A&A 374, 957-967 (2001)
E. Solano1 - E. Paunzen2 - O. I. Pintado3, - J. Varela4
1 - Laboratorio de Astrofísica Espacial y Física Fundamental (LAEFF), Apartado de Correos 50727, 28080 Madrid, Spain
2 - Institut für Astronomie der Universität Wien, Türkenschanzstr. 17, 1180 Wien, Austria
3 - Departamento de Física, Facultad de Ciencias Exactas y Tecnología, Universidad Nacional de Tucumán, Argentina - Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas de la República Argentina
4 - IMAFF, Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas, c/ Serrano 113, 28006 Madrid, Spain
Received 7 December 2000 / Accepted 26 April 2001
This is the first of two papers whose main goal is to update and improve the information available on the physical properties of the Bootis stars. The determination of the stellar parameters is of fundamental importance to shed light into the different theories proposed to explain the Bootis phenomenon. With this aim, projected rotational velocities, effective temperatures, surface gravities and chemical abundances of a sample of suspected Bootis stars have been calculated. Five objects showing composite spectra typical of binary systems were found in our analysis. The abundance distribution of the program stars does not resemble the chemical composition of the class prototype, Boo, which poses some concerns regarding the idea of a well-defined, chemically homogeneous group of stars. A possible relation between rotational velocities and the Bootis phenomenon has been found. This result would be in agreement with the accretion scenario proposed by Turcotte & Charbonneau (1993).
Key words: stars: chemically peculiar - stars: abundances
Observational results supporting the accretion theory are the high [C/Si] and [O/Si] abundance ratios found in some Bootis stars which can be used as indicators of gas-dust separation (Paunzen et al. 1999a): carbon and oxygen have low condensation temperatures and tends to remain in the gas phase of the interstellar medium. Silicon, on the other side, has a high condensation temperature representing the elements locked up in the grains. Any preferential accretion of gas will lead to a [C/Si] or [O/Si] larger than solar. The correlation with Si of other elements of high condensation temperature also fits nicely with the accretion scenario (Stürenburg 1993). Charbonneau (1991) combined the accretion hypothesis with the diffusion theory concluding that, with an accretion rate of the order of 10 yr-1, many peculiar characteristics of the Bootis stars (including their restriction to the above-mentioned spectral types) are reproduced quite naturally. Turcotte & Charbonneau (1993) investigated the effect of mixing through meridional circulation, concluding that the abundance anomalies would disappear in 106 years, so all of the Bootis stars should be essentially young objects on or just arriving to the ZAMS. The scarcity of Bootis will be also explained by the strict requirements for the accretion rate. The fact that all Bootis stars are young objects is further strengthened by the lack of Bootis stars in open clusters older than 107 years (Gray & Corbally 1988) and the discovery of Bootis stars in the young Orion OB1 association and NGC 2264 (Paunzen & Gray 1997).
A critical point in the accretion scenario is the necessary existence of gas and dust shells around Bootis stars. Some Bootis stars show clear indications of both gas (circumstellar lines) and dust (IR excess) shells (Holweger & Rentzsch-Holm 1995; Holweger et al. 1999). However, the fact that some Bootis stars do not show evidence of shells does not necessary rule out this hypothesis. King (1994) concluded that the amount of depleted gas required to cause underabundances in Bootis stars is small enough that any circumstellar dust associated with this gas is not necessarily detectable in the IR or submillimetre regions.
Michaud & Charland (1986) investigated the effect on abundances in stellar atmospheres of the diffusion mechanism operating in the presence of mass loss. They found that, after about 108-109 years, mass-loss rates of only 10 yr-1 can reduce the extreme overabundances predicted by diffusion theory for the Am stars to underabundances of many elements, the degree of underabundance of an element being a function of both gravity and time. According to this, Bootis stars would be rather old and at the end of their Main Sequence.
There are, however, some points that cannot be explained with theory. One is the moderate underabundances predicted (only a factor of five less solar), very far from the strong underabundances found by Venn & Lambert (1990) in the three classical Bootis stars ( Boo, Ori and 29 Cyg). Also it is difficult to understand how diffusion could operate in the presence of the meridional circulation which would likely be generated by rapid rotation. Turcotte & Charbonneau (1993) showed that even an equatorial rotational velocity of 50 kms-1 suppresses the appearance, at any epoch of Main Sequence evolution, of the characteristic Bootis abundance pattern.
