A&A 377, 206-240 (2001)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20011073
H. M. Schmid1,
- A. Kaufer2 - M. Camenzind1 - Th. Rivinius3 - O. Stahl1 - T. Szeifert2 -
S. Tubbesing1 - B. Wolf1
1 - Landessternwarte Heidelberg-Königstuhl,
69117 Heidelberg, Germany
2 - European Southern Observatory, Alonso de Cordova 3107, Santiago 19,
Chile
3 - European Southern Observatory, Karl-Schwarzschild-Str. 2,
85748 Garching bei München, Germany
Received 11 June 2001 / Accepted 24 July 2001
Abstract
We present the results of an intensive monitoring program
of the jet absorptions in the symbiotic system MWC 560,
obtained with the FEROS echelle spectrograph at the ESO 1.5 m Telescope.
MWC 560 is a unique jet source because the line
of sight lies practically parallel to the jet axis so that the
outflowing gas is seen as absorption in the continuum
of the accreting object, in the emission line spectrum of the accretion
disk and temporary also in the spectrum
of the red giant companion. Highly variable, blue-shifted
jet absorption components, due to H I, He I,
Na I, Ca II and Fe II are observed, which are detached from
the undisplaced, narrow emission line components. The allowed emission lines
from neutral and singly ionized heavy elements vary simultaneously with
the strongly variable continuum emission. Therefore they can
be attributed to the irradiated (chromospheric) layers of the neutral part
of the accretion disk. The fluxes of forbidden emission lines are
practically constant because they originate in a much larger volume.
The structure and variability of the jet absorptions indicate
the presence of three distinct outflow regions along the jet axis:
I. An initial acceleration region above the disk with
low velocities <
which covers only partly the central continuum
source; II. A highly variable outflow region covering the
continuum source and up to about half of the line emission from the
disk. This region shows repeatedly high velocity components
which are
decelerated to <
within one to a few days. The appearance of high velocity components
is anti-correlated and therefore closely related to the low velocity
absorptions of region I. The life time of the high velocity
components suggests that region II extends to about one to a few
AU from the jet source; III. A steady flow at an
intermediate velocity of
at a distance
of the order
10 AU from the jet source. This component
covers the hot continuum source and the entire narrow line region of
the accretion disk. At the beginning of our campaign region III
covers also the extended red giant companion with two absorption
components at 1250
and
1140
,
which can be considered
as terminal velocities
of the jet outflow. The components
disappear during the following several weeks as expected for
the end of an occultation phase of the red giant by the
collimated jet occuring probably regularly once per binary orbit.
Several fast moving (
), narrow absorptions
are present in the Ca II resonance lines. The high speed,
low column density, and the long life time (
months)
suggest that these are radiative bow shocks in the
jet cocoon generated by the collision of the transient
high velocity components with slower moving jet material.
A geometric model for the jet outflow in MWC 560 is presented.
System parameters are derived based on our spectroscopic data and
previous studies. Beside other parameters a binary separation
of the order 4 AU, a jet inclination of <
,
a mass accretion rate of
and a
jet outflow rate larger than
are derived.
Key words: ISM: jets and outflows - binaries: symbiotic - circumstellar matter - stars: mass loss - stars: individual: MWC 560 = V694 Mon
The peculiar nature of MWC 560 (V694 Mon) was first reported in the
catalogue of Be and Ae stars by Merrill & Burwell (1943).
They noticed emission lines of H I and Ca II K
with absorption components on their blue sides displaced by
about 1000
.
Balmer emission and blue shifted
absorptions
were also found to be present about thirty years later
by Sanduleak & Stephenson (1973). They detected also TiO bands
and classified therefore the object as M4ep for peculiar M-type
emission line star. Due to the emission lines, the blue continuum
and the red giant absorptions MWC 560 is often classified as
symbiotic binary. A short report of dedicated observations
was later given by Bond et al. (1984). They found that the
blue shifted absorption components have a complex structure
extending to
which varied strongly on time scales
of one day. An IUE spectrum showed a strong UV continuum with
a low-excitation absorption spectrum, and high-speed photometry
revealed flux variations of 0.2 mag on a time scale of a few
min.
MWC 560 underwent in early 1990 a photometric outburst of about
2 mag. Spectra taken during this phase by Tomov et al. (1990)
display spectacular spectral changes in the blue shifted
absorption components of H I and Ca II.
Tomov et al. (1990) proposed that a jet outflow
seen along the line of sight could explain the observations.
This publication triggered many new observational studies of MWC 560.
The spectroscopic observations during the outburst maximum between
January and April 1990 showed strongly variable outflow components
having sometimes radial velocities (RV) beyond
and sometimes low velocity around
.
The maximum outflow velocity measured for an absorption component
was
for March 14, 1990 (Tomov et al. 1990;
Buckley 1992; Tomov & Kolev 1997).
IUE spectra taken between February and April 1990
by Michalitsianos et al. (1991) revealed the same
RV-variability in low excitation absorption lines in the UV region.
In addition strong short term variations (flickering) of the hot
continuum were measured.
During the following observing season from September 1990 to March 1991
the velocity of the absorption components has dropped to about
(Tomov & Kolev 1997; Buckley 1992).
At the same time the UV continuum
was almost entirely attenuated by a curtain of innumerable absorption
lines of neutral and ionized heavy elements in a dense outflow
(Maran et al. 1991; Shore et al. 1994).
In September 1991 the absorption components have reached again a higher
velocity of about
.
Since then the strong Balmer lines,
e.g., H
,
H
and H
showed always a
variable but persistent, deep and broad absorption trough around
with occasional extensions to
(Tomov & Kolev 1997;
Mikolajewski et al. 1997; Panferov et al. 1997;
Iijima 2000).
This seems to be the "normal'' type of outflow for the MWC 560 system
as the same type of absorptions was already reported for the
pre-outburst observations mentioned above.
We are not aware of any spectroscopic observations taken before
the 1990 outburst or after September 1991 where no strongly blue-shifted
(
), deep and broad absorptions
were visible for the strong Balmer lines H
,
H
or H
.
Thus the outburst has interrupted the persistent outflow from the
MWC 560 system with a phase of very high velocity ejections in early 1990,
followed by a phase with a high density but slow outflow which lasted about
a year.
The brightness of the MWC 560 decreased after the outburst maximum
of about mV=9.2 mag in mid-1990 to
10 mag in mid-1991
and
10.5 mag in 1993. Since then the object remained
at a level around 10.5-11.0 mag (e.g., Tomov et al. 1996;
Mikolajewski et al. 1997).
Before the 1990 outburst the brightness
of MWC 560 varied since about 1930 in the range
mB=11.0-12.5 mag and was never brighter than 10.5 mag
(Luthardt 1991; Doroshenko et al. 1993).
Thus, the 1990 outburst is the brightest phase recorded
for this object.
Short term flickering variability of
0.2-0.4 mag
on time scales of 10-60 min was measured for
the hot component before, during and after the 1990 outburst
(Bond et al. 1984; Tomov et al. 1990, 1996;
Michalitsianos et al. 1991, 1993;
Dobrzycka et al. 1996; Ishioka et al. 2001).
It seems that the strong flickering of the hot component is always
present in MWC 560.
Based on these consideration the jet hypothesis is very reasonable for the interpretation of the outflow from MWC 560. Jets are observed in many astrophysical objects, like pre-main sequence stars (e.g., Mundt & Fried 1983), binaries with compact objects, like SS 433 or black hole binaries (e.g., Margon 1984; Mirabel & Rodriguez 1999), supersoft X-ray sources (e.g., Cowley et al. 1998), and of course in active galactic nuclei. All these systems have an accretion disk which is considered to be a necessary condition for jet outflows. Further, it is widely believed that a rotating magnetosphere is required for accelerating and collimating the jet outflow from these systems (e.g., Camenzind 1997).
MWC 560 has the required properties for a jet source. It is a symbiotic
binary system, where a late M giant transfers matter onto
a companion. Orbital periods for symbiotic systems are
several hundred days or
longer. Thus the combination of a giant companion undergoing heavy
mass loss and the long orbital period allow that an extended
accretion disk with an outer radius
and a high mass transfer rate of
can be present in these systems. The flickering activity can
thereby be interpreted as accretion phenomenon at the inner disk boundary
as observed in many cataclysmic variables. The outburst is probably
caused by an accretion disk instability similar to dwarf novae
or FU Ori stars.
In most symbiotic systems the accreting object is a white dwarf.
The flickering time scale and the outflow velocities measured
for MWC 560 suggest that also this symbiotic binary
harbors an accreting white dwarf.
MWC 560 is not alone among the symbiotic systems in having a jet outflow. CH Cyg is famous for having produced a well observed two-sided jet after a distinct drop in visual brightness (Taylor et al. 1986). Or, the suspected symbiotic system He2-90 exhibits a highly collimated, two-sided optical jet with more than five pairs of emission knots located symmetrically on either side of the source (Sahai & Nyman 2000).
However, MWC 560 is an extraordinary jet source because the line
of sight lies practically parallel to the jet axis.
Given the small opening angle for jets of about ![]()
only a tiny fraction (![]()
)
of all jet sources offer the
possibility to have the line of sight to the jet source
within the jet. To our knowledge MWC 560 is the only stellar
jet source known, where this is the case. This very special
configuration offers the unique opportunity to obtain complementary
information about the physics
involved in the acceleration and collimation of stellar jets.
Therefore we performed for MWC 560 an intensive monitoring
program with high resolution spectroscopy in order to investigate
the dynamics of the jet gas near the central source.
In this paper we describe the properties of the different spectral components and derive physical parameters and a geometric model for the MWC 560 system. In a forthcoming study we will concentrate on the geometry and dynamics of the jet acceleration region.
|
a: Affected by scattered light in the UV-blue region
(e.g., H |
MWC 560 has been intensively monitored
with FEROS at the ESO 1.5 m telescope. FEROS is a new generation
fiber fed echelle spectrograph, providing a high resolution of
,
a wide wavelength coverage from about 3700 Å to
9000 Å in one exposure and a high detective efficiency
(Kaufer et al. 1999, 2000). The 39 orders of the echelle
spectrum are registered with a 2k
4k EEV CCD with excellent
quantum efficiency. The spectrograph
was built for ESO by the FEROS consortium of the
Landessternwarte Heidelberg and the Astronomical Observatory Copenhagen.
The present data have been collected from Nov. 1998 to Jan. 1999
during commissioning time and guaranteed observing time
(the latter for building FEROS). In total 86 echelle spectra have been
secured during two series of 26 and 31 consecutive nights. Only during
one night no data could be obtained due to bad weather. In 22 nights
two or more spectra were taken in order to assess spectroscopic
changes on timescales of
hours. Table 1 gives a log of the
observations. With the typical exposure time of 15 min a signal-to-noise
ratio of
is obtained for MWC 560
from about 4200 Å to 7500 Å and somewhat less at shorter and
longer wavelengths.
A fraction of our echelle spectra could in principle be flux calibrated using the spectra of standard stars observed during the same night, provided the data were taken under photometric conditions. For a relative flux estimate of all spectra it is more advantageous to use the relative strength of the spectral features from the red giant as "flux calibration source'', assuming that the red giant spectrum is constant during our campaign (see Sect. 2.4).
All spectra are reduced using the dedicated FEROS data reduction software implemented in the ESO-MIDAS system. The spectra are stored in a on-line searchable data base at the Landessternwarte in Heidelberg. Part of these spectra, those taken during the commissioning period, are public and retrievable via Internet (see http://www.lsw.uni-heidelberg.de).
Figure 1 shows a mean spectrum of MWC 560 from 3750 Å to 6750 Å. The predominant features in the spectrum are:
All spectra have been normalized by fitting a spline function to continuum points spaced roughly by 100 Å. Determining the continuum level is not everywhere unambiguous. In the region 3750 Å to 4000 Å there are many broad absorption lines and innumerable narrow emission lines making a continuum determination difficult. Another problem in this range is the instrument response curve which decreases strongly towards the UV. For longer wavelengths it is easy to find line free continuum regions for the normalization. For the red portion of the spectra we have chosen the continuum points in regions where no strong discontinuities due to the TiO bands from the cool giant are present.
