A&A 379, 557-563 (2001)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20011333
M. Benedettini1 - S. Pezzuto1 - T. Giannini2 - D. Lorenzetti2 - B. Nisini2
1 - CNR-Istituto di Fisica dello Spazio Interplanetario, Area di
Ricerca di Tor Vergata,
via del Fosso del Cavaliere 100, 00133, Roma, Italy
2 -
Osservatorio Astronomico di Roma, via Frascati 33, 00040, Monte Porzio,
Italy
Received 16 July 2001 / Accepted 20 September 2001
Abstract
The ISO-SWS full grating spectrum (2.3-45 m) of the Herbig Be star MWC 297
is presented. The spectrum is dominated by a strong continuum with superimposed
emission lines and features both in absorption and in emission. In particular,
we detect in emission 23 H I recombination lines of the Brackett, Pfund and Humphreys series
and four PAH features, while in absorption two broad silicate bands at 9.7 and
16.4
m, solid CO2 at 4.27
m and solid H2O at 2.96
m have been
observed. The ISO-SWS spectrum has been combined with ISO-LWS data and ground
based photometry to derive the spectral energy distribution (SED) from optical
to radio wavelengths. The observed SED has been fitted with a model that assumes
a spherical dusty envelope parametrized by density and temperature power laws,
deriving suitable values for the spectral type (B2), the visual extinction
(7.5 mag) and the distance (280 pc). Consistent determination of the extinction
and estimates of both the source mass loss rate (
yr-1) and the size of the emitting ionized region (30 stellar
radii) have been derived by the analysis of the H I recombination lines
of the Brackett, Pfund and Humphreys series observed by ISO-SWS together with
Paschen and Brackett lines observed from the ground. Some peculiarities have
been observed in the ISO-SWS spectrum of this source: i) the ratio between
the column density of the solid
and
(
)
higher
than the values usually observed and ii) the presence of a silicate broad
absorption band at 16.4
m stronger than the 9.7
m absorption. The
observed silicate absorption features are probably due to the extended dusty
cloud in which the star is embedded and their relative strengths could be
evidence that they are composed by processed grains.
Key words: stars: circumstellar matter - stars: individual: MWC 297 - infrared:
ISM: lines and bands
MWC 297 is a highly reddened object whose optical spectrum is characterized by
the presence of hundreds of atomic emission lines (Andrillat & Jaschek 1998).
The H
line is extremely strong and broadened (Drew et al. 1997), indicating the presence of
strong winds in the stellar environment. This source has originally been
classified as a pre-Main Sequence object of intermediate mass and was inserted
in the original list of Herbig Ae/Be (HAEBE) stars (Herbig 1960); however its
evolutionary state, as well as other important physical parameters, are not yet
accurately known. Bergen et al. (1988) classified MWC 297 as a B0 star and
Cantó et al. (1984) derived a distance of 450 pc. More recently Drew et al.
(1997), from the analysis of optical spectra, revised this view attributing to
the object a spectral type B1.5, a distance of 250 pc and a later evolutionary
state. The 5 GHz radio map by Drew et al. (1997) shows that the source is
elongated in the north-south direction (
)
suggesting
the presence of an equatorial disc. The absence of polarization changes across
the H
line (Oudmaijer & Drew 1999) would imply however that the ionized
envelope is spherically symmetric. KAO images by Di Francesco et al. (1998) show
the presence of a quite extended FIR circumstellar region, whose size is
.
The dusty envelope has been resolved also at NIR
wavelengths by interferometric observations in the H and
bands
(Millan-Gabet et al. 2001). The 1.3 mm map by Henning et al. (1998) reveals a central core at the same position of the optical star, surrounded by a more extended
envelope.
![]() |
Figure 1:
ISO-SWS (2.3-45 ![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
We observed MWC 297 with the two spectrometers onboard the Infrared Space
Observatory (ISO, Kessler et al. 1996). The Long Wavelength Spectrometer (LWS,
Clegg et al. 1996) spectrum (43-197 m) presents the two [O I] lines at 63
m
and 145
m and the [C II] line at 158
m (Lorenzetti et al. 1999). The
ratio between the two [O I] lines
([O I] 63
m/[O I] 145
)
is extremely low with
respect to the predictions of both Photo-Dissociation Regions (Kaufman et al. 1999)
and shocks (Hollenbach & McKee 1989). Lorenzetti et al. (1999) suggest that the observed ratio could be due to a strong absorption of the [O I] 63
m line by
cold (
100 K) atomic oxygen present along the line of sight.
In this paper we analyze the 2.3-45 m spectrum of MWC 297, provided by the
Short Wavelength Spectrometer (SWS, de Graauw et al. 1996) in order to derive information
about the distribution and the physical parameters of the circumstellar envelope
and to investigate the properties of the ionized wind which characterizes the
early stage of the stellar evolution. In Sect. 2 the observations and the
reduction method are described and in Sect. 3 the results are presented.
