0.038 | -46 | -36 | |
| 4347.379 | O II (16) | 0.029 | a | 0.045 | -48 | 5156.111 | Fe III (5) | -2.018 | e | 0.025 | -72 | -66 | |
| 4349.427 | O II (2) | 0.060 | a | 0.178 | -49 | a | 0.029 | -28 | -22 | ||||
| 4351.268 | O II (16) | 0.251 | a | 0.060 | -43 | 5158.810 | [FeII] (19F) | e | 0.040 | -58 | -51 | ||
| 4359.340 | [FeII] (7F) | e | 0.040 | -56 | 5197.577 | Fe II (49) | -2.100 | e | 0.067 | -32 | -32 | ||
| 4366.893 | O II (2) | -0.348 | a | 0.140 | -53 | 5199 | UN | e | 0.005 | ||||
| 4387.929 | He I (51) | -0.883 | a | 0.390 | -41 | 5200 | UN | e | 0.040 | ||||
| 4411.364 | C II (39) | 0.918 | a | 0.036 | -60 | 5206.650 | O II (32) | -0.266 | a | 0.021 | -35 | ||
| 4414.900 | O II (5) | 0.172 | a | 0.180 | -53 | 5219 | UN | a | 0.022 | ||||
| 4416.980 | O II (5) | -0.077 | a | 0.120 | -46 | 5227.830 | Fe III | -0.055 | a | 0.017 | -45 | ||
| 4437.551 | He I (50) | -2.034 | a | 0.094 | -41 | 5261.620 | [FeII] (19F) | e | 0.015 | -59 | |||
| 4447.030 | N II (55) | 0.285 | a | 0.088 | -49 | 5273.380 | [FeII] (18F) | e | 0.010 | -62 | -52 | ||
| 4452.380 | O II (5) | -0.789 | a | 0.044 | -41 | 5357 | UN | e | 0.065 | ||||
| 4471.485 | He I (14) | 0.053 | a | 0.430 | -26 | 5454.214 | N II (29) | -0.827 | a | 0.042 | -48 | ||
| 4481.207 | Mg II(4) | 0.985 | a | 0.190 | -33 | 5463 | UN | a | 0.035 | ||||
| 4512.565 | Al III (3) | 0.410 | a | 0.026 | -41 | 5495.653 | N II (29) | -0.266 | a | 0.036 | -47 | ||
| 4529.164 | Al III (3) | 0.706 | a | 0.072 | -47 | 5639 | UN | a | 0.050 | ||||
| 4552.622 | Si III (2) | 0.181 | a | 0.274 | -51 | 5646 | UN | a | 0.035 | ||||
| 4567.840 | Si III (2) | -0.039 | a | 0.220 | -53 | -29 | 5662.459 | C II (15) | -0.249 | a | 0.025 | -44 | |
| 4574.757 | Si III (2) | -0.509 | a | 0.110 | -51 | 5666.627 | N II (3) | -0.045 | a | 0.118 | -42 | -27 | |
| 4590.974 | O II (15) | 0.350 | a | 0.088 | -50 | -32 | 5676.015 | N II (3) | -0.368 | a | 0.106 | -37 | -30 |
| 4596.160 | O II (15) | 0.225 | a | 0.075 | -49 | 5679.554 | N II (3) | 0.250 | a | 0.200 | -33 | -31 | |
| 4601.481 | N II (5) | -0.428 | a | 0.035 | -35 | 5686.212 | N II (3) | -0.549 | a | 0.049 | -35 | -11 | |
| 4607.149 | N II (5) | -0.507 | a | 0.044 | -46 | 5696.604 | Al III (2) | 0.230 | a | 0.168 | -46 | -34 | |
| 4609.473 | O II (93) | 0.729 | a | 0.042 | -51 | 5710.766 | N II (3) | -0.518 | a | 0.074 | -43 | -25 | |
| 4613.670 | O II (92) | -1.040 | a | blend | 5722.730 | Al III (2) | -0.070 | a | 0.123 | -46 | -31 | ||
| 4613.868 | N II (5) | -0.665 | a | weak | 5730.660 | N II (3) | -1.704 | a | 0.020 | -40 | |||
| 4619.249 | C II | 1.142 | a | 0.014 | -49 | 5739.734 | Si III (4) | -0.160 | a | 0.220 | -47 | -34 | |
| 4621.241 | O II (92) | -1.150 | a | blend | 5780.410 | DIB | a | 0.100 | -10 | ||||