The presence of several bad CCD columns (cosmetics) requires a careful assessment of the 2d frames for the identification of spurious features in the extracted spectrum. Regions where bad CCD columns affect the spectrum are marked in Fig. 1 with a horizontal line. Wavelength intervals up to 40 Å are sometimes contaminated by a single bad column because they are in the same direction as the (bend) echelle orders. For the contaminated regions relative flux uncertainties of the order 5-10% must be expected which produce in the spectrum spurious humps and wiggles. As the instrument set-up remains fixed the bad CCD columns affect always the same spectral regions.
![]() |
Figure 2:
Spectral changes in the jet absorptions
of H |
Several strong, blue-sifted jet absorptions are visible in our data due to H I, He I, Na I, Ca II and Fe II (see Fig. 1). The identifications are listed in Table 2 together with equivalent widths (EW) for days 153, 144, 191 and 193. Days 153 and 191 represent epochs with relatively narrow jet absorptions. During days 144 and 193 high velocity components are present so that the jet absorptions are extremely broad. A flag in Table 2 indicates whether the lines are saturated and deep or not. Figures 2 and 6 illustrates the huge difference in line strengths and structure. For the measurements of EW the narrow emission lines (and the narrow absorptions for Ca II) have been clipped. Because the continuum normalization is uncertain in the region below 3800 Å no EW are given for H10 and H11.
|
a: Mean of two observations; b: problems with continuum definition; c: includes correction for fast, narrow absorption components; d: blended with He I 4921.93 or 5015.68 respectively; e: red giant contributes significantly (
|
Particularly strong with
Å are the
jet absorptions from the Balmer lines and Ca II K.
In all these lines, except H
,
the residual flux in the broad absorption trough is about 0.1 of
the continuum flux or less indicating that the absorptions are
at least partly saturated. The broad H
absorptions are
less deep and the equivalent widths smaller than for H
or H
,
because the continuum has in the red a strong
contribution from the red giant (see also Fig. 4).
Considering only the H
jet absorption in the continuum
of the hot component would yield corrected EW for H
,
which are about a factor 1.6 (
)
larger than the values given in Table 2.
H
and H8 are blended with
Ca II H and He I
3889, respectively, as can be
inferred from the presence of the strong He I
5876
and Ca II K absorptions as well as from the slightly
disturbed progression of equivalent widths along the Balmer series.
Of intermediate strengths are the jet absorptions of
Fe II multiplet 42
4924, 5018, 5169 and
the three blended lines from He I
5876,
Na I D2
5890 and Na I D1
5896.
These absorptions are not saturated. The relative contribution
of the individual components in the He I/Na I blend
are about 0.45 for He I, 0.35 and 0.20 for Na I D2 and D1, respectively. Also the Fe II absorption
4924 and
5018 are probably blended with contributions
from He I
4922 and
5016, respectively.
However, the contribution of He I to these blends is small,
at most 30%, as can be estimated from the strengths of
the unblended Fe II
5169 and other He I absorptions.
Previous measurements of the H I jet absorption EWs
dating from 1990 to 1993 are given in Tomov & Kolev (1997).
The data taken since the end of 1991 (after the outburst and
slow outflow phase) show also rather strong variations EWs,
which stayed, however, always within a well defined range, e.g.
9 Å
Å, similar to our observing period.
Also the EW measurements of metal lines from Ca II and Fe II
from 1993 (Tomov et al. 1995) are close to our values
given in Table 2.
Thus, no long term trend in the
jet absorption equivalent widths is apparent since Sep. 1991.
Further we have detected many very shallow jet absorptions
mainly from He I and Fe II transitions. Often
they are hardly visible in the spectra, which are full
of narrow emission lines in the blue and structured
by the cool giant absorptions in the red spectral region.
However, in the difference spectra of two observations with
and without high velocity jet component characteristic features
are apparent pointing to the weak jet absorption components.
Figure 3 demonstrates this search technique.
Measuring the equivalent widths of these weak jet absorptions
is very difficult, because this depends critically on a very accurate
continuum definition. We found it more reliable to measure
the strengths of the difference features relative to the
stronger comparison absorptions He I
4471.5
(for the He I lines) and Fe II
5169
(for the metal lines). Table 3
gives the relative
strengths of weak jet absorptions estimated with this procedure.
It should be noted that the values correspond to
equivalent width ratios relative to the total continuum.
Thus the strong contribution of the red giant spectrum must be
considered for the interpretation of the strengths of the red
jet absorptions, especially He I
7065.2
and O I
7773.4.
| identification | comparison line | ratio | error | |
| x | y | x/y | ||
| He I 4026.2 | He I 4471 | 0.48 | 0.15 | |
| Fe II (27) 4233.17 | Fe II 5169 | 0.17 | 0.08 | |
| He I 4387.9 | He I 4471 | 0.15 | 0.08 | |
| Fe II (38) 4549.47 | Fe II 5169 | 0.25 | 0.15 | a |
| Fe II (38) 4583.83 | Fe II 5169 | 0.18 | 0.08 | |
| Fe II (37) 4629.33 | Fe II 5169 | 0.10 | 0.07 | |
| He I 4713.9 | He I 4471 | 0.11 | 0.07 | |
| Fe II (49) 5316.61 | Fe II 5169 | 0.15 | 0.08 | |
| Si II (2) 6347.09 | Fe II 5169 | 0.08 | 0.06 | b, c |
| Si II (2) 6371.36 | Fe II 5169 | 0.08 | 0.06 | b, c |
| He I 6678.2 | He I 4471 | 0.68 | 0.15 | b |
| He I 7065.2 | He I 4471 | 0.26 | 0.08 | b |
| O I (1) 7773.4 | Fe II 5169 | 0.87 | 0.25 | b, d |
Several of the weak jet absorptions are identified here for the
first time for MWC 560. Of interest are the detections of weak
jet absorptions from Si II multiplet 2
and O I multiplet 1, which may be
used in connection with UV absorptions for gas temperature
determinations. Further jet absorptions are due to He I
transitions as expected from the presence of the strong
5876
transition. In addition there are
weak absorptions from the most prominent lines
of different well known Fe II multiplets. Other
Fe II absorptions are present besides those listed in Table 3,
but they are either
weaker or affected by blending. The Fe II absorptions
4233,
4549, and
4584 were seen previously by
Kolev & Tomov (1993) during the 1990/1991 low velocity phase.
These Fe II lines appeared then together with Ti II
absorptions indicating a lower ionization degree of the outflowing
gas at that time.
Redward of the H
line the contribution of the
red giant to the spectrum becomes more and more significant.
Strong TiO band heads, e.g.,
4954,
5448,
6681 and others, can be easlily recognized in the mean spectrum
plotted in Fig. 1. The near-infrared portion
Å of our FEROS-spectra is dominated by strong
TiO bands. For the interpretation of the jet absorptions depths it is
necessary to estimate the strength of the red giant spectrum. For this we
compare the observable red giant features in our MWC 560 spectra
with a comparison star of similar spectral type.
The molecular features in the near infrared indicate
a spectral type of M5.5 III for the red giant in MWC 560
(e.g., Meier et al. 1996; Mürset & Schmid 1999).
For our comparison spectrum we have
observed with FEROS (on day 145) the red giant S Lep,
which is classified as M6+ IIIa by Keenan & McNeil (1989).
The spectrum of S Lep is shown in
Fig. 4 for the H
and Na I/He I
region in comparison with the MWC 560 spectrum for day 153. The S Lep
spectrum has thereby been scaled to match the strengths of
the red giant features seen in MWC 560 and the
flux level obtained for S Lep yields the contribution of the red giant in
the MWC 560 spectrum.
In the broad jet absorption trough of the H
line the
red giant spectrum is exposed practically free from contributions
of the hot component. This region is therefore ideal for measuring
the relative strength of the red giant spectrum. We measure
as mean relative flux in the RV-range
-1000 to
corresponding to
the wavelength range 6541Å to
6544Å. The jet absorption for the H
line is around
deeper than the
estimated continuum of the red giant. This indicates that
the jet gas absorbs for this velocity a substantial fraction
of the red giant spectrum. In Sect. 5 the properties of
this absorption are discussed in more detail.
The flux of the hot component in MWC 560 varies strongly on
times scales of hours, as will be discussed in the next section.
Therefore, the relative contribution of the red giant to the
total continuum varies by about
-25% around a mean value.
During our observations the mean contributions of the red giant
relative to the total continuum at the position of important
jet absorptions are:
3% for H
,
6%, 3% and 9% for Fe II
4924,
5018 and
5169, respectively,
15% for He I
5876, 10% for Na I D1,2
and 45% for H
(see Fig. 4).
It is known from various studies that the blue continuum in
MWC 560 is strongly variable. The measured variations have an amplitude
of the order of 0.1-0.3 mag in the V-band
on a typical time scale of hours (e.g.
Michalitsianos et al. 1991; Tomov et al. 1996).
Thereby short term brightness changes as large as
mag have been measured in the U-band.
We use the red giant features to measure the relative strength
of the hot continuum assuming that the red giant flux is
constant. Thus, the hot component is bright when the
relative strengths of the TiO bands are low and the H
jet absorption is deep (see Fig. 13).
First we check the correlation between the relative flux of the
red giant
measured at 6542.5 Å in the H
jet absorption and the strengths of the TiO bands
.
For
we measure the difference in flux
on the blue f1 and the red side f2 of the band heads.
The mean strengths of the TiO features is
for TiO
4954 and 0.078 for TiO
5448.
The relative scatter
for
is
for both the
4954 and
5448 features during our campaign. The two upper panels
in Fig. 5
illustrate that the relative strengths of the TiO bands are well
correlated with the relative red giant flux
as measured in the H
absorption.
The solid curves in these panels are lines along which the
relative strengths of the red giant features
(which are assumed to be constant on an
absolute scale) would move if the absolute flux of the
hot continuum is varied.
The fact that the observed points lie
along these lines indicates that the flux
variations of the hot continuum are at least to a first approximation
colour independent in the 4900 Å to 6600 Å range.
The flux of the hot continuum relative to the
cool giant continuum
is given by
the re-normalization of the total continuum flux
(initially normalized to f=1) to the
red giant continuum
in the H
jet absorption
according to:
The values
are of course only valid for the region around
6540. But as was shown above, the relative flux changes of
the hot continuum are at least roughly colour independent
and therefore representative for a broad wavelength range.
The structures of the jet absorption in MWC 560 are strongly variable.
The absorptions recorded during our campaign showed a relatively
stable component around a radial velocity (RV
)
of roughly
.
In addition there appeared repeatedly highly blue-shifted
components with RVs up to and beyond
.
Characteristic for MWC 560 is that the jet absorptions are detached from
the center of the emission components by about
to
.
This produces a region without or with only little absorption
between the systemic velocity of the line (i.e. the center of the
emission component)
and the main jet absorption trough.
Figure 6 illustrates the absorption structures for the
H I Balmer lines, He I, Na I, Fe II and
Ca II for day 153 and day 144.
For day 153 the absorptions extend to
,
while for
day 144 a high velocity component is present so that the absorptions
extend to about
(at a residual flux level of 0.8).
These two particular dates give a representative comparison
between times with and without high
velocity jet absorption component. During our observing campaign the high
velocity components behave for a given day similar for all lines in
the optical wavelength region. There are interesting exceptions to
this general rule, mainly for the He I lines as will
be discussed below.
In the following paragraphs we discuss some general features of
the jet absorptions.
For H
,
H
and H9 the absorption troughs are
over a broad range saturated.
Around
the
residual flux is for all three lines less than 10% of the
continuum flux for day 153, day 144, and also for practically
all other days covered by our campaign.
In the high (negative)
velocity component of day 144 the residual flux at
is about 27%, again practically the same for all three lines H
,
H
and H9. The oscillator strength fij and the corresponding line opacity is about a factor of 20 larger for H
than H9. This requires that the strongly
blue-shifted jet absorptions are highly saturated for the
Balmer transitions. Thus the high velocity components are opaque in the
Balmer lines but they usually do not fully cover the hot continuum
source. A further property of the
H I absorptions is their smooth structure without
narrow subcomponents. Thereby the residual flux is always
increasing or at least constant towards higher outflow
velocities but never decreasing. This is equivalent to the statement that the
covering factor for the higher outflow velocity gas is smaller than
or at most equal to the covering factor at lower velocities down
to about
.
