A&A 381, 703-708 (2002)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20011557
P. P. Korsun13 - K. Jockers 2
1 - Main Astronomical Observatory, Ukrainian Academy of Sciences, Kyiv,
Ukraine
2 -
Max-Planck-Institute for Aeronomy, Kaltenburg-Lindau, Germany
3 - Isaac Newton Institute of Chile, Kiev
Branch, Ukraine
Received 31 July 2001 / Accepted 24 October 2001
Abstract
Comet C/1999 J3 (LINEAR) was observed with 2 m
telescope of the Pik Terskol Observatory on September 19, 1999. Narrow-band
CCD images of the CN, NH2, and dust atmospheres were recorded
with
the Two-Channel focal reducer of the Max-Plank-Institute for Aeronomy. The
distributions of the CN and NH2 molecules in the comet atmosphere
were fitted with a Monte
Carlo model. For the CN atmosphere the best agreement between
observed and calculated surface profiles was reached with the CN
photodissociation lifetime
s and with the
parent photodissociation lifetime
s. This result indicates that HCN is the main source
of the CN radicals in the atmosphere of comet C/1999 J3 (LINEAR). Regarding the
NH2 radicals, there is no doubt that NH3 is the dominant source of
this species in the comet atmosphere. The lifetimes
s for NH2 and
s for its parent are close to theoretical
calculations. The gas-production rates of CN,
mol s-1, and NH2,
mol s-1 have
also been determined. The appearance of the comet and the obtained
data show that the comet is a gaseous one.
The
values are 21.6 cm for the blue spectral window and 23.4 cm
for the red one. The normalized spectral gradient of the cometary dust is low,
4.0% per 1000 Å. The ratio log((
/Q(CN)) = -24.25
indicates a very low dust to gas ratio as well.
Key words: comets: individual: C/1999 J3 (LINEAR) - molecular processes - methods: numerical
Comet C/1999 J3 (LINEAR) was discovered by
the LINEAR
team on May 12, 1999. The new object was initially identified as an asteroid.
Its cometary nature was later revealed by observers at Klet
Observatory in the Czech Republic. According to the orbital elements the comet
has a period of 63 000 years and is not a "new'' comet. It passed its
perihelion on September 20, 1999 and reached a magnitude of 7.5 in the middle of
October.
Observations of comet C/1999 J3 were made with the the 2m telescope of
the Pik Terskol Observatory on September 19, 1999, one day before the comet's
perihelion passage. The heliocentric and geocentric distances of the comet were
0.977 AU and 0.983 AU respectively. The Two-Channel focal reducer of the
Max-Planck-Institute for Aeronomy equipped with CCD detectors (Jockers 1997)
was used to study the comet's atmosphere. The observed sky fields were
arcmin with a pixel size of 1.0 arcsec and
arcmin
with a pixel size of 0.8 arcsec in the blue and red channels, respectively. The
interference filters IF390 (
nm, FWHM=10.5 nm) and IF662
(
nm, FWHM=5.9 nm) were chosen to isolate the emissions of
the CN and NH2 molecules. The underlying dust continua were determined
from observations through interference filters IF642 (
nm,
FWHM=2.6 nm) and IF443 (
nm, FWHM=4.4 nm). More details on
the observed data can be found in Table 1.
Date (UT) | Exposure | Aperture size | Pixel size | Interference filter | |||
September, 1999 | s | arcmin | arcsec | Designation |
![]() |
FWHM, Å | Species |
19.004 | 600 |
![]() |
![]() |
IF390 | 3894 | 105 | CN |
19.014 | 600 |
![]() |
![]() |
IF443 | 4432 | 44 | Dust |
19.004 | 600 |
![]() |
![]() |
IF662 | 6621 | 59 | NH2 |
19.014 | 600 |
![]() |
![]() |
IF642 | 6416 | 26 | Dust |
The original CCD frames were bias subtracted, flat-fielded and cleaned of cosmic events. Star trails were also removed from the comet images. The night sky level was estimated from the parts of the sky field not covered by the cometary coma and was subtracted. The cometary counts were converted to an absolute intensity scale using observations of the standard star 15 UMa. Its flux was taken from Voloshina et al. (1982).