| 4621.396 | N II (5) | -0.514 | a | 0.012 | -35 | 5797.030 | DIB | a | 0.040 | -8 | |||
| 4630.543 | N II (5) | 0.094 | a | 0.106 | -40 | -28 | 5833.938 | Fe III (114) | 0.616 | a | 0.037 | -40 | |
| 4638.851 | O II (1) | -0.332 | a | 0.107 | -50 | -27 | 5875.661 | He I (11) | 0.740 | e | -39 | -22 | |
| 4641.810 | O II (1) | 0.054 | a | 0.215 | -53 | -29 | a | 8 | -35 | ||||
| 4643.090 | N II (5) | -0.359 | a | 0.052 | -40 | -28 | 5889.951 | Na I (1) | 0.117 | a | 0.160 | -72 | |
| 4647.419 | C III (1) | 0.070 | a | 0.070 | -50 | -34 | a | 0.070 | -67 | -66 | |||
| 4649.138 | O II (1) | 0.308 | a | 0.292 | -47 | -30 | a | 0.080 | -52 | ||||
| 4650.838 | O II (1) | -0.361 | a | 0.160 | -50 | -29 | a | 0.125 | -28 | ||||
| 4651.018 | C III (1) | -0.432 | a | blend | a | 0.330 | -17 | -11 | |||||
| 4661.635 | O II (1) | -0.278 | a | 0.135 | -47 | -30 | 5895.924 | Na I (1) | -0.184 | a | 0.125 | -73 | |
| 4673.732 | O II (1) | -1.089 | a | 0.043 | -41 | a | 0.055 | -68 | -65 | ||||
| 4676.231 | O II (1) | -0.395 | a | 0.118 | -44 | -33 | a | 0.060 | -52 | ||||
| 4696.356 | O II (1) | -1.380 | a | 0.009 | -45 | a | 0.090 | -28 | |||||
| 4699.215 | O II (25) | 0.270 | a | 0.047 | -54 | a | 0.300 | -16 | -10 | ||||
| 4703.209 | O II (40) | 0.538 | a | 0.013 | -64 | 5957.559 | Si II (4) | -0.301 | e | 0.026 | -49 | -54 | |
| 4705.343 | O II (25) | 0.476 | a | 0.062 | -51 | 5978.930 | Si II (4) | 0.004 | e | 0.090 | -44 | -53 | |
| 4710.012 | O II (24) | -0.226 | a | 0.019 | -48 | 6195.990 | DIB | a | 0.030 | -10 | |||
| 4713.171 | He I (13) | -0.976 | a | 0.140 | -28 | -22 | 6203.060 | DIB | a | 0.050 | -19 | ||
| 4803.287 | N II (20) | -0.113 | a | 0.023 | -53 | 6347.109 | Si II (2) | 0.297 | e | 0.171 | -57 | ||
| 4813.333 | Si III (9) | 0.850 | a | weak | 6371.371 | Si II (2) | -0.003 | e | 0.065 | -54 | |||
| 4814.550 | [FeII] (20F) | e | 0.025 | -56 | -52 | 6379.616 | N II (2) | -0.951 | a | 0.041 | -32 | ||
| 4819.688 | Si III (9) | 0.998 | a | 0.060 | -54 | 6402.246 | Ne I (1) | 0.360 | a | 0.057 | -37 | ||
| 4828.957 | Si III (9) | 1.111 | a | 0.060 | -51 | 6548.100 | [N I] (1F) | e | 0.050 | -55 | |||
| 4856.594 | O II (29) | -0.583 | a | 0.060 | -47 | 6562.797 | H I (1) | 0.710 | e | 13.0 | -35 | ||
| 4861.323 | H I (1) | -0.020 | e | 1.80 | -45 | -29 | 6578.053 | C II (2) | -0.026 | a | 0.258 | -30 | |
| 4905.350 | [FeII] (20F) | e | 0.006 | -58 | 6582.882 | C II (2) | -0.328 | a | 0.057 | -31 | |||
| 4906.830 | O II (28) | -0.160 | a | 0.037 | -58 | 6583.600 | [N I] (1F) | e | bl. | ||||
| 4921.931 | He I (48) | -0.435 | a | 0.470 | -32 | -42 | 6605 | UN | e | 0.110 | |||
| 4924.525 | O II (28) | 0.074 | a | 0.037 | -53 | 6613.630 | DIB | a | 0.030 | -16 | |||