At the low (negative) velocity end of the H I absorption troughs,
around
,
the situation is different. There
the absorptions are always weaker for higher Balmer transitions
as can also be seen for days 153 and 144 (Fig. 6).
This indicates that the Balmer line opacities are
for this velocity region not very high.
The onset of the broad jet absorption trough at
about
absorbs also the extreme blue wing of the strong H
and
H
emission lines. Thus, these extreme line wings,
which are attributed to Raman scattered Ly
and Ly
line wing photons, must originate from behind the absorbing H I gas
(see Sect. 4.5).
A shallow absorption component is visible for the higher Balmer transitions
between about
to
corresponding to the region between the broad absorption trough
and the emission line peak.
Similarly the strong H
and H
emission
seem to have an additional absorption on the blue side indicative
of some sort of low velocity outflow. It can again be concluded
that this absorption is saturated but covers only a fraction
of the continuum source because the strength of the absorption
decreases not for higher Balmer lines. This is
described in more detail in Sect. 4.5.
If He I high velocity components are present as for day 144, then they extend as far as the corresponding H I Balmer absorptions. However the fast absorptions of He I retreat on a shorter time scale after a velocity maximum when compared to the Balmer lines. The He I high velocity absorption is often deeper than the absorption at intermediate velocity unlike the saturated Balmer lines. Metal lines have also such absorption components but they are narrower and more structured than the He I lines. For the interpretation of these differences in spectral structure and temporal variability it must be considered that the He I absorptions originate from much higher excited transitions than e.g. the Balmer lines or the lines from Fe II.
In our spectra no emission line is visible for He I
5876,
neither for any other He I line.
A major difference to H I is that the jet absorptions for Fe II and Na I are not saturated. In the case of the Ca II K line saturation occurs only for a relatively narrow RV-region. Thus we can see substructures in the main absorption components which are not visible in the saturated H I lines. The subcomponents occur in the different metal lines simultaneously (see e.g., day 144 in Fig. 6).
A further characteristic of the metal lines is that there
is almost no absorption visible for
.
This is especially true for the neutral (zero excitation)
Na I
5896 absorption which has a well defined
low (negative) velocity edge. This indicates that
lower velocity gas has an ionization degree which is too high
to produce Na I absorptions.
The metal lines producing jet absorptions have also emission components
at the systemic velocity. The emission lines structures of the
resonance transitions of Na I
and Ca II are strongly affected by
interstellar absorption components. Further we see for Ca II
several blue-shifted, narrow absorption components in the range
RV=-1800 to
.
Their high velocity indicates a tight
connection with the jet outflow. It will be suggested
in Sect. 7 that they are produced by shocks in the jet.
| line ( |
fjk | EW/ |
atomic state | Nj |
| a | [Å] | [cm-2] | ||
| H |
0.119 | 37.8 | H I, n=2 | >
|
| H9 3835 | 0.0054 | 26.4 | H I, n=2 | >
|
| He I 4471 | 0.125 |
|
He I, 23P |
|
| Na I 5896 | 0.327 |
|
Na I |
|
| Ca II 3934 | 0.69 | 14.6 | Ca II | >
|
| Fe II 5169 | 0.0057 |
|
Fe II, a6S |
|
a: Oscillator strengths are from the compilations of
Wiese et al. (1966, 1969) and Fuhr et al. (1981);
b: assuming that the line absorption of
5896 is 20% of the
He I/Na I blend.
Column densities for weak (unsaturated) absorptions
are proportional to the measured EW (in Å) according to
the formula
For saturated jet absorptions accurate column densities are
difficult to determine, but lower limits can be derived.
For deep absorptions we have to replace in the above formula
the equivalent width EW by the wavelength integral
(measured in Å) of the jet gas optical depth
,
where
is the (residual)
intensity of the jet absorption in the normalized spectrum:
The integral
is for the hydrogen (H
to H9) jet
absorptions 2.0
times larger than the EWs given in
Table 2.
The corresponding factor for Ca II K is 1.7
.
Derived values and limits for column densities
are given in Table 4 for different species based
on the absorptions measured on day 144.
The large difference
in the lower limit of N(H I, n=2) derived from H
and H9 demonstrates well the difficulty in determining column
densities from saturated jet absorptions. In any case, less
saturated transitions give more accurate results.
For the total jet column density of hydrogen and helium a
population for the highly excited levels H I, n=2and He I, 2p3
,
respectively, has to be
adopted. But without
detailed knowledge on gas temperature, density, ionization
degree, and radiation field these level populations
are highly uncertain.
Better suited for an estimate of the total column density
of the jet gas are the transitions of the metal lines. The Na I
and Ca II resonance lines yield directly the
column density of the corresponding atoms. The Fe II
Boltzmann excitation ratio N(a6S)/N(Fe II)
is about 10-3 for the electron temperature
K
and 10-2 for 15000 K.
Thus, the total abundance of singly ionized iron N(Fe II)
is more than about 103 times higher
than Na I or Ca II. This indicates that sodium and calcium
are predominantly in the ionization state Na II and Ca III.
This is well possible when comparing the ionization potential of
16.2 eV for Fe II to only 11.9 eV for Ca II
or 5.1 eV for Na I.
We conclude that the column density of Fe II in the jet is
N(Fe II)
.
Assuming
further that Fe II is the dominant ionization state of iron
and that the iron abundance is solar
in MWC 560 yields a total
hydrogen column density of the order
.
The variability in the broad jet absorptions is one of the characteristics of MWC 560. Whenever repeated spectral observations were taken it was recognized that the jet absorptions are strongly variable on times scales as short as days or even a few hours (e.g., Bond et al. 1984; Tomov et al. 1990; Michalitsianos et al. 1991; Buckley 1992; Tomov & Kolev 1997). However, our FEROS high resolution spectra are the first data set where the spectral changes of the jet absorptions are followed during (many) consecutive nights. Therefore a detailed description of the observed changes is given here.
Figure 7 gives a first impression on the observed
variations from the evolution of the spectra of the H
and Ca II jet absorptions over eight consecutive nights.
The plotted data series includes the appearence and disappearence
of a strong high velocity component with RV up to
around day 181 which is
seen in both the H
and the Ca II line simultaneously.
At the same time the flux between the absorption trough and
the emission lines
to
has a maximum for H
.
The same is
probably true for Ca II, but the effect is less pronounced and the
continuum determination is less accurate in the crowded UV region.
A splitting of the Ca II absorption into
two components occurs on day 180 and
a flux maximum in the middle at
appears for three
days. Further there seems to be
a connection between a subtle shift of the low (negative)
velocity edge of the broad absorptions at
and the occurrence of
the high veloctiy component.
This description and its visualization in Fig. 7 of the complex line variability pattern covers only two lines and a small fraction of our campaign. Due to the lack of space it is not possible to present all the observed spectral variations in such a form. We therefore use other ways to present our data and select those features which seem to be the most important.
An overview on the temporal variations of the jet absorptions
can be gained from the dynamical spectra for H
,
Ca II K, the He I/Na I-blend and Fe II
5169 plotted in Fig. 8. The panels show
for these lines the normalized radial velocity spectra for
the 56 nights covered by our campaign. If more than one spectrum
was taken during a given night the exposure time weighted mean was
used. All spectra were taken during the same hours of the
observing nights (between about UT 02:00 and 09:00) so that
an equal spacing between consecutive nights is warranted
for the discussion of the day to day evolution.
An interesting difference between H I
and He I is that the transient high velocity
absorption for He I disappears faster after having reached
its maximum strengths. Further the transient high velocity components
in He I are relatively strong compared to the absorption around
.
Therefore, the
He I
5876 high velocity components are easily seen
even if their counterpart in the hydrogen absorptions is relatively
weak. Due to the higher excitation potential of the He I transitions, the He I absorption behaviour can be associated
with the hotter or higher ionized gas component in the jet outflow.
The radial velocity of the deepest absorption component in
Ca II and Fe II lines
is about
for days 131 to 165. For
days 171 to 201 this absorption
shifts slowly from
RV=-1100 to
.
Very much the same long term trend can be recognized for
Na I doublet despite the blending of the two components.
Very interesting is the behaviour of the shallow low velocity
absorption
to
in H
and the
other Balmer lines. The absorption in this low velocity region is
very weak if the high velocity component is strong and much more
pronounced if the high velocity component is absent. Thus there exists an
anti-correlation between the low and high velocity regimes
of the absorbing gas, similar to the case of He I and
the metal lines described above. In the following sections,
this anti-correlation will be investigated in more detail.
A very illustrative way to show the fast spectral changes are
difference spectra between consecutive observations,
which corresponds to a discrete time derivative of the spectral flux.
Our data sampling is best suited for plotting the difference between
the mean spectrum of consecutive days
.
The resulting 2-dimensional daily difference spectrum for H
is plotted in Fig. 9. From this figure it is visible
that changes occur mainly for the RV-regions
-2500 to
and -800 to
.
Between these two regions is the saturated jet
absorption trough where the absolute flux changes are small.
The two main variability pattern emerge clearly in Fig. 9.
First, there are the strong changes in the widths of the saturated jet absorption trough, which widens abruptly on the blue side together with the appearence of a strong high velocity component (black in Fig. 9) and then retreats continously towards the inital widths within several days. Such deep absorption components appear on days 137, 143/144, 181 and 192/193 and will be called hereafter major high velocity absorption components.
Second, there are the fast variations or strong daily
flux differences on both sides of the absorption trough,
which are anti-correlated between the low and high velocity side.
This phenomenon is always occurring when a major high velocity
absorption component appears. In addition there are also minor
high velocity absorption components
which are less deep and have a life time
of only about
1 day. They are best visible in the
dynamical spectrum of the He I line in Fig. 8,
e.g., for the stronger events occuring for days 184, 188 or 199
or weaker events for days 140, 172, 175 and probably also for
day 149. The
stronger events share the anti-correlation between high and low
radial velocity absorption dephts of the major components as
is clearly visible in the difference spectra (Fig. 9).
For the weaker short term events the situation is less clear. Because of the limited sampling we may have missed the phase where the minor high velocity component was strong enough for recognizing the anti-correlation phenomenon. Thus we see at least that short lived (or minor) high velocity absorptions occur repeatedly on a recurrence time scale of a few days.
The fast variations, i.e. the daily flux differences, extend all the
way to the H
emission peak at
(see Sect. 4.5). Thus the variation seen around
,
due mainly to the varying absorption in the blue
emission line wing of H
,
are practically the same as
those seen around
for the aborption of the continuum.
This proves that the absorbing gas with radial velocity in the
range -500 to
affects the continuum emission
and the emission of the H I lines in the same way as
will be further discussed in Sect. 4.5.
For the emission line peak at
where the normalized flux reaches a value of
10,
it should be noted that the variations seen in the difference
spectra (Fig. 9) are relative changes on
the 5-10% level only. These variations must
be considered with respect to the strongly varying
continuum level against which the spectrum has been normalized.
In Fig. 10 the temporal behaviour of the normalized flux
is compared for the H
and Ca II jet absorptions
in different velocity bins. The plotted fluxes are mean values
for RV-intervals of 200
widths centered at the RV-value indicated.
The chosen velocity bins exclude spectral features like strong
narrow lines which could potentially disturb the absorption depths
interpretation.
The plotted curves are in principle vertical cuts through the dynamical spectra plotted in Figs. 8a and b. However, for Fig. 10 the fluxes and times from individual spectra are used and not just "daily means'' as in dynamical spectra. To account for the long term velocity trend sometimes different RV-bins are taken for the two data series. Not included are in Fig. 10 data from some low quality spectra flagged in Table 1, namely 138 B, C, D, 184, and in the case of Ca II also 141.
The flux changes plotted in Fig. 10 for the low velocity
side of the absorption trough at RV=-800 to
are
in anti-correlation with respect to the mean fluxes in the
intervals.
This is particularly well visible
for the variations between days 180 and 200, but also the
excursions around days 144 and 137 are present. No
systematic time-difference between the flux maxima at low velocity
and flux minima at high velocity can be recognized with our
temporal resolution. The anti-correlation
is not perfect in the sense that the strength of the flux maxima
at low velocities does not scales linearly with the strength of
the flux minima at high velocities. But this non-perfect
(anti-) match may just indicate that the description of the
jet absorptions variability in terms of mean flux absorptions in
given RV-bins is oversimplified. This is not surprising when
considering a sequence of individual line profiles like in
Fig. 7.