Faraggiana & Bonifacio (1999) proposed this alternative to explain the underabundances of, at least, some Bootis stars. The composite spectra of a binary system with disentangled components not very dissimilar produces a veiling effect with apparent underabundances. The authors pointed out that the lack of a uniform pattern in the chemical composition of the Bootis stars can be easily reconciled with the binary hypothesis. Moreover, they claimed that the hypothesis of all Bootis stars being very young objects in the late phase of their PMS evolution is highly improbable on the basis of the rapid evolution and the number of bright Bootis candidates which would imply that the star formation process is still very active in the solar neighborhood, leading to an unexpected large number of Main Sequence B stars in a similar volume.
Andrievsky (1997) proposed a complementary scenario in which Bootis stars would be the result of the coalescence of contact binaries of W UMa type. The system would be formed by two main-sequence components of approximately equal spectral types. This scenario would lead to an age for Bootis stars of 1 Gyr explaining the rather evolved nature of some Bootis stars and the origin of the material around them.
A class definition of the Bootis group is essential on one hand to distinguish these stars from other groups of stars populating the same region of the HR diagram and, on the other hand, to shed light into the nature of the Bootis phenomenon. Ideally, a stellar class should be formed by a homogeneous sample of stars showing common properties originated by the same astrophysical processes. Historically, this has not been the case for the Bootis group since the use in the past of classification criteria not unique to the group (weakness of the Mg II 4481 Å line, presence of spectral features at 1600 Å and 3040 Å, IR excess, ...) has led to the inclusion of spurious members (horizontal branch stars, Ap stars, shell stars, He-weak stars, ...). Although the problem of the class definition can be efficiently alleviated making use of unambiguous criteria defined in the ultraviolet range (Solano & Paunzen 1998, 1999), the chemical composition-based definition of the class makes it necessary to perform an accurate determination of the stellar parameters for the final decision on the membership of a potential candidate to the Bootis group. The observed sample was selected from the list of suspected Bootis stars given in Paunzen (2000). HD 68758 and HD 184190 were also included as possible members of the class.
The observations were performed in May 1998 at the Complejo Astronómico el Leoncito (CASLEO) using the 2.15-m telescope equipped with a REOSC echelle spectrograph and a Tek-1024 CCD. A grating with 1200 lines mm-1 was used as a cross disperser. A resolving power of 26000 was achieved. Two wavelength ranges were observed (3830-4570 Å; 4520-5230 Å).
The spectra were reduced using the context echelle of the MIDAS reduction package. A typical session of echelle reduction comprises the following steps: bias subtraction, spatial positioning of the spectral orders, flatfield correction (several master flatfield exposures were taken every night), background subtraction, order extraction and wavelength calibration. The wavelength calibration of the stellar spectra was done with thorium-argon comparison spectra. Polynomial calibrations of wavelength as a function of pixel number were calculated for every night. The lower sensitivity at the edges of the orders typical of echelle spectra (ripple effect) was corrected by using Procyon as standard star. A blaze function was derived for each order.
The reliability of the measured equivalent widths depends to a great extent on the accuracy of the continuum placement: an improper placement of the continuum level will lead to systematic errors which can misrepresent the data. Most Bootis stars are characterized as having broad and often shallow absorption line profiles. In this case, the continuum placement cannot be set by simply connecting the highest points in the observed spectrum, which would produce an underestimation of the equivalent widths. We solved this problem by defining the "true'' continuum level as that of a synthetic spectrum of physical parameters ( , , [M/H], ) similar to those of the observed object. As a first approach, effective temperatures and surface gravities were derived using Moon & Dworetsky (1985). Rotational velocities were estimated using the method described in Sect. 3 where a pseudo-continuum was defined by connecting the highest points in the line profile: the small influence of the continuum level on the method used to calculate rotational velocities permits this approximation. Also, a value of was used for all the stars, which is justified by the results from our detailed abundance analysis. The normalized spectra were then derived by dividing the extracted spectra by this continuum level. Line identification was performed with the help of Moore et al. (1966).