| 4994.367 | N II (24) | -0.069 | a | 0.016 | -50 | 6678.154 | He I (46) | 0.329 | a | 0.258 | -15 | ||
| 5001.339 | N II (19) | 0.661 | a | 0.110 | -48 | -33 | 6721.384 | O I (4) | -0.609 | a | 0.057 | -48 | |
| 5005.154 | N II (19) | 0.592 | a | 0.094 | -51 | -33 | 6779.939 | C II (14) | 0.024 | a | bl. | ||
| 5007.333 | N II (24) | 0.171 | a | 0.042 | -48 | -30 | 6780.599 | C II (14) | -0.377 | a | bl. | ||
| 5010.622 | N II (4) | -0.606 | a | 0.045 | -42 | -29 | 6783.908 | C II (14) | 0.304 | a | 0.054 | -43 | |
| 5012.032 | N II (64) | 0.136 | a | 0.009 | -58 | 6787.207 | C II (14) | -0.378 | a | 0.016 | weak | ||
| 5015.678 | He I (4) | -0.820 | e | -67 | -48 | 6791.466 | C II (14) | -0.271 | a | 0.025 | weak | ||
| a | -23 | -14 | 6798.104 | C II (14) | -1.077 | a | 0. | weak | |||||
| 5041.024 | Si II (5) | 0.291 | e | 0.018 | -55 | -58 | 6800.683 | C II (14) | -0.345 | a | 0.020 | weak | |
| 5044.356 | C II (35) | -0.500 | a | blend | 7065.246 | He I (10) | -0.205 | e | -58 | ||||
| 5045.103 | N II (4) | -0.407 | a | 0.082 | -55 | -33 | a | 11 | |||||
| 5047.117 | C II (35) | -1.000 | a | blend | 7771.941 | O I (1) | 0.369 | a | 0.334 | -26 | |||
| 5047.738 | He I (47) | -1.602 | a | 0.110 | -34 | -28 | 7774.161 | O I (1) | 0.223 | a | 0.263 | -25 | |
| 5056.017 | Si II (5) | 0.639 | e | 0.090 | -62 | -53 | 7775.390 | O I (1) | 0.001 | a | 0.150 | -28 |
For an independent
estimate, we compared the
observed spectrum with a synthetic one, calculated from the Kurucz
(1993) LTE models with the solar chemical composition. The
best fit was obtained for
K, microturbulent
velocity
km s-1, and surface gravity
(see Figs. 1 and 2).
Overall, the spectrum of IRAS 01005 is very similar to that of a
low-mass post-AGB star
V1853 Cyg = LS II +34
26 (B1.5 Ia,
García-Lario et al. 1997; Arkhipova et al.
2001a). For example, V1853 Cyg exhibits a strong oxygen
IR-triplet at
Å (
Å), whose
intensity increases with luminosity (Faraggiana et al.
1988). In the spectrum of IRAS 01005 this triplet has
Å, confirming its high luminosity. However, we
cannot estimate the latter due to a lack of hot stars with the measured
strength of the triplet.
Since the spectrum of IRAS 01005 contains many absorption lines without visible emission components (see Table 2), we can estimate abundances of several chemical elements in its atmosphere. However, we have to keep in mind that both the model parameters and chemical composition, determined for such a hot and luminous star with the unstable and extended gaseous-dusty envelope in the framework of a static plane-parallel atmospheric model under the LTE approach, can be considered as a first approximation only.