Most interesting is the variability of Ca II at
,
where for H I
the line absorption
is strongly saturated. In this range the Ca II feature displays
strong flux variations in clear anti-correlation with the flux changes
at higher velocities. The variations at
in the
first data series (days 131-156) is due to a shift of the low velocity
end of the absorption trough towards the blue, associated
with the appearance of the high velocity components (see profiles
in Figs. 6 and 7). This happens also during
days 171-201.
In addition the broad jet absorptions split during days with
strong high velocity components into two components leaving a distinct flux
maximum in the middle around
.
The
temporary splitting disappears when the two components merge again
(Fig. 7). We have plotted the corresponding fluxes
for
in Fig. 10 for
days 171-201 because this
effect is particularly strong during the second data series. But
also for day 144 such a line splitting is visible (see Fig. 6).
The Ca II
flux
variability pattern
is also recognizable at a velocity of
and
partly also for
.
However in this
latter velocity regime the
variations are much smaller than for H
and harder to measure
due to the larger uncertainties in the spectrum normalization
for the Ca II spectral region.
A first impression on the similarities and differences in the jet absorptions of different elements can be gained from the dynamical spectra. Figure 11 provides a more detailed view on the flux variations for given RV-bins.
Striking is the high similiarity between H
and He I
5876 for the flux variations in the range
.
Practically each
wiggle seen in the
H
-curve is also visible in He I. A difference
between the two curves is that the strong flux absorptions, e.g.,
around days 144, 181 or 193 disappear faster for the He I
line compared to the H I line. Note that the He I flux
scale has been stretched in Fig. 11.
Also the Ca II and Fe II flux curves show a very
similar flux pattern, especially for the high
velocity range
.
It should be noted that
the Fe II absorptions are weak and that the variations
in normalized flux are only of the order 0.1-0.2. The
good match in flux variations is obtained despite the presence of narrow
emission lines, or narrow absorptions in the case of Ca II.
Further, the Fe II-region shows the presence of a red giant
continuum against which the hot component continuum (and the Fe II
absorption therein) is varying due to flickering activity.
The correspondence between the Ca II and Fe II flux
curves for
is also very good.
Differences have to be expected for this central region of the
jet absorption, because the Ca II line is partly
saturated there while the weaker Fe II line is not.
The flux level on the low (negative)
velocity side of the main absorption trough
varies in anti-correlation relative to the high velocity side.
Illustrative for these spectral variations is the comparison of
different Balmer lines for day 177 and day 181 in Fig. 12.
Between these two dates the flux level increased steadily from a low
to a high value (see Figs. 10 and 11).
![]() |
Figure 12: Structure and variations of the H I line emission and the low velocity absorption in the blue line wing. |
It is apparent that the different Balmer lines in Fig. 12
show a very similar flux increase on their blue side. This is
true for the weak Balmer lines like H8, where the flux is
predominantly due to the blue continuum as well as for the strong
Balmer lines like H
and H
,
where the emission line
wings dominate. Despite the large difference in oscillator
strengths (i.e. absorption cross section) the relative flux increase
between day 177 and day 181 is for all Balmer lines about a factor 1.8 for
where the continuum dominates
and about a factor 1.4 at
where the
line emission is strong (see Table 5).
At the same time the flux in the red line wings remains unchanged.
This must be interpreted
as a change in the covering factor of the low velocity gas outflow.
The fact that continuum and the blue line wing of H I emission
react simultaneously indicates that the corresponding
emission regions coincide partly or have at least a very similar geometry.
The broad H
and H
line wings
can be attributed to Raman
scattering by neutral hydrogen in the accretion disk.
Raman scattering converts e.g., the Ly
and Ly
line wing photons into H
and H
line wing photons,
respectively, whereby the RV-shift from the line center is
enhanced by a factor of about 6.4 (see Nussbaumer et al. 1989).
This effect is often observed in symbiotic systems, because they
have strong H I Lyman line emission and dense and extended
neutral hydrogen regions for Raman scattering (e.g., Lee 2000;
Schmid 2001). In the case of MWC 560 the Lyman line
emission from the bright disk "chromosphere'' can be
Raman scattered in the underlying neutral disk "photosphere''.
The spectral changes described here between days 177 and 181 are characteristic for the absorption variability in the blue wing of the H I emission lines and the adjacent continuum although they are usually not so strong. Because the flux in the red wing of the Balmer line emission is not affected by line absorption it must change together with the strongly variable continuum flux.
| day/ratio | H |
H |
H |
H |
H8a | mean |
|
flux at
|
1.48 | 0.64 | 0.46 | 0.52 | 0.46 | |
| f(181) | 2.26 | 1.11 | 0.91 | 0.92 | 0.82 | |
| f(181)/f(177) | 1.53 | 1.73 | 1.98 | 1.77 | 1.78 | 1.76 |
|
flux at
|
7.10 | 2.71 | 1.61 | 1.29 | 0.98 | |
| f(181) | 10.7 | 4.11 | 2.23 | 1.66 | 1.33 | |
| f(181)/f(177) | 1.51 | 1.52 | 1.39 | 1.29 | 1.36 | 1.41 |
|
flux at
|
10.4 | 3.39 | 1.83 | 1.49 | 1.14 | |
| f(181) | 10.3 | 3.21 | 1.73 | 1.50 | 1.17 | |
| f(181)/f(177) | 0.99 | 0.95 | 0.95 | 1.01 | 1.03 | 0.99 |
| integrated line flux f(177) | 135. | 24.1 | 7.7 | 3.6 | 1.4 | |
| f(181) | 174. | 32.9 | 9.7 | 5.0 | 2.1 | |
| f(181)/f(177) | 1.29 | 1.37 | 1.26 | 1.39 | 1.5 | 1.36 |
a: Fluxes for other Balmer lines, like H
,
H9 and H10,
are not accurately measurable because of blending with narrow emission lines,
Ca II emission and interstellar absorption (for H
)
and uncertainties in the spectrum normalization (for H10, H11).
For day 181 there is at
an absorption component
which is much weaker in H8 than e.g. in H
.
This is an
example for an absorption with a moderate line opacity, but which
covers practically the entire continuum source.
Finally an estimate on the H I line fluxes
of MWC 560 is given. Assuming an apparent brightness of roughly
mV=10.5 mag and mB=11 mag for MWC 560 for our campaign
(disregarding the flickering variations) yields a continuum flux of about 4.8 and
at 4500 Å and 5500 Å, respectively.
With the EW for day 177 the approximate
line fluxes of 1.1 for H
,
2.4 for H
,
6.5
for H
and 24.3 for H
in units of
are obtained.
In MWC 560 the outflow profiles and their temporal variability
differs completely from classical P Cygni profiles pointing to
a very specific outflow structure.
P Cygni type line profiles from stellar outflows are due to
gas which is accelerated outwards from a small velocity near
the source to high velocities at large distances
approaching asymptotically a terminal velocity
.
If variability is observed in these P Cygni profiles they can be
characterized as net absorption enhancements evolving in RV velocity like
a discrete component in the accelerated wind
(see e.g., Lamers & Cassinelli 1999).
For the following discussion of the MWC 560 outflow absorptions we just assume that the gas is accelerated from low velocities and then reaches a high velocity at large distances. The important characteristics of the profiles observed during our campaign are:
Thus, compared to the P Cygni type outflow, MWC 560 shows
a pulsed acceleration to high velocities
from a low radial velocity region <
located close but not in front (at most partly)
of the radiation source. The high velocity gas is then decelerated
to an intermediate terminal velocity of roughly 1200
.
This major result follows from the observed jet absorptions
in the hot continuum. Further support and additional constraints
are obtained from the jet absorptions seen in front of the
red giant (Sect. 5) and the narrow line region
(Sect. 6).
The spectral variations in the jet absorptions are witnessing
strong changes in the mass outflow. The time scale for the
appearance or disappearance of components gives thereby
a measure of the life time of gas structures and estimates on the
length of the probed jet along the line of sight.
For example, absorbing gas with a RV of
travels
within one day about 1 AU further
away from the jet source. The fact that there are often two or
even more deep (saturated) absorptions
with strongly different velocities present, as e.g., for
day 181 in Fig. 7, proves that the gas components
cover the entire continuum source
and are therefore located behind each other along the line of sight.
The mass outflow per unit time and surface element
can be roughly estimated from the time
scale and the EW changes of jet absorption structures.
Strong jet components, which appear on time scales of one day,
have EW of up to 40% of the entire jet absorption EW
(see Table 2). This is also true for Fe II,
although the total EW as given in Table 2
changes much less than for saturated absorptions.
This is because the lower velocity
component is weakened when a high velocity component appears,
due to the described anti-correlation effect.
Thus the spectral variability together with the previously determined column
densities (Sect. 3.1) indicate that
a column density of roughly
is replenished in
day in the jet outflow along the
line of sight during the appearance of a high velocity component.
Still to be determined remains the total cross section
of the probed jet for an estimate on
the mass outflow. However, the value of
depends strongly on the adopted system parameters and the jet geometry
and will be discussed in Sect. 8.2.
The red giant contributes about 45% to the continuum
in the H
region. In the H
jet absorption trough
the hot component is strongly obscured for
to
and the remaining flux is at least
predominantly due to the red giant. But within this velocity range an even
deeper absorption component is present which must be due
to gas in front of the red giant. This absorption is very strong
at the begining of our campaign and then diminishes and
disappears within the 70 days covered by our data. Such an obscuration
of the red giant companion by the jet could be caused by the
binary motion or by a precession of the jet axis.
Figure 13 illustrates the structure and the
temporal evolution of the H
component in the red giant continuum.
The spectra are normalized relative to the radial velocity
interval -1000 to
.
This RV-region shows the red giant spectrum free from contamination
by the hot component. It can also be said that this part of the
red giant spectrum is not or at most only very slightly absorbed by
the jet gas. This can be concluded from days where the
transient high velocity components are deep, as for day 201 or 193,
which reveal also for
the level of
the red giant continuum as expected from the normalization region
RV=-1000 to
.
The normalized
spectrum from the comparison star S Lep (M6+ IIIa) shows that
all narrow features in the absorption trough come from the red giant spectrum.
The H
jet absorption in front of the red giant shows
a very smooth evolution in contrast to the strongly variable
absorption in the continuum of the hot component. The absorption is around
day 133 strong and has a blue and red component centered at
and
respectively. The red component
weakens steadily from our first observation on day 133 and disappears
between day 154 and 171 where no observations were made.
The EW of the blue component remains from day 133 to about 142 constant
and then decreases steadily and vanishes around day 200.
Measured line widths for the blue component are
(FWHM)
up to day 156. From day 171 onwards the widths is
and the center of the profile has slightly shifted to
.
The width of the red component is about
.
Table 6 lists for some dates the equivalent widths and the residual central intensity relative to the red giant continuum for the blue and red component. Thereby we have split the total line equivalent widths into a blue and red value according to the strengths of the two line components. The total line equivalent widths is just the sum of these two values. For day 171 and later, when the red component is absent, only values for the blue component are given.
A search for similar jet absorptions in the red giant spectrum for other strong transitions was unsuccessful. In particular no signatures were found in the region of the Na I resonance lines and the Ca II triplet.
It is suspected that this obscuration event could be a periodic phenomenon, because the evolution of the line strengths is similar to the egress phase of an eclipse curve. Further a similar event with a blue shifted absorption in the spectrum of the red giant was reported for April 1990 by Meier et al. (1996).
| day | 2blue | 2red | ||
| EW | EW | |||
| 131 | 1.76 | 0.26 | 0.98 | 0.34 |
| 133 | 1.79 | 0.24 | 0.85 | 0.36 |
| 137 | 1.70 | 0.25 | 0.74 | 0.42 |
| 142 | 1.74 | 0.20 | 0.70 | 0.43 |
| 148 | 1.57 | 0.28 | 0.50 | 0.58 |
| 154 | 1.24 | 0.32 | 0.39 | 0.65 |
| 171 | 0.76 | 0.38 | <0.10 | -- |
| 179 | 0.54 | 0.46 | -- | -- |
| 187 | 0.31 | 0.71 | -- | -- |
| 194 | 0.22 | 0.81 | -- | -- |
| 201 | <0.10 | -- | -- | -- |
| err. |
Still, there remains the principle problem that it is difficult to estimate the total hydrogen column density N(H) because of the unknown population of the level n=2.
