In this section we discuss the applied analysis methods and individual results for the observed comets. After describing the morphology we discuss their magnitudes and make an attempt to estimate the nuclear radii. We also analyze the time series data.
As can be seen in Fig. 1,
despite the large solar distances, the observed comets are fairly
active. The general appearance is dominated by a small circular coma
and a faint, considerably long tail.
Although this behaviour is not typical for
Short Period Comets, the Long Period Comets display exactly this
appearance, keeping the level of activity over a very wide range
of distances (Meech 1991). The presented images, that are
single exposures, were enhanced nonlinearly to emphasize
the faint tail extensions.
![]() |
Figure 3: The R lightcurves of C/1999 J2 (Skiff) on July 6 and July 9, 2000. The lower panels show the seeing variations. |
To derive the physical length of tails one has to estimate their
apparent size. The end of the tail was defined where the
signal-to-noise ratio of the surface brightness was 2 on the
composite images (4 individual exposures co-added).
The apparent tails are visible out to 5
8 (C/1999 F2),
5
2 (C/1999 J2), 3
0 (C/1999 N4), 0
8 (C/1999 T2),
0
3 (C/2000 H1) and 5
9 (C/2000 K1).
The measured position
angles (PA) are the following (antisolar directions in parentheses):
C/1999 F2 - PA 230
(PA 98
);
C/1999 J2 - PA 18
(PA 80
);
C/1999 N4 - PA 97
(PA 111
);
C/1999 T2 - PA 150
(PA 220
);
C/2000 H1 - PA 90
(PA 76
);
C/2000 K1 - PA 150
(PA 102
).
One can find large difference in C/1999 J2 and C/1999 T2
and a smaller one
in C/2000 K1, implying a significant amount of tail curvature in
these comets. This is supported for C/1999 J2 by the antitail
observations by Fukushima et al. (2000) made two months before our
observing run. In the meantime the Earth crossed the orbital
plane and the tail turned significantly. A colour index of C/1999 J2
also supports a dusty tail (see the photometric analysis)
where one may observe apparently long tails if the curvature affects
the projection significantly.
Neglecting this curvature we calculated the true lengths
taking into account the
projection effect. The results are
km (C/1999 F2),
km (C/1999 J2),
km (C/1999 N4),
km (C/1999 T2),
km (C/2000 H1) and
km (C/2000 K1).
Based on the test images taken previously on non-photometric nights,
three of the potential targets were
excluded from further observations. The potential targets
C/1999 T2 and C/2000 H1 were not
really "distant'' object during the observations. Furthermore, C/2000 H1
was quite compact and faint (
,
integrated
in the innermost 6
). C/1999 T2 was bright
(
)
with a strongly visible coma and 50
-long tail.
The integrated R magnitude of C/1999 F2 was 19
1 in the inner 6
,
which is fainter than our practical limit.
We note the impressive cyrrus-like tail as long as 350
.
The surface brightness profiles (e.g. Jewitt & Meech 1987; Lowry et al. 1999) were also calculated to examine the coma regularity. In spherically homogeneous and isotropic cases, the surface brightness (B) profile bears a simple linear relation with a logarithmic derivative of -1. Interaction between overstreaming matter and the radiation pressure modifies this value down to about -2, according to the models by Jewitt & Meech (1987). For our images the profiles were calculated by a model coma along with the nuclear brightness estimation.
The model comae were characterized by two free parameters, namely the slope parameter (logarithmic derivative of the surface brightness) and coma-to-nucleus brightness ratio. The resultant structure is a power-function of the radius with negative exponent, while the nucleus is represented with a delta-function in the center. To simulate the apparent motion and the effect of seeing, the model coma was convolved by the motion and the PSF (Lamy et al. 1998). The latter was determined from individual stellar profiles and its form was a simple Gaussian. We have performed a least-squares analysis, where the finally adopted parameters resulted in an appropriate fit of the observed surface brightness distribution.
The adopted numerical fits of the individual comae are examined
in Fig. 2.
A comparison of the measurements, the modelled coma components
and their sums are presented. The measured brightnesses were
averaged in neighbouring rings with a width of
.
As the background has been taken into account as an additive constant,
the effect has been taken into account in this representation too.
This allows us to show the photometric data with respect to the real limit of
the sky conditions.
Determination of the absolute brightness of the coma allows one to calculate the apparent magnitude of the core, which results in an estimate of the diameter of the solid nucleus. Certainly, as the coma strongly affects the brightness of the nucleus, the apparent brightness of the nucleus can be determined with quite large errors. In the case of the present calculations, the coma contamination was about 1.5-2 magnitudes, therefore, the confidence interval of the estimated diameters may be in the range of half to twice the accepted values.
From the R-band nuclear magnitudes
the mean optical cross sections of the nucleii were determined
using the equation (Eddington 1910)
where pR is the red geometric albedo,
is the mean
cross section,
mag is the R-band magnitude
of the Sun and
is the mean R magnitude of the comet, while
is usually assumed to be 0.04 (Luu & Jewitt 1992).
An important question is the involved
sytematic error, which is very difficult to estimate.