Cometary images obtained through the interference filters IF390 and IF662 contain
the CN and NH2 emissions as well as dust continuum. Therefore, in order
to study the distribution of these molecules in the atmosphere of comet C/1999 J3
the dust continuum must be removed. This is done by subtraction of the
appropriately scaled continuum images from the images containing emission and
dust. The continuum scaling
factor k can be calculated taking into account the wavelength dependence of the solar
spectrum
and the effect of the reddened cometary continuum
![]() |
(1) |
Here the subscripts 642 and 443 refer to the interference filters IF642 and IF443
and the subscripts m+d and d to the interference filters used for
observation of the molecule and the adjacent dust continuum (i.e. 390 and 443 for CN and
662 and 642 for NH2).
denotes the solar flux
convoluted with the transmission curve of the filter indicated in the subscript,
is the wavelength, and
the corresponding
albedo-filling factor-distance product (see Sect. 4.3).
The solar spectrum was taken from Arvesen et al. (1969).
Preliminary results of these observations have been published recently (Korsun & Jockers 2000).
For the analysis of our data we use a random walk model which is based on the Monte Carlo simulation. Such a model regarding the movement of a test particle in a collision environment has been discussed in detail by Cashwell & Everett (1959). The basic ideas of this model have been adapted by Combi and co-authors to explain the formation of cometary neutral comae. The details of the algorithm were described by Combi & Delsemme (1980) and Combi & Smyth (1988).
The fundamental equation of this model is as follows.
If p(x)dx is the
probability of x lying between x and
and if it is known that xalways is in the
range
,
i.e.
then
a properly distributed random value of x is found by solving
![]() |
(2) |
First of all we must define a background environment in which
we trace the test particles. Because water molecules dominate in
cometary atmospheres, their spatial distribution can serve this purpose.
The number density of the water targets )
is written as
where
is the radial distance from the nucleus,
Q(H2O) the water
production rate, and
the water outflow velocity.
We take the 1/
dependence without exponential factor according to the
discussion of Combi & Smyth (1988).
In our calculations we use as a model parameter
(Jockers et al. 2000). For the water outflow
velocity we used the in situ measurements by Giotto in the atmosphere of Comet
Halley
(Lämmerzahl et al. 1987). We assumed that the outflow velocity of
the
investigated parent molecules is the same as for water.
Because around the time of our observations comet C/1999 J3 did not show a brightness
variability other than the monotonic dependence on heliocentric distance,
we assume that
the molecular production rate is constant. So, an individual parent molecule is released
from the nucleus at the time
![]() |
(4) |
Here
is a random number and
is the
time interval from t=0 to the moment of observation.
If the nucleus is an isotropic source of the gas, the outflow direction of
the molecule has uniform probability. Then the spherical polar angles
and
can be calculated from
![]() |
(5) |
The above three random numbers and the assumed outflow speed completely specify the initial trajectory of the parent molecule.
The parent molecule has a finite photodissociation lifetime
after
which it dissociates into simple fragments, daughter molecules, at the time
![]() |
(6) |
The initial trajectory of the daughter molecule is determined by the vector sum of the parent radial velocity plus some additional velocity of the radical, caused by the energy excess when the parent photodissociates. The direction of this additional velocity is random in the frame of the parent molecule. Further movement of the radical is controlled by the bulk distribution of the H2O molecules which represent the dominant component of cometary atmospheres. The radical collides with water targets and its post-collision trajectory is determined by the energy and momentum balance equations. Elastic molecule-molecule collisions are assumed here. The collision path length in the water atmosphere is highly dependent on radial distance as the bulk density of the water decreases quickly (see Eq. (3)). We use here Eq. (10) from Combi & Smyth (1988).
We follow the trajectory of the radical from collision to collision
until the time of
observation
or until the time
,
when
the daughter molecule photodissociates in the solar radiation field.
The photodissociation life time of the daughter fragment
is given by
![]() |
(7) |
where Ri is a new random number. To build a model atmosphere
with
satisfactory statistics we trace
particles in our calculations.
