It is generally accepted that long-period comets (e.g.
comets with periods greater than the traditional lower limit of
200 years) originate from the Oort cloud, from which their stable
orbits have been perturbed into the inner Solar System by the
cumulative effects of the galactic tidal field and the passage of
nearby stars or giant molecular clouds. Such comets possess nearly
parabolic incoming orbits described by positive reciprocals of
semimajor axes, e.g.:
.
However, in the sample of about three hundred long-period comets
with well determined orbits there are about 10% which have
hyperbolic incoming orbits (
). The problem of
the negative tail of the distribution of original binding energies
(proportional to
)
has been discussed in detail
in literature by many authors. First, the quality of astrometric
data, the method of data selection (including the problem of
weighting the individual measurements), and the applied method of
integration may all strongly affect the orbit computation of each
individual "hyperbolic'' comet (even comets with orbits ascribed as
1A - highest quality class). Second, since all the negative
excess energies are small, corresponding to roughly
-10-4 AU-1 in inverse semimajor axis, Marsden et al.
(1973) speculate that neglecting the non-gravitational
effects tends to produce original orbit which appear to be more
hyperbolic than they really are. In particular, it is possible
that most "hyperbolic'' comets with small perihelion distances
originate from the Oort's cloud of comets. The latter suggestion
is strongly supported by the fact that perihelion distances of two
comets with a greatest negative excess of
are
smaller than 0.9 AU.
On the other hand, Yabushita (1991) found that
the maximum excess velocity at great distance due to non-symmetric
outgassing from cometary nuclei is equal to 0.18 kms-1.
Thus, he argues that for at least 15 comets the calculated
original orbits are "highly hyperbolic'' and are not "compatible
with elliptical orbits modified by the non-gravitational
accelerations''. More recently, Bolatto et al. (1995)
concluded that the non-gravitational perturbation in a
near-parabolic comet's energy per orbital revolution is generally
smaller than about 10-4 AU-1. However these two papers
neglect the influence of variations of osculating orbital elements
on
when the non-gravitational effects are
implied from observational data. Present calculations show that
hyperbolic original orbits are produced by hyperbolic osculating
orbits resulting from positional data in the case of pure
gravitational motions.
There are several generally accepted reasons that extrasolar
comets exist. An important question is whether such comets could
be observed if they actually were observed. The modern theories (e.g.
Clube & Napier 1984; Duncan et al. 1987) for the formation of comets in the interstellar
environment predict many more extrasolar comets than bound comets.
However, the estimates of the expected rate for detection of
extrasolar comets are uncertain. McGlynn & Chapman (1989)
show that the rate of hyperbolic comets passing with perihelion
q<2 AU is 0.6 per year which implies that a total of about six
extrasolar comets should have been detected over the last 150
years. More recently, Sen & Rana (1993) argued that the
density of stars in the solar neighbourhood was overestimated by
McGlynn and Chapman. Using a value of 0.014
pc-3Sen & Rana found that the expected number of detectable
interstellar comets per century is less than one. Hughes
(1991) gives an even smaller number of expected comets on
hyperbolic orbits. He argues that hyperbolic comets occur at a
rate of 0.00225 yr-1, which yields one such comet on average
every 450 yrs. It seems clear that at most only a few known
"hyperbolic'' comets could really have interstellar origins.
Nevertheless, using modern techniques for comet searches, the
detection rate of extrasolar comets will increase dramatically in
the future. Presently it is possible to weed out false members from the sample of
"hyperbolic'' comets.
In this paper the non-gravitational motions of individual
"hyperbolic'' comets from the Catalogue of Cometary Orbits (Marsden
& Williams 1997; hereafter MW Catalogue) are examined. The
aim of the present study is to prove that incoming orbits of
"hyperbolic'' comets for which it was possible to determine the
non-gravitational effects are almost all elliptical. Next, we show
that using objective statistical criteria for the remaining
"hyperbolic'' comets, excess energies derived for pure
gravitational motion are systematically smaller than those given
in the MW Catalogue. The new method of
uncertainty estimates are also used.
Copyright ESO 2001