The results are analyzed and discussed in Sect. 4 and the conclusions are given
in Sect. 5.
MWC 297 (RA(2000): 18h27m39.5s; DEC(2000): -0349
52.1
)
was observed with SWS and LWS onboard the ISO satellite on the 23rd
October 1997. The SWS observations were carried out with the AOT01 full
grating scan mode at speed 2, corresponding to a resolution from 250 to 600;
the LWS spectrum was obtained with the AOT01 full grating scan mode with a
resolution
200. Raw satellite data have been reduced by using the ISO-SWS
Interactive Analysis procedures (OSIA1.0) and the ISO Spectral Analysis Package
(ISAP1.6). The wavelength and flux calibrations were based on the calibration
files available in version 7 of the Off-Line Processing pipeline for the SWS
data and version 9 for the LWS data. The corresponding wavelength calibration
accuracy for the SWS spectrum is better than 1/5 of the resolution element
(Valentijn et al. 1996) and the absolute flux calibration accuracy ranges from 7% in the
short wavelength (<4.1
m) part of the spectrum to
30% in the long
wavelength (>29
m) part (Leech et al. 1997). Spurious signals due to the cosmic
ray impacts were removed and the data of the 12 detectors were averaged together
and rebinned at about twice the nominal instrumental resolution.
As regards the LWS data, we concentrate our interest on the continuum spectrum
because the emission lines have already been analyzed by Lorenzetti et al.
(1999). The overall flux accuracy of the LWS data is
30%; the final
spectrum has been obtained averaging the scans of each detector after the
de-glitching procedure.
![]() |
Figure 2: Portions of the continuum subtracted spectrum of MWC 297 where the H I recombination lines have beendetected. |
Open with DEXTER |
The ISO-SWS spectrum of MWC 297 (see Fig. 1) is dominated by a strong continuum with superimposed emission lines from the H I recombination series, PAH emission and absorption by solid CO2, H2O and silicates. We consider as a detection a feature or a line with signal to noise ratio greater than 3; for the lines a second requirement is that the FWHM is comparable with the nominal instrumental resolution.
Figure 2 shows the continuum subtracted portion of the ISO-SWS spectrum in
which the following H I recombination lines have been detected: Br,
Br
,
Pfund
lines from Pf
to Pf19 and Humphreys lines from Hu
to Hu
plus Hu14, 15 and 16. These lines are listed in Table 1 (Col. 1) together with
the fitted central wavelength (Col. 2) and the integrated flux (computed by a
Gaussian fitting) with the associated 1
statistical error (Col. 3),
which refers to the rms noise of the local baseline; for the Hu11, 12 and 13
lines the 3
upper limit is given.
The Pf
is blended with the Hu17, whose flux is expected to be smaller
than the Hu16 flux (
Wcm-2); thus we consider the
calculated line flux (
Wcm-2) as an upper limit for the
Pf
flux. All the lines are observed with the same beam aperture of
with the exception of the Hu
at 12.38
m
for which the aperture is slightly larger (
);
nevertheless, in the analysis we do not apply any beam correction to the
Hu
line because it is expected that the region responsible for the
H I recombination lines is much smaller than the beam aperture.
The comparison of the ISO-SWS Br
flux with ground-based observations
by Nisini et al. (1995) (
Wcm-2) and by Drew et al. (1997) (
Wcm-2), indicates a variability of this line, also observed in the
H
line (Drew et al. 1997).
line id. |
![]() |
![]() |
(![]() |
(10-18 Wcm-2) | |
Br![]() |
4.052 | 7.5 ![]() |
Br![]() |
2.626 | 5.5 ![]() |
Pf![]() |
7.460 | 1.3 ![]() |
Pf![]() |
4.654 | 1.6 ![]() |
Pf![]() ![]() |
3.742 | 2.1 ![]() |
Pf![]() |
3.297 | 1.42 ![]() |
Pf10 | 3.039 | 1.19 ![]() |
Pf11 | 2.873 | 1.2 ![]() |
Pf12 | 2.759 | 1.4 ![]() |
Pf13 | 2.674 | 0.9 ![]() |
Pf14 | 2.612 | 1.0 ![]() |
Pf15 | 2.564 | 0.8 ![]() |
Pf16 | 2.526 | 0.7 ![]() |
Pf17 | 2.495 | 0.7 ![]() |
Pf18 | 2.470 | 0.3 ![]() |
Pf19 | 2.450 | 0.5 ![]() |
Hu![]() |
12.38 | 0.6 ![]() |
Hu![]() |
7.703 | 0.9 ![]() |
Hu![]() |
5.908 | 0.5 ![]() |
Hu![]() |
5.129 | 0.6 ![]() |
Hu11 | 4.673 | <0.6 |
Hu12 | 4.376 | <0.6 |
Hu13 | 4.170 | <0.6 |
Hu14 | 4.021 | 0.49 ![]() |
Hu15 | 3.908 | 0.52 ![]() |
Hu16 | 3.819 | 0.5 ![]() |
Blended lines.