All atomic parameters for the lines from Table 2 (oscillator strenghts, damping constants, etc.) were taken from the VALD database (Piskunov et al. 1995). Note that virtually all the He I lines are distorted by emission components, therefore we were not able to estimate the He content.
The chemical abundances were calculated using the Kurucz
(1993) models and Kurucz's WIDTH9 program. The effective
temperature (
K) and the surface
gravity (
)
values were improved by using the
criterion of the Si II/Si III ionization balance,
i.e. equality of the Si II and Si III abundances.
The estimated uncertainties in the abundances caused by the errors
in
and
are equal to
dex, which
are similar to those due to the errors of the equivalent widths. A
good agreement of the abundances derived for the pair C
II/C III supports the above model atmosphere parameters.
In order to estimate the microturbulent velocity
,
we used the numerous well-measured O II absorption lines
and found that such a
value produced a zero slope
in a diagram of
abundances calculated for individual
O II lines versus equivalent widths. Formal application of
the generally adopted method leads to a very large value of
km s-1. It is evident that the
supersonic value of
is mainly caused by use of
a plane-parallel static atmosphere model approximation for a
high-luminosity and high-temperature star with an unstable
atmosphere. Takeda (1992) showed that the microturbulent
velocity suddenly grows when the atmosphere becomes unstable,
because the radiation force is larger than the gravitational
force. Such unrealistically large microturbulent velocities,
obtained under the LTE-approach, is a well-known fact in hot
star spectra simulations (Takeda 1977). Gies & Lambert
(1992) showed that, taking into account deviations from the
LTE approximation, the microturbulent velocity can be reduced from
25-30 to 8-11 km s-1. To reduce systematic errors and
derive more realistic chemical abundances, we did not take into
account all the strong lines with
mÅ, since
the weak lines are practically independent of the microturbulent
velocity. A typical value of
km s-1for high-luminosity hot stars (Gies & Lambert 1992;
Parthsarathy et al. 2000) within the LTE-approach was
adopted in our calculations.
| Sun | IRAS 18062+2410 1 | 9 Cep 2 | IRAS 01005+7910 | |||||
| 22 000, 3.0, 15 | 19 040, 2.61, 28.9 | 21 500, 3.0, 15 | ||||||
| X |
|
|
X |
|
|
n | [X/H] |
|
| C | 8.55 | 6.95 | C II | 8.12 | 8.32 | 6 | 0.12 | -0.23 |
| C III | 8.42 | 1 | -0.13 | |||||
| N | 7.97 | 7.27 | N II | 8.03 | 7.70 | 10 | 0.25 | -0.27 |
| O | 8.87 | 8.27 | O II | 8.66 | 8.24 | 12 | 0.21 | -0.63 |
| Mg | 7.58 | 7.08 | Mg II | 7.443 | 1 | -0.13 | ||
| Al | 6.47 | 5.87 | Al III | 5.82 | 2 | -0.65 | ||
| Si | 7.55 | 6.75 | Si II | 6.87 | 7.41 | 2 | -0.14 | |
| Si III | 7.40 | 5 | 0.20 | -0.15 | ||||
| Fe | 7.50 | 6.90 | Fe III | 7.68 | 7.19 | 4 | 0.20 | -0.31 |
1 Results from Parthasarathy et al. (2000)
are recalculated using the solar abundances from Col. 2.
2 From Gies & Lambert (1992).
3 The Mg abundance may be overestimated since it was derived from strong (
mÅ) line.
To illustrate the role of non-LTE effects for the IRAS 01005
spectrum we calculated an oxygen abundance from the lines of both
ions and neutral atoms. It is well known that the lines of the
oxygen IR-triplet at
Å are very sensitive to
non-LTE effects. Using the equivalent widths of these lines from
Table 2 we obtained
O I)=9.49, while
a lower value of
O II)=8.24 was derived from
the weak O II lines.
The average chemical abundances for different species are
presented in Table 3. The abundances are given on the
usual scale,
with
.
The chemical composition for a
normal supergiant 9 Cep (Gies & Lambert 1992) is given for
comparison.