To have an estimation of the measurements errors in equivalent widths, the standard star Procyon ( CMi, HR 2943) was observed and the spectra compared to the spectrum of the Atlas of Procyon (Griffin & Griffin 1979). It can be seen in Table 1 how the equivalent widths measured in the observed spectra are only slightly larger than those measured in the Atlas. We also compared the equivalent widths of spectral lines present in the overlapping region between spectral orders finding no systematic trend. The list of observed objects is given in Table 2.
|type||(Å)||This work||This work||This work|
|/Other sources||/Other sources||/Other sources|
|HD 107233||kA1hF0mA1Va A1V||7.37||3830-4570||7000(H),6900(H)||(24)|
|/7225(4),7244(5),7200(2)||/4.2(), 4.05(4), 4.1(2)|
|type||(Å)||This work||This work||This work|
|/Other sources||/Other sources||/Other sources|
|/7650(4),7700(10)||/4.15(), 3.9(4,12)||/147 (10)|
|/8100(4), 8100(10), 8080(13)||/3.5(4),3.6(10),3.6(13)||/95(10), 83(13)|
References: (1) Paunzen et al. (1998a); (2) Iliev & Barzova (1995); (3) Bohlender et al. (1999); (4) Moon & Dworetsky (1985); (5) Paunzen (1997); (6) Paunzen et al. (1998b); (7) Stürenburg (1993); (8) Holweger & Rentzsch-Holm (1995); (9) North et al. (1994); (10) Paunzen et al. (1999a); (11) Gray & Corbally (1993); (12) Faraggiana & Bonifacio (1999); (13) Holweger et al. (1999).
Five targets of our sample show a composite spectra and no attempt to derive their abundance pattern was done (Fig. 1). All of them are identified as members of binary systems:
Different methods can be found in the literature to calculate rotational velocities. In this work we have used the technique based on the Fourier transform proposed by Gray (1992) which has shown to give superior results than those based on the convolution of a non-rotating standard star of similar spectral type with a rotational function or on the identification of a particular parameter of the spectral lines (e.g. FWHM). Whereas these two latter methods require one to build up a calibration of rotational velocities, Gray's method provides a direct and independent measurement of . In short, the method relies on the relation between and the frequencies where the Fourier transform of the rotational profile reaches a relative minimum. Instrumental broadening may add relative minima in the Fourier transform but at higher frequencies than those used to calculate the rotational velocity. Projected rotational velocities for our sample of stars are given in Table 2.
It is well established that the Balmer lines are good temperature indicators for 8000-8250 because of their small gravity and metallicity dependence (Solano & Fernley 1997). As the spectral orders are not wide enough to fully embrace the wings of the observed Balmer lines (H , H , H ), an alternative method based on the variations in intensity at two different wavelengths was used instead. These wavelengths, free of contamination of metallic lines, were selected in such a way that they lie in the region of the Balmer line profile where the dependency with temperature is maximum. Prior to this, the observed Balmer lines were shifted to the laboratory values to correct for radial velocity displacements. Effective temperatures were then calculated by comparing the observed intensity ratio with the intensity ratio measured in a grid of synthetic Balmer profiles previously convolved with the corresponding rotational and instrumental profiles.
Balmer lines are known to be very sensitive to convection as it can
alter the temperature structure where the lines are formed. In this work, the
turbulent convection model developed by Canuto et al. (1996) and
implemented in the ATLAS9 code by Kupka (1999) has been
used. This convection model has been found to
reproduce adequately the temperature of standard stars whereas the standard
mixing-length theory models with overshooting, originally implemented in ATLAS9,
are clearly discrepant
(Gardiner et al. 1999; Smalley & Kupka 1997). The effective temperatures are given
in Table 2. An error of
Some concern may also exist in the use of Balmer lines as temperature
indicators due to the existence of peculiar Balmer
profiles (weak, narrow core typical of late A-type dwarfs but with strong
wings proper to early A-type dwarfs) in some Bootis stars (Gray 1988). Based on this criterion, Bootis stars have been
traditionally classified in two groups:
normal hydrogen-lines (NHL) and peculiar hydrogen-line profiles (PHL).