Other features detected in the ISO-SWS spectrum are: ice absorption at 2.96 m
and 4.27
m associated with O-H stretching mode of solid H2O and
C=O asymmetric stretching vibration of solid CO2, respectively and two broad
absorption silicate bands between 8-11
m and 12-23
m; the first, peaking
at 9.7
m, is associated to the Si-O stretching vibrations in amorphous
silicates, the second to the O-Si-O bending mode and peaks at 16.4
m. In
addition, emission features from Polyciclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) at
3.53, 6.22, 13.56 and 14.21
m have been detected. In Table 2 the detected
features are listed together with the parameters derived from the fit of their
profile: the central wavelength (Col. 2), the integrated flux with its
1
statistical error (Col. 3) and the FWHM (Col. 4).
Looking at the ISO-SWS spectra of HAEBE stars (Meeus et al. 2001) it can be noticed
that the NIR range is very similar for all the objects while in the MIR and FIR
regions a large diversity in the spectral features and shape is revealed. In
particular, in some of the sources of the Meeus et al. sample a blackbody
continuum component, features emission of PAHs and silicates are not present. In
MWC 297 we detect PAHs emission but the two silicate bands are in absorption;
silicate absorption at 9.7 m has been detected also in the HAEBE star
LkH
225 (van den Ancker et al. 2000).
id. |
![]() |
![]() |
FWHM |
(![]() |
(10-18 W cm-2) | (![]() |
|
H2O![]() |
2.96 | 7 ![]() |
0.1 |
PAH![]() |
3.53 | 2.3 ![]() |
0.03 |
CO2![]() |
4.27 | 7.5 ![]() |
0.05 |
PAH![]() |
6.22 | 3.6 ![]() |
0.1 |
silicate![]() |
9.7* | - | ![]() |
PAH![]() |
13.56 | 0.6 ![]() |
0.08 |
PAH![]() |
14.21 | 0.6 ![]() |
0.1 |
silicate![]() |
16.4* | - | ![]() |
Absorption feature.
Emission feature.
* Wavelength of the absorption peak.
The ISO-SWS and ISO-LWS spectra of MWC 297 are shown in Fig. 1 together with
ground based photometry by Berrilli et al. (1992) in the L (
m), M (
m), N1 (
m), N2 (
m), N3 (
=12.89
m) bands, the IRAS Point Source Catalog intensity at 12, 25, 60 and 100
m and the KAO data at 50 and 100
m (Di Francesco et al. 1998). The ground based photometry is in agreement with the ISO data, within the SWS
flux calibration accuracy, with the exception of the M band, but it can be due
to the strong sky absorption variability in this band. At variance, the IRAS
fluxes have significantly larger values with respect to the ISO ones, except for
the 60
m flux. In the SWS range this difference can be accounted for by
considering that the IRAS beam apertures are much larger than the ISO apertures
(
for 2.3
12
m,
for 12
27
m,
for 27
29
m,
for 29
45
m
and
for 43
197
m) and that the emitting source
is more extended than the ISO-SWS apertures, as it can be inferred by
considering that whenever the source is observed with a larger aperture, a rise
in the flux level is revealed (e.g. the gap at 27
m between the SWS
bands 2 and 3, the gap at 29
m between the SWS bands 3 and 4 and the gap at
45
m between SWS and LWS). KAO images by Di Francesco et al. (1998)
indicates that the size (FWHM) of the source at 50
m is
(
,
with a total flux density of
Jy and (
at 100
m with
a total flux density of
Jy; these values are consistent with the
ISO-LWS ones. In particular, the 100
m image reveals the presence of a
diffuse background emission which can account for the higher value measured by
IRAS. The consistency between the ISO-SWS and the ground based photometry
testifies for a no variability of the continuum emission at near and mid
infrared wavelengths, as also found in the visible range, with the exception of
the U band in which a variability is reported (Bergen et al. 1988).