The H
jet absorption in the red giant spectrum
can be considered as cross section through the jet at large distance
from the source. The measured velocity of the two components
at the systemic RV of -1250 and
can thereby be
considered as terminal velocity
of the jet outflow.
The two velocity components and the fact that one component
disappears before the other component indicates
that the jet has also at larger distance from the
source (
10 AU) an internal velocity structure.
Many hundreds of narrow emission lines are visible in the optical spectrum of MWC 560. From these lines we can estimate physical parameters of the emitting gas and investigate whether and how the jet absorptions occult the corresponding emission line region.
Most strong narrow lines are allowed transitions from singly ionized heavy elements, mainly from Fe II, Ti II and others. In addition there are lines from allowed transitions of neutral metals, most notably Fe I and Mg I. The emissions from the resonance doublets of Ca II and Na I are also present but strongly affected by interstellar absorption components. Forbidden lines are seen from [O I] and [Fe II].
Identifications for many of these lines are given in Kolev & Tomov (1993) and Chentsov et al. (1997).
Due to the large number of lines we discuss here only the properties of some selected lines in order to gain insight in physical parameters and the location of the emitting gas.
The formation of Fe II emission lines depends strongly on often rather badly known parameters like radiation field, line optical depths, Fe II abundance, electron density and gas temperature. It is beyond the scope of this paper to make a detailed analysis of these parameters based on the narrow line spectrum. However, based on numerical calculations on the Fe II emission line spectrum given in the literature (e.g., Netzer & Wills 1983; Joly 1981; Verner et al. 1999) a few rough estimates can be made from the basic properties of the Fe II emission line spectrum in MWC 560.
First, it can be concluded that Fe II is emitted in MWC 560
in a partially ionized region
N(H II)/N(H I)
.
This follows
from the presence of the strong line spectrum of the Ti II
ion, which has practically the same ionization potential as
H I. Strong ionization of hydrogen would also
cause ionization (and depletion) of
Ti II in conflict with the narrow line spectrum.
A partially ionized Fe II-region can also explain
the fast Fe II flux variations to be described
in the following sections. The Fe II lines show
absolute flux variations of up to a factor of 2 within approximately
one day simultaneously with the continuum flux.
Such variations cannot be due to radiative excitation because
the absorption profiles are narrow and the line depths
for the Fe II UV transitions are high (see below).
However, if the continuum radiation changes the electron
density
,
e.g., by a factor of 2, as response to
the photoionization of H I, then an immediate change of
the Fe II emission line flux
(Fe II)
in step with the variation of the ionizing flux is possible
(
:
required excitation potential for the emitted line;
k: Boltzmann constant).
A rough upper limit on the electron temperature of
K follows from the requirement that hydrogen is
predominantly neutral in the Fe II region. For higher temperatures
hydrogen would be substantially ionized by electron collisions
(e.g., Arnaud & Rothenflug 1985). However, under
many different astrophysical conditions the temperature
in partially neutral N(H II)/N(H I)
regions emitting Fe II is below
K.
A lower limit on the electron temperature
in the Fe II region can be made from the presence of the many strong optical
Fe II emission lines. The formation of these lines requires
that the lowest odd level of Fe II at about 5 eV are readily
excited. For this a minimum electron temperature of about
K is needed for collisional excitation
(see e.g., Netzer 1988).
Radiative excitation of the odd levels at 5 eV
by continuum radiation is also possible but
most likely not efficient in MWC 560, because the absorbing
(i.e. the emitting) gas has only narrow lines and can therefore
absorb only a limited amount of UV radiation. Further we can
assume that the covering factor of the continuum radiation by the
(stationary) narrow line Fe II gas is much lower than unity
in view of the presence of a strong polar outflow region.
The mean electron density
of the Fe II
emitting gas is larger than
as can be inferred from the weakness of the
forbidden [Fe II] compared to allowed Fe II lines.
A similar constraint on
is obtained from the short time
scale of
1 day for the Fe II line variations.
We assume as suggested above that this variability is caused by
changes in the hydrogen ionization degree in the Fe II region due to the variable ionizing flux from the accreting object.
The corresponding recombination time scale
for H II is given by
,
where
is the radiative
H II recombination cross section
(
).
Thus, the observational requirement that
day yields
.
For the total hydrogen density N(H) it must be considered that a
low ionization fraction N(H II)
(H I)
is adopted for the Fe II region. This yields from the
estimated
above a lower limit for the hydrogen density
of at least N(H)
.
However, it must
be supposed that the density could be in reality orders of magnitudes
higher.
It is well known that line optical depths can significantly change the flux ratios between optical and UV transitions of Fe II (e.g., Netzer 1988). For MWC 560, Michalitsianos et al. (1991) report narrow absorptions but no strong narrow emission lines from UV (IUE) satellite observations. This suggests that the optical depths in the strong UV transitions of Fe II are so high that UV line photons are converted into optical Fe II line photons after multiple scatterings.
In summary, the parameters of the partially ionized Fe II
region are characterized by a temperature in the range
K, particle densities larger
(most likely much larger) than
and N(H)
and substantial
optical depths in the UV line transitions of Fe II.
Further it is assumed that the Fe II line variations
are caused by strong changes in the ionization degree
N(H II)/N(H I)
(H I) in the Fe II
region due to the variable ionizing flux from the accreting object.
Further it can be inferred from the absence of [N II], [S II]
and [O II] lines that the ionization fraction in the
forbidden line region is low. The absence of the [N II]
lines indicates that the gas temperature is
K. For higher temperatures strong
[N II] lines (R([N II]/[O I])
)
are expected according to emission line calculations for a
gas in collisional ("coronal'') ionization equilibrium (see
e.g., Hamann 1994).
The narrow line spectrum in MWC 560 is very rich and many lines are blended. Therefore we have carefully selected some representative, unblended lines in order to study the profile structures of forbidden and allowed transitions from neutral and singly ionized atoms.
Almost all narrow lines have a Gaussian structure. Some of the strongest Fe II lines are exceptions, as they display an extended blue line wing (Fig. 14). Exceptions are also the Ca II triplet lines which are double-peaked.
Table 7 gives line centers and
radial velocity widths (FWHM) for representative lines.
These parameters are obtained by fitting Gaussian profiles to the
lines observed on day 153. No significant temporal
changes (>
)
are detected in line widths and centers during our campaign.
However, line strengths are variable (see next section).
We measure a radial velocity of
for the line centers
of all selected lines. The line widths differ between different
line types. For forbidden [O I] and [Fe II] lines
as well as for allowed Fe I lines the widths are
.
The Mg I
5172.68 line is significantly broader
with a FWHM of
.
Although the other strong Mg I features of the multiplets 2 and 3 are blended or located in the wing of another strong line, they confirm this
result.
The allowed Fe II lines show a range in line widths
and blue wing strengths. The very strong Fe II lines
from multiplet 42 are broad
(
)
and have
pronounced blue wings extending more than
100
towards the
jet absorption component. Other strong Fe II lines with
traces of a jet absorption component, like Fe II
4233.17,
show a similar profile with a somewhat weaker blue wing.
Further there are strong Fe II lines with a width in the
range
and a very weak blue extension.
However, the majority
of lines from singly ionized atoms have Gaussian profiles with
a width like the neutral Fe I lines and the forbidden lines.
The Ca II triplet lines are strong, broad
(
),
and double peaked. Their equivalent widths is about 1-2 Å, relative
to the strong red giant continuum in this spectral region.
The two Ca II transitions at
8542.09 and
8662.14
have very similar profiles with a weaker flux maximum
at
,
a stronger maximum at
,
and a central minimum at
.
The profile of the third
Ca II line at
8498.02 differs significantly.
The two flux maxima have practically equal strengths and are
located at +28 and
,
with the central mimimum
at
close to the systemic velocity.
The fact that the
profiles of the two transitions
8498 and
8542
from the same upper level (4p
)
differ strongly indicates that radiative
transfer affects the line structure of these transitions
significantly. Certainly, the Ca II lines have a significant
diagnostic potential. However, in order to get reliable information
detailed radiative transfer calculations are required for the
narrow line region what is beyond the scope of this paper.
|
a: The well separated [O I] night sky line was clipped before measuring line parameters; b: weak line, where photon noise contributes to the observed scatter in line strengths. |
Line strengths
are measured relative to the continuum
(where
)
and called hereafter
emission line equivalent widths (
). For absolute
line flux variations the flux of the variable continuum must
be considered. This can be done by scaling the measured
to the unobscured red giant flux in the H
absorption
trough according to
.
The
of allowed transitions of singly ionized atoms
like Fe II, but also Ti II, Cr II and others,
show only small relative variations
%
(Table 7 or Fig. 15).
The expected
scatter from photon shot noise is of the
order of 1% for strong narrow lines with
Å and 5% or larger for weak lines
Å.
However, compared to the
relative continuum variations of 23% (Sect. 2.4) due to the
flickering hot component, the relative line flux variations
of less than 10% are small. Thus to a
first approximation the line fluxes for the
singly ionized metal lines change in step with the strong
continuum flux variations.
For the allowed lines of Fe I and Mg I the scatter
is enhanced with a relative value of
.
Much larger
are the
variations for the forbidden [Fe II] lines
4815
and
5159. Also enhanced is the scatter for the
[O I]
6300 line in the red (Fig. 15),
especially when considering
the significant contribution of about
30% from the non-variable
red giant to the total continuum at this wavelength.
![]() |
Figure 15:
Variations of the narrow emission lines
[O I] |
Measuring the line strengths
,
relative to the continuum of the red giant
as measured in the broad H
absorption trough (Sect. 2.4)
yields a different picture.
The relative variations
are
much lower for the [O I]
6300 compared
to Mg I and Fe II
(Table 7 or Fig. 15).
The case for [Fe II] and Fe I
is less clear, probably because they are weak and more affected
by measuring uncertainties. But for Fe I
the scatter is larger for fluxes measured relative to the constant
cool giant continuum compared to fluxes measured relative to the
variable continuum (mainly) due to the hot component. The opposite is true for
the [Fe II] lines. Fe I behaves more like Fe II and [Fe II] more like [O I]
Thus the following trend can be recognized. The absolute flux of the [O I] lines is practically constant like the continuum of the red giant. [Fe II] and Mg I vary only slightly and may be composed of a main constant component with a contribution of a variable component, while the Fe I, the Fe II and other allowed lines of singly ionized atoms vary predominantly like the hot component. This can be interpreted as a clear stratification between allowed transitions originating mainly in an emission region varying in step with the hot component and the forbidden lines with rather constant flux. This variability pattern indicates also that the Fe II region is relatively compact and close to the continuum source, while the [O I]-region is much more extended. Thereby the [O I] emission may originate from a region not directly associated with the hot continuum source.
In this section we investigate whether and how
the narrow line
emission region is occulted by the blue shifted absorptions
from the jet gas. That some occultation is present can already
be suspected from the spectral distribution on narrow lines,
which shows pronounced gaps on the blue side of the strong
Balmer emission lines H
to H8 (see Fig. 1).
The partial obscuration of narrow lines by the variable jet
absorptions was already noticed by Tomov & Kolev (1997)
and can be clearly seen on published spectra in
Kolev & Tomov (1993) and Tomov et al. (1997).
However these studies
give no assessment of this effect. In the following we investigate
the occultation of the narrow line
region with three different methods in order to make a quantitative
statement.
Fortunately the measured line ratios and branching ratios agree
significantly better (scatter
0.25 dex) between
lines from multiplet Cr II 30 (a
-z
)
near H
and multiplet Cr II 43 (b
-z
)
around 5300 Å, having the identical upper level and the same J and L quantum numbers for the lower level, e.g. for ratios like
which refers to
.
The same is found for corresponding line ratios between multiplet
Ti II 41 (a
-z
)
lines near H
and
multiplet Ti II 61 (b
-z
)
lines around
4400 Å. We suspect that these ratios are better suited for
this analysis because systematic errors in the atomic data
and radiative transfer effects may be comparable for transitions
having an identical upper level and the same quantum numbers
for the lower levels. Such special line ratios are rather rare
and it is a fortunate coincidence that useful lines occur at
the position of the expected H
and H
jet absoptions.