As follows from Table 3, the atmospheric abundances of
all the elements found for IRAS 01005 and for a normal supergiant
9 Cep are different. The iron content
of IRAS 01005 is slightly smaller
relative to the solar one, while it is larger for 9 Cep
(
). The abundances of such metals as
Mg, Al, and Si show the same feature in both objects. As follows
from the results by Gies & Lambert (1992), a chemical
abundance pattern in the case of 9 Cep agrees with the
evolutionary stage of a massive supergiant: carbon is
underabundant in its metal-rich atmosphere, contaminated by the
CN-cycle products. The CNO-group behaviour in the IRAS 01005
atmosphere (the carbon abundance is enhanced relative to the solar
one,
,
while the oxygen content is
deficient,
)
is opposite to that of
9 Cep. These differences in the chemical abundance picture allow
us to rule out a hypothesis that IRAS 01005 is a normal
supergiant.
We note here that the main spectral peculiarities, the atmospheric
parameters
K,
,
and the
atmospheric abundances of IRAS 01005 are similar to those of the
post-AGB object IRAS 18062+2410, whose high-resolution spectra
were studied by Arkhipova et al. (2001a) and Parthasarathy
et al. (2000). The most remarkable difference between
IRAS 01005 and IRAS 18062+2410 is the behaviour of the CNO
abundances (Table 3). For IRAS 18062+2410, the N- and
O-abundances are similar to the metallicity at a strong
C-deficiency. For IRAS 01005 we see a different picture: the C-
and N-abundances follow the iron content at a large oxygen
deficiency. The carbon/oxygen ratio is
for
IRAS 18062+2410 while for IRAS 01005 the ratio
is in agreement with details in its IR-spectrum (Hrivnak et al.
2000, see Sect. 1). Therefore we confirmed a
result by Hrivnak et al. (2000) that the central star of
IRAS 01005 belongs to the group of carbon-rich PPNe.
![]() |
Figure 3: The He I and Balmer line profile variations. The suggested systemic velocity -23 km s-1 is shown by vertical dashed lines. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
In the spectra obtained in 2000, the hydrogen Balmer lines
H
,
H
and H
have asymmetric single-peaked
emission profiles (Fig. 3) with a maximum intensity at a
of -40 km s-1. The intensity of the blue
wing decreases faster at low velocities than that of the red wing,
while the situation is reversed at velocities more than
40 km s-1 from the line maximum. Such a profile can be a
combination of two emission components with different intensities
and a component due to self-absorption. In 2001 the H
and
H
profile shape became double-peaked with the intensities,
which differ by an order of magnitude.
The He I line profiles vary from straight to inverse
P Cyg-type through almost pure emission or absorption
(Fig. 3). Furthermore, in the spectrum obtained on December 02, 2001 with R=60 000 a straight P Cyg-type profile of the
Å line and an inverse P Cyg-type profile of the
Å line are seen together. At the same time, in
this spectrum the He I line at
Å, which
does not show emission wings, is split into two absorption
components, as if a weak emission in the core is present. Finally,
on July 06, 2000 the
Å and
Å lines have inverse P Cyg-type profiles with the emission and
absorption components at -75 and -27 km s-1,
respectively. However, on July 13, 2000 noticeable emission
components are absent in both lines.
| Ion (Mult.) | Jul. 2000 | Nov. 2000 | Aug. 2001 | Dec. 2001 | Jan. 2002 | Feb. 2002 |
| Absorption lines | ||||||
| C II (16) | -49 (4) | -31 (3) | -50 (3) | |||
| N II (3) | -38 (6) | -50 (5) | -41 (5) | -25 (5) | -43 (5) | |
| O II (1) | -47 (8) | -30 (6) | -41 (7) | -47 (7) | ||
| Al III (2) | -46 (2) | -51 (2) | -46 (2) | -33 (2) | -47 (2) | |
| Si III (2,4) | -50 (4) | -48 (1) | -45 (1) | -32 (2) | -39 (3) | -43 (1) |
| Fe III (5) | -27 (2) | -23 (2) | -23 (1) | |||
| H |
-92 | |||||
| H |
-84 | -105, -75 | -118, -80 | |||
| H |
-179 | -103, -73 | ||||
| Emission lines | ||||||
|
|
-58 (6) | -51 (3) | -51 (1) | -53 (3) | ||
| Fe III (5) | -72 (2) | -67 (2) | ||||
| Si II (2,4,5) | -54 (6) | -49 (3) | -55 (4) | -56 (4) | -50 (4) | |
| H |
-35 | -32, -124 | ||||
| H |
-45 | -34 | -100, -30 | -32 | -35 | |
| H |
-43 | -39 | ||||
The
behaviour of individual lines is more
complicated. The
of both the absorption and emission
lines correlate with the oscillator strengths (Fig. 4): the
stronger lines have more negative velocities. This is more likely a
result of a velocity gradient in the expanding envelope and
atmosphere of the supergiant. Furthermore, the slope of the linear
relationship varies from one spectrum to another (Fig. 4).