Iliev & Barzova (1993) suggested that PHL profiles could be fitted by using two
theoretical profiles with different effective temperatures, one for the core
and other for the wings. Faraggiana & Bonifacio (1999) pointed out that this duplicity
can be explained in terms of a binary system although
some of the stars catalogued as PHL objects (e.g., HD 142703, HD 142994,
HD 204041) do not show in their spectra any
sign of the presence of companion. Moreover, this scenario would
not explain why PHL profiles are more frequent at
lower temperatures as proposed by Iliev & Barzova (1993).
To ensure the reliability of the temperatures calculated using Balmer lines,
they have been compared with those calculated
using the photometric calibration by Moon & Dworetsky (1985) finding no systematic
differences (Table 2).
|Identification||Parallax||Bolometric||log )||log ( )||log t|
The method of calculating spectroscopic gravities using the standard
technique of making
both neutral and ionized iron lines agree was not used here due to the
scarcity of usable Fe II lines in the observed
wavelength range. Alternatively, surface gravities were derived for those
stars with accurate parallaxes in the HIPPARCOS catalogue
following a method similar to that described in Nissen et al. (1997). In short,
the method relies on the basic relations
The mass of the stars were calculated from its position in the
diagram by interpolating in the isochrones given in
Claret (1995). The mass so calculated was used as input value in
- diagram to obtain the surface gravity. A chemical
composition X = 0.70, Z = 0.02 (solar abundance) was adopted. This is based on the fact that
the main contribution to the overall metallicity is due to
C, N, O (solar abundant in Bootis stars). Furthermore, there are strong indications that the Bootis phenomenon is restricted to the stellar surface (Holweger &
Rentzsch-Holm 1995). The mixing length and core
overshooting parameters were fixed to 1.52 and 2.0 respectively. Surfaces
gravities are given in Table 2. Parallaxes, bolometric corrections,
luminosities, masses and ages are displayed in Table 3. Age estimations for the sample
stars indicate that they cover an area slightly above the Main Sequence. Surface gravities calculated
using HIPPARCOS are only slightly higher
than those derived using Moon & Dworetsky (1985) (
). A conservative
= 0.15 dex has been estimated based on errors in the
bolometric correction and in the calculated mass.
The abundance analysis was performed making use of a modified version of the ATLAS9 code (Kurucz 1993) in which the classical mixing length theory used for the treatment of convection has been replaced by the turbulent theory implemented by Kupka (1999) as described in Sect. 4.
Since the wavelength coverage of our spectra is quite extensive, we have been restrictive in the selection of lines for abundance analysis. Weak lines with large errors in equivalent width due to noise and strong lines with a high sensitivity to errors in microturbulence were discarded. Moreover, the typically high rotational velocities of the Bootis stars produce a strong blending of the spectral lines and it is an additional limiting factor in the line selection. Only blended features formed by lines of the same element and ionization stage were considered (Fig. 2). The abundance of the different elements were computed line by line by linearly interpolating in the grid of metallicity values for a given and , the final abundance being the average value. Results are displayed in Table 4 and plotted in form of abundance patterns in Fig. 3. For those program stars in common with Stürenburg (1993), abundances have been also displayed, showing good agreement.
Microturbulence was calculated in an independent way for each individual spectrum by making abundance results of weak and strong lines agree. We have used the iron lines since they are the most numerous and are spread over a wide range in equivalent width. In those cases where the scarcity of Fe I lines prevents from using this method, a value of kms-1 was adopted (Stürenburg 1993).
One source of uncertainty is the quality of the oscillator strengths values. To avoid using lines with values of poor quality, a careful selection has been made using the most recent papers in the literature and the VALD database (Kupka et al. 1999). An average value was adopted. As a further test we compared, for every spectrum, the abundance value derived from every single line with the average value. Lines with abundance values clearly discrepant (which could be attributed to a wrong ) were discarded.
Another source of uncertainty results from the errors of the input atmospheric parameters. To get an estimation of how sensitive our results are to these errors we have derived the abundances of a synthetic spectrum with : 7500 , : 4.0, [M/H]: -1.0 varied by , dex. Errors in metallicity of dex are obtained on average. As expected, the abundance of ions changes with changes in whereas the neutral species tend to have negligible changes. On the contrary, changes in produce changes in the abundances derived from neutral species while the abundances derived from ions remain unchanged.