From this analysis we find that the Cr II 30 lines
4848.24 (
),
4856.19 (
),
4864.32 (
)
near H
and the Ti II 41 line
4330.71 (
)
near H
are about a factor 5-10 weaker than expected
from the branching ratios. Other lines from the multiplets
Cr II 30 and Ti II 41
are not weakened during days like day 153 when the
jet absorption trough in the continuum is narrow and
extends only from about
to
.
Obscurations of lines by high velocity absorption components occur
but this effect is more easily studied in terms of line flux
variations (see below).
Thus, it can be concluded
that the jet gas obscures also the narrow line region, at least
for the RV-range -800 to
.
No suitable lines
can be used to test the RV-region from -1300
to
with this method. However there are many lines with
and
,
and they are
like the continuum not obscured. A better sampling of the
RV-space and the behaviour for days with high velocity
absorption components are discussed in the following sections.
The two narrow line features in the vicinity of the strong Balmer lines
(
)
are probably
affected by absorption and radiative transfer effects in the
H I line wings.
Thus, the
line ratios in Table 8
agree with the finding made above based on atomic branching ratios.
But in the comparison with XX Oph more lines could be included
in the analysis giving a better coverage of the RV-space. This
defines well the RV-edge of the jet absorption in front of the
narrow line region at
for day 153. This
value agrees with the jet absorption edge for the continuum.
|
|
|
I153 |
|
|
|
|
H | 4798.53 Ti II 17 | -3837 | 0.207 | 0.97 | 0.83 |
| a | 4805.09 Ti II 92 | -3432 | 0.387 | 0.98 | 1.05 |
| b | 4812.34 Cr II 30 | -2985 | 0.102 | 0.78 | 0.43 |
| c | 4814.55 [Fe II] 20F | -2849 | 0.108 | 0.87 | 0.64 |
| d | 4823.31 Y II 22 | -2308 | 0.129 | 0.86 | |
| e | 4824.14 Cr II 30 | -2258 | 0.413 | 0.78 | |
| f | 4825.72 Fe II 30 | -2164 | 0.073 | 1.1 | 0.43 |
| g | 4833.21 Fe II 30 | -1699 | 0.064 | 0.44 | 0.36 |
| h | 4836.22 Cr II 30 | -1512 | 0.145 | 0.39 | 0.56 |
| i | 4839.9
| -1281 | <0.030 | < 0.19 | |
| j | 4846.4
| -884 | <0.010 | < 0.10 | |
| k | 4848.24 Cr II 30 | -767 | 0.073 | 1.2 | 0.15 |
| l | 4849.18 Ti II 29 | -709 | 0.016 | 1.1 | 0.06 |
| m | 4865.61 Ti II 29 | +298 | 0.121 | 0.55 | 0.61 |
| n | 4871.27 Fe II 25 | +649 | 0.122 | 0.48 | 0.49 |
| o | 4874.01 Ti II 114 | +818 | 0.284 | 0.75 | 0.86 |
| p | 4876.4
| +967 | 0.299 | 0.98 | 0.75 |
| 4883.68 Y II 22 | +1414 | 0.221 | 0.85 | 1.30 | |
| 4884.60 Cr II 30 | +1471 | 0.075 | 0.69 | 0.44 | |
| 4889.62 [Fe II] 4F | +1780 | 0.080 | 0.95 | 0.62 | |
|
H | 4290.22 Ti II 41 | -3822 | 0.686 | 0.90 | 1.11 |
| 4294.10 Ti II 20 | -3167 | 0.452 | 0.84 | 0.96 | |
| 4296.57 Fe II 28 | -2996 | 0.474 | 0.87 | 0.62 | |
| a | 4300.06 Ti II 41 | -2755 | 0.858 | 0.91 | 1.30 |
| b | 4301.93 Ti II 41 | -2627 | 0.636 | 0.86 | 1.23 |
| c | 4303.17 Fe II 27 | -2540 | 0.745 | 0.83 | 1.00 |
| d | 4307.90 Ti II 41 | -2216 | 0.596 | 0.81 | 1.49 |
| e | 4312.86 Ti II 41 | -1871 | 0.584 | 0.53 | 1.22 |
| f | 4314.2
| -1782 | 0.467 | 0.48 | 0.97 |
| g | 4314.98 Ti II 41 | -1726 | 0.427 | 0.45 | 1.47 |
| h | 4316.81 Ti II 94 | -1600 | 0.166 | 0.46 | [0cm][0cm]}1.48 |
| i | 4317.32 Zr II 40 | -1565 | 0.071 | 0.52 | |
| j | 4319.62 [Fe II] 21F | -1404 | 0.044 | 0.77 | b |
| k | 4320.8
| -1324 | 0.300 | 0.51 | 0.97 |
| l | 4325.01 Sc II 15 | -1032 | 0.069 | 1.1 | 0.30 |
| m | 4325.76 Fe I 42 | -981 | 0.036 | 1.2 | 0.15 |
| n | 4330.26 Ti II 94 | -668 | 0.021 | 2.5 | [0cm][0cm]} 0.12 |
| o | 4330.71 Ti II 41 | -639 | 0.041 | 2.2 | |
| p | 4337.92 Ti II 20 | -138 | 0.115 | 0.96 | c |
| q | 4344.29 Ti II 20 | +299 | 0.231 | 0.58 | 0.75 |
| 4351.76 Fe II 27 | +816 | 1.138 | 0.80 | 0.98 | |
| 4367.66 Ti II 104 | +1914 | 0.328 | 1.00 | 0.84 |
|
a: Blended lines; 4876.40/.48 Ti II30 + Ti II30;
4314.08/.29 Sc II15 + Fe II32; 4320.74/.95 Sc II15 + Ti II41. b: Too weak to be measured in our XX Oph spectrum. c: Affected in XX Oph by the P Cygni-absorption of H |
From Table 8 follows that the lines in the
RV-range
to
are weakened for day 194
relative to day 153. The line ratios
I194/I153 are for this
RV-range only
times the value measured for lines
with
or
.
A noticable exception
is the [Fe II]
4319.62 line flux, which
stays practically constant. This supports the previous finding
that forbidden lines originate predominantly from a different
(larger) region than the allowed lines (Sect. 6.1).
In addition it is found
that the lines "n'' and "o'' in the lower panel of Fig. 16
near
are significantly stronger for day 194 compared
to day 153. Thus also the narrow lines display the anti-correlation
between high and low velocity absorption depths described for the
continuum in Sect. 4.3.
The temporal flux changes for various narrow lines in the
H
region is plotted in Fig. 17. There the
measured line fluxes are given together with the continuum variations
at the same radial velocity measured for the H
jet absorption.
This figure illustrates that the strong line flux changes
coincide with strong continuum flux changes. However, the
decrease in line flux is less than the continuum flux decrease.
The attenuation level for the narrow emission lines indicates
that the transient high velocity gas obscures not more than about
half of the narrow line emission region. Further, Fig. 17
shows that short lived high velocity components (or the highest
velocity parts of strong components) clearly present in
the continuum are hardly or not seen in the line fluxes.
Examples are in Fig. 17 the components at
for days 180 and 193/194 or at
for days 144/145, 175, 188 and more.
This suggests that these absorptions
result from geometrically small structures, small compared to
the characteristic size of the Fe II-emitting
narrow line region.
The jet absorption components obscure this (variable) narrow line region in different ways.
Major high velocity components are able to occult about half of the narrow line region. However, the initial highest velocity continuum absorptions produce hardly a flux weakening for the narrow lines. Thus these transient high velocity absorptions are small and then grow with time as they decelerate to dimensions of roughly half the size of the narrow line region. The short lived minor high velocity components can not be clearly recognized in the fluxes of the narrow lines. Thus they cover less than about 20% of the narrow line region.
For radial velocities in the intermediate range
to
the narrow lines are weakened
due to the outflowing gas to a residual relative flux of
about 0.2 or even less. Thus the intermediate velocity gas
covers practically the entire (variable) narrow line region.
Thereby the lines around
vary
like the shallow low velocity components associated previously
with the initial acceleration region. Around
close to the jet terminal velocity
the occultation of practically the entire narrow line
region is probably caused by the jet outflow at larger distances
from the source.
Both resonance lines of Ca II show several blue shifted
narrow absorption components (Fig. 18; see
also Fig. 8b).
The radial velocities of these narrow absorptions lie in the
range
to
.
The narrow absorptions are of course only visible when the strongly
variable broad absorption troughs extend not too far to the blue
or are shallow as for day 193.
In Fig. 18 the seven strongest absorption lines
seen for day 135 are identified. Despite some emission lines it
is visible that all these components occur for both Ca II
resonance transitions.
Line parameters for the absorption
components A to F are given in Table 9.
The typical equivalent widths of the identified narrow
Ca II absorptions are about
0.05-0.20 Å.
The equivalent widths are measured with respect
to a pseudo-continuum level defined by (relatively) line free
sections, e.g., at
or
.
The decrease of the continuum towards the red
is caused by a high velocity absorption wing from
the broad absorption troughs.
For the widths of the narrow absorptions
we measure
(FWHM). But several
of the features are again composed of subfeatures,
e.g., F and G for day 135. Absorptions with "clean'' Gaussian
profiles (e.g., feature A for days 156,173,190, or feature C, etc.)
have practically always a width of only
(
0.13-0.18 Å).
The lower panel of Fig. 18 demonstrates that the absorptions remain rather stable on time scales of months. Therefore the narrow lines can also be seen in the mean spectrum plotted in Fig. 1 near 3915 Å and 3950 Å. Observed changes over 55 days are a 50% increase of the strengths for feature A, the emergence of a new component in the blue wing of feature D, a substantial weakening of feature E, or a temporary splitting of feature G into two components around day 156. All these changes are not only seen in the Ca II K transition as shown in Fig. 18, but also in Ca II H. From this we conclude that the typical lifetime of the blue shifted, narrow absorption lines is of the order of a month or longer.
Radial velocity changes up to
are measured for the line centers of the narrow absorptions
(Table 9).
Thereby it must be carefully distinguished whether we see
a true line shift or just a change in relative strength of
subcomponents within a given feature. The latter case seems
to happen for absorption features B and F. However, the
line profile evolution of feature A and the strong central
component of feature D indicate a real shift in radial velocity
towards lower outflow velocity.
This evolution could therefore be caused by a deceleration
of the corresponding outflow components.
Narrow absorption features are not visible redward of the
broad absoption troughs
.
Due to the broad absorption no continuum flux is usually visible
from about
to
.
An exception are the
spectra around day 193 where the variable absorption troughs
are extremely broad but shallow (Fig. 2).
These spectra show that narrow
absorptions are absent for
.
We have searched for corresponding narrow absorptions (i.e. same RV as for
Ca II) in the strong H I Balmer transitions and for
Na I with negative result.
An upper limit for the equivalent widths
for such narrow absorptions is about 0.03 Å in H
,
Na I or H
.
| 3day 135 | 2day 190 | ||||
| RV | 2EW [Å] | RV | EW [Å] | ||
| [kms-1] | Ca II K | Ca II H | [kms-1] | Ca II K | |
| A | -1705 | 0.10 | blend | -1697 | 0.15 |
| B | -1665 | 0.10 | 0.08 | -1655 | 0.05 |
| C | -1635 | 0.06 | 0.04 | -1637 | 0.04 |
| D | -1554 | 0.14 | 0.09 | -1550 | 0.25 |
| E | -1441 | 0.12 | 0.06 | absent | |
| F | -1396 | 0.18 | 0.09 | -1401 | 0.10 |
| G | -1296 | 0.16 | a | a | a |
| error |
The fast, narrow absorptions are certainly closely linked to the jet outflow in MWC 560, because the radial velocity of the narrow components is comparable to the RV of the jet outflow. Further we know that the jet is directed towards us, so that an absorption in the continuum spectrum of the jet source must be due to gas located close to the jet outflow.
Column densities for the narrow high velocity
absorption components are
N(Ca II)
calculated for an EW of 0.1 Å (see Sect. 3.1).