The brightness profile of the coma may be distorted by anisotropic
substructures (e.g. jets, bright patches) blurred by the seeing.
Therefore one can barely calculate the brightness of the nuclei in the case of
ground-based observations, and the resulted nuclear diameters are
often overestimated (I. Tóth, personal communication).
The remarks on the individual comets are as follows.
C/1999 J2 (Skiff)
The object was detected for the first time on CCD frames of
the LONEOS-Schmidt (59 cm) telescope on May 13, 1999 for the first time
(Skiff et al. 1999).
This comet with a discovery brightness
of 16
0 has the third largest perihelion distance known
(7.110 AU, the transit was on April 5, 2000).
The apparent total visual brightness was 14
5
during the observations, and because of its high declination it was
a favourable target for observers in the northern hemisphere.
The derived absolute brightness is 3
0, which is quite
bright compared to other similar comets.
The intrinsic peculiarity of this comet was also
suggested by the dust antitail reported by Fukushima et al. (2000)
in May, 2000.
The observed V-R colour index of the inner coma is
.
A weak ion tail is barely visible on the direct images, and therefore
the relatively bluish colour may be attributed to possible
C2 emission in the V-band.
The obtained coma-corrected absolute photometry gave the following mean
nuclear brightness:
.
The coma contamination was estimated to be
% of the total inner
intensity (formal error). Assuming 0.04 albedo, the calculated cross section
is
resulting in a nuclear diameter of
km.
This is a quite large value, however, it is simply necessary to
support the tremendous activity observed. The logarithmic
coma brightness density is linear in the inner 13
0 with a slope
of
.
This value is significantly larger than the expected
one for an isotropic steady-state coma and suggests strong interaction
of the outflow and the radiation pressure.
Time-series observations showed that there were rapid small-amplitude
variations on a time-scale of an hour, though with small
significance. We present
the lightcurves in Fig. 3 (the data regard to 1
3 aperture
radius). In order to quantify the cyclic variation, a standard
Fourier-analysis was performed. A very short period of
was revealed, the phase diagram is plotted in Fig. 4.
As rotation is the easiest way to explain light variability,
we have compared the observed behaviour with the
rotational breakup calculations of Davidsson (1999).
Accepting rotational variability, the period of rotation is twice
the period of the lightcurves. This means approximately
2 hours for the rotational period, which is physically permitted
for thopse bodies which are smaller than 4 km in spherical
approximation.
This does not contradict the estimated diameter of the nucleus.
However, other alternative mechanisms cannot be exluded, which are
presently unknown. It is worthwhile noting that
a similarly fast oscillation has been found for the asteroid
1689 Floris-Jan (Pych 1999), which has long rotational period.
The rapid variations were suggested to be caused by secondary
rotational effects, though no firm physical explanation was drawn.
C/1999 N4 (LINEAR)
This retrograde comet was found as an asteroid
by the LINEAR project on July 12, 1999 and its unusual
motion raised the question of its real nature
(Tichy et al. 1999). The discovery was made almost a year before
the perihelion at 5.505 AU, therefore, the evolution of this object
could be well monitored. The initial brightness of 17
5
brightened up to 15
0.
Our measurements were taken on 2 nights. On July 4/5 the comet showed a light
variation of 0
3, the most striking feature of which is the rapid dimming
between 23.2 - 01 UT. The lightcurve is presented in Fig. 5.
On the second night (July 6) we could detect only an ambiguous
variation with an amplitude not exceeding 0
08, while
a rotation effect would have been expected on this night too.
To exclude the correlation with the seeing, the seeing variation is
also presented below the lightcurves.
The V-R colour index of the inner coma is 0
47
0
05, fairly
close to the solar value ((V-R)
,
Meech et al. 1995).
This implies a relatively simple reflection with no emission and
little dust.
The obtained coma-corrected absolute photometry gave the following mean
nuclear brightness:
.
The coma contamination was estimated to be
% of the total inner
intensity (formal error). Assuming 0.04 albedo, the calculated cross section
is
resulting in a nuclear diameter of
km.
The logarithmic surface
brightness profile is the same as for the coma of C/1999 J2: a linear relation
in the inner 8
0 with a slope of
.
C/2000 K1
The retrograde comet was discovered at a brightness of 18
0
by the LINEAR project in May 2000 (Shelly et al. 2000).
Further prediscovery images
were found on frames from
the previous year (Amburgey & Zoltowski 2000).
The perihelion passage occurred at 6.276 AU and
a visual brightness of 14
5.
We have found no significant variation during the observing run (Fig. 6).
Unfortunately, we could obtain only the presented 3-hour data series
which does not allow any firm conclusion to be drawn.
The V-R colour index of the inner coma is
,
slightly reddish. This means a considerably dusty coma.
The obtained coma-corrected absolute photometry gave the following mean
nuclear brightness:
.
The coma contamination was estimated to be
% of the total inner
intensity (formal error). Assuming 0.04 albedo, the
calculated cross section
is
resulting in a nuclear diameter of
km. As for C/1999 J2, the remarkable tail and
coma activity requires a large nucleus.
The recorded logarithmic surface brightness profile has a slope
of
determined in the inner 14
0.
Copyright ESO 2001