Asteroseismology is a powerful tool to explore the internal structure of stars and test the predictions of stellar evolution. Its application to the late stages of medium mass stellar evolution, i.e., to planetary nebulae nuclei and white dwarfs, has been particularly fruitful owing to the short period oscillations observed in these compact stars, allowing the accumulation of a large number of pulsation cycles over relatively short observation times. The organization of coordinated multisite observing campaigns was a breakthrough in the study of compact multiperiodic pulsators. In this respect, the Whole Earth Telescope network (WET, Nather et al. 1990), performing coordinated photometric campaigns, successfully contributed to this effort.
In these late stages of stellar evolution, stars have several opportunities
to become pulsationally unstable.
The first instability region is encountered during the high
luminosity planetary nebula phase, and nine variable planetary nebulae
nuclei (PNNV) are presently known (Ciardullo & Bond 1996).
The second
instability region is found among the pre-white dwarf stars of the PG 1159
spectral type, which are direct
descendants of a significant fraction of PNN. These stars have passed the turning
point in the H-R diagram, where planetary nebulae nuclei reach their
highest effective temperature and start cooling towards lower temperatures and
luminosities, as they begin contracting towards the white dwarf
cooling sequence. Six such pulsating PG 1159 stars, also known as
GW Vir variable stars, are presently known.
Five are plain PG 1159 type stars that show no hydrogen in their spectra:
PG 1159-035 (McGraw et al. 1979;
Winget et al. 1991),
PG 2131+066 (Bond et al. 1984; Kawaler et al. 1995),
PG 1707+427 (Bond et al. 1984; Fontaine et al. 1991;
Grauer et al. 1992),
PG 0122+200 (Bond & Grauer 1987; Vauclair et al. 1995;
O'Brien et al.
1996, 1998; Vauclair et al. 2001)
and RXJ 2117+3412, the subject of this paper.
The sixth object, HS 2324+3944 (Silvotti
1996; Silvotti et al. 1999),
is a "hybrid'' PG 1159 type star, which has hydrogen in its spectrum.
Both the PNNV and the PG 1159 instability
strips are not "pure'' instability strips, i.e., both non-variable and variable
stars are present in the same temperature and luminosity range. We still do not
understand why stars of the same effective
temperature and surface gravity, have some that pulsate, while others do not. In the
case of the PG 1159 type stars, the only known distinction comes
from spectroscopy: pulsating PG 1159 stars show nitrogen in their spectra while
non-pulsating PG 1159 stars do not (Dreizler 1998; Dreizler & Heber
1998).
However, there is the noticeable and puzzling
exception of PG 1144+005, which shows N in its spectrum at the same level
as the pulsating PG 1159 stars, but was not found to pulsate (Grauer et al. 1987).
Observatory | Location | Telescopes | (m) | |
1992 | 1993 | 1994 | ||
OMP | Pic du Midi, France | 2.0 | ||
Teide | Tenerife, Canary Islands | 1.5 | 0.8 | |
Roque de los Muchachos | La Palma, Canary Islands | 2.5 | 1.0 | |
LNA | Itajuba, Brazil | 1.6 | ||
McDonald | Mount Locke, Texas | 2.0 | 0.9 | 2.0, 2.6 |
Steward Observatory | Mount Bigelow, Arizona | 1.5 | ||
Steward Observatory | Mount Lemmon, Arizona | 1.5 | ||
U. of Hawaii | Mauna Kea, Hawaii | 0.6 | 0.6 | |
Siding Spring | Siding Spring Mt., Australia | 1.0 | ||
Beijing Observatory | Xinglong, China | 2.1 | ||
Vainu Bappu | Kavalur, India | 2.2 | 1.0 | |
Maidanak | Maidanak, Uzbekistan | 1.0 | 1.0 | |
Wise | Mount Ramon, Israel | 1.0 | ||
Suhora | Mount Suhora, Poland | 0.6 | 0.6 | 0.6 |
For completeness, we note that there are
two more white dwarf instability strips.
They are the pulsating helium atmosphere
white dwarfs (8 DBVs known) and the pulsating hydrogen atmosphere white dwarfs
(31
DAVs or ZZ Cetis known).
The DBV instability strip is not a "pure'' instability strip either. The
fraction of non-variable stars found within the instability strip varies
between 25% and
50% depending whether their
atmospheric parameters are derived from pure He model atmospheres or from
model atmospheres allowing for a small admixture of undetectable
hydrogen (Beauchamp et al. 1999).
In contrast with the PNNV, PG 1159 and DBV instability strips, the DAVs
form a "pure'' instability strip, i.e., no stable stars are found within
the domain of the HR diagram (or equivalently in the
-
diagram) where the DAVs are located, once the mass dependence
of the blue edge of the instability strip is properly accounted for (Kepler et al.