Adopting solar abundances and assuming that Ca II is
the dominant ionization stage of calcium yields a hydrogen
column density of
for a typical narrow absorption component.
The fact that there are no similar absorptions visible for
the Balmer lines suggests a low temperature of roughly
K for the absorbing gas. This follows
from the expected n=2 level population of H I
(Boltzmann-factor) and ionization degree of calcium and hydrogen
in collisional (coronal) equilibrium
(Arnaud & Rothenflug 1985).
The observations suggest a life time of these components
of one month or longer during which they travel about
30 AU (for
)
further away from the
source. Thus their mean distance to the source is of
the order 10-100 AU or larger. This fast moving gas
will produce shocks in the expectedly very heterogeneous circumstellar
environment of MWC 560. Thus, the fact that we see cool gas requires
a short cooling time
(e.g., Spitzer 1978) compared to the
life time of an absorption component.
Thus, the density of the cool gas is at least of the order
or larger to allow cooling of
the shocked gas within a few days. This yields an extension of
less than
along the line of sight for an absorbing Ca II gas component.
Gas clumps of this small size and high speed are likely to be
immediately dispersed. However, thin radiative shock fronts
generated by the jet could survive for a long time.
In the previous sections we have determined from our spectroscopic data model free parameters like time scales, radial velocities, column densities or covering factors. Considering further that we see a fast outflow from the hot component in a symbiotic binary yields already a rough velocity structure for the outflowing gas. Thus it is possible to construct a schematic geometric model for the gas outflow in the MWC 560 system without knowing accurate system parameters. This basic outflow geometry will be illustrated in the following section.
In order to estimate more accuratly the geometric dimensions and physical parameters of the jet outflow we have to adopt system parameters like distance, binary separation, orbital inclination and more. For this we review existing estimates in the literature and make our own determinations if necessary.
Figure 19 gives a schematic illustration of the jet geometry showing the location of the emission components and the lines of sights (dotted) along which the outflowing gas produces the different absorption components.
The Fe II emission line region is closely associated with the hot continuum source, because the line strengths vary in step with the continuum variations. As the narrow lines are at the systemic radial velocities it can be assumed that they originate in the accretion disk, probably in the irradiated upper layers (chromosphere) of the neutral disk. Varying irradiation can change the ionization fraction of the partly ionized emission region and cause immediate flux changes in the emission lines in step with the continuum radiation. Based on these arguments, a disk structure seems to be the only viable geometry for the Fe II emission line region. However, the extent and the radial flux distribution of the line emission is unclear. In addition there is some emission of forbidden lines, like [O I] and [Fe II], from an extended low density region. It is difficult to constrain the geometric location of this region. Because the lines are narrow and at the systemic RV they could originate in the cool outer accretion disk or the outer atmosphere of the cool giant.
The late spectral type M5.5 III of the cool giant indicates
a very extended photospheric emission
located beside the accretion disk and hot continuum source in the
binary system seen practically pole on.
Based on the structure and variability of the jet absorptions discussed in detail in Sect. 4.6 three different outflow regions along the jet axis are found having distinct radial velocity properties:
The three radial velocity components cover also at least partly the narrow line emission region as worked out in Sect. 6.
The low velocity region I causes a measurable weakening
in the RV range -600 to
of the Balmer lines
but does not completely extinguish the narrow lines
or the H I blue line wing emission. Thus a substantial
fraction (
30%) of the extended emission line region is
covered by low velocity gas. At the same time only half or
less of the much smaller central continuum source is behind
this low velocity component. This is strong evidence
that the initial outflow acceleration occurs above the
accretion disk. Acceleration of gas could also occur close
to the compact accreting object without producing low velocity
absorption components. If the outflow rate from this region
is large enough then the wind can be optically thick due to
electron scattering, so that only the fast moving gas at
radii
is visible (see also Sect. 8.2).
A more detailed analysis of the absorption components is required
to support or refute such an outflow from the central region.
Major high velocity components from region II cover fully the continuum source but only about half of the narrow emission line region. Thereby, the size of a given component is initially small and then grows as its velocity is decelerated. Short lived (<2 days), minor high velocity components absorb often only about half of the continuum radiation and cause no significant weakening (<20%) of the narrow line emission. This indicates that the high velocity components have different geometrical dimensions perpendicular to the jet axis ranging from about the size of the continuum source for minor component to about half the size of the narrow emission line region for major components.
Gas from the more remote outflow region III covers fully the continuum source and about 80% or more of the narrow emission line region. In addition the outflow at large distance from the jet source is also capable to cover at least 75% of the red giant companion. Thus the jet radius must reach at larger distances from the source the dimensions of the narrow line region and the red giant companion.
From this discussion it can be concluded that the jet radius in MWC 560 increases with distance from the jet source.
A very intriguing property of the narrow absorptions is that
their RV is larger than the terminal RV of the jet as
derived from the H
jet absorption in front of the red giant.
Because shock fronts move slower than the pre-shock gas, and
since only the transient high velocity jet components
have velocities in excess of the narrow Ca II absorptions,
it must be concluded that they are responsible for these structures.
Thus the cool Ca II shock fronts are most likely generated
by the shocks due to the collision of the transient high
velocity jet components with previously ejected slower gas in
the jet.
The generation of shocks is expected for variable jet outflows,
where the amplitude of the velocity variations exceeds the
sound speed. If the pressure in the generated shocks internal to the jet
is high enough then the gas is forced out of the jet in lateral
direction producing fast moving shock fronts in the jet cocoon.
This was shown by numerical simulation
(e.g., Stone & Norman 1993) although not for
jet parameters similiar to MWC 560. Thus shocks are
certainly present in region II in MWC 560,
where transient components have a velocity which is up to about
1000
higher than the mean jet velocity. Further the
covering factor of the high velocity components increases
as they are decelerated indicating a lateral expansion of
the shocked gas. This may force fast moving jet gas into the
so-called jet cocoon producing shock regions.
Whether, such shocks can cool and form Ca II absorption features
with the temperature, column density, life time and velocity
as observed in MWC 560 remains to be investigated.
However, the number of observed Ca II features
can be explained with this scenario. If the Ca II shock fronts are generated by the high velocity components
occuring on a time scale of about a week, then their
inferred lifetime of about a couple of months yields
the observed number of Ca II features of about 5 to 10.
Deriving system parameters for MWC 560 has often to rely on indirect methods and assumptions. Therefore the uncertainties are hard to quantify and the derived results have to be considered cautiously. In Table 10 the obtained parameters for MWC 560 are summarized and detailed discussions are given for each value in the following paragraphs. We are aware that many of these estimates can be considerably improved with detailed investigations which are, however, beyond the scope of this paper. Thus Table 10 is a compilation of parameters which will hopefully be strongly improved in the near future.
As discussed in Sect. 5 the obscuration of the red giant by
the jet as seen in the H
absorption is probably caused
by a periodic eclipse effect locked to the binary orbit.
Our observations cover only the egress phase of this obscuration
which lasts about 2 months. We are not aware of other observations
of the H
jet absorption structure taken earlier in 1998 which
could further constrain the full duration of this event.
However, a lower limit on the
full eclipse phase is 4 months assuming that the duration of the
ingress phase is comparable to the egress phase.
A similar jet absorption in the spectrum of the red giant was
seen for the He I
10831 line in April 1990,
and less prominent in January 1991, by Meier et al. (1996).
This may be interpreted as obscuration phase lasting about 10 months
or longer. If both are eclipse effects due to the binary orbit
of MWC 560 then the orbital period is
years or an
integer fraction of this. Thus, the other possibilities above the
lower limit of Mürset & Schmid (1999)
are the periods P=4.25 or 2.83 years.
Thereby the long duration of the obscuration phase favours
long orbital periods. Therefore we consider in the following only
P=4.25 and 8.5 years.
For an estimate on the binary separation we assume
stellar masses of 0.5
and 1.5
for the accreting
object and the red giant respectively. Such masses are typical
for symbiotic systems (e.g., Mürset et al. 2000).
This yields for circular orbits a binary separation of a=5.2 AU
for a period of P=8.5 yr, or 3.3 AU for P=4.25 yr.
The upper limit on the inclination can be obtained from
limits on orbital radial velocity variations. With the
parameters adopted above the orbital velocities of the
two stellar components with respect to the
center of mass are
for the
red giant and
for the hot component
assuming a period of P=8.5 yr.
The corresponding values for P=4.25 yr are
and
.
Unpublished high resolution spectroscopy of red giant absorption
lines from MWC 560 taken with the coude echelle spectrograph (CES) at
the ESO 1.4 m CAT telescope by the
Zürich group (see e.g., Schild et al. 2001)
yields a mean radial velocity
of 36.7
with a scatter of
for 16 measurements
taken between April 1992 and December 1997. Our FEROS spectra
provide daily radial velocities for the red giant.
The measurements show that there exist RV variations of
about 0.4
on time scales of a few days. Further,
the mean velocity determined for our campaign is between
about 37.8
and
38.2
depending on the choosen spectral region.
No periodic radial velocity variations are obvious
in these data. The measured variations must be
attributed partly to large scale surface motions and the fact that
different measurements (wavelength regions) measure the RV of different surface layers within a radially expanding outer
atmosphere. Further, it must be considered that for the CES and FEROS
measurements different radial velocity standard stars were employed
for the cross correlation analysis. It is beyond the scope
of this work to investigate these details. However, we
estimate that the full amplitude of the orbital RV variations for
the red giant in MWC 560 must be smaller than
2.5
.
Thus the
maximum inclination for orbital velocities derived above
is
according to
Similarly, the RV of the narrow emission lines is also practically
constant at about
.
Unfortunately we found no
measurements of narrow line RVs in the literature with an accuracy
of ours (Table 7). The comparison with the measurements
of Tomov & Kolev (1997) or Chentsov et al. (1997)
indicates at least that possible orbital RV-variations must be smaller
(full amplitude) than about 8
for the narrow lines.
Assuming that the narrow line region
traces the orbit of the hot component yields the upper limit
of
for the inclination confirming but not improving
the result above.
It can be expected that new high resolution measurments will improve significantly this result in the near future.
| parameter | value | (mainly) deduced from |
| orbital period P | 4.25, 8.5 yr | 1990 and 1998 obscuration |
| binary separation a | 3-5.5 AU | P, typical masses for symbiotic binaries |
|
jet inclination
|
< | P, a, upper limits on orbital RV variations |
|
red giant
|
| spectral type M5.5 III |
| distance d |
|
|
| extinction EB-V | 0.15 mag | 2200 Å feature |
|
hot component
|
| d, measured flux, EB-V |
|
accretion rate
|
| |
|
hot continnum
|
| |
|
em. line region
|
| |
|
jet outflow rate
|
>
|
|
A lower limit for the distance can be obtained from the radial
velocities of interstellar absorption lines. MWC 560 has the galactic
coordinates
,
where
according to the maps of Brand & Blitz (1993) the radial velocities
of the interstellar medium is increasing with increasing distance.
Both Na I and both Ca II doublet lines show the
same absorption structure with 4 narrow components
at +14.1, +41.2, +49.1 and
+66.3
.
The last component is significantly weaker than the other
components. According to Brand & Blitz (1993) the features
at +41.2
and +49.1
indicate a distance of
kpc
while the weak component at
+66.3
must be due to a (small) absorption
cloud with peculiar velocity. Tomov et al. (1992) attribute the
(main) double component at +41/
to the MWC 560 circumstellar region.
However, the much higher resolution of our spectra show that
this absorption is composed of very narrow components and that
they are significantly red shifted with respect to the systemic
velocity of
.
This makes
an association with a circumstellar (outflow) region unlikely.
The distance estimate is confirmed by the apparent IR-brightness
of the red giant which indicates a distance of
d=2.5 kpc (Meier et al. 1996). For this it was assumed that the
M5.5 III giant in MWC 560 has a typical luminosity for its spectral type.
The interstellar extinction can be estimated from the broad
UV absorption feature at 2200 Å. A rough analysis of
the 2200 Å depression in the IUE spectrum
from April 29, 1990 plotted by Maran et al. (1991) suggests an
extinction of
mag. This spectrum
is ideal for extinction estimates as it was taken when
the continuum was bright and the jet absorptions weak
(see Buckley 1992).