Additionally, we take into consideration the solar radiation pressure on the daughter molecules. To be compared with observations, the calculated cometary atmosphere is projected on the sky plane as it was seen by the observer.
We compared the observed surface distribution of the analyzed species with the calculated model. The Chi-square goodness-of-fit test has been adopted for this purpose.
CN molecule. Although CN is the second species which was detected in comets, so far there is no agreement among researchers regarding the nature of its parent. The most plausible hypothesis is that the HCN molecule is the major contributor to this radical in the cometary atmosphere. This molecule is stable and observed in comets. HCN is sufficiently abundant to represent the main parent molecule of CN (Ziurys et al. 1999). Additionally, recent comparison of the morphology of HCN and CN in Comet Hale-Bopp evidences that some CN jets are produced by HCN jets (Woodney et al. 1998). Nevertheless, there is probably a secondary source of CN radicals in cometary atmospheres. A likely candidate for this secondary source is dust (A'Hearn et al. 1995), however, C2N2, as suggested by Festou et al. (1998), is also possible.
From this discussion it seems reasonable to start our
model calculations assuming that the photochemical reaction
![]() |
(8) |
![]() |
(9) |
We satisfactorily fitted the observed CN atmosphere with a model having lifetimes
of
s for CN and
s for its
parent. Figure 1 shows
observed and modeled isophotes of CN with the observed CN atmosphere
as background. Profiles along and perpendicular to the solar and
anti-solar direction are presented as well.
![]() |
Figure 1:
Modelled and
observed isophotes and radial profiles of the CN atmosphere. The zero point
of radial distance is placed at the brightest point. Positive values are toward
the Sun. Radial profiles are averaged across a lane of 5
![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
At the time of our observations (September 1999) the Sun was close to the maximum of its activity. There is excellent agreement between observed and calculated data. We conclude that the assumption of HCN as parent molecule of CN is consistent with our observations.
The moderate distortion of the CN atmosphere in the tail direction is caused by the solar radiation pressure which accelerates the CN molecules tailwards. An acceleration a=0.3 cm s-2 provides the best fit of our models. This value agrees with the data of Boice (1990).
NH2 molecule. Previous observations of the NH2 surface
brightness distribution in comets were mainly derived from long-slit spectra.
Because the NH2 emission bands are weak and in many cases blended with
features of other species, it is very difficult to interpret the observations.
Tegler & Wyckoff (1989) have proposed that
NH3 is the parent of NH2. Later, this was supported by other
researchers (Krasnopolsky & Tkachuk 1991; Tegler et al. 1992;
Korsun 1995; Kawakita & Watanabe 1998).
Theoretical calculations of the lifetimes for NH2 and its
parent have been provided by Allen et al. (1987), Tegler et al.
(1992), Van Dishoeck (1992, cited as private communication in
Feldman et al. 1993), and Huebner & Link (1999). According to
Huebner & Link (1999) there are several ways to produce NH2from NH3. In the solar radiation field the reaction
displayed below is dominant.
![]() |
(11) |
![]() |
Figure 2:
Modelled and
observed isophotes and radial profiles for the NH2 atmosphere. The zero point
of radial distance is placed at the brightest point. Positive values are
toward the Sun. Radial profiles are averaged across a lane of 4
![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
We interpret here observations of the two-dimensional NH2 atmosphere.
Previously this was only done by Tegler et al. (1992).
Our computed
surface profiles are in reasonably good agreement with the observed ones, if
we adopt the theoretical values for the time scales of NH2,
(NH
s, and
(NH
s for its parent, the NH3 molecule. We conclude that NH3 is
probably the dominant source of NH2 in the coma of comet C/1999 J3 (LINEAR).
Figure 2 shows the comparison of the model and observed data. A tailward acceleration
of the NH2 molecules by the solar radiation pressure a=0.27 cm s-2(Boice 1990) was taken into account and leads to a satisfactory description
of the sunward distortion of the observed coma.