![]() |
Figure 3:
SED of MWC 297: circles are ground base photometric measurements
and ISO data (binned with steps of about 10 ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
The ISO data have been complemented with photometric measurements from optical to radio wavelengths to derive the spectral energy distribution (SED) of MWC 297. The observed SED has been compared with the SED's computed with a spherical dusty envelope model in order to probe if such a circumstellar matter distribution is compatible with the observations, deriving also suitable values for the parameters of the circumstellar matter as well as of the central source. The temperature and density distributions of the circumstellar envelope are parametrized by a radial power law with index q and p, respectively. A detailed description of the model and references of the photometric data are given in Pezzuto et al. (1997).
By fitting the observed SED (Fig. 3) the following parameters have been derived:
q=0.5, p=1.1,
,
distance D=280 pc and visual extinction
mag. The model has a circumstellar extinction, due to its own
envelope, of 0.5 mag, while the interstellar extinction, found as part of the
best fit search, is 7.0 mag. This means that to fit all the data from optical
bands to radio wavelengths, a model with a small amount of circumstellar dust
has been selected. As a consequence, the silicate bands of the model are in
emission whereas in the spectrum absorption features have been observed and, in
general, the agreement between the observational data and our model is quite
poor in the region around 10
m. It is worth noting that in a sample of ISO-SWS
spectra of HAEBE stars (Meeus et al. 2001) the silicate features appear in emission
for the more evolved and not embedded objects, while the silicate at 9.7
m
has been detected in absorption in LkH
225 (van den Ancker et al. 2000). As MWC 297, as well as LkH
225, is surrounded by an extended dusty cloud, the silicate absorption can be ascribed to this extended component rather than to the star envelope. If we assume that the extended component is distinct from MWC 297, in the sense that its temperature and density are not directly related to the physical properties of the circumstellar dust around MWC 297, it is not surprising that our model fails to reproduce the observed silicate absorption
bands. In any case, the addition of ISO data with respect to the previous
results of Pezzuto et al. (1997) has improved the determination of some
parameters such as the distance and the spectral type which are now in
agreement with the values given by Drew et al. (1997). We also note that
interferometric observations (Millan-Gabet et al. 2001) at near IR wavelengths (H and
bands) are also consistent with a spherically dusty envelope
around the central star even if a model with a flat blackbody face-on disc
cannot be ruled out.
In the ISO-SWS spectrum 23 H I recombination lines of the Brackett, Pfund and Humphreys
series have been detected. Moreover observations of Brackett and Paschen lines
are available in literature, in particular Thompson et al. (1977) measured the
Brackett lines from Br10 to Br20 and Br
plus the Pa
and
Pa
lines while McGregor et al. (1984) measured the Paschen lines from
Pa
to Pa16. These H I recombination lines have been compared with a wind model (see
Benedettini et al. 1998) which considers a spherically symmetric and fully ionized envelope
with a constant rate of mass loss. The gas is assumed to be in LTE condition
with a temperature of T=104 K. The adopted gas velocity law is:
![]() |
(1) |
![]() |
Figure 4:
Line ratios of the Paschen, Brackett, Pfund and Humphreys series with
respect to the Br![]() ![]() |
Open with DEXTER |
Also in this object as well as towards other HAEBE stars observed with ISO-SWS
(i.e. MWC1080 and CoD-4211721 Benedettini et al. 1998; BD+40
4124
van den Ancker et al. 2000), the line decrement of the H I recombination spectral series can be
reproduced by assuming a ionization bounded compact region instead of a density
bounded wind model.
From the absolute flux of the Br,
Br
,
Pf
,
Pf
and under the assumption of a distance of 450 pc and of a density bounded
flow, Nisini et al. (1995) found
yr-1, slightly higher than the present result. If in our model we
assume the distance of 450 pc the corresponding best fit parameters are:
yr-1, R=60r* and
mag;
the mass loss rate and the size of the emitting region differ by a of factor 2
from the values derived with D=250 pc while the visual extinction does not
change.
The ionized region in which the H I recombination lines are produced emits also a free-free
continuum in the radio range. Under the physical assumptions of our model, the
radio continuum is related to the Br
flux by the simple relation
(Simon et al.
1983). By using the observed Br
flux we derived
mJy consistent with the value measured by Skinner et al. (1993) (
mJy
from the average of three measurements). We conclude that the region responsible
for the H I recombination lines is also responsible for the observed radio continuum
emission.
The ground based photometry by Berrilli et al. (1992) has already revealed the
presence of an absorption feature at 9.7 m in MWC 297 (see Fig. 1), but the
authors attributed the observed decrement of the continuum level to a single
absorption band while the ISO-SWS spectrum reveals the presence of two bands.