A higher interstellar extinction (
EB-V=0.23 mag)
was previously estimated from the IR colours of the red giant
by Tomov et al. (1992) and Zhekov et al. (1996).
For this they adopted a spectral type of M4.5 for the giant
in MWC 560. Their method would also give a lower extinction
if a spectral type of M5.5, as favoured by us, is adopted.
Based on these arguments we assume for our model of MWC 560 a distance of 2.5 kpc and an extinction of EB-V=0.15 mag (or AV=0.45 mag).
The luminosity in the hot continuum can now be determined with
the distance and extinction derived above. The observed spectral
energy distribution for the hot component in MWC 560 can be derived
from published IUE spectra and photometry
(e.g., Michalitsianos et al. 1991;
Tomov et al. 1996). This has also been done by Panferov
et al. (1997) for the maximum in April 1990 and
a later phase where the brightness was lower. Dereddening the
hot continuum spectrum with
EB-V=0.15 mag and integrating yields
a total flux in the wavelength range
1000-8000 Å of
for April 1990, about half to one third this value for 1992 and later,
and about a forth for the pre-outburst IUE observation of 1984.
This translates with d=2.5 kpc into a luminosity of
for April 1990 and correspondingly lower values
for the other dates. For our 1998/99 observations we adopt a
total luminosity of
for the hot continuum. This
accounts not only for the flux
Å but also for the ionizing
radiation which is estimated to be about
from
the strengths of the H I lines (e.g.,
dereddened line flux for 1998/99).
The luminosity of the hot continuum could be composed of 3 components:
the accretion disk luminosity
,
the luminosity of the boundary layer
and the intrinsic luminosity of the accreting star
.
We neglect in the following
assuming that
.
The reasons are that a white dwarf with high luminosity
would produce highly ionized circumstellar emission lines what is
not observed. On the other hand if the accreting star is luminous
and has an extended, relatively cool photosphere then it would
dominate the optical spectrum and the fast flickering activity
must be attributed to unexpectedly large and fast changes in the photosphere.
That the hot continuum is predominately due to accretion luminosity is
not only supported by the fast flickering activity but also
by the 1990 outburst characteristics. This outburst
was coupled with strong changes in the jet outflow speed. The emission
lines remained narrow and stayed at the systemic velocity indicating
that no multi-directional (quasi-spherical) ejection or wind phase
as for novae or similar thermonuclear events took place.
The flickering activity can be explained by accretion instabilities
near the boundary layer (perhaps defined by the stellar magnetosphere)
between disk and accreting object. The typical flickering time scale
of
30 min corresponds to an orbital period of gas in a
Keplerian accretion disk at a distance of
from the center of the accreting object with mass
.
Based on basic accretion disk theory
(e.g. Pringle 1981; Warner 1995)
the luminosities due to the accretion disk
and the boundary layer
are to a first approximation equal:
Accretion onto an object
would
produce a hard photon continuum with an effective temperature
of
(
:
Stefan-Boltzman constant)
emitting a large amount of hard photons in the EUV or soft X-ray region.
But MWC 560 exhibits no emission lines from highly
ionized gas indicating that reprocessing of radiation in the
innermost accretion region must occur. A dense, spherical wind from the
central region would be optically thick due to electron scattering
(
:
Thomson cross section) out to a radius
.
For a mass loss of
and an outflow velocity of
the photospheric radius is
.
The corresponding effective
temperature
K is then compatible with the low
ionization spectrum observed for MWC 560.
This interpretation implies that outflowing gas from the central accretion region has already a high velocity when it reaches the photosphere and becomes visible to the observer. Currently it is not clear, whether such a wind component is present among the different absorptions seen along the line of sight, and whether such an outflow from the central region could provide a significant fraction of the subsequently collimated jet gas. Thus, the jet gas could be due to a combination of outflows originating partly from the central optically thick region, and partly from the accretion disk as witnessed by the low velocity absoption component associated with region I in Fig. 19.
An alternative accretion disk model producing no hard photons involves
a central star with a large radius
.
But this would require for the observed bolometric luminosity
an unrealistically high accretion rate of >
.
Such a disk is much
to bright in the visual region and the rotation time scale
at the inner boundary is too long for explaining the fast
flickering activity observed for MWC 560.
For simplicity we may assume that the continuum source is composed of
two components: (a) a relatively small region around the accreting object
where the luminosity of the boundary layer is emitted; and
(b) the inner hot accretion disk radiating in the optical range.
Thus, for the extent of the continuum source it is
sufficient to know the size of the optically bright accretion disk.
In principle this could be derived from standard accretion disk
theory with a constant slope temperature structure
at large disk radii
and an
integrated flux distribution of
.
However the spectral distribution of the hot
continuum in MWC 560 is much flatter than this, more like
.
This points to a non-standard
disk temperature profile caused e.g., by irradiation effects
from the boundary layer, by the strong jet outflow,
or another process.
We will not discuss non-standard disks here,
although they should be investigated in future studies on MWC 560.
For a very rough estimate it is sufficient to adopt a mean
effective temperature
and calculate with the luminosity and
the Stefan-Boltzmann law a characteristic emission radius.
We can infer from the observed
spectral energy distribution (and the absence of highly ionized
emission lines, like He I) that the hot continuum comes
predominantly from an optically thick region with a temperature
of
K to 40000 K. Given the estimated luminosity of
1000
the radius of this emission region is
between about 10
for 10000 K and 0.65
for 40000 K.
For our MWC 560 model we adopt a radius of
for the emitting region corresponding to a temperature of
K.
Determining the size of the narrow line emission region is crucial for estimates on the jet outflow rate, because we can measure observationally the size of the absorbing jet components relative to the size of the line emitting region of the accretion disk. Unfortunately it is difficult to determine the surface distribution of the line emission. It can be safely assumed from the strength of the emission lines that the narrow line region is significantly larger than the continuum source. Nonetheless it must be assumed that the line emission is peaked towards the disk center where the irradiation and excitation of the line emission is enhanced.
An emission measure can be obtained for the emission line region from
the H I line fluxes, e.g.,
,
estimated in Sect. 4.5. With a reddening
AV=0.45 (
EB-V=0.15) and a distance of d=2.5 kpc
this translates into a H
luminosity of
and an emission measure
assuming
that H
is due to recombination radiation at
K.
For the emitting volume a disk geometry with radius
and height
is adopted. The emission measure derived above yields
for the densities
,
1011 or
the disk radii
,
or
,
respectively.
Thus the H I and Fe II emission could originate
from a relatively small part of the accretion disk. Therefore
it seems to be reasonable to
assume that a disk area with a radius of
is covered by the major high velocity
components of the jet absorbing about half of the narrow line flux.
The Fe II jet absorptions show changes involving
gas column densities of
with time scales of roughly one to a few days (Sects. 3.1
and 4.7). This can be taken as measure for
the replenished mass in the jet per unit area along the
line of sight. However this rough estimate is based on events when strong
changes in the jet absorptions occurred, i.e. when high velocity
components appeared. Counting only the gas in the high velocity
components may be quite reasonable, because they sweep up
the slower moving gas in front of them. Thus the
"quasi''-discrete (decelerating) jet gas absorptions may
represent a major fraction of the jet gas near the
source. Still, the relative contribution of the "steady'' outflow
between the high velocity events remains to be
clarified. For this steady outflow there lacks the information how
long the probed gas stream is and how much time it requires
to replenish the gas. Thus it may be assumed as lower limit
that a column density of
is replenished in the jet at least for each strong high velocity
outburst, which occur on a time scale of a week. Thus the
minimum (mean) mass outflow column density is
.
For the total mass outflow we
have to adopt a jet cross section
corresponding to the determined mass outflow column density.
As the strongly variable jet components
are saturated for the H I transitions, they must
cover practically the entire continuum source. We estimated above
that the size of the continuum source is roughly
.
The stronger
high velocity components cover also about half of the
narrow line emission, an area which was estimated to
have a radius of the order
.
Adopting
as jet radius
probed by the Fe II absorptions yields together with the
mass outflow column density estimated above a
total mass outflow rate
.
This result should be considered as lower limit
because it accounts only for the outflowing mass seen due to
the ejection by the high velocity components.
Thus, it is found that the jet outflow rate
is at least one hundredth to one tenth of the mass accretion rate
derived above. Different types of uncertainties
are involved for the derivation of these quantities. For example
depends on the adopted distance d and the
radius of the accreting object
.
However, if
is higher, also the continuum and
narrow line emission region will be larger and the
resulting jet mass outflow rate will scale accordingly.
Thus the ratio
is less affected by uncertainties in the system parameters.
We present the results of an intensive monitoring program of the jet absorptions in the symbiotic system MWC 560. In this work a general description of the data and the spectroscopic properties of the outflowing gas is given.
Many results of this study are new and have not been described in previous investigations of MWC 560. The characteristics and time scale of the strong jet absorption variability has been determined at least for the time covered by our campaign. Our data revealed the anti-correlation between the high velocity component and the shallow low velocity absorptions which proves their tight connection. Further the observations happened to show the end of an obscuration phase of the red giant by the jet gas probing the outflow at large distance from the source. It is also the first time that the fast, narrow absorption components of Ca II are described. In addition we investigated the properties of the narrow line emission. It is found that the allowed emission lines vary strongly like the hot continuum radiation and are obscured by the jet outflow. Thereby the transient high velocity components cover about half of the narrow line emission from the accretion disk while the continuous outflow at larger distance covers practically the entire narrow line region. Contrary to this the nebular lines (forbidden line transitions) are practically constant and not significantly absorbed by the jet gas.
Combining all this new information yields an outflow structure for the jet im MWC 560 described in detail in the previous section. The outflow can be characterized by three different regions along the jet axis: I. An initial acceleration region located mainly besides the accreting object above the accretion disk; II. A highly variable region extending to about one to a few AU showing the pulsed ejection and subsequent deceleration of high velocity material, whereby high velocity components appear in anti-correlation with the absorption from the initial acceleration region; III. A rather steady outflow region at larger distances. In addition we provide evidence that the fast, narrow Ca II absorptions can be attributed to the shocks generated by the collision of the pulsed high velocity gas ejections with slower moving jet gas.
For all these components we derive time scales, radial velocities, gas parameters and column densities and provide a geometric model and physical parameters for the MWC 560 jet outflow.
The obtained results demonstrate the enormous diagnostic possibilities
offered by the MWC 560 system for the investigation of astrophysical
jet outflows. Because the line of sight is practically parallel
to the jet axis the outflowing gas can be studied as absorption against
the underlying emission regions of the binary system. Small
gas structures can therefore be followed in radial velocity space with
high temporal resolution revealing the motion and
physical properties of the gas in and near the acceleration region
of the jet. To our knowledge, MWC 560 is the only stellar jet source
known where this information can be obtained so easily from
spectroscopic data. Also very favorable is the typical outflow
velocity
and variability time scales
103-106 s of the MWC 560 source because this range
can be easily covered by available high resolution spectroscopy.
Due to these very advantageous properties of MWC 560, this system
provides an important source of information for the investigation
of astrophysical jets. It is often emphasized that basic
parameters of jets from different sources obey simple scaling laws.
For example the velocities of jet outflows scale roughly like the
escape velocity from the accreting object
(see e.g., Pringle 1993; Blandford 1993;
Camenzind 1997; Livio 1999).
This suggests that the results found for MWC 560 could also be relevant
for jet outflows in pre-main sequence stars, black hole binaries
and active galactic nuclei. It is beyond the scope of this
paper to discuss the results found for the outflow of MWC 560
in this more general context of astrophysical jets. However,
we like to emphasize that MWC 560 is a most important object
for studying the jet acceleration region close to the source.
Therefore, the main result found in this study
which is the velocity structure of the jet outflow
with its pulsed acceleration and the subsequent deceleration,
which generates shock features, and the termination in a rather
smooth outflow could be a general property of astrophysical jets.
Acknowledgements
We are indebted to Toma Tomov who supplied a reduced Echelle spectrum of XX Oph. We thank Werner Schmutz (PMOD Davos) for discussions on radiative transfer issues, Markus Thiele (LSW Heidelberg) on jet hydrodynamics, and Andreas Korn (USM Munich) for support in our search for atomic data. HMS acknowledges financial support by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (WO 296/27-1).