If we know the amount of molecules
used in the Monte-Carlo model,
and the model production rate,
,
then the total gas production
rate of the modeled species,
[mol s-1] can be expressed as
![]() |
(13) |
The g-factor of CN has been computed by Schleicher (A'Hearn et al. 1995).
We used the
value of 2.4
10-13 erg s-1 mol-1 valid for a
heliocentric velocity of comet C/1999 J3 (LINEAR) at the moment of observation
of -0.5 km s-1. From our model parameters
and
and
Eq. (12) we get
mol s-1.
To determine the gas production rate for NH2 we have used the revised
g-factor for the (0, 7, 0) band derived by Kawakita et al.
(2001),
erg s-1 mol-1.
As a result we find the NH2 production rate
mol s-1.
The water production rate for this comet has been determined by
Jockers et al. (2000) from H2O+ observations using
MHD similarity law. The value of
mol s-1was found.
Comparison with our data shows that
Q(CN)/Q(H
% and Q(NH2)/Q(H
%. If the number
of NH2 molecules in the cometary atmospheres accounts for
96% of NH3 (see Sect. 4.1) then
Q(NH3)/Q(H
% in comet C/1999 J3 (LINEAR).
These results agree with values obtained previously for a number
of comets. CCD spectroscopy of 39 comets suggests that
Q(CN)/Q(H
)
varies between 0.11% and 0.30% (Fink &
Hicks 1996). Our ammonia abundance of 0.45% is
comparable with the values derived from recent direct
measurements in the radio range of comet C/1996 B2 (Hyakutake), 0.6%, and comet
C/1995 O1 (Hale-Bopp), 0.7% (Bird et al. 1997). Previous determinations of
the ammonia abundance derived from observations of NH2 in the visual
wavelength range yield values
from 0.05% to 0.20% (Fink & Hicks 1996; Wyckoff et al.
1991). They must be corrected in accordance with the
revised g-factors of NH2.
As we have CCD frames taken in two different cometary
dust continuum windows we can estimate the dust production rate and
dust color of the comet C/1999 J3. It has become customary to determine the
product to characterize the dust coma of a comet (A'Hearn et al.
1984). This value is proportional to the dust production rate and
is independent of the projected distance
from the cometary nucleus if
the cometary continuum brightness follows a
law. The
albedo - filling factor - distance product
is defined as
![]() |
(14) |
Because the aperture of the CCD chip is larger than the size of the detectable
cometary dust coma, and Eq. (14) is valid only if the cometary continuum
brightness follows a
law, we determine an effective radius,
,
in our calculations. It is obtained by analyzing the
slope of the average dust brightness profiles where it follows a
law. As a result, we derive (
cm for the blue continuum window and
(
cm for the red continuum red window.
data have been obtained
for many comets and show a wide scatter (Storrs et al. 1992; A'Hearn
et al. 1995). The so-called gaseous comets have low
values, like comet C/1999 J3.
The derived
values allow to estimate the
color of the cometary dust as the normalized gradient of the
product,
.
It is defined by
![]() |
(15) |
Finally, we can calculate the ratio
(CN)), as was done
previously by A'Hearn et al. (1995).
The calculated value, -24.25, exhibits a very low ratio of dust to CN. This is
characteristic for gaseous comets. Moreover, only two comets from 85 analyszed
ones have a ratio less than our value (A'Hearn et al. 1995).
Table 2 summarizes our results on the coma of comet C/1999 J3
(LINEAR).
Parameter | Value |
Lifetime of CN |
![]() |
Lifetime of parent of CN |
![]() |
Lifetime of NH2 |
![]() |
Lifetime of parent of NH2 |
![]() |
Production rate of
H2O![]() |
![]() |
Production rate of CN |
![]() |
Q(CN)/Q(H2O) | 0.24% |
Production rate of NH2 |
![]() |
Q(NH2)/Q(H2O) | 0.43% |
![]() ![]() |
21.6 cm |
![]() |
-24.25 |
![]() ![]() |
23.4 cm |
Color of the dust | 4.0% |
Acknowledgements
We thank the personnel of the Pik Terskol Observatory for assistance with the observations. P. Korsun acknowledges support by a grant of the Ministry for Science and Education of Ukraine.