The systemic velocity we define as a limiting velocity of the lines
with small oscillator strengths. For all our spectra this limit is
km s-1.
In Table 4 we show the heliocentric
derived
from absorption and emission lines and/or their components at
different epochs. A typical uncertainty of the
measurements for a single line is about 1 km s-1 for the
spectrometer NES, 2 km s-1 for LYNX, and 4 km s-1 for
PFES. A significant shift (-15 km s-1) in most of the
absorption line
(except for those of Fe III)
occurred in December 2001. This phenomenon may be due to changes in
the star's atmospheric structure, which may also cause the
disappearance of the H
line absorption component. Pulsations
as a mechanism, responsible for similar
variations,
was suggested by García-Lario et al. (1997) for
V1853 Cyg. Our present time coverage does not allow us to comment
on other possible reasons for it, such as orbital motion in a
binary system.
![]() |
Figure 4:
Relations between the heliocentric |
| Open with DEXTER | |
![]() |
Figure 5: The Na I D1 (dotted) and D2 (solid) line profiles in high resolution spectra of Dec. 2001 (a) and Feb. 2002 (b). |
| Open with DEXTER | |
In Fig. 5 the Na I resonance doublet profiles,
obtained with the R=60 000 on two different dates, are shown. We
were able to distinguish five absorption components with velocities
of -11, -28, -52, -65, and -73 km s-1. In addition,
the absorption profile of the
5890 Å line in the
spectrum of December 2, 2001 is superseded on a broad high-velocity
emission component, whose width is the same as those of the
hydrogen line emission components. In the other spectrum there
are no noticeable emission components. The first and the
strongest absorption component has a
of
-3 km s-1 with respect to local standard of rest, and is
most likely interstellar. The radio observations of the CO
emission (Grenier et al. 1989) and those of the
interstellar Na I lines for nearby stars in the direction
of IRAS 01005 (e.g., Welty et al. 1994) give the LSR
velocity for the interstellar medium from -8 to +10 km s-1.
The next Na I component in the spectrum of IRAS 01005 (at
-28 km s-1) is located very close to the systemic
velocity. It may be formed in the outer, slowest (
-10 km s-1), and optically thin part of the circumstellar
envelope. The three remaining components may arise either in more
rapidly expanding shells or in the interstellar medium.
The spectral features mentioned above led us to the following
suggestions. The system of IRAS 01005 contains a high-luminosity
early-B type star surrounded by a gaseous envelope. The
transformation of the He I line profiles from inverse (in
2000) to straight (in 2001) P Cyg-type is suggestive of a change
from accretion to outflow in the inner parts of the envelope. The
increasing separation between the emission components of the H
line observed simultaneously supports the outflow
hypothesis. The co-existence of the straight and inverse
P Cyg-type profiles in different He I lines in one
spectrum suggests that accretion and outflow can be present at the
same time, however probably in different parts of the envelope.
The difference in the profile shapes of the Balmer and He I
lines may be due to a more spherical zone of the He I line
formation, as it has been suggested for an LBV candidate
MWC 314 (Frémat et al. 1998).
The presence of the relation between the line velocity and the oscillator strength may be due to the velocity gradient in the unstable atmosphere of IRAS 01005. Phases of atmosphere instability from time to time alternate with phases of a relative quiescence, characterized by a low or negligible velocity gradient (Fig. 4).