Berrilli et al. (1992) estimated the optical depth of the 9.7 silicate
absorption,
,
from the N2 and N3 photometric bands supposing
only one absorption band. A more accurate value of the peak optical depth
can be derived from the ISO-SWS spectrum; however it is difficult to give a very
precise estimate because of the difficulty in the determination of the
real continuum level, especially at wavelengths longer than 10
m. A first
order estimate can be given by linearly fitting the local continuum: in this
case the 9.7
m silicate optical depth is
.
The visual extinction can be derived by using the Rieke & Lebofsky (1985)
relation
.
From our
estimate we
obtain
mag, which can be considered a lower limit to the
real value since the presence of the broad adjacent 16.4
m absorption band
probably leads to an underestimate of the continuum level which turns into an
underestimate of the visual extinction. Taking into account these
considerations, we can say that the extinction is compatible with the value
derived by using both the H I recombination lines and the continuum data.
The position at 9.7 m of the absorption peak indicates that the silicate
responsible for this absorption is mainly amorphous olivine. The other silicate
band peaks at a wavelength (16.4
m) shorter than expected (
18
m), and
has an intensity higher than the 9.7
m absorption (9.7
m/16.4
m
integrated intensity ratio is
0.4), while theoretical studies (e.g.
Draine & Hyung 1984) predict that the absorption band at
10
m is stronger
than that at
18
m. However, in a review work by Nuth III & Hecht (1990)
it is shown that both the peak positions and the intensity ratio between the 10
m and the 18
m bands can assume very different values. In general, as
silicate grains are annealed the peak of the 10
m band shifts at longer
wavelengths while the peak of the 18
m band shifts at shorter wavelength and
its absolute intensity increases. Several laboratory experiments indicate that
the more the dust grains are processed the stronger the 18
m band is compared to the 10
m band. In particular, studies (Nuth III & Moore 1988) of the
silicate residual from proton irradiation of Fe(CO)5-SiH4-H2O ices have
shown an integrated absorption ratio of 10
m/18
m less than 1. Observational
evidences supporting this thesis are given by the work of Demyk et al. (1999)
which, analyzing a set of ISO-SWS data, found that the 10
m/18
m ratio
decreases from evolved stars to protostars being a tracer of the silicate
processing. The very low ratio observed along the line of sight of MWC 297 and
the shifted position at lower wavelength of the peak of the 18
m band can be
an indication that we are observing "old'' silicates even if in this case a
shift at longer wavelengths would be expected for the 9.7
m feature.
The detection of H2O and CO2 ices at 2.96 m and 4.27
m
respectively, indicates the presence of dense molecular material along the line
of sight of MWC 297. The CO2 and H2O peak optical depths are:
and
.
From those values we
calculate the column densities of the two molecules by using the approximate
formula:
![]() |
(2) |
The ISO-SWS full grating spectrum of the Herbig Be star MWC 297 has been
presented. The spectrum is dominated by a strong continuum; in addition,
emission lines from the H I recombination series, PAH emission and
absorption by solid CO2, H2O, and silicates have been detected. Some of
the observed features show peculiar characteristics. The ratio between the
column density of solid CO2 and H2O (
)
is higher than the values usually observed by ISO-SWS
(0.10-0.23) in different lines of sight. The silicate absorption band
associated to the O-Si-O bending mode, peaks at wavelength lower than expected
(16.4
m rather than
18
m) and has a total intensity higher than that of the 9.7
m band: we suggest that the silicates along the line of sight of MWC 297 are
composed by processed dust grains.
We have shown that the overall SED of MWC 297 from optical to radio wavelengths is compatible with a spherical distribution of the circumstellar matter.
The 23 H I recombination lines of the Brackett, Pfund and Humphreys series observed with ISO-SWS plus the Brackett and Paschen lines observed from the ground have been fitted with a ionized wind model; the line decrement of the spectral series have been reproduced by assuming a ionization bounded compact region. The same region is also responsible for the radio flux observed by Skinner et al. (1993).
From the analysis carried out on the ISO data, we derived a consistent set of
physical parameters for the matter surrounding MWC 297 and for the object itself:
,
distance
pc, visual extinction
mag,
index of the temperature and density profile q=0.5 and p=1.1 respectively,
mass loss rate
yr-1, radius of the
ionized circumstellar region R=30r* and optical depth at 9.7
m
.
Acknowledgements
We acknowledge Prof. F. Strafella for his contribution to the analysis of the continuum data and Prof. G. Strazzulla for the useful discussion about the ice features.