Uncertainties in the abundance values due to NLTE effects should also be included. However, according to Heiter et al. (1998), corrections due to non-LTE effects are of the same order as the abundance error bars in the range of temperature of our program stars making the LTE approach perfectly valid.
Finally, it must be stressed that some abundances rely in only one or few spectral lines so that the uncertainty is high.
|Procyon||2.0||(2/2)||(4/1)||-0.02 (1/1)||(4/3)||-0.03 (1/1)|
|HD 81290||3.0||(2/2)||-0.89 (1/1)||-0.88 (1/1)||(4/2)||(2/1)|
|HD 83041||3.0||(3/1)||-1.31 (1/1)||-0.86 (1/1)||(6/1)|
|HD 184190||3.0||0.20 (1/1)||-0.18 (1/1)||(1/2)|
|-1.08 (1/1)||0 (3/6)||(3/1)|
In order to search for correlations providing clues about the nature of Bootis stars, the abundances for our program stars have been compared with those of Procyon, a primary standard with solar metallicity (Steffen 1985). Chemical abundances of the class prototype, Boo, were taken from the literature (Paunzen et al. 1999b). As can be deduced from Table 4, all the program stars but one (HD 184190) show a clear metal deficiency when compared to Procyon. Moreover, it is quite evident that the candidate Bootis stars here analyzed do not resemble the abundance pattern of the class prototype, in particular for some chemical species (magnesium, titanium and iron). This result poses some concern with the idea of that Bootis stars form a well separate, chemically homogeneous group of the stars. On the contrary, this result reinforces the hypothesis proposed by Stürenburg (1993) that Bootis stars cover a continuous sequence of underabundances from very metal week to solar metallicities.
At this point, it would be necessary to reopen the question of the Bootis class definition. If the definition by Baschek & Searle (1969) - "... Bootis stars can be defined as stars whose composition resembles that of Boo itself'' - is strictly adopted, then all the stars in our sample should be rejected as potential candidates to the Bootis group. On the contrary, if the more conservative definition given by Paunzen et al. (1997a) is considered - "... Bootis stars are Population I, metal-weak (except for C, N, O, S) stars'' -, all the stars (except HD 184190) could be catalogued as members of the Bootis class provided that they show solar abundances for carbon, nitrogen, oxygen and sulphur. It is of fundamental importance to stress this point since the Bootis phenomenon is not ascribed to an overall metal deficiency but to a mechanism able to produce underabundances of the heavy elements contrasting with the solar abundances of C, N, O and S. None of these species have been analyzed in this paper due to the lack of spectral lines fulfilling the requirements quoted in Sect. 6. NLTE abundances of nitrogen and sulphur for the program stars will be part of a subsequent paper (Kamp et al. 2001).
The observed distribution of the abundance values does not permit us to discriminate between the theories proposed to explain the Bootis phenomenon. It could be explained in terms of the diffusion/mass-loss hypothesis on the basis of different stages of the diffusion process. Under the assumption of the accretion hypothesis, the observed differential deficiencies would reflect different scenarios in the gas-dust decoupling ascribed to different disk properties. Moreover, the binarity theories would be also supported. The relation between metallicity and , , has been plotted in Fig. 4. Whereas no obvious correlation between and with [Fe/H] exists, there is evidence for a connection between projected rotational velocities and metallicity in the sense that the metallicity is higher when increases, although the correlation coefficient ( ) and the small number of measurements (n = 14) do not permit to obtain any statistically significant conclusion. A similar result was found by Holweger & Rentzsch-Holm (1995) using calcium abundances derived from the Ca II K line. If, after the determination of the C, N, O and S abundances the membership of the program stars to the Bootis group is finally confirmed, this result would nicely fit with the accretion theory: for large the meridional circulation mixes material of solar composition from the stellar interior into the convection zone so that any surface contamination due accretion of circumstellar material should vanish.
The authors acknowledge use of the CCD and data acquisition system supported under U.S. National Science Foundation grant AST-90-15827 to R. M. Rich.
|ª||Figure 3: Chemical abundances of the program stars (filled rectangles). Abundances from Stürenburg (1993) (triangles) and Paunzen et~al. (1999b) (empty rectangles) are also plotted for comparison. Abundances for the class prototype ( Boo) and a solar metallicity star (Procyon) are from Paunzen et~al. (1999b) and Steffen (1995), respectively.|