Given a high luminosity, the star should be distant. From his optical photometry, Hu (2001) suggested that the interstellar extinction AV=1.2, while not attempting a distance estimate, as IRAS 01005 is peculiar. Indeed, both luminosity and kinematic distance calibrations are mostly based on the galactic disk stars, while IRAS 01005 most likely belongs to the halo. Our result for AV (Sect. 3.1) might imply that part of the extinction is circumstellar.
Let us try to estimate the luminosity and distance of
IRAS 01005 by using the values
K and
we obtained. As follows from the locus of likely
post-AGB stars in the
vs.
plane (Fig. 3
from Schönberner & Blöcker 1993), we can adopt
a mass of the object of
.
According to theoretical post-AGB evolutionary tracks
(Blöcker 1995), such an object would have a luminosity of
(
). From the observed
V=11.2 mag (Hu 2001) and the interstellar (and
circumstellar) extinction AV=1.2 mag, we have the
dereddened V0=10 mag and, accepting the bolometric correction
BC=-2 mag, we obtain
V0-MV=12.3 mag, that
corresponds to a distance of
3 kpc. Taking into account the
uncertainities in the effective temperature and surface gravity
(see Sect. 3.2), we estimate an error of the distance
determination to be about 20%. Such a distance is consistent with
the presence of the sodium D-lines absorption components at
km s-1 that may be due to the
interstellar material within the Perseus arm (Münch 1957).
The interstellar origin of the higher-velocity components
(see Fig. 5) requires a larger distance toward the object,
which would make it more luminous and more rapidly evolving along the
post-AGB track. Since there is no evidence of rapid evolution, one
can suggest that these components were formed in the circumstellar
envelope ejected during the AGB-phase.
The reduced metallicity of IRAS 01005
in combination with the altered
CNO-abundances (
)
and the high galactic latitude,
suggests that it is a hot post-AGB star. If its luminosity and,
hence, mass are large enough, the star's
will
increase quickly (Blöcker 1995). As a result, one can
expect an increase of the emission-line strengths in the object's
spectrum, because in comparison with other early-type PPNe (OY
Gem and IRAS 18062+2410), IRAS 01005 shows a relatively weak
emission-line spectrum. Alternatively, the latter might imply that
its gaseous envelope is compact, being limited by the presence of
a companion star. Another indication for binarity can be the
envelope's asphericity (inferred from the emission line
profiles). Therefore, further spectroscopic monitoring of
IRAS 01005 is highly desirable to further constrain its
properties.
We accomplished the first detailed indentification of the observed
features in the high-resolution optical spectrum of an optical
counterpart of the PPN candidate IRAS 01005. The absorption lines
of C II/ III, N II, O II, Al III,
Si II/ III, and the Mg II
Å line, as well as emission lines of Si II and [Fe II]
were found in the spectrum. Both emission and absorption
components are present in the hydrogen Balmer lines, in the
resonance Na I D1,2 lines, and in the He I
and Fe III lines. A significant variability of the optical
spectrum was detected: the He I lines change their profiles
from straight to inverse P Cyg-type on a timescale of days-months.
A high effective temperature
K, a low
surface gravity
,
and a reduced metallicity of IRAS 01005
(
)
in combination with the altered
atmospheric CNO-abundances (
)
and a high galactic
latitude, confirm the evolutionary state of a hot post-AGB C-rich star.
We suggest that IRAS 01005 is a high-luminosity
early-B type post-AGB star at a distance of
3 kpc, surrounded by a non-spherical gaseous envelope with
both observable accretion and outflow. The envelope geometry and
weakness of the emission-line spectrum may indicate binarity of
the system.
Acknowledgements
We are much indebted to the anonymous referee, who stimulated the analysis of the chemical composition of IRAS 01005. This work was supported in part by Russian Foundation for Basic Research (project No. 02-02-16085). The research described in this publication was made possible in part by Award No. RP1-2264 of the U.S. Civilian Research & Development Foundation for the Independent States of the Former Soviet Union (CRDF). This research has made use of the SIMBAD database operated at CDS (Strasbourg, France) and of the VALD database operated at Vienna.