2000). The list and the properties of the variable planetary nebulae nuclei,
variable PG 1159 type stars, DBVs and DAVs are summarized in Bradley (2000).
The variable stars in the pre-white dwarf evolutionary stage and on the white dwarf cooling sequence are non-radial gravity mode pulsators. This is unambiguously demonstrated for the two ZZ Cetis, R 548 (Robinson et al. 1982) and G 117-B15A (Kepler 1984). In the framework of the linear pulsation theory, it has been possible to extract fundamental stellar parameters for most of the pulsators in the PG 1159 instability strip: the total mass from the period spacing, the rotational period from the frequency splitting, the depth of the chemical composition transition zone between the helium-rich outer layer and the carbon-oxygen core etc. As a by-product of the asteroseismological analysis, the luminosity and distance can be derived for each star (Winget et al. 1994). In the case of the PNNV, few have been studied with the same scrutiny, because observing them requires CCD photometry campaigns to remove the surrounding nebula. In addition, the PNNV mode amplitudes vary on short time scales (days to weeks), making the mode identification difficult. However, the best studied case, NGC 1501 (Bond et al. 1996) shows many similarities with the GW Vir stars. The evolutionary link between the PNN and the PG 1159 stars is now well established and the stellar parameters deduced from asteroseismology of PNNV and GW Vir stars provide further confirmation.
The discovery that RXJ 2117+3412, an X-ray source detected in the ROSAT
sky survey, is a member of the PG 1159 spectral class (Motch et al. 1993)
is an additional
evidence of an evolutionary link between the PNN and the white dwarfs.
The low surface brightness planetary nebula surrounding RXJ 2117+3412
was discovered
to be the largest planetary nebula known
(Appleton et al. 1993). The nebula has an angular diameter of 13 arcmin, and at an estimated
distance of 1.4 kpc (Motch et al. 1993), its linear extent
should be about 5.3 pc. Furthermore, the complex
structure of the nebula, which shows many thin filaments, is reminiscent of
the structure predicted for the shock produced when a
"superwind'' generated by the hot central star collides with
the material ejected at
the end of the previous AGB phase (Appleton et al. 1993).
|
Telescope | Date | Start Time | Run Length |
(UT) | (UTC) | (s) | ||
|
Suhora 60 cm | 22 September 92 | 01:07:15 | 4155 |
jesem-05 | Maidanak 1 m | 22 September 92 | 16:00:00 | 19930 |
x-8008 | Suhora 60 cm | 22 September 92 | 23:32:30 | 9550 |
int-0014 | Isaak Newton 2.5 m | 24 September 92 | 01:05:40 | 5920 |
ro-021 | Itajuba 1.6 m | 24 September 92 | 01:23:40 | 5825 |
pab-0147 | McDonald 82
![]() |
24 September 92 | 07:15:30 | 7620 |
jesem-06 | Maidanak 1 m | 24 September 92 | 14:49:50 | 22765 |
x-8011 | Suhora 60 cm | 25 September 92 | 01:05:10 | 4685 |
int-0017 | Isaak Newton 2.5 m | 25 September 92 | 20:50:10 | 18695 |
x-8013 | Suhora 60 cm | 25 September 92 | 23:53:20 | 6670 |
pab-0156 | McDonald 82
![]() |
26 September 92 | 01:46:00 | 14135 |
jesem-10 | Maidanak 1 m | 26 September 92 | 15:22:30 | 17945 |
x-8016 | Suhora 60 cm | 27 September 92 | 00:38:00 | 7480 |
int-0019 | Isaak Newton 2.5 m | 27 September 92 | 02:00:30 | 6025 |
pab-0160 | McDonald 82
![]() |
27 September 92 | 08:10:30 | 5260 |
maw-0107 | Mauna Kea 24
![]() |
27 September 92 | 10:35:20 | 5845 |
x-8018 | Suhora 60 cm | 27 September 92 | 21:26:45 | 17025 |
int-0022 | Isaak Newton 2.5 m | 28 September 92 | 01:27:40 | 7765 |
pab-0163 | McDonald 82
![]() |
28 September 92 | 06:54:30 | 9915 |
x-8019 | Suhora 60 cm | 28 September 92 | 18:27:35 | 2095 |
pab-0166 | McDonald 82
![]() |
29 September 92 | 07:39:00 | 6975 |
ro-023 | Itajuba 1.6 m | 29 September 92 | 22:15:50 | 16245 |
pab-0168 | McDonald 82
![]() |
30 September 92 | 01:40:30 | 28170 |
maw-0111 | Mauna Kea 24
![]() |
30 September 92 | 05:30:00 | 24085 |
sjk-0208 | Siding Spring 40
![]() |
30 September 92 | 12:02:00 | 8240 |
ro-025 | Itajuba 1.6 m | 30 September 92 | 23:51:40 | 8410 |
pab-0171 | McDonald 82
![]() |
1 October 92 | 01:50:00 | 27345 |
maw-0114 | Mauna Kea 24
![]() |
1 October 92 | 08:36:20 | 14360 |
x-8020 | Suhora 60 cm | 1 October 92 | 20:29:00 | 9780 |
pab-0173 | McDonald 82
![]() |
2 October 92 | 01:50:00 | 26910 |
maw-0118 | Mauna Kea 24
![]() |
3 October 92 | 06:02:20 | 15230 |
|
Telescope | Date | Start Time | Run Length |
(UT) | (UTC) | (s) | ||
|
TCS 1.5 m | 14 September 93 | 21:26:00 | 15420 |
rx-0915 | TCS 1.5 m | 15 September 93 | 20:46:00 | 20670 |
suh-0001 | Suhora 60 cm | 15 September 93 | 21:19:40 | 5260 |
a-402 | Mt. Bigelow 61
![]() |
16 September 93 | 03:51:00 | 19310 |
k93-0214 | Kavalur 90
![]() |
16 September 93 | 18:14:00 | 8325 |
rx-0916 | TCS 1.5 m | 16 September 93 | 21:29:00 | 14660 |
rx-0917 | TCS 1.5 m | 17 September 93 | 20:13:00 | 21690 |
a-404 | Mt. Bigelow 61
![]() |
18 September 93 | 02:36:00 | 21430 |
k93-0215 | Kavalur 90
![]() |
18 September 93 | 14:16:10 | 18390 |
suh-0002 | Suhora 60 cm | 18 September 93 | 18:47:00 | 5890 |
rx-0918 | TCS 1.5 m | 18 September 93 | 20:19:00 | 21910 |
a-405 | Mt. Bigelow 61
![]() |
19 September 93 | 02:46:00 | 22500 |
suh-0003 | Suhora 60 cm | 19 September 93 | 18:16:00 | 30210 |
rx-0919 | TCS 1.5 m | 19 September 93 | 20:48:00 | 19100 |
a-407 | Mt. Bigelow 61
![]() |
20 September 93 | 02:39:00 | 28930 |
ra-288 | McDonald 36
![]() |
20 September 93 | 03:34:40 | 18120 |
suh-0004 | Suhora 60 cm | 20 September 93 | 19:17:30 | 23685 |
rx-0920 | TCS 1.5 m | 20 September 93 | 20:27:00 | 20390 |
a-408 | Mt. Bigelow 61
![]() |
21 September 93 | 02:29:00 | 28460 |
a-409 | Mt. Lemmon 60
![]() |
22 September 93 | 02:43:00 | 27070 |
suh-0005 | Suhora 60 cm | 22 September 93 | 19:16:00 | 21825 |
rx-0922 | TCS 1.5 m | 22 September 93 | 20:37:00 | 19530 |
a-410 | Mt. Lemmon 60
![]() |
23 September 93 | 02:37:00 | 27300 |
suh-0006 | Suhora 60 cm | 23 September 93 | 18:33:00 | 20515 |
rx-0923a | TCS 1.5 m | 23 September 93 | 20:21:00 | 4620 |
rx-0923b | TCS 1.5 m | 23 September 93 | 22:51:00 | 4720 |
The subsequent analysis of a HST high resolution spectrum of
RXJ 2117+3412, using NLTE model atmosphere, indicates that it is
the hottest known PG 1159 type star with
K,
+0.3-0.2, and abundance ratios typical of other PG 1159 stars:
/23.8/6.2 (by numbers) (Werner et al. 1996;
Rauch & Werner 1997). The HST spectrum also
shows evidence of ongoing mass loss from the central star. The mass loss
is confirmed by more recent observations; it is estimated to be of the order of
=
from C IV line (Koesterke
et al.
1998), or
from O VI line
(Koesterke &
Werner 1998), with a terminal velocity of 3500 km s-1.
Because of the association of a planetary nebula with a PG 1159-type central star,
and because it is
close to the point in the HR diagram where high luminosity PNN turn to
lower effective temperature and luminosity to join the white dwarf
cooling sequence (Dreizler & Heber 1998, see their Fig. 8),
RXJ 2117+3412 is presently the best example of a PNN on its way to the
white dwarf sequence.
Shortly after RXJ 2117+3412 was announced as a new PG 1159 type star, photometric observations were performed to determine whether it is a pulsator. Watson (1992) and Vauclair et al. (1993) independently discovered that RXJ 2117+3412 is pulsating. This opened the opportunity to investigate the internal structure and evolutionary status of this unique object.
This paper presents the results of an asteroseismological study of RXJ 2117+3412. The observational campaigns, which cover the 1992, 1993 and 1994 seasons are described in Sect. 2. Section 3 gives the analysis of the power spectra. The various stellar parameters derived for RXJ 2117+3412 from this analysis are discussed in Sect. 4. Section 5 summarizes the results and suggests some ideas for future work.
Copyright